Although I'm fan of both his big bands I didn't realise what power Brian McGee brought to the live shows - awesome. And Derek Forbes is bass royalty; the band chose their touring musicians well.
Derek Forbes and Brian McGee (both ex-Simple Minds) on bass and drums -- think this is one of the few clips of them playing with Claudia-era Propaganda. Thanks for posting!
My thoughts exactly. Best ever drummer and bass player from Simple Minds, so bittersweet to see them here. Their performance on The Tube was great but this one below is probably my favourite: - th-cam.com/video/2zjnKZ8WqZ0/w-d-xo.html
The backing track for most of the studio version is playing along. There is no keyboard player on stage, so all the synth stuff is on backing, for example.
If people really think this is the studio version they must have been playing "A Secret Wish" on very poor equipment, lol! Propaganda "live" relied on BACKING TAPES, Michael Mertens is playing bloody MARIMBAS instead of keyboards, and since their sound is very much keyboard based, he wouldn't have been able to duplicate is anyway! The vocals are very much LIVE! (and I hesitate to use the word FLAT since I love Claudia!)
@@morkygorky That's the studio vocal with a little bit of live on top. It sounds like a blend. There are other songs from this show where brucken is singing live but this isn't one of them.
@@NashSpaceRocket Thanks for pointing that out (I guess I was focusing more on their dancing, lol) the vocal does sound exactly like the album (and that one verse wouldn't be hard to sing live) - but I forgive her , she was a very young and inexperienced singer, and Propaganda was indeed a studio project more than a live band anyway , but love them just as much! The 1985 concert that was supposed to happen in Copenhagen was cancelled :-(( Can't wait for Claudias new projects xoxo
Well, simply because the 90's were clearly better hands down without further dispute......lmao l j/k but all decades windows of time seem to have a kind of specific series of likely forgotten instances or "magic of the moments" obscurely imbued within each one of our personal and collective experiences.
Having been in high school when the Second British Invasion began--yes, I know Propaganda are German, but the German artists rode this wave--I've always thought that it was due to the feel-good era of Reagan and Thatcher. Now, I'm American and never lived in England, so I'm not the best to comment on this but, these days I hear Margaret Thatcher being widely vilified. And Reagan isn't regarded much better here in the States. And yet, in his bid for re-election, the ONLY state Reagan did not win was Minnesota, the home of his opponent Walter Mondale, and he lost by only 0.18%! That is unfathomable today. I know the parliamentary system in England is different in that the party in power chooses the prime minister, but Thatcher was Prime Minister until 1990. So, to people who think Reagan and Thatcher were so terrible, well, of course no leader will be everything to everybody, and there were things Reagan did that tarnished his legacy. Nevertheless, the election results during that time period speak for themselves. Nobody was being forced to vote for them, yet the majority did.
Look, I have no problem with the fact that the only 'live' part of this is contributed by the guitarist. It sounds and looks great. BUT Brian McGee's red tank top. I can't believe Paul Morley let that one through. For shame.
Has the uploader blended the real live audio with the studio? I notice some heavy editing overlap at circa 1:31... And I have also heard this live version before without the strong presence of the studio version. Not simply a case of backing tracks. Why this was done is beyond me.
Lasse Mann no no, seriously, I think this is an edited upload. Backing tracks were part of Propaganda’s live gigs (mostly the synth parts and sequencer triggers) but this upload is not 100% audio from that gig.
![🎤 ไปกันต่อออ! จับฉลากร้องเพลง x P’ #XXSIVK [EP.2] (1/2) เพลงของใครจึ้งสุดน้าา 💓🎤 #MXFRUIT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mLI_K0sAS4o/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m seeing myself with 16 hearing it for the first time. How lucky I am to have lived fully this great music and time.
Crimnally underrated band. Outrageously good
Claudia!! The voice of 'Propaganda' and her strange beauty. Epic song!
Yes indeed though with her hair she reminds me of Woodstock from peanuts
Is out of this world
Although I'm fan of both his big bands I didn't realise what power Brian McGee brought to the live shows - awesome. And Derek Forbes is bass royalty; the band chose their touring musicians well.
When Claudia sings, I get goosebumps. Is this normal for a 56 year old Aussie guy?
Nope. Her voice is extraordinary, still is
I miss dancing like that!
soundtrack to some of the happiest days i can remember.
Haunting. Claudia has an amazing voice❤
One of the best group of the 80's with mecano
Sound fantastico che sconfigge il tempo
th-cam.com/video/m5z0L0LeO_I/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=LuckasOZ do you remember some sountrack of this scene? xD
Derek Forbes and Brian McGee (both ex-Simple Minds) on bass and drums -- think this is one of the few clips of them playing with Claudia-era Propaganda. Thanks for posting!
My thoughts exactly. Best ever drummer and bass player from Simple Minds, so bittersweet to see them here. Their performance on The Tube was great but this one below is probably my favourite: -
th-cam.com/video/2zjnKZ8WqZ0/w-d-xo.html
Impeccable live performance that lives up to the studio version.
I think it is the studio version :(
The backing track for most of the studio version is playing along. There is no keyboard player on stage, so all the synth stuff is on backing, for example.
If people really think this is the studio version they must have been playing "A Secret Wish" on very poor equipment, lol!
Propaganda "live" relied on BACKING TAPES, Michael Mertens is playing bloody MARIMBAS instead of keyboards, and since their sound is very much keyboard based, he wouldn't have been able to duplicate is anyway!
The vocals are very much LIVE! (and I hesitate to use the word FLAT since I love Claudia!)
@@morkygorky That's the studio vocal with a little bit of live on top. It sounds like a blend. There are other songs from this show where brucken is singing live but this isn't one of them.
@@NashSpaceRocket Thanks for pointing that out (I guess I was focusing more on their dancing, lol) the vocal does sound exactly like the album (and that one verse wouldn't be hard to sing live) - but I forgive her , she was a very young and inexperienced singer, and Propaganda was indeed a studio project more than a live band anyway , but love them just as much! The 1985 concert that was supposed to happen in Copenhagen was cancelled :-((
Can't wait for Claudias new projects xoxo
Fantastic, Amazing,Divine Voice👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻🕺🕺🕺💃💃💃
why were the 80's so good I want to go there:):)
Well, simply because the 90's were clearly better hands down without further dispute......lmao l j/k but all decades windows of time seem to have a kind of specific series of likely forgotten instances or "magic of the moments" obscurely imbued within each one of our personal and collective experiences.
@@MysTeri0usMatT7 thank you
Having been in high school when the Second British Invasion began--yes, I know Propaganda are German, but the German artists rode this wave--I've always thought that it was due to the feel-good era of Reagan and Thatcher. Now, I'm American and never lived in England, so I'm not the best to comment on this but, these days I hear Margaret Thatcher being widely vilified. And Reagan isn't regarded much better here in the States. And yet, in his bid for re-election, the ONLY state Reagan did not win was Minnesota, the home of his opponent Walter Mondale, and he lost by only 0.18%! That is unfathomable today. I know the parliamentary system in England is different in that the party in power chooses the prime minister, but Thatcher was Prime Minister until 1990. So, to people who think Reagan and Thatcher were so terrible, well, of course no leader will be everything to everybody, and there were things Reagan did that tarnished his legacy. Nevertheless, the election results during that time period speak for themselves. Nobody was being forced to vote for them, yet the majority did.
I mean this in a good way; this is the most-'80's thing I have seen (and heard) in a long, long time. 🙂
3:15 Increible!!!! goku no es el unico super saijayin, este misterioso joven ha cortado a freezer con mucha facilidad!!! ¿Quien sera.......? 3:45
Big thanks for giving this to us
1985 a 10.10.2019 quem ouve viagem no tempo ....
tempo bom 1985 á quê saudade sexta 22 de novembro de 2019
Best track on the album.
so great love this band so much later after the event
Perfect!!!
Trunks vs Freeza
Love the look of Claudia ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Wonderful
EXCELENTE
hey''' thank you for this ...
Acabo de ver este Grupo, despues de 25 años, por la epica escena de Trunks y freezer, buena adaptación y s compagino con el momento.
3:08 Freezer : ahhhhhh locutor y presentador : quién es este joven quien será?
Jajaja usaron remakes de tracks de propaganda para esos episodios
Nada le costo al japonés dar regalías tendríamos unas de las mejores canciones de dbz
@@EnriqueHerrera-rr6ck yo tengo la teoría de que yamamoto pensó que dragon ball no salía de Japón
@@damiancooper6186 creo que si lástima porque hubiera sido de los mejores soundtracks
Gitarren kommen in dem Song gar nicht vor, aber Gitarren waren in den 80ern mega in.
Incredible power in this tune. Claudia's vocals are unique. ZTT captured this in their studio production.
FREEEEEEZAAAAAAA
We need moar cowbell!!!!
More cowbell!
Look, I have no problem with the fact that the only 'live' part of this is contributed by the guitarist. It sounds and looks great. BUT Brian McGee's red tank top. I can't believe Paul Morley let that one through. For shame.
What ARE you talking about?
More COWBELL !!
Lo mejor PROPAGANDA
Fantastic music much better than todays bullshit
Como suena,MAMITAAA ESPECTACULAR ✌👏👏👏❤👍🇦🇷
Has the uploader blended the real live audio with the studio? I notice some heavy editing overlap at circa 1:31... And I have also heard this live version before without the strong presence of the studio version. Not simply a case of backing tracks. Why this was done is beyond me.
this was a "trick" many used back in the day. no audience,just a stage but live performance
Lasse Mann no no, seriously, I think this is an edited upload. Backing tracks were part of Propaganda’s live gigs (mostly the synth parts and sequencer triggers) but this upload is not 100% audio from that gig.
@@FrankNFurter1000 Yes this is a mix of live and studio versions... for my own satisfaction... Best of both worlds.
03:07 .... !!!!!!
Derek Forbes of Simple mind base guitar..fuck me..Epic
Susan takes you near the river on a fryday . gr. JETORI
With a blunt traveling...
Needs more cowbell
Why no shots of the keyboard player? Guess its backing... like most of the sound. :(
derek forbes ??
The Girls don't wear Pantys every Gig!
Chase ?wasn't that an American Hero?