ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- On July 30, the second and final draft of the National Register of Citizens was released.
Names of around 40 lakh people out of 3 crore 29 lakh applicants were not included in the list...
This led to a raging national debate. In today's In Depth, we understand what is NRC, why is it being updated now, why does it concern only the state of Assam, and why do political parties have differing opinions on the issue.
First Congress and now BJP with CAB (Citizenship Amendment Bill). We don't want any Bangladeshi whether he is Muslim, Hindu, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, etc. We don't want any Bangladeshi in Assam.
Yeah I stand by your words
Bjp & congress both are making a dumping site for bangladesh in assam in the name of vote bank.
Congress bring muslim from East Bengal/bangladesh
Bjp bring hindu from East Bengal/bangladesh
BJP and INC both are thinking assam is a dumping ground
CAB/CAA violates the Assam Accord! Joi Aai Axom ✊✊✊
this is one of the best episodes, very comprehensive coverage
Thank you...for ur vital contribution in my upsc preparation...
Did you clear? Job mila?
How's your life now ? I hope you have cleared the exam 🙏🏽
I feel cab should be withdrawed because we are grappling with our own population and should invite more to compete !
Pagal ho kya,ata pta kuch nahin aur comment karne aa gye
@@vishalreddy4431 well that's what violates against Assam Accord Bro. So CAA should be withdrawn.
@@vishalreddy4431 Assam is not included in ILP provisions. Get your facts right. Besides, speaking for other northeastern states, ILP solves only 1/4th of the problem of legitimising illegal immigrants
@@navaneetbaruah3610 really d tribal areas?????
@@navaneetbaruah3610 plz dont be misguided by aasu nd Congress. Kindly try 2 understand d caa properly nd instead of opposing caa ask govt. to explain how it will not affect assam. Nd remember it is BJP only who can save assam from being like kashmir nd kerela otherwise with d name of language ur culture will also be in danger. Assamese nd bengali culture r not too different except bihu but once Islam increase in d state u will lose everything.
The Dark Knight Rises theme music playing in the background!
O'God this is good.
It's really good Initiative that subtitle has been come with vedio.
Background score of The Dark Knight Theme by Hans Zimmer
good coverage of the issue.tnx rs tv
Profoundly explained. Thanks.
14:14 foreigners were very important vote baks for congress.
Extreme Islam is the only root cause of such critical situation. If you want to save Non Islamic Religious people CAB is good but on the other hand if you want to save the culture of Assam then CAb is not good
Extreme Islam? Where did Islam come into picture here? How about extreme Assamese? Am Hindu and Assamese btw.
@@woahbarman Extreme Assamese??
Every Bangladeshi should leave India irrespective of religion or race, because of Bangladeshi we Muslim Indians get called immigrants even though my grandfather was a freedom fighter and was arrested during quit India movement. Political parties are playing this Hindu Muslim politics to satisfy thier vote banks. Every Muslim, every Hindu Bangladeshi should be kicked out of Assam.
Me ro Rahi hu. Frustrated hu. In log ko bas vote bharne he or kuch nahi. Desh ki safety ka kya esse toh koi bhi apna nakli certificate bana k dikheyega ki dekho me hindu Buddhist hu or citizenship le lega
@@loveanime9890 Haa sahi kaha
Nice coverage thanx RStv team.
People who are in the favour of development in Northeastern area of India... Pay tax first (except Assam). And Btw what is this "mainland" nonsense? India is not China! And the thing about unemployment... Work hard! People from northeast are cracking upsc ( toughest exam of India)! Peace out!
Assamese kaha tax bartey hai? Gandu juut mat bol
@@kipayaniang9421 Kipa Yaniang Tu school ja, geography history padh le thoda,kyu bhoj Bana hua hai India Ka? Kuch pata v h Tax kya hota h kaise dete hai?
Everyone is paying taxes. Mind your own business. Even on a 10 rs choclate, everyone is paying indirect tax.
@@abinashdas9619 okay fair enough! So people who who are paying direct taxes (10%-15% of their salary) plus indirect taxes should benefit first. You please wait for you turn to come. Don't cry wolf!
@@kishoredas204 everyone having income above certain level is also paying direct taxes. And some businessman are paying income taxes combined together 1000 s of salaried class people's income taxes. Being a person with regular income should make us aware of what changes economic inequality can bring to our society. So it is our responsibility and duty as a citizen to pay our taxes, we can question the officials regarding the management of taxpayers money, how well and efficiently it is being managed. Delhi govt management of taxpayers money is a prime example
In depth u r superb.
Should solve root causes first.
- no jobs, high unemployment
- insufficient highways, roads, bridges, specially in states other than assam
- insufficient representation. Low no of mp's
- insufficient telecommunication coverage. States like arunachal don't even have proper internet coverage other than sub-par bsnl
- no investments in business/service sector. Reason for growing unemployment
- closed borders/passes. No trade possible with neighbour countries. Totally dependent on mainland.
There might be more problems. Unless these are addressed, any fresh competition on the already low resources will give rise to protests. Also, there should be more effort put into solutions to conserve regional culture etc. Expecting the people to emerge out of their "tribal" culture will just lead to us losing an important cultural heritage and legacy
On what ground is the date 24th march 1971 decided? Why not earlier or later?
Bharat Terang well that's possibly becoz two days later Bangladesh became an Independent country (declaration was made on 25th March 1971 nd their official date of independence is 26th March 1971). Before that there was a huge refugee crisis in our country as a lot of people were influxing in our territory from East Pakistan side to save themselves from the brutalities of Pakistani army. With due course of time it become clear that soon East Pakistan will be a new nation nd seeing that INDIAN armed forces crushing the Pakistani forces nd situation normalising gradually a lot of refugees started going back .Now in a move to save the country from unnecessary influx of migrants from Bangladesh from here after as situation has more or less normalised the Indian authorities declared a final date that after this date no Bangladeshis' would be further entertained in our country nd this date was 24th March 1971 . Nd one more reason for not selecting a prior date was that NRC wasn't updated after 1951 nd it would have been a herculian task to identify Bangladeshis' who came illegally even before the crisis .
atulya yaduvanshi ok. Thank you for providing the necessary information.
@@ay6401 Any idea why north east people oppsing CAB n NRC?
@@Suniana085 the people of Assam are mainly protesting against the passed legislation the citizenship amendment act (CAA). it is so because the locals there feel that their culture and resources will heavily be affected once the stay of lakhs of hindu illegal migrants (from Bangladesh) are legitimised according to the provisions of the act . The act provides for according citizenship to hindus, Buddhists , Jains, Sikhs and Christians who have fled Bangladesh , Afghanistan and Pakistan due their persecution in these three nations . The nationwide protest against CAA is possibly because illegal muslim migrants from these three countries have been left out from being accorded Indian citizenship under the provisions of the act and is also because it has been rumored around by certain vested groups (who want to disturb peace and stability of our nation) that muslims already living in India would be forced out of the country during the NATION wide NRC if they don't produce the required documents ( nothing about which is in public domain) .
@@Suniana085 the people of other north eastern India states were protesting for the same concern (as the people of Assam) that is legitimising illegal migrants would distort the local culture and would burden the states' resources.
How the tribunal will know who came after 25th or before 25th?
record of crossing border will be main source
According to the citizenship act and census of 1951 but it is really difficult ....and as sir siad rediculios to identify...
CAA opposed for Assam..joy aie axom
Just Noticed they have used 'The Dark Knight' Score in Background music.
Mr.Sidda and DK and Congress Gunda will issue voter id and bpl cards to these people
Can't believe you, a government channel, are using Hans Zimmer's composition for the Dark Knight. Did you buy rights?
why does it concerns you so much? get the information they are providing
Very informative
🌐What was *Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunal ) (IMDT) Act* ?
🎃Known as the *IMDT Act (1983)* it described the *procedures to detect illegal immigrants* (from Bangladesh) and expel them from Assam. The Act was pushed through mainly on the grounds that it *provided special protections against undue harassment to the “minorities”* affected by the Assam Agitation. It *was applicable to the state of Assam only* whereas in other states, detection of foreigners is done under The Foreigners Act, 1946.
🗺When was it abolished?
☞ It was struck down by the Supreme Court of India in *2005* in *Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India* .
☃Why was the act controversial?
☛The act *made it difficult to deport illegal immigrants from Assam* . It has been alleged to be one of the *main reasons* for the *rapid rise of the Muslim population and demographic change* in *Assam* .
🔍How a person is declared a Foreigner?
☛ *Under IMDT*
●The burden of *proving the citizenship* or otherwise *rested on the accuser and the police* , not the accused.
●Accuser must reside within a 3 km radius of accused.
●Accused is required to produce a *ration card* to prove his Indian citizenship.
●Tribunals made up of retired judges would finally decide on deportation based on the facts.
*The Foreigners Act,1946*
●According to the Foreigners (Report to the police) Order, 2001, made under the Foreigners Act 1946, where *any person* who has reason to believe that a *foreigner* has entered India *without valid documents* or is staying in India *beyond the authorized period* .It shall be the duty of such person to inform the nearest police station, within 24 hours, of the presence of such foreigner.
●Foreigners Act empowers the Indian administration to detain a person until he/she is deported back to his/her own country.
*Source:Wikipedia* .
Avinash Singh IMDT act completely change Assam demography
Ucuuuhic
Karnataka kannadiga should be care full these people will Land in our soil
೧೦೦% ನಿಜ ಗುರು. ಇವತ್ತೇ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರಿಗೆ ಏನು ಸಿಗುತ್ತಾ ಇಲ್ಲಾ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕದಲ್ಲಿ.
U want to be a civil servant..nd u promote regionalism
@@salvatore-zh3rd so what ?
Can't we save our language ?
Assamese is down to 48% in its own state
Bangladeshis won't take time to go to other states
@@depressed2021exactly our country is not an orphanage……..have you seen any case immigrants migrating to China ?……north east people see India as a failed nation a total loser China Pakistan occupied Indian land not the vice versa ,how can we trust a country who itself is not able to protect its own territory
@@salvatore-zh3rdIndia failed to protect north east India failed in many things so can’t trust this dumb ass loser country
Someone noticed Avengers endgames background theme along the video?
Anyone heard Batman theme from background
All banladeshi who entered India must go out but some who hav suffered religious persecution should b considered
What community did he mention at 5:10 ?
Kavya Bhat Tai-Phake
Vamsi Krishna Gedela thanks !
@@kimten007 u expected fuckee
i didnt understand this clause in Assam accord that those whose names were deleted from the voter lists were to be restored after the expiry of 10 years..why? they have been deleted bcz they were illegal immigrant, instead of deporting why are we restoring their names in electoral roll again? why assamese protesters agreed to something like this
Probably the people who came in that time period were miniscule and hence there was a compromise on humanitarian grounds. They were however not given representation rights.
say no to citizenship amendment bill
Leave immediately from Assam or India
Assam accord was a useless thing because- 1/ it has no power and 2/ who the hell are they to give land and rights in Assam to the illegal immigrants from 1947-1971? In these 23 years the damage was already done.
Assam Accord was a fraud
Yes. why the then leadership of Assam Agitation movement agreed the cut of date of 24th March 1971? Because of it rest of India has different cut of date from Assam regarding the issue of citizenship of our country. And thus Assam has to take the burden of lots of illegal migrants by accepting Indian citizens.
I support CAA and NRC and NPR
OM NAMO SHIVAAY
where will you deport these 40 lakhs ? Bangladesh!! .... India will be hammered in UN(UN doesnt recognise cultural rights , but it recognises Human Rights ) and all hopes for ASEAN initiative will turn into ashes ......
annonymous but we can't jus sit & watch illegal foreigners influxing our country....
reality is there is no way forward to deport those,we can only stop new illegal entries.We really need to work out some another option.Constant vigil is the least we can do.
Atleast there voting right will be disbanded and population control measure should be enforced on them.
But that doesn't mean we will just hand over citizenship to those immigrants..
@Alcatraz 》
India is secular
They cant do that
Meghalya court said india should became a hindu Country
But we cant
If me make then ready for civil war in india
#However it was the duty of govt to identify the illegal migrants but SC have to give directions to do so that...& govt and some groups do allegations on SC as judicial activism...is it right??
#Who came in india as on 25th march 1971& onwards now govt want to expelled them,, is it not the violation of natural human rights ?? What was govt doing from 25th of march 1971??
#On the one hand we used to chanting our cultural values i.e "वसुधैव कुटुम्बकम्", the land of peace, MK Gandhi, migrants etc.. R we going away from our values or political vote banks politics have been showing dominance still in a democratic country????
#Indeed ,What r we ???
invincible will very well said bro.
sunny chandrayan
#Indeed i m not the favor of to make our country ,the land of migrants but it the matter of generations not mere of migrants..
What about those who have taken birth, education, language & cultural values of this land??
You are in a position to speak about grandiose gestures towards illegal immigrants, callously dismissing the concerns and problems of the indigenous who are also Indian citizens, because you know you are not going to bear the burden or suffer like the indigeneous people of Assam are suffering, for several decades now. Was it our fault that the Government failed to act? Was it our fault that our wishes weren't respected, even when several hundreds of us were martyred, and many more disabled for life, while fighting for this cause? Then why should we have to bear the burden always? Why is it our rights, our opportunities that needs to be sacrificed every single time?
@@navaneetbaruah3610 well said bro..
If they are born in India,then they should be given citizenship
No. India doesn't have birthright citizenship. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli
born before 1986 citizenship by birth applies
@@AC-en2oz no you are wrong. It doesn't apply if the parents are illegal immigrants. Persons born in India before 1986 whose parents are not Indian citizens but living in India legally are to be given citizenship.
@@bhaskarjyotiborgohain766 Jury is still out on that. However what you said the spirit of that should have been applied to rest of India also other than NE India. Fine reading of citizenship act belies that . Jus Sanguine cannot act retrospectively against Jus Soli . Something cannot be done forcefully at least in places of India not covered by Assam Accord. ( Can't remember when I commented on this channel ) peace.
Haha Bangladeshi Illegal immigrants
hell yeah they r using dark knight tone
copyright ? haha
we opposed caa,, assam opposed caa, north east opposed caa,, joi aii oxom,, go back illigel bangladeshi, bjp go back