Another great show 😊 Jacob you always manage to put forward well thought out questions to your guests. Drawing out informative answers. I'm forever learning, Thankyou
@@dunk_lawThe fact that it will have been more sensible to create just only one Diatessaron-like Gospel & falsely attribute it to Peter or James-instead of having 3 synoptics Gospels known as having SUB-apostolic authors such as Mark & Luke, and one attributed to Matthew whom we know for a fact authored a Semitic-Language Gospel that was translated into Greek, and therefore, of whom a Greek version of his Gospel served as a source for our canonical "Matthew"
Great video. Dr. Roth is both erudite and elocuent. Marcion without a doubt was a major player. If he were not there would not be so many Christians queueing up to denounce him. Also I believe that without him there would be no Paul as he had all the letters and made them widely known through his followers.
The fact that there are 3 synoptics & one Johannine gospels when just one merged single gospel would have been far more sensible as a response to Marcion
Mark and Matthew have hard sayings of Jesus missing in Luke like the Syrophoenician woman who Jesus rejects at first and refers to her people as dogs. That being the case, Marcion edited that out and some Yahwistic passages about "evil god". His editing is our Luke today.He didn't see the many Judahite deities like El, Baal,Adonay fused with Yahweh unfortunately.
Please buy a lavalier mic so you can wire it up to your guests to improve audio. We can hear him but you're officially a big content creator now, you need to hire an audio/visual assistant
I wish I was live i would have asked him if the varient n jude 5 ie jesus or god christ or lord *see vs jude 4* may be a marcionite rebuttal to his antithesis.
Morrissey College of Arts and Sciences - "The Department’s five primary areas of research include biblical studies, comparative theology, history of Christianity, >>>systematic theology
Also Reformed Theological Seminary if im not mistaken I think he is a former student of Michael J Kruger, former undergrad of Ehrman and phd under Larry Hurtado.
Get Dieter Roth's book! ➡📚amzn.to/3WqFcon
Wow! The caliber of your guests are super impressive. Dr. Roth is a big deal in this space! Well done 👏🏼
Lmao caliber
Longed for you to have him on! Awesome!
You asked all of the most important questions and he gave great answers!
Keep up the good work!
Another great show 😊 Jacob you always manage to put forward well thought out questions to your guests. Drawing out informative answers. I'm forever learning, Thankyou
Marcion wasn't the first to come up with a gospel , he was just the first one to put Christian writings together into a canon
And your evidence for that is?
@@dunk_lawThe fact that it will have been more sensible to create just only one Diatessaron-like Gospel & falsely attribute it to Peter or James-instead of having 3 synoptics Gospels known as having SUB-apostolic authors such as Mark & Luke, and one attributed to Matthew whom we know for a fact authored a Semitic-Language Gospel that was translated into Greek, and therefore, of whom a Greek version of his Gospel served as a source for our canonical "Matthew"
Finally! Thanks jacob
Love ur show! Unfortunately ... this one, audio? However, I will catch the next one. PeaceMac
without actual documents, idk how these reconstructions are anything more than model theory
At 54:04, proof that Jacob is wearing pants, for once! Jacob, I applaud your attempts at conformity!!!
Great video. Dr. Roth is both erudite and elocuent. Marcion without a doubt was a major player. If he were not there would not be so many Christians queueing up to denounce him. Also I believe that without him there would be no Paul as he had all the letters and made them widely known through his followers.
Hans Niemann vibes 😊
Also great video
I really wish Jacob wouldve at least asked him to date the gospels if they are first century or 2nd century
I am still waiting for ANY evidence for ANY of the gospels before the mid second century?
The fact that there are 3 synoptics & one Johannine gospels when just one merged single gospel would have been far more sensible as a response to Marcion
Mark and Matthew have hard sayings of Jesus missing in Luke like the Syrophoenician woman who Jesus rejects at first and refers to her people as dogs. That being the case, Marcion edited that out and some Yahwistic passages about "evil god". His editing is our Luke today.He didn't see the many Judahite deities like El, Baal,Adonay fused with Yahweh unfortunately.
Please buy a lavalier mic so you can wire it up to your guests to improve audio. We can hear him but you're officially a big content creator now, you need to hire an audio/visual assistant
Maybe.
I wish I was live i would have asked him if the varient n jude 5 ie jesus or god christ or lord *see vs jude 4* may be a marcionite rebuttal to his antithesis.
Why don't they focus on the Ebionite gospel?
Morrissey College of Arts and Sciences - "The Department’s five primary areas of research include biblical studies, comparative theology, history of Christianity, >>>systematic theology
Focus on his arguments - not incompetent ad homimems
Epiphanius is too late to matter. This is Rome church VS the rest.
Chapel hill, hmmm.
Also Reformed Theological Seminary if im not mistaken
I think he is a former student of Michael J Kruger, former undergrad of Ehrman and phd under Larry Hurtado.
@@milkydudI used to communicate with Larry and knew some of his biases.
"stream of Jesus tradition" - evidence please, or is this another chicken and egg puzzle?
Start your research