[Knowing Bros] Aespa vs LE SSERAFIM vs IVE 🔥 4th Gen KPOP Girl Group Song Comparison🎵
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ค. 2024
- Song List🎵
aespa Winter
00:00 All about you
01:16 Secret Garden
aespa NINGNING
02:46 If Ain't Got You
04:28 Maria
LE SSERAFIM Chaewon
05:41 Love On Top
LE SSERAFIM Yunjin
07:21 Think of Me
IVE LIZ
08:18 Atlantis Princess
09:24 After LIKE Ballad ver.
Your 'Like' and ' Subscribe ' are always welcomed!
"Discover your taste in K-contents"
#knowingbros #aespa #winter #ningning #lesserafim #chaewon #yunjin #ive #liz #live
------------------------------------------------------
* What's the program in the video?
【Knowing bros】
tv.jtbc.co.kr/knowingbros
------------------------------------------------------ - บันเทิง
![[ENG] We DO have K-POP idol vocalists! Crazy high note match between NMIXX and KISS OF LIFE](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qDLgJt0tbb8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG] We DO have K-POP idol vocalists! Crazy high note match between NMIXX and KISS OF LIFE](/img/tr.png)
![[Knowing Bros] CUTE aespa Winter Compilation🥰](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AQuUW4ueDQo/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow, aespa really on top, winter and ningning breath control and technique are amazing.also why are they always effortless like it's nothing?😂
Vocal queens duh
Always practice and training. Practice makes perfect
I mean wintwr train for 4years and ningning train for 5 years
they ate CDs for lunch
They’re from SM, so.. yeah! 😍
Ningning the main vocal of all main vocals in 4th gen🔥🔥🔥🔥
3rd
Liz suaranya enyakk
Femenina porque masculina nadie supera a honjong de Ateez
AESPA- 100% Vocal (different Range from Highest to low), 100% Visual (No Doubt it's SM) and Dancing skills good.
There’s hope for 4th gen vocals! Aespa on another next level with all 4 having exceptional vocal talent.
Karina and Giselle are vocal talents? 🤣 Haewon and Lily are the best 4th gen vocal duo.
Winter and NingNing are probably next. They are great in a recording booth but when they have to entertain on stage it's a snoozefest. Charisma nonexistent. Dancing on beginner mode.
@@monochromedout NMIXX not even on top 5 in 4th Gen. JYFLOPS💩💩💩
@@monochromedout dude lily is good, but she becomes average when you hear Wendy of Red velvet.. she has wide vocal range but clearly lacks in dynamics in hitting her highest notes
@@monochromedoutKarina and Giselle can be main vocals of Lesserafim and Ive combine 😂😂😂
@@monochromedoutkarina has good vocals. What are u on about. Aespa>nmixx
Aespa 💙 💙 💙 ❤❤ ❤
Hahaha
Winter voice is like spring (calm) and Ningning voice is like water and siren
Winter and NingNing are just on an another level. I think Chaewon went off a little only because I think she saw the camera and smiled. And Damn Yunjin with the Opera Voice :O and Liz's sweet voice makes me want to hear a duet with Winter. So unfair that 'Nobody" was filmed separately. They all have their own vocals, tones and ranges. We shouldn't have to compare.
Chaewon was never off stop😭
@@bbl1188 I didn’t say she was! There was a tiny point where her voice changed and it was when she saw the camera.
aespa got it all no wonder they are SM . but liz vocal is not a joke …
Aespa members debuted later than two members from both IVE Lesserafim, but Aespa sounds more vocally advanced in their studies.
aespa vocals are really my fav from 4th gen. All 4 are so talented and sing amazing live
Ningning belting those high notes effortlessly.
Aespa 🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
Winter and Liz's voice is just simply beautiful ❤
Minjeong's voice is heavenly😇
NingNing already on another level among all 4th gen I guess~
But Liz's voice, listening to her singing always makes me happy and those sweet honey vocals feels like heaven 💕
ningning 3rd best vocalist in 4th gen! ❤🎉
@@thatoneperson731 thats your opinion... Ning is the best among them🔥🔥🔥🔥😎
@@danissegomez7953 in terms of technique, lily and haewon are better. (nayul is the best “in 4th gen” but i dont really consider her 4th gen)
Liz could def be an SM artist, but nothing is beating Winter and Ning
Fun fact she was an sm trainee.😊
@@yanayanaya990 It really shows
winter's vocal color is crazy 💜💜
I'm so obsessed with Ning's low notes, vobrato, and runs.
Winter is really the best! We are so lucky to have all 4 strong vocals in aespa!!
IVE’s vocalists are so underrated they don’t get the appreciation they deserve especially Liz
aespa on the next level
Ningning's lower register is beautiful
Aespa for sure
Aespa 💙🌙⭐️🦋
I feel like I was listening to an angel. Winter sings with her heart makes me cry 😭
I'm surprised that Winter opted for falsetto than her mix voice. That Taeyeon song is kind of her range tbh
Taeyeon herself sang the song in a very light and soft way herself, at least the part she covered
@@rosepark2669 just because people belt a song doesn't mean it ain't soft. And taeyeon belt half the song tho.
aespa 1
Ningning on top. Bada said about her vocal. Nothing to compare
Ningning and Winter Aespa our best 4th Gen vocalists. Pakistan and China will always support you 🤩😍🥰🧡💚💙💜❤💖
At the end of the day, people judge based on the tones they prefer but don't take the techniques into account. I agree that Aespa is the best on certain points, but that doesn't mean the others are any less good. I would say that NingNing is indeed the best, she has a great technique, a powerful voice and a great tone, whereas Winter would concentrate more on highlighting emotions with a softer, less powerful voice. The good thing about Aespa is that they're all excellent singers, which makes the group very complete vocally. Yunjin is a mixture of NingNing and Winter, she sings with incredible emotion while having power and great technique, probably one of the best. Chaewon is the most stable of all when she's dancing, and her tone is higher than Yunjin's, so they blend very well in the group. Liz has a very good tone but less technique, she can sing high notes but lacks a bit of power and constancy. The good thing is that she has Yujin in her group who, even though she's not in the video, balances Liz out well with her powerful voice.
I'm certainly not saying that you can't prefer Liz's voice or others, some people will prefer weaker voices to a powerful tone, and that's the beauty of singers.
I'd also like to conclude by saying that I think all these groups are very well balanced, with different abilities and skills in each of them. So there's no need to fight with others or to disrespect these girls if you don't agree.... They're all good singers
Chaewon "most stable" while dancing? Girl, are you not aware of their coachella performance? I'm not hating on Chaewon, I really like her but that stage really disappointed me 😭😭😭
@@happypeach8791have to agree with you, she’s not the “most stable”. but also, le sserafim choreo are unnecessarily difficult. i don’t really understand why the company always give them such tiring moves when their vocal are not that stable
@@happypeach8791 chaewon was still the most stable while dancing at coachella and singing 100% live. i have yet to hear ive or aespa sing 100% live while dancing with no backtrack or prerecorded vocals. i think that’s the point this person was making.
@@cardcaptortwink nah aespa has tons of videos where they sang 100% live while performing. You just hv to do some research. I went to their concert & they killed it. I believe your explanation contradicts with the op's points. Op highlighted that chaewon was the most stable in her GROUP, & not comparing it with aespa/ive. U can read it again
up
Winter and Ningning ❤
I cant tell winter is sangmin's favourite idol.. he always closed his eyes when she sings
She should be everyone's...
@@DUNGSTAeveryone has their taste
Aespa 👏👏👏👏
Aespa. Ningning best and Winter good secondplace.
1. Aespa 2. Liz 3. Lesserafim
Liz’s voice has always been my favorite. It’s soothing, and emotional sounding. Only one that gives me the chills.
aespa outsang all
Aespa ❤❤
Aespa, Le Sserafim, Liz love all of them
Aespa queens of vocal🔥🔥🔥
Kim family's vocal as expected ❤😆 Liz Winter Chaewon 😘 They three are like Kim Taeyeon daughter 😎
Winter your voice is magical
SM's vocals never disappoints ❤ my awesome aespa girls ❤
Winter our very own MinJeoung is so talented and took the show to Next level. MinJee best, Pakistan will always support you and Aespa of coure :)💕💕😍😍❤❤
But first you guys support your own women? And live them alone.
Liz has that sweet honey angel voice and I’m in love💕
aespa
1:07 winter is angle 🙌✨😇❤️
Ningning winter and liz in love with their voices🌟🥹
aespa♥️🥰
aespa for sure
I am in love with Winter's voice
Liz's voice is so pretty . She did a cover of IU's "love wins all" its gorgeous
Winter on top
aespa ftw
Aespa and Liz ❤️
Ningning has a beautiful and strong voice
ningning winter🔥liz also🔥
If winter sang this on live instead on knowing bros . Some peopls would still claim its not live because her mouth didnt open much
Liz's vocal colour is so pretty omg !! 💞
Aespa is just something else🤍
Liz's voice is soooo eargasm
AEspa💚💚💚💚❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
aespa 💙💙💙💙
winter is taeyeon’s daughter fr
Liz and Yujin are too slept on
Most common talked about their voice tone and only few mention their vocal technique. Conclusion: not many people understand about vocal technique, so they cannot compare objectively.
Winter: always use breathy vocal. In Lee Mujin Service, she sang with her emotion. Ningning: Ballad and powerful voice. But she struggle sing RnB genre because of riffs and runs. Chaewon: clear voice but not powerful. She has good agility and riffs and runs. She is good in RnB genre when she cover Bambie from Bakhyeun in Lee Mujin Service. Yunjin: She can do classical technique and powerful voice. She usually make melody more simple. She prioritize the emotion rather of technique like Winter. But her technique better than Winter. Liz: need to work with her mix voice. She use head dominan mix. The voice tone is subjective, so you can like the weakest vocal technique because of their voice tone. Singing while dancing is different. Singer cannot belting high note when they jumping or do weird body pose. They also cannot maintain dynamic volume while dancing. So when dancing, the vical technique will limited and the requirement only sing with stable volume. More harder the choreo more harder to sing. Le sserafim have hardest choreo, and Chaewon has best stability voice when dancing.
@@anistardi ty for deep analysis 👏👏👏👌
💩
True. I mean Winter just recently got a lot of accusations for lip syncing just because she did high notes flawlessly that people couldn’t believe it was real because she wasn’t struggling to reach a note or showing struggle.
@@anistardi Your analysis is not based on technique as well. "Someone struggle with certain style" and simple "powerful" even "ballad voice" is not an analysis...
Ningning has the widest supported range of them all, her mix is clean and forward, but sometimes can get nasal and too shrill. One good thing is that when she ascends she lightens up her mix so that she can stay there easily without much straining or sounding painful. I don't hear her head voice enough so I can't comment on that.
[Edited] Ningning's agility is actually above average. True that she might sometimes struggle with long and complex riffs, but she's completely capable of doing shorter runs, esp. in her upper register (see Spicy recording). Her head voice is very solid, in fact sometimes she uses it to substitute high belt and the quality is as solid as a mixed voice. She switches registers with ease, one of the best transition I've heard of among newer generation idols. Her low register is the strongest among the ladies mentioned here.
Winter tends to use either a breathy tone or a pushed tone, her upper register is a falsetto. If she can balance out her mix and work on her upper, that will give her a great push.
Chaewon has a clean mix however the nasality limits the openness hence the potential power. Her low is weak to average and her upper register is a falsetto. She has definitely worked on her agility, at times her riffs can get sloppy and the flow can be a bit unnatural at times. Her stamina is very good indeed.
Liz's mix is head dominant, which is fine by itself, but a pity as it limits her potential full power and she tends to get nasal at closer vowels. She has demonstrated head voice before but she mostly sings with falsetto in her upper register.
Yunjin's head voice is stronger than most ones here. It can be more mask-y and more well connected to eliminate the breathiness in her head voice, but maybe it's her choice here. However her mix (not showcased in this video) is one of the weakest, and the throatiest, among the ones that are listed here.
Aespa ❤❤❤❤
People in this comment section showing love for all 3 groups are the best ❤❤❤ pure good vibes and absolutely no toxicity.
there still are lol. people in the comments complimenting le ssera are followed by hate comments
ニンニンは全音域がクリアできれいなうえ歌に表情がある！
チェウォン、ユンジンともに本場の曲を聴き込んでるって感じがすごいな！ふつうにソロ歌手としてやっていけるレベルだよね❤
Wintaaaa🥺
Lizzzzzz🩷
MINJEONG😍❤️
I need winter to full cover the second song
aespa vokal VS other girlgrup👆 U sure ? I mean 😌
Vokal* girlgrup*😂😂
Go to school asap
What is this abysmal English 💀
WINTER⭐
Winter is really Taeyeon daughter 🥹
Winterrrr 😭😭😭❤❤❤
LIZ HAS THE SWEETEST TONE IN KPOP FOR ME SHE CARRIES
Do you even know what carry means ?
@@rabielamrabet1533 IDK U TELL ME
Liz
I love winter voice😆
3 of my favorite groups in one video?? *Chef’s Kiss* 🥰
Vocal Queen of;
3rd Gen: Mamamoo
4th Gen: Aespa
5th Gen: KIOF/Babymonster
Nmixx 4th gen.
@@adrianjuaneza4305 nope aespa
@@itsalissa5800its nmixx ! Cry about it 🤣
As an aespa fan nmixx should be there …. In my opinion vocal groups are : SES SNSD FX Red Velvet Mamamoo Apink Sistar aespa KIOF nmixx
@@moazenmyracle I forgot about Nmixx 😅 but yeah, they also deserve that spot, and I think both of them are the vocal queens of 4th gen.
Chaewon strong vocals singing one of the hardest song from Beyonce, Yunjin singing opera that not everybody can do it. what an amazing team !
Coachella⚰️
@@cris-iy7rb TOP 3
@@Waender 🥳🐓🐓🐓🐓🐓
@@cris-iy7rb 💆🏻♀️💆🏻♀️💆🏻♀️💆🏻♀️💆🏻♀️
@@cris-iy7rbno one can dance hard and sing better than lesserafim
*aespa's* Ningning and Winter, *IVE's* Yujin, Liz and Leeso *can sing without* Celemony Melodyne, without RePitch, without FlexPitch and without Revoice.
*Other 4th and 5th Gen GG* that can sing are;
NMIXX, STAYC, PURPLE KISS, KISS OF LIFE, the new MONSTER of KPOP- *BaeMon* and outside KPOP is *XG* again, *can sing without* Celemony Melodyne, without RePitch, without FlexPitch and without Revoice.
I think I like Liz's voice the best.
THEY ALL CAN SING AND ARE ALL INCREDIBLE ARTISTS AND PROFESSIONALS. BUT MORE IMPORTANT, WHILE THE FANDOMS ARE FIGHTING AND PITTING WOMEN AGAINST EACHOTHER, LIKE THIS VIDEO AND THIS WHOLE SHOW'S CONCEPTS, THE GIRLS THEMSELVES ARE ALL FRIENDS AND SUPPORT AND ARE FAN ON EACH OTHER SO STOP BEING CHILDISH IN THE COMMENTS, YOU ARE JUST BORED AND HAVE NO LIFE.
1*Aespa 2*IVE 3*LeSera
Winters' voice is like that of an angel... too beautiful to be real and perfect 😍🥰
Kim chaewon❤❤❤❤❤❤
NingNing is MYs vocal queen❤
Winter will be the 4th gen OST Queen, just like mother Taeyeon.
aespa on the next level❤❤
Ofcourse without any doubt SM artists
Lesserafim
Chaewon ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I find no one better than aespa💜
Liz tone is crazy 😻
KIM JIWON❤ IVE LIZ ALWAYS SLAYED AS USUAL URI MAIN VOCAL 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤
LIZ ❤
NINGNING🦋
yeah, at least chaewon can sing 👍😂