항상 그렇듯이 법륜스님의 정직하면서도 때로는 실랄한 정확한 통찰력에 존경을 표합니다. 이런 모든 사항을 영어로 재창작하시는 동시통역사분도 진심 존경합니다. 법륜스님의 명강의가 최고의 동시통역사분에 의하여 더 많은 전세계 사람들에게 전달되어 위로와 깨달음을 받기를 원합니다. (I do always admire Ven. Pomnyun's honest, sharp and correct insight(answer) and the simultaneous interpreter's wonderful translation. Hope every video of his lecture spread all over the world so they can get comfort and awakening enlightenment~ )
How do Buddhists resolve the contradiction that everything is impermanent and beings are reincarnated? Even the enlightened are somewhere forever. It seems to me that our essence is permanent. Whether it is our soul or our self, it exists forever and is indestructible. The Dalai Lama is the reincarnation of Avalokiteshvara, the Bodhisattva of compassion and mercy as were all his predecessors. Thank you
종교라고 하는 것은 힘들때 무언가 바라고 요청하는게 종교의 특성이다. 본인 앞에 집착을 놔라 하는 것은 철학적인 요소와 수행적인 요소고, 복을 주세요 하는 것은 종교적인 요소다. 모순이 있을 수밖에 없다. 어느게 옳다는 건 없다. 이렇다고 정해진 답은 없다. 우린 이러한 모순을 탐구하는 거다. 탐구하다보면 여러분들은 갈등할 필요가 없는 상황에 이르게 된다. (수행의 목표는 자유와 행복이다. ) 종교는 다르지만 저도 수행자입니다. ^^ 감사합니다.
Of course there are contridictions, buddhism is a manmade belief and I am proud of this fact… tthere is no claim for divinity, this is made by human all with our intelligence and flaws. The only constant is change, buddha’s words are not finite, it’s only a guidance for you to make your own decisions whether that leads you to god, or enlightenment or just being a good human being. It doesn’t matter
Yes.. you are right but it is that peoples problem.Otherwise it is not a contradiction in the buddism. That is not a problem in buddist philosophy. It is these peoples prpblem.
The question was a simple one...and its not about contradiction but about why does the temple feels the need to put someone's name to the donation. Total evasion of the question....oh well...
I don' agree on the part that buddhism had some influence from indian ancient tradition because buddha rejected the idea of rites and ritual , caste system and creator god which was very much prevelant at that time ...moreover buddhism is a part of Shramanic tradition. ..buddha imphasised on non self(anatma ),which has its root in dependent origination or emptiness and vipasana (ensight meditation to know the true nature of reality ),self creation instead of creator god. ..which is still to this day concepts only found in buddhist tradition. ..
Tenzin Negi by Indian cultural influence he is talking about cultural aspect of buddhism which passed on from india, china then to korea. On Buddhism as a practice and its base teachings (as buddha himself taught) his view is same as yours.
kleeo83 buddhism is not linked with any culture nor their is any concept of holy land. .. ..Buddhism is not even a religion it is a practice and philosophy. ..That's why buddhism in china or chinese buddhism(combation of taoism and confucianism ) is very different from what is practised in srilanka or india. .
Tenzin Negi As Buddhist fundamental describe all is empty. Buddhism as religion exists, not as an idea but as a medium to carry that core idea. To exist on Buddhism has developed a way to coexist with cultural practices with that land. That is no different even with southeast asia or india, Only different in its cultural aspect. The core idea of Buddhism itself is universal.
@@believer1465 As Buddhism traveled throughout the world, and even as time passed in India, it began to incorporated local aspects of the time and place. Even Sri Lankan Buddhism is influenced by Hindu practices (Richard Gombrich). Additionally, as soon as 100 years of the Buddha's Mahaparinibbana we can see the local Indian influences taking place in form of the 1st Buddhist Schism of the Sthravira and Mahasamghikas. Furthermore contemporary Indian Buddhism has been imported from Sri Lanka, Myanmar, and Bangladesh. However, the biggest influence in the revival of Indian Buddhism is due to Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar who convinced many of the "Dalits" to convert to Buddhism.
She asked an excellent question, he completely avoided the answer. The thing is that right at this moment in history Korean society is completely materialistic and judgmental. If I donate money to the temple in exchange for a prayer I also receive an upgrade in social recognition. But that has nothing to do with a true teachings of Buddha, Pomnyun sunim.
Do share your thoughts. I believe 법륜스님 answered beautifully in a single sentence. By admitting there are contradictions to the religion itself. I also thought her question was beautiful and admit that she was absolutely right. I suspect you misunderstood the translation.
1. You misunderstood the answer. He explained by recognizing the contradictions in his own religion. 2. You also make a broad assumption that Korea is "completely" materialistic and judgemental, but Korea is also very secular at the same time. No one would bat an eye even if you donate one million dollars to a church, temple, w/e, unless you're deeply involved in that religious community, which is not the majority.
What an intelligent woman. That's just one of the contradictions in Budhism, even Budha's own 4 noble truths contradict each other. If you want true peace, come to Jesus Christ! "For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son, so whoever believes on him should have eternal life." John 3:16
In 4 noble truth there is no any contradictions. If you think like that that reminds your misunderstanding about that. There might be contradictions in your understandings not in buddhas teachings.
Some simple reasoning shows that it does contradict itself. The four noble truths 1.) Suffering exists 2.) Suffering is caused by desire 3) eliminate desire to eliminate suffering 4) following eightfold path rids desire and reaches nirvana. Firstly, we all have desire so it's impossible to rid desire, unless we are dead. Secondly, following the eightfold path would be, by definition, "desire" so you haven't ended any desire, a clear self- contradiction
@@cedward85 see thats why i told that you are misunderstood. Buddha himself said that if someone want to become enlightened then they have desire. And that desire also will remove after the enlightenment and then they don't want to show or teached about that. Onece buddha said " we use a boat only for cross the rever.you Don't take the boat and put it in your back after when you cross the rever." Desire and the dhramma buddha taugt is the boat and it is only useful until you become enlightened. After that you don't need it anymore and you don't try to protect it or spred it unless if someone asked you to explain it to them or teach it to them. Thats why buddhism teached disire is not a bad thing but a thing must be control by ourselves until we become enlightened
@@cedward85 and you wil see if you see it carefully in eightfold path that how you should practice it .buddhism is to practice. When you practice eightfold path then you will learn how to control your disires and you will see what is the corse of desires and then you know how to use that desires also. Continues practice is the main path to enlightenment and it is not always happening in one life. Buddha also spent milions of births to learn and practice it. Enlightenment didn't just happened in one night. It is a result of that practice.
@@udayangadananjaya7914 well i have read a lot of teaching too but i observe a contradiction on what you say too. practice and control implies effort so there is a motive of desire behind it. if you control your desires it is a motive to achieve something that's in the field of the known so its out of the meditation state. no you don't need time to become enlightened because otherwise you operate in the field of time which is a psychological product of thought . that product is the ego which is illusion so gautama didn't become enlightened because of practice but because he observed or understood that through practice and effort the mind works in the field of the ego. that's why the moment he rejected his strict austerities of 7 years was outside of that field and then there is only the state of peace (enlightenment).
If he is awakened then he is not dead. I know he is not dead for sure so then he is some where in some form but awakened. So why do you not search for that Buddha who is awakened and present in both world. Ritual are ok but extreme longing and thoughtful of Awakened Buddha will definitely yield in supreme Union.
At least this channel doesn't have any ads. Well done 🙏🙏🙏 and thank you for that! 👍 🙏
Such a clear explanation about Buddhism. Thank you.
동시 통역 하시는분 실력이
대단 합니다~~~^^
행복하고 자유로우세요 . 말씀감사합니다.
항상 그렇듯이 법륜스님의 정직하면서도 때로는 실랄한 정확한 통찰력에 존경을 표합니다. 이런 모든 사항을 영어로 재창작하시는 동시통역사분도 진심 존경합니다. 법륜스님의 명강의가 최고의 동시통역사분에 의하여 더 많은 전세계 사람들에게 전달되어 위로와 깨달음을 받기를 원합니다. (I do always admire Ven. Pomnyun's honest, sharp and correct insight(answer) and the simultaneous interpreter's wonderful translation. Hope every video of his lecture spread all over the world so they can get comfort and awakening enlightenment~ )
Master is great!!
Great question and brilliant answer.
Very clear answer to the question. Many aspects of Buddhism based on the culture and focus. Thanks! #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Respectfully impressive!
How do Buddhists resolve the contradiction that everything is impermanent and beings are reincarnated? Even the enlightened are somewhere forever.
It seems to me that our essence is permanent. Whether it is our soul or our self, it exists forever and is indestructible.
The Dalai Lama is the reincarnation of Avalokiteshvara, the Bodhisattva of compassion and mercy as were all his predecessors.
Thank you
Thank you ..our great Pummyum dharma......
동시통역정말대단하십니다.
진리는 부처님과 예수님께 있지 않고 수행정진에 있음을 다시 한 번 깨닫고 갑니다..
법륜스님께 무한한 은혜를 입고 갑니다..법륜스님의 자비심과 자비행에 큰 감명을 받고 갑니다..
고맙습니다..법륜스님...
동시통역하시는분 대단하당
😂동시통역이 아니라 순차통역
@@고소미-n9s 동시통역이당
1. 복을 비는 종교
2. 심오한 철학
3. 행복과 자유를 위한 수행
부천님의 지혜의 말씀을 영어로 배울수 있어 감사합니다 부산에서~~~🧎♀️🧎♂️🧎♀️🙏🙏🙏
부천님이 아니라 인천님😂
Words of wisdom. Thank you! #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Thank you for sharing your wisdom with others. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
I love how she was blurred out first and showen in full focus afterwards 🙊
And thank you for speech...
Beautiful explanation 👏
thank you for your wise words and for your peaceful presence and example dearest Pomnyun Sunim!
Great way to learn buddha's teaching. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
혼자있어도 외롭지않고
둘이있어도 귀찮지 않고
이런상황이 될수있다.
종교라고 하는 것은 힘들때 무언가 바라고 요청하는게 종교의 특성이다. 본인 앞에 집착을 놔라 하는 것은 철학적인 요소와 수행적인 요소고, 복을 주세요 하는 것은 종교적인 요소다. 모순이 있을 수밖에 없다. 어느게 옳다는 건 없다. 이렇다고 정해진 답은 없다. 우린 이러한 모순을 탐구하는 거다. 탐구하다보면 여러분들은 갈등할 필요가 없는 상황에 이르게 된다. (수행의 목표는 자유와 행복이다. )
종교는 다르지만 저도 수행자입니다. ^^ 감사합니다.
Thank you our great dharma.......last. Couple yrs walking. With Sunims inspirational. Sometime with. Philosophic. Point. View. Then. To. Spiritual and. Over al. Respect. As. Religiously....So happy. And. Grateful......
Jesus Christ is truth!!! Jesus is God!!!
This is an amazing lecture. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Insights to look at every angle and understand the truth. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Thank you for your teaching. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Very simple but effective way to ~ #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Of course there are contridictions, buddhism is a manmade belief and I am proud of this fact… tthere is no claim for divinity, this is made by human all with our intelligence and flaws. The only constant is change, buddha’s words are not finite, it’s only a guidance for you to make your own decisions whether that leads you to god, or enlightenment or just being a good human being. It doesn’t matter
Your saying is always impressive. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
재밌네요 어디서 강연한건가요? 더 업로드해주세요!!
@richdog82 알려주셔서 감사합니다!
Very interesting and clear answer! #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
It is very helpful. Thank you. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Very inspiring, Thanks! #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
Spiritual practice Buddhism ! #pomnyun #jungtosociety
Yes.. you are right but it is that peoples problem.Otherwise it is not a contradiction in the buddism. That is not a problem in buddist philosophy. It is these peoples prpblem.
His explanation is realistic. #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
The question was a simple one...and its not about contradiction but about why does the temple feels the need to put someone's name to the donation. Total evasion of the question....oh well...
He didn't evade anything. It was very clear to me.
Buddhism as a practice
I learned well.😃
#pomnyun, #JungtoSociety
🙏🙇😍😻🙌
👏👏👏👏👏😍
thank you. #buddhism #contradictions #pomnyun
🙏🙏 Good good.
🙏🙏🙏
Sadhu, Sadhu, Sadhu!
I can see the women who asked the question although you masked it 1st. :P
부처님과 아난존자
I don' agree on the part that buddhism had some influence from indian ancient tradition because buddha rejected the idea of rites and ritual , caste system and creator god which was very much prevelant at that time ...moreover buddhism is a part of Shramanic tradition. ..buddha imphasised on non self(anatma ),which has its root in dependent origination or emptiness and vipasana (ensight meditation to know the true nature of reality ),self creation instead of creator god. ..which is still to this day concepts only found in buddhist tradition. ..
Tenzin Negi by Indian cultural influence he is talking about cultural aspect of buddhism which passed on from india, china then to korea. On Buddhism as a practice and its base teachings (as buddha himself taught) his view is same as yours.
kleeo83 buddhism is not linked with any culture nor their is any concept of holy land. .. ..Buddhism is not even a religion it is a practice and philosophy. ..That's why buddhism in china or chinese buddhism(combation of taoism and confucianism ) is very different from what is practised in srilanka or india. .
Tenzin Negi As Buddhist fundamental describe all is empty. Buddhism as religion exists, not as an idea but as a medium to carry that core idea. To exist on Buddhism has developed a way to coexist with cultural practices with that land. That is no different even with southeast asia or india, Only different in its cultural aspect. The core idea of Buddhism itself is universal.
@@believer1465 As Buddhism traveled throughout the world, and even as time passed in India, it began to incorporated local aspects of the time and place. Even Sri Lankan Buddhism is influenced by Hindu practices (Richard Gombrich). Additionally, as soon as 100 years of the Buddha's Mahaparinibbana we can see the local Indian influences taking place in form of the 1st Buddhist Schism of the Sthravira and Mahasamghikas. Furthermore contemporary Indian Buddhism has been imported from Sri Lanka, Myanmar, and Bangladesh. However, the biggest influence in the revival of Indian Buddhism is due to Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar who convinced many of the "Dalits" to convert to Buddhism.
불교에 대해 잘못 알고 계신듯한데요..
어디서 누구한테 불교에 대해 배웠어요?
철학과 수행만이 있다 종교관습은 받지 말자!!!
여기 어디서 즉문즉설 하신 건지 아는 분 계세요?
조계사라 적혀있네요
She asked an excellent question,
he completely avoided the answer.
The thing is that right at this moment in history Korean society is completely materialistic and judgmental.
If I donate money to the temple in exchange for a prayer I also receive an upgrade in social recognition.
But that has nothing to do with a true teachings of Buddha, Pomnyun sunim.
Do share your thoughts. I believe 법륜스님 answered beautifully in a single sentence. By admitting there are contradictions to the religion itself.
I also thought her question was beautiful and admit that she was absolutely right. I suspect you misunderstood the translation.
1. You misunderstood the answer. He explained by recognizing the contradictions in his own religion. 2. You also make a broad assumption that Korea is "completely" materialistic and judgemental, but Korea is also very secular at the same time. No one would bat an eye even if you donate one million dollars to a church, temple, w/e, unless you're deeply involved in that religious community, which is not the majority.
법륜스님도 일본에서 일본불교를 체험삼아서 결혼생활을 한번 경험해 😝😍보세요!
master!!!!!there are no controdictions in bhuddism!!!the controdiction is in you!!!shame on you!!!dont mislead the crowd.
Buddy be tolerant she just asked a question chill
r u sure u r not looking at the mirror!lol
r u sure u r not looking at the mirror!lol@Tony Droid
Did you even make it to the half mark of his talk?
What an intelligent woman. That's just one of the contradictions in Budhism, even Budha's own 4 noble truths contradict each other. If you want true peace, come to Jesus Christ! "For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son, so whoever believes on him should have eternal life."
John 3:16
In 4 noble truth there is no any contradictions. If you think like that that reminds your misunderstanding about that. There might be contradictions in your understandings not in buddhas teachings.
Some simple reasoning shows that it does contradict itself. The four noble truths 1.) Suffering exists 2.) Suffering is caused by desire 3) eliminate desire to eliminate suffering 4) following eightfold path rids desire and reaches nirvana. Firstly, we all have desire so it's impossible to rid desire, unless we are dead. Secondly, following the eightfold path would be, by definition, "desire" so you haven't ended any desire, a clear self- contradiction
@@cedward85 see thats why i told that you are misunderstood. Buddha himself said that if someone want to become enlightened then they have desire. And that desire also will remove after the enlightenment and then they don't want to show or teached about that. Onece buddha said " we use a boat only for cross the rever.you Don't take the boat and put it in your back after when you cross the rever." Desire and the dhramma buddha taugt is the boat and it is only useful until you become enlightened. After that you don't need it anymore and you don't try to protect it or spred it unless if someone asked you to explain it to them or teach it to them. Thats why buddhism teached disire is not a bad thing but a thing must be control by ourselves until we become enlightened
@@cedward85 and you wil see if you see it carefully in eightfold path that how you should practice it .buddhism is to practice. When you practice eightfold path then you will learn how to control your disires and you will see what is the corse of desires and then you know how to use that desires also. Continues practice is the main path to enlightenment and it is not always happening in one life. Buddha also spent milions of births to learn and practice it. Enlightenment didn't just happened in one night. It is a result of that practice.
@@udayangadananjaya7914 well i have read a lot of teaching too but i observe a contradiction on what you say too. practice and control implies effort so there is a motive of desire behind it. if you control your desires it is a motive to achieve something that's in the field of the known so its out of the meditation state. no you don't need time to become enlightened because otherwise you operate in the field of time which is a psychological product of thought . that product is the ego which is illusion so gautama didn't become enlightened because of practice but because he observed or understood that through practice and effort the mind works in the field of the ego. that's why the moment he rejected his strict austerities of 7 years was outside of that field and then there is only the state of peace (enlightenment).
If he is awakened then he is not dead. I know he is not dead for sure so then he is some where in some form but awakened. So why do you not search for that Buddha who is awakened and present in both world. Ritual are ok but extreme longing and thoughtful of Awakened Buddha will definitely yield in supreme Union.
Thank you for your teaching! #pomnyun, #JungtoSociety