For a recently released game, this is really good, animations are good, graphics, and the maps, i like the upgrades actually having real gun names (like smaw, m208 etc) and the military focused theme is just ideal for me The only missing aspect is skins but im sure they will be added further on. I give it a 8.5/10
@@Jay-qd7ib the gameplay's pretty fun! The grind is a bit much though... If I ever get tired, I take a two week break and it reignites my interest in the game
yo a neat idea for the game TDX, is to add a key bind for the skip button so that we don't have to drag our cursor from a good placement we have on a tower or an upgrade we are waiting to do, just to click the skip button. I'm sure your fanbase would love this neat idea, hopefully not too much people is dissing your game rn and I wish you the best of luck on development. :)
The release of this game was pretty well balanced and it was very good (I like the small heathbar change update though) one thing I would ask is to make the placement boxes slightly smaller so you can fit two towers in good spots (if they are small)
Love the game, excited for the future. I just hope that you add a lobby creation system so that it's easier to group and team up with people and select the maps you want to play rather than just sit there and hope it shows up.
@@washed3711 Wasn't the original comment about how they HOPE they ADD a lobby creation system later on? I just commented on their suggestion, sounds like you're the one who doesn't know how to read and just likes to assume things, of course I understand it's just a beta, the game is already good as it is.
I believe nightmare mode is going to be a ‘PTSD’ sequence like gamemode where the enemies are reimagined into nightmarish creatures. Like the nightmare animatronics in Fnaf 4
@@Scaryyy_Prod tds literally is just a generic tower defense game. In tdx, there are battleships, and towers can die as well, I just think I enjoy the challenge from tdx a lot more than boring tds.
7:34 Jhon, observing this part where you wanted to put some DJs to boost the ships, seeing this, I can suggest some troop or support unit that allows you to put other troops in the water and something like a float or another ship. I don't know what that idea sounds like to you.
I always loved the idea of being able to choose where Artillery fires, because in some other TD games you cant and it annoys me like its literally just another normal rpg class, the aiming part is was makes artillery fun T~T. SO Thank you for doing this, and keep up the great work. ever since you announced it Ive been watchin' every tdx video you have I love the ideas you and your team come up with for it plus the amazing style of it all ^-^ keep up the great work and thank you and your team so much for giving us this.
an opinion / recommendation of mine is to have the zombies' labels that show up when hovering the mouse over to stay even when the zombie walks out of mouse range, so you dont have to closely follow your mouse to see the stats / hp of the zombie, similarly to how tower battles did it.
I feel like laser gunner's ability should be reworked to a passive, heres my idea of a rework: it can reveal enemies in its range temporarily and once its gone its stealth cant be revealed anymore by other laser gunners maybe the passive is given at 0-4 as an x amount of seconds and then the last level will be to reveal it for x amount of seconds (more than lvl 4). The laser gunner is already a pretty strong tower in my opinion but the ability is genuinely underwhelming
Would you consider buffing the speed gamepass in a future update? It's fine as it is but in my opinion 50% for $10 isn't alot considering other games like btd6 give much faster speed buffs for free, maybe 2x speed or the ability to switch between 1.5x or 2x speed would be cool, just a suggestion to hopefully consider
Tds is engaging with its towers, as they get better Tdx is more engaging with its gameplay in general despite being the same genra, with more interactive gameplay and mechanics
The game actually goes on pretty well, it's just a little slow on mobile though. Mainly in the main lobby, it's kind of hard to move around and in rounds, with all the entities and towers, it still runs a bit slowly. In any case though, it's an amazing game!
John should add a play again option, after you beat the boss and the game is over there is an option to play again but a different mode, like you are when you join the game
John, ty for this MOST QUALITY TD gama ever... I just wanted to say ty, now i have fun with friends in TDX(We was bored of other TD'S games). Bro, just, ty.
Also good job John on this great game when I first played it it was an amazing game you made roblox fun for me again this game is truly better then tds
John Thank you for better optimizing the game for mobile, I am a mobile player of TDS and TDX and the difference in game play is surreal, while TDS was lagging , troop improvements took a long time and to Taking out troops was much more time consuming, and before in TDS it was not possible to make a call on Discord and play at the same time without freezing or the call dropping in TDX I can make a call without any problems and play With 60 FPS.
Please add barracks i been waiting for so long I'm just addicted to spawning units. But at least make a show case video. God bless you and have a good life
The game is very good, but as a relatively new player grinding for new towers is extremely difficult. I recommend increasing the reward payout. Though, you don’t have to listen to me, a random stranger on the internet, so do what ever to your amazing game!
Things that are better (In my opinion): He spawns more bosses which makes the game better, It’s a great quality game, finally, The towers are creative and good.
Hello, I want to ask a question of the new update. Which is a new tower called barracks. I currently have 2.5k coins, and I am planning to buy Barracks, would you recommend the tower?
Your game kinda cool-cool but something still need more tinker, like unit's gunfire (or AR actually louder than shotgun?), HD graphics (some dude during my match complain about it), buff Humvee on operator (to be honest it's too weak than I expect, and maybe improve it model too if possible) and other stats / game difficulty changes, but for me this is rad, can't wait for more updates and following up on your game P.S. I just wanna yapping on suggestion because Idk I just feel like it, no need to mind it at all Add Grenadier unit next if I can suggest Arm with M203 as starter, damage around 5-10 at first. Average to high upgrade cost but mostly useful for shredding heavy armoured enemies where missile troops was too slow or bullets too weak for them >Maxed Upper path would be marine soldier with M32 grenade launcher, ability of it is signal smoke that signal attack bomber to strike on target (have stealth detection) >Maxed Lower path would be Russian soldier with automatic grenade launcher, small chances that it's launch gas grenade to slow down enemy instead (expensive, good for extreme crowd control, moderate damage might not too good to handle bosses)
@@LavelinaAli I can't wait to see that in the next update, but yeah you don't have to tell me furthermore because I already said I just wanna yapping because no reason given
john can you PLEASE add a solo elevator, People always join the squad elevators when you are trying to solo something and they cant read your chat because your in the tank, so could you add a solo elevator?
thinking about this i have an idea, if your the first person to join a elevator you can select the mode: Squad, Trio, Duo or Solo. I think it would help alot
Yo john i have a cool event tower idea if u guys are gonna make event towers. Wouldnt it be cool to have doomguy? One path will make him have a bfg 50 while the other will make him have the big red sword( i forgot the name) and the event would be fighting against hell related zombies like demons. Just had an idea like this btw the game is nice good work.
I have an idea, grab a ground support plane and give it the owner of that plane ability to make lines (Where the plane will fly and fire) and the plane goes back to the starting point by flying back to where it take off
Hey John Roblox you’re amazing and your game is just perfect so keep up the good work. Idea later maybe do skins that would be cool keep up the good work
I love the physics and stuff in this game, it actually makes this somewhat more enjoyable than TDS, hopefully this game will thrive and have more awesome updates!
How about an air strike tower? You know, the one where a bomber flies over the paths and drops bombs on the paths it crosses, you can also change which direction the bomber comes from.
please for use the capacity put the button on the left or right because having to click on the troops then when you have a lot of capacities to manage it's complicated
great game. one thing i would say could be improved is have the abilities in the same place as in tds to make using them easier. but john. this game is perfect and one more thing. please make laser ability passive
Thank you John,Tdx has been a huge blown up to TH-cam and roblox users,the graphics and mechanics are super cool,and I just think that tdx is the most played game,congratulations on your hard work,we all love you -Jason
i love tdx
www.roblox.com/games/9503261072/Tower-Defense-X-BETA-RELEASE
twitter.com/TowerDefenseX/status/1726694753117634772
discord.gg/tdx
Same
me 2
same
Cool
Me too
at this point it’s not even abuse, John is just using it as intended since doing this kind of stuff in his own game was inevitable
Any one noticed the arty crew dance heavily resembles denji and power dancing?
@@tanktalesans yeah
@@tanktalesans I was thinking the same thing, could it be that John got inspired?
battle cat
Rocker Cat is a Rare Cat that can be unlocked by playing the Rare Cat Capsule. True Form added in Version 5.9 increases health and attack power.
For a recently released game, this is really good, animations are good, graphics, and the maps, i like the upgrades actually having real gun names (like smaw, m208 etc) and the military focused theme is just ideal for me
The only missing aspect is skins but im sure they will be added further on.
I give it a 8.5/10
Yea skins are added now
when it was released it was a solid 3/10
good that stuff..BUT THE GAMEPLAY 😭 ITS HORRIBLE
@@Jay-qd7ib the gameplay's pretty fun! The grind is a bit much though...
If I ever get tired, I take a two week break and it reignites my interest in the game
I paused my TDX to watch a video of TDX then continued playing TDX while watching TDX. This is epic.
100% certified epic move 😎🔥
yo a neat idea for the game TDX, is to add a key bind for the skip button so that we don't have to drag our cursor from a good placement we have on a tower or an upgrade we are waiting to do, just to click the skip button. I'm sure your fanbase would love this neat idea, hopefully not too much people is dissing your game rn and I wish you the best of luck on development. :)
The release of this game was pretty well balanced and it was very good (I like the small heathbar change update though) one thing I would ask is to make the placement boxes slightly smaller so you can fit two towers in good spots (if they are small)
First admin trolling in TDS and now admin trolling in TDX? How times have changed
cant wait for him to spam level 0 cyro blasters, farm, edj and troll
he isnt admin trolling tdx he owner trolling in tdx 😎😎😎
Only OGs remember the TB trolling
Been having a blast with this game, huge respect to the devs
Idea, the artillery shoots fireworks up after you win.
That's an amazing idea
It could be a fourth of July or new years exclusive skin
I never had this much fun playing a roblox game in years. A truly deserved success.
The only reason I play roblox now is just for this game. Thank you to John and the devs
Guys! U think that tdx will wave events or no? Comment if yes or no!
Not obrigatory
john said yes
Love the game, excited for the future. I just hope that you add a lobby creation system so that it's easier to group and team up with people and select the maps you want to play rather than just sit there and hope it shows up.
Right, Tower Blitz did the system right, among other things, TDX's current one is a hot mess and a timewaste, this is my biggest issue.
@@washed3711 Wasn't the original comment about how they HOPE they ADD a lobby creation system later on? I just commented on their suggestion, sounds like you're the one who doesn't know how to read and just likes to assume things, of course I understand it's just a beta, the game is already good as it is.
@@Shirley-qk4zc oh wait sorry I misread the thing
My issues was the gold gain, but now it’s fine because of the gold buffs
Did you know that cats can be gay lesbian or bisexual :3
I believe nightmare mode is going to be a ‘PTSD’ sequence like gamemode where the enemies are reimagined into nightmarish creatures. Like the nightmare animatronics in Fnaf 4
your game is already more fun than tds even though you have 1/4 of their development timeframe, very impressive. Keep it up
LOL ITS NOT CLOSE TO BETTER THAN TDS ITS GOOD BUT THE MEAT RIDE IS TOO MUCH LMAO
im a level 200 in tds and I can that tdx is way better than tds ngl u might be an ed
@@Scaryyy_Prod
and I can say*
@@Scaryyy_Prod tds literally is just a generic tower defense game. In tdx, there are battleships, and towers can die as well, I just think I enjoy the challenge from tdx a lot more than boring tds.
@@averagecheeseenjoyer5430 Tower death was literally "inspired" by WTD.
Only in TDX, for sure!
Hey John! Idea for the artillery's emote at 9:35, the artillery should fire some firework on the sky.. yeah.
7:34 Jhon, observing this part where you wanted to put some DJs to boost the ships, seeing this, I can suggest some troop or support unit that allows you to put other troops in the water and something like a float or another ship. I don't know what that idea sounds like to you.
maybe a cargo ship that is an alternative to farm? idk
ice monkey from btd6, flagship from btd6
pontoon from btd6
@@Jam3Z0 Pontoon originates from BTD5
@@trickygamer555whats the point of this???
In my opinion, I like it so much when the towers/troops celebrate when they win. Its such a small detail but very cool at the same time.
I always loved the idea of being able to choose where Artillery fires, because in some other TD games you cant and it annoys me like its literally just another normal rpg class, the aiming part is was makes artillery fun T~T. SO Thank you for doing this, and keep up the great work. ever since you announced it Ive been watchin' every tdx video you have I love the ideas you and your team come up with for it plus the amazing style of it all ^-^ keep up the great work and thank you and your team so much for giving us this.
Btd6 mortar
Idea: You could rename the farm tower to something like "Supply Drop" so that it matches the tower and also goes with the military theme
8:05 “kill the patrol boats with purely naval tower spam”
*friendly fire enabled*
Imagine friendly fire WAS a thing though, your crowd control would be a bit more risky like that.
@@trickygamer555top path cryomancer lowering attack speed
friendly fire
@@TETANUS. Would be a good mechanic. Also a good excuse to buff cryo a little bit.
an opinion / recommendation of mine is to have the zombies' labels that show up when hovering the mouse over to stay even when the zombie walks out of mouse range, so you dont have to closely follow your mouse to see the stats / hp of the zombie, similarly to how tower battles did it.
Make it so that when you lose or win a game, you can restart, it will be so useful
Good idea since you wouldn’t need to worry abt some random noob joining ur team
@QuickStrike-ns8uo trying to play solo without someone joining you is pain and then all they have is ranger
I feel like laser gunner's ability should be reworked to a passive, heres my idea of a rework: it can reveal enemies in its range temporarily and once its gone its stealth cant be revealed anymore by other laser gunners maybe the passive is given at 0-4 as an x amount of seconds and then the last level will be to reveal it for x amount of seconds (more than lvl 4). The laser gunner is already a pretty strong tower in my opinion but the ability is genuinely underwhelming
Would you consider buffing the speed gamepass in a future update? It's fine as it is but in my opinion 50% for $10 isn't alot considering other games like btd6 give much faster speed buffs for free, maybe 2x speed or the ability to switch between 1.5x or 2x speed would be cool, just a suggestion to hopefully consider
now maybe just me, but i dont think you can place down tower and upgrade that fast
@@rachaelthorne5201 you can always untoggle it if necessary
it should also be usable outside of solo, but all players must press the button toggle it
@@I_need2upload feel like that would create conflict in random teams tho and newer players would have no clue how to toggle something like that
@@grasstouchersensei idk theres just no better way to do it
John you could have made the artillery spin around shooting rounds like that civilian airliner meme.
Petition to bring back milo👇
its arsenal’s mascot.
Tds is engaging with its towers, as they get better
Tdx is more engaging with its gameplay in general despite being the same genra, with more interactive gameplay and mechanics
Yesterday was my birthday like the comment if you wanted to say happy birthday btw I love tdx
the skyhawk win animation sould shoot bombs into the sky as if they were fireworks.
Hot take: Yagidabo
That’s a pretty hot take
Woah man, isnt that illegal?
Bro leaked his opinion
WOAH THAT TAKE IS WAY TOO CONTROVERSIAL BRO CALM DOWN
god damn bro youre risking your life with this one..
Damn there's a warship and patrol boat. What next aircraft carrier. I love tdx
day 1 asking for a code in-game with my name that give 1 gold
Dream to this happen
And he never continued..
W
ok dude
whens day 2
i don't really like or play Tower Defense games, but this one caught my attention for some reason. and i have been playing this one quite a bit.
WHY DOESN T JOHN WORK WİTH TDS??
No John tower.
Its his decision
The Sky hawk artillery almost feels like the Gustov artillery from WW2 but it's smaller, weaker and with much less range
The game actually goes on pretty well, it's just a little slow on mobile though. Mainly in the main lobby, it's kind of hard to move around and in rounds, with all the entities and towers, it still runs a bit slowly. In any case though, it's an amazing game!
John should add a play again option, after you beat the boss and the game is over there is an option to play again but a different mode, like you are when you join the game
This is a great game. Really hoping you can make the missile troopers dance when you win lol.
John, ty for this MOST QUALITY TD gama ever... I just wanted to say ty, now i have fun with friends in TDX(We was bored of other TD'S games). Bro, just, ty.
Game idea: on patrol boat you would make it to where there is an upgrade where it will put a ranger on the boat for extra dmg
Also good job John on this great game when I first played it it was an amazing game you made roblox fun for me again this game is truly better then tds
John Thank you for better optimizing the game for mobile, I am a mobile player of TDS and TDX and the difference in game play is surreal, while TDS was lagging , troop improvements took a long time and to Taking out troops was much more time consuming, and before in TDS it was not possible to make a call on Discord and play at the same time without freezing or the call dropping in TDX I can make a call without any problems and play With 60 FPS.
Check out endless mode lmao
Please add barracks i been waiting for so long I'm just addicted to spawning units. But at least make a show case video. God bless you and have a good life
gotta love the different victory animations, the duo partner dance for artillery's gotta be the best one
Hey, there's an achievment for beating hard map, but there's no achievment for beating impossible one. But yea amazing game!
The game is very good, but as a relatively new player grinding for new towers is extremely difficult. I recommend increasing the reward payout. Though, you don’t have to listen to me, a random stranger on the internet, so do what ever to your amazing game!
You should add the artillery shooting out fireworks as the victory animation.
bottom path artillery after triumph: im only human
Not going to lie, but the "Laser gunner" looks like a pilot from Titanfall 2
tdx honestly is something i was expecting it to just be another tower defense game but woah good job on the good work to everyone who helped make it
One question: John will you ever add events towers like tds
I really like how this game is both challenging and newbie friendly. It really helps transitioning from other tower defense games!
john can you tell me what was you thinking with the reward sistem from beating any of the modes?
hey john really good game but when are new skins coming?
Things that are better (In my opinion): He spawns more bosses which makes the game better, It’s a great quality game, finally, The towers are creative and good.
Hello, I want to ask a question of the new update. Which is a new tower called barracks. I currently have 2.5k coins, and I am planning to buy Barracks, would you recommend the tower?
what happened to the toxinator
update : i know know about the toxinator (it was released 2 months ago)
Your game kinda cool-cool but something still need more tinker, like unit's gunfire (or AR actually louder than shotgun?), HD graphics (some dude during my match complain about it), buff Humvee on operator (to be honest it's too weak than I expect, and maybe improve it model too if possible) and other stats / game difficulty changes, but for me this is rad, can't wait for more updates and following up on your game
P.S. I just wanna yapping on suggestion because Idk I just feel like it, no need to mind it at all
Add Grenadier unit next if I can suggest
Arm with M203 as starter, damage around 5-10 at first. Average to high upgrade cost but mostly useful for shredding heavy armoured enemies where missile troops was too slow or bullets too weak for them
>Maxed Upper path would be marine soldier with M32 grenade launcher, ability of it is signal smoke that signal attack bomber to strike on target (have stealth detection)
>Maxed Lower path would be Russian soldier with automatic grenade launcher, small chances that it's launch gas grenade to slow down enemy instead (expensive, good for extreme crowd control, moderate damage might not too good to handle bosses)
He said that path 1 is more stronger than path 2 operator
There's already a grenade launcher tower he leaked a while ago
@@LavelinaAli I see
@@LavelinaAli I can't wait to see that in the next update, but yeah you don't have to tell me furthermore because I already said I just wanna yapping because no reason given
Hey bro Ive been trying to make my own tower defense game and its hard I want to ask you for tips Or help on my game
ngl it would be funny if you make nightmare mode with some bosses and the final boss flame proof
John for the artillery, you could make it a guy pops out and does a little cheer with one of his hands
love your game😍, do you have any tips for starters?
Hey John! I think that you should make the artillery shoot fireworks as a victory animation!
john can you PLEASE add a solo elevator, People always join the squad elevators when you are trying to solo something and they cant read your chat because your in the tank, so could you add a solo elevator?
thinking about this i have an idea, if your the first person to join a elevator you can select the mode: Squad, Trio, Duo or Solo. I think it would help alot
John will there be events like TDS?
A fresh start dude. Thank you for making this game
Bro this game is 🔥 keep on going with the banger
Yo john i have a cool event tower idea if u guys are gonna make event towers. Wouldnt it be cool to have doomguy? One path will make him have a bfg 50 while the other will make him have the big red sword( i forgot the name) and the event would be fighting against hell related zombies like demons. Just had an idea like this btw the game is nice good work.
That just the john tower
Can you demonstrate the warship in a few videos! I think that would be very interesting to see.
You should add a 1v1 2v2 3v3 and 4v4 system in your game
I think he's planning to add that in the future
Ok
I have an idea, grab a ground support plane and give it the owner of that plane ability to make lines (Where the plane will fly and fire) and the plane goes back to the starting point by flying back to where it take off
Tower idea: Commissar, every time it gets a kill, it spawns a friendly soldier on the path.
6:29 you better player in entire Roblox i very proud in this community
how about making the victory animation of missile trooper him shooting fireworks and leaning on the rocket launcher?
tdx towers after win: yay *dancing*
tdx missile trooper: *stares at the void*
artillery reminds me of bloons mortar
1:10 How did i get to top 10 most intermidiate wins 💀 (Placed 8th)
Something that would be neat is the Naval towers would bounce up and down in the water instead of being still and depressing.
hey john what perks would you add with vip in the future?
Hey john as an idea for the artillery tower it could shoot fireworks to celebrate defeating a boss instead of spinning
Hey John Roblox you’re amazing and your game is just perfect so keep up the good work. Idea later maybe do skins that would be cool keep up the good work
I don’t know how to say this but
EDJ model actually started to have certain arts of her somewhere on the internet
Hey would it be possible to give blox out water? So the patrol boat is useful there. There doesn’t seem to be a lot of water maps.
i dont know English well but still love watching your videos
I love the physics and stuff in this game, it actually makes this somewhat more enjoyable than TDS, hopefully this game will thrive and have more awesome updates!
How about an air strike tower? You know, the one where a bomber flies over the paths and drops bombs on the paths it crosses, you can also change which direction the bomber comes from.
please for use the capacity put the button on the left or right because having to click on the troops then when you have a lot of capacities to manage it's complicated
I’ve got an idea for a tower that could be added later on. To have more navel towers u could add a submarine
The end just makes my heart feel so funny. I'm so glad everything is going well john :)
great game. one thing i would say could be improved is have the abilities in the same place as in tds to make using them easier. but john. this game is perfect and one more thing. please make laser ability passive
when the game is finished(if it isnt already) will the 1.50 times speed be cheaper? cus rn it is a little expensive
Hey john, can you add more maps with water for the boats? Its boring playing the same two maps over and over just for my only good tower, patrol boat
But your forgetting hidden detection
Hello John Roblox
How did you get the admin commands in Tower Defence Simulator?
From one of your subscribers.
John will you do events ?
love the game man hope u can make it way better
Hey uh I wanna do a question, I wanna play tdx on the Xbox I have so what's the mechanic for the Xbox please?
This game reminds me of Bloons TD 6
Love the game my guy honestly best tower defense
tdx seems like an actual good tds game that isn't just oversaturated tower battles
Thank you John,Tdx has been a huge blown up to TH-cam and roblox users,the graphics and mechanics are super cool,and I just think that tdx is the most played game,congratulations on your hard work,we all love you -Jason