The Scientific Relevance of Marxism
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 พ.ค. 2024
- In this lecture Dr. Taimur Rahman explains the development of the materialist conception of history in the larger context of the epistemological debates in philosophy. He also explains that the charge of economic reductionism is absolutely absurd and that the materialist conception of history remains the most scientific way of understanding history.
*English TH-cam: / taimurrahman1975
*Instagram: / taimur_laal
*Twitter: / taimur_laal
![Mod Phil 9: Religion is the Opium of the Masses [Urdu]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X9CwaE0joLc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 4 // 100T vs GEN | G2 vs TH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UkTGSxdCUQw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Mod Phil 6: Hegel: Logic and Dialectics [Urdu]](/img/n.gif)
As A 16 Year old Student Of Class 12 [humanities] From India I Like Your Lectures On Political Philosophy Specially On Marxism
Bhootni k apni study pr focus rakho, pehlay khud ko sambhaalo phir inqlaab Lana. Yadhee k
Same
😇
@@Khan36000 ja ke padhai kr na..
Kha se hain Bhai...
I'm a Practicing Muslim but a if Marx has become irrelevant than why I'm a Politically Radical Marxist in 2024 and I have been a Radical Marxist since sixth grade when I was only 12 years old and I read Communist Manifesto in grade 6 and to open up why I tilted towards Marxism after 2003 our financial situation started deteriorating and I was introduced to Marx by a very intellectual teacher in 2004 and the starting statement of Communist Manifesto was a bombshell i-e A Spectre is haunting Europe the Spectre of Communism 😊😊
Yadhee k jhootay, tu ne 12saal ki age main kesay Marx parh lee the? 12 Saal ki age tumhen L ka pata nhn tha. Dramay karte ho yadhee k
@@Khan36000 ye mumkin hai, han gaadho ke liye ye mumkin nehi ho sakta sai
Sir what is your thoughts on osho
L thoughts hain, L dekha hai kabhi Kisi ka?
@@Khan36000 yes Dekha hai L of molvi inserted into you
@@Khan36000 yes Dekha hai special L to your mutarm sahiba by molana
@@artist-fk1uk it is my credit to bring you on the worst & below the belt discussion, before this you were known as Arrastooo in the community 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@Khan36000great for representing your beautiful thoughts
sir, a tip place something moving in the background on the bookshelf, it could be a toy or moving cool figure of miniature marx or anything. This is for attention grabbing, its called a hook or something.
Wonderful lecture Taimur Sahib. Thank you!
This man is well read. Clear headed. Red. Red. ❤❤😅😅
Economic "base" and philosophico-legal-political "superstructure" go hand in hand, parallel, in conformity, in simultaneous movement.
Activities generate ideas but what are actually ideas. How they came from. Are they product of matter if yes so where does this quality came from the matter?
The material world and ideas are separate from each other. Marxism failed because it doesn’t evolve. It considered as humans a being which can be transformed if the society is changed. What is human nature ? Change the society human nature can get changed. The thing is human beings are always in contradiction because because of their nature which they contain deep inside them and it has been relying on their free will which they have since the beginning.
Ideas are processes of the brain. The brain is the product of evolution. Ideas are part of the material world. Human transform their own society. There is no such thing. Human nature keeps changing.
@@Taimur_Laal dr sahib here I am referring the nature of the human which is inherent in itself. Which he contains from the beginning. The ideas which are the fundamentals to lead a life. The fundamentals ideas about the right and wrong. When the humans remain contradictory among these fundamentals ideas which he knows deep inside in it self. You are referring nature as something which is changeable so my question is. Is depriving someone from their right became an unjust act from the 21st century or telling lie become a wrong act in recent time or it is in deep inside the human nature. Material world can be a way through which we remain connected with our nature. It doesn’t change us. As Parmenides regarded that change is illusion. It is the appearance that change but essence remains.
Very good, Taimur sahab. Brilliant work!
An excellent explanation of historical materialism and dialectical materialism.
Awesome efforts of video lecture on such an important and interesting topic.
Please keep it up.
Sir plz try to share your lectures divide into parts, more people will get benefits from your lectures.
Taimur saheb work hard for the change mentality of ummah and introducing new subjects.
Bhai Jan ummah bari bhenchood hai, ummah ko chooren pehlay Ap khud sudhar jaen bari Baat ho ge . Yadhee k
آپ نے ایک اہم نکتے پر بہترین رہنمائی فرمائی ہے۔
Same case with me in the swat grammar school 😂
کونسا نکتہ؟
Sir you are absolutely right but
1. The history of human beings is around 7 to 9000 years old which includes hunter gatherers to modern human beings, whereas nature is billions of years old.
2. We know the nature of elements but their combinations are highly unpredictable therefore cannot comment upon them , For example hydrogen which is highly flammable and oxygen which also is highly flammable but the combination of these two elements makes water which is used otherwise. SIM is the case with sodium and chlorine.
3. As human beings delves more he is amazed to find the complexities which he has not even thought about for example when we try to get into the atom we find a world that the speed of light is nothing ie particles may be billions of miles away but they actively respond to each other in real time and particles behaviour is dependent upon the onlookers.( Quantum mechanics)
4. We still know nothing about the human body as we are unable to treat any ailment except infections.
In the end I would like to say that human beings have a big mouth but we control nothing
Sorry nothing philosophical
Bhootni k 2 lines main baat khatam karte hain, tu ne alag se apna Das Capital likh maara hai. Kanjroo Kuch hosh kro, saray philosophy maarnay a jaatay ho daily. Yadhee k
Without fear and greed, no system can work
good sir,confusion dour hogayii.....
Sir. Why you become so slow in on going series of Islamic philosophy.
Totally treat to learn.
Kindly, upload next episodes of that series.😊
Islamic philosophy sirf madarsay main lounday bazi ko kehtay Hain. Yadhee day ooo
بہت عمدہ لیکچر۔۔۔۔۔مارکسزم ایک مشکل موضوع ہے۔۔۔۔۔لیکن آپ اسے آسان زبان میں بیان کرتے ہیں۔۔۔۔۔۔تین، چار مرتبہ سنیں گے تو بہتر طریقے سے سمجھیں گے
Thank you sir. You are legend.
Kanjrooo har banday ki kushaamad band kr do. Professor ne koi Naya teeeer nhn mara, Jo pehlay se likha hua tha wahi parh k sunaya hai. Yadhee k
Last me apne jo lines kahi wo meri zindagi ki philosophy hai, har ksi ko suno smjho phr apni samajh k mutabiq sab ki achi cheze le lo...at the end of the day insan or insanityat ki bhalai he asal maqsad hai
Thank you for your efforts sir❤
گریٹ سر جی❤
Youthiye aur surkhay main total 5 Rupay ka farq hota hai.
Kanjroo iss main Great wali koun c baat hai? Yahi Baat woh daily karta hai 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Qaiser Ahmed Raja sahab is waiting to have an academic discussion with you on Marxism 🙂
Professor bhaya, Marxism kin halaat main implement ho sakta hai phir? Jo issues ap abhi bata rahay hain ye baaten Marx ne kiyon nhn ki?
Ap ki baaton ka matlab hai jab Allah chahay ga tab Marxism bhe a jay ga
God is dead bro...
@@BlackWhite-ku2qy alhamdulillah
@@Khan36000 🤭😂
lovely
please try to mention references and resourses in descrition also
Kiya pat Leena hai tum logo ne references ka? Yadhee k
You should read story of philosophy by will Durant...the book can be Renamed story of kant as well...
Chal oye bhootni k Arrastooo, yadhee k
Muhakkik e Alaf Sani?
Correction: If reference is AD....then
Muhakkik e Alif Salis(3rd)
Marxism will remain when ever there is life in the world....❤
Not at all, Marxism was false at that time as well that's why he went to UK.
Marx was Ashkenazi he always remain skeptical of European Monarchies.
Calculas nukta e Nazar hi badal diya...first time of human
History insanone infinity ko ijtemal Kiya like playing football...so to understanding enlightenment of kant u have to understand darkness of Hume and light of calculas...
Yeh ek aur yadhee ka philosophy maarnay a gaya hai
@@Khan36000 Kis yahudi Kal falsafa zara bataiyega?
Kant was student of mathematics aur physics student ...
how it affects law of attraction?
I don't know what Marx gives you or not.
But I guarantee you Marx could make you independent critical thinker which helps you all your life❤
Have you read hegel ??? Hegel
Discuss total hindu philosophy , greek philosophy , christian philosophy , chinese philosophy but except islam...why? Because he gave that duty on poet goethe ...so hegel is imcopmplete without goethe...
Yeh ek aur yadhee k philosopher a gaya hai market main, pehlay iss tarboooz ki sun lo saray
Plato expelled poet from his republic and communist expell poet from soviet russia in practical like gorky was expelled from russia...
Very beautiful ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
In Jinnah's directionless Pakistan....
..
..
Most relevant!
Sir voice glitch
Where does Immanuel Kant Critique of Pure Reason figure in this debate?
Materialism in Marxist ideology doens't just remain to historical materialism but pervades to all other domain of society like family system, religion etc etc..
This is fundamental reason, in my opinion, Marxism can never take root in Muslim society who practice and believe in Islam. Prevalent idea of private property being absolute right can be disproven within the fiqh, but since materialism always leads to denial of revelation and ergo hadith and fiqh(or atleast dethroning it), Marxism won't become dominant ideology.
Is it possible to build socialism on foundation of idea other than materialism?
Biggest drawback in socialism was, I did not engage the human instincts in it though it look good on paper
❤
You have to distinguish between Greek philosopher and Islamic poets...
Otherwise?
In my school i said loudly that i am a socialist😅 then instantly regret it.. My teacher give me a lecture in front of class, that this against Islam...😢
It's sad..
Apnay aap ko socialist kehnay se koi surkha nhn ban jaata, jesay apnay app ko Muslim kehnay se koi Musliman nhn ban jaata, yadhee k Dua kr Bach gaya hai, apni study complete kr phir inqlaab lana bhootni k mistree L Singh
Indeed its against Islam!
@@shoibericsson5007how?
@@shoibericsson5007 then Islam is against the wellbeing and development of human and their societies. It's bitter but true...
❤❤❤❤❤
❤❤❤
Socialism and capitalism are both extreme points... You have adopt norway, findland model. They have incorporated best of socialism and capitalism into new model.. where basic necessities like medicine and education are socialised....its same model of islam..which gives best of both worlds without their negatives
Marx ko samajh na bari asan keu ke o labour class ka religion hai...but nietzhe ko samaj na bari mushkil keuko o
Middle class or burjoise ka religion hai...both science derived german religion...
Marx said all man are equal and nietzshe said all man are unequal ...both of them are devil becuse both of them are extrmreamist in their point of view...but nietzhe is more wise than marx because he admit himself as devil, deunasus or satan but marx do nat admit himself as satan or devil or deunasus...
Ye ek aur yadhee ka philosophy maarnay a gaya hai.
@@Khan36000 Marx was a Jew
Communist Party of Pakistan. Ever thought? Could Jinnah, a law student might have read Hegal's Logic/ Philosophy of Law/ dialectics...? Karl Marx? Jinnah was intellectually poor. An illustration, a sentence from his speech:- "... now everyone is free to go to one's Ibadatgaah..."! Is that the essence of his conception of Pakistan? Too simplistic! For a man of his calibre! A great lawyer (arguer/manipulator/maneuver) need NOT be intellectually competent.
Jinnah was shrewed, but not wise! Like a petty manager office clerk! If Nehru is PM, I too will be one! Even if it's to be possible by dissecting the heart of Punjab! Being permanent slave of the West comes from his policy (tactics) of sitting in the lap of the British Crown! Petty peoplw do such tactics in municipal and ration card / food supply department liason. Not much impressive.
Let us not read 20 volumes on Jinnah to understand his politics (of manuvering). Only one line from his speech is enough. He can't articulate. Can't do thought formation. Conditions suited him.
Mujhy khuch smjh nahi arha 😢
A mere pass tujhe samjhaaon sari socialism yadhee k
Ram Lal...
Nathu Lal...
Jeevan Lal...
Taimur Laal ❤😃
Reason ko damage/ destroy Kiya Kant nehi balke reason ko worship Karne Wala Hume...
Not really. His analysis deals with 19th century crude industrial capitalism. His solution was worse than the disease. Well documented in the USSR, Cambodia etc.
Radical Socialist apologist 😂
No, he is not relevant today as he was irrelevant yesterday.
Janab you are irrelevant 😢
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Iss Liye main kehta hon k surkha bhe youthiya he hota hai.
Iss ka Saboot ap ka reply hai professor bhaya 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@Khan36000 thank you.
@@Khan36000
لعنت آپ پہ
@@Taimur_Laal
👍🏻