I didn't know that challenger's name is Rachel. I checked her wiki, she went to Berkeley quite recently, and went to international school in china, but she's still born and raised mostly in China. I know of her because a song she wrote which is really good, was covered in another singing show. I'm saying this because when the guy said she went to Berkley in response to you saying she sound western and asking if she's Chinese, it seems to make sense to you. But based on the English lyrics she wrote on a few of her song, it's quite obvious she's not fluent in English. So I think it's even more impressive that youre questioning whether she's Chinese. Because I tend to get a bit picky about that too, when Chinese singer sings and English song, if it isn't the pronunciation that's bothering me it's just the "vibe" singing style or whatever that I think not too fitting to the English song. Compared to someone like David Tao and LeeHom who was pretty much born raised in western culture, it's really rare for someone who isn't very fluent in English to be able to sing an English song so westernised. I mean many Chinese singers have probably listened to some English pop growing up, but it's different when they're really into the culture or are living in that culture. Also, I don't know why but despite all the praises you have on SunNan and how well he's received, I just can't seem to enjoy his performance. For me it feels very boring. It has been hat way since watching him on the show years ago. I notice how much he improved, but I still can't seem to enjoy it. I listened to this song several time's to see if I haven't given it a fair chance, but I just don't like it. Also I'm familiar with the song, and I think the arrangement he made don't make sense, it's kind of too emotional in a cheesy kind of way, the way he arranged it, there's that kind of cry sound at the beginning that I feel is a little over the top dramatic, and all in all it just makes the song boring. I wish you guy would review the original QiQin's version. There isn't that high and low variations like this one, not to mention SunNan adds a lot of high notes too, and I just feel like he's arranging it to display his vocal technique rather than servicing the song and its lyrics. The original sounds much simpler, but personally I find it profoundly moving.
Fully agreed about your comment on Yellow !!! Indeed he was the standout performer among others in this 5th episode. I believe if the judging definition are similar with American Idol, he should be in top 3.
Thats not what she said. She's saying as someone watching the show from episode to episode, his performance did not stand out, because he's doing what hes done before. That's why the better singer so to speak, or the more experienced singers are often the initial 7 in this show. because in a competition for you to get that far with so many performance is much harder, because no matter how good you are, people kinda want to see a different side of you instead of you just singing the thing youre good at over and over. Its the same with American idol, thats why in singing competition the winner are often the more versatile singer. They may not be the best at 1 genre, but they're above average in multiple. Someone like Kelly Clarkson I feel is the best representation. That's why it's usually the others that's not in the first place, that usually have a better career. Except for Kelly Clarkson, she's really good covering all sorts of genre.
黃宣這週唱得更爵士也更藍調，但就跟前幾週一樣還是爵士的範疇（雖然曲風還是有些微不同）。所以可能聽起來就沒有我們期待的那麼驚艷。 但是如果我們結合背景音樂、結合樂團的演奏、結合這首歌的律動，才是黃宣完整的呈現！只聽聲音的話，沒辦法感受到所有的樂趣、這首沒爆點的歌也會覺得差了那麼點意思。 其實有些半音的地方唱得有點早期黑人靈魂樂的味道，聽起來還是很過癮的～ Yellow is more Jazzy&Bluesy this week , but it’s still the same Jazz like he used to be . So , maybe it’s not as good as we expect . But , if u combine the background music , combine with the band , combine the groove , that is the complete Yellow ! If we just listen to the vocal , it will only show us 50% interesting . By the way , there are some old time soul music flavor in it , when it comes to some Bluesy chromatic scales (half steps). It’s kind of wild and crazy ! Sounds pretty nice .
I think it's interesting that you talked about how the competitive nature kind of forced the singer to sing out of the box and you get these faouzia and change performances in this episode. But I think it depends on the singer's attitude towards a singing competition. Having watched this show from the first season. There are usually a few types of singers. There are some that's going to pick big/classic songs that are popular, almost all the time, there are some who'd do this picking a variation to show a different side of them, there are some who aren't competitive and just sings songs they like, another would pick songs they feel are meaningful, sort of like promoting good songs kind of agenda, and then there are a few, that picks songs that they like but they know exactly what kind of song works well for them, and don't necessarily pick song outside of their comfort zones if they can't do it well. The show tells a lot about a singer, and that's what I think is so interesting about the show. The risk takers are usually the younger ones, they want to explore their own possibility. But there are just some that are really focused on picking songs that they know would sound good for them, or songs that fits them but they never get a chance to, because they have been known for a certain genre, most of their career. Jessie J for instance, all her song choices are Big classic very popular songs, that clearly would show skill, but at the same time, one might say a safe choice. Then there are people like WangFeng and ZhouShen who challenges and go out of their comfort zone too, pick songs that they were never known for or anyone would expect they sing, but something they can pull off.
![เป็นไปได้ไหม - WanMai [Teaser] | 05-12-24](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P5Uto6e453w/mqdefault.jpg)
我能理解老師喜歡黃宣的點是藝術又誠懇。 感受到歌手發自內心的真實熱愛
老师的头发好可爱
我本身很喜歡看百老匯跟歌劇跟爵士音樂，黃宣是裡面亞洲人可以入選的。很高興黃宣被更多人看到他的才華。
黃宣從29分左右開始
黃宣超讚啊
看他表演都超enjoy 🥰
看你們的影片真的是好過癮
不得不說黃宣為什麼都能把各種風格散發出來 玩出來 唱歌與藝術並存😮
完全被他吸引住！
現在真的會唱歌的太多了 黃宣真的很獨特
這髮型怎麼回事😂😂
好可愛但表情好嚴肅
西方蘇運瑩
這期的髮型設計我覺得不太好 😆
髮型好可愛😂😂然後嚴肅的評論歌曲😂😂😂
可愛的髮型😆
每個禮拜都很期待欸～
每次都感覺一個禮拜有兩次歌手
一次自己看的
一次跟老師一起看（然後下一期又出了！
我也是🎉
+1
*1
😉
28:46 黃宣的部分❤😊
ty
謝謝
謝謝
看這個show專門看黃宣的部分就好了
感謝
天曉得在這舞台聽見方大同+Steive Wonder是多感動的事情
真的，其实我期待他之后会不会选Eric Clapton 的 change the world.我感觉会很适合❤
而且兩首歌的旋律和歌詞也接的很流暢，我覺得是很棒的改編
下一場他真的該唱個英文歌了
雞皮疙瘩出來了
@@VincentGPT-lol 下一期是 范曉萱《你的甜蜜》
這期感覺大家開始都對每個歌手更嚴苛了，跳脫舒適圈的歌手並沒唱對味，較在舒適圈的歌手又聽的開始有點疲乏，真是矛盾與兩難， 選歌很重要之外，如何改編也是，不敢大改編，可能擔心被喜歡聽原曲的說亂改，破壞原曲味道。較按照原曲的唱，又可能不適合自己的唱法風格，而且又很難唱得比已經是經典的原曲更好。
覺得這是這期歌手較大的考驗，誰能翻唱成功變成自己的代表曲。所以再次佩服以前【歌手】節目的鄧紫棋、A-Lin...等厲害的歌手，能翻唱紅許多歌，變成自己的歌。
這期我只有凡西亞翻唱史汀的那首歌，有令我覺得蠻成功變成自己的歌。黃宣唱的【思念】也算有點成功，他們都剛好是男歌女唱，女歌男唱，這種選歌通常會更有機會成功，因為男聲跟女聲本來就很難放一起做比較，各自有不一樣好聽的部分。
沒錯，這種比賽就是這樣，很難有一個歌手可在許多不同類型的歌，都唱的好，又吸引人。
也許賽制、賽期拖太長了因此每次硬要做出些不同東西。American/British Got Talent 相對緊湊些
所以全能型的天王天后才难得 舒适圈大点才能每周不一样风格不疲劳
歌手太侷限一種唱法舒適圈本來就只能吸引小眾 所以周的歌為何要各種都涉獵 就是為了吸引各種風格的粉絲 這也是周跟其他歌手粉絲量的差距 還有就是作品 沒有好的適合自己的作品 歌唱得再厲害聲音在好聽也很難大紅大紫
等等，ALine是沙小!?新的聊天軟體喔
審美疲勞真的是每位參賽歌手選歌與編曲必須要考慮到的問題
Rachel's performance is impressive.
She is a good competitor against Yellow.
Both are excellent, and I really enjoyed both performances this round.
看到很多不喜欢张钰琪的评论，真是大家看法不同，我就喜欢张钰琪，听了就觉得眼前一亮，虽然很年轻，但气息音准都很不错，她其实是13岁就登台的小童星了，之后拿奖学金去Berkley深造，相信她未来一定大有前途，未来可期
看到有人說為什麼汪蘇瀧資源這麼好？第一期好像講了，開始沒有人請他寫OST，他就很認真寫了年輪，得到了認可，有人看到邀請他來音綜，他成績很好，上億播放。然後抓住每次機會，作為獨立音樂人，完全靠自己奮鬥，得到市場認可，很佩服！
喜欢汪苏泷，旋律美，音色美。听QQ听到他好多歌曲❤最近循环行走的鱼❤
終於看到我想看的了，他真的有資源就不需要到處拋頭露面，他就是想學習，想讓大家聽到他的音樂，還好瀧瀧比我們堅強。；；
@@QiQi49_7moon真的respect, 已經是那麼有名受歡迎的歌手了，還勇敢接受挑戰，面對質疑壓力，表現還能越來越穩定。反正對聽歌的人，不管什麼風格，好聽就行❤
+1，這就是我很難討厭他的理由
也許他唱得不怎麼樣，但論拼搏、態度及匠心，我還想繼續跟著他歷險與成長
老師真的好可愛，好真，這週感覺等老師的影片等的特別久～🥰
Waw faouzia 👍👏👏😍😍
這期的老師表現好好，
好好笑充滿了娛樂的看點，
覺得這個節目越來越有趣了，
不僅專業，
還扣人心弦，
讓人想一看再看重複再看😂
喜歡老師今天的髮型😂😂😂
是因为无意中看到橘老师的点评，才去关注到歌手这个节目。而我也并不看电视，而是节目之后看单曲、看老师这个频道。在这里，滤去伴奏，更能听清楚歌手的演唱，老师的点评经常是那么清晰和可爱，做很多比喻，讲的很详尽透彻，非常喜爱。并且经过老师的点评，能有更多角度欣赏歌曲，也会逐渐发现哪些歌手是真的值得去听。而对于有专业需求的听众，看老师的评语，相信会收获良多。
黃宣超棒
我们中国南昌最棒
@@montane-ub9jc赞你，但为什么啊？？？ 这是什么梗？
28:42 黃宣
I didn't know that challenger's name is Rachel. I checked her wiki, she went to Berkeley quite recently, and went to international school in china, but she's still born and raised mostly in China. I know of her because a song she wrote which is really good, was covered in another singing show. I'm saying this because when the guy said she went to Berkley in response to you saying she sound western and asking if she's Chinese, it seems to make sense to you.
But based on the English lyrics she wrote on a few of her song, it's quite obvious she's not fluent in English. So I think it's even more impressive that youre questioning whether she's Chinese. Because I tend to get a bit picky about that too, when Chinese singer sings and English song, if it isn't the pronunciation that's bothering me it's just the "vibe" singing style or whatever that I think not too fitting to the English song. Compared to someone like David Tao and LeeHom who was pretty much born raised in western culture, it's really rare for someone who isn't very fluent in English to be able to sing an English song so westernised. I mean many Chinese singers have probably listened to some English pop growing up, but it's different when they're really into the culture or are living in that culture.
Also, I don't know why but despite all the praises you have on SunNan and how well he's received, I just can't seem to enjoy his performance. For me it feels very boring. It has been hat way since watching him on the show years ago. I notice how much he improved, but I still can't seem to enjoy it. I listened to this song several time's to see if I haven't given it a fair chance, but I just don't like it. Also I'm familiar with the song, and I think the arrangement he made don't make sense, it's kind of too emotional in a cheesy kind of way, the way he arranged it, there's that kind of cry sound at the beginning that I feel is a little over the top dramatic, and all in all it just makes the song boring. I wish you guy would review the original QiQin's version. There isn't that high and low variations like this one, not to mention SunNan adds a lot of high notes too, and I just feel like he's arranging it to display his vocal technique rather than servicing the song and its lyrics. The original sounds much simpler, but personally I find it profoundly moving.
36:23
不能说她后来去了Berekely就认为她现在的表现就make sence。其实远在她2019年参加《明日之子》的时候，不管是初舞台的原创《Baby dont cry》，还是后面的几首cover及原创，均显示了她与生俱来的成熟嗓音及创作能力，其实她是一个舞台表演经验相当丰富的小童星。
不是啦，老師應該是說她的唱腔比較西方
应该说从小去international school, 这样就make sence了
每一次只期待黃宣的表演跟這個頻道的reaction
Fully agreed about your comment on Yellow !!! Indeed he was the standout performer among others in this 5th episode. I believe if the judging definition are similar with American Idol, he should be in top 3.
Thats not what she said. She's saying as someone watching the show from episode to episode, his performance did not stand out, because he's doing what hes done before. That's why the better singer so to speak, or the more experienced singers are often the initial 7 in this show. because in a competition for you to get that far with so many performance is much harder, because no matter how good you are, people kinda want to see a different side of you instead of you just singing the thing youre good at over and over.
Its the same with American idol, thats why in singing competition the winner are often the more versatile singer. They may not be the best at 1 genre, but they're above average in multiple. Someone like Kelly Clarkson I feel is the best representation. That's why it's usually the others that's not in the first place, that usually have a better career. Except for Kelly Clarkson, she's really good covering all sorts of genre.
27:29 剪得真好完美的歡樂回憶！太棒了😂我笑的非常開心❤
天啊 這髮型太適合老師樂吧 好可愛啊❤
Tbh faouzia NAILED it this week , she's really spectacular and I think no one would sing it like she did
我最喜歡Whitney Houston，已經是刻在骨髓的喜愛了。因老師的分享去聽Jessie J - I Wanna Dance With Somebody.真的很棒，就像團熊熊燃燒的烈火，個人風格非常強烈。謝謝。
兩個風格似乎不太一樣，Jessie J的比較熾熱成熟，Whitney Houston比較雀躍青澀，但是技巧都超棒耶！
Rozette老師在黃宣和張鈺琪之間的抉擇；在我的感覺就像是張鈺琪像是歌唱界的芭蕾舞，把控的非常好非常美，而黃宣是歌唱界的街舞隨性自在時而驚喜有趣。
那英姐…這集有認真了吧！有好好練歌吧！覺得穩很多，我覺得歌手2024讓那英思考了很多，適合她的風格，還有她的武器殺手鐧 ，資歷如果沒有與時俱進，不進則退，並不能讓她坐穩寶座。
敲碗黃宣唱chicken attack啦😂
I love Faouzia, and I think this is the performance I liked the most
Same
有一个问题真的很想问老师，像Chante和Fouzia这样，或者说像很多有自己显著特色的歌手那样，演唱“稍微不那么适合他们的歌曲”的时候，尽管从声乐技术层面上完成得很完美，却仍然感觉“差点意思”“不太对劲”，这种情况是否有办法“改良”？毕竟照着我们认为更舒适的方向去唱的话，也许就失掉他们个人的特色而变得不像他们了？或者说再优秀的歌手，总会有他们无法表达好的音乐风格，没办法做出打动人的翻唱版本，是不是要坦然接受这一点？
黃宣的自我介紹詞本來就有摩登大聖！😂
他還試圖在自我介紹詞裡再增加一些詞進去。
台版金凱瑞 XD
節目長度有限，沒辦法讓他一直練肖話😅
哈克难最后的表舅真的笑烂
每周看完歌手之后最期待的就是老师的re和点评了❤哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈断眉来期待老师的re！！！！
你確定斷眉會來嗎？我怎麼聽說他不來了
@@葉秋英-r6m 啥？！如果真的确定了断眉不会来了那除了听听凡希亚香缇莫看看下次请谁来袭榜外其他真没啥看头了
张钰琪太长脸了，真棒
橘老師在這期講到一點很有趣，真的要你掏錢去買票看表演，會選誰，至目前為止的印象，我一定選黃宣，第二名我會選杭蓋，第三名選橘老師（咦？XD)，但這集的表演，整體上真的是蠻無聊的一集。
跟老師一樣 我也覺得張鈺琪的Black Sheep是本集第一 歌選得太好 她也表現得恰到好處，第二是Faouzia，黃宣第三
完全赞同
太期待老師評價冠軍及黃宣了！
B站已经更新了
唯一和老師看法不同的就是張了
實在欣賞不來，可能學術派的能懂
作為一般聽眾原本覺得普通，聽完原唱覺得完全不喜
孫憑音準拿第一真的很難看，他唱的甚至比原唱更老派，可惜裡面沒人聽過原唱
@@蒨-b5h 我還沒有看到說法，不過我看到其他人的評論，滿有共鳴的。
張的整體演出很像選手駕駛一台配備超高級的跑車，而她卻飆不起來😂
@@snoope.snoope哇，好贴切的说法，完全表达了我的感受！！
@@蒨-b5h同意你的說法 齊秦唱的是不同等級的存在
黃宣在我心中也是第一名，主要是他真的很享在表演，而不是在意比賽
日常表白橘老師，橘老師總是這麼可愛❤😂
真高興老師說出了節目搞事的原則😉
但這恰恰就是為難之處😅
有時候我們希望歌手突破，例如孫楠，音色唱功俱佳，但唱法能不能與時俱進一下？
有時又覺得，為何不能讓歌手一直發揮自身強項呢？走出的舒適區，可能是歌手的，同時也可能是聽眾的啊😬
張鈺琪先前沒聽過，今天之後會想多找些她的歌來聽呢。
還有很會起名的 Fine樂隊唱歌時，我也是想到那個很會唱韓語歌的小姐姐😁
然後讓我挺難述說的黃宣，今天這首是四場以來我接受度最高的一首，夠有他的特色又還在我的承受範圍。如果我想向別人介紹黃宣，我會放這首給人家聽😉
但我更想先去找 Stevie Wonder 的歌回味一下😋
张钰琪两年前参加选秀节目的表演就不错，还有不错原创，还以为她昙花一现了，能参加歌手这是升级了
看著Fauozia隨風飄動的仙氣感，伍佰表示：演唱會帶電風扇這我很熟！
你比喻的太好😂
想看老師評論徐佳瑩，她之前也有參加歌手，跟CoCo李玟同期，改編滿多歌曲都很好聽，也很有自己的風格
跟老師一起看，就有討論的感覺！有些觀點好好笑，老師的反應很有趣❤❤❤
精准的评论，对节目的要求解析非常到位
那英第二純屬搞笑 從演出誠意上就不過關 一直盯著提詞板看 貌合神離。
19:00 Faouzia ❤
老師有聽過 動力火車嗎🥲
推上去
推
推推推
推
推
感覺黃宣很適合西貢小姐裡工程師(Engineer)唱的American Dream，可以考慮一些音樂劇或Disney歌曲，既可炫技又富有情感又親民!~~
真的欸，神燈歌一定超適合他
@@jacqyko 獨上C樓的風格就跟friends like me 一樣。
哈哈 engineer 經常是光頭演的，感覺他真的可以唱個american dream.
老師對黃宣音樂品味靈感來源有興趣的話，
VOGUE TAIWAN有黃宣的採訪，黃宣人生歌單
黃宣這週唱得更爵士也更藍調，但就跟前幾週一樣還是爵士的範疇（雖然曲風還是有些微不同）。所以可能聽起來就沒有我們期待的那麼驚艷。
但是如果我們結合背景音樂、結合樂團的演奏、結合這首歌的律動，才是黃宣完整的呈現！只聽聲音的話，沒辦法感受到所有的樂趣、這首沒爆點的歌也會覺得差了那麼點意思。
其實有些半音的地方唱得有點早期黑人靈魂樂的味道，聽起來還是很過癮的～
Yellow is more Jazzy&Bluesy this week , but it’s still the same Jazz like he used to be . So , maybe it’s not as good as we expect .
But , if u combine the background music , combine with the band , combine the groove , that is the complete Yellow ! If we just listen to the vocal , it will only show us 50% interesting .
By the way , there are some old time soul music flavor in it , when it comes to some Bluesy chromatic scales (half steps). It’s kind of wild and crazy ! Sounds pretty nice .
我覺得黃宣是唱他自己喜歡的歌不是大家都會喜歡的歌。
但我覺得很耐聽 重播好幾次
老實說 我不是要對英子苛刻，如果長年以大腕、實力派、音樂導師身分處在華語樂壇，真正要上場競賽是否應該要拿出大師的風範(還是享受當大師的榮耀 不需要有大師的實力)...不能每次都表現不完美都歸於緊張發揮不好(或者她實力就是這樣??)。英子的紛絲們......就舞台表現來說.........真的覺得英子可以拿到前三名嗎?????????至少我覺得比她表現好的就至少三個了....
加上她對別人也苛刻 甚至瞧不起 所以被別人逮到機會就會被踩得很嚴重
重點她還是評審，😂
有人脉 有网军给挽尊啊
@@robertem2463 所以她過去的好朋友，一個個都沒了。
有代表作又有基本功的老資歷歌手基本都是走這路線
沒辦法
最近因為歌手5的關係
又回去重刷了林憶蓮的串燒
在這邊懇請 杰凱讓橘子老師聽聽 林憶蓮的串燒
不論技巧 高音 情緒 意境都到位的 「柿子」
或者 清亮 空靈 高音的 「藍蓮花」
又或者口吻情緒滿分的代表作 「不必在乎我是誰」
都行!!! 拜託 好想知道橘子老師對這幾首歌的看法QQQ
杰楷好像不喜歡林憶蓮 雖然她比那英好上百倍 不是同一個年代的唱法
@@里夫-l1b 雖然我不是林憶蓮的粉，但確實比那英強，隨便丟幾個G5 F5，海豚音，加上會跳舞快歌，加上長音....非常全能(那屆我喜歡譚晶)
認同！華語樂壇裡，林憶蓮是其中一位最能唱出歌曲意境的歌手❤
橘子老师有做林忆莲的review，在B站上看到的😂回刷的时候看到
@@playgameonly173 譚晶的確是大魔王 一首九兒唱的我起雞皮疙瘩 技巧 感情都無懈可擊 可惜好像只唱了兩首歌 就不知道為啥會派孫楠這貨出戰
左右护法真的太有趣了
汪苏泷每期唱的都一样的感觉，不管什么歌
聽完這期，最喜歡就是黃宣和Faouzia，當然也是聽到方大同和Stevie Wonder和Whitney Houston雞皮疙瘩出來了
敲碗 A-Lin 月牙灣🥣🥣🥣
為什麼孫楠要把齊秦的歌唱成山歌呢?
真的，這首歌其實很好聽，被他唱的很難聽
就整個俗氣感上升
@@ASDFGHJKL-x8w 原唱真的很好聽，大家不管是任何立場，真的必須聽一下........洗耳😂
孫不行啦，非常明顯選錯歌，改編錯歌曲
這種感覺是不是那英說刀郎的"土味" 這也能第一名.......
@@里夫-l1b至少刀郎的土味能感動人吧
老師的髮型太可愛了吧❤
橘老師才是我看我是歌手的動力🎉
感覺老師們愈來愈受歡迎，Fans愈來愈多，聽點評時都受益不淺，將大眾的水欣賞水平都提高了
喜歡老師的平價。 喜歡有靈魂的表演。❤
拜託去聽原版的懸崖 跪求了 孫楠把整首歌的靈魂唱壞了。齊秦這首歌本來的空靈感完全像被孫楠滲透了10kg菜油。
同感。给他唱出了攀岩的感觉
真的难听死了 主要是好吵
他只是想盡量展現他的歌喉聲音 卻沒有唱出讓觀眾認同的風格 所以選歌如果要選情境高的 真的大起獲大落 擱淺就是一個例子
但其實他把這首歌唱出了他自己的味道 只是不符合你們的期待而以
換個方式想...比較喜歡他的人搞不好覺得他這樣唱很好聽阿
我在官方下评论，还被人说我不懂欣赏😂😂😂
老师不喜欢悬崖这首歌很大可能是被孙楠唱成opera了，应该听听齐秦的😅
確實是沒有驚喜也不吸引的歌
真的！聽到孫楠的唱法好心痛🥲，這首是我的愛歌說⋯⋯
明明是在聽歌手唱流行樂，真的誤以為去了歌劇院
太佩服老師了 我完全說不出來香緹唱得哪裡怪 但聽老師完全說出我的心聲XD
老師對汪蘇瀧評價太深得我心，他真的是一個超級無聊的歌手，問題是他跟那英一樣資源豐富，可以在各個歌唱節目出現，你總是會看到他
這類型的資深歌手是中國節目是最詭異的存在，因為他們是無敵的，也不需要進步...
這個是收視率的問題 電視台又不是慈濟…….
汪蘇瀧幾乎都想快轉
他不是 vocal diva 这个舞台不合适他
就是流量高啊
@@iamyourfather9008 他在演藝圈超過10年，數十年如一日沒有任何變化，這不是舞台類型適合的問題
他的個性很像一個公務員，追求無功無過的表演，就僅僅只是完成這樣...
這在中國會被很多人尊敬，但是表演舞台上需要驚喜，他根本不適合這個職業...
汪應該就是俗說的大白嗓吧，唱歌跟傳遞聲音表情的天賦很相關，但是他又是學音樂創作，音色又跟大紅的JJ很類似，個性若有趣再經營網紅路線其實很討巧。他應該更適合其他類型的音樂節目。
黃宣才是真正的大白嗓
確實 汪蘇龍這家伙的聲音本來就令人印象不深 會有點知名度還是因為年輕時候幾首很甜的歌
行蓋樂隊 我個人是覺得很油膩 受不了
凡希亞 豐富又好聽 心目中前三
張鈺琪也好好聽 強大又新鮮的血液
黃宣這期真的很好聽 不是故意要說 節奏把握真好 心目中前三
燦爛的你這首歌 歌詞寓意很好
孫楠唱的這個 技巧很好 但我對老歌沒什麼感覺
孙楠唱得还不如齐秦，除了共鸣真的是啥也没有，而且主歌的关键离调音还唱不准，听得人难受
I think it's interesting that you talked about how the competitive nature kind of forced the singer to sing out of the box and you get these faouzia and change performances in this episode. But I think it depends on the singer's attitude towards a singing competition. Having watched this show from the first season. There are usually a few types of singers. There are some that's going to pick big/classic songs that are popular, almost all the time, there are some who'd do this picking a variation to show a different side of them, there are some who aren't competitive and just sings songs they like, another would pick songs they feel are meaningful, sort of like promoting good songs kind of agenda, and then there are a few, that picks songs that they like but they know exactly what kind of song works well for them, and don't necessarily pick song outside of their comfort zones if they can't do it well. The show tells a lot about a singer, and that's what I think is so interesting about the show.
The risk takers are usually the younger ones, they want to explore their own possibility. But there are just some that are really focused on picking songs that they know would sound good for them, or songs that fits them but they never get a chance to, because they have been known for a certain genre, most of their career.
Jessie J for instance, all her song choices are Big classic very popular songs, that clearly would show skill, but at the same time, one might say a safe choice. Then there are people like WangFeng and ZhouShen who challenges and go out of their comfort zone too, pick songs that they were never known for or anyone would expect they sing, but something they can pull off.
以前我很常會快轉老師的講評，不是不喜歡，就是我看影片的習慣
音樂會照正常速度，偏向資訊的部份就快轉
但HELLO，我必須把唱歌的部份快轉，然後感謝橘老師的解讀讓我平心靜氣
很謝謝老師說出演唱者的優秀與不合適，我是唱歌外行，只覺得我喜歡的歌味道都不對了
可是無法說服自己因為演唱者很厲害就得接受
有點想聽老師說明像席琳狄翁跟Adele唱歌的高明之處了
為卡祖笛的顫音鼓掌👏🏼🎉🤣
老師擔心黃宣繼續選爵士樂，對比賽不是很有利……他唱一般的歌或許排名會更前面
但是黃宣是來推廣他的音樂
偶爾來一下突襲，讓大家知道他能演譯其他曲風也是一個選擇，畢竟這是娛樂節目。他不是大Vocal歌手，能混幾期就幾期，這是中國人的節目，不用太期待。
呦 还以为一代宗师呢 真了不起
誰管黃宣啊
@@montane-ub9jc 你講得出專業的意見，那別人也叫你老師宗師
而且老師是很普遍在叫的
@@Leeogh 你不管黃宣，也沒人當你是啞巴喔
想看老师点评Jessie J 2018年参加歌手的那几期
Chante仍努力而真摯傳遞情感，但她似乎也開始進入了一個撞牆期？場上最好的仍會選兩個外國人，第三選黃宣。
出場順序是歌手自行抽籤的(有沒有做假就不知道了😅)
汪終於選對歌了❤️😭
个人建议，可以考虑下次在提到某位歌手的时候给一个那个歌手的镜头。例如提到josh groben，给个josh的镜头。观众体验感可以拉满。
敲碗A-Lin之前上歌手的串燒
看到28分钟左右，想说深有感触，这就是为什么我现在很少给别人分享、推荐我喜欢的歌，因为以前仅有的几次分享的结果都是对方反应平平，而且音乐品味本来就是每个人都不同，没有共鸣也没什么，于是也就没心思推荐了。还有就是有些音乐技术性很强、难度很高或者编排很高大上，可能十分具有艺术性，然而对于我这样一个普通的欣赏者来说，我听不懂也get不到，就会觉得“噢……还行吧……”，这种情况在器乐领域更明显，比如我听一些指弹或者古典的吉他乐曲，有时候好听的也许是简单的，复杂的也许并不那么“悦耳”
奇怪…印象中前幾天聽別的影片black sheep 時感覺張的聲音太暗不喜歡，這裡聽好多了，還不錯。
但還是pick 黃宣
我也發現了 似乎有調整過 之前聽音色悶悶的
純享版的都有修音
me,too
特別是高音的部分顯得比較亮了一點，之前聽真的有種洞窟聲，只有一小段大概三四句聲音比較亮，我懷疑那才是她本來的音色。
我看到有提到Jessie J，然後出現了一個念頭，很想敲碗看橘老師評論Jessie J在歌手2018裡所唱的歌，很好奇，我可以直接提供連結
th-cam.com/video/aCtqhV1Z1QM/w-d-xo.htmlsi=KLUDD0Ge7dUVvUS6
敲碗敲碗敲碗😂
這一季新的歌手2024，已經不是洪濤製作的，所以沒有特別去了解賽制規則跟以前有沒有什麼不同，以前的應該是最多可以唱自已的歌兩次，多數一定是別人的歌，但一般是用「自選」兩字，是否為節目組安排的不知道，另外我相信大多數歌曲要唱之前，或多或少會有該歌手的一些說明或練習之類的片段，比如這期的孫楠在跑步，讓兩個跟拍的跟丟了，那英唱的則是原唱汪峰給的建議與練唱的過程（以前的印象是比較有針對歌曲上的解說，比較能知道為什麼唱這一首歌），考量到這系列主要是評論歌唱，我猜JKAI跟老師都是只有看歌曲部份，所以對於已知或有看完整內容的人而言，就會有認知上的誤差了。
杭蓋樂隊能唱到現在或許算不錯了，我覺得比較明顯的偏硬式搖滾或重金屬搖滾的團，在華語環境，只能得到小眾的喜愛，大眾一般是不愛的，偏流行搖滾或新搖滾的風格，大眾接受度才會比較高，何況杭蓋樂隊還帶著蒙古族風格，在這場很可能是最後一場的表演，唱他們自已蒙古族的民歌，還是用蒙古語唱，真的只是不受大眾喜愛的風格罷了（呼斯楞是國語的原唱）
Fine樂團的男性，一年可寫81首歌，這次唱的也是他寫的，就是他們自已較有名高流量的歌了，下期評論可能很不妙。
黄宣鬼才
Singer 2024 is quite boring, but it's fun to watch it with coach, love her reactions!
我個人不太喜歡張鈺淇的唱法，但她這種唱法，喜歡和不喜歡的是人兩個極端吧
她的聲色我個人不愛。
@@kellyhsieh9239+1
明顯聲帶有點疲乏感，需要休息保養
但聽得出來是有唱功的
不喜歡+1
欧美歌坛近些年流行的唱法，就是女性歌手唱法和音色中性化，与这两年女性主义崛起有很大关系
很想聽老師點評一下動力火車，感覺老師有可能會很愛
27:12 听单依纯唱歌对我来说就是这个感觉，理性的大脑一直在夸赞她，声音真好，音准也好，技巧好成熟，但没感觉。但毛不易唱歌，你不觉得他有多有技巧，但觉得他的声音像一只大手拧了我的心脏。
只聽人聲的版本
我對張鈺琪改觀了
功力非常不錯
看直播的時候覺得她還好
My 1 Faouzia 2Rachel
+1 直播時覺的唱的很平很無聊，人聲確很有張力，怪怪？
如果拿掉伴奏更好听了，可以有两种理由：
一、歌手无需伴奏
二、歌手盖不过伴奏
她聲音很好，未來無可限量
老师口红好好看啊！哈哈哈
不太认同老师所说的唱hello 时就要遵照某个固定的模式.。如果是这样的话， 翻唱就没有新鲜感了。Chante 的版本未必可以比得上原版，因为Adele 的声音是比较浑厚的，但我认为她唱出了自己的风格。
the way using Chinese in "一起拍" was way better than "你好 from the other side"
整句變得不倫不類🤣
老师的情商绝对是天花板级别的
JKAI～歌很好聽
love this hairstyle
坦白說，個人不喜歡孫楠和那英一貫的唱法，雖然兩人的音色技巧都是公認的好。勇於跳出舒適圈雖然有風險，但勇氣可嘉，是值得鼓勵和肯定！
Listen to the song “exothermic“ if you want to hear Faouzia do all those R&B runs.
我超喜歡燦爛的你這首歌，我又是一個很愛尋覓各種翻唱表演的人，但這次我完全不買單那英的詮釋，汪峰、譚軒轅的版本甚至中國好聲音學員大合唱的版本都比這個好，這首歌就是汪峰一貫的創作能量，平凡的人也有無比強大的力量，所以儘管他的嗓音表現不是走完美路線，但這才是這類歌曲可以動人的原因，然而那英的演出就只有平凡，一點能量都沒有...，整首歌的音域都在她的舒適區，但這區間就她的強項，能理解不能relate
那英唱的好不燦爛…
小心翼翼的你那種感覺
那英第二，嚴重高估！
一貫的拘謹、諷刺的是感覺不到燦爛的那英。看看 Faouzia 和 Chante Moore 在台上的自在自如，層次分明的嗓音。那英唱的戰戰兢兢、太理性了 😂
這首歌本來就是這種風格，不用太多有的沒的，挺適合她。
@@adl8595 这首歌的唱法是要战战兢兢的唱？ 真的？ 🤣
第二真的不行
明明是Faouzia跟Chante兩個爭第一名鬥得難分難解，你告訴大家孫第一那第二
這不是明顯開玩笑嗎
畢竟她有地主優勢
@@FreeCat77审美疲劳了 一个全是技巧 没什么感情 一个选的曲子驾驭不了 ，那英唯一优势估计就是唱的中文 可以有共情吧。别天天阴谋论了
1:00:17 老師扮disney的樣子太像 太好笑了XD