Unsustainable losses put pressure on Putin's invasion | Col. Philip Ingram
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- Putin's troop losses after the Kharkiv offensive have become unsustainable, Philip Ingram tells Frontline on #timesradio
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.c...
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.c...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.c...
Please stop playing a portion of the interview and then start the interview and repeat that portion. It makes me just fast forward. It’s not clever STOP doing it please.
Totally agree, very annoying.
Same. It's such a frustrating Times Radio feature.
@@mangosuklaa : They do it because it draws in viewers with short attention spans who get bored within the first 10 seconds of watching a 'normally' edited video. They must have viewer stats of people who stop watching within 10 seconds.
@@timonsolusagreed but put it out as a yt short
Yes, agree.
Putin to self: "Massive casualties didn't bother Stalin. They don't bother me either. "
Sausage you'll get yours 👍
Massive casualties didn't bother the Czar in 1917. Ooooops.
Putin to self: "Do I salt my pasta before, or after its boiling?"
Note 2 russia 🇷🇺 💩 tin is more like zar Nicolas nothing like starlin.
Full support for Ukraine. 🇬🇧💛💙💛💙🇺🇦
Europe as well
He is lying, US didn’t just give 3m shells. It has given 3 million since 2022.
BLA BLA BLA nonsese 😂
🇷🇺😘
@@Bryankips Keep coping Ivan. Your army is a joke.
@@Bryankips In 2024, Russia has taken about 0.13% of Ukraine's territory. Those are Russian GAINS in 2024.The cost has been the LIVES of 45,000 Russian soldiers. At this rate of "progress", Russia will conquer all of Ukraine in 377 YEARS and it will cost the LIVES of 34 MILLION Russian soldiers. Russia is PATHETIC.😂
Ukraine as multiple times smaller than Russia has been valiantly defending well against Russia. Stay strong Ukraine!
@@russellspeed1693defending against a military 10 times your strength who were expected to walk into Kiev within a week is a decent definition. Although I'm SURE you know better ay, ?
@@billdoor3140 The problem is that those expectations were created by not Russia. So creatng a goal russia for Russia then acting liek they failed it. Is just a fake argument.
So do you think Finland did bad against the USSR during the winter war?
@@attilamarics3374 haha so official Russian goals denazify - fantasy to begin with
Demilitarize - Ukrainian army is about 5 times what it was with far more equipment.
Now Russia just bleeds while turning into North Korea its people betrayed by Russian leader and bots like you.
@@attilamarics3374 well a lot of russia did believe that too....most of then did not believe that russia would attake
Russians need to KNOW they have lost 530k men.
They don't
Did you count them, just like Ingram did.
If you switch Russians with Ukrainians in that statement it will be more accurate.
@@domino20 ok Boris
@@domino20 ok Boris
Excellent ..... Philip Ingraham also Excellent commentary
"The relationship between Donald Trump and Vladamir Putin, there is so much SPECULATION around, um there is certainly something there between the two of them."
You people are ridiculous! I bet most people who subscribe to this channel are ignorant and don't know that the "Russian Collusion" claims were FAKE.
Also, I bet that most people here don't know that Hunter Biden's laptop WAS NOT a part of Russian Disinformation like the 51 former American intelligence officers attested to in a letter.
I mean, Col. Philip here doesn't seem to know. Otherwise why would he be spewing nonsense like there is some relationship with Trump and Putin. If Col. Philip and the viewers and people commenting here did know that all the Russia accusations against Trump were faked, fraudulent, and a bunch of lies, saying that there is "something" going on with Trump and Putin is asinine and has no bearing in reality. Let's not forget about YOUR Imam though:
In 2012, during a nuclear security summit in Seoul, President Barack Obama was overheard on a hot mic speaking to then-Russian President Dmitry Medvedev. Obama told Medvedev, "This is my last election. After my election, I have more flexibility." Medvedev responded, "I understand. I will transmit this information to Vladimir."
Who has "something" with Putin again??
Putin going all-in with Ukraine is like someone burning down their log cabin to keep warm.
Russia is already broken and Putin is making it much worse.
Putin is acting like a monster.
@@gretabrown8320 Well, he IS a monster.
Hes not acting ! He is a monster !@gretabrown8320
Putin was dealt a strong hand and managed to play himself into a weak position. Twenty years ago Russia was on a roll. It's interesting if you plot Russian and Norwegian GDP against oil prices, the plots look almost identical. But Norway managed to parlay that into the second highest Human Development Index in the world, just slighly behind Switzerland. Russia ranks at #56, well below, say, Greece at #33.
Russia squandered the money coming in enriching people with political connections to Putin. It could have used its economic power to transform its cultural connections to places like Ukraine into soft power, instead it chose to meddle in their politics, to bully and intimidate it's neighbors so even the most stubborn neutral of them decided they'd be better off in NATO.
Really the only thing that approaches Russia for stubbornly bad decision making in modern history is Japan heading into WW2.
That´s not true - Russians have totally NEW equipment. The golf carts are brandnew from Alibaba, also the motorbikes and bikes.
😂A lean and mean military. War on the cheap is a losing proposition.
@@kralikkral5560 bro. It is Russia that teaches the world how war fought, very soon you will imitate every single thing Russia did in this war.
@@kirikoo9981 which planet are you on?
@@kirikoo9981 And that "bro" thing, why do you pretend that you are American?
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
God bless Ukraine 🇺🇦 🇺🇦🇺🇦❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
Да не bless он никакую Ukraine. Бог всегда на стороне правых, а это и есть Россия.
as part of Russia!
@@alexanderlazarev3570 russia is going to loose it's pointless war, you know how I know this? it's because the worst people in this world support them...
@@martinkim5493 No, as an independent, sovereign, democratic state, as it was before the invasion .
@@martinkim5493 The USSR is dead, botski.
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
as part of Russia!
Slava Propaganda!
@@martinkim5493 In 2024, Russia has captured about 0.13% of Ukraine's territory. Those are Russian GAINS in 2024.The cost has been the LIVES of 45,000 Russian soldiers. At this rate of "progress", Russia will conquer all of Ukraine in 377 YEARS and it will cost the LIVES of 34 MILLION Russian soldiers. Russia is PATHETIC. Eventually, Russians will remove Putin by coup.
"I don't think Donald Trump has thought about that yet."
Best joke of the day.
Depends. If the CIA convinced Johnson that he had to swutch his stance with Jkraine so will the CIA and the Pentagon with a potential russian war in Europe if they back away from Ukraine
"The relationship between Donald Trump and Vladamir Putin, there is so much SPECULATION around, um there is certainly something there between the two of them."
You people are ridiculous! I bet most people who subscribe to this channel are ignorant and don't know that the "Russian Collusion" claims were FAKE.
Also, I bet that most people here don't know that Hunter Biden's laptop WAS NOT a part of Russian Disinformation like the 51 former American intelligence officers attested to in a letter.
I mean, Col. Philip here doesn't seem to know. Otherwise why would he be spewing nonsense like there is some relationship with Trump and Putin. If Col. Philip and the viewers and people commenting here did know that all the Russia accusations against Trump were faked, fraudulent, and a bunch of lies, saying that there is "something" going on with Trump and Putin is asinine and has no bearing in reality. Let's not forget about YOUR Imam though:
In 2012, during a nuclear security summit in Seoul, President Barack Obama was overheard on a hot mic speaking to then-Russian President Dmitry Medvedev. Obama told Medvedev, "This is my last election. After my election, I have more flexibility." Medvedev responded, "I understand. I will transmit this information to Vladimir."
Who has "something" with Putin again??
i don't think Trump ever has a thought in his tiny brain.
Trump, _how does this benefit me?_
It was and is clear that Trump's foreign affairs attention is way off. The man has repeatedly shown little to no appreciation for it and seriously put the US and the world at risk. Just look at his terrible meeting with Kim Jong Un. It only made the latter feel more comfortable to manifest himself even more on the negative level.
The US is not alone, they better keep a decent eye on other countries with a leader that realises it's essence.
Many thanks for the excellent analysis and insights from Phillip Ingram.We support Ukraine whilst also battling Russian influence at the highest levels in our own Western governments. This war has truly revealed the stench of corruption within our own corridors of power.
There is no relationship between Donald Trump and reality, full stop. 😅 He is the world's most successful con artist.
Trump 2024….. he’ll be living rent free in your head for life 😂
Meghan Trainor's words apply here as well.
maybe if europe listen to trump about nato spending you guys wouldn’t be in the situation your in.
@@dsds173 this is a very good point.
@@dsds173we're guilty of this in Canada was well.
I always love to hear the Colonel's assessment of what's happening in this war. Very interesting.
Tell me what's changed in Russia since czarist times. Just a brutalised society.😊
So true. A society at its peak in mid nineteenth century and still a savage, imperialistic kleptocracy, a nation completely out of step with the civilised world.
@@djanitatiana they are not like us. They dont expect democracy to help them in their day to day, they expect a tough leader (like Putin Stalin...) that keeps them in line under the neverending speech of "respect russia if not fear it". When they go anywere they expect that people pay them to be over the locals because "Im russian". They need to be taught a very well deserved lesson.
Medieval
@djanitatiana .....Russia was at its peak in the early 1960s.....but then the wheels fell off......at least the USSR had a politburo of old party hacks to keep the top man in check.....before that i5 was Stalin and now Putin - total dictatorships with all the danger that entails......
Actually, the mishmash of Chinese mercenaries say it's horrendous-- NOT worth it, hardly pays for the risks & traumas, no more bonuses, no benefits- & bare minimal chance of survival!--??!!... They look aghast b/c Russians do NOT Save their own wounded, & most all of their teams died rapidly!!...
I watch the water I. Ukraine everyday since day one . We never hear about those New batches or Abrams tanks or about 309 Bradley’s which are truly game changers and moral boosters . If I were fighting on the ground, I’d pick a Bradley over an Abrams any day of the week . What an amazing , successful piece of equipment.
They have been useless and ineffective that's why Ukraine has no air defense and over half million dead troops
Bradleys don't have much armour and get knocked out at a rapid rate. They are visible from a long way away being 10 feet or more tall.
How many game changers has Ukraine received now, if they really were effective Ukraine would be winning
@@mrjerzheel what you say doesnt make sense. You could also make the point that if they didnt receive any they would be losing instead of holding.
@@patsanters2741 The only Challenger I have seen that was verifiably near the front line was on fire.
Excellent analysis and insight from Col Ingram as always. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Let's see how many russian internet trolls show themselves in the comment section today and how hard they'll cope with all the russian losses!
Reality is not your strong suit
I am vlad.
I'm turning the West traditional and conservative, just like the majority, 75% rest of the globe.
Hope you're not a pink haired minority
@@Rtg5637 How is that not reality?
How do we know what the true losses are? The Ukrainians have probably lost just as many.
@MojoHaiku we found one 😂
Full support for Ukraine
Additional body bag supplies on their way?
@@TenylegMinekez-uc7cobot
respectfully, i wouldn't call 30 Abrams tank a 'huge' amount. The tactical methods in this war/modern warfare are really hampering the influences of main battle tanks
Even the Ukrainians apparently feel that Abrams are too delicate and high-maintenance for what is happening in Ukraine. They need the massive war machine and logistical support of the US forces behind them.
30 tanks v 10000 tanks 30 isn't really a game changer,probably haven't even turned up most places to make a change.
Everything helps. 30 is better then zero. 30 good tanks vs a few thousand (they don`t even HAVE 10 000 tanks derpy) old inferior soviet tanks, with all the other parts of tank warfare, (i.e. bradleys ect) is def a win for Ukraine. remember the Russians are not about Quality. They are all about quantity, Which never equals Real quality. 1 good man, can defeat 10 000 men, if he uses strategy in accordance with the true eternal laws of the living universe we all live in.
None of the foreign tanks have been anything but a PR stunt and a burden on Ukraine's military.
@@MrOptimusheath Bud, there arent that many differences between these tanks. Maybe the Abrams is better than a T-72, but they arent that much better. In a combat situation a T-72 crew will know the advantages they have and the disadvantages, and they will play according to that. So It wont really matter.
You think Trump might be communicating with Putin? 😂 Well his plane was parked next to a Russian plane at Dulles airport a few days ago. Could that be a clue?
No
July 16, 2018 Trump met Putin in Helsinki. A reporter asked him if he talked to Putin about intereference in the US election. Trump said he believed Putin and not US military intelligence. TRUMP IS A TRAITOR.
@@marymarlow3646
Putin wasn't on it and I thought Russian aircraft were banned from US airspace? And if not, why not?
Dont think any Russian aircraft was in US airspace, not even civil
@@pp2021 It was photographed.
Putin is very brave, with the lives of others.
Your projecting its usa using every last Ukrainian for its proxy war
Biden is very brave with Ukrainian soldiers….as the US was with the soldiers of Korea…Vietnam…Iraq…Afghanistan…Syria…sorry who have I missed.
He makes some huge sacrifices... with his soldiers
It's MR. V. V. Putin for you and he's massively brave PErIoD! 💪🇷🇺💪 He done it all - single-handedly piloted the tu-160 strategic bomber, beat russia's best in Ice hockey & judo, guided endangered birds to safety on a paraplane. Plz have a bit more respect for the great dear leader of the federation. 💤
@@Bac4-qu6qg7sk4vF pootin
Zelensky needs to stand strong on the complete removal of Russian troops from Ukrainian territory previous to 2014 and the establishment of NATO membership to maintain security from thereon.
3 million 155 mm shells from the USA in the latest package??? Where has he heard that??
@@KEB129 its on the web list of the latest official release. We opened a bunch of new manufacturing hubs in America. Lend lease doesn't shrink. It snowballs. It will continue to increase. Not just from America.
@@VajrahahaShunyata Oh boys! Good news!
Russia is unfamiliar with open source information, for obvious reasons.
They may have promised them but they haven't delivered them. They are trying to double production with a new plant to open in third quarter of 2025.
@@VajrahahaShunyata They said they will give money to Ukraine to buy shells, shells that dont actually exist. I dotn know from where you guy got this 3 million number. The last time you guys talked about millions of shells, a few months later when the talkingpoint went away, the truth came out, that only 40% of the shells were ready and even they needed to be refurbished.
Putin's going to have to start drafting more and more from the core of Russia, instead the ethnic minorities and the prisons.
@@russellspeed1693August 2022 they had a partial mobilisation. A draft is done in the form of a lottery. Partial mobilisation is just a way for the russian state to target minorities and other people they don't care about.
Putin is hiring mercenaries from china and several other countries.
@@russellspeed1693
So a million young Russian men fled the country and many more hid from authorities because the Russian government doesn't conscript any men to fight in the war in Ukraine or so you claim?
I doubt that even Russian state media claims such nonsense.
@@russellspeed1693They needed 300k men or the from would collapse. Call it whatever the Kremlim wants but a partial-mobilization is a draft even from a specific age range with military experience (which many didnr had actual experience but only served the compulsory conscription at young age).
@@russellspeed1693Stop lying. There are Russian men in their 40s and 50s on the battlefield in Eastern Ukraine as we speak. There are also women. It's all over telegram and cannot be hidden
Agree 100% all Times Radio shows are the same. Utter poor judgment by the controllers/producers.
They've been saying this for years now.
Stop spreading propaganda.
What is he talking about ‘brigades of Abrams”? I haven’t seen anything about a new package of additional Abrams to Ukraine. Where’s he getting that?
Apparently, he means secret supplies, that is, much more weapons have been delivered to Ukraine than officially announced, and even this does not help. In a couple of months, 16 Abrams were destroyed, this is half of the "official" supplies, if you consider how many should be repaired, how many are kept in reserve, how many machines are allocated for training, there may be more than a hundred of them, what about the face of the west?
Interesting that only TR has this news.
Tell the TRUTH
Are you guys living in an alternative reality?
Come join us - it's called the real reality. Where Putin wears shoes with lifts in, and as a result of his 'small man' insecurity, has reduced his country to once again having to pay tribute to the Mongols in the East just to survive.
The military talking heads know the truth, but must toe-the-line that NATO and the west will prevail in this unnecessary conflict of attrition that is destroying Ukraine and it's young men
These are the facts, in 2024 Russia has taken about 0.13% of Ukraine's territory. Those are Russian GAINS in 2024.The cost has been the LIVES of 45,000 Russian soldiers. At this rate of "progress", Russia will conquer all of Ukraine in 377 YEARS and it will cost the LIVES of 34 MILLION Russian soldiers. Russia is PATHETIC.
That's a great question for the Internet Research Agency.
For a military commentator, he had a lot of opinions about politics.
Delusional Times Radio
It is pathetic. War mongering from 1940.
How are the Ukrainian losses?
Ukrainian losses are roughly equal to Russia's. But Ukrainians are defending against an INVADER ruled by a Dictator. They are more likely to continue the fight than are the Russian people. In 2024, Russia has taken about 0.13% of Ukraine's territory. Those are Russian GAINS in 2024.The cost has been the LIVES of 45,000 Russian soldiers. At this rate of "progress", Russia will conquer all of Ukraine in 377 YEARS and it will cost the LIVES of 34 MILLION Russian soldiers. At some point, the Russian people will be sick and tired of this meat-grinder and Russian generals will remove Putin from power.
Oh please stop acting like russians care about russian lives.
The Kremlin doesn't care about Russian lives. Russians do care.
It is remarkable to a Westerner how Russians care nothing whatsoever for the lives of others, even their brothers, husbands, fathers, cousins, friends. Are these the ":tradition al values" we hear Russian propaganda proclaiming so much?
The Russians rolled out the T-62 and even T-54 tanks more than two years ago. There is no justification for using such obsolete equipment, except that you don't have better. The Russians started using S-300 and S-400 AA for ground attack two years ago. Two years ago, the Russians used ship-to-ship missiles to hit buildings in Krematorsk. Two years ago, the Russians started using ICBMs, designed to fly 8000 miles, to hit ground targets in Ukraine a few hundred kilos away. The Russians dont even have one aircraft carrier. Their big visit to Cuba was one submarine and a couple of cruisers. Russia is bankrupt, impoverisehd, and run by a racist imperialist sociopath.
You forgot about the tug!
The flotillette sent to Cuba was a frigate, a sub (NOT a nuclear-armed one), a tanker (probably to ensure the ability to refuel the frigate) and a tug.
Ukraine has almost no air defence. Patriots haven't arrived. F16s have not arrived. F16's are not in the skies.
Give it a little while.
Still living in 2014 are you?
They destroyed a patriot system near odessa yesterday.
@TheCoolhead27 they didn't though did they. Zero reports of this even in Russian media.
@@TheCoolhead27 Do we have any proof for this claim, botski? Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
The day I see our nations pledge to help Ukraine WIN, and act on it, is the day I will feel that our leaders have come to terms with what it takes.
What is the point of these calculations if the war continues in full force? These numbers are taken from thin air for both sides. If the war is unsustainable why it is not over???
Both sides have at least a general if not very accurate idea of each others loses they aren't staring into an abyss with zero data points.
Because Russia is still in Ukraine
'Unsustainable' means that, eventually, some state or event will no longer be able to continue. Not that it must stop now. The calculations are done in an attempt to estimate when that end point of sustainability might actually be.
In 2024, Russia has taken about 0.13% of Ukraine's territory. Those are Russian GAINS in 2024.The cost has been the LIVES of 45,000 Russian soldiers. At this rate of "progress", Russia will conquer all of Ukraine in 377 YEARS and it will cost the LIVES of 34 MILLION Russian soldiers.
There’s nothing extreme or wrong about supporting Palestine!
You support the Oct 7th actions?
@@philipmain5701 they won't condemn Oct 7 crimes committed by Palestinians, but they will say the IDF is morally equivalent and then they condemn the IDF. Such people are evil.
So why Ukraine is not winning
Certainly not losing a this point in time ... . ;)
Why didn't Russia win in just three days, as Russia 1 tv promised?
Because so far Ukraine has been drip fed second hand weapons along with nonsensical restrictions about their use to strike military targets within ruzzian borders.
Russia has lost, that's why Putin wants a peace deal, hes so desperate that he sent potato head Lukashenko to meet Zelensky. The war is unsustainable, he's sacrificing troops for insignificant gains thinking he can hold all of this with a peace deal, what a fool.
Putin has succeeded in uniting NATO, bringing Sweden and Finland into NATO, increasing NATO's BUDGET, isolating Russia and exposing the pathetic weakness of the Russian armed forces. Consider the progress of the Russian army in 2024. During this time, they have captured .13% of Ukraine's territory and it's still being contested. Russia has lost 45,000 (KIA) soldiers in 2024. At this rate of "progress" it will take Russia 384 YEARS to conquer ALL of Ukraine and it will cost an additional 34 MILLION Russian soldiers their LIVES. All things considered, RUSSIA is not WINNING. How long will it be before Putin loses power? The Russian population is 1/2 of the USA population and during the past 2.5 years Russia has lost MORE soldiers in Ukraine, than the USA lost in ALL of its Wars in the last 79 years. That includes, Korea, Vietnam, Lebanon, Grenada, Iraq 1991, Iraq 2003 to present, Afghanistan 2001 to 2021. Face the facts, the Ukraine invasion is a DISASTER FOR RUSSIA. Ukraine will ultimately win and Putin will lose power. Ukraine is Putin's BLUNDER.
starmer will do nothing good for the UK, we are dying as a country and already starmer has stated he will hasten our demise, the big problems we have is due to overpopulation and starmer has already squashed one solution without giving alternatives, he has said every one coming here will be given a visa and housing sooner, they are bleeding us dry our services are overwhelmed and we have zero money to enlarge them, this is bad news for Ukraine as people in the uk will be suffering their own pain so Ukraine will sink into the background. for all those people who say we should take in whoever want to come here I ask you how many is your limit, 10 million 100 or 500 million give me a number as i think we surpassed managable numbers 20 years ago. Had to spend time down local hospital with relative recently over 12 hours waiting to be seen then 3 days waiting treatment, I saw over 70% of beds taken by immigrants
The USA has the same problem, we are going broke supporting the thanks democrats 👍
@@geoffgill5334 "...we are going broke supporting THEM thanks to the Democrats."
trumps advisors first have to figure out how to put the complex concepts of warfare and diplomacy into picture books...
Having deducted the cost of the nuclear deterrent, does the UK even meet the 2% spending target?
Laughable
In 2024, Russia has taken about 0.13% of Ukraine's territory. Those are Russian GAINS in 2024.The cost has been the LIVES of 45,000 Russian soldiers. At this rate of "progress", Russia will conquer all of Ukraine in 377 YEARS and it will cost the LIVES of 34 MILLION Russian soldiers. Russia is PATHETIC.
Being against genocide isn’t an extreme position. Get serious.
Slava Ukraini!🇺🇦💪❤️🇨🇦
The same is true for Ukraine. They have a personnel shortage already, they just don't admit it publicly. This is a very serious situation as both countries suffer from long term birth decline rates and Putin knows it real well.
At least they still demobilize men, and they don't send cripples on the frontline like russians do.
The difference is, Ukrainians are DEFENDING their country from RUSSIAN INVADERS.
Russians are dying to enlarge an ALREADY ENORMOUS Russian state. WHY? Russians will soon lose their appetite for this UNNECESSARY WAR.
Putin is losing this war, he has only succeeded in uniting NATO, bringing Sweden and Finland into NATO, increasing NATO's BUDGET, isolating Russia and exposing the pathetic weakness of the Russian armed forces. This has been a disaster for Putin.
Col. Ingram references the "infamous F-16." What's wrong with it? Is the F-16 crash-prone, a widow-maker killing its pilots? Is it vastly inferior to other allied and Russian fighters? What's wrong with the F-16?
There's plenty wrong with the F-16... if you're Putin.
Infamous for the enemy.
Nothing wrong with the f16 … but the press oversold their delivery dates. They keep being hyped in the media but they never considered training and support requirements.
Tack!
Over 500,000 Ukraine soldiers killed in this conflict , very sad
Wrong, fifty million Ukrainians have been killed last month
Source: trust me, bro
Over 556,850 /+ 662500 = 1,212,390 updated Russian soldiers KIA in this conflict, plus 662,500 wounded very sad no not for us, the update is to let 1.325000 wounded they add in may 2024 50 % died of injuries due to cluster munitions & other fact bleeding out no training in saving life on battlefield of Russian @W@??
Thanks!
Everyone keeps saying unsustainable losses but history tells us this simply isn’t true with a place as vast as Russia.
That's a hyperbole. History means nothing. Losing more per month than is being recruited isn't sustainable. It's basic mathematics.
What history are you talking about? WW1? Perhaps? Or try Russo-Japanese War, which led to Russan revolution and the end of the Tsar? Or the Soviet-Afghan War which led, in part, to the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991? There are others. So what history are you talking about?
With only roughly 90 million ethnic Russians attrition most definitely has a part to play in this conflict whether it takes 3 years or 6 .. Putin is not as safe as it seems.
@@KiwisDownUnderhead nail hit 👍
Russia is not the Soviet Union, it’s been in terminal demographic collapse since the 80’s even by (undoubtedly heavily massaged) Russian statistics which made this war inevitable and this has just accelerated as a result of the war. This is Russia’s existential crisis, Putin is rolling the dice but the gamble is not paying off thanks to the endemic corruption baked in to his oligarchy.
For those who like to use "Teaser Trailers" at the beginning of their videos,, Apparently you think that this somehow further entices veiwers to watch it,, When truth be told,, It does not,, In fact the veiwer sees it more as a "Spoiler Trailer" that only serves to ruin that part of the video,, Just the act of the veiwer clicking on the video already shows that they are interested in watching it WITHOUT having a part of the video ruined for them before they even get the chance to watch it in full..I personally find your videos very informative & enjoyable & they would be even more so WITHOUT your "Teaser Trailers" or as your veiwers refer to them "Spoiler Trailers"..Thank you for your time.
"Happy"
Russia is losing on one battlefield, but has plenty of little helpers in European and American politics.
Russia only needs to hold the line until Trump gets in or Le-Pen takes control of France's nuclear deterrent.
Le Pen won't rock the boat and will stay in line, it would be political suicide for her to support Putin. If Trump lies himself into the Whitehouse and helps Putin the EU support will carry on. By January 2025 Russia may be totally exhausted anyway.😊
Ihr habt überhaupt keine Ahnung werdet ihr nur verarscht. Die Ukrainische Armee ist zerstört und verliert täglich 2000 Plus X an Soldaten ihre Reserve reicht für einen Monat. Bandera Nazis kaputt. England Bankrott. Gruss aus Germany
just more silly nonsense
There is no telling what Trump will do. Trump's statement that Putin invaded because Biden is weak doesn't imply that Trump is likely to back down.
If Russia was losing Ukraine would be advancing all across the front line but they arent
Never underestimate those fighting for freedom!
Man what you talking about, full internet showing Ukraine is loosing territories as you speak......
Barely, and not in the North.
"RU loses are unsustainable". OK, for how long can they go?
That was also the question in 1917
I saw a video earlier of a Russian soldier finding pieces of WOOD in his body "armour".
at least Putin made a fortune on that defense contract!
Go Ukraine! We love you.
They already burned male prisoners, professional mercenaries, elite units, most professional soldiers.
At the moment they burn female prisoners, amateur mercenaries from Africa, Cuba, Nepal, SriLanka, amateur soldiers from Eastern Ukraine, Asians of former Soviet countries etc.
The air is really getting thinner and thinner for Putin - on the ground less and less able staff, and many specialists (pilots, air defence staff, electronic warfare staff) were killed, which only can be replaced after years.
He can of course send "anybody" to the frontline - BUT remember 2.WW: Nazis did send millions of soldiers to the frontlines in 44/45, called "Volkssturm". Older, teens, women, whatever ... with almost no effect. And in 2024 such types of soldiers have even less effectivity than 1944, as the military technic is now more complicated than in 1944.
If he sends 500.000 new "soldiers" for every single one there are waiting 2-3 drones to explode directly in their undertroucers.
And in Russian society most people are not willing to give their life for Putin. Just look at Dagestan, they already started rebellion and attack police stations, killing many policemen. And most killed Russian soldiers in Ukraine were from Dagestan.
Unsustainable! Over what period of time?
I've watched countless videos that say Russia is on its last legs ....yet they keep grinding on and taking more land. 🤔🙄🤨
Yes, you can stagger on for quite a while being very ill. Russia is very ill.
@@reluctantheist5224 Ukraine doesn't seem particularly healthy, either. 🤔🙄
@@shannonhenson609 Yeah, there's a war on. A neighbouring dictator is trying to destroy them Though at current rates of advance it'll take about 12 years to capture the Donbass region and around 4 to 5 million men.
Simply not true that Ruzzia is taking more land. Your media are lying to you.
These so called experts have been saying this for the best part ov two years
Poor UK is falling.😅😅😅😅😅
British defence spending is clearly far too low. 75,000 soldiers with poor recruitment records are nothing more than a token effort. We should be at least doubling the army number along with appropriate equipment. That’s not being considered by the folks who run the country. Hence Labour and previously Conservatives have effectively done nothing.
We've been talking about this for 2.5yrs. WHEN???
Putin is playing the long game. It is a smart move becase you can see the cowards in the democracies starting to whine and cry.
When Russia eventually realises they can't win, and how long they wish to remain in a battle of attrition before eventually deciding to withdraw and get out of the mess they've created. Happened with the USA in Vietnam, also Russia (or USSR) in Afghanistan.
@@NoxiousRobyup
It won't happen
@@NoxiousRobthis isn't like Afghanistan at all
I fail to see why the USA should spend on European defense if the Europeans refuse to spend on European defense.
David Lammy did have a program on lbc. He didn’t come across as being particularly bright.
Most politicians aren’t, but they are very good at telling people what (they think) people want to hear.
From Sweden here..have a feeling this new gov gonna be a mess,there are lot of far left people there and Starmer gonna have a headache with these people..just hope he can controll this group..but might be wrong,will see
He'll control them easily just like Blair did with the same majority
Labour is not far left
Depressing that Starmer has put Islamists in positions of power...
So Zarhawi and Javed aren't Muslims then.....
SmackheadGaming it's depressing that you have the ability to type but not the intellectual capacity to count to 10.
@@graemelake657 Aren't they? Since when?
@@terrancedactielle5460 You know it's usually the dimwits that resort to personal attacks straight away, yeah?
depressing that you’re still desperately unable to parse the current situation 😂
❤Ukrainian ❤
well done USA and Joe Biden for supporting ukraine
Of course they are it's the septics proxy war, you lot and nato started this, try reading and learning might help you in the long run
Well done Joe, you answered all the questions!!!
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Whilst I applaud the US aid package, I have to ask why it has taken this long to reach this point. Ukraine needed the ammo, the APV, the tanks and the f-16s two years ago. So many lives have been lost due to indecision of western politicians.
labour govt will be short lived so it does not matter that much.
5 years is a long time
Is our crystal ball working today? Amazing.
The scale of Russian losses will grow. Don’t rely on Russian stats: reported male population is overstated by 5-10%. Labour has trouble with immigration policy.
Please stop the repeat at the start. I can't be the o ly one who finds it annoying
Why ask a military guy about politicians?
Exactly!
"The relationship between Donald Trump and Vladamir Putin, there is so much SPECULATION around, um there is certainly something there between the two of them."
You people are ridiculous! I bet most people who subscribe to this channel are ignorant and don't know that the "Russian Collusion" claims were FAKE.
Also, I bet that most people here don't know that Hunter Biden's laptop WAS NOT a part of Russian Disinformation like the 51 former American intelligence officers attested to in a letter.
I mean, Col. Philip here doesn't seem to know. Otherwise why would he be spewing nonsense like there is some relationship with Trump and Putin. If Col. Philip and the viewers and people commenting here did know that all the Russia accusations against Trump were faked, fraudulent, and a bunch of lies, saying that there is "something" going on with Trump and Putin is asinine and has no bearing in reality. Let's not forget about YOUR Imam though:
In 2012, during a nuclear security summit in Seoul, President Barack Obama was overheard on a hot mic speaking to then-Russian President Dmitry Medvedev. Obama told Medvedev, "This is my last election. After my election, I have more flexibility." Medvedev responded, "I understand. I will transmit this information to Vladimir."
Who has "something" with Putin again??
Because Times Radio is a Murdock mouthpiece, so of course they will have someone who will attack the new government. But no it's nothing to do with Col. Philip Ingram as he is retired
Politicians determine DEFENSE policy.
Oh quiet you liars...the GPS review contradicts all your propaganda
David Lammy as foreign secretary is a serious accident waiting to happen, Starmer has had an easy ride up to now in opposition with very little real scrutiny, we will see the real face of his Labour party in the next couple of years i fear .
Careful you will be arrestwd soon for questioning the new govt
At least it wasn’t Abbott. If it wasn’t so terrifying, you’d love to see her in charge of something important just for the lols.
@@georgedavidson957 careful the times wiñl delete your comment. They like doing that
Little scrutiny? You must be kidding. The right wing press in the UK are after anything that makes Labour look bad. The fact they couldn't find anything speaks volumes. Just look at the way Starmer and his team ran the election campaign and compare it with the utter clown show from the Tories! In fact if you compare the qualifications for the jobs the cabinet have from the previous Tory cabinet its clear that the Labour front bench are head and shoulders better qualified for the job than the Tories were.
He reminds me of Diane Abbott!
The difference between the wars entered into by US and Russia is the PURPOSE. US made war with some countries to stop them from being aggressive, brutal, adventurous, despotic, repressive, autocratic, terroristic, crime lord, etc. Whereas, Russia initiated wars to gain land, excert control and undue influence among the countries she invaded.
👍🇺🇦🇮🇪🇺🇦
🇷🇺Russian flying shovel is deadly 😅😅😅😅
Which side is running away from Vovchansk? Ha, ha, ha, ha
Global situations require mature statesmen and women, unfortunately David Lammy and Slippery Starmer don’t come close to the criteria.
Ahem the tories?😂
Erm what the sigma
sources: trust me bro. no seriously this time we're telling the truth! lol
Bro, nobody is disputing these facts, in 2024, Russia has taken about 0.13% of Ukraine's territory. Those are Russian GAINS in 2024.The cost has been the LIVES of 45,000 Russian soldiers. At this rate of "progress", Russia will conquer all of Ukraine in 377 YEARS and it will cost the LIVES of 34 MILLION Russian soldiers. Russia is PATHETIC.
Been hearing this since day 1
Day 1 was 864 days ago... !!! How is that '4-5' day war going comrade?
@@F-DJT-PABIt's always going fine no comrade. You know the formula, according to the Putin's plans.
Understand your frustration it’s mine frustration as well
I think the Times Radio commentators won't give Keir Starmer a fair view. Its presumably Rupert Murdoch backed.
The Sun backed Labour this time
He is killing children! 😱😢😢😢
Oh dear. Crying into your Horlicks about a Labour government.
Where are these pictures of Russian equipment failures? There seems to be a media blackout form ukraine
God help us all if D. Trump returns to the White House in 2025, most likely he'll try to give aid to Putin.
Putin does not need any aid from Trump.
God help us all if we just keep escalating this mess to nuclear war that destroys everything.
Actually he’ll make a deal with Putin and the war will stop … is Peace bad???
Thats some hysterical fanfic right there.
How do you know?@michaelmullins3396
All Propaganda.
I also watch other videos of CIA analysts and US Army intelligence officers. They tell very different stories.
I was a Ukraine supporter but I have since been schooled.
Please check out other sources before you believe what he claims.
uk troops had to buy there own kit, for iraq 2003, i had to buy my boots,
Did you go into battle on a cheap Chinese motorcycle?
Clickbait title. 10 minutes into the interview and we're still talking about British politics....
Good Time for Radio optimism but bad Time for Ukrainian reality. With this approach we are going to end with a very small Ukraine.
When regions in Russia start to breakaway Ukraine will take everything back, and China will grab regions in the far east, Canada will become the new largest country in the world
Russia 1 tv said that Russia would easily win in just three days. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha
The real question is how long will the US aid package last. Trump will be elected (95% probability) and US help will dry up or come to a complete halt for 4 years. Will Ukraine survive 4 years without US packages? European military help or military capabilities are a joke.
Trump has a golf cart...he should get involved helping out his buddy Putin...heel spurs no problem cuz he'll be fighting while riding his battle cart! 😅
It is an impossible job to lead Britain.😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀
UK propaghanda just like the radio times in 1940.
Are we really that old to remember the Radio Times in 1940? Dear me ...