I really appreciate the commentary given on this channel. Brian is the only content creator I can listen with my eyes closed and visualize every single detail of the game.
Would love to see your Beta collection if ever you wanted to make a video on it. I'm always interested in seeing sweet collections. Good luck at eternal weekend ❤️
18:04 An alternative play would be to, make a food, cast oath, pass turn, opp likely can`t do anything, then oko their graf on next turn and time walk into your extra turn, get atraxa.
This is why we test! Can't wait to see how you did, and the changes that you made. Info's probably already out on the bird app, but I don't go there, so! It'll be a nice surprise to hear about it on the channel soon!
16:50 Knowing you have an oath on top of the deck I don't understand why you kill their ruby instead of their grafdigger's cage. I guess finding Oko solves both the cage and the "give them a creature" problem but if you had found Forbidden Orchard instead you'd be kicking yourself.
14:30 my intuition is that vamp for strip and kill saga is the play here but im not sure if that’s right. Anyway thank you for the vintage vids! Always a treat to get to watch this format
By no means a vintage player at all, but I think a possible line in game 1 was to vamp for atraxa, make a food with oko, and eat the food into atraka off the top with citadel.
48:40 You're pretty much dead in this spot, but there's another option in situations like this. You can get Force of Negation out of his hand by casting Show and Tell as a bluff. Since you just Vampiric Tutored and he doesn't know what you got, it looks obviously like you just set up the Show and Tell or something involving it, so from his perspective it's an absolute must counter. You're in effect trading your useless Show and Tell for his counter when you have nothing else to do. Luis Scott-Vargas did that to a guy twice in one game once to clear the Forces from the guy's hand then beat him with his real card afterward.
At 47:04, why do you cast Force of Will pitching Force of Negation instead of the other way around (exiling the Ancestral Recall)? Do we not rather want it exiled than in the grave? I suppose there is some difference related to mana value? Since your deck doesn't have any graveyard recursion for the Force you get in there, it can't be this imo (unless I missed something).
I did the math, you said that your videos that show the trophy perform better than the ones that don't. There is some truth to that I analyzed every video that you have posted in the last 11 months for a comparison. You average about 18.8k views on every non trophy legacy/vintage video, in the trophy videos you average 21.5k views. It's not a big difference but it's there. An interesting fact I have found though in my studies which I am sure you already know is your non legacy videos suffer from a huge drop off modern is about 65.4% less views where as pioneer is about 54.2% legacy cube is roughly around the same as pioneer. There was a more interesting find in that you non blue legacy games are also about half the views of the legacy games starting the color blue, with lands being an expectation. (which I am personally glad of because your 8 mulch videos are my favorite) My favorite find is that while your non blue legacy videos normally suffer your non blue trophy video are easily your highest performing increasing over 4 times the non trophy counterpart. While you legacy video featuring blue that trophy average nearly the same as the non trophy videos. I know the later it goes down the list the less exact my number become that's because I have spent nearly 2 hours on this after work, it's 2 am my time and I want to be done so I can watch this video and go to sleep. While it's not the evidence I was hoping to find to show you shouldn't click bait the trophy videos thus spoiling them and by effect the all of your other videos that you don't click bait as not 5-0ing. I would like to add in my two cents that if you want a compromise click bait all of your non blue videos as trophying because they WAY out perform the ones that aren't click baited. I personally don't feel like you blue videos change very much at all as far as views go. Also I'm not recommending you not only do blue legacy videos. I know a big amount of your support come from patron viewer deck lists. I just saw an interesting theme and thought you might like to know if you didn't already. If you want me to analyze your videos more seriously or try and give you more detailed information just let me know, I had fun doing this even if it's not exactly the results I was looking for when I started it. If you are reading this I appreciate your videos, for the last year I go to sleep to them every night since they come out at 12 am my time, and when I wake up I find where I left off and finish them. I really enjoy them. I also hope you are having a wonderful thanksgiving.
Hi, I appreciate the amount of work you did on this. 13% higher views on average for trophy videos is good information to have. There's a couple responses here that I'd like to share. -All of my videos come from Patreon subscribers. Legacy vs non-legacy, blue vs. non-blue, my business model does not select for these things. I do know what's going to be more and less successful and stagger my releases accordingly, but I do not refuse to take on Modern/Vintage/Pioneer projects from paying customers. -Views are not the only relevant measure of success. Impression click through, likes and comments, shares, duration of views, subscribers gained, and did the viewer click to another video of mine after this one are all important too. Most of those measures can't be analyzed from my public page, but I have access to deep analytics in the back end. -Artistically speaking, winning and losing are not important on my channel. Thinking and trying new things and learning are what I'm promoting. Whether I 5-0 or 0-5, I spend an hour or more doing it and reducing those efforts to "you spoiled it" is a disservice to the actual product I provide. I don't care if I win or lose in these videos and if I can get 13% more views on average by "spoiling" a result I do not believe anything was lost. -The term "clickbait" is a loaded one. There is honest clickbait, in terms of "I 5-0ed with a silly deck!" which is honest and a viewer can decide for themselves if that's something they want to click on. Then there is dishonest clickbait, such as "CAN GOBLIN POX 5-0!?" and then the answer is "no" in my 2-3 video. All of my titles deliver exactly what they advertise. -For what it's worth, I have made the 5-0 more discrete, placing it at the end of the title instead of the front. Daily viewers have been pleasantly surprised lately when I trophy. That is I believe the best compromise because I get the SEO from saying it but viewers can just click in without reading the whole title and description and still be surprised.
For clarification I wasn't saying click bait as a negative term. Click bait when you have the content to back it up, which you do. Is quite positive because it encourages people to click on something they end up enjoying. I also am not suggesting you don't do pioneer, modern or non blue legacy decks. I do know that most of your revenue from the channel most likely comes from viewer submitted deck lists. I just had the data and thought you might be interested in it. I wasn't trying to suggest you change anything. I also have noticed the increased less obvious trophy. Its both at the end of the title and the physical trophy picture in the thumb nail is visible smaller. I do seriously appreciate it. Don't take my post too seriously. It mostly done on a whim and once I had all of the information done and it proves that you were right about them doing better. I thought well I have all of this data... Is there anything else interesting I can find in it that he might want to know? I do appreciate how your videos put gameplay first and they arent 90% arguments with twitch chat about something completely unrelated like a lot of other mtg content creators. I actually haven't play MTG in 4 months and haven't play legacy in over 7 years. I have grown to love the format by watching your videos.
![เปิดคำทำนาย นอสตราดามุส - บาบา วานก้า ปี 2025 คนทั่วโลกต้องเจออะไรบ้าง? | แฉ 11 ธ.ค. 67 [2/3] |GMM25](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xmTIKWJUMPM/mqdefault.jpg)
At 08:00, vamp for atraxa, make food with Oko, crack food, cast atraxa = profit
I really appreciate the commentary given on this channel. Brian is the only content creator I can listen with my eyes closed and visualize every single detail of the game.
Same. And the only one which allows you to sleep at night because of his calm voice.
@@isocity-infoi do the same thing, it’s so nice
He does offer at home services where he comes to your home and plays magic beside you and talks until you sleep. It's 1000$ per sleep.
nah
At 8:20 you could've vamp tutored atraxa used oko to make a food and sacrifice it.
27:13 Pithing Needle naming A Good Day To Pie, happy Thanksgiving.
brian, thank you for doing 2 vintage vids back to back. best giving of thanks ever
rip to the 15-0 based off title :(
Third time's a (bad luck) charm
This thanksgiving I'm thankful for BoshNRoll 🙏
Been learning vintage since the UB Lurrus video and having a blast. Thanks for making these formats more accessible for us mere mortals
Amazing series of games. 13/2 with the only loses occurring to the mirror. Well done.
Would love to see your Beta collection if ever you wanted to make a video on it. I'm always interested in seeing sweet collections.
Good luck at eternal weekend ❤️
7:50 I think you could have cracked a food with oko for 3 more life
It's amazing that you know exactly where the game turns in each players' favor. These decks look like they take a whole lot of brain power.
18:04 An alternative play would be to, make a food, cast oath, pass turn, opp likely can`t do anything, then oko their graf on next turn and time walk into your extra turn, get atraxa.
This is why we test! Can't wait to see how you did, and the changes that you made. Info's probably already out on the bird app, but I don't go there, so! It'll be a nice surprise to hear about it on the channel soon!
You briefly mentioned your Beta collection. Would love to see a video showing what other cards you have!
48:50 couldn't you strip mine the trop and pass to second main to cast your Oath? If their hand is Oath+FoN they wouldn't be able to counter it then.
was going to say the same thing, I thought when he was talking about stripping them off force that was the plan
16:50 Knowing you have an oath on top of the deck I don't understand why you kill their ruby instead of their grafdigger's cage. I guess finding Oko solves both the cage and the "give them a creature" problem but if you had found Forbidden Orchard instead you'd be kicking yourself.
Hello!
Hello!
14:30 my intuition is that vamp for strip and kill saga is the play here but im not sure if that’s right. Anyway thank you for the vintage vids! Always a treat to get to watch this format
By no means a vintage player at all, but I think a possible line in game 1 was to vamp for atraxa, make a food with oko, and eat the food into atraka off the top with citadel.
48:40 You're pretty much dead in this spot, but there's another option in situations like this. You can get Force of Negation out of his hand by casting Show and Tell as a bluff. Since you just Vampiric Tutored and he doesn't know what you got, it looks obviously like you just set up the Show and Tell or something involving it, so from his perspective it's an absolute must counter. You're in effect trading your useless Show and Tell for his counter when you have nothing else to do. Luis Scott-Vargas did that to a guy twice in one game once to clear the Forces from the guy's hand then beat him with his real card afterward.
Happy Thanksgiving Brian!
Happy Thanksgiving Brian! You thinking about those beans today 🤣?
AYO BOSH YOU MY FUCKING BOY DAWG DONT EVER FORGET IT
Would leyline of sanctity be good in the mirror? I’m probably thinking too hard about it but it makes a little sense
A lot of times, the games come down to draw steps being really good. Leyline is a really bad draw step
@@RumpledNutskin that makes a lot of sense
are you able to tap forbidden orchard in the untap step before oath triggers?
Players don’t get priority in the untap step. :(
At 47:04, why do you cast Force of Will pitching Force of Negation instead of the other way around (exiling the Ancestral Recall)?
Do we not rather want it exiled than in the grave?
I suppose there is some difference related to mana value?
Since your deck doesn't have any graveyard recursion for the Force you get in there, it can't be this imo (unless I missed something).
It’s my turn :)
People asking "why is atraxa in your bolas's citadel deck" why are you reanimating Troll of Khazad-dûm? Life total is a resource
I thought to myself: I've seen this vid. then I saw the upload time
Obligatory algorithmic contribution
Does anyone know how the tournament went for Brian? I looked up the results, but couldn't find his name anywhere.
My report comes out tomorrow :)
Look for boshnroll on melee for the European events and you will find him
"wow vintage players are the worst" i damn near fell out of my chair laughing and i spit watermelon monster all over my desk.
I did the math, you said that your videos that show the trophy perform better than the ones that don't. There is some truth to that I analyzed every video that you have posted in the last 11 months for a comparison.
You average about 18.8k views on every non trophy legacy/vintage video, in the trophy videos you average 21.5k views. It's not a big difference but it's there.
An interesting fact I have found though in my studies which I am sure you already know is your non legacy videos suffer from a huge drop off modern is about 65.4% less views where as pioneer is about 54.2% legacy cube is roughly around the same as pioneer.
There was a more interesting find in that you non blue legacy games are also about half the views of the legacy games starting the color blue, with lands being an expectation. (which I am personally glad of because your 8 mulch videos are my favorite)
My favorite find is that while your non blue legacy videos normally suffer your non blue trophy video are easily your highest performing increasing over 4 times the non trophy counterpart. While you legacy video featuring blue that trophy average nearly the same as the non trophy videos.
I know the later it goes down the list the less exact my number become that's because I have spent nearly 2 hours on this after work, it's 2 am my time and I want to be done so I can watch this video and go to sleep.
While it's not the evidence I was hoping to find to show you shouldn't click bait the trophy videos thus spoiling them and by effect the all of your other videos that you don't click bait as not 5-0ing.
I would like to add in my two cents that if you want a compromise click bait all of your non blue videos as trophying because they WAY out perform the ones that aren't click baited. I personally don't feel like you blue videos change very much at all as far as views go.
Also I'm not recommending you not only do blue legacy videos. I know a big amount of your support come from patron viewer deck lists. I just saw an interesting theme and thought you might like to know if you didn't already.
If you want me to analyze your videos more seriously or try and give you more detailed information just let me know, I had fun doing this even if it's not exactly the results I was looking for when I started it.
If you are reading this I appreciate your videos, for the last year I go to sleep to them every night since they come out at 12 am my time, and when I wake up I find where I left off and finish them. I really enjoy them. I also hope you are having a wonderful thanksgiving.
Hi, I appreciate the amount of work you did on this. 13% higher views on average for trophy videos is good information to have.
There's a couple responses here that I'd like to share.
-All of my videos come from Patreon subscribers. Legacy vs non-legacy, blue vs. non-blue, my business model does not select for these things. I do know what's going to be more and less successful and stagger my releases accordingly, but I do not refuse to take on Modern/Vintage/Pioneer projects from paying customers.
-Views are not the only relevant measure of success. Impression click through, likes and comments, shares, duration of views, subscribers gained, and did the viewer click to another video of mine after this one are all important too. Most of those measures can't be analyzed from my public page, but I have access to deep analytics in the back end.
-Artistically speaking, winning and losing are not important on my channel. Thinking and trying new things and learning are what I'm promoting. Whether I 5-0 or 0-5, I spend an hour or more doing it and reducing those efforts to "you spoiled it" is a disservice to the actual product I provide. I don't care if I win or lose in these videos and if I can get 13% more views on average by "spoiling" a result I do not believe anything was lost.
-The term "clickbait" is a loaded one. There is honest clickbait, in terms of "I 5-0ed with a silly deck!" which is honest and a viewer can decide for themselves if that's something they want to click on. Then there is dishonest clickbait, such as "CAN GOBLIN POX 5-0!?" and then the answer is "no" in my 2-3 video. All of my titles deliver exactly what they advertise.
-For what it's worth, I have made the 5-0 more discrete, placing it at the end of the title instead of the front. Daily viewers have been pleasantly surprised lately when I trophy. That is I believe the best compromise because I get the SEO from saying it but viewers can just click in without reading the whole title and description and still be surprised.
fyi "discreet" = sneaky, "discrete" = separable into individual instances@@BoshNRoll
Appreciate that your titles are honest btw
For clarification I wasn't saying click bait as a negative term. Click bait when you have the content to back it up, which you do. Is quite positive because it encourages people to click on something they end up enjoying.
I also am not suggesting you don't do pioneer, modern or non blue legacy decks. I do know that most of your revenue from the channel most likely comes from viewer submitted deck lists.
I just had the data and thought you might be interested in it. I wasn't trying to suggest you change anything.
I also have noticed the increased less obvious trophy. Its both at the end of the title and the physical trophy picture in the thumb nail is visible smaller. I do seriously appreciate it.
Don't take my post too seriously. It mostly done on a whim and once I had all of the information done and it proves that you were right about them doing better. I thought well I have all of this data... Is there anything else interesting I can find in it that he might want to know?
I do appreciate how your videos put gameplay first and they arent 90% arguments with twitch chat about something completely unrelated like a lot of other mtg content creators.
I actually haven't play MTG in 4 months and haven't play legacy in over 7 years. I have grown to love the format by watching your videos.
coulda gained life from an Oko food m1g1 and vamped for atraxa
the secret hidden mode
@@sinbread526like the saying with Liliana, her secret mode was not using any mode 😂
@@sinbread526 Did you know that in addition to becoming three 1/1 goblins, a Blood token can also discard a card to draw a card?
Why not board out top against oof?
24:05 Vintage players don't like to play vintage
23:59