The first movement of this kata, where the left hand is inside the right, refers to a Chinese greeting. Note: This greeting appears in many old kung fu movies.
If you want self defense, just practice MMA or learn jiu jitsu, rather than karate (I realized after years of practising karate). I love karate, but...
So, I know everyone sees things from their own perspective. I have been studying the martial arts for close to 45 years and specifically looking at self-defense for over 40 years. Some of this has been an exploration of self-defense classes, military training, and police control tactics (another course I developed long ago). As it happens neither MMA nor jui jitsu (or modern karate) is a self-defense system. Although they offer a wide range of skills that could be used in a self-defense situation, the dynamic is different from self-defense. Put two people together to fight, the dynamic is just different. How to address this issue best, if ever recognized, differs from practitioner to practitioner. As you can see from some of the description of my channel, I have developed a Self-Defense system using the Kata of Shotokan (ShotoryuGoshinjutsu). It involves primarily defending against the most likely, most common attacks. Not sparring, not randori, or rolling, but really taking a step back in perspective and thinking 'what would really happen here during an attack?`. I think I will write more on this subject in the near future.
@@okigi-wo5zm you have to remember here, that I am trying to take a self-defense perspective. It is not a sport, it is not a contest with a highly trained adversary that requires a lot of strategy. When you say they are cooperating, it is true that they are somewhat compliant because you have to start somewhere when introducing a technique or concept and these scenarios are the most simplified, however it is true that some people are tougher or meaner or more determined when they attack and they may not respond as well to some of the defensive strikes or actions. So, at each step you have to increase the level of intensity and chaos in the attack. I do this regularly when I'm teaching these concepts in class, but don't have as much time in a seminar or a quick demonstration. So, examples are more vigorous grabs, multiple punches random punches with the 'wrong' side, whatever makes it more difficult to defend against. In any self-defense training, it is important to stress that you hope the technique will be effective, but you cannot depend on it. You must be willing to continue if necessary.
Brillant!
One of my best bunkais to Watch on TH-cam with Abernethy, Lupo, Froidure, Bilicki and Jesse Enkamp!
Thanks sensei!
I'm addicted to your videos sensei, keep em coming.
Nice ideas. Thanks a lot.
Thank you so much for sharing ! You are a big inspiration !
Very nice applications, thank you very much for sharing !
Thanks for your detailed bunkai in Jion.
The first movement of this kata, where the left hand is inside the right, refers to a Chinese greeting. Note: This greeting appears in many old kung fu movies.
👍
Gracias!
Nice
thank you
❤❤❤❤
If you want self defense, just practice MMA or learn jiu jitsu, rather than karate (I realized after years of practising karate). I love karate, but...
So, I know everyone sees things from their own perspective. I have been studying the martial arts for close to 45 years and specifically looking at self-defense for over 40 years. Some of this has been an exploration of self-defense classes, military training, and police control tactics (another course I developed long ago). As it happens neither MMA nor jui jitsu (or modern karate) is a self-defense system. Although they offer a wide range of skills that could be used in a self-defense situation, the dynamic is different from self-defense. Put two people together to fight, the dynamic is just different. How to address this issue best, if ever recognized, differs from practitioner to practitioner. As you can see from some of the description of my channel, I have developed a Self-Defense system using the Kata of Shotokan (ShotoryuGoshinjutsu). It involves primarily defending against the most likely, most common attacks. Not sparring, not randori, or rolling, but really taking a step back in perspective and thinking 'what would really happen here during an attack?`. I think I will write more on this subject in the near future.
@@DaveInMinnesotaa lot of these demonstrations assume your attacker will cooperate with your defenses. What happens when they don't?
@@okigi-wo5zm you have to remember here, that I am trying to take a self-defense perspective. It is not a sport, it is not a contest with a highly trained adversary that requires a lot of strategy. When you say they are cooperating, it is true that they are somewhat compliant because you have to start somewhere when introducing a technique or concept and these scenarios are the most simplified, however it is true that some people are tougher or meaner or more determined when they attack and they may not respond as well to some of the defensive strikes or actions. So, at each step you have to increase the level of intensity and chaos in the attack. I do this regularly when I'm teaching these concepts in class, but don't have as much time in a seminar or a quick demonstration. So, examples are more vigorous grabs, multiple punches random punches with the 'wrong' side, whatever makes it more difficult to defend against. In any self-defense training, it is important to stress that you hope the technique will be effective, but you cannot depend on it. You must be willing to continue if necessary.