Trust Palaye Royale to have the most aesthetically pleasing music videos, love love love the vibe of this. Teenager me is screaming cuz of the NIN cover, this was my jam back then
I was 11 when this song came out. I was still into this music though. Nirvana, NIN, Tool, etc. I’m always curious about the younger generations though…how did you happen upon this song? When I was a teen we used a chat room on the Nine Inch Nails website. I met & got to know so many random NIN fans and even had one guy call me from his land line from across the country. Anyway, his mom called later & was very angry & said that her son was not to call me anymore. It was because it cost her a fortune every time he called long distance.
@@aliciamarie9704 Well my mother is born in the late seventies so she was a teen when most of these bands were popular so I have her to thank for my love of rock and metal. I'm in my twenties and I think most people my age that listen to "older bands" probably found them through their parents or other family members, but hey what do I know lol
Same except I was like 2 Lolol I remember cus my cousin saw the unedited version in the 90s. And she was taking care of me. I remember the beat and everything that cemented my luv of rock / metal/ alternative etc. I was hooked. I would hum it n she got in trouble with my mum , so my fam would play like pop n Caribbean music to try n stop me from saying some of the words but my grandma would just let me say it Lolol. She said it’s better I get it out and say it, then when I’m older I wouldn’t say it as much takes out the fun of it. Which was basically true lol. Luv Caribbean music buttt NIN was my intro to the world of rock n without it, I wouldn’t b me. This is the best cover version I think. Fucking luvvvv remys voice.
@@Mistress-Noir That’s a wise gran. The less of a fuss made, the less a child will do it (usually). My mum had that philosophy by the time I came along & it worked. I’m cracking up imagining a wee girl singing these lyrics though 😆 omg!
@@Bethsabee_Sheba_Newrose lol I know right, my toddler self jumpin up n down and “trying” to sing, singing lyrics tht I thought were just fun. I would love to see the look on my family’s faces again, Lolol. And yea I think it works, when I have a kid I’d do the same thing my grandma did. After lik 6 kids I think she got it down pretty good Lolol
I really don't like covers. They are usually trying to sound too much like the original or change the original so much it's not the same song anymore. This kinda hits in the right spots though...
I guess I'll be the first to say that I LOVE their outfits in this. Remington and Emerson look straight out of a Tim Burton creation, and Sebastian looks AMAZING in that skirt. I've never been a fan of this song until now! Definitly gives some Marilyn Manson vibes, but it's so unequivocally Palaye 🖤
Give respect. Their original music is fucking incredible. Thought feeling emotional and they got that Victorian gypsy glam style . Love it. Everything else now is down tuned and all sounds the same . Remember you get credit for style!!!!
every element of this music video is just so aesthetically pleasing! the lighting the outfits the vibe of the song it all just melts together, honestly I think it did the OG song justice, there's just something about Rem's vocals that just pulls the whole song together IMO
Trent Reznor meets American Horror Story The og is a sexy song and this is such a primal take on it. Well done Palaye. Everything I’ve heard from Sextape is a banger
This band is the epitomy of epic....writing, surfing genres, artistic genius....and no live band ive ever experienced can hold a torch to them....and im 54, ive seen alot
Several boomers criticizing this version but it gives a different tone but just as perverse as the original, the message remains the same, a more current tone, a tone just as sick. It's the best ver in covers of this song. Let's be real, U can't live angry with all the remakes and everything current.
Shit, he can’t, he’ll return it all toooo unobtrusively for real. Sick Sad World’s not ready for such healthy things...if only Remington would be gentle as fuck
This just made me fall in love with my dream to become an costume designer even more. Thank you guys so much for this awesome cover and the inspiration you're giving me with everything you do! Also love Rem flipping his middlefingers up to the sky after singing "you get me closer to god" at 1:30 lol
Serpentine crawling not only coming out in a lyrical gut wrench but the way in which Remington can encapsulate the theme of the song, is brilliant. Darkness seeping out of him, Emerson and Sebastian. Beautiful and inspirational.
Usually I don't have any faith in 'Closer' covers because most of the time they try to hard to be sexy and completely forget the point of desperation the song has because after all it talks about s3ggS yeah but expressing it from someone addicted to it, someone who is SICK in the head and craves it, and has withdrawals of it, someone's actual vice, not someone whos just horn knee, so I don't like when they just try to be sexy and completely forget that unhinged (and I believe very important) side the song has. But THIS completely embodied that, this was the perfect cover for this song and the only one that does it justice from the ones I've heard. This was next level!
This is the best example of perfectly remastering a song and breaking the original into pieces and smothering it in disgusting sexy sickness!!! Never underestimate these guys. They deliver on another level!!
They're remaking everything... to reliive the same spirit as the original. Why it's all the hype. Ppl like it or dislike it but the new age creativity "upgrade" is endless. It's fun to experimeeent.
First Adam Lambert, now Palaye. My ears keep getting gifted with perfect covers of this amazing song and I'm HERE FOR ITTT 😍 also, the aesthetics of this video are incredible 😳🤩
As a hardcore NIN fan, I never really liked Closer because it was so damned overplayed, but big kudos to this cover. What a way to breathe new life into this tired track. They made it their own while paying homage to a great musical pioneer in the Industrial genre.
Извините, но вот я расстроилась, что нигде не написано, что это кавер. Я тоже безумно люблю NIN, и в России мало кто знает Трента. И представила, что если эта песня получит большую популярность как Hurt Джонни Кеша, то опять никто не узнаёт, что мотив и текст принадлежат Тренту. Для меня это грустно, и я даже чуть не заплакала. Или это нормально, что не подписали автора?
excuse me while i pick my jaw off the floor, damn nailed it again guys, remington your voice is so uniquely amazing, so good, and this video infinity out of infinity, holy wow, hot video
@@Devik666Nothing ever will be but this is a pretty awesome cover! When I saw the title I was like… wait…. No way… Are they really…? Yup, they’re gonna cover NIN’s most infamous song and I’m here for it! 😂
Trent Reznor is god! My all time fav artist. Many have tried to redo this song, and this is the best remake I have heard. The visuals and vocals are amazing. It has been a very long time since I found a new band I liked , I am definitely liking this band. Great job.
How does this not have more likes ??? I have been a fan for years now and holy sh*t this is amazing. I want to see this in concert!! Thank you for blessing us with this amazing Master Piece. I feel like I am in a Silent Hill movie but like in a hot way.
Only found out now that this is a cover and all I have to say is this: This is an amazing song compared to the original. The original is boring as it lacks the aggressive element but they mastered it here. Everything builds itself and it is beautiful.
Wow, this was absolutely incredible! The visual aspects are unique and I wasn’t expecting this kind of artistic interpretation of this song. It kind of reminded me of Manson in a way as well. You guys did an amazing job like always!
Sellout reznor most likely will. Sometimes I wonder if he's been a total poser this whole entire time. This song it terrible. It was a good song originally but now everyone has played it to death. Rip closer
That’s crazy, last year I thought “it would be so cool if they did a cover” BUT I THOUGHT IT WOULD NEVER HAPPEN WTF ?! Also, Yulia’s work is amazing, didn’t recognized her style at first but I was very pleased when I checked who directed the video 😌
i was the same until this. i think everybody has certain songs that must never be touched & for me this one was on that list but i can't deny, they really did an amazing job sonically & aesthetically here. i never wanna hear a cover of any song from Pretty Hate Machine, was/am obsessed with that record.
Nah nah see I love me some sleep token and etc but my babies Palaye came back with this- it got me having shivers down my spine!!! Remington was so dirty with this!!!🩵🩵👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
New Palaye Royale album 'Death or Glory' out August 30th
Pre-order: sumerian.lnk.to/deathorglory
Didn't think anyone could really pull off a cover of this song, I must say I'm impressed. NIN is a lifelong favorite.
Trust Palaye Royale to have the most aesthetically pleasing music videos, love love love the vibe of this. Teenager me is screaming cuz of the NIN cover, this was my jam back then
I was 11 when this song came out. I was still into this music though. Nirvana, NIN, Tool, etc. I’m always curious about the younger generations though…how did you happen upon this song?
When I was a teen we used a chat room on the Nine Inch Nails website. I met & got to know so many random NIN fans and even had one guy call me from his land line from across the country. Anyway, his mom called later & was very angry & said that her son was not to call me anymore. It was because it cost her a fortune every time he called long distance.
@@aliciamarie9704 Well my mother is born in the late seventies so she was a teen when most of these bands were popular so I have her to thank for my love of rock and metal. I'm in my twenties and I think most people my age that listen to "older bands" probably found them through their parents or other family members, but hey what do I know lol
Same except I was like 2 Lolol I remember cus my cousin saw the unedited version in the 90s. And she was taking care of me. I remember the beat and everything that cemented my luv of rock / metal/ alternative etc. I was hooked. I would hum it n she got in trouble with my mum , so my fam would play like pop n Caribbean music to try n stop me from saying some of the words but my grandma would just let me say it Lolol. She said it’s better I get it out and say it, then when I’m older I wouldn’t say it as much takes out the fun of it. Which was basically true lol. Luv Caribbean music buttt NIN was my intro to the world of rock n without it, I wouldn’t b me. This is the best cover version I think. Fucking luvvvv remys voice.
@@Mistress-Noir That’s a wise gran. The less of a fuss made, the less a child will do it (usually). My mum had that philosophy by the time I came along & it worked. I’m cracking up imagining a wee girl singing these lyrics though 😆 omg!
@@Bethsabee_Sheba_Newrose lol I know right, my toddler self jumpin up n down and “trying” to sing, singing lyrics tht I thought were just fun. I would love to see the look on my family’s faces again, Lolol. And yea I think it works, when I have a kid I’d do the same thing my grandma did. After lik 6 kids I think she got it down pretty good Lolol
THE VISUALS FOR THIS IS DRIVING ME INSANE.
As a NIN fan, you guys gave this SO much justice!!! I sat in awe listening to this. G**damn masterpiece, well done!!
I agree so well done!
I didn't realize how much I needed this cover until now. YES to everything about this.
cover?
Closer by Nine inch Nails
@@Dev-zq8wl gracias 🙂
Have you heard the Asking Alexandria version? imo, it's better than this.
no way Maria Brinks version is the BEST
@@javierdavidromero4825
Hearing this song live with cranked bass and strobe lights would do things to me man
I love the aesthetic and ambiance of this EP, they are the absolute best
I usually hate covers….but his voice was made for this song 😍🥵
Agree, his voice is so sexy 🥵
Honestly this is a pretty good cover ☺️
who's the original?
@@KittyLovesGlovernine inch nails
I really don't like covers. They are usually trying to sound too much like the original or change the original so much it's not the same song anymore. This kinda hits in the right spots though...
I guess I'll be the first to say that I LOVE their outfits in this. Remington and Emerson look straight out of a Tim Burton creation, and Sebastian looks AMAZING in that skirt.
I've never been a fan of this song until now! Definitly gives some Marilyn Manson vibes, but it's so unequivocally Palaye 🖤
Q1
D2333
I LOVE PALAYE AND MARYLIN MANSON 🤩🤩
Give respect. Their original music is fucking incredible. Thought feeling emotional and they got that Victorian gypsy glam style . Love it. Everything else now is down tuned and all sounds the same . Remember you get credit for style!!!!
@@shermantracy2629 I agree! I'm a huge fan of them and love their original stuff as well! :)
every element of this music video is just so aesthetically pleasing! the lighting the outfits the vibe of the song it all just melts together, honestly I think it did the OG song justice, there's just something about Rem's vocals that just pulls the whole song together IMO
Trent Reznor meets American Horror Story
The og is a sexy song and this is such a primal take on it. Well done Palaye. Everything I’ve heard from Sextape is a banger
Trent Reznor father of American horror Story. 1994 Closer.
This band is the epitomy of epic....writing, surfing genres, artistic genius....and no live band ive ever experienced can hold a torch to them....and im 54, ive seen alot
It's like Nine Inch Nails and Marilyn Manson had a baby
NIN and manson did have a baby: the first three marilyn manson albums.
Several boomers criticizing this version but it gives a different tone but just as perverse as the original, the message remains the same, a more current tone, a tone just as sick. It's the best ver in covers of this song. Let's be real, U can't live angry with all the remakes and everything current.
pretty sure you mean gen x :) also i love this version
Been looking at the comments and I don't see any boomers complaining. Maybe your just assuming they will? I'm gen x and I love this cover
@daemonionx you can still be aborted.
@@MyXyle666there are but they usually get few likes
Lol boomers 😂😅 idk if boomers were listening to nine inch nails lol 🤣
The girl inside of me who used to write fan fiction of Remington is screaming rn
User please
THATS SO REAL. CAUSE SAME.
@@i_spyder900 USERS! *USERNAMES!*
Okay, hear me out, Remington as The Crow.
Yes.
Oh my god hiii@@PalayeRoyale
Definitely!
@@PalayeRoyale God, yes.
Shit, he can’t, he’ll return it all toooo unobtrusively for real. Sick Sad World’s not ready for such healthy things...if only Remington would be gentle as fuck
This just made me fall in love with my dream to become an costume designer even more. Thank you guys so much for this awesome cover and the inspiration you're giving me with everything you do!
Also love Rem flipping his middlefingers up to the sky after singing "you get me closer to god" at 1:30 lol
May you achieve your dream!
@@corncobbob2326thank you! I just graduated this week so that I can now concentrate on applying to college :)
Remington charisma is something with something... The guys are on top as always!
YOU WANNA WHAT???????????????????
I mean I'm down ngl lmao
I would let him tbh I’m of age 😂
I'd accept tbh
hey juice
haiiiiii :3333@@babbibabbs7203
Serpentine crawling not only coming out in a lyrical gut wrench but the way in which Remington can encapsulate the theme of the song, is brilliant. Darkness seeping out of him, Emerson and Sebastian. Beautiful and inspirational.
Palaye Royale is a group of great quality, their music is really great, their aesthetic is sublime
Usually I don't have any faith in 'Closer' covers because most of the time they try to hard to be sexy and completely forget the point of desperation the song has because after all it talks about s3ggS yeah but expressing it from someone addicted to it, someone who is SICK in the head and craves it, and has withdrawals of it, someone's actual vice, not someone whos just horn knee, so I don't like when they just try to be sexy and completely forget that unhinged (and I believe very important) side the song has.
But THIS completely embodied that, this was the perfect cover for this song and the only one that does it justice from the ones I've heard. This was next level!
I'm so glad I decided not to sleep so I can listen to this banger on repeat.
Same. Oversleeping and being late the next day was totally worth it
This is the best example of perfectly remastering a song and breaking the original into pieces and smothering it in disgusting sexy sickness!!! Never underestimate these guys. They deliver on another level!!
They knew exactly what they were doing with this 🔥hehehehehe 😊
Best cover of this song ever!!!
I'm obsessed with this music video. It's just SO GOOD
I feel like this cover would go perfect in the new "The Crow" movie coming out.
Agreed
There re making the crow ?
They're remaking everything... to reliive the same spirit as the original. Why it's all the hype. Ppl like it or dislike it but the new age creativity "upgrade" is endless. It's fun to experimeeent.
OMG YES
@@dustyduz Bill Skarsgard is Eric Draven
Yes. This is an absolute unequivocal yes. Every note, word, tone, vibe, spot on. This is everything I would expect in a cover.
First Adam Lambert, now Palaye. My ears keep getting gifted with perfect covers of this amazing song and I'm HERE FOR ITTT 😍 also, the aesthetics of this video are incredible 😳🤩
I love the whole thing but like, Remington's hair looks gorgeous, I have that weird overwhelming desire to put a flower crown on his head...
As a hardcore NIN fan, I never really liked Closer because it was so damned overplayed, but big kudos to this cover. What a way to breathe new life into this tired track. They made it their own while paying homage to a great musical pioneer in the Industrial genre.
Извините, но вот я расстроилась, что нигде не написано, что это кавер. Я тоже безумно люблю NIN, и в России мало кто знает Трента. И представила, что если эта песня получит большую популярность как Hurt Джонни Кеша, то опять никто не узнаёт, что мотив и текст принадлежат Тренту. Для меня это грустно, и я даже чуть не заплакала. Или это нормально, что не подписали автора?
Still works as a pick up line for me to this day, i send this on the second date, by the 3rd im a laid man
couldnt have said it better myself 🤣🤣 but fr tho this comment is why i came to this thread... thx for articulating :D'
The cover I never knew I needed. This music video is phenomenal. Sounds like a Reznor/Manson love child, and its amazing. I want more. 🖤
I’m speechless. This is art. This is everything. I didn’t know I needed this.
This is like listening and watching this song for the first time. I've got goose bumps. His voice is so similar to Reznor's as well... damn.
excuse me while i pick my jaw off the floor, damn nailed it again guys, remington your voice is so uniquely amazing, so good, and this video infinity out of infinity, holy wow, hot video
These guys got it fuck yeah ! Killed the NIN cover !
I love that new generation bands are covering nine inch nail songs, makes me proud that I named my son Reznor! He’s so talented!
Love this song when nine inch nails did it, love it even more now
Same!!
Fair enough but not as good a NIN
@@Devik666Nothing ever will be but this is a pretty awesome cover! When I saw the title I was like… wait…. No way… Are they really…? Yup, they’re gonna cover NIN’s most infamous song and I’m here for it! 😂
He is so perfect, with his voice, behaivours, appearance, aura. And his voice is not like another singers, it's son peacefully 🥺💙
Trent Reznor is god! My all time fav artist. Many have tried to redo this song, and this is the best remake I have heard. The visuals and vocals are amazing. It has been a very long time since I found a new band I liked , I am definitely liking this band. Great job.
I love everything about this. The outfits, the cover, the music video. So good
I never was a fan of this song until I heard this version and omg I am obsessed with the music and everything!! :00
How does this not have more likes ??? I have been a fan for years now and holy sh*t this is amazing. I want to see this in concert!! Thank you for blessing us with this amazing Master Piece. I feel like I am in a Silent Hill movie but like in a hot way.
I am a great fan of the original song. This cover fuggin rocks!!!! Thank you for bringing it back to times.
Amazing!! Chefs kisses for the music, lyrics, video production, dress/make up and everyone to bring us this!!!
I never thought I’d hear a version that wasn’t the OG that I’d love. That being said… 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🙌🏻🖤🖤🖤 HELL YES!!! Great job on every aspect!
Only found out now that this is a cover and all I have to say is this:
This is an amazing song compared to the original.
The original is boring as it lacks the aggressive element but they mastered it here. Everything builds itself and it is beautiful.
Best remake EVER!!!
Wow, this was absolutely incredible! The visual aspects are unique and I wasn’t expecting this kind of artistic interpretation of this song. It kind of reminded me of Manson in a way as well. You guys did an amazing job like always!
I can see this cover definitely be on season 2 of the Relentless series if they ever come out with it 💀🖤
I love when the three of them come into the screen
Y’all I’m ngl I have probably listened to this like 35 times within the past 4 days😅
Best tribute I've heard. Reznor should appreciate this.
Sellout reznor most likely will. Sometimes I wonder if he's been a total poser this whole entire time. This song it terrible. It was a good song originally but now everyone has played it to death. Rip closer
@@Joannalauralanglight wow, so edgy
OMG. I am a huge NIN fan and a big Palaye Royal fan..Had no idea I needed this! ❤❤
Насколько это охринено, это делает мой день уже 2 недели...... Не перестану это слушать
🖤🫀 of all the bands to cover this masterpiece, Palaye did it perfectly 👌
I love this and the In This Moment cover the most
Wait! I'm still processing my love for Dead to Me, and now I love this song too, I want more
Marilyn Manson vibes
Remind me Sweet Dreams, don't you think ?
IT'S LIKE RAYAAAAIIN @@autumnwind2957
Ghostemane hydrochloride vibes
Definitely New sh*t song😅
Thats because TR produces Marilyn Manson albums
This is NIN
I felt like I was 14 years old and watching a Dir en Grey mv~ love it
I thought I was the only one who was reminded of Obscure, lol
Palaye did this song justice i love this cover i swear Palaye are making hits left and right
That’s crazy, last year I thought “it would be so cool if they did a cover” BUT I THOUGHT IT WOULD NEVER HAPPEN WTF ?! Also, Yulia’s work is amazing, didn’t recognized her style at first but I was very pleased when I checked who directed the video 😌
Love this vibe, their look, their sound, they’re a total package
Didn’t think I would ever find another good nin inch nails cover but you guys absolutely killed it❤
You should check out Halocene's cover of this song
i was the same until this. i think everybody has certain songs that must never be touched & for me this one was on that list but i can't deny, they really did an amazing job sonically & aesthetically here. i never wanna hear a cover of any song from Pretty Hate Machine, was/am obsessed with that record.
@@justonperez9779 oh for real???? its good?!?! 🤯 en route to check out now. Thank you! 😀🖤
Does so much justice to the song. Beautiful song. Awesome remix
The artistry of every single shot is absolutely stunning!!!
…. I hope youre joking
What a lovely cover!
Классно! Обожаю эту группу. Каждый раз удивляете . Ребята молодцы не останавливайтесь....
how many times have i watched this?
YES
Как же подходят Ремингтону эти образы ♥️😍
божее как же я с вами согласна!!!
THE STYLE, THE ENERGY, THE PERFORMANCE, UTTER PERFECTION
Honestly is Remington trying to kill us all??!! Love it.
TRUTH
Okay, love this song!!!! 🖤💋
Nah nah see I love me some sleep token and etc but my babies Palaye came back with this- it got me having shivers down my spine!!!
Remington was so dirty with this!!!🩵🩵👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Honestly one of the best covers ever, and the music video *chefs kiss* !!!
They all look so good, the music is soooo good! They just made my whole month at least. THX
It's like that song has always been meant for them!!
No matter how many times i watch this video.... I think.. Trent has to be impressed by this.
i love this song sm & the music video is so fucking cool you guys outdid urself once again wow
Remington's voice on this song is so 😩👌
Guess that's my new favourite music video now. Love it! 🖤
Easily the best cover of the year! LOVE THIS
This is way to good I don't know whether to cry or what ahhhhh
Awesome choice!! Trent Reznor is a master!!!
Y'all slayed it!!!!
I really like this cover... when he sings it he means it.
i fxxking love this band. been here since 2016 and never want to leave.
Took a masterpiece and made it their own! You guys are awesome as usual!!!!!
I LOVE EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS!!!!!!!! Atmosphere, outfits, cover that i didn't know i need but i need it. I'm in love
This is fantastic. I'm at a loss for words to describe the feelings this invokes.
Always loved this song. Great to see such a fantastic cover.
OMG 🖤 I’m speechless but with my soul full of Palaye Royale’s energy 🖤 I love you guys
Such a great cover. Love when people cover this song!
This is INCREDIBLE! Something otherworldly, something from another dimension
Thats because its Trent Reznor who created it
Closer is one of my favorite songs of all time and I think you've done it justice. 🖤
“how many times have you watched it?”
me: yes
This is absolutely the best cover ever.
The MV is a masterpiece fr
Giving the movie saw vibes ❤❤ I’m here for it!!
This is such a damn good cover.
This is my favourite cover ever…. The perfect people to do it 🖤