@@AhmadSaifudin116, the trope - if you could even call it a trope at the time - was used in "Dune", which was published in 1965. "Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back" (the film that Darth Vader says the line in) was released in 1980. Even "Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope" wasn't released until 1977.
@@AhmadSaifudin116 Dune Prophecy is based on one of the later books written by Herbert's son. Herbets accusation was Star Wars *as a whole* was a direct rip off of Dune. He discussed wanting to sue him and later it said they came to some kind of out of court solution.
At this point the only winning scenario I can see in Episode 6 is that Desmond decapitates the Sisterhood, including Sister Francesca, but dies in the process. Javicco finds his cojones and creates the Sardukar. The remnants of the sisterhood fall back and rebuild, under the leadership of Lila/Dorotea/Raquella. Yes, she is abomination, but the best of both sides, packed into one body.
Although Tula did horrible things on Valya's orders, she did defy her by not killing that last Atreidies boy. Her job was to wipe out the entire bloodline. Not only did she FAIL at that, she gave them their most dangerous heir. Valya would have killed Desmond Hart at birth if she had known about him.
Vorian was always leaving families around all over the place there was no way to get every Atreides in any scenario I think the goal was just to take some of Vorian’s family out not every single one of them
Was it necessary for the entire saga to be slavish to male trops and themes? It would have been more exciting had old cliches of male power themes to have been utterly replaced by female perspectives and goals. I had high expectations of this series but it is formulaic amd predictable.
In fairness Dune did it before Star Wars.
Did you really just say Dune is relying on a Star Wars trope? You know Star Wars stole it from Dune right? Frank Herbert was vocal about it.
Isn't the book dune prophecy based on only come out about few years ago?
@@AhmadSaifudin116, the trope - if you could even call it a trope at the time - was used in "Dune", which was published in 1965. "Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back" (the film that Darth Vader says the line in) was released in 1980. Even "Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope" wasn't released until 1977.
@@AhmadSaifudin116 Dune Prophecy is based on one of the later books written by Herbert's son. Herbets accusation was Star Wars *as a whole* was a direct rip off of Dune. He discussed wanting to sue him and later it said they came to some kind of out of court solution.
@@AhmadSaifudin116 yes but original Dune had Baron Harkonen was Lady Jessica's Father thus Paul Atreides grandfather. Same reveal.
At this point the only winning scenario I can see in Episode 6 is that Desmond decapitates the Sisterhood, including Sister Francesca, but dies in the process. Javicco finds his cojones and creates the Sardukar. The remnants of the sisterhood fall back and rebuild, under the leadership of Lila/Dorotea/Raquella. Yes, she is abomination, but the best of both sides, packed into one body.
Although Tula did horrible things on Valya's orders, she did defy her by not killing that last Atreidies boy. Her job was to wipe out the entire bloodline. Not only did she FAIL at that, she gave them their most dangerous heir. Valya would have killed Desmond Hart at birth if she had known about him.
Vorian was always leaving families around all over the place there was no way to get every Atreides in any scenario I think the goal was just to take some of Vorian’s family out not every single one of them
Love the video. My inner nerd kept screaming, “No. I am your father.”
Are you confused about what came first because dune is much older than Star Wars
I like this more than the movies such a great work and acting
Why do you think💁
Dune came first! Do your research.
So what?
Thanks for pointing that out.
son is older than mom
Uhm sir its called the Dune first trope. Thank you
Welp you just riled up Dune Children. Dune was written in the sixties which George Lucas got his inspiration.
Was it necessary for the entire saga to be slavish to male trops and themes? It would have been more exciting had old cliches of male power themes to have been utterly replaced by female perspectives and goals. I had high expectations of this series but it is formulaic amd predictable.
Isn't this crap based on one of the stupid prequels? Why does anybody need to guess what happens?
Dune is better.