Dear David, your shows are an antidote to the soulless, CGI infested detritus so common these days. You feed us wholesome, nutritious food, not cheaply made poison. Thank you!
Yea.......... What David said. ☺ Just soooooo very Interesting...🙂 Universe is so full of Wonders, many are frankly terrifying. But wonders nonetheless. Black Holes. Just a part of the Nature of our Universe.
@@ihateyoutubecomments8100 Lots of people do weird stuff like that. If I find something I really like, I save it locally so I've always got it. Then if someone takes it down, it can still be shared and seen.
Thank you Mr. Butler for the well put video. Happy New Year and may you continue to shower us with your intellect and knowledge. I know the past year was tough, but may you continue to recover and keep looking forward. We definitely missed you and your videos.
The Ideal channel for me-so tired of the snazzy cgi, I just want to learn and am thrilled that I still have this hunger at the age of 65! Thank you so much for all of your fine work, it really is appreciated!
Thank you for the years of well constructed, informative, and entertaining content! It is nice to see the associated equations displayed next to the stellar imagery :)
This channel is a source of soothing and comfort for me. That's not to say I understand it - far from it - but I find it comforting amid a sea of anxiety and uncertainty. Thank you David Butler - and thank YOU to the many curious and science-literate individuals watching this content.
This is the absolute BEST astrophysics channel on TH-cam. No one explains the universe in such an intelligent, thorough, yet simple way. Perfect visuals, everything is just perfect. The necessary time is taken so that the viewer can truly understand the topic being explained. No one else on TH-cam even comes close, and I’ve watched a LOT of physics videos, ha. Cannot rate this channel highly enough, just truly LOVE Mr. Butler’s videos. So good. Thank you! Please keep making these!
Thank you, David, for this episode about Black Holes. You described the entire issue related to them perfectly. You showed many of the physical processes that accompany them. I am very glad that you raised the hypothesis about the formation of primary BH from denser centers of matter. That's how I imagine it. I watched it with great pleasure.
I love black holes 🕳 more than anything in astronomy. And love Mr. Butler’s voice & content. Upon seeing this video I clicked so fast….but not as fast as matter within an accretion disk spinning about a supermassive black hole!
Hey doc, I'm several years into your instructional videos and still learning! I'm always amazed by the wonders of our universe in your presentations! Thx doc!
I love to listen to David talk. He reminds me of just how little I know about the cosmos and just what a "nimnal" I really am! Thank you, David, you keep me so humbled 😅
I just subscribed to your channel because I loved the accurate explanations, appropriate illustrations, and on top of that it's all mixed with the most wonderful music.
Amazing:))). Definitely one of my favourite guys: No opinions, no guess work, just plain and simple facts as we know them via interpretation. Obviously all things have half-lifes but still as of today brilliant. Thanks. 11:11
Thanks Mr Butler for such informative and beautiful videos, the graphics and animation helps a lot to get the ideas about how the universe works. I really appreciate and enjoy your videos 😊
Fantastic. As always. I so aspire to have an equivalent stong command of subject matter expertise in my own field. And to be as calm and confident while laying out the facts that support my arguments as David Butler does here.
A lot of people criticize the scientific community when we find out that our original theories about stuff like the early universe and the big bang are wrong. But I find it incredibly exciting. It just means there's a universe out there that is full of new and unexplored phenomena!
Always....... Understand things.... Then understanding new findings about what was once thought solved... The search for Truth and Knowledge. As is the Universe.. Always.
David Buttler, i think you'd love the book "thru two doors at once" on wave/particle duality, if you get the opportunity to read it or listen to the audio. I've vatched your videos for probably 7 years. I've seen all of the full length series a dozen times each. They are both informative and educational. Thank you for all the hard work you put into these
![The Largest Black Holes [4K]](/img/n.gif)
Hands down one of the greatest channels for all things astronomy. The voice, the tempo and the music makes the content therapeutic!
@fudgeholeJenkins lol what a great name
You do know you can't divide by zero? So no such thing as a black hole.
your clearly consumed by your egoic mind set, it your egoic mind set fears most zero/Nort@@whatdoiknowsmith
Reminds me a bit of Carl Sagan's "Cosmos" series, where the music was also just... stellar... sorry...hehehe
@@whatdoiknowsmith The infinite whatever is bending nothing without force🤣
Dear David, your shows are an antidote to the soulless, CGI infested detritus so common these days. You feed us wholesome, nutritious food, not cheaply made poison. Thank you!
Yea..........
What David said.
☺
Just soooooo very Interesting...🙂
Universe is so full of Wonders, many are frankly terrifying.
But wonders nonetheless.
Black Holes.
Just a part of the Nature of our Universe.
Thank you. Don't ever take down this content. You can scarcely imagine how many minds you're helping.
I have breass on my chest and on my back is that okay?
@@pmamonthero6641it’s fine. No worries.
@@pmamonthero6641I have no pity for back titty.
Also, what would make you think he would ever take this down?
@@ihateyoutubecomments8100 Lots of people do weird stuff like that. If I find something I really like, I save it locally so I've always got it. Then if someone takes it down, it can still be shared and seen.
These videos are unmatched. Love every minute!
Thank you Mr. Butler for the well put video. Happy New Year and may you continue to shower us with your intellect and knowledge. I know the past year was tough, but may you continue to recover and keep looking forward. We definitely missed you and your videos.
The Ideal channel for me-so tired of the snazzy cgi, I just want to learn and am thrilled that I still have this hunger at the age of 65!
Thank you so much for all of your fine work, it really is appreciated!
Lllpoyyiijy😅 57:34
Sir, every year I wait for your video of a recap. I hope you last at least 200 years. 😊 listen to you is so hypnotic.
Thank you for the years of well constructed, informative, and entertaining content! It is nice to see the associated equations displayed next to the stellar imagery :)
This channel is a source of soothing and comfort for me. That's not to say I understand it - far from it - but I find it comforting amid a sea of anxiety and uncertainty. Thank you David Butler - and thank YOU to the many curious and science-literate individuals watching this content.
This is the absolute BEST astrophysics channel on TH-cam. No one explains the universe in such an intelligent, thorough, yet simple way. Perfect visuals, everything is just perfect. The necessary time is taken so that the viewer can truly understand the topic being explained. No one else on TH-cam even comes close, and I’ve watched a LOT of physics videos, ha. Cannot rate this channel highly enough, just truly LOVE Mr. Butler’s videos. So good. Thank you! Please keep making these!
David Butler must be protected at all cost! Global treasure.
The content quality and production value are just incredible. So well done!
Glad to see this episode come together. Many thanks
I definitely would not go on the Internet tomorrow if I was you 😢
Uh… why?
We love you Mr. Butler❤ thank you for all you do & hope we get to watch much more of your beautiful work & many more years to enjoy it together :)
Yours is the most informative and accurate channel on YT, far far away any other.. As always, thank you mr Butler
Sending hate from Zimbabwe 🇿🇼
Nice, calm, mature, intelligent video without yelling and crazy visuals. A blessing to the ears and eyes.
One of the most comprehensive, accessible, accurate astrophysical discussions I've ever seen on YT!
Thank you for your outstanding content.
i just came to take a bow to your channel, sir. thank you
That hour flew by 😅 Great presentation, as always!
Awesome post! Happy New Years to all 2024!
I’ve watched this guy many times and it’s always refreshing to come back to him. Enjoy it thoroughly.
Thank you, David, for this episode about Black Holes. You described the entire issue related to them perfectly. You showed many of the physical processes that accompany them. I am very glad that you raised the hypothesis about the formation of primary BH from denser centers of matter. That's how I imagine it. I watched it with great pleasure.
It's been a while since I was so intrigued by a video. It delivers very well. A work of art. It speaks what no one else does with elegance.
"It" is a person 🤔 😉
This is the greatest fall asleep video ever made. Nothing puts you to sleep faster.
We got a PBS spacetime and a David Butler video today. Today was a good day.
I love u man, no one put in sleep like you do.
Of course, I was confident to pause and click like at time 0:03 to make this comment. Mr. Butler is near legend with his physics/cosmology videos...
You have reached #1 groupie status 👍
Hecking yes, new David Butler and just before bedtime at that.
You are my favorite content creator on TH-cam, it is always filled with easily digestible informative content
Please make more long ones ..... we love you ....
I love black holes 🕳 more than anything in astronomy. And love Mr. Butler’s voice & content. Upon seeing this video I clicked so fast….but not as fast as matter within an accretion disk spinning about a supermassive black hole!
Take two tabs of acid and enough MDMA and you can visit yourself.
Hey doc, I'm several years into your instructional videos and still learning! I'm always amazed by the wonders of our universe in your presentations! Thx doc!
Just when i thought you couldnt get better. You step it up again. Well done sir. Thank you.
Great to see you again David (not sure why the TH-cam algorithm does not suggest more videos from you). Please keep making such great content.
The satellite mentioned hear conforming frame dragging is utterly amazing to me
Mr Butler…your presentations are always informative and unique. Thanks for the education entertainment and great music!
I fell into a black hole of deep sleep. I love the subject matter, but these are the best videos I've found for inducing sleep 😮
This is one of the best ASMR videos in existence. I sleep so well, also learn so much
Thank you for going into so much detail and explaining how the formulas tie in. I really really appreciate what you do here!
I love to listen to David talk. He reminds me of just how little I know about the cosmos and just what a "nimnal" I really am! Thank you, David, you keep me so humbled 😅
Thank you so much, was looking forward to your new one! Can't wait to watch it a couple of times before i actually get it in its entirety 😅
I just subscribed to your channel because I loved the accurate explanations, appropriate illustrations, and on top of that it's all mixed with the most wonderful music.
This is excellent. I still can't understand it worth a damn but this is a hell of a try.
Thank you Dr Butler! Wishing you and yours the best for the New Year, and waiting impatiently for your next videos.
Damn 360* of perfection!! I appreciate your work Butler!!!
This content is mesmerizing, thank you, Professor Butler.
thank you for new content! from my favorite cosmology channel - tied with Kosmo!
Thank you for putting these amazing videos together. Best easily-accessible resources for this content that I've found so far. It is much appreciated.
Excellent explanation and presentation, by far the best black holes mini-doc I've seen to a novice like me. Keep em coming! 🌌
All your videos are fascinating Sir , thank you and keep up the brilliant work. Respect 👍peace and love ✌️x x x x
This is amazing. Shut in due to weather and I have been listening to this over and over all day.
Your voice is meticulously soothing
This video clearly deserves millions of views!
This is an amazing overview of black holes, excellent work.
I get crushed sometimes when I hear the “you’ll recall”… I sure do. I love this cat. Back up and pause hahaha
Just found this channel and wow! Your voice and the music is so calming, keep it up
One of the greatest voice ever!
On my 5th view because I’ve fallen asleep every time but I’m interested in the content 😂 thanks for your work David!
Amazing:))).
Definitely one of my favourite guys:
No opinions, no guess work, just plain and simple facts as we know them via interpretation.
Obviously all things have half-lifes but still as of today brilliant.
Thanks.
11:11
Thank you so much for another awesome video.
I once let a man ejaculate on my tits 😅
Looking forward to your 2023 in review video!
Thank you Mr. Butler.
Sir, your content belongs to the very best science / astronomy content on TH-cam. Truly amazing.
He's back!
Thanks Mr Butler for such informative and beautiful videos, the graphics and animation helps a lot to get the ideas about how the universe works. I really appreciate and enjoy your videos 😊
Love the classical 🎻 background music. Nice touch indeed😉
Another in a long list of fantastic videos. Thank you.
DIVID , your videos are the MOST informative videos of all videos on space......and the small things 😁
Thank you
Amazing, was waiting for more of your long form content again! Thank you for this!
It's been so long ty so much mr butler
Yesss another video!
Wow, where has this channel been hiding? It’s great!
This was fascinating. Thank you so much for making this content.
Fantastic. As always. I so aspire to have an equivalent stong command of subject matter expertise in my own field. And to be as calm and confident while laying out the facts that support my arguments as David Butler does here.
A lot of people criticize the scientific community when we find out that our original theories about stuff like the early universe and the big bang are wrong. But I find it incredibly exciting. It just means there's a universe out there that is full of new and unexplored phenomena!
Always.......
Understand things.... Then understanding new findings about what was once thought solved...
The search for Truth and Knowledge.
As is the Universe.. Always.
This is great ASMR!
Complex science and so much learned about black holes and so much more to be learned! Much, much respect to astronomers!
It’s been too long since we had a video! Upload more please!!! 🙏 ❤
I'm am the devil and I am watching everything that you do. FILTH!!!!
I actually asked for such a video 😊 thanks David 😊
Superb video. Just the right level of detail for me, including the math.
Thank you for keep sharing these information sir. You've no idea how much i adore and appreciate your this content and effort. Thank you so so much 🙌.
YES YES YES! I watched so many of this channels videos and with new phone could not remember the channel name and it finally reccomends to me
David Buttler, i think you'd love the book "thru two doors at once" on wave/particle duality, if you get the opportunity to read it or listen to the audio.
I've vatched your videos for probably 7 years. I've seen all of the full length series a dozen times each. They are both informative and educational. Thank you for all the hard work you put into these
Thank you for all the hard work you put into these videos
Great channel! Love your videos thanks David Butler.
So happy about the new video.
Schwarz-Schild means Black-Shield by the way.
Best wishes for 2024.
The legend has returned 🙌
I'm so happy now daddy will let me poo
Ah the best science voice with a big video. Thx u dr David
So happy when I see a new video from Dr Butler
never get rid of the music, please
Ever.
The wonderful symphony and various works of the composers just go right with the Wonders an Beauty of the Universe.
Thank you again, sir!
Always grateful, thank you sir
Thank you for this great video.
Another high quality video, thanks!🎉
Great video again David, love your channel…🫡👍
Great job David, another excellent video ❤
Thank You !!
Great job, as usual !!
Amazing. Thank you so much!
Good information. As far as early black hole formation goes, both predominant theories could be likely. In other words, why not both.
@19:55 is the second D(L) in the Superluminal Motion diagram an approximation due to the small angle, phi?
Yes.
@@howfarawayisit That really emphasizes how small these units of angle are! Thank you for clearing that up.