shadowbringers and the art of grief

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ก.ค. 2024
  • happy dawntrail release weekend everyone! what better way to celebrate the new expansion than by spilling my guts all over the one that came out five years ago
    CHAPTER LIST
    0:00 intro
    5:44 a world full of grief
    11:53 interlude- comrade alphinaud
    16:29 a world full of grief (cont.)
    18:26 the characters are (also) full of grief
    36:35 interlude- girl so what
    41:09 oh god we gotta talk about that guy
    55:17 autovivisection for your entertainment
    1:07:30 tomorrow and tomorrow
    microphone on loan from my girlfriend❤️ which is why i was very mediocre at using it.
    additional music from SHADOWBRINGERS: FINAL FANTASY XIV ORIGINAL SOUNDTRACK composed by Masayoshi Soken
    featured cosplay sewed by myself with 3D printing by Dangerous Ladies
    A Friendly Letter to Everyone by Tim Rogers can be found at / a-friendly-letter-to-e...
    (what is functionally a ffxiv) twitter: / daintyprotag
  • บันเทิง

ความคิดเห็น • 129

  • @tarrotpatch
    @tarrotpatch 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +90

    Shadowbringers is, unsurprisingly, also my favourite because I, too, am a sucker for stories about grief. Now look at this scrunkly little man with 12,000 years of depression.

  • @riaglitta
    @riaglitta 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +55

    Alisaie acting appropriately like the one after whom she was named - STEALING THAT LIMIT BREAK

  • @funnywes
    @funnywes 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +23

    shadowbringers was integral to helping me deal with my lingering grief in a both literal and figuretive transition period of my life, i played it at a certain "new beginning" stage. i lost my father at a young age and now and again i'd get into low points of "oh god just how am i supposed to live without this guy. why feel anything good if he isnt here" and this game was 'the' thing that got me out of that (Hopefully) last slump. the game hits just as hard as it did a year and a half or so later. this is, without exaggeration, my favorite piece on this game i've ever seen. not just shadowbringers, final fantasy 14 as a whole. immensely happy you got some enjoyment out of it. had a lump in my throat for pretty much the entire runtime, fantastic work
    (also Real for the tim rogers mention)
    (also keep drawing that little freak i oughta dub more of those comics)

  • @Jhakri_
    @Jhakri_ 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +28

    I'm glad someone else loves Thancred here. Him constantly wrestling with the desire to have *his* Minfilia back knowing that sacrificing the young girl isn't fair to her & it wouldn't be something Minfilia-Prime would want him to force on her. He knows it's wrong but it doesn't quell how much he still wants the person he cared about most back.
    Side note, between Magnus & Lyna they brought their absolute A game when it comes to voice acting for Shadowbringers

    • @RothAnim
      @RothAnim วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      My take on is very close to Mads'. Thancred knew that it was not his place to choose young Minfilia's destiny, and I think he tried to emotionally distance himself from her so as not to place his thumb on the scale, as it were. In practice, however, that made it seem to everyone else that he did have a preference, and it was not for her life. I think by Shadowbringers, Thancred has grown to care for young Minfillia as her own person, and is struggling instead with the knowledge that regardless of the choice being made, he would lose someone he cares about as a result.

  • @SapphWolf
    @SapphWolf 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +42

    That scene with Magnus always makes me cry. You can just feel conflict between wanting to smash the thing he feels took his wife from him into tiny pieces and his desire hold onto it as a last, unexpected, cherished gift.

  • @joshuayung5158
    @joshuayung5158 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +19

    Thancred/Emet parallels aside, the side story for Ran'jit shows a similar mirror. Like Thancred, Ran'jit knew a "greater" Minfilia, and like Minfilia Warde, she is lost in sacrifice towards a greater good. Despite great inner turmoil, Thancred is ultimately able to separate his love for Minfilia with his love for Ryne.
    Ran'jit cannot.
    It's possible that Ran'jit spent more time in the company of the 'first' Minfilia than Thancred spent with Warde. He has, in all likelihood, the longest tenure in all of Norvrandt of combat against the sin eaters, and I doubt honeyed promise of luxury or bliss from Vauthry could tempt him. Ran'jit aligns himself with Vauthry not out of ideology or a means to an end, but as an end to his pain.

    • @stitches1110
      @stitches1110 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I’d say it’s not just the first “Minfillia” but all of them up to the rise of Vauthry that Ranjit connects himself too. When he passes he specifically calls out to his “precious girls”, plural, and as the commander of Eulmore’s armies, he would have raised and watched them all die. So it’s not hard to see why he might choose to follow a leader who would allow one of those precious girls to not suffer that same fate.

  • @graycalls
    @graycalls 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +45

    16:14 shoutout to the best example of cat naming I've ever seen. Truly an alisae move if I'd ever seen one

  • @dalthorn
    @dalthorn 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    What amazes me still is the voice actor for Magnus not only did an amazing job for this relatively minor character but he also voices fucking Barnabas/Odin from FF16 which has a 180° turn on the energy.

  • @arpyzero
    @arpyzero 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +38

    The whole bit where you came out in full blown cosplay and explained quite amusingly that you would not be able to be impersonal about Emet and everyone around you knew that before you even played the game was perhaps the finest cover for the deeply affecting bits to come. Thank you for this essay - I cannot imagine it was easy emotionally.
    You spoke towards the end about retreading the same ground can't create the same experience. Sure you see more and the machinery reveals itself to you but our brains are boundless and incorporate especially impacting information quite well. I have always evaded replaying or rewatching or rereading whatever media because I felt that it would be better to preserve the memory of the original experience than gain insight into how it was made, but recently I have been going away from that, for reasons you've outlined here. Sometimes it is worth it just to reach the conclusion that yes, what you saw was a whole experience despite the pieces. I'll likely do the same with this very video.

  • @unclejoeljoestar988
    @unclejoeljoestar988 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +41

    This is one of the best videos I've ever seen, and it's an accessible mirror to why Shadowbringers is one of my favourite pieces of fiction ever.
    Truth is, even if I was spared the pain of physical abuse in my lifetime, the amount of emotional suffering I've endured for the sake of betterment of others is... hard to put into words. The most fucked up thing about grief, in my opinion, is that it's so distant from normality, that to be understood, you have to blow people's minds and hope, just hope, that they will not be too preoccupied with their own horror of realisation about how... much invisible pain is there in the world.
    I, too, constructed temples in memory of the worst moments on my life, to prove the point to onlookers, that I'm not weak-willed, cowardly, hysterical. But the problem is, doing that has made me stuck emotionally. My care for others never went away, but it became a performance of genuine kindness without my ability to emotionally connect with it.
    I think it's about time I stopped reciting age-old books for the sake of people that don't care about me, and pass on the torch of hope to yet another person, now in earnest
    thank you for this video

  • @SageofLight777
    @SageofLight777 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    After listening to this essay, I think I can put words to why Amaurot, the map zone, is one of my favorites. Especially the map theme "Neath Dark Waters"; that ticking clock. Emblematic of both the forward march of time and a man for whom time has not meaningfully moved forward for literal millenia. Amaurot is a tribute to the past and a monument to one man's descent into maddening grief and his refusal to accept his loss for what it is.

  • @gradientforce761
    @gradientforce761 วันที่ผ่านมา +5

    54:16 This bit right here. MASTERFUL editing. I had never put the two and two together that Thancred is a scaled down scope Emmet. And him being the one to break though the barrier, to see though the layer of grief that Emmet has surrounded himself with because he KNOWS the answer to the questions he's asking is just SO poignant

    • @kithers425
      @kithers425 18 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      THIS 💯 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @fieldofyellowroses
    @fieldofyellowroses วันที่ผ่านมา +6

    The hours of gposing in Shadowbringers is so real. You are a lovely human being. I can't articulate words even half as well as you, but baring your soul to us strangers on the internet was really brave and heavily amplifies the overall message of your video essay. Thank you so much for the experience!

  • @bendonatier
    @bendonatier 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +24

    There is something so uniquely powerful about a game painting the most utterly beautiful and real picture of grief and suffering, and then telling the player to "Yes and?" It. This world is dead, but there are still people here. My loved one is gone, but there are new people to love. My friend has changed, and is now my enemy, but they are stilll possesed of the things that made them your friend.
    For me its the scene with Ardbert and Feo Ul on the watchtower, telling you to just take a moment to breath. They remind you that its not past, present, or future that matters, but all three at once, anf none of them at all. The offer to take the role of Titania amd lock yourself away in a depression nest, not because its healthy but because your loved ones would rather protect you in pain then let your suffering actually kill you.
    This would have been a beautiful essay if only for the script, but your editing, cinematography, and cosplay were perfect. Even your damn thumbnail is Peek. Heres hoping you enjoy Dawn Trail.

  • @kiyoskedante
    @kiyoskedante 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +15

    As someone who also experienced shadowbringers in the wake of grieving i too felt the quite rudely outspoken portrayal of grief and the madness of focusing on it.
    I also see the companion scene in endwalker of Emet-Selch going "you believe any of this? That mad with grief i would turn the world inside out to bring someone back?" And all the knowledge of Amurot and the moon thinking "that i know the guy at the table with you at all means i know how bad you regret his departure."
    Just stunning poetry of story telling on display.

  • @Castersvarog
    @Castersvarog วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    God I loved Lythes voice acting in that first scene. It’s just so well done you can feel, not just hear, feel the grief in her voice, and her desire to just cry

  • @mooglesguard
    @mooglesguard 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +23

    how does this only have 700 views. literally the best ffxiv video i’ve seen on this site

    • @mooglesguard
      @mooglesguard 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

      I MADE THIS COMMENT AT THE BEGINNING OF THE VIDEO AND THEN. THE EMET SELCH OUTFIT?!?!?!?!?!?!?! FAVORITE VIDEO EVER ACTUALLY

  • @shaneh6707
    @shaneh6707 12 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา +1

    Shadowbringers, at least replaying it, unironically helped me grieve the loss of my cat whom I had for 12 years. Its still my favorite expansion to this day

  • @bonetower
    @bonetower 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +11

    First of all: CAT!
    Second... The algorithm gut punches. Giving me this as a suggestion to watch as i struggle with my own emotions and trauma in the last zone of Dawntrail, to a point where very few others will feel the same due to why i'm feeling the way i am - yes being vague as we have yet to even touch launch outside early access.
    Grief and pain are some of the most difficult things to deal with, that heavy weight under your heart that persists for weeks on end that you just learn to live with, how quickly your emotions churn again when it's even vaguely prodded.
    The writers did an amazing job. I love them for it. I hate them for it.

  • @edwardnowakowski5990
    @edwardnowakowski5990 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +11

    39:00 “The poems and platitudes of wiser men. Musings on sadness and loss... Studied and memorized... and meaningless in the moment.”
    Ironically, my favorite quote about grief is about the uselessness of quotes about grief when you’re in the midst of it

  • @jaymarlow851
    @jaymarlow851 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +18

    30 minutes in and i'm crying over how much you get ardbert. you've laid out every single reason why i adore him and his role in the story and as a mirror to the wol... also god i love how you've covered thancred's messy and difficult grief and i'm crying over minfilia and thancred and how grief has shaped them both (literally her whole existence is defined by ranjit's grief and then thancred's until she breaks out of her shell!) i'm not normal and i AM sobbing

  • @NomadicalNomad
    @NomadicalNomad วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    A fantastically stunning, and rightfully gut punching recount of shadowbringers. Its never been an easy thing for some people, myself notably to voice how a story like this effects everyone on their first, rather raw experience of it, but if I ever have a need for it, this video will be a cherished memory that I'll find one excuse after another to come back to.

  • @Tardisntimbits
    @Tardisntimbits วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I've had to endure a lot of grief from the time ShB came out, to now. Hell, it hasn't even been 24 hours since we had to get our dear elderly cat put down, so the timing and poignancy of finding this video today is remarkable. Sometimes, with the rate of people and family pets lost, it feels like I'm drowning in a neverending sea of sorrow and loss. It's hard to talk about it when it's this raw. So instead, I'll talk about the game. I loved Emet-Selch from the first moment I saw him (much like I did with Ardyn from XV), and ShB as a whole expressed so much that resonated with me. Of course he wanted desperately to be with his loved ones. Of course you have to protect not just yours, but all of the shards. It's just a beautiful, gut-twisting story.

  • @tikusya
    @tikusya วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    this was so beautifully made and the part about your personal grief. god. that pain and heartache is second to none. I also lost my father at a young age, was forced to stand by a podium and announce my feelings of sorrow and loss when i hadn't fully comprehended them. Now life goes on and there's a big gaping hole in my life that i don't know what to do with. But if FFXIV has taught me anything it's to not let grief weigh you down and that you should keep on living. shadowbringers is such a painful and beautiful story of loss ( and fire and faith), and ardbert as a character will never fail to make me ugly cry.
    This video might be. the video of all time. holy fucking shit its so very beautiful. i hope the algorithm spreads this video far and wide because this deserves tens of thousands of views. amazing video 11/10 would cry again, shoutout peakbringers i love found family !!!!!!!!

  • @artemisjohns2209
    @artemisjohns2209 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    Absolutely fantastic essay. I don't know if I really have quite the words to explain why, but this piece of writing got to me like few others have. Thinking about some of the parallels that I'd missed has me looking forward to a second play of Shadowbringers on a second character I've been leveling on the side. I'll probably be back to write something more when I've had more time to marinate on this (and probably watch it again). Thank you so much for making this ❤

  • @Yuuni3D
    @Yuuni3D วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Phenomenal Essay in both your delivery and its contents. Even after all these years, Shadowbringers and my first experience with its story remains among the frequently remembered moments in my head. Shadowbringer's themes are relatable to anyone affected by the shadow of grief, and i cant help but feel a welling of emotions when viewing grief through a lens as grandiose as this expansion. The context endwalker provides to a lot of the story beats in Shadowbringers makes the two expansions feel so closely connected, on a much deeper level than "this is just the next expansion".
    Thanks for putting this out there! It definitely brought back very fond memories.

  • @Salt_Mage
    @Salt_Mage 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Another great word for the Shadowbringers/Endwalker duology is *Legacy*.
    The Ancients, Ardbert, the failed timeline. What mark do we leave on the world? How do our actions inform the actions of those that follow?

  • @sonagihan9589
    @sonagihan9589 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +12

    i just finished this video essay and like many of the other people in the comments started crying or almost crying every 10-15 minutes or so, especially about ryne and thancred. thank you so much for making this video.

  • @garbagemancer8592
    @garbagemancer8592 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Holy fuck I wasn't expecting to be seen so hard with this video. As a fellow Father-Loser it's nearly impossible to describe the intimacy of grief and how painfully obvious it is to us- to the point where we often doubt ourselves about whether what we feel is actually grief or if it's just habit born of a suffering that, unless you have been in the position to feel it, you cannot truly comprehend the scope of. Such that when you see it and you try to explain it, it feels like you're insane. But you did, or at least I felt like you did, and I'm thankful for that. Thank you.

  • @cstaie85
    @cstaie85 8 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา +1

    This video is the best piece of media that I have ever seen to explore the link between art, video games, grief, and loss than I think I will ever see. I love your work. And it is incredible.

  • @MaelraJade
    @MaelraJade 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    I rejoice at someone that knows and understands Cylva! There are dozens of us players that know and care about her.

    • @aerieleah533
      @aerieleah533 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Blows my mind that she and the reconstruction of the 13th is locked behind the role quests.
      But God I love it. Comparatively, I was just a touch disappointed with how Endwalkers ended up. Love the actual role quests, but felt something was missing from the cumulative quest.

  • @puttingthethotinthottbot
    @puttingthethotinthottbot 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Up until this expansion, I didn't fully appreciate the differences in the day and night overworld themes. That first moment you kill a lightwarden and the day clears out to bring the sky from punishing light to gentle darkness accompanied by a beautiful piano score... It changed something indescribable in me

  • @nexumine
    @nexumine 8 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    "this is alisaie! i named her after the elf girl-" and she's living up to it too!

  • @rogthepirate4593
    @rogthepirate4593 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    1:50 I know the feeling. Started playing during ShB out of desperation because I craved story-driven games with emotional impact to help me through the lockdown boredom. I'd tried to get into it years before but couldn't get past ARR, and I supposed that MMOs and a good story were just fundamentally incompatible things. Whooboy. Never been so glad to be absolutely, horrendously wrong about something before.

  • @ryoujiarisato7308
    @ryoujiarisato7308 9 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Shadowbringers was this game's peak. At first i was extremely disappointed that endwalker and dawntrail didn't come even close to it, but not i've happyily accepted that that was just peak and i'll remember it dearly

  • @GaaraofthePhunk
    @GaaraofthePhunk 21 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา +1

    I just finished the main Shadowbringers MSQ this week. Thanks for spending so much time digging into its themes :)

  • @Blue_Harmony
    @Blue_Harmony วันที่ผ่านมา

    You put in to words why Shadowbringers is such a special story. I also think with how the Amaurot Emet created is forever stuck to repeat the days before the final days hit is another example of how he can't move on from the past even to the day his world changed with the final days hitting yet the reality of it all still looms in his mind

  • @kadeosborne3937
    @kadeosborne3937 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    shadowbringers will always be my favorite expansion in any mmo because it was one of the first games that made me realize I shouldn't punish myself for feeling miserable nor should I stew in it and instead I should focus on bettering my self and the people around me, and I've played many games that touch on mental health and other serious subject matters but shadowbringers was like staring into a new horizon, I still love heavensward because of its emotional strengths but my respect will always be focused on shadowbringers and how amazingly written it was.

  • @ryanwagner7444
    @ryanwagner7444 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +5

    Spent a lot of this video thinking you write like Tim Rogers. Then you quote Tim Rogers. This video was excellent.

  • @hehashivemind6111
    @hehashivemind6111 20 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    This was beautifully written and spoken.
    The Tim Roger’s quote is a hell of a thing.
    I struggled with grief and depression for a better part of my life (I, too, lost my father as a young teen, though I never got to give a eulogy; a few years later I lost my eldest half sister), deeply affecting me and crippling me, making me resentful about who I could have been had I not been stricken with it, about lost potential. But in that time, I expressed myself through writing and art, and much like yourself, I found myself not only gravitating towards the theme of grief in bodies of work (through somewhat avoidant where I can), but I also have learned to become both poetic and self-critical in pursuit of refinement, clarity, and creating the best version of a thing I could make. Your intermission notes on changes to the essay as reflections of its evolution were particularly personalizing.
    In a weird and wild way, I find you both kindred spirit and alien to me, and felt that way throughout the one hour and twelve minutes. I simultaneously want to reach out and befriend you, but know that that’s the least of your desire from a video essay you put out on the internet, and moreover, you strike me as the kind of artist and friend who I would inevitably have a falling out with, if not outright rejection. Maybe that’s just my complex speaking.
    This video, and your channel, has reminded me that I really do need to get back on my creative horse. I need to write, and I need to draw. I have a story I’m still in the middle of telling, and it’s nowhere near done. I have a cathedral to build, and leaving it unfinished weighs on me something terrible.
    There is art to be made. Thank you for this video. I hope you’re enjoying Dawntrail! I certainly am.

  • @Uniboros
    @Uniboros วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Your emet-selch cosplay is fabb 😍 and such a lovely essay too!!!

  • @FrancisPlamondon1982
    @FrancisPlamondon1982 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Is it weird if I clapped at the end, alone in my office? I had never realized the parallel between Thancred and Emet's dialogues until you put them side by side. Now I feel the need to play again after almost two years.

  • @larcesciel
    @larcesciel 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    "The rains and have ceased and we have been graced with another beautiful day. But you are not here to see it"
    Above all the other lines in the story I think this one has stuck with me the most simply by how much grief it conveys. Sometimes in spite of how beautiful life can truly be our grief can blind us to the hope that tomorrow can promise. And yet it is for tomorrow we will have to learn to live for again and again.
    Shadowbringers will always be special and I love that Endwalker serves as true continuance of its theme in the face of overwhelming despair.
    Thank you for the video and the Emet-Selch fan club has another great member for sure.

  • @RothAnim
    @RothAnim วันที่ผ่านมา

    This is a lovely essay; I hadn't considered that parallel between Thancred and Emet-Selch before.

  • @livingreverie5951
    @livingreverie5951 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    Disappears for 2 years
    Comes back and cooks about an expansion to tell the story about the Second most fucked world in FF14
    (the first goes to the 13th. If you know you know).
    Truly one of the videos of all time
    Yknow what, keep cooking

  • @Phyrior
    @Phyrior 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Really tempting fate there by naming the little attacker after the scrappier of the twins...

  • @WakkaMadeInYevon
    @WakkaMadeInYevon วันที่ผ่านมา

    I thought i had processed all of my Shadowbringers emotions.
    Then i actually did the Keanu Reeves crying meme when you started talking about Seto.
    Fantastic video.

  • @ThunderKnightSilver2
    @ThunderKnightSilver2 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    I really shouldn't have played this video at 11:00PM. I don't know what to do with these feelings. I'm filled to the brim with so much grief not just for past tragedies which altered myself as a person in profound and terrifying ways but also a future (whether irrational or not) I can never see as being truly within my grasp. What I'm trying to say is this was an excellent video essay and everyone should replay Shadowbrigers

  • @Swix_FGC
    @Swix_FGC 11 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    This has to be one of the best if not THE best essays i've listened to about SHB. Just excellent.

  • @minananar
    @minananar 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    Had to stop watching this video every like 15 minutes, because I'd start crying, as I thought back to the story, and then would hit play again to listen to your amazing analysis, this expansion is so wonderful and thank you for wonderfully dissecting its narrative.

  • @noobminatorTBNK
    @noobminatorTBNK วันที่ผ่านมา

    "Remember us. Remember that we once lived."

  • @aerieleah533
    @aerieleah533 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    God this expansion is absolutely art. Somehow I hadn't made the full connection between Thancred and Emet Selch that you did, probably because I didn't stop to think on that one. I was so engrossed in thinking of the connection between him and G'raha, which is his perfect foil in the macro. I didn't see how Thancred is also a perfect foil in the micro. Wow.
    Also your cosplay of Emet was great. And I did something similar. I dont wear my fandoms on my sleeve. Dont buy trinkets or paintings. Dont wear clothes for it. But I have not one, not two, but three displates for this game. All are up prominantly on my wall. All are around the ancients or endwalker themed.

  • @jonathangarver
    @jonathangarver วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank you for a finely crafted essay, it was a good look back at those aspects that really did enable that narrative to pull my heartstrings so intensely

  • @Tobeh
    @Tobeh 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    My girlfriend pointed out the burger king crown is what people call the mentor crown.

  • @Burrenyuu
    @Burrenyuu วันที่ผ่านมา

    I'm not one to really out here writing comments, but this video was absolutely incredible. I wasn't at all prepared for the feelings your analysis brought about in me. I was fighting back tears in the middle of a walmart... kudos

  • @aeiuo42
    @aeiuo42 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    we have reached peak ffxiv video

  • @xSaraxMxNeffx
    @xSaraxMxNeffx 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    "This is alisaie~" *proceeds to prove how she got her name*

    • @fieldofyellowroses
      @fieldofyellowroses 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      The cat is so cute! Very clearly named accurately 🤣

  • @zeroanonymity9736
    @zeroanonymity9736 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    So I just made it past Interlude 2, paused it right when the ticking of Amaurot's theme began, and I only include that to give the next sentence some weight:
    This is one of the best essays I've had the pleasure of experiencing. You've nailed it, everything I enjoyed about Shadowbringers and its themes is included as well as details I hadn't thought critically about. I cannot wait to hear your thoughts on Emet Selch and to watch your other videos once this is over. You've more than earned this sub.
    Also Alisae, the cat (and please pardon my likely misspelling of her name), is ADORABLE.

  • @MelissaThornton
    @MelissaThornton 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I think that this is why we all latch on to new players going through the story. It is that we all have our individual pain and experience in life, but the story here gives us all a shared reference for those feelings, be they high or low.

  • @puttingthethotinthottbot
    @puttingthethotinthottbot 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    "Remember us... Remember that we once lived"

  • @mardocOz
    @mardocOz 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank you. I thoroughly enjoyed this essay into the themes of Shadowbringers, and your exploration of its main cast and how they approach grief and loss.
    Both your writing, explaining themes and threads that we may have missed the first time through, and your overall presentation were both clear and entertaining throughout, and while the subject matter may be difficult and trigger challenging memories and emotions within us, I nevertheless enjoyed watching until the end.
    I expect this took a long time and a lot of effort to put together and appreciate the effort. Should you feel so inspired in the future I would be interesting in hearing your thoughts and insights about other expansions/games.

  • @cooball
    @cooball วันที่ผ่านมา

    What an absolutely fantastic essay. Beyond glad this ended up recommended to me.

  • @jjjuser1
    @jjjuser1 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    God I love this expansion, in retrospect it helped me work through some personal issues that a philosophy degree only did a patch job for. This was a great reflection and analysis. I really appreciated the thorough breakdown of the emet/thancred parallels. Also loved the femro rep, mine mostly either smirks or dudebro's her way through the story despite my efforts to attach some sort of inner angst or particularly complex interiority, so its fun to see what trials and tribulations yours and others WOLs go through. Do you think emet would ever smoke weed? I feel like its a no as he's not allowed to have fun, but would be interested in other opinions.

  • @Shifft-This
    @Shifft-This 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    TH-cam auto played this and I was working on my laptop. I kept planning on swapping to a different video as soon as I got to a good place to move my hands from my laptop to my actual PC. Managed to watch the entire video. Well done. Was not expecting you to keep me engaged as long as you did.
    Your train of thought was entertaining and when I first set eyes on you and your musings I didn't think you seemed like the kind of person that would "get" Final Fantasy. I'm happy to say I was clearly wrong.

  • @poro9084
    @poro9084 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    when they needed me most.. i started crying at that point

  • @davidcollins9213
    @davidcollins9213 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    7:30
    This. This is my relationship with my WoL since the vault, and I have been figuring out who she is ever since. And my time with this game has been richer for it.
    Also FEM ROE REPRESENT!

  • @raunjisto2925
    @raunjisto2925 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Wow. I've never seen or heard anyone explain the themes of this story so well. I never even realized half of these things until you pointed them all out. So now I love this expansion more than I already did. So thank you very much for this video!

  • @outeremissary4438
    @outeremissary4438 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    This is a wonderful essay- thank you for sharing it! I don't have a good comment but wanted to express how touching it was anyway, especially in the vulnerability of how personal it is

  • @pudo5044
    @pudo5044 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    never watched anything of yours before, but this video is unbelievably beautiful

  • @dieselsandwich42
    @dieselsandwich42 6 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Sometimes you just gotta watch a video essay about the themes of ffxiv and weep for a while.

  • @quianachase6651
    @quianachase6651 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Finally, a TH-cam video made specifically for me 🥺
    I'm gonna watch this while leveling Pictomancer and then I will Return and Report

  • @Spielmeister456
    @Spielmeister456 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +5

    god this is such a great yappathon. Thank you for not going overboard in editing; definitely helps highlight your feelings & enthusiasm in your wording throughout the video. Definitely one of the best things I've watched in a fat minute and I hope you make more XIV analysis stuff :)

  • @beltofbelt
    @beltofbelt 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank you, I love this.

  • @Flare122Mw2
    @Flare122Mw2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    You deserve the notification bell young lady! I’ll be waiting for your next movie

  • @zkng
    @zkng 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank you, this was a great watch

  • @VeronwDS
    @VeronwDS 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wow. This is incredibly well done!

  • @deathknell609
    @deathknell609 22 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Excellent video. Thank you

  • @Coolio_Ash
    @Coolio_Ash 5 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Ill watch this till im through the dawntrail cue

  • @dom7595p
    @dom7595p 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    awesome video!

  • @lampdevil
    @lampdevil 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    This was FANTASTIC. I know Shadowbringers end to end, have discussed the characters to the point where I feel like I've gone over every possible point... but putting the lens of exploration so firmly on grief brings things into focus that maybe I haven't stared at too long because it's too hard to behold. Endwalker is in conversation with Shadowbringers, for sure, and it's Endwalker's explorations of loss and what it means to continue to live are what left me shaken and weepy for days afterwards. I think I'm going to have some things to process the next time I replay Shadowbringers. So thank you.

  • @ASplashOfCol0urs
    @ASplashOfCol0urs วันที่ผ่านมา

    As soon as I saw your cat behind you I knew what she was about to do little darling she is ❤

  • @SRN_RL
    @SRN_RL 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This was really good!
    ...I should play through this game again. Sometime soon, after Dawntrail.

  • @lck0ut348
    @lck0ut348 4 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    The writers who touched FFXIV have done damn good jobs writing all of their antagonists, yet Emet-Selch stands apart to me. He's the one I relished the defeat of the most, but also empathized with the most, and understood the motives of the most (even if I disagreed with his methods).
    The extra character development he gets in Endwalker just furthered this in my mind. I do disagree with his actions (sacrificing those he did to try to summon Zodiark), his ultimate downfall at the hands of the WoL became all that much sweeter, but I also felt sympathetic to his motives even more.

  • @mp-0845
    @mp-0845 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    in your intro, i thought i recognized the wol, but when i saw the charm at 1:22 i screamed "FORGIVEN WHIMSY." haha. love your stuff sm! the video was really good! 🤍🤧

  • @thed4rknss673
    @thed4rknss673 22 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Beautifull essay

  • @bellringer53
    @bellringer53 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Oh my god the emet cosplay!!! It made it into the video!!!

  • @EmberRabbit
    @EmberRabbit วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I’m going to post this here because I have nowhere else to talk about this but this has spoilers for post Endwalker and the allied race quests and some trigger warnings and content warnings for various horrible things.
    Everyone who knows me knows I’m the loporrits’ biggest fan, I rescue bunnies in real life and my husband calls me his Lovingway. The Loporrit allied race quests -regardless of how much I love them- are the ones that speak truest to me and have shifted my life in a wonderful way. SPOILERS FROM HERE ON OUT after the final days and the death of Hydaelyn the loporrits are absolutely lost, devastated now that they cannot fulfill their single task of saving and helping the people of Etheirys; some take it in stride and others’, like the black loporrit, have been driven to the point of despair that they are contemplating the loporrit equivalent of ending themselves in the form of eternal stasis.
    TW from here out. My family was extremely abusive, I was raised and groomed to be one thing and one thing only, a wife and mother, and I was expected to do it by the time I was 16. I was exposed to vivid descriptions of what I should be doing to my future (much older) husband when I was still in the single digits of age. This led me to be sexually abused by my partners. I had been sheltered from the outside world. Isolated from people my age. And gaslit for everything. Told I was lying when I told the truth. Told I was not bulimic but just cared about my body. There are many other far more disgusting things but those are the most relevant and don’t want to make people miserable just to air my grievances. I ran away the moment I was legal with a man I had met online. He kept me safe and told me that I could be myself now except I didn’t know who I was. My only purpose was stripped away, the family I knew was gone, the looming threat was gone, and I had never wanted to disappear more than then. Everything hit all at once and I didn’t know WHO I was. I was lost. I was scared. I knew who I WANTED to be but I didn’t know how to get there. It seemed like to grand of a task to even attempt, like climbing Everest with no materials or time to prep. I wanted to disappear. I wanted to just be absorbed by the earth and decompose for the earth to use my body better than I was. I got help after a lot of fighting against it, I went to therapy, I found friends who liked me regardless of my boisterous, loud albeit clumsy and sometimes naive personality, I ended my eating disorder and learned to accept my body even when I drastically changed. And then I got Covid. I was bedridden for 8 months, and after those 8 months I waited a year and a half more before going to the hospital for a severe chest pain that had been there nonstop, it was a pulmonary embolism that could have killed me anytime but waited for me to find it. I have had to relearn how to do many things because my brain is permanently damaged now and I’ve had to learn to live in this much more broken body. I’ve had to completely restart my life from everything I knew, just like the black loporrit.
    My WOL is me. I made her to be the me I’ve always wanted to be and that me never gave up on the black loporrit. No matter how much they wanted to disappear, no matter how much they fought and scoffed and cringed while we tried to find worth and value outside of Hydaelyn’s single task left for them I never gave up helping them find a dream. And finally something changes, they open up about their pain, they ask for help, and they find something new and beautiful without having to leave all of their dreams behind. They change their name and they open their hearts to new love, new friends, and new dreams. So I did the same. I changed my name and despite the horrors I knew of the world I knew I wanted to be a dancer and an artist and that dream never left, so I scrapped everything and started creating again. I found my dreams again. And I found happiness and the path that will lead me to the myself I want to be. The loporrits changed me for the better and have inspired me to BE again.

  • @mun3692
    @mun3692 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    incredibly, incredibly well put together essay. you should be proud of the art you've created from, well, art.
    this essay is important to me, and therefore, it holds value no matter what.

  • @XainRussell
    @XainRussell 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Excellent video! I’ve been replaying through the MSQ with a new player, and this just made me all the more excited to get to Shadowbringers.
    (Technical critique: maybe consider a pop-filter for your mic? It did distract a bit for me.)

  • @maplemabel
    @maplemabel 6 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    the way thancred and emet mirror each other's grief as it's still fresh for him... ough

  • @Driahva
    @Driahva 12 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Oh my goodness Alisaie is so perfect and violent.

  • @22Arkantos
    @22Arkantos 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This video essay might be your cathedral, but damn- what a beautiful cathedral it is!

  • @LordPhiI
    @LordPhiI 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Loved this!
    Also kind of funny my Roe had the same hair and color when I went through EW

  • @cptroot
    @cptroot 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    MFW I have to stop watching halfway through for fear of spoiling the role quest capstone for myself. One of these days I'll get back to that...

  • @triplejy2k451
    @triplejy2k451 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    YOU GOT INTO THE GAME CAUSE OF THE FUCKING EMET MOTHER FANCAM?!?!??! I CANT

    • @madsengland
      @madsengland  2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      not only did it get me into the game, like 90% of the reason it exists at all was to get me, specifically, into the game

  • @richardatha6860
    @richardatha6860 วันที่ผ่านมา

    And he would do it all again

  • @Beaniboi
    @Beaniboi 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    ah. what a great hour long video i sat through in its entirety and made me rethink some of my personal recent history. time to go to the comments and-
    OH MY GOODNESS. WHERE ARE THE VIEWS??
    SQUIDWAAAAARD

  • @bofdm
    @bofdm 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The man so burdened with grief he walks with a literal slouch.

  • @Acalypha48
    @Acalypha48 วันที่ผ่านมา

    you can't just open the video like that, fuck im already crying

  • @swellowtail3117
    @swellowtail3117 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    THIS VIDEO IS SO FUCKING GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD