how did you find it...some readers say it changed their lives...what did you like the most from this book...could share bit....thank you...I am kind of enticed few weeks now...
I’ve just finished it myself and gonna read it again, I think I missed a lot since I was reading it sporadically(it took me a month) whereas it should’ve taken me a week really,I wanna absorb it properly the next time. Many people have said that the book changed their lives/views,but I didn’t see anything connected to a life changing experience in the book,which I suspect I missed. A great book it is.
@@Rixoonify you may find a piece of you while you are reading because -idk if you love to question life in anyway you might think- this book really reveals it and it was amazingly written there are also some wise saying. All i could say for this book is if you don't understand the message between lines read it again :) if you dont understand again wait for like some years, wait for sth that u will have been through hardly and ready to got the message. All the classic books are like this. If you dont understand them the problem is you not them. Read all the classics and see yourself becoming a more wise man
@@Tlhakxza It wasn't life-changing for me either, but I understand its importance. I think nowadays psychological stories are too common, we see them in films and books and theater, even in music, but that was not the case back in those days. That said, I do think Raskolnikov's character is one of the best psychological portraits of guilt I've ever seen.
As a literature student i have read many novels of many authors and times some of my favorites include 'Mill on the Floss', 'Hard Times' and of course 'Crime and Punishment''. i read crime and punishment some 3 or 4 years back and whenever i hear the name of the novel i get chills its like the whole life of Raskolnikov come and goes in a flash and i say to myself what a novel that was. The novel shows the power of true love can do anything....imagine if there was no character called sonia then what would would have happened to the Rodion Raskolnikov......We all need someone who will be sonia to us....
I am starting to read crime and punishment, but my reading pace is too slow. Not because I am a slow reader but because every sentence is full of richness.
I’ve just finished reading this book, I am proud of myself and have great respect for FYODOR DOSTOEVSKY,I’m not a novel kinda guy but this book was worth all my time and attention,I loved the bumpy,emotional ride I was taken on...now I’m gonna read more of DOSTOEVSKY’s Books, he’s indeed a brilliant writer.✌🏿🇿🇦😉
before the confession of his crimes Raskolnikov suffered but this suffering didn't stop in Cyberia for a while . but one day when Sonya visited him , he hugged her and started crying om her feet . he fainally got to the salvation this is important theme in the book. some people think that as soon as you will get Christian you will feel good . but it's not always so . you get tested by the faith you chose , and once you can prove that you really are true Christian , than and only than you will feel well to yourself
Alright, I´ve found Fyodor thru Bungo Stray Dogs and yes, I know that this is an anime but since the characters are based on their authors most famous book, I had to look into fyodor since his ability isnt explained and is only known to kill anyone he comes in contact with.
lmao samee. Fyodor's ability was so mysterious that i couldn't get a hold of it. especially after watching bungo stray dogs: dead apple movie i decided to read this book to understand his ability better.
I just wanted to say it was never confirmed that svidrigalov actually commited any crimes. He was accused of murdered and other things were hinted at, but in the translation I read it was only rumors, no real proof of any crime committed by him.
If i remember correctly , he kills her with a meat cleaver, ''borrowed'' by his apartment's shared kitchen ? He hid the cleaver under his coat, hanging by a make-shift nook.
He does with an axe, as our russian friends clarified, May i add that it was taken from de doorman's bedroom, and that he did it with the back of the axe, not with the sharp end. I think its a small analogy that shows a little bit raskolnikov is not a blood thirsty killer. Sorry for my english, im from Argentina.
Why is he talking so fast... Or is it so that it would fit the whole story in 13 min.? Nothing insightful but it simplified the plot which idk if it is good or bad. this would be great for someone who didn't read it but has exams.
I mean… a surface level antagonist for Raskolnikov for much of the book is Porfiry, but the “antagonist” is mainly an internal conflict within Raskolnikov
@@jeantarr1314 It is only a fair interpretation of Dostoyevsky to put an emphasis on this kind of degradation of morality. And the gulags is another proof of this lack of morals. By the way there is a reason ruzzians now are called ''orcs''. In LOTR lore orcs were once were elfs, but they were changed by evil and become evil themselves.
"Beating her, and treating her like a slave" "Devoid of any true Christian ideals" Don't be so harsh on poor Alyona Ivanovna. She may not be have practiced slavery EXACTLY as it was prescribed in the bible, but she got closer than most people do these days.
I finished reading it last night and this is an excellent cherry on the top -- thank you Course Hero!
how did you find it...some readers say it changed their lives...what did you like the most from this book...could share bit....thank you...I am kind of enticed few weeks now...
@@Rixoonify they are watching this for a grade. You’re asking the wrong person.
I’ve just finished it myself and gonna read it again, I think I missed a lot since I was reading it sporadically(it took me a month) whereas it should’ve taken me a week really,I wanna absorb it properly the next time.
Many people have said that the book changed their lives/views,but I didn’t see anything connected to a life changing experience in the book,which I suspect I missed.
A great book it is.
@@Rixoonify you may find a piece of you while you are reading because -idk if you love to question life in anyway you might think- this book really reveals it and it was amazingly written there are also some wise saying. All i could say for this book is if you don't understand the message between lines read it again :) if you dont understand again wait for like some years, wait for sth that u will have been through hardly and ready to got the message. All the classic books are like this. If you dont understand them the problem is you not them. Read all the classics and see yourself becoming a more wise man
@@Tlhakxza It wasn't life-changing for me either, but I understand its importance. I think nowadays psychological stories are too common, we see them in films and books and theater, even in music, but that was not the case back in those days. That said, I do think Raskolnikov's character is one of the best psychological portraits of guilt I've ever seen.
As a literature student i have read many novels of many authors and times some of my favorites include 'Mill on the Floss', 'Hard Times' and of course 'Crime and Punishment''. i read crime and punishment some 3 or 4 years back and whenever i hear the name of the novel i get chills its like the whole life of Raskolnikov come and goes in a flash and i say to myself what a novel that was. The novel shows the power of true love can do anything....imagine if there was no character called sonia then what would would have happened to the Rodion Raskolnikov......We all need someone who will be sonia to us....
I am starting to read crime and punishment, but my reading pace is too slow. Not because I am a slow reader but because every sentence is full of richness.
@@boysonthm1462 idk man sounds kinda gay to me
You should read The Magic Mountain by Thomas Mann. It is insanely good.
@@pereiraplaza222 Sure
@@abrahamanthony976 it's a harder read than Crime and Punishment. But it's so deep and mind blowing and captivating.
I’ve just finished reading this book, I am proud of myself and have great respect for FYODOR DOSTOEVSKY,I’m not a novel kinda guy but this book was worth all my time and attention,I loved the bumpy,emotional ride I was taken on...now I’m gonna read more of DOSTOEVSKY’s Books, he’s indeed a brilliant writer.✌🏿🇿🇦😉
I really recommend Anna Karenina (Leo Tolstoy) if you want to read another good Russian novel.
I wish I could keep their names straight
I used flashcards for this. Writing their first name, surname and nickname. It's difficult because author uses all 3 within a couple of ages.
Does this for 3-4 characters within a page or two.
that was honestly the hardest part about digesting this book
Something from course hero without a pay wall... 👏🏻
This saved me
greg
fyoder
Same
SAME LMAO
Have an exam, I procrastinated, I have been saved.
Enjoyed the enthusiastic and energetic delivery as well as the novel's details.
The most interesting and perfect lecture on this novel , I have ever heard. Keep making this kind of stuff.
Love the attitude the speaker gives, very engaging :)
before the confession of his crimes Raskolnikov suffered but this suffering didn't stop in Cyberia for a while . but one day when Sonya visited him , he hugged her and started crying om her feet . he fainally got to the salvation
this is important theme in the book. some people think that as soon as you will get Christian you will feel good . but it's not always so . you get tested by the faith you chose , and once you can prove that you really are true Christian , than and only than you will feel well to yourself
Excellent summary. I had a difficult time reading and comprehending this book, but absolutely admire its themes and moral qualities.
I'm gonna read this. I hear it's good. The last book I read was good too. The guy ended up liking the green eggs and ham.
What is the point of this comment
@@neuronneuron3645 Is funny.
But did he like it here or there?
Alright, I´ve found Fyodor thru Bungo Stray Dogs and yes, I know that this is an anime but since the characters are based on their authors most famous book, I had to look into fyodor since his ability isnt explained and is only known to kill anyone he comes in contact with.
Also came here because of Bungo! It's like if Jojo was books.
@@adagamefreak oooo Hello fellow bungo watcher!!
lmao samee. Fyodor's ability was so mysterious that i couldn't get a hold of it. especially after watching bungo stray dogs: dead apple movie i decided to read this book to understand his ability better.
Yes! ❤
This rescued me.
Just finished the book. This helped a lot
I know the book was hard to keep up with and I was like "this smokgddjncd guy sounds REAL rapey" but I wasn't sure
I approve of this.
Dude you’re a bit extra throughout the book… check the vibe sometimes
Deserves more views.
I just finished this epic novel it was amazing reading. I just love Sonya n have empathy n compassion for her.
Saved my grade
Saving my life rn
I love the passion of the speaker. By the way, what are the songs you use in these videos? They are cool
To everyone seeking a new beginning; redemption is key.
You make no mention at all of Dreams and Taverns and Rodion "Rodya" Romanovitch Raskolnikov's idea of the Extraordinary man...?
He did, it’s about Napoleon.
Thank you for this
Representation comment for RAZUMIKHIN, for being an easily likeable character.
I just wanted to say it was never confirmed that svidrigalov actually commited any crimes. He was accused of murdered and other things were hinted at, but in the translation I read it was only rumors, no real proof of any crime committed by him.
Just finished the book last night -28/1/23
Awesome sir 🙏. Love and respect from India🇮🇳
oh my god thank you so much
THANK YOU YOU LIFESAVER
Thank you for saving my life
great job.
This dude is a hero
9:26 it’s important to note that raskolnikov basically scared and forced her to read it out to hum
> Doonya
This book is a lot more fun when you pronounce the character names like they're from shows on the Treehouse channel
thanks
Which translation is the best to read?
thank you so much sir..it was very much helpful..
That's amazing
Great video
My favourite book!
Why are you yelling?
3:43 The characters
Ty
Napoleon
i have a book report due on this is like 5 hours you came in clutch
Have to read this for my book club and I actually hated reading this
Thanks sooo much 😊❤
If i remember correctly , he kills her with a meat cleaver, ''borrowed'' by his apartment's shared kitchen ?
He hid the cleaver under his coat, hanging by a make-shift nook.
Нет, это именно был топор, который он взял где-то, а после убийства положил обратно.
Он не взял его с кухни потому что там была Настасья
@@sssrklass Thank you :)
He does with an axe, as our russian friends clarified, May i add that it was taken from de doorman's bedroom, and that he did it with the back of the axe, not with the sharp end. I think its a small analogy that shows a little bit raskolnikov is not a blood thirsty killer. Sorry for my english, im from Argentina.
I cried 3 times reading this
ive imagined the scene in literlly opposite side and its bothering me
What is marmaledo confession?
thank you
Why is he talking so fast... Or is it so that it would fit the whole story in 13 min.? Nothing insightful but it simplified the plot which idk if it is good or bad. this would be great for someone who didn't read it but has exams.
who’s the antagonist in this book
I mean… a surface level antagonist for Raskolnikov for much of the book is Porfiry, but the “antagonist” is mainly an internal conflict within Raskolnikov
Bsd fandom where you at??
Lol I watched the entire playlist instead of reading when I was supposed to
I think this video was too shallow i was expecting more... not bad but definitely not enough
This is gonna save me. See you after my exam 😂
Why'd you talk so fast dawg?
I cheated my way through school because of videos like this. Nobody is truly educated
Knowing how to use the resources available to you is the read education.
Napolean?! Its Napoleon!
Sonya is redeemed my her suffering.
Dostoevsky justifies the terrible murders of the main character. It is a commentary on russian ''morality''.
your "commentary" smells like you know what
@@jeantarr1314 truth is not always pleasant
@@johnsun3854 well, it's just subjective truth
@@jeantarr1314
It is only a fair interpretation of Dostoyevsky to put an emphasis on this kind of degradation of morality. And the gulags is another proof of this lack of morals.
By the way there is a reason ruzzians now are called ''orcs''. In LOTR lore orcs were once were elfs, but they were changed by evil and become evil themselves.
Is that a Twin Cities accent?
Razumihin is ridiculous, bro is christ
"Beating her, and treating her like a slave"
"Devoid of any true Christian ideals"
Don't be so harsh on poor Alyona Ivanovna. She may not be have practiced slavery EXACTLY as it was prescribed in the bible, but she got closer than most people do these days.
Good video but Napoleon didn't commit any crimes.
What
Excellent commentary and analysis but you don't know how to spell "Napoleon(e)".
Lol this guy is so extra and for what xd
So extra.... what a ridiculous expression
Ikr i kinda like it
NapoleAn.... Seriously? 🤣
Ty