Tiago EV vs CNG vs Petrol - बेहतर कौन?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 มิ.ย. 2023
- Tiago has all three variants of electric, CNG and petrol cars. Comparing on-road prices, we understand that electric cars are more hefty in budget than CNG and petrol cars. In this video, you will learn all the maths about whether you should buy a CNG car or an EV car or a petrol car. I have discussed all the costs and expenses upto 5 years right from buying the car to maintenance upto fuel and resale. Check out this video to know all the details.
If you are in Pune & want to talk about your car or bike on Sahi Gaadi then get in touch via email - shrangar@videoschool.co.in
More videos for you:
Electric Vehicle Ka Kadwa Sach - • Video
CNG का ये कडवा सच कोई नहीं बताएगा⚠😭 • CNG Car Mat Lena - CNG...
Tiago EV Ownership Experience: • Tiago EV Ownership Exp...
New Tata Nexon EV Ownership Review 2023: • New Tata Nexon EV Owne...
Tata Nexon EV Max Ownership Review: • Tata Nexon EV Max Owne...
#sahigaadi #tiago - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
EV vehicle का पिछले कुछ समय कुछ ज्यादा प्रमोशन किया जा रहा है।
जबकि इसके पीछे की सच्चाई यह है कि।
जब 2014 में श्री मोदी जी,
पहली बार प्रधानमंत्री बने थे उसे समय 2014 विदेशी दौरे पर थे,
और बिना सोचे समझे इस संधि पर हस्ताक्षर करके आए थे कि भारत को 2023 तक भारत में कार्बन उत्सर्जन का मात्रा 50% कम करनी होगी। बदले में भारत को अन्य देशों के साथ व्यापार करने पर भारी छूट दी जाएगी।
जबकि दुनिया में सबसे ज्यादा कार्बन उत्सर्जन चीन और अमेरिका करता है।
क्योंकि यूरोपीय देशों में बहुत ज्यादा ठंड होती है तो वहां पर घर मे 24 घंटे हीटर चलता है और कार्बन उत्सर्जन बहुत ज्यादा होता है।
और अब 2023 की डेडलाइन नजदीक आने लगी है। और भारत में कार्बन उत्सर्जन कम नहीं हुआ। इसलिए जल्दबाजी में गाड़ियों में bs4 के बाद सीधा स्कीप करके bs6 लाया गया।
और अब bs7 लाया जा रहा है।
साथी जल्दबाजी इलेक्ट्रिकल व्हीकल के लिए प्रेशर बनाया जा रहा है पेट्रोल डीजल के प्राइस बढ़ा दिए जा रहे हैं।
ताकि लोग मजबूरी में EV व्हीकल खरीदने लगे।
अभी आने वाले दिनों में भारत पर यह प्रेशर बनाया जा रहा है कि भारत में जो बिजली का उत्पादन होता है वह कोयले की जगह किसी और संसाधन से बिजली का उत्पादन किया जाए। जबकि इतना सब बदलाव करने में भारत में अभी संभव नहीं है।
Rajasthan me Petrol 108 hai.
Mere mitra ne tiago ev liya. 3.5 month me 12000km complete kiya. Month me almost 15 din gadi se jana aana hota hai. 300KM aprox total travel hota hai per day. Office me gadi charge karna free hai.
Petrol ki li hoti to ab tak 65k-70k rs ka petrol lag jata. Lekin abhi tak sirf maintainance ka 1500 se 2000 ke beech ka hi laga, wo bhi gadi dhulwane ke aur chote mote service charges.
Conclusion ye hai ki: Agar aapko daily kam hi chalna ho ya fir jadatar gadi khadi rakhni ho to Tiago CNG best hai.
EV unke liye best hai jo daily jada travel karte hain.
What if charging is not free at office and he had to charge it in home electricity or pay to office on higher rate as commercial charges of electricity?
Bahut hi jabardast calculation hai Bhai
Most important factor EV come in AMT if you are comparing please include AMT version in all pertrol, CNG as well.
Not needed. As EV doesn't come in gears. And generally people don't choose AMT.
People who choose AMT, will NEVER watch videos on Milagros!😅
You are right bro
chup rah chomu. sahi bol rha h wo.@@nikhilpathak5682
भैया डीजल चलाई और पेट्रोल भी चलाई और cng भी झेली निचोड़ ये हैँ पेट्रोल is best.. मेरा निजी अनुभव. हैँ.. डीजल गाड़ी ज़ब सर्विस पर जाती हो आँखे बाहर निकल आती हैँ सर्विस कास्ट... Cng मे कार मे 5 लोग बैठ क़र हाईवे पर ओवरटेक मे गाड़ी हाफने लगती हैँ cng पंप मे किलोमीटर लम्बी लाइन.. पेट्रोल मे सर्विस कास्ट बहुत काम पिक up दमदार। 🙏
Bhai sabse badhiya analysis kiya hai apne, pahle laga aap b EV walo se payment leke promotion krne aa gye pr last me sab clear ho gaya.
I have owned several cars during last 22 years. Even an 800 cc engine could never ever give average of more than 14 or 15 km/L of petrol. That is why the whole calculation is flawed. It is more a question of having a great experience of driving apart from economics. Every time you take your petrol car for service, it never cost less than Rs.10,000. You also have to see that the EVs are automatic.
Good input
अभी मैंने पूरी विडीओ नहीं देखी है लेकिन.....ये बात सच है कि CNG में 32 का एवरेज है TIGOR का ❤
एक बात और है...... AC के साथ 😂
Meri runing 50000-60000/year hai ab bolo mujhe konsi best rhegi leni i have also vw taigun jo maine 4 month pehle li h or 17000 chal chuki h
5-6 saal bad jab ev bechne jaoge tab battery technology bhi bohot upgraded aur price kam ho jayega..to tab tum naya battery pack dalwa bhi lete ho to bohot achha resale value nikl jayega
Compatibility ka issue aa sakta hai.
अभी भी गाँव मे जरा सी हवा तेज चले या बारिश हो जाये तो पूरी रात या 1 से 2 दिन बिजली गायब हो जाती है, और गर्मी के मौसम मे वोल्टेज पूछो हि ना 100- 120 वोल्ट मिल जाये गो बहुत है, और बिजली गर्मी मे अति भी है तो 8-10 घंटे मुश्किल से उसमे भी कम से कम 50 बार कटती है
My calculations show that EV , CNG or petrol - all cost almost samr for 50K Km. But if u take 1 lac Km , then EV saves a lot. But again - life of battery after 1 L Km, tyre degradation etc needs to b considered.
If you consider 10 years time, then CNG will be a Value for Money Car. Not EV, because of the New Battery Cost!
Lot of companies r now also shifting tech from Li ion to hydrogen or hybrid or sodium based or something else. Best would b to stick to traditional rather than trying something new which might get obsolete sooner or later.
Petrol pump is luxury in India but charging station is new business second automatic experience in city traffic and last battery replacement making new car no vibration making car body not degradation early in case of CNG and fuel cars
U are right to some extent but 70% u made video wrong there is no comparison of automatic with manual.
People pay more for luxury & automatic is need for these days coz of traffic.
Ice car ki warranty 3 saal 1 lakh km hoti h but chalti utna h jitna tum chaho.
Same ev b 3 lakh km + chalegi Aur battery ke kuch cells hi change honge
Tiago petrol owners will be very delighted if they get a mileage of 17-18 kms per lt. 😊 another thing that you are misinformed is that you don’t need to change the entire battery even if the battery% drops. They would probably just need to change few cells in the battery pack.
And please consider the fact that EVs are automatic - you can’t compare manual vs automatic as automatic ICE cars will have lesser mileage than their manual counterparts.
Right, correct way is to compare petrol automatic Tiago with EV. Apples with apples and not oranges
These Chinese batteries need to full replacement
And do u know the cost of DC motor if it fails?? It's upwards of 3 lakh rupees
@@prathameshbirajdar8778Only the bad cells need to be replaced not the full battery pack.
@@prathameshbirajdar8778DC motors can last 10-15 years.
Tiago EV ka price 8.30 lac hai because of RTO charges ya subsidy free hai but anyway a good explanation
Sir ji CNG waali Swift Tour S chala Raha hu 5 year se CNG cylinder ki wajah se Luggage ka bohot problem hota hai ye point aapne Bataya hi nahi 😮
Very Well explained.. thanks ❤
My pleasure 😊
Bhai ki sari calculation thik hai lekin ev battery ki jo lyf batai hai wo galat hai kuki agar warranty k hisab se dekhoge to fir petrol CNG ki warrenty 1lkh km ki hoti hai as compare to EV
CNG पे मेन्टेनेन्स ज्यादा होता है , पेट्रोल मे फ्यूयल खर्च ज़्यादा होता है और EV मे 5 साल के बाद बेटरी चेन्ज करानी होगी 5 साल बाद महगाई से बैटरी प्राइज 10 लाख हो जायेगा कुल मिलाके सब एज ही है भाई.
CNG me engine ko Kam power bhi milti hai petrol ke mukable
CNG ki service 7000km par aur
Petrol ki service 10000km par hoti hai
Ye keval video me bakwas kar Raha hai isko kush malum nhi hai sahi ae
Bhai 4 sal bad or sasta hoga kiu ki jada matra me product hoga uplabdh
5 saal me battery kyo change karni hogi ?agar karani bhi hogi to bhi warranty me free me change hogi kyunki 8 saal ki warranty hai agar kilometres pure nhi huye.Aur future me technology ki vje se battery ki cost bhi reduce hogi😂
nice style &data.
thx dear.
Most welcome
Petrol and CNG are manual transmission. But ev is automatic, and comfortable for city drive. You missed on that aspect and silent cabin, no noice, no vibration unlike petrol and CNG cars
Extra EMI and insurance premium should also be considered in EV and CNG.
Bro, there is a thing called Opportunity Cost, EV ke liye initially jo 3.5 lakhs de rahe hai wo agar invest karte hai to 10% year-on-year growth see 5 lakh ban jate hai In 5 years). Secondly, EVs are easy to drive in city because it's a genuine automatic (Better than AMT, DCT, Torque converter etc) to wo additional benefit hai EV ka. Third, EV me humesha range anxiety hogi, city usage ke liye sahi hai but it cannot be your Primary car (At least in 2023) future me bhale hee ye resolve ho jaye ya fir Hydrogen cars aa jaye, you never know. Basically, EV can be a secondary car and for city usage it is really useful, else, stick to Petrol (Kam chalna hai to), else go with CNG (Benefit of alternate fuel, jo ki EV me nahi hai).
Ekdum sahi baat hai
Fir to bhai tatal amount ko hi invest kro bcoz 1 year mai 12000 km ki cost apko cab mai bhut kam rhegi apki persnal car ki jgeh or jitna aapko intrest milega us se bhi kam lgega cab mai apka
@@pawansaggu8692 Khud ki car hone ka convenience aapko Cab me nahi milega, so wo bhi ek value add karta hai. Baki jaisi jiski requirement hai waise options vary karenge.
Ev base modal come with automatic sooo i think value for money is ev around city bcoz its like scooty❤
With cruise control
Bhai information bdi zabardast rhi aapki
Mjaa aa gya brother,keep growing bro
Thank you so much bhai.
Bhai aapka calculation sahi hai lekin agar betry wala car ko 3mahine band rah gaya to kya hoga aur chalte samay betry discharge ho gaya to charging time bhi to alag se chahiye
Next
CNG winter ke samay me gadi ka start hona muskil ho jata hai aur har mod par CNG milta bhi nahi agar emargency ho to kya karega aur to aur jo lagej ka jagah cover kar leta hai fir lagej kaha rakhoge
Next
Petrol engine ko 6 mahine band rakho ya fir winter me chalao ya iska boot space dekho kisi me koi rukawat nahi hai rupya ke hisab se jarurate bhi Puri kar Raha hai 😂
Sometimes after 5 to 6 years...no doubt ev battery wil degrade for some extent.....but we have technologies like cell ballancing....if ev is maintained in good condition.....then there is no need to replace the whole battery......only some degraded cells could be replaced.....which u cant do with petrol engines.....
I am using revolt rv 400 from. Past 3 years......driven 42,000 km.....but still now also....if i maintain a speed of 35km /hr in city drive u wil just reach 5 to 10 mins late at your destination......i get an avg of 1% 2km.....so evry time i am getting an avg of 160 to 180km in single seat and 130 to 150km on double seat. in one single chargem.... I have spend 1.4 lakhs on revolt out of which i have recoverde 85 k rupees by fuel saving....
Same is with cars....if you drive nexov EV at a constant speed of 40 to 45 km in city mode...u can get 1% 3km range....on higways also with constant speed of 70km/hr u can get upto 250 ,to 260 km per charge ..... By maintaining wat/hours near by 100...
People dont drive ev cars in ev ways...they just harsly place accelerater like petrol heads....thus thet dont get good avg.......
Thanks for sharing
The battery of EV is required to be replaced after 7 years which is around 40% of the Car Cost. This cost per year + 15% hidden loss per year on capital ( that is the purchase cost difference of the cars) should also be considered while calculating per year running expenses of EV.
पर में ईवी लेने के बाद सिर्फ़ हजार किल्योमीटर थोड़ी चलूँगा
सीधा दो हज़ार चलेगी गाड़ी
क्योंकि पेट्रोल का खर्चा तो होना नहीं हे
जहाँ में बाइक से जाता था वहां भी कार से जाऊँगा
Maja gaya bhai❤❤
Bhai sahi baat boli
Now I change my mind
Kya baat h bhai aapne to meri aakhe khol di super knowledge ❤❤❤
Thanks bhai
Good job brother.. thanks for the great information 👍
My pleasure
Bhaiya Mein Abhi Petrol Car Me Khoosh Hoon. Boot Space Meri Zaroorat Hai. City Aur Highway Dono Me Mujhe Badhiya Experience Hai.
Very useful video 👍 Thanku
Welcome 😊
@@SahiGaadi😢
USA me 10 sal purana Toyota Prius normally 2 lakh km tak chal chuka hota hai. Isliye EV battery warranty ko consider karte hue ye comparison at least 8 se 10 sal ka karte to accha hota. hum logo ko fir bhi pata chal gya EV is cheapest, lekin range anxiety ka kuch nehi ho sakta 😂
I think range anxiety bhi khatm ho jaygi, if range is 500+ and fast charging support
@@SahiGaadi Fast charging 30 min me charge karega, aur uska price bhi agar petrol jaisa aya to mushkil hojayega
You are absolutely correct, thanks.
You're welcome
INNOVATION KE KARAN BATTERY COST KAM AUR BADIYA HO JAYGI AANE WAE 2-3 YEARS ME , BATTERY INNOVATION ME KAAFI IMPROVEMENT HONE WALA HAI . CATL COMPANY NE 10 MIN ME 400 KM KI RANGE KI BATTERY PRODUCTION ME AANE WALE HAI, TATA NE BHI BATTERY ME RESEAH KR DI HAI
Haan par agar abhi koi EV le rha hai to bahut bada amount par kar rha hai na, thoda ruk jaayein 2-3 saal to kaafi bachat ho jaygi
Bro, nice presentation. Appreciated your efforts in detailed explanation.
Please note, I will opt in for EV only if my daily run is more than 40 kms. You have calculated for 60K kms in 5 years. I have S-Cross diesel and i have clocked 1.7Lacs kms in just 5 years. For such usage, i will opt EV.
Note: Its not like battery has lifetime of 8 years. Its replacement warranty is 8 years. Cost for replacement is 5-6 Lacs, which is at this very moment. Think about battery cost after 6 or 7 years. It will be cheaper.
Agreed 100%
bro 20lakhs m ko si Tesla aati ,,, they have quality .. which Indian market haven't.
Great infy.mere sare doubt clear ho Gaye ❤
Thanks
Pure china me 40 % cars electric horahi h to kya vaha ki population ye nahi sochti …. Esa nahi h bro abhi demand bhi utni nahi h jisse aap hisab laaga rahe ho 5 saal baad batteries bhi sasti ho jaengi jab demand badegi
Nice ! your presentation is very good.
Thanks a lot
Eye opener 🙏
Thanks
Wonderful 😊 Amazing Keep up the good work 🎉
Thank you so much 😀
Ev गाड़ी की मिनिमम 1000 रिचार्ज साइकल होती हे उस हिसाब से गाड़ी 1000 x 160 km (min) = 1,60,000 km चलेगी। उसके बाद बैटरी degradation चालू होगी 5-10 % पर लाख km। गाड़ी 30% बैटरी dagradation होते होते ऐसे ही 4 लाख km चली जायेगी। तो ऐसा बिलकुल नहीं हैं की गाड़ी 1,60,000 km या 8 साल बैटरी वारंटी के बाद खत्म हो जाएगी। 4 लाख km पे तो 10-15 लाख रूपये ऐसे ही बचा लिए तो गाड़ी sell करनी ही क्यों हे? इतने लाख km चलाने के लिए एक और नई CNG/ पेट्रोल गाड़ी के और 6 लाख रुपए यूंही बचा लिए। FYI: Tesla की गाड़ी 5 से 8 लाख km चल जाती है रेंज कॉम्प्रोमाइज के साथ।
Thanks for sharing
Very nice
Right answer
Achha
Bhai ne EV ki poori study nahi kari h😂
Bhut bhadia review and clearity by u
Thanks a ton
Sahi kaha bahi sahab .....
Thanks
Bhai aapki information sahi hai but correct karna chahunga agar ev lenge to wo petrol or cng se jada hi run karegi. Ev ko ek tarah bike ki tarah use hogi. Specially city mein. Automatically ev hi sasti padegi.
Haan EV hai to use bhi jyada hota hai local me, but long term ke lie maine logo ko petrol gaadi rent karte hue dekha hai qki unki EV nahi ja sakti utne door
True
सीएनजी पंप हमारे कुछ इलाकों में दूर-दूर तक नहीं हैं। एक लाख किलोमीटर चलाने के बाद सीएनजी गाडी इंजिन का काम निकालती है।
Correct, battery degradation is not 50% it's only 10-15% for 5 years. The missing cost is the EVs tyre replacement needs to be done a little early due to the extra weight of the battery. For ICE cars, there will be engine wear and tear so need to consider that degradation also.
Thanks for sharing this
Such me bhai Aaj finally clear ho gya ki kaun si gadi best h… thanks 🙏
Welcome Nitesh ji
Kon si best hai
Aapne to Sara confusion hi dur kar diya, love you sir...
Thank you Ashish bhai
Battery warranty is 8 years, it does't mean that it is to be replaced after 8 years. Entire Battery need not to be replace, only degraded cells to be replaced. Battery life is @3000 charging cycles. If you use the EV 1000 km per month, it is to be charged 5 to 6 times a month. So for 1000 km a month running, battery need not to be replaced for entire vehicle life.
1,20,000 kilometres whichever is earlier go and pay 5 lakhs for battery😅
@@letitbe3625for battery it's 1,60,000 . And in next 5 to 7 years the cost of battery will also decrease
In smaller towns, it is stop and go traffic, you'll never exceed 15+ kms/ltr in such environment, EVs shine in this speed. Also, the difference b/w (3 cylinder) manual and single peddle driving should also be considered. In few years, EV maintenance would be DIY (coolant change) mostly and battery/cell upgradation outside OEM.
Thanks for sharing this information
Option hone chahiye ban nhi jisko jo pasand ha vo khrid sake
EV are worst when it comes to maintenance. You can't do DIY stuffs it gets software upgrades as well which is used to degrade battery life and still charging as well range is biggest weak points of EV.
Bahetreen Description 👌
Thank you so much 😀
Right said❤
बिल्कुल परफेक्ट जानकारी दिया है भाई आपने
Thanks bhai
Please refresh your knowledge about ev battries. These are capable of 3000 recharges. That would mean 3000x250 = 750000 km. And still there would be battery left with 70-80 % capacity. With this battery pack you can certainly do 7-8 L km.
मान गए उस्ताद🎉
गजब की प्रजेंटेशन थी🎉
आपने अच्छे से समझाया। धन्यवाद।।
Swagat hai
Pls refresh ur knowledge bro about lithium phosphate battery
1 ) life cycle 2000 /2500
2) maximum 30 % degrading life cycle.
3) more than 30 year life with 70% useble.
4) not to change whole battery just change non proper cells and u can use it.
2000 x 150 = 3 lac km minimum life tata tiago ev life and 100 km per chanrge next full life useble.
10 x 19 = 190 means 1.1 / km after 3 lac km it's 2 Rs / km . Wow it's market reality bro. Because I'm using tata tigor ev tourist purpose last 1 year and tention free maintenance.
Bhai how is ev vehicle for taxi buisness??
CNG is Evergreen 👍👍✌️....
If your daily running is within 250 kms then no car is better than Nexon ev Max
I am buying tiago amt cng. Ev jaisa clutch free comfort and cng ki economy ek saath.
Compare for 160000km run
Mostly cars wil get charged at home and malls, offices etc...
We cannot fill petrol or CNG at home or office. So charging station won't be required like Petrolpump or CNG station.
If have seen many videos they all miss this consideration that ev will get chaged at home because only user know that 95% time cars will get charged at home only.
I think for city drive if daily run is < 80 km < 180 km ev is best option.
So far I have changed only once on charging station.
Thank you sir
If you consider 10 years time, then CNG will be a Value for Money Car. Not EV, because of the New Battery Cost!
Good knowledge
So nice of you
बहुत हीअच्छी इन्फो दिया आपने
Bahut-bahut dhanyavaad 🙏
Best video, awesome 👍👍👍
Thank you Manish bhai
Very good information thanks
So nice of you
What about safety of cng car ? Blast ?
Well explained Bhai❣️
Thanks Rahul bahi
Apana sahi bola cng and hydrogen is best
Thanks
bhai thoda sa knowledge bdhao ev gadi sbse jada chalti hai, tesla ev 16 lac 17 lac km chal chuki hai, jo petrol desel kabi ni chal skti hai 5 lac me kude chali jati hai, battery ka price day by day km ho rha hai 8 sal bad battery ki kimat 2 se 3 lac hogi fir ni ho jayegi. service sasti hoti hai, cng car ki life 2 lac km se jada ni hoti hai
Battery mein aag laga toh kya battery replacement ka price ka kya woh batya hi nahi, battery replacement cost of ev almost 50 percent car cost,or garmi mein fire catch hua ev mein uska kya
Battery capacity is 3000 cycles for one battery, means 3000*200=6L kms... I don't think that a person can drive a car more than that... They definitely go to new car... And you compared just 30kms a day, compare if a person travel 100kms a day like bike... I think EV is the best choice in this days..
Thanks for sharing
Very Very informative vedeo🎉🎉
Thanks a lot
Buying used petrol cat in good condition is the best option for saving 💰
Guys don't listen to this. Go for EV or CNG! petrol cars are very expensive to run. For 500km petrol cars cost 3.5k where CNG cars cost 1.2k to 1.5k. so it's cheaper than petrol cars for sure. And maintenance of both cars are the same.
Aap ki presention very good 👍.
Thank you
बहुत ही सही बताया आपने 👌🙏
Thanks
Thanks bro, you explain very well
You are welcome
Supose koi din raat taxi use kare battery vali gadi par
To vo 120000 in one year
I think cng best..bcoz ev ko leke Koi long tour nehi ja paoge charging stations nehi milega toh ? 10 lac invest kar ke only limited distance running loss he...Acc to Govt plan 2024 tak 8000 cng station ho jayega ,maximum city me cng station available jayega.. so i think cng car is best option comparison to petrol & ev for next 10 years.
You have not added the service cost of any car. Which will increase the cost of petrol and CNG
Excellent explanation
Thank you so much
Very nice analysis
Thanks a lot
Nice information bro
Thanks
Cng leni hai to maruti lo best hai
Tiago cng milage 20-22
Nice information and fact
Thank you so much 😀
Good analysis 🎉
Thanks
Petrol ka autometic vehicle ka cost pakro because ev has no gear, registration fee consider karo, difference is only 2 lac, 15000 km chalane ka cost is 1 lc more than ev in 1 year, also you have to change lube 3.5 time and maintenance Rs 15000 in petrol,
Very good explaination
Thanks
What do you say about tiago cng amt
Initial cost jyada as compared to petrol 4.5 Lakhs ki agar hum Fixed deposit karte hai Bank me 2625 Rs interest mil jayega monthly ya fir 4.5 lakhs Mutul fund me growth ho jayenge.
Correct. Aap paisa fixed deposit karo.
Tangein salamat toh kadamon se chal na hi sehat keliye achha hai. 😊😊😊
Right bro
Very good information
So nice of you
Bhai log accident ke case me kya hoga EV battery ka...jyada jor se hua to crush ho jeyegi and then what? we have to replace complete battery or repair bhi hoti he?
Good advice 💯😃💯😃💯
Glad you think so!