Melinda is so awesome. This is one of my favorite performances besides MFV. I don't know WHAT the judges were talking about. They were CRAZY to think she wasn't great. She was the best on Bee Gees night. I think Melinda should've won Idol. To quote Simon, she was humble, VERY likeable and has a powerful voice. I love this woman and I can't wait for the album in June. :)
Sounds a little between Randy Crawford and Chaka Khan. This girl should have been the winner on those Idols. Meeeeeen, the way she sings next to the piano at the beginning of this clip! Perfect!
To me, this performance is similar to Heaven Knows, the song she sang during Gwen Stefani week. Both from the same genre/era, both great, both underrated!
i like melinda doolitle alot but i did not like this performance at all, not even close to how good she can sing! Randy and Simon also agree with me as you can hear
Hey! I'm replying to this 8 years later. :p I think this performance deserved 20 points higher on whatnottosing. There wasn't anything wrong with her vocal at all; the song just didn't really do that much for her voice. Still a strong performance.
@@rdhaley96 Hey! And I'm replying to this 6 months later. :P I actually love the song, and it's actually one of my favs. from her. So I guess that puts me in the minority.........
No wonder she lost to Jordin. Jordin knew how to choose a song that makes her stand out. I got goosebumps watching Jordin performing I Who Have Nothing & Broken Wings. However, Melinda seemed to choose those middle-of-the-road songs that couldn't touch people or wow people after sailing through the top 10.
La peor interpretación, pobre morena la debe de cantar en R&B solo por que es lo que gusta en ese país, pero en realidad solo echaron a perder la canción, por favor, no es una canción de coro de iglesia
Melinda is so awesome. This is one of my favorite performances besides MFV. I don't know WHAT the judges were talking about. They were CRAZY to think she wasn't great. She was the best on Bee Gees night. I think Melinda should've won Idol. To quote Simon, she was humble, VERY likeable and has a powerful voice. I love this woman and I can't wait for the album in June. :)
Sounds a little between Randy Crawford and Chaka Khan.
This girl should have been the winner on those Idols.
Meeeeeen, the way she sings next to the piano at the beginning of this clip!
Perfect!
She's perfect!!! & will always be a star!!!
THIS WOMAN WAS TRULY SINGING THAT SONG! SHE WAS REALLY THE BEST DURING THIS SEASON! SO SAD SHE DIDN'T WIN!
I remember when she performed this on the show I thought it was f'ing incredible then yrs ago and it's incredible now yrs later
This is Soul Music.
REEEEALLLLLY GOOD... Loved it!!!
I always loved her...I hope she is doing great in life...She deserves it..Such a nice girl..
that was beautiful.
I'm sorry that performance was amazing!
This is when I started loving the BeeGees!!! But she sang my song!!!
@asharak84
Deffintiely have to agree here.
Leslie Feist just has this song so "on point" its just that much more tangible.
To me, this performance is similar to Heaven Knows, the song she sang during Gwen Stefani week.
Both from the same genre/era, both great, both underrated!
I liked Latoya London’s version because it was more personalized but this is nice too 🤷🏽♀️
DAMN
esa canción tiene un poder sobrenatural y una fuerza interna descomunal y muchos no la conocen bee gees los mejores ,,,
Sound like in the sky high. Make it fly
She's great!!! But I think another song would have highlighted her voice so much better.
Asu cantar una de bee gees s recontra dificil pero ella lo acomdo bien e...good job...sweety
She was robbed!
I can't help feeling that Feist was better (and also 'made it work' as a solo earlier)
One in a MiLLioN 8)
i like melinda doolitle alot but i did not like this performance at all, not even close to how good she can sing! Randy and Simon also agree with me as you can hear
i agree with simon.
This is the only Mindy Doo performance to fall below 50 on whatnottosing. Thoughts?
Hey! I'm replying to this 8 years later. :p
I think this performance deserved 20 points higher on whatnottosing. There wasn't anything wrong with her vocal at all; the song just didn't really do that much for her voice. Still a strong performance.
@@rdhaley96 Hey! And I'm replying to this 6 months later. :P I actually love the song, and it's actually one of my favs. from her. So I guess that puts me in the minority.........
hmmm randy and chaka....rather astute deltantony
No wonder she lost to Jordin. Jordin knew how to choose a song that makes her stand out. I got goosebumps watching Jordin performing I Who Have Nothing & Broken Wings. However, Melinda seemed to choose those middle-of-the-road songs that couldn't touch people or wow people after sailing through the top 10.
La peor interpretación, pobre morena la debe de cantar en R&B solo por que es lo que gusta en ese país, pero en realidad solo echaron a perder la canción, por favor, no es una canción de coro de iglesia
eso mismo pensè yo, esa cancion solo puede ser interpretada por los bee gees
weak......another idol cover this song and was much,much better...