Thanks to Helix Sleep for sponsoring this video. Helix is offering Toldinstone fans an exclusive discount: 27% off your mattress purchase, plus two free pillows. To take advantage of this offer, visit: helixsleep.com/toldinstone and use the promo code HELIXPARTNER27. This discount ends after Labor Day, but you’ll still get 20% off using my link. Offers subject to change. #helixsleep
I break my back as funeral clown yet the emperor lets non-romans stay on our rich arable land. I get they're just fleeing the Huns but I swear those Goths will be the end of good Roman society.
- Shabby, run down apartments that cost more than a labourer's annual income; - A handful of rich people owning most property; - Badly maintained, cramped and dirty housing; Truly, nothing changes.
But back then, it didn't have any negative effects to social cohesion and long term social structures...just like today right. That's why the empire is still so strong....
@@letsburn00 I disagree with you on that. The grain dole, public feasts and public spectacles like chariot races and gladiator fights were paid for, at great cost, to mollify the poor.
I often mistakenly assume that people in ancient times lived so differently as to be beyond my ability to imagine it, but the way you explain the topics of your videos helps me vividly picure them in a way that is so relatable and connecting. It makes me so excited to learn more about them! Thank you for your videos.
Circumstances change, but human nature doesn’t change much. Plumbing and electrify are the big differences between housing then and housing now- and even those technologies weren’t widely used until less than 200 years ago. That’s a short time compared to the 20 centuries since Augustus was Emperor.
Man some things truly never change do they? Despite the thousands of years and advancements in indoor plumbing, chucking my urine and feces out the window into the street below is still a favorite pastime.
I was just at Ostia earlier this month. I was absolutely floored to see how well the Insulae were preserved. The narrow streets flanked by brick walls reminded me a lot of Brownstones in america haha.
I'm amazed that a city of a million people just had a note somewhere saying like " to rent this insulae, talk to Capridonicus" with no description of the guy, no address to see the guy.
@@EireHammerI'm an introvert. I would spend a lot of money on getting scribes to write and send messages for me. This meeting could have been s scroll or wax tablet.
Hey boomer, did you have to "find John, he'll sort you out", with nothing else to go by, therefore you had to wander the streets and ask passerbys "do you know John"?
They were painted with white with caustic lime for the more plebeian units Few had the luxury of having them painted, as paint falls of and needs to be reapplied, frescos were very expensive and caustic lime is very permanent
This takes me back to my ninth grade Latin class. The teacher told us that the most important question when house-hunting in ancient Rome was whether the insula was likely to burn down or fall down. If it looked sturdy, it would likely burn down, so you'd want a room on the first or second floor. If it looked likely to fall down, you'd want something on the top floor.
Okay, now I finally understand why some of those colorful life summary Roman epitaphs note the deceased's relief that death means an end to paying rent.
The fact that they generally needed to get water from public sources got me thinking that the astrological sign Aquarius, the water-bearer (our name today still in Latin, although the Romans did not actually invent the zodiac), would have been a far more natural image for the ancients to imagine in the sky than it would be in the contemporary world. It’s just one more distant echo from the past, among the many that still surround us to this day.
We came across that 5 story insulae you mentioned the last time we were in Rome. From the sidewalk you can look down over the guard rail to see where the original street level was. It's pretty cool and easy to miss in this busy area.
The concept of a multifloor apartment building made of concrete and (maybe) with plumbing sounds so modern that it's insane to think that not only did such things exist 2 thousand years ago but that there also were thousands of them!
But that is where WE got the idea from. The Roman emperors were the first who built apts above their Malls. Yes, Malls. We have borrowed so much from the ancient Romans it is beyond belief. And did you know that the Romans actually copied and borrowed from the Davidic kingdom of the Old Testament! Fun fact: Hitler is the one that invented the Highway roads/ system. In Italy they are called the Autobahn.
@@SunsetBoulevard111 what davidic kingdom? there is 0 archaeological evidence for such a thing, though it's plausible that a local ruler of that name existed
@0_1_2 4 to 6 floors, solid concrete, 2 millenia ago, and it's NOT a major public work or ego project? And there's thousands of them? Yeah, I'm pretty impressed
I very much like the new studio, but you might want to consider the angle of the lighting, which at the moment seems to be quite overhead, casting a clear shadow down on the front of your shirt. A flatter angle, perhaps skewed horizontally, might be more flattering.
@JohnDoe-tv4zf I'm not speaking about "beauty," unimportant to Dr. Ryan's great content, which I have gladly watched for quite a while. I'm making a lighting suggestion which might further improve the new approach the channel is taking to its videography and staging.
@@Asa-bh7zi Overhead lighting is not a problem, he just needs side lights and a light from under that points upwards, that will give even lighting, even if he adjusted the overhead it wont do anything but cast the shadow otherwise. The best he can do is lower the brightness on it and invest in more side lights. For video, more is always better, for photo you can get away with a tri-point setup.
@SMGJohn Indeed, but if I had to work with one or limited lights I might try to cast the shadow "behind" him on the set just to push it away from the central visual point. Naturally the full array you describe would entirely eliminate the issue
You forgot to mention the part where if you owned an insuli and a fire spread from your insuli to another, you could be held legally liable for the damages. So you could lose your own insuli AND have to pay for another ten that burnt down. One good fire could bankrupt a wealthy family.
Wow what a great style: quiet, professional, direct and to the point, no sensationalism or politicking like Mary Beard. Seems like a very solid channel. Subscribed.
@@MrFredericandre During the day, yes. But after a whole summer, heat builds up anyway and it doesn't cool during the night. Sleeping in 30+ degrees without a breeze is not fun - from personal experience.
For anyone interested in the subject I can very highly recommend Janet DeLaine's recent book _Roman Architecture._ It does exactly what it states on the tin, is very easy to read, beautifully illustrated, and mostly free of jargon.
Man your intro to the commercial caught me off guard! I watched it and that's the first one that did not annoy me and I appreciate that. Helix is lucky to have you.
Congratulations on the best segue from content into commercial I have seen since the first ad I have seen on this platform. 🎉the “helix” bit you slid in after you pointed out the bed frame surviving from Herculeanium not being very nice………….”that’s because they didn’t have HELIX…….” I call that perfect timing, working and also the visual was exactly what the eye was expecting more of so it hit the reward centers in my brain and kept me there 🎉 well done well done from the title to the content, if I have to be sold stuff so that I can be told stuff, then it should always be this seamlessly validating experience.
I have a picture of that exact same bed I took in Herculaneum a few months ago! It’s amazing how much wood was preserved from the ash that fell on that town. Thinking of that sliding wood panel door
It is no any problem that we are living in these Rome houses, except the missing of some modern kitchen appliances, hygiene facilities and power convenience.
7:30 I have had a discussion about this claim and I believe the literary source merely states he stayed in an apartment overlaying a bath, but not that he lived there. And at that it really wasnt *above* the actual bathhouse and more so next to and overlooking, given the archeological finds in ostia of insulae-bathhouse combination properties
Always good Garrett. I notice recently that it's obvious you're looking down to your notes as you talk. You might think to invest in a cue reader in front of your camera to eliminate this distracting problem. Keep up the great work.
Thank you for the excellent and informative video I have been waiting for that other historians never write about these details. Now I’d love a video on the kind of jobs and pay and stores.
Thank you for years of excellent content, Garrett. Having studied history & economics for so long, it's always been a particularly compelling counterfactual to imagine how Imperial Rome would have progressed if it abolished its slave-based society & economy. I'd be VERY interested to see any kind of collaboration or exploration of the subject. And again, thanks as always for the fine work you do, and stay safe overseas!
Wow. That was the smoothest segue into an advertisement that I've ever seen. You have a lot going on in your mind! Don't be worried, Dr. Ryan, your content is very interesting. We won't leave! (Unless the boss is coming down the corridor.)
I was fortunate enough to be able to visit Ostia Antica, a short train ride from Rome, several years ago. There is an insula which is still in good enough condition for you to climb up to the third floor in. It was very cool.
I'm sitting here listening to this, and looking at the picture of the insula,in your opening and straight ahead and above me is a picture of my mom's house in Italy when she was a young girl , and it's designed the same way ! exactly, store 1st, and living rooms 3 story's up.
In London 10 years ago my sister was paying more than that for a room. Not even particularly central, either. I'm glad she left. Now she has a lovely house
Do you provide a list of your sources? Im studying architecture and land use and this is a gold mine for historical context. Any other civilizations would be great too like the mycenaean empire.
Thanks to Helix Sleep for sponsoring this video. Helix is offering Toldinstone fans an exclusive discount: 27% off your mattress purchase, plus two free pillows. To take advantage of this offer, visit: helixsleep.com/toldinstone and use the promo code HELIXPARTNER27. This discount ends after Labor Day, but you’ll still get 20% off using my link. Offers subject to change. #helixsleep
Fascinating ☺ Nothing new under the sun. Sigh.
great commercial segue lol
I can't stand mattresses. My bed is more like the Roman bed shown in the video. Sorry, Helix.
Killer Segue into the ad! Cumia would be proud
Your sponsor missed a trick surely by not naming their kingsize bed the 'Double Helix'?
Getting an insula these days is ridiculus! A 1 bedroom floor in Rome cost 69 denarii/month! Thanks Tiberius!
I break my back as funeral clown yet the emperor lets non-romans stay on our rich arable land. I get they're just fleeing the Huns but I swear those Goths will be the end of good Roman society.
People need to stop blaming Tiberius we all know well it was Augustus who's at fault
69 .. nice
Tiberionomics?
That's nothing. In Novo Yorkus, rent is 7,000 sestertii a month.
- Shabby, run down apartments that cost more than a labourer's annual income;
- A handful of rich people owning most property;
- Badly maintained, cramped and dirty housing;
Truly, nothing changes.
The more things change, the more they stay the same.
But back then, it didn't have any negative effects to social cohesion and long term social structures...just like today right. That's why the empire is still so strong....
like newyork appartments
@@letsburn00 I disagree with you on that. The grain dole, public feasts and public spectacles like chariot races and gladiator fights were paid for, at great cost, to mollify the poor.
@@letsburn00 The Roman Empire fell....
“insulae were built by wealthy speculators”….it sounds SO much like what we have today in Rome. I feel my hometown will never change nor evolve.
If it makes you feel better, pretty much all apartment buildings are like this in cities around the world
I often mistakenly assume that people in ancient times lived so differently as to be beyond my ability to imagine it, but the way you explain the topics of your videos helps me vividly picure them in a way that is so relatable and connecting. It makes me so excited to learn more about them! Thank you for your videos.
Circumstances change, but human nature doesn’t change much.
Plumbing and electrify are the big differences between housing then and housing now- and even those technologies weren’t widely used until less than 200 years ago. That’s a short time compared to the 20 centuries since Augustus was Emperor.
Man some things truly never change do they? Despite the thousands of years and advancements in indoor plumbing, chucking my urine and feces out the window into the street below is still a favorite pastime.
Oh, it isn’t watching a fleet of sharks fight a slave galley in the coliseum during an aquatic show?
I see you are living in a very diverse and inclusive hood
well yeah... depends how much vinum you have at the party. 😄
bro i was just thinking the same thing
I was just at Ostia earlier this month. I was absolutely floored to see how well the Insulae were preserved. The narrow streets flanked by brick walls reminded me a lot of Brownstones in america haha.
Convergent....architecture? Need follows form follows function?
@@MM22966I’m from DC and we took like half the building designs from Greco-Roman style. It’s probably deliberate
@@nickywags0712 Yeah, but we're talking row housing, not a governmental place with dorian columns.
I'm amazed that a city of a million people just had a note somewhere saying like " to rent this insulae, talk to Capridonicus" with no description of the guy, no address to see the guy.
I’m sure that they had basic office hours
*Gasp* we had to _talk_ to people to find out local information?!?😂😂😂
@@EireHammerI'm an introvert. I would spend a lot of money on getting scribes to write and send messages for me. This meeting could have been s scroll or wax tablet.
Zoomer detected. The world was really different before mobile phones...
Hey boomer, did you have to "find John, he'll sort you out", with nothing else to go by, therefore you had to wander the streets and ask passerbys "do you know John"?
If only Nero had mattress from Helix, he might been an alright leader.
He only needed a good nights sleep
4:56 Glad to see the interiors weren't just "landlord white" paint.
They were painted with white with caustic lime for the more plebeian units
Few had the luxury of having them painted, as paint falls of and needs to be reapplied, frescos were very expensive and caustic lime is very permanent
@@alezar2035 Oh!
This takes me back to my ninth grade Latin class. The teacher told us that the most important question when house-hunting in ancient Rome was whether the insula was likely to burn down or fall down. If it looked sturdy, it would likely burn down, so you'd want a room on the first or second floor. If it looked likely to fall down, you'd want something on the top floor.
Okay, now I finally understand why some of those colorful life summary Roman epitaphs note the deceased's relief that death means an end to paying rent.
Love the mock-up rental website.
It should be a real thing. Updated as new archeological finds and documents get unearthed.
The fact that they generally needed to get water from public sources got me thinking that the astrological sign Aquarius, the water-bearer (our name today still in Latin, although the Romans did not actually invent the zodiac), would have been a far more natural image for the ancients to imagine in the sky than it would be in the contemporary world. It’s just one more distant echo from the past, among the many that still surround us to this day.
At 6:00 "...leased to investors who sublet..." Wow, some things never change!
We came across that 5 story insulae you mentioned the last time we were in Rome. From the sidewalk you can look down over the guard rail to see where the original street level was. It's pretty cool and easy to miss in this busy area.
Even ancient romans could not escape the 5-over-1
😆
V
I
That segue to the advert was masterful.
God I’m thankful for modern plumbing
Imagine the _graffiti_ 'Cicero's a slum landlord' having an impact on the annual election...
Cicero: if i were a slumlord, if my apartments were so bad then why my tenants, my clients, always leave me tips?
OK, I was not expecting that, 5:02 , actual historical glass panes. That is just so kick ass.
I chuckled at the notes on the chalkboard.
Ok, I laughed at that Helix ad transition.
Why don’t you go ahead and buy one then, buddy?
This isn’t the channel for cheap laughs. It’s a business..
@@0_1_2 you sound offended? He just thought its funny
@@0_1_2 watch out for this alpha male right here
@@0_1_2my bad I forgot he doesn’t make ad revenue. Wait….
@@0_1_2 I'm not your buddy, Pal!
You telling me what to look out for and how to rent an apartment in Ancient Rome is exactly what I use the internet for.....
Subbed
The concept of a multifloor apartment building made of concrete and (maybe) with plumbing sounds so modern that it's insane to think that not only did such things exist 2 thousand years ago but that there also were thousands of them!
But that is where WE got the idea from. The Roman emperors were the first who built apts above their Malls. Yes, Malls. We have borrowed so much from the ancient Romans it is beyond belief. And did you know that the Romans actually copied and borrowed from the Davidic kingdom of the Old Testament! Fun fact: Hitler is the one that invented the Highway roads/ system. In Italy they are called the Autobahn.
@@SunsetBoulevard111 what davidic kingdom? there is 0 archaeological evidence for such a thing, though it's plausible that a local ruler of that name existed
This is MTR Domus and this is my crib *pans to windowless apartment 3 stories up*
Multifloor building sound insane to you? 🤨
@0_1_2 4 to 6 floors, solid concrete, 2 millenia ago, and it's NOT a major public work or ego project? And there's thousands of them? Yeah, I'm pretty impressed
I very much like the new studio, but you might want to consider the angle of the lighting, which at the moment seems to be quite overhead, casting a clear shadow down on the front of your shirt. A flatter angle, perhaps skewed horizontally, might be more flattering.
Beauty is on the inside champ.
@JohnDoe-tv4zf I'm not speaking about "beauty," unimportant to Dr. Ryan's great content, which I have gladly watched for quite a while. I'm making a lighting suggestion which might further improve the new approach the channel is taking to its videography and staging.
@@Asa-bh7zi
Overhead lighting is not a problem, he just needs side lights and a light from under that points upwards, that will give even lighting, even if he adjusted the overhead it wont do anything but cast the shadow otherwise.
The best he can do is lower the brightness on it and invest in more side lights. For video, more is always better, for photo you can get away with a tri-point setup.
@SMGJohn Indeed, but if I had to work with one or limited lights I might try to cast the shadow "behind" him on the set just to push it away from the central visual point. Naturally the full array you describe would entirely eliminate the issue
I was going to have an opinion about this until I realized I watch both Mr Beat and Spectacles and love both their styles
aaaaaa, Rome comes to life again, thank you....
This information about how these people lived is absolutely captivating. Thanks for the video
You forgot to mention the part where if you owned an insuli and a fire spread from your insuli to another, you could be held legally liable for the damages. So you could lose your own insuli AND have to pay for another ten that burnt down. One good fire could bankrupt a wealthy family.
Heh, living in a giant round amphora sounds more like my budget.
The Helix plug got me good
TH-cam is better because of this channel.
Been following for a few years, love your channel! Excited for the new additions.
I really liked the video. It was very instructive. Thanks.🌎
Wow what a great style: quiet, professional, direct and to the point, no sensationalism or politicking like Mary Beard. Seems like a very solid channel. Subscribed.
2:40 Great transition. Made me chuckle.
A windowless bedroom during a Roman Summer, especially during the Roman Warm Period, sounds close to hellish.
Nah, it was probably closed during the day, thus cooler inside.
Had to be cooler than it is now
@@MrFredericandre During the day, yes. But after a whole summer, heat builds up anyway and it doesn't cool during the night. Sleeping in 30+ degrees without a breeze is not fun - from personal experience.
Mosquito time.
Oh I misread that, sorry.
IT'S MALARIA TIME.
No mosquitos, less noise and fewer weird smells sounds sort of ideal, even with the heat.
I love the way you lead into your sponsorships.
If you love it so much Then how come you didn’t purchase one of the mattresses?
@@0_1_2 Probably because they're terrible. They have to be if they're advertising on youtube.
Reminded me of the terrifying experience first time I ever released a spiral-packed spring mattress from its vacuum-packed cocoon.
I found the chalkboard notes inspiring!
I always learn something. Great stuff.
The changes to the chanel are well thought through!
I gotta say, that was one of the best transitions to a sponsor message I've ever seen.
Right?! I thought Helix was an actual ancient mattress.
really enjoying the new style cuz, keep it up
Much appreciated!
Oh, that ad transition was amazing!
For anyone interested in the subject I can very highly recommend Janet DeLaine's recent book _Roman Architecture._ It does exactly what it states on the tin, is very easy to read, beautifully illustrated, and mostly free of jargon.
Ooh yes, please. That's going on my Christmas list. Thanks!
Thanks for the suggestion. Does it have any advertisements for mattresses?
Thank you!
Love your videos, Garrett!
Is it just me or does the audio sound crisp? I love it!
It's fascinating that so many things in the ancient past are so similar (if not the same) as today.
I suppose some things never really change.
Human nature. Go figure. How stunning that human beings have acted in their own perceived best interest before us.
Man your intro to the commercial caught me off guard!
I watched it and that's the first one that did not annoy me and I appreciate that.
Helix is lucky to have you.
Excellent! Thank you!
Great video, thank you for sharing.
I enjoy your distinctive voice as a Narrator. I have enjoyed all your research.
Congratulations on the best segue from content into commercial I have seen since the first ad I have seen on this platform. 🎉the “helix” bit you slid in after you pointed out the bed frame surviving from Herculeanium not being very nice………….”that’s because they didn’t have HELIX…….” I call that perfect timing, working and also the visual was exactly what the eye was expecting more of so it hit the reward centers in my brain and kept me there 🎉 well done well done from the title to the content, if I have to be sold stuff so that I can be told stuff, then it should always be this seamlessly validating experience.
Thanks so much for this! I'm going to Rome in 3 weeks and was finding stuff to do. So I'm planning on going to the Ostia Antica.
Have you heard of the Colosseum? It was a popular place for Christians to unwind.
Maybe two full days at Ostia; there's much there to appreciate.
You won't be sorry. Ostia was a memorable place, buildings notably complete.
Quousque tandem, Cambricus,!
Welcome back! It was about time for you to get out of your ínsula and meet us in the forum !
I think I read somewhere, maybe in a book my Mary Beard, that the Romans did have Helix mattresses.
I love the new format! May I suggest you invest in a teleprompter.
I have a picture of that exact same bed I took in Herculaneum a few months ago! It’s amazing how much wood was preserved from the ash that fell on that town. Thinking of that sliding wood panel door
It is no any problem that we are
living in these Rome houses, except
the missing of some modern kitchen
appliances, hygiene facilities and
power convenience.
Fascinating as always Dr. Ryan. Thank you.
Peaceful Skies
Youre a beast toldinstone
Remarkable that one of these structures still exists almost 2000 years after. Testimony to quality workmanship.
Its slays fascinating to see how they did things then and to see how things haven't really changed much.
7:30 I have had a discussion about this claim and I believe the literary source merely states he stayed in an apartment overlaying a bath, but not that he lived there. And at that it really wasnt *above* the actual bathhouse and more so next to and overlooking, given the archeological finds in ostia of insulae-bathhouse combination properties
Pompeii would have been rebuilt if it were insured. Ask the Geico Gecko about home insurance today.
😀
This was so good! thank you for making this!
Awesome video! Love these ones that deal with the day to day dealings of average Roman citizens
Always good Garrett. I notice recently that it's obvious you're looking down to your notes as you talk. You might think to invest in a cue reader in front of your camera to eliminate this distracting problem. Keep up the great work.
Great video! I can't wait to check out your new book!!
How little has it changed!
Thank you for the excellent and informative video I have been waiting for that other historians never write about these details.
Now I’d love a video on the kind of jobs and pay and stores.
Great video! Thank you.
Very interesting video, love the details of life and the descriptions.
i love the elevtaed foundations, & the tiny sets of stairs leading in to the structures! i'm sure they were precautious of water and flooding . . .
I was wondering about that. Thanks for filling that gap. Wall colors and frescos are interesting. Sometimes I'm thinking of doing my place like that.
Thanks for all your hard work on these videos...👍
interesting as always loving the new setup
Algo feeding comment.
Rewrite that in Latin!
@@markmuller7962 commentarium hic est algorithmum pascendi
@@protocetid Well done 😄
I think the comment needs to be at least 7 words for the algo to pick it up. But noble effort.
One of my favorites so far, watching for second time. Good job :):):)
Some things never change! Great video. Your channel is so very
So very… WHAT?
Thank you for years of excellent content, Garrett. Having studied history & economics for so long, it's always been a particularly compelling counterfactual to imagine how Imperial Rome would have progressed if it abolished its slave-based society & economy. I'd be VERY interested to see any kind of collaboration or exploration of the subject. And again, thanks as always for the fine work you do, and stay safe overseas!
Helix mattress transition is top notch.
Wow. That was the smoothest segue into an advertisement that I've ever seen. You have a lot going on in your mind! Don't be worried, Dr. Ryan, your content is very interesting. We won't leave! (Unless the boss is coming down the corridor.)
I was fortunate enough to be able to visit Ostia Antica, a short train ride from Rome, several years ago. There is an insula which is still in good enough condition for you to climb up to the third floor in. It was very cool.
I'm sitting here listening to this, and looking at the picture of the insula,in your opening and straight ahead and above me is a picture of my mom's house in Italy when she was a young girl , and it's designed the same way ! exactly, store 1st, and living rooms 3 story's up.
9:20 goodness me. Ive walked past that very building and stopped for a few minutes to examine it. 😊
Oh how I miss the good ole days!
It’s really fascinating how the real estate market worked in era throughout history. Are there any sources for other societies throughout antiquity?
I had to pay $800 a month in Brooklyn for just a room. Here in the Appalachians, I rent an entire townhouse for the same price!
In London 10 years ago my sister was paying more than that for a room. Not even particularly central, either. I'm glad she left. Now she has a lovely house
Nice! What’s it like living in the middle of nowhere miles away from anything important?
In 2005 I paid 1100 a month for a room in Vail.
I paid 1500 for a small studio in dowtown SLC last year. The place was built in 1904 and probably just as flammable as an insulae.
The advertisement tie-in almost made me cry. I love this channel but I can't escape ads even when I think I'm safe.
Ah, a fellow "side sleeper." Nice segway to the promo.
That ad transition was so smooth it had me thinking "hmm you're right yes the Romans didn't have modern beds did they..."
I saw where that last insulae was located, near the coliseum and the circus and I just went "oh, oh shit that looks expensive, way too expensive"
Location, location, location
3:26 that bed is so tall he’s practically halfway to the ceiling
Do you provide a list of your sources? Im studying architecture and land use and this is a gold mine for historical context. Any other civilizations would be great too like the mycenaean empire.
Ok, that chalkboard is just perfect. :)
I’ve been so used to looking at listings while apartment hunting that the Rillow listing hardly registered as out of place
This channel is my Roman Empire.
That ad segue hit me like a ballista.
I will be watching your Blackboard closely 😘 this was really fascinating. Thank you🎉