@@linitistyou’re so confidently wrong, friend :) Treating indian vs western (diatonic) music theory as differing genres is like calling American football and Soccer the same sport of separate leagues just because both have a ball and two opposing teams 😅
The worst part about this is i had never realized the beauty of indian classical style cuz my school music teacher had been teaching the indian music style in the western manner like stepcase sa re ga ma and i have been living in india my whole life..Let that sink in
There might be two reasons for that 1) Your teacher doesn't know himself 2) He teaches you the simple and most basic one as he might have thought that it would be too difficult for you to get introduction with gamakas
It is probably because we see it from a foreign perspective than the one which we have occassionally seen in our country. Btw their are wonderful Indian channels as well it is probably your pull towards the foreign channels that does not recommend you Indian channels.
@@varunthapliyal8960 Western music evolves and incorporates elements from all over the world. Indian music is the same as 1000 years ago, you're the one living in a bubble.
Indian classical music is further divided into Carnatic music and Hindustani music. The melody of the raag is what makes the difference between the two.
@@TexaSurvivalthat would be awesome. I looked a while and found a few that seem like they kind of fit that mold but nothing that actually fits both genres sadly.
I’m an American choir singer, and when she showed the wobble graphic I was like “oh, like a voice trill or vibrato?” And nothing could’ve prepared me for that scale with your beautiful voice
Listen to Girija Devi on YT. She was (was! 😩) an unsurpassed master of one of the Hindustani styles called thumri. People even called her a Thumri Queen. You may not be able to immediately grasp the beauty of her singing because your ears are “tuned” to the Western scale. That’s all right, just keep listening. Eventually you’ll make it, and once you do - you’ll be swept off your feet. Thumri is considered a semi-classical style, so for you it will be easier to make a transition.
@@memdaletpeynah, mate. That's like drunken master kung fu style. It's fun and cute, but no one will ever take it for real. It's nothing more than curiosity, easy to be forgotten. 💁♂️
@@DrDomich Dude you might not take her style of singing for real because it's not what you have grown up with but in Indian subcontinent, Hindustani singing style is still more prominent. In my opinion, pure Indian classical singing is harder to master than Western Classical.
I love this explanation! I presumed that those sounds were added by performers in the past, it's so cool to learn that they are written into the music!
Indian music has two types distinct and popularly recognised types too 'Carnatic' ( what you just did ) which is more from the southern region of india and 'Hindustani Classical' comes from the northern region of india . there's different sounds from eastern and western parts of the country too , extremely diverse .
@@TzarTsaryes, but I’m sure you haven’t heard one single Indian composer and please do not use an Indian commercial music to make your point, we’re talking classical here buddy.
I sing for an American choir and recently I was in a study hall in the teacher who runs forensics at my school’s classroom. One student came in to practice her forensics thing and she was singing Indian music. It was so angelic
@@hindisikhnewaalaa forensics is a public speaking club (and it’s competitive) and at my nerd school it’s a really big deal during forensics season. There’s also forensic science (which is like dead people or something??)
Forensic science is the use of science in law (often murder cases or other crimes), but the word comes from "forensis" in latin, which is a word describing a forum@@katfoo10yt
@@katfoo10yt ??? HUH? How is that not confusing. Forensics is criminal investigation. It can deal with homicide (bodies, etc) but doesn't have to. Fingerprints, bullets, data forensics also exists. But they decided to name a competitive public speaking club 'Forensics?' Bruh. It does sound cool but without context, that's unhinged
I’m in an american choir too and this hindi composer wanted us to premiere her piece so we learned them (the pronunciation was difficult 😭 but I loved it) and we learned all about different types of scales! I thought we knew everything but I’d never even heard of these, I’m going to go ask my conductor about it!
@@jbtpsd how would a non-indian know the accent of the indian songs? I dont see anything wrong in mentioning that because only native speakers are good judges of their language
When I visited India, I didn't like the music. But in short order, I truly enjoyed it and found it so wonderfully complex and lovely. Thanks for sharing this. It brings back good memories. ❤
You probably didn't like the music because it was trashy and stinging to your ears. As an Indian I can relate. What they perfom today and how they present ancient music is nothing like the spirit of actual ancient Indian music. More and more magic was added in different eras of monarchs. Everything downgraded with the rise of the heavy commercialization of films and music. It's a pitty that young Indian artists don't know how to make the best from both western and Indian music. Considering they are the two horsemen of great music, their amalgamation would be outstanding.
It depends on what was 'the music' that you heard in India. The two classical forms are not the only ones in India. There are innumerable folk music and dance cultures in India, most of which wouldn't sound anything like you've ever heard before. And we enjoy music when can appreciate the pattern; so if a music is entirely new to you, you might not be able to even recognize the patterns.
Yeah, the whole idea of "western" (strictly diatonic, unembelished) vs "Indian" (nondiatonic, embellished) is pretty questionable. Plenty of examples of the opposites of both.
@@ihaka3925 yea, the way we classify ragas and in the diatonic western system, it is classified as scales which is not as diverse due to the absence of having two different varieties of the same note, but still very detailed too is an example. What this video highlights is only a small portion. We can sing a raga's arohanam and avarohanam as straight notes as well.
@@nav_2709 There are multiple varieties of the same note, there's also microtonal within "western music". Indian music is doing the same stuff as western music, it's just known by different names, like the scale in the video. The Indian scale isn't introducing different notes or a different system, it just uses vibrato more heavily, which is something used in western music.
@@raven4442 yes I should've worded it differently, I didn't mean to say it isn't In western music. I just meant it's used a lot in Carnatic and its something students find difficult at first. In no way did I mean that western is any less valuable or interesting. Also the vibrato she did here was overdone. There's specific rules based on Ragas about where and for what notes a vibrato can be given.
I always thought the western music was not that good cz since childhood I was used to Indian music which soo soo complicated and it took me a while to appreciate western singers
I think people should know that Carnatic Classical music isn't the only type of Indian Classical music. There are 2 types of Indian Classical music, namely Hindustani Classical music and Carnatic Classical music and there are differences between those 2 types of Indian Classical music too. Both of them should be mentioned while talking about "Indian Classical music".
I do agree but it's not just odissi all Indian classicals have there own positions including bharatanatyam, kuchipudi, mohiniattam , kathakali , katak , manipuri everything mesmerizes... Probably you understand odissi thus you are more connected if you understand Tamil , bharatanatyam makes you to forget yourself afterall it was the real essence of natyasastra gifted to this world by parameshwara from which all other classics like kuchipudi , odissi all derived there roots , accordingly if you understand Malayalam mohiniattam is something sooo graceful you feel nothing can compete this ,same with the complications of kuchipudi with its property dances of complexity when you understand telugu , it's not good to give justified statement that this is the only thing , India is meant for diversity, we see the lord in diverse subjects and diverse arts that is connected accordingly with diverse geographies , let it be jagannathas odissa , Sri venkateshwara- mallikarjuna Bhramarambas telugu states , chidambara sivagami nataraja Saravanabhavas Tamil state all have there own importance
@@Trayitheindiancore it is ok. He mentioned "for him". he is entitled to his own choice/opinion. but mass consensus is on what you stated which is, each dance forms in India are unique and equally important
@@apocalypse4144 what so consensus in this.. historically, Indian art forms have soo much to study and analyse , they hold there unique position, i said they have there own unique position, this doesn't mean only they have unique position , there may be such deep rooted art forms all over the world, accordingly, everything has there own position.. I was not judgemental , I was more generous, if you think it was more consensual I think you understood me wrongly, secondly your statement saying it has no position in this world was soo offensive, where it derives you know nothing about arts especially eastern arts
Great video, quality content, keep going. The Gamakas are optional, you can sing flat, but gamakas do add flair. There are several schools of Indian music and they put different stress on Gamakas. Rabindra Sangeet is relatively flat, but Carnatic leans very heavily on it.
She isn't a raag bhairavi or sorts. Western one was just decent and soothing, indian tunes are generally intense, some suras will liberate your brain and make you sweat. I have never liked a rock guitar kinda shit music, but what she did was pretty.
Well explained and a beautiful voice. Let me add that those in between notes which are usually tied to each other and then on to the main ones are called microtones.
@@pbilkyes, ours is very similar to Indian but we use many almost voice warbling and cracks into our singing that are different ways of using the throat almost like an instrument, it’s called maqam (at least Arab)
This one video has made me understand what I couldn’t for YEARS. Sadly most Indian TH-cam gurus teach in their native language and I don’t understand a thing ☹️
First time I'm getting the basic knowledge of my own music . Thank you so much P.s. I leave a thankful comment to the creator!! What did I do wrong with the people in my reply section?!!🐒 Seems like I need to read a whole book of human psychology!!!💀👀
@@mirnasrullahkhan6588 yeah bro I completely agree knowledge can only be gained by reading heavy text books. These cellphones, internet are just a means/tools for our entertainment
Yes but we also start learning with your staircase pattern and then improvise and use gamkas according to different raags and moods actually the 7 shuddha + 5 vikrit notes have been further divided into 22-24 shrutis depending on the raags different gamkas are used
As an ex student of hindustani classical music ,the way you demonstrated western music its almost same how i was taught and many others hindustani singers follow the same. Indian classical music (shastra sangeet) Later got divided into two branches , hindustani (used in north ,east india and pakistan). Carnatic mainly used in southern indian region.
This is not the only difference by the way. Even the fundamental harmonics are slightly different. That means inter note difference in harmonics for Sa Re Ga is not the same as Do Re Mi And there are differences. Indian music aims at expression of emotions to the level of devotion. An artist must surrender to the notes of the music and not try to Master it
The vocalists voice control is insane, beautiful. I'd say less a trick stair case and more an ancient hill molded by rain from the lightest drizzle to the strongest storm, the path isn't even but it's still has beauty.
Actually in India their is 2type of classical music- Hindustani classical music and Carnatic classical music. The one you showcased is the carnatic one.
What she sang as a latter part is *not* Indian Classical music, but rather a specific type of subset called Carnatic music. The other subset called Hindustani Classical music is a lot like the former example with staircase style.
I’m Persian and traditional Persian music has something similar. It’s pretty hard to do and is like throat singing almost. If you have heat the queen of the night aria where she does the vibrato and sounds like a bird chirping well it’s similar to that almost. Very hard to describe with words. I think music like this is beautiful, most of Asia has something similar and growing ups it’s Bollywood movies and Indian music I really love and appreciate these sounds.
@@rrajaratnamncrt has recently removed that 💩 🎉🎉🎉. Indians have been in india more more than 40,000 years. There were some gardners during the bristhish colonial period though whoes wifes played around and produced another breeed in india who propogate aryan invasion😂😂
Singing skills + presentation skills + Real knowledge - Awesome
What does it equal
😂i think he means = instead of -@@Aftmost17
MINUS AWESOME?! HOW FUCKING DARE YOU!
@@maximizerboy imo he wants to say it equals to awesome
@@maximizerboy Chill tf out😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
As an indian her voice is angelic
As an American her voice is angelic.
as an angel her voice is angelic
As a voice her voice is angelic
As a ball l only have one ball😢
@@brownerjerry174as a two ball holder I approve
She casually showcased her talent in both music genres
It’s not even genres it’s different musics lol
🤓🤣🤣
Theyre called musical tone scales 😂
@Linitist nah genres is western music would be rock vs pop, this is western against Indian, it's one level higher
@@linitistyou’re so confidently wrong, friend :)
Treating indian vs western (diatonic) music theory as differing genres is like calling American football and Soccer the same sport of separate leagues just because both have a ball and two opposing teams 😅
The worst part about this is i had never realized the beauty of indian classical style cuz my school music teacher had been teaching the indian music style in the western manner like stepcase sa re ga ma and i have been living in india my whole life..Let that sink in
I don't see no sink!?
There might be two reasons for that
1) Your teacher doesn't know himself
2) He teaches you the simple and most basic one as he might have thought that it would be too difficult for you to get introduction with gamakas
Because he was teaching you Hindustani classical music, this example is from Karnataka classical music.
@@shalmalipethe2331 Carnatic*. I think Hindustani also has gamaka
@@hmmlol-yi9kvCarnatic is an English based name... it's Karnataka Sangeetham meaning music that is pleasing to one's ears
I am an Indian and I'm telling you, NOTHING could have prepared me for the Indian music of yours. Kudos, you are amazing!!
She's an Indian Origin
@@MicahBell38Cool
@@MicahBell38 ok? And? They just said nothing could've prepared them for ut
@@MangoTwT So You wanna say That Indians don't expect other Indians to sing their own Traditional songs properly?
@@MicahBell38 they just weren't expecting it lmao
She had the chance to break the internet with this one 😭😭
Had?
Has******
Ting ting ting ting ting ting ting ting
@@sincover5732 💀
@@sincover5732oh c'mon 😂
I'm at that point where I'm learning more about india from foreign channels than from indian channels.
Probably because all the Indian channels are speaking Hindi
@@edmdeathmachine🤣
same ive learned they are dirtier than i thought cool place but horrendously filthy ❤
It is probably because we see it from a foreign perspective than the one which we have occassionally seen in our country. Btw their are wonderful Indian channels as well it is probably your pull towards the foreign channels that does not recommend you Indian channels.
😂😂😂this gave a good laugh thanks bro it's eye opening, maybe many keep this knowledge to themselves I am assuming that way
Maybe it’s just me, but the way “Kampita Gamaka” was said felt satisfying.
First clip:- Naah she American..
Second clip:- Sings like I attended Sangeet program yesterday❤❤❤
Relatable
She’s still American
@@theendurancedoesn't change the fact, she is good at both
True 😂
It’s interesting that “sangeet” and “singing” sound like cousin words from an ancient past
Indian singing requires a crazy amount of agility, while western singing is more about power.
Shut up
So Indians are more agile, while Westerners only want power. Got it.
no
@@dikobayak9910why
Noo Sir...Indians can't sing better
This is freaking amazing, i learned something today! This was illustrated and described perfectly 😅❤
Indian music has trills? Good job, western music has trills as well, it just doesn't use them 100% of the time because it has many other things
@@ekklesiast😂😂live in your bubble
@@ekklesiast Indian music has many many other things as well buddy.
@@varunthapliyal8960 Western music evolves and incorporates elements from all over the world. Indian music is the same as 1000 years ago, you're the one living in a bubble.
@@ekklesiastYeah ok but this was about music theory, not music. India has their own.
Indian music has tremendous variety because of its geography.
Wow 😲 your indian voice was so amazing ❤
That's coz she is Indian
@@dee9ak her accent is...
Indian voice?
@@Epicurousdemosindian voice american accent
US born
@@prashantdhotre she was born in india?
Indian classical music is further divided into Carnatic music and Hindustani music. The melody of the raag is what makes the difference between the two.
Agree. I learned hindustani classical music from a Carnatic teacher and as a result learned some carnatic features.
At first glance I saw “hindustrial” and now I need it.
Carnatic predates hindustani
also small differences in tala/taal systems with different languages in use
@@TexaSurvivalthat would be awesome. I looked a while and found a few that seem like they kind of fit that mold but nothing that actually fits both genres sadly.
I feel special when I hear Indian music ❤🇮🇳🕉️
I feel western when I hear western music 😎🫠
I’m an American choir singer, and when she showed the wobble graphic I was like “oh, like a voice trill or vibrato?” And nothing could’ve prepared me for that scale with your beautiful voice
The skill it requires to do the Indian scale❤
You need to get classical Indian teacher
Listen to Girija Devi on YT. She was (was! 😩) an unsurpassed master of one of the Hindustani styles called thumri. People even called her a Thumri Queen. You may not be able to immediately grasp the beauty of her singing because your ears are “tuned” to the Western scale. That’s all right, just keep listening. Eventually you’ll make it, and once you do - you’ll be swept off your feet.
Thumri is considered a semi-classical style, so for you it will be easier to make a transition.
@@memdaletpeynah, mate. That's like drunken master kung fu style. It's fun and cute, but no one will ever take it for real. It's nothing more than curiosity, easy to be forgotten. 💁♂️
@@DrDomich Dude you might not take her style of singing for real because it's not what you have grown up with but in Indian subcontinent, Hindustani singing style is still more prominent. In my opinion, pure Indian classical singing is harder to master than Western Classical.
Her enunciation of Indian notes stumped me😮❤❤ Amazing
I’m pretty sure she’s Indian dude
Aji lund mera,,, all music are marvels of human civilization be it Indian Western Egyptian chinese etc ,, no self glory..
I just became the 100th liker!!
I love this explanation! I presumed that those sounds were added by performers in the past, it's so cool to learn that they are written into the music!
Oh yes it's very very ancient
Yeah they are very very ancient
This was a cool informative short.
Indian music has two types distinct and popularly recognised types too 'Carnatic' ( what you just did ) which is more from the southern region of india and 'Hindustani Classical' comes from the northern region of india . there's different sounds from eastern and western parts of the country too , extremely diverse .
It's like karnataki I think
Everybody knows there are two Indias..
@@M3ganwillslay except Indians may be.
And may I ask who or what gave u dat wierd idea of 2 Indias?
@@sanatani2864typical idli creating their own happiness
@@rajatsingh1375just stop that racism...she is leftist..Indians don't believe that stupid 2 India shit...
Please sing that Indian gamaka fully. Wooooow it melted my heart ! 🎉❤
Indian classical music is just on another level of fantastic
HAVE YOU NEVER HEARD THE LIKES OF BACH, BEETHOVEN, MOZART, AND ALL THE GREAT CLASSICAL COMPOSERS?
@@TzarTsaryes, but I’m sure you haven’t heard one single Indian composer and please do not use an Indian commercial music to make your point, we’re talking classical here buddy.
@@TzarTsarindian classical music is the oldest music. Come to india i will show you what level it is
Who cares?
@@rinkumoninath903 Okay where can I find you I'm booking my flight now
I LOVE Indian music!!!!!!!! So beautiful!!!
I sing for an American choir and recently I was in a study hall in the teacher who runs forensics at my school’s classroom. One student came in to practice her forensics thing and she was singing Indian music. It was so angelic
The teacher runs *forensics* ? The student was practising her *forensic* thing? What is that?
@@hindisikhnewaalaa forensics is a public speaking club (and it’s competitive) and at my nerd school it’s a really big deal during forensics season. There’s also forensic science (which is like dead people or something??)
Forensic science is the use of science in law (often murder cases or other crimes), but the word comes from "forensis" in latin, which is a word describing a forum@@katfoo10yt
@@katfoo10yt ???
HUH? How is that not confusing.
Forensics is criminal investigation. It can deal with homicide (bodies, etc) but doesn't have to. Fingerprints, bullets, data forensics also exists.
But they decided to name a competitive public speaking club 'Forensics?' Bruh. It does sound cool but without context, that's unhinged
I’m in an american choir too and this hindi composer wanted us to premiere her piece so we learned them (the pronunciation was difficult 😭 but I loved it) and we learned all about different types of scales! I thought we knew everything but I’d never even heard of these, I’m going to go ask my conductor about it!
Why is TH-cam recommending me this regularly, even when iam not a classical music guy😅
Prob because she did a bang up job explaining it from a sort of science way of thinking about the system of it
You're missing alot in music....
@virajnaik6836
Because it knows you have potential 🥺
That what omnitrix do to ben
same
also not Indian
As an Indian, i gota say her voice is beautiful
You don't need to specify that you're Indian
@@gokuuzumaki70why not
u could just compliment that her voice is beautiful, specifying as an Indian adds no extra point there
@@jbtpsd how would a non-indian know the accent of the indian songs? I dont see anything wrong in mentioning that because only native speakers are good judges of their language
@@saulgoodman6710 that would be true if they were, like u said, complimenting the language or accent. they were solely complimenting her voice.
im not indian but big respect to all the cultures and art like this 🙌🙏
Its indian
@@SoniaAli-ft5cb but the person who wrote the original comment isn't.b
@@darren9678 being arrogant and stupid is a trend out there.
Why?
Such an intrigued Indian Classical music voice
Beautiful rendition of the indian music genre. You definitely should do more of those indian music videos 🔥🔥
Since my childhood I’ve watched some of the Indian films)))))) thanx for the explanation
👍👍👍
Truly mesmerizing a voice from heaven itself
You know what that was the best explanation about Indian music 🎶
For those who are confused She is Indian who is lives in America
ID?
You have to go back
@@zebulaun where?
Why would that matter?
@@justadefaultguy cultural background
Beautiful 😌
When I visited India, I didn't like the music. But in short order, I truly enjoyed it and found it so wonderfully complex and lovely. Thanks for sharing this. It brings back good memories. ❤
If you like to listen , I will recommend some songs .
You probably didn't like the music because it was trashy and stinging to your ears. As an Indian I can relate. What they perfom today and how they present ancient music is nothing like the spirit of actual ancient Indian music. More and more magic was added in different eras of monarchs. Everything downgraded with the rise of the heavy commercialization of films and music. It's a pitty that young Indian artists don't know how to make the best from both western and Indian music. Considering they are the two horsemen of great music, their amalgamation would be outstanding.
It depends on what was 'the music' that you heard in India. The two classical forms are not the only ones in India. There are innumerable folk music and dance cultures in India, most of which wouldn't sound anything like you've ever heard before. And we enjoy music when can appreciate the pattern; so if a music is entirely new to you, you might not be able to even recognize the patterns.
Western music: walking up and down the stairs.
Indian music: falling down the stairs
😂😂
😂😂
😅😂🙃
More like wandering along the stairs
😂
It is to note we have 16 swaras in Carnatic music, which adds to the extra complexity. We sing a note by oscillating it between two different notes.
Yeah, the whole idea of "western" (strictly diatonic, unembelished) vs "Indian" (nondiatonic, embellished) is pretty questionable. Plenty of examples of the opposites of both.
@@ihaka3925 yea, the way we classify ragas and in the diatonic western system, it is classified as scales which is not as diverse due to the absence of having two different varieties of the same note, but still very detailed too is an example. What this video highlights is only a small portion. We can sing a raga's arohanam and avarohanam as straight notes as well.
@@nav_2709 There are multiple varieties of the same note, there's also microtonal within "western music".
Indian music is doing the same stuff as western music, it's just known by different names, like the scale in the video. The Indian scale isn't introducing different notes or a different system, it just uses vibrato more heavily, which is something used in western music.
@@raven4442 yes I should've worded it differently, I didn't mean to say it isn't In western music. I just meant it's used a lot in Carnatic and its something students find difficult at first. In no way did I mean that western is any less valuable or interesting. Also the vibrato she did here was overdone. There's specific rules based on Ragas about where and for what notes a vibrato can be given.
@@raven4442 also thanks for enlightening me with the term, "microtonal". That's the word I was looking for.
Western: a a a a a a a a a
Indian: a a A a̶̧̟̒̋ ȧ̷̼̑͐ a̸̢̦̫͆́̑Á̸͜ A̴͙̕Ả̷̱̂Ạ̴̲̣̓͑
Real
indian music on TOP 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳‼️‼️‼️
Lol
@@sadicycandle3226
Ok bud lemme go grab your clown makeup kit for you
@sadicycandle3226 let's not get carried away.
Maan, when you sang Sa. Re. ga. It felt soooo relieving I felt relaxed. Sich a melodious voice 😊
This video is inspired from voxguru indian channel. This is also nice. Just mentioning it for more info for those who are interested.
Thanks man
I always thought the western music was not that good cz since childhood I was used to Indian music which soo soo complicated and it took me a while to appreciate western singers
She sings it so perfectly such an angelic voice
The sheer complexity of indian music which like everything indian has its root in spirituality is astounding.
yes yes complexity is complex
@@davidheisnam743 haha I see it now.
@@adnanshabbar9310 😄
Spirituality is in Carnatic music
Hindustani convey human emotions
Your indian voice is so beautiful
I think people should know that Carnatic Classical music isn't the only type of Indian Classical music. There are 2 types of Indian Classical music, namely Hindustani Classical music and Carnatic Classical music and there are differences between those 2 types of Indian Classical music too. Both of them should be mentioned while talking about "Indian Classical music".
Very interesting, never seen "ti" note, it's called "si" in that notation wich is Italian
Yes, I also made the same observation. "Do Re Mi Fa Sol La Si" are the notes names in Italian.
In French it’s also like that 😊
It's how americans say it.. for some reason.
It's to make every note start with a different consonant.
the reason is because half a step above Sol is Si, also called Le
Same in Spanish
the kind of control and practice that takes is astounding fr,, hearing it is wonderful 🥺✨✨
E
Damn, the Indian scale is epic
The music of Odissi dance style is out of this world for me❤💃🏼🕺
yep, it does not have a place in this world
Yes the the dance and music both are beautiful. I just keep watching their videos.
I do agree but it's not just odissi all Indian classicals have there own positions including bharatanatyam, kuchipudi, mohiniattam , kathakali , katak , manipuri everything mesmerizes... Probably you understand odissi thus you are more connected if you understand Tamil , bharatanatyam makes you to forget yourself afterall it was the real essence of natyasastra gifted to this world by parameshwara from which all other classics like kuchipudi , odissi all derived there roots , accordingly if you understand Malayalam mohiniattam is something sooo graceful you feel nothing can compete this ,same with the complications of kuchipudi with its property dances of complexity when you understand telugu , it's not good to give justified statement that this is the only thing , India is meant for diversity, we see the lord in diverse subjects and diverse arts that is connected accordingly with diverse geographies , let it be jagannathas odissa , Sri venkateshwara- mallikarjuna Bhramarambas telugu states , chidambara sivagami nataraja Saravanabhavas Tamil state all have there own importance
@@Trayitheindiancore it is ok. He mentioned "for him". he is entitled to his own choice/opinion. but mass consensus is on what you stated which is, each dance forms in India are unique and equally important
@@apocalypse4144 what so consensus in this.. historically, Indian art forms have soo much to study and analyse , they hold there unique position, i said they have there own unique position, this doesn't mean only they have unique position , there may be such deep rooted art forms all over the world, accordingly, everything has there own position.. I was not judgemental , I was more generous, if you think it was more consensual I think you understood me wrongly, secondly your statement saying it has no position in this world was soo offensive, where it derives you know nothing about arts especially eastern arts
Great video, quality content, keep going. The Gamakas are optional, you can sing flat, but gamakas do add flair. There are several schools of Indian music and they put different stress on Gamakas. Rabindra Sangeet is relatively flat, but Carnatic leans very heavily on it.
Can we appreciate how beautiful n mesmerizing the indian tune is ..and her voice ❤
Not for people outside India
She isn't a raag bhairavi or sorts. Western one was just decent and soothing, indian tunes are generally intense, some suras will liberate your brain and make you sweat. I have never liked a rock guitar kinda shit music, but what she did was pretty.
Indian music, in this demo particularly, sounds so annoying like a drunkard wobbling along the pavement.
@@dangalladon8417nah
It might be interesting in the context of “that’s what indian music is”, but in the context of western music theory it just doesn’t sound good.
Well explained and a beautiful voice. Let me add that those in between notes which are usually tied to each other and then on to the main ones are called microtones.
And we call them Swarasthanas in Carnatic music 😀
Woah woah, i wasn't ready for this.
Whatever the region of music.. it connects us together.. that's the power of music..
And this is why the Indian subcontinent and middle eastern music to me is breathtaking, such a different perspective on melody and composition
Yes, how close is this to Middle Eastern music, it sounds very similar but I assume it's a little different.
@@pbilkyes, ours is very similar to Indian but we use many almost voice warbling and cracks into our singing that are different ways of using the throat almost like an instrument, it’s called maqam (at least Arab)
Very cool! I thought it was different but I wasn't sure how. I think I know what you mean by cracks and wrabling, do you have any examples?
Very different, arguably better melodically, while western scales are better harmonically, it's all subjective though
Indian and Middle Eastern music is very different
Wow, she hit those notes perfectly 👌
This one video has made me understand what I couldn’t for YEARS. Sadly most Indian TH-cam gurus teach in their native language and I don’t understand a thing ☹️
First time I'm getting the basic knowledge of my own music .
Thank you so much
P.s. I leave a thankful comment to the creator!! What did I do wrong with the people in my reply section?!!🐒
Seems like I need to read a whole book of human psychology!!!💀👀
Short videos are entertainment not knowledge, stop patting your back for everything
@@mirnasrullahkhan6588lol, this one is by 50% and FAR FAR BETTER THAN THOSE Skibidi Toilet Shortz
Are u jealous of our rich culture@@mirnasrullahkhan6588
@@mirnasrullahkhan6588 yeah bro I completely agree knowledge can only be gained by reading heavy text books. These cellphones, internet are just a means/tools for our entertainment
Bro chill... it's 'basic' knowledge
Yes but we also start learning with your staircase pattern and then improvise and use gamkas according to different raags and moods actually the 7 shuddha + 5 vikrit notes have been further divided into 22-24 shrutis depending on the raags different gamkas are used
That was pretty simple, plain and informative. Thank you 🙏🏻
As an ex student of hindustani classical music ,the way you demonstrated western music its almost same how i was taught and many others hindustani singers follow the same.
Indian classical music (shastra sangeet)
Later got divided into two branches , hindustani (used in north ,east india and pakistan).
Carnatic mainly used in southern indian region.
Yeah she explained the carnatic style as Indian music
This is not the only difference by the way. Even the fundamental harmonics are slightly different. That means inter note difference in harmonics for Sa Re Ga is not the same as Do Re Mi
And there are differences.
Indian music aims at expression of emotions to the level of devotion. An artist must surrender to the notes of the music and not try to Master it
This is actually more interesting than I thought it would be. Thanks for sharing!
People in the comments surprised by her "Indian Voice"- her name is Priakhil and she is of Indian origin.
I LOVE how different music from around the world can be while still sounding great and BEiNG music
Aaaa
I love learning
Wowww 😮 that Voice. I'm mesmerized ❤
The vocalists voice control is insane, beautiful. I'd say less a trick stair case and more an ancient hill molded by rain from the lightest drizzle to the strongest storm, the path isn't even but it's still has beauty.
Oh my goodness, the Indian version gave me goosebumps for some reasons. What a great voice 💕
"Western music is like a staircase"
Yeah, a staircase with different sized steps
Well, if the staircase includes sharps and flats, the steps would be the same height
@@dragonlazersure, but in this case, I'm talking about the scale she is singing which is not the same height each time, but otherwise, absolutely.
@@Crazywave89_Gd oh, i get it now
Western music is gu tter infront of Indian music.
@@mangopudding5979no one listens to Indian music bc of how bad it is
That’s a great and a brand new explanation that’s most convincing. And the visuals nail the point too. ❤🎉🎉
Ooof that voice can sing for eternity and i wont be bored
Not Indian but this video brought me a better understanding and appreciation for the music of India. That oscillation actually made me tingle.
I don't want this video to end. Please.
Sounds like heaven's door just opened...wow.. my soul just rejoiced in your voice. It went straight to the heart.
Is it possible to know the name of this singer? That Indian music was so blisful to my ears! ❤
priakhil
HERE BEFORE THIS COMMENT BLOWS UP
Normie spotted @@Kenobi-vf6wz
@@Kenobi-vf6wz Here before kenobi can make an original comment.
That was beautifully explained.
indian music sooooooooooooooooooooo good and your voice
sheat man the indian voice was like a breath of fresh air
She is Indian.
@@idrivesu assuming from her accent , it doesn't seem like so
@@RMCF22xaccents can be easily rectified
Personally my accent changes with the language I speak
@@Emoechaiti personally I tried fixing my "dond you dell whad to do" accent but it never got rectified
@@RMCF22x skill issue
Excellent. She clarified the difference with such expertise. Wow !
She didn't explain anything... there's waaaay too much more to both sides
this is the kind of content that makes me feel like the internet wasn't a mistake
Beautiful trained singer...you've got such a soft angelic voice ❤
"shits street violently"
XD
Racist
@@boxguy-e3r compliments won't help you here:)
@@SvartVargSkog don't want u ppl's validation
@@SvartVargSkog
Shits shits and subways and doesnot wash with water .
Behenji you are extremely talented in both! Didn’t expect the svaras to be beautifully rendered.
nicely explained about 🇮🇳🇮🇳 classic music basic steps and nice voice of yours❤❤❤ from 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏🙏
That explains a lot😢😢
her voice is so pure .
What an amazing explanation 🎉🎉🔥🔥
I appreciate the education; very well done and thorough for such a short video. Keep up the great work.
If there was any award for best youtube shorts video. It has to go to this. Beautiful!!❤
Woow.. the gamakkas were so good whoever did it..👍👍👏👏❤️❤️
😮
Indian music is the best to hear.
Especially classical music.
It is relaxing
Have you ever heard Metallica? They are relaxing too.😂
@@RnR1001 i searched it because of you, its great but sorry not relaxing.
@@RnR1001😂😂😂😂
Bullawood has ruined image of indian music
Cause you are an indian
Actually in India their is 2type of classical music- Hindustani classical music and Carnatic classical music. The one you showcased is the carnatic one.
Her voice 😳...wow
wow... I think I should study music. My coutry is awesome.
Your tone in indian Music feel same like indians Exactly 😊 so nice there is many ragas
What she sang as a latter part is *not* Indian Classical music, but rather a specific type of subset called Carnatic music. The other subset called Hindustani Classical music is a lot like the former example with staircase style.
Ti --> Si .... «Ut queant laxis
Resonare fibris
Mira gestorum
Famuli tuorum
Solve polluti
Labii reatum
Sancte Iohannes»
Also sol, not 'so'
By her voice I say she definitely have Indian origins
I’m Persian and traditional Persian music has something similar. It’s pretty hard to do and is like throat singing almost. If you have heat the queen of the night aria where she does the vibrato and sounds like a bird chirping well it’s similar to that almost. Very hard to describe with words.
I think music like this is beautiful, most of Asia has something similar and growing ups it’s Bollywood movies and Indian music I really love and appreciate these sounds.
There is a Persian song that became very famous in India recently . Look up Jamal jamalo song
North indians came from turkey/Iran areas.. so you see all the similarity in terms of food, culture, music, DNA, look and feel and religion etc.
@@rrajaratnamncrt has recently removed that 💩 🎉🎉🎉. Indians have been in india more more than 40,000 years. There were some gardners during the bristhish colonial period though whoes wifes played around and produced another breeed in india who propogate aryan invasion😂😂
I enjoy indian singing very much. Shreya and Arijit are my default go to.
Are you from the Caribbean?