Suman says Gigi did not hit the high note and gives her red light. He gave Chantel green light before because of her potentials but why he gives her red light for final? I think Gigi is amazing and well deserved to be number 1!
I think Gigi is very emotional and nearly cry in the song, she deserves the green light as she has the emotion break through in this performance! That’s her first time ,
@@wkpp0706 please continue to cover this topic before season 2 starts! would love to hear more behind the scenes about who voted for which contestant, the exact filming date for each episode and whether there were any second takes, how much tuning was used etc.
Some points towards the alleged fairness issue of the scoring system. Excuse a longer post 😁 * if i were not wrong, online votes that got lumped into round 1 judges' result were those gathered DURING round 1, and EXCLUDING online votes gathered cumulatively over the last 3 or 4 weeks before the final. The latter determined the 2nd 🏆 * to remind, the scoring system was made known to all concerned before the final and shared with media. At least I did hear it on YT so it's quite tranparent If deemed unfair, why didn't the contestants, media, the public etc voice out, make noises etc earlier? * to be blunt, contestants knew full well what they were getting into , and can't have the cake and eat it. To be fair, don't think they did. Well may be some of their more passionate fans do 😉 * last not least, I recall Mr LEE mentioned very early that, paraphrasing, Stars Academy sought to discover a star who sings well , and NOT just a *good singer* 'cos many people sing well but... I'd say the ability to sufficiently persuade viewers to be bothered to vote for you is a key part of the deal. That's charisma, man! Admittedly, Chantel has it despite not topping the techniques category. Ditto, Gigi, even Yumi, and plausibly Archie in various capacities. It's commercial, like it or not. In short, 願賭服輸。當然，TVB最好可以review and improve 賽制 la.... In pre/post interviews the four runners up unanimously said they didn't mind not being the winner ,and all. May not have fully meant it but i think Archie and Chantel knew they probably weren't that star amongst final 5, unless Gigi flopped big time. She didn't despite imperfections, per most professional analyses available so far. Sadly, some very minority views suggest those lights could be manipulated (hence some didn't work) . Well, anything was possible ,hackers anyone?! God bless if fraud was committed so publicly during a rather visible live show and balantly in front of 25+ pros.... 😱
On top of that, everyone should sing twice. This will only take no more than 30 minutes, which includes running commercials. Let everyone showcase their talents one more time. They all work hard enough to earn a spot in final round. Archie got robe. His profile doesn’t match what TVB is looking for? He is actually better than Rock.
Hi Peggy, another great video , good final and Gigi was a deserved winner, but really TVB should have given the runner up a prize as well, as Chantel deserved it for getting 2nd place. if it wasn't for Chantel, 聲夢傳奇 would not be as successful, as she brought a lot of attention to the series.
Gigi和Chantel 原來都生病，昨晚兩位仍然盡力表演，十分專業，很欣賞。決賽怎樣都是要比試實力，Gigi慢歌和快歌都係揀高難度風險的，可見信心十足，三料冠軍🏆🏆🏆實至名歸👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
其實炎明熹真係好實至名歸！雖然第一場有點失誤，但整體不差。也大大証明佢做到心理調整，第2場完全感受到佢盡力，放晒咁唱！而且唱得十分好！呢樣我真係好欣賞！你諗下，佢早2日仲要商演，又傷過聲，又承受咁多人既期望，壓力真的很大！而第2場真係一出場已知佢會力壓對手！係佢最擅長的曲style!跳舞真好有台型，中段跳得十分正，其實好有節奏感。負評總會有，希望Gigi集中在欣賞佢既人，佢確係有實力，冇壓力下更是歌壇上的無敵巨人！🔥琴晚真係睇到我好感動，眼濕濕😭炎明熹唔止係努力實至名歸橫掃3獎，背後既故事，令我好大感受，真係會心痛呢個女孩，好希望佢會成功！快樂！前途美好！
對呀！昨晚真係好感動🥲
多謝分享，原來2個小妹妹都帶病演出，能有這樣的表現真的很不錯了，直播真的很不簡單。而且他們都是一班懂得感恩的孩子，現今比較少見了。希望他們可以向着自己目標前進啦，我哋會繼續支持佢哋㗎。💪💪💪
係呀！兩個小妹妹表現真係好叻，很有專業精，我地一定繼續支持佢哋💪
謝謝peggie老師分享，成晚好催淚，尤其gigi 段感言好感動，電視直播睇到現場好多人都落淚，佢情感控制真係好好，唱「領悟」唱到自己都喊，跳唱 bad Romance收拾心情入型入格。最最最……感動既一集，😭😭😭
Yes , 真係好多人喊
好耐冇見過一個咁有才華、又睇得、性格又好好的星
gigi真係好好好勁，由第一集到宜家，首首歌都好高難度，佢真係「百變天后」我好欣賞佢，唱左唔同曲風🤩。今日兩首歌 loop唔停，中曬毒😆
我都睇到喊晒口，又Lur晒音，又走音，我真快要哭了。
@@wkpp0706
Gigi真係不可多得,性格好,善良孝順,唱功好, 有情感
是一個百變小天后
炎明熹係第一個令到我會心痛，好真心想佢開心，成功既人😭
佢好清純、真誠，又唱得睇得
@@wkpp0706 未來天后，原本我真係連TVB都唔留意，直到我聽到有個人唱得幾好聽，就搵果個人是誰，然後發現是Gigi,留意多左佢，慢慢變埋佢粉絲😂我以前都好唔中意內地黎/TVB,因為佢，我改左觀，我覺得炎明熹就算係內地出生又有什麼問題，而在tvb工作也只是個平台讓佢發揮，我看的是她這個人，她開演唱會/出碟一定支持🔥
@@nickkk9739 +1
Gigi 好乖女好得人鍾意！💖
@@wkpp0706 百變小天后,性格好,孝順又懂感恩👍好欣賞她🔥
Gigi尋晚唱2首歌
領悟，Bad Romance完全2種極端的曲風
我相信好多人聽領悟都會一齊落淚
呢種魅力完全係冇得練，係天賦
我真係唔明點解會得17分
非常感動
唱出想家人的感覺，經過咁多集後，評審對gigi要求好高，差2粒音，但我感動了。💯💯💯
@@wongelenge 我都覺得評審對她的要求比其實的學員高。
@@w_cathy 認同，由一開始就有啲超班感覺🤩🤩🤩
Gigi 的歌聲已把我灌醉了 🌟😍🤩🥇👍🥰🏆實至名歸！期待Gigi 的靚聲再閃耀舞台
☺️👍💪🏻💪🏻
谢谢你的分析。我觉得Gigi 是很有potential 的。A new Star is going to shine. 我喜欢Gigi 的风格。勇敢突破知己。I'm really impressed. 最后我很喜欢你的分析。
感謝🙏🏻你
其實，除了Gigi巨星的誕生令人感動外，一直令人感動的是幾位星級導師和她自己的老師的悉心教導。她一路唱，她台下的老師一路喊，這種師徒情，現今世代真心好難搵。恭喜他們，全晚都好感動。
☺️❤️👍
其實好開心見到Gigi終於用到自己深情體會去唱領悟,亦幫佢平反有些人批評佢常玩歌用技巧帶動感情(味精)去演繹, 縱使有少量瑕疵但方向正確,經過呢次佢應該更可提高把握力去演唱, 自己聽完後真係好想Gigi試唱辛曉琪嘅味道, 效果應可拍住小谷喺流行經典五十年果次👍
當時辛曉琪-真係好紅！令人勾起好多回憶
GIGI個人老師賽前同佢講 : ""如果你感動到自己，感動到別人，如果有人批評你個呢一句嗰一句既小瑕疵，咁可能，連批評嗰個人自己都忘記左咩野係喜歡音樂，欣賞音樂。音樂係某程度上本來就唔應該具有批判性，人性化既演繹先至做到The perfect imperfection! ""
唔怪得佢今次唱到咁投入, 而有咁多聽眾為所動容, 原來用心, 真係最高境界
💝👍用心唱最能感動人
昨晚聽GIGI 唱 領悟 我都流了眼淚，
VERY GOOD 唱到入我心，想起20年前聽這首歌，情境。。。。
領悟這首歌真的帶給我們好多回憶！還有「味道」這首歌
多謝黄老師說出真相原來 Gigi 準決賽當晚發燒！謝謝你細心+專業分析！
她當晚應該退了燒，是之前一日☺️❤️
Gigi台下好鄰家少女feel,有時個樣好似夢遊緊,講嘢似劉以達好玄懵懵吓,好攪笑;但一上台成個人變哂,似super star上咗身咁,光芒萬丈,日後歌唱事業發展定無可限量。
十分同意☺️👍
Gigi是火星女神
依家仲多一個新名「Lady Gigi」
她 沒有刻意去 告訴別人 她自己不舒服 去博少少同情分數 👍👍👍
其實賽前都有報道話佢發燒
恭喜gigi，心路歷程，百變演繹，比賽已完結，15位畢業生，各有所長，聲途才剛開始，誰可跑到最後，誰是未來的，天皇天后級，人生旅途漫長，一路上加油，支持你們，樂壇發光發亮，指日可待。💯💯💯（期待第二季）
Yes, congrats to gigi 🎉👍💝❤️
我好心痛Gigi所受的壓力！見到佢喊，我都喊埋一份！Gigi 冠軍實至名歸！首bad。romance好有氣勢為，比而家好多所謂歌星更掂。其他學員都好好，喜見一班努力追夢的年青人，加油💪
對！一齊追夢！💪💪
Well said 真係超感動！🙏🏻🙏🏻😭😭🥰🥰
真的很touching
炎明熹站在台上的王者風範、霸氣迫人、唱功了得、揮灑自如,連掃三獎,絕對是實至名歸,眾望所歸。
Agree so much !❤️👍
多謝Peggie的分折和分享，我個人認為賽果都係十分正常。炎明熹以大熱姿態，順利勇奪星夢的三個大獎，乃是眾望所歸。不過，雖然Gigi係帶病去比賽，但係佢唱領悟有點出現情緒失控，最終被評判扣了分。相信作為她的粉絲，當時一定看得十分緊張的。如果因為這樣而被foul了，那就真係十分不值了。不論怎樣，她整晚的表現都係值得我們讚賞的！👏👏👏
對，十分欣賞她！👍🏻
Me 2
Gigi唱到感動到自己 感動到觀眾 真係非常之利害 我喺電視前都俾佢感動到喊了💜
我咁晚睇東張西望也再喊！真攞命！😖
雖然2個都帶病出戰但是2個人歌唱的2首歌聽到好感動
對呀，十分感動！🥲❤️
唔知點解一路聽領悟一路自自然然流緊眼淚Gigi唱功好犀利
👍☺️❤️
我都係，好感動太好聽了💜💜🔥🔥
恭喜gigi🍾️🎊💜🔥🍾️🎊💜🔥
👍🏻❤️☺️🎊🎉😍
人到傷心時說話都會食字，根本是情感爆發，啲不懂的評審聽得太耐現代的歌手，已忘記以前唱歌是這種感動的！
Gigi 喺舞臺好有魅力， 喺台下係一位純情學生妹，上到台真係比佢深深吸引，有大將之風， 三料冠軍係實至名歸
人心肉做 真情流露
令到咁多位評審頭痛
用歌唱去唱出自己經歷，而到最後一晚情緒爆發
別忘記只有十六歲，再堅強的人都會有崩潰時候
我們都是人而不是機器，投票結果足以證明到評審們真的是用心去陪伴學員成長，用心去感受會一位學員，19燈 跟兩個17燈 的我都覺得係個晚臝左，但只係個晚，但總計整個聲夢旅程，我唸大家都會有自己心水
我會唸 如果呢個節目冇左gigi ，會吾會最多都會變成以前既超級巨星呢？雖然今次個ending吾係太理想，不是所有人的預期，但正正是感人結局另所有人會記得這一晚，而只是一個普通的唱歌比賽咁簡單
謝謝🙏
對，大家都會好記得今晚❤️
多謝分享拍攝既趣事同感受^^
好似只得我一個喺度喪笑🤣🤣
我覺得，由第一日開始，個個已經不停講Gigi 會第一，根本無咩係絕對，Gigi仍然係要好努力一關一關咁面對，起起跌跌，心裡好難受。直至全港嘅人都話自己係冠軍，好似抹殺曬佢嘅壓力同努力咁，以致佢壓力爆煲，after all，佢得16歲，點頂？大人都唔得，所以，我聽到佢病，真係心痛左出來。
💪🏻💝
我都係😪😪
黃老師你每次演繹都好好聽，希望有機會都聽到你嘅演出，或者你同學員一齊演出俾我哋欣賞😍
👍☺️❤️好提議
多謝 分享 🙏🙏🙏
Thx ☺️
在Yt重聽Gigi首領悟，同當晚電視好唔同，聽得清楚好多，佢真摯的感情演繹蓋過了所有瑕疪，同埋表達到「痛」的悲鳴，令我有揪心的感覺！
對呀！我聽第一段都已經想喊
嗰晚決賽，如果再睇返佢敢言…真係會再喊！仲有佢姑丈姑媽同老師真係見到都會喊！好耐未試過有咁嘅節目
@@wkpp0706 我嗰晚都睇到眼濕濕。可能我細女同佢差唔多年紀，佢父母又唔係身邊，佢又乖又努力，所以對佢特別有感覺
對呀，感動了好多人🥲
謝謝分享😀
👏🏻👏🏻🎉☺️
Last time you mentioned Gigi sings a bit 慢熱, but in the finale’s 領悟，I can completely feel her emotions from her first line. So proud of her 😎🤟🏻
We all love her ! A lovely n sincere girl ! ❤️
@@wkpp0706 Y E S 🥰🥰
妳的分析清楚易明，有實例引證，好有立體感! 謝謝妳!!!
感謝你☺️❤️wing Tak chiu
有睇我最新片講「領悟」嗎？
聽到你話GIGI發燒個下，我即刻喊左
唔怪得知Gigi 佢噚晚咁感觸喇，又病又大壓力，又掛住爹娘，情感真係一觸即發，🥺🥺🥺🥺
HAPPY TO SEE GIGI WON !!! 👍👏👏👏❤️
謝謝💐💐💜💜
謝謝分享❤️👍
Thx Eva 😀👍💖❤️
我個人唔應同《舒文》講法，Gigi 尾段有走音，Gigi 唱《領悟》尾段我聽咗好多次喺有炒聲，少少炒聲，但未至於走音， 但係佢啲感情喺做得好好， 落咗好多心機。
👍☺️❤️
我唔覺得最後GiGi對Chantel係一場對決😂反而係一場好精彩冇比併嘅演出😚
因為我有份投票俾Chantel，同埋叫全家人投票俾佢！純粹係想佢入到兩強唱多一首歌！可以俾佢喺聲夢舞台最後一次唱到兩首歌 滿足支持佢嘅觀眾🙈佢已經超額完成㗎啦！一開始入佢拎9分入危險區 慢慢見佢一集一集飛躍進步 觀眾都好替佢開心😊呢位小妹妹前途無可限量！希望佢讀完書之後可以喺唱歌路上繼續發展！
我都明白佢出身富貴家庭 可能要繼承父業/其他行業 未必再唱歌 但我亦好希望佢未來日子會繼續唱歌 成為一位全職歌手😊👍🏻因為佢嘅潛質同埋虛心學習絕對係佢優勝之處☺️💪🏼
👍☺️❤️
一个人好用心地把自己的嗜好玩得好就已經系成功和美麗
@@user-dd1rl2eq3p ：👍👍☺️
Suman says Gigi did not hit the high note and gives her red light. He gave Chantel green light before because of her potentials but why he gives her red light for final? I think Gigi is amazing and well deserved to be number 1!
I think Gigi is very emotional and nearly cry in the song, she deserves the green light as she has the emotion break through in this performance! That’s her first time ,
舉個例子，如果拿奧運比賽跳水來說，領悟這首歌的難道分數是極高的，archie的我是懷念難道分數是中等的，gigi完成得有一點小水花，所以就算archie完美完成，也不能高分過gigi，rock的衝口而出難度也是極高的，大大的浪花所以炒粉了只有4分，chantel愛很簡單是中等難度，完成得中規中矩，yumi第4晚心情只有低等難度，完成得不算完美但尚算可以，大家可以評評有沒有道理。那位舒文大叔評gigi説有點瑕疵，以她的唱功唔應該犯錯，應該可以更好？？sorry囉！他可能是忘記了gigi不是專業歌手，而是只得16歲的小妹妹。我相信很多歌手去比賽，在決賽時都不敢去唱這種超高難度的歌，更何況是一位16歲的小妹妹，還從未走入過娛樂圈，她不衹是面對全港觀眾，還有世界幾個大城市，都還未算整過廣東省能觀看無線翡翠台的觀眾，面對的壓力有多少？她也勇敢面對去完成這個超高難度動作，只有小小的浪花，這樣還不是冠軍嗎？如果她不拿冠軍才是做馬！！
黃老師，都好多謝你一直以來嘅分享同意，期待第2季都可以聽到你那麼精彩嘅分享👍🏻
👍🏻☺️❤️
很喜歡你的分析
Thanks for sharing, love them all. ,
☺️❤️👍
原來GIGI和CHANTEL都生病,大家都好專業,好認真,盡力做好自己,值得讚賞。
2強演出完只有gigi和gin lee講野，應該比chantel和JW合作。真心Chantel舞蹈都OK，相比gigi技巧和壓台感，gigi的確優勝好多。
Chantel由第1集得9分，逃生門的進步讓JW感動，戀愛預告令大家甜蜜，成為國民初戀。矛盾一生和我這樣愛你都做得好好👍遇見仍得到JW好多既鼓勵和信心,發揮穩定！總決賽愛很簡單可能直播加上生病的關係，大家都好緊張，甚至有D失準，chantel有觀眾緣，JW和Chantel告白love you，JW看到chantel入到2強既驚喜又開心。
Chantel好大進步，有潛質,還需要磨練和提昇實力,一直陪著chantel如姐妹既JW真的居功至偉，加上音樂團隊，奶爸,保姆哥哥和評審的意見幫忙。CHANTEL的努力,仍有潛質,記住JW和JANICE既説話,最後得第2都已經很好了,始終只係比賽，大家盡情享受，做好自己，舞台留下自己精彩的表演更重要。
15個學員,導師歌手,主理人奶爸,保姆哥哥,評審,音樂團隊,舞蹈團隊都是聲夢大家庭,如GIN LEE所講一直都會在學員的身邊支持和愛大家,只要是唱歌和音樂的問題都會願意教導她們,導師歌手和學員加上奶爸已經投入好多感情和放了好多心機,視學員仔仔女女,亦師亦友,兄弟姐妹。私心自己想jw和chantel,gin lee和gigi好姐妹有合唱曲。
Gigi下一個巨星！chantel下一個天后，再加上另一姐妹yumi跳唱天后，將來的發展需要遇到歌曲和舞台表演的機會，加上運氣幫助，15個每位在舞台都留下精彩的表演,繼續加油努力。聲夢的完結也是繼續下一個目標和夢想的開始,成為全能歌手,實力派歌手,偶像歌手,創作型歌手和全能藝人,大家都要KEEP GOING！相信每一位之後可能會有不同的發展,不忘初心,努力必有回報,願大家的願望成真！
其實唔只學員學到嘢，經過你細心分析，令到我哋對唱歌、舞台表演技考都有較多認識，我哋都學到嘢！多謝你
☺️❤️💝👍
Yes I'm touched by the first song.
Yes, v touching 🥲❤️
谢谢分享，gigi 實至名歸
☺️👍❤️
Gigi 作晚勝出聲夢傳奇，原因有幾個，第一她揀啱自己歌路的歌唱。第二她發揮到隻歌，能夠感動人心，touching到大部份評判。Chantel 就揀錯歌唱，第一首愛很簡單，係國語歌，她唱得一般，不過不失，冇咩驚喜，同戀愛預告比較差好遠。第二隻快歌，她的發揮，平平無奇，做唔到outstanding, 所以就輸比GiGi.😎
Agree
Chantel唱快歌果段平平無奇，
Gigi發燒？🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺好肉尺！
病完都可以有咁好嘅表演，我真係佩服！
我都很佩服她
Thank you for sharing 👍
Thx 廖卫揚❤️☺️
Thank you, Miss Wong
☺️❤️
😃😀好好的仔細的分析
Thx Siuchi 💝👍
Gigi 從來都冇講過話佢發燒🤒️，聽到的時候真的好心痛，從來都唔會讓fans 擔心
Gigi 真的很譲人喜愛❤️
謝謝你的分享❤️❤️再次恭喜Gigi奪獎！可惜的是，昨晚的直播時間好像有點趕急以及Archie無法晉級兩強席位呢！
Gigi 實至名歸！☺️👍
其實Archie 做得很好
@@wkpp0706 Archie 超慘！想睇餓狼傳說 😢🤧🥲
@@hermiachui4728 原來好多人都想睇
@@wkpp0706 希望tvb會在youtube播番Archie 彩排片啦 🤧🤧
好欣賞你好正面咁評論好同唔好的位，professional
Thx Man☺️👍
GiGi發燒及唱第一首時哭著唱,估計是會影響發聲的！唱第二首簡直感受到未來天后誕生了.......
❤️☺️
gonna miss your post-match youtube analysis videos
Will have part 2 for last nite ‘s competition ☺️, any suggestion for my clips after 聲夢？☺️💝
@@wkpp0706 please continue to cover this topic before season 2 starts! would love to hear more behind the scenes about who voted for which contestant, the exact filming date for each episode and whether there were any second takes, how much tuning was used etc.
賽制對Archie，yumi唔公平，一個19分，一個17分，GiGi17分，同yumi系同分但yumi,archie佢哋人氣分唔夠就無得進入決賽，初時我以為每人都可以唱一首快一首慢對決，原來要進入決賽先可以唱多一首，😆如我人氣分唔夠咪即系上來陪親?🤣🤣，GiGi唱第一首歌我都聽都有走音，我估佢自己都知道，慶幸仍有17分，如果yumi人氣和佢對調我估GiGi進入唔到決賽了以這賽制，😎今次佢第一round贏得系有點幸運，不過佢唱Bad Romance..總算帶來驚喜，跳唱好好睇，無令GiGi粉絲失望。。😍Chantel個晚表現唱個兩首歌，唉！失望，由其唱個首快歌完全 駕馭唔到首歌神韻 點都好Archie，yumi,兩個好努力個晚佢哋只欠天時地利人和，🙁
很喜歡聽老師分享幕後的趣事。
🤣👍❤️
good show, could hardly tell it was recorded live if you didn't reaffirm it, only complaint was the lack of a live audience for fans and family
Yes, it was live and so exciting …☺️🎉
Chantel把扇比DANCER飛走左, 佢好叻女, 執生能力好高~
多謝黃老師分析~
☺️❤️👍
佢真的很鎮定👍
原來！仲以為佢唔記得左带 😅
謝謝你每次嘅分析，等大家可以了解多啲個演繹～～老師，我想八卦下😅chantel唱完，jw 講i love u , sammy又話好多愛，其實台上發生咩事？睇到一頭霧水😅😅
Ohoh，因JW 真的好錫Chantel 的，她們之間好有愛的❤️
見到Peggie 老師 同伍仲衡老師一齊同聲夢學員玩自拍 ................! 噚晚gigi 走時都成夜晚三點了 , 其實妳入了娛樂圈 , 如兼顧學業兩面發展 , 一定會好辛苦 , 但希望gigi支持到啦 !
☺️💝💪🏻
@@wkpp0706 聲夢傳奇總決賽完結 , Peggie 老師可以無禁忌 , 爆多D 我們幕前睇唔到D野畀我地知了................
@@user-yk2te2fo6g :haha 🤣好呀好呀
Peggie老師, 每次都分析得好細緻精彩👍👍
🙏🏻☺️❤️thx cherrie
好喜歡Gigi,她真的好勁，未來天后
美麗的黃老師星夢完了之後記得多出片說說現在香港樂壇什麼情況大家好友會繼續支持你💐💐💐💐
感謝大家一直支持！好呀！大家想看什麼？
@@wkpp0706
當然是黃老師開現場自彈自唱喇🌟🌟🌟🌟
請問peggie 老師gigi唱到中間，好似有兩把聲，gigi好似係做和音，之前windy 既bang bang都有類似效果，但係係獨唱，有咩作用？音樂請教，謝謝🤔🙏
對，為了將首歌推到高潮，通常這時歌手都會唱ad lib 部份… 「啊…啊⋯⋯」而和音歌手就唱歌詞..之後就返去歌手唱最後一段副歌☺️
@@wkpp0706 謝謝你既解答，呢D位置實在太特別🙏
☺️
好多人，包括我都好想問一個問題：「到底莫文蔚上去做乜？唱完首歌之後又唔係做評審，重好似走埋，咁不如叫蘇永康唱？情願佢將 D 時間加多個決賽位，最好就五個人都要唱晒兩首。」
觀眾投票佔既比率實在太大，希望下季會檢討下個比分制。
我係唔係唯一一個覺得 Chantel 唱『Chotto 等等』唱得好似“快歌慢唱”？
🤣🤣
Yes, thx for your suggestion 👍🏻☺️
多謝！Peggy 老師中肯意见，Chantel add oil
❤️👍🙏🏻☺️
Chantel之前接受雜誌訪問，話決賽歌富童話色彩，首歌開頭就似迪士尼啲音樂咁，佢想玩帶童話跳唱，森美笑佢似兒歌咁，yumi跳性感舞，chantel跳下其他嘅，開另一條路，香港都冇呢啲，性感狂野啲舞佢再大個啲先玩都未遲。
👍❤️☺️
十分好睇的總決賽
Yes ar!好刺激
最後兩強，你係咪俾左燈Chantel？見到周錫漢有俾
I like Gigi, 加油
謝謝你的分享！其實尋晚我覺得個結果幾驚訝，Gigi第一首歌失準唔少，而yumi基本上穩定發揮，咁嘅情況Gigi都可以有17燈....而且觀眾投票佔比太多，其他三個基本都係陪跑，未比都已經保送Gigi冠軍了
我都係!O左咀! 😔
d評判來回廁所事件真係幾funny喎😂
真係好撹笑的
黃老師，下次錄影可以大聲d嗎？我喺mtr聽，較到最大聲都唔夠☺️
☺️okok 👌
Some points towards the alleged fairness issue of the scoring system. Excuse a longer post 😁
* if i were not wrong, online votes that got lumped into round 1 judges' result were those gathered DURING round 1, and EXCLUDING online votes gathered cumulatively over the last 3 or 4 weeks before the final. The latter determined the 2nd 🏆
* to remind, the scoring system was made known to all concerned before the final and shared with media. At least I did hear it on YT so it's quite tranparent If deemed unfair, why didn't the contestants, media, the public etc voice out, make noises etc earlier?
* to be blunt, contestants knew full well what they were getting into , and can't have the cake and eat it. To be fair, don't think they did. Well may be some of their more passionate fans do 😉
* last not least, I recall Mr LEE mentioned very early that, paraphrasing, Stars Academy sought to discover a star who sings well , and NOT just a *good singer* 'cos many people sing well but... I'd say the ability to sufficiently persuade viewers to be bothered to vote for you is a key part of the deal. That's charisma, man! Admittedly, Chantel has it despite not topping the techniques category. Ditto, Gigi, even Yumi, and plausibly Archie in various capacities. It's commercial, like it or not.
In short, 願賭服輸。當然，TVB最好可以review and improve 賽制 la....
In pre/post interviews the four runners up unanimously said they didn't mind not being the winner ,and all. May not have fully meant it but i think Archie and Chantel knew they probably weren't that star amongst final 5, unless Gigi flopped big time. She didn't despite imperfections, per most professional analyses available so far.
Sadly, some very minority views suggest those lights could be manipulated (hence some didn't work) . Well, anything was possible ,hackers anyone?! God bless if fraud was committed so publicly during a rather visible live show and balantly in front of 25+ pros.... 😱
❤️❤️
想請教中女，gigi bad romance嗰兩句性感說話，係配定係佢自己講的？
佢自己講的☺️❤️
@@wkpp0706 謝謝妳呀！估不到她可以咁性感語氣，就如愛情陷阱嘅jazz咬字醉音味道。
@@fyyg82bmo 對呀！她真是屬於舞台的☺️👍
謝謝分析呀！其實Chantel自己都有講無諗住要爭冠軍，就只係想盡量做好！佢都好慘，前一日m痛，電視睇佢都面青青，所以其實小菲象聽多兩首歌已經好滿足
對呀！她常常m痛…真的要補補身體啊！☺️❤️👍💪🏻
佢飲太多珍珠奶茶，女仔飲太多凍野唔好
😯 咁我估啱左!真係又因為M痛....
@@lovertori7682 後生仔女就係喜歡飲凍嘢😅
Which one do u like the most?
Hm.. not easy to choose as each of them has his / her own characteristics..
Actually I like YUMI & ARCHIE VERY MUCH TOO 😔
They performed so well
dancer接個支mic時，放低後面透明膠坐上，攞起把扇失手跌咗落地，1-2秒間，chantel果刻見到冇扇，反應快，繼續表演，所以森美之後補上話，手中冇扇，心中有扇。🤣🤣🤣
我都翻睇左幾次，幸好Chantel 反應快，執生😆👍
昨天評分制度有誤, 企不影響實質結果。第二回合不應25評審一同比燈, 賽制應是分開比燈, 再將第一, 第二回合燈數合計, 才是評審大獎, 因為快歌慢哥各一首,應是兩者合併計算。
另, 觀眾評分佔50%有點不公平, 失去比賽目的, 對ARCHIE第一回合超水準比演不公平, 是整個SHOW嘅扣分點。
Gd suggestion actually ❤️
On top of that, everyone should sing twice. This will only take no more than 30 minutes, which includes running commercials. Let everyone showcase their talents one more time. They all work hard enough to earn a spot in final round. Archie got robe. His profile doesn’t match what TVB is looking for? He is actually better than Rock.
Hi Peggy, another great video , good final and Gigi was a deserved winner, but really TVB should have given the runner up a prize as well, as Chantel deserved it for getting 2nd place. if it wasn't for Chantel, 聲夢傳奇 would not be as successful, as she brought a lot of attention to the series.
I agree 100%
Really want to see at that time how the many more professionals judged for Bad Romance by Gigi. But I understood it is a rush Live show.
Not her perfect performance, but gd enough as a professional singer !
👍☺️
English pronunciation really need improvement.
But congratulations to Gigi, looking forward to see her do well in the near future.
@@chilo1306 : yes we love her ❤️❤️
江湖傳說，
「Gigi發緊燒都唱贏姜濤」。
原來她發緊燒都唱贏chantel ，
果然是來自火星的妳。
🤣🤣
用姜濤同Gigi比，唔係掛…
Archie Rock Windy已經足夠
殺雞焉用牛刀
喺香港，唱得贏Gigi的有幾多個
@@MrHighcloud 好一句「殺雞焉用牛刀」👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
以決賽表現，archie更值冠軍，不過tvb唔想 gigi 輸，賽制有問題，亦有偏幫佢， 佢失誤值得原諒，其他參賽者失誤立即foul， 世事我真係睇唔透
我又唔覺,都只係最大公約數...
真既！乜tvb對gigi咁冇信心？比Archie (Yumi)入左去r2 覺得gigi會攞唔到冠軍？!睇到r2 gigi vs Chantel 真係完全冇心機睇 😤
蓮姐走音出局
但Gigi最尾個下走音都好明顯，但有17盞燈係有d夾硬黎
舒文做得出評審做既野，就係一首一首歌去評，唔係個歌手本身擁有既技術去評當下個首歌既表演，希望評審專業d
蓮姐走音出局,果首邊止走,重有破音,同好遊離,重有高音上唔倒...
首先，我純粹以比賽角度去睇，Gigi個下走音係好明顯，17分真係過高，仲有李志剛明顯就係有Bias，俾人感覺就算Gigi唱成點都好，佢都會俾綠燈。
但我想講Gigi唱Bad Romance係技術性贏Chantel
Wow... 玩 一刀切? 跳水有多少水花都一樣分》
@@lovertori7682 同意，不單止走音；還有未能控制感情，放左收唔返。係感動到人，但攪到自己情緒失控唱不下去？
奧運石偉雄難度最高，但結果失手就也是出局；並不代表他比其他選手差，只是比賽失手就是失手吧！
若只計首回合表現，我覺得 Gigi 只能排第四，Archie + Yumi or Chantel
第二回合，Gigi 優勝也是無可置疑，其實二個表現並不相距那麼遠；但 Gigi 明顯難度系數較高，所以完勝非常合理
聽吓鏡頭後的情況好有趣
唔知其他評審覺唔覺得好好笑，我成日乜嘢都覺得好好笑🤣🤣
一諗起朋友問可唔可以擺杯珍珠奶茶喺附近我就覺得好好笑
前晚睇TVs全城迎奧運，見到Chantel狀態好好，成個人好似發光一樣，好吸睛
😀❤️👍
Miss Wong遲啲會唔會講下Yumi
小朋友壓力好大😨
超級巨聲帶來了林欣彤 許廷鏗 胡鴻鈞 吳業坤 馮允謙 Gin Lee亦是憑此初為人識
希望聲夢會制造更多明日之星
對呀！👍☺️
似佢哋就死、無個大紅大紫
聲夢學員aska ,windy,阿rock陸續出單曲會唔會出片
☺️💖👍
如果只係睇比賽，chantel似係揀錯歌輸左，但睇埋兩次商場表演，佢係揀啱歌，一隻唔會要好高跳舞技巧，聽眾認識度又高，容易炒熱氣氛，方便大合唱，加埋把摺扇，商演一流，加上Chantel 愈唱愈好，所以chantel係贏係比賽之後。
可以想像他們的壓力大到一個点
完全同意❤️