They debuted with bad live recordings but then they have improved a lot My bias is Lee Sem, and although she has left the group, I'm still proud of them. They have been trying so hard to improve their singing and dancing skills, and now they are singing live better than dozens of other female idols, but they are not lucky enough to be able to become famous. Sorry for my girls. I have been watching them since their debut.
I really don't think this is the actual pre-debut performance. If you actually watched the documentary, the first lineup of 9muses was introduced to the song. You can clearly hear Eunji, Bini, Rana, Euaerin and Minah in this. If you watch the documentary and watch some of the no playboy live stages, Euaerin struggled with the high note.
Lineups can change at any moment, and trainees get cut from content if they don't make the lineup. Viki and Soorin were already in a Star Empire project unit in late 2009, and it was confirmed that Sungah was a predebut member before coming back
The company considered that Sungah did not have enough training to debut, so they left her as a reserve member until 2013 (that's why when Jaekyung left, they did not consider her as a member to join) and she DID have the talent and desire to being an Idol so the company signed a 7-year contract with her, Kyungri on the other hand was the az of Star Empire. She was trained in singing, modeling, acting and in addition she was very pretty, but the only thing they considered that she What needed to be perfected was her quality of dance and performance, so she was momentarily transferred as a backup dancer for Park Mi Kyung (Soloist and current member of Golden Girls) debuting in the song "Come Back" by the same artist, in 2012 the contract Kyungri's career as a dancer was over and she had improved and perfected her performance quality so Star Empire finally signed her as a member of 9Muses.
Yes! please watch the documentary of then full version 1hour and 20mins.. Eunhye was supposed to debut with 9muses but Arum,Yuri,Kyungri and Sungah left so that Surin and Viki also left and Rana, Eunji ,Erin,Minha,Hyebin,Hyemi joined for the debut line up
@@anakin0128 hi , i need your information. Who is Arum. I end up seeing her name in credit of nine muses documentary but dont know who she is and what minute that she shown in the video , can you please more explain so i can recheck with it , thank you
han areum of t ara?? Spilled the tea she was trainee and pre debut of 9muses and getting rejected at other company she left after or before promotion of no playboy?
The voices are from the original lineup, not the predebut girls. The only diference between the final song and this is the rap (Erin instead of Lee Saem), and Rana and Lee Saem instead of Erin.
Agreed. In their documentary , they are introduced to the song for the first time in their debut line up. And you can very clearly hear Rana and Erin's vocals here.
This is weird cause Wikipedia doesn't even mention this lineup. I know Wikipedia isn't the most reliable but they usually go into detail for miniscule subjects like music groups and famous artists. Does anyone know where I can read up on this lineup?
Maybe they just didn’t mention this lineup because they didn’t know about this lineup? Or maybe it was just predebut? Or i don’t know. But don’t blame Wikipedia itself, some users created that page, lol.
Sungah finished her studies first before officially joining the group. Meanwhile, Kyungri left star empire and been to different agencies but later on thought that her height and image suits Namyu well so, she came back.
I’m pretty sure since it was predebut they took test shoots, and recorded a few songs to figure out what worked best for the girls. They also have other predebut pics online too, soo pretty
Yes, this version is sung by the debut lineup. It was used for the behind the scenes of the song's music video and people with delusion think it's sung by this pre-debut lineup.
I am not quite sure but Keumjo, Sojin, Park Hi (from p101,) and Eunice (DIA) are trainees in 2014. Sojin would debut with 9MUSES in 2014 but didn't make it. Keumjo is pretty much the last minute member. Park Hi and Eunice would have debuted either Jewelry or 9Muses but Park Hi left for acting career and Eunice left because she wasn't chosen for 9Muses and Jewelry disbanded
@@Sanas_Shy_Language The demo version is actually sung by JYP (you can find it here on TH-cam), this version is an early version recorded by the debut lineup - and it was used on the behind the scenes to the song's music video.
Sungah,Eunhye,Sera and Yuri are so pretty!!! Kyungri looks like she’s 9. Seoyoung look like Dee Dee and Oggy from the cartoon”Oggy and the Cockroaches” Seoyeon looks like a boy and her name was inspired in Fromis_9 Hyunjoo looks like a rabbit and her name was inspired in April Soorin looks like Eunji. Yuri reminds me of Yuri from SNSD but pretty! Sungah looks most prettiest of them all! Eunhye is uhh... v-ve-very uhh also pretty.Haha! Sera is super happy. So that’s all
@Sana’s Shy Language lmao, this was a cringe comment of mine. And at that time i was 9 years old so then i made this awkward compliment 😬. Especially for Eunhye which makes me sound like i’m lying about her being pretty lollll 💀- Now i’m 11 so i cringed at this, lmaoo-
![말해줘 - 지누션 (With 장원영) [2024 KBS 가요대축제 글로벌페스티벌] | KBS 241220 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/V7bBrPKpnkE/mqdefault.jpg)
They debuted with bad live recordings
but then they have improved a lot
My bias is Lee Sem, and although she has left the group, I'm still proud of them. They have been trying so hard to improve their singing and dancing skills, and now they are singing live better than dozens of other female idols, but they are not lucky enough to be able to become famous. Sorry for my girls. I have been watching them since their debut.
Where’s Lee Sem now?
Suyon from single inferno? Viki from Dalshabet? Wow i didn’t know about thit
The fact that two of these members would then be added to Nine Muses after debut is strange-
One of the reasons of many 9muses members leaving the group is because they already knew the agency had their replacement
Like it and for Sungah and Kyungri they came back in 2012 for News Dolls and Wild.
Viki was such a good rapper, luv her in Dalshabet line
IM SO FUCKING SHOOK I NEVER KNEW OF THIS PREDEBUT LINEUP
watch also the documentary full version 1hour and 20mins so that you can see the very first line up
Ani Santos yasss i will
@Van Ratanak how do you know? Just curious
I really don't think this is the actual pre-debut performance. If you actually watched the documentary, the first lineup of 9muses was introduced to the song. You can clearly hear Eunji, Bini, Rana, Euaerin and Minah in this. If you watch the documentary and watch some of the no playboy live stages, Euaerin struggled with the high note.
yes, you're right
Exactly, the documentary show the debut formation.
Lineups can change at any moment, and trainees get cut from content if they don't make the lineup. Viki and Soorin were already in a Star Empire project unit in late 2009, and it was confirmed that Sungah was a predebut member before coming back
Love it
Ani Santos no Erin was rapping.
@@rebeccablackvirus975 no she raps kinda in the second verse
Soorinの自信あり気な感じが惹かれる
Seoyeonは日本人っぽい
YuriはRUnextのルセラの候補生に似てる
Victoria vikiって名前かっこ良すぎ
この4人の現在気になる。
多分9muのオーディションにいた15人の内の4人？
This was from the predebut lineup but why Kyungri and Sungah joined after 2-3 years 9Muses debuted?
They both left to get more experience. They returned when they had gotten that experience and when the agency needed member to replace Rana and Bini.
박수짝짝짝 oh i understand it now thankyou :>
Sungah was in fact the first ever muse. She was the first one to be scouted by the company to form 9muses.
The company considered that Sungah did not have enough training to debut, so they left her as a reserve member until 2013 (that's why when Jaekyung left, they did not consider her as a member to join) and she DID have the talent and desire to being an Idol so the company signed a 7-year contract with her, Kyungri on the other hand was the az of Star Empire. She was trained in singing, modeling, acting and in addition she was very pretty, but the only thing they considered that she What needed to be perfected was her quality of dance and performance, so she was momentarily transferred as a backup dancer for Park Mi Kyung (Soloist and current member of Golden Girls) debuting in the song "Come Back" by the same artist, in 2012 the contract Kyungri's career as a dancer was over and she had improved and perfected her performance quality so Star Empire finally signed her as a member of 9Muses.
I think rap part is Viki but also has SEM in that part
Kyungri has come SO FAR 🤣
oh wow~ isn't that viki, former dal shabet member? didn't know she was with 9muses~
Yes! please watch the documentary of then full version 1hour and 20mins.. Eunhye was supposed to debut with 9muses but Arum,Yuri,Kyungri and Sungah left so that Surin and Viki also left and Rana, Eunji ,Erin,Minha,Hyebin,Hyemi joined for the debut line up
Ani Santos who’s Arum?
@@anakin0128 hi , i need your information. Who is Arum. I end up seeing her name in credit of nine muses documentary but dont know who she is and what minute that she shown in the video , can you please more explain so i can recheck with it , thank you
han areum of t ara?? Spilled the tea she was trainee and pre debut of 9muses and getting rejected at other company she left after or before promotion of no playboy?
Sunah i wanna real man part is legendary
The voices are from the original lineup, not the predebut girls. The only diference between the final song and this is the rap (Erin instead of Lee Saem), and Rana and Lee Saem instead of Erin.
Agreed. In their documentary , they are introduced to the song for the first time in their debut line up. And you can very clearly hear Rana and Erin's vocals here.
I can hear Minha, Rana and Erin's voices here
Wait kyungri was suppose to debut during that time? then why did she left and join again?
Kokoro Kiseki she left to gain more experiences and came back when 2012. You can watch her interview about that on weekly idol her rewriting profile
@@anakin0128 isn't that also Sungah who joined a bit after Kyungree? I guess she did the same thing.
@@skipperbarbie3058 Sungah was the first muse. She is the first one to be scouted for 9muses.
Studio version Lee Sem’s rap is soooo addictive!!
HOW DID I NEVER KNOW THIS
This is a recording with Minha and Eurin as rapper not those in pictures LOL
This is weird cause Wikipedia doesn't even mention this lineup. I know Wikipedia isn't the most reliable but they usually go into detail for miniscule subjects like music groups and famous artists. Does anyone know where I can read up on this lineup?
They had a documetary. Nine Muses Documentary with 1hour and 20 miutes (?) They showed the predebut line up.
fαntαsч hello
Maybe they just didn’t mention this lineup because they didn’t know about this lineup? Or maybe it was just predebut? Or i don’t know. But don’t blame Wikipedia itself, some users created that page, lol.
Pre-debut members are never added to a group's Wikipedia page.
1:27 OMG, it's really Sungah voice
What happened?
Sungah finished her studies first before officially joining the group. Meanwhile, Kyungri left star empire and been to different agencies but later on thought that her height and image suits Namyu well so, she came back.
its almost the same (when she debuted in Dolls)
its clearly Rana , Sungah sounds like her a little bit
this is crazy, kyungri is in the debut lineup??
문현아 표혜미 박민하 이유애린 영입이 신의한수였다 진짜
Where did you find this??
Ani Santos could you send me the link?
can you share that video?
@@anakin0128 Yah I want to see that too
if this was really sung by the actual debut lineup then where did these pictures came from? and when was this lineup?
I’m pretty sure since it was predebut they took test shoots, and recorded a few songs to figure out what worked best for the girls. They also have other predebut pics online too, soo pretty
can you please post DL link?
wow where did you get this from?
i like this version
Where could Yuri soorin and seoyeon now?
LIVing in their best life
Eran re tiernas ;-;
Is this Minha's voice?? 1:20
Yes, this version is sung by the debut lineup. It was used for the behind the scenes of the song's music video and people with delusion think it's sung by this pre-debut lineup.
@@iampause LMAO the way you said it was so funny 💀💀💀
I THOUGHT SEOYEON WAS SOYEON FROM GIDLE AT FIRST-
Lmfao
2023🎉
Are keimjo and sojin also from the orginal line up?
I am not quite sure but Keumjo, Sojin, Park Hi (from p101,) and Eunice (DIA) are trainees in 2014. Sojin would debut with 9MUSES in 2014 but didn't make it. Keumjo is pretty much the last minute member. Park Hi and Eunice would have debuted either Jewelry or 9Muses but Park Hi left for acting career and Eunice left because she wasn't chosen for 9Muses and Jewelry disbanded
@@fushim5510 Eunice is supposed to be in Jewelry but they disband so she find another company to debut in a group
Sungah looks like park seyoung
how's that!!!!!
Im sorry to say this but this audio is exactly the same like the audio at the no playboy mv making video~
It’s definitely still a different version to the actual one cause that’s definitely Sungah and that’s def more than one person singing the chorus
LOL I don't know Thais version
its not a Thai version it was a version of their predebut. before their debut stage
its not a Thai version it was a version of their predebut. before their debut stage
Ani Santos Sorry, I wrote "this version" and ended up going Thais version
+After Work its OK😊
@@afterwork6327 lol you can edit your comment
Are you serious? No playboy its 2010 production .
no. not this line up. debut line up is this demo' s line up.
Most demo version aren’t sang by the group.
@@Sanas_Shy_Language The demo version is actually sung by JYP (you can find it here on TH-cam), this version is an early version recorded by the debut lineup - and it was used on the behind the scenes to the song's music video.
Kyungri !!!! (Utt aaaa)
Sungah,Eunhye,Sera and Yuri are so pretty!!!
Kyungri looks like she’s 9.
Seoyoung look like Dee Dee and Oggy from the cartoon”Oggy and the Cockroaches”
Seoyeon looks like a boy and her name was inspired in Fromis_9
Hyunjoo looks like a rabbit and her name was inspired in April
Soorin looks like Eunji.
Yuri reminds me of Yuri from SNSD but pretty!
Sungah looks most prettiest of them all!
Eunhye is uhh... v-ve-very uhh also pretty.Haha!
Sera is super happy.
So that’s all
This comes across very hate-y. Don’t know if you meant to do that-
@Sana’s Shy Language lmao, this was a cringe comment of mine. And at that time i was 9 years old so then i made this awkward compliment 😬. Especially for Eunhye which makes me sound like i’m lying about her being pretty lollll 💀- Now i’m 11 so i cringed at this, lmaoo-
@@prate7517 and calling kyungri 9-
@Sana’s Shy Language Oh my gosh, I AM SO SORRY GIRL. I thought she looked 9 so that’s why i wrote this, LMAOOO 💀🤣😭😂❤️-
Park soyeon/suyeon was looks likedeedee from oggy and the cockroaches makes me dying at laughing
viki dalshabet
Soyeon of t-ara is that she
I don't think so. Soyeon of T-ara was a trainee in other group before debut in 2009. This pre-record was also in that year