Understanding Everybody Wants To Rule The World
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- Tears For Fears were famous for their meticulous production, spending months dialing in the exact sounds they needed to make their audacious synthpop anthems work. But what would happen if you took that attention to detail and forced them to make a whole song, start to finish, in like 2 weeks? Well, that's how you get Everybody Wants To Rule The World. It was a last-minute addition, conceived and created at the very end of the production process for the album, but that risk paid off.
Patreon: / 12tonevideos
Merch: standard.tv/12tone
Discord: / discord
Facebook: / 12tonevideos
Twitter: / 12tonevideos
Twitch: / 12tonevideos
Email: 12tonevideos@gmail.com
Last: • How Sheet Music Lies T...
Rick's video: • What Makes This Song G...
Script: tinyurl.com/2p...
Huge thanks to our Elephant Club members:
Susan Jones
Jill Jones
Duck
Howard Levine
Brian Etheredge
Khristofor Saraga
Len Lanphar
Ken Arnold
Elaine Pratt
William (Bill) Boston
Chris Prentice
Jack Carlson
Christopher Lucas
Andrew Beals
Dov Zazkis
Hendrik P
Thomas Morley
Jacob Helwig
Warren Huart
Kevin Wilamowski
Davis Sprague
Grant Aldonas
Alex Knauth
Braum Meakes
Hendrik Stüwe
Dan Bonelli
Kevin Boyce
Kelly Christoffersen
Donal Botkin
Scott Howarth
Luke
Stephen Cook
David Bartz
Symmetry
Dhruv Monga
Ken Jones
Obadiah Wright
Kobalent
Carlos Rendon
Aleksandar Milojković
Kylie McInnes
Jody
Daniel Reaman
Tom
PhilRosas
Reiji Kobayashi
MISLS
Neil Moore
And thanks as well to Henry Reich, Gabi Ghita, Gene Lushtak, Owen Campbell-Moore, Eugene Bulkin, Logan Jones, Oliver, Anna Work, Adam Neely, Rick Lees, Dave Mayer, CodenaCrow, Nikolay Semyonov, Arnas, Caroline Simpson, Michael Alan Dorman, Blake Boyd, Luke Rihn, Charles Gaskell, Ian Seymour, Trevor Sullivan, Tom Evans, Lamadesbois, JH, David Conrad, Chris Chapin, Chris Borland, Todd Davidson, Elliot Burke, Tim S., Elias Simon, Jake Lizzio, Jerry D. Brown, Ohad Lutzky, Aaron Epstein, Chris Connett, Peter Leventis, Kenneth Kousen, James, h2g2guy, W. Dennis Sorrell, James A. Thornton, Brian Dinger, Professor Elliot, Stefan Strohmaier, Shadow Kat, Adam Wurstmann, Kelsey Freese, Angela Flierman, Richard T. Anderson, Andrew Engel, Kevin Johnson, Ryan, Rodrigo "rrc2soft" Roman, Jeremy Zolner, Patrick Callier, Danny, Francois LaPlante, Volker Wegert, Joshua Gleitze, Britt Ratliff, Darzzr, Joshua La Macchia, Peter Brinkmann, Alexey Fedotov, Alex Keeny, Valentin Lupachev, John Bejarano, Gary Butterfield, naomio, Alex Mole, Steve Brand, Rene Miklas, Red Uncle, Kaisai Morihito, Doug Nottingham, Nicholas Wolf, Betsy, Tonya Custis, Dave Shapiro, Jacopo Cascioli, Rafael Martinez Salas, Walther, Robert Beach, Jason Nebergall, Graeme Lewis, Jake Sand, Mathew Wolak, S, Lincoln Mendell, Aditya Baradwaj, Sam Rezek, Destros, Lucas Augusto, Juan Madrigal, Evan Satinsky, James Little, RaptorCat, Jim Hayes, Scott Albertine, Jigglypuffer, leftaroundabout ., Jens Schäfer, Mikely Whiplash, Austin Amberg, Francisco Rodrigues, Elizabeth, Michael Tsuk, רועי סיני, Conor Stuart Roe, ThoraSTooth, Brandon Legawiec, Dragix PL, Evgeni Kunev, Hikaru Katayamma, Alon Kellner, Rob Hardy, Gary Evesson, Kottolett, Dylan Vidas, Patrick Chieppe, Eric Stark, David Haughn, Gordon Dell, Byron DeLaBarre, Matty Crocker, anemamata, Brian Miller, Lee-orr Orbach, Eric Plume, Kevin Pierce, Jon Hancock, Jason Peterson, Peggy Youell, EJ Hambleton, Jos Mulder, Daryl Banttari, J.T. Vandenbree, Brian Davis, Pamela O'Neill, Thomas Morgan, Ludwick Kennedy, Wayne Robinson, Gabriel Totusek, Ridley Kemp, Mark James, SecretKittehs, Mnemosyne Music, AkselA, Philip Miller, Sam Plotkin, David MacDonald, Nellie Speirs Baron, Charles R., Joshua Lewis, Adam Ziegenhals, Mark, Amelia Lewis, Sam, DialMForManning, Wayne Weil, Michael Wehling, PatSandmann, Brandon Peckham, Kristofer Hill, William Merryman, Ryan Mayle, J Denton, James, David T Peterson, Bryan C. Mills, Justin St John-Brooks, Mark Lacey, Jaren Tilford, Catherine Berry, Watch Harder, XCompWiz, Michael Blaby, Bean, A Devoted Servant, Milan Brezovsky, Edmund Horner, Daria Gibbons, NinoDoko, Fernando Felix, Joseph Satin, Piush Dahal, Matthew Moore, Walt Seefeld, M. Bock, Daniel Joseph Moynihan, Andrew Wyld, Josh Witkowski, not a coincidence, Graham Orndorff, Michael Sacksteder, JD White, Jeffrey Mann, Jason McPherson, Chris Robson, A.J. Yates, Matt Moulder, Leander Tietjen, Joe Johnston, Jordan Friendshuh, Alex Tafur, Chris Davis, findRED, Howl’s one-handed, Gary Backaus, Eugen Lounkine, Fernando Gros, Geoffrey Barnett, OVB_2nd, Hakim C, Joe Molloy, gunnito, מתן אריאל-הברון, Claymore Alexander, Dixon Roberts, Jay Wilson, RoxyPop, Pär Nord, Paul Tanenholz, Chris Cresswell, Chris Breault, Julio D, Justin Zboyovski, Adam Poata-Smith, J.R. Hyde, and A! Your support helps make 12tone even better!
Also, thanks to Jareth Arnold!
Some additional thoughts/corrections:
1) For reasons I don't fully understand, the stems I found for this song seem to be slightly sped up relative to the actual recording? Which is weird, 'cause it's typically the other way around. Anyway it seems to be only a couple BPM, so I'm not sure anyone would notice if I didn't say anything, but it does make the notes fairly sharp compared to the things I'm saying, to the point where it'd probably be slightly more accurate to round up to the next half-step. I decided to go with the note names based on the original recording instead of the thing I was actually playing for consistency, but in case anyone out there has perfect pitch and was confused, this is why.
2) One could argue that the intro riff _is_ in groups of 2, and it's meant to be a polyrhythm against the main groove. That fits with what's on the paper, but it doesn't match my hearing. The lack of dynamic accents means that, when the drum beat is played, the riff naturally organizes itself (for me) in groups of 3. It's only when that beat is missing that I hear groups of 2.
3) All the information on specific synth tones comes from this incredible article reconstructing the entire song: reverbmachine.com/blog/tears-for-fears-everybody-wants-to-rule-the-world-synths/
4) A minor clarification: I said Smith drags his chest voice up instead of using his mixed voice, but mixed voice includes elements of chest voice. I think it's clear enough that I meant he drags up his _full_ chest voice, but if you want to be pedantic, here's your pedantic correction.
5) I said Smith and Orzabal adopted similar techniques, and I stand by that, but there are some differences. In general, I think Smith's delivery is more relaxed, while Orzabal's is more percussive, and he's also more likely to flip up into head voice, like in Head Over Heels. But when singing through this middle range, they both share that same approach to registration, which was my main point. Listening to this song and Shout, it is not immediately obvious to me that the two songs have different singers. (Also to be clear I don't know why they chose to do this, or whether it was in fact a conscious choice at all. When I said that it meant you could always tell you were listening to Tears For Fears, I was discussing effect, not intention.)
6) I didn't get into this in the video because it's not relevant to this specific song, but when talking about how the explosion of affordable synth technology in the 80s changed music, it's hard not to think of the legacy of the Roland TR-808. This was technically an analogue synth, not a digital one, but its relatively low price made it a staple of the evolving hip-hop scene, and the sounds and techniques it introduced can still be heard in hip-hop today.
The sharp pitch is something that's always bugged me about that song. All versions that I know of are like this - just confirmed it with the official TFF TH-cam and Spotify. Was this an artistic decision or just a badly calibrated tape machine? Maybe we'll never know!
Interestingly the remake of the song in the Reverb article linked is much closer to standard tuning, in case we wondered what it would have sounded like in the studio originally.
Great song choice! I also had the same feeling that something was wrong in the intro but your explanation seems correct.
I started college as a Music Education Major - Voice was my instrument... so it was cool to hear you mention that was your focus much of the way through your time in college. I was shocked when you said that Smith was using his chest voice to hit that F#. I ALWAYS heard that as head voice. I thought he was using falsetto. It STILL sounds like that to me.
I trust you 100%. You know more about music than I ever have or ever will. Much respect. It's just odd that my ear is so off in this case. My ear was never all that great, but I clearly hear falsetto. Anyway, as always, I love your content, appreciate the work you put into it, and value the information and entertainment. Thank you!
TIL the singer on Shout wasn't the same singer as on Everybody Wants To Rule The World.
Maybe the stems are at 44.1 kHz but you were playing them at 48khz? Or maybe someone else did something like this before you got the files
This has been one of my go-to karaoke songs for awhile now. Definitely gonna use "loose intonation" as an excuse the next time I drunkenly botch a verse 😅
Love it.
I’ve done it for karaoke as well. It brings down the house.
This is one of my favorite songs, and takes me straight back to 1985, the moment I hear it.
I can't sing "world" Too deep
@@ransbarger o
Anyone who hasn’t listened to the entire Songs from the Big Chair album *needs* to…it’s TFF’s magnum opus, imo. This tune, the entire head over heels suite, mothers talk, listen, the working hour, shout…it’s just a front to back masterpiece. On top of that, it’s a really good representation of what was happening in the mid-80s. Lots of reverb, Linn drum machine, clean strats, thick bass, tight playing and massive vocals.
For real.
The Working Hour💖💖💖💖💖
While I agree that Songs From the Big Chair was an amazing album, I personally considered Sowing the Seeds of Love their greatest achievement. But, to each their own.
I totally echo your sentiments about the album!
Listen is probably my favorite Tears for Fears song.
@@deathbypigx3h
Absolutely, listen is such an overlooked cut. I think the slow build might be a bit much people with short attention spans.
7:00 - Something else about Curt Smith's voice: His singing voice is VERY different from his speaking voice. This isn't particularly uncommon, but the differences between his two voices are VERY noticeable. Accent, timbre, everything. The whole "pulling his chest into his head" thing that you discuss is likely a big part of this.
That's true for every British singer known for singing RnB and Soul music.
I grew up listening to to Tears for Fears and Genesis. Always knew it was good music but it wasn’t until fairly recently that I realized exactly how complex some of these songs are. I love it.
Eh depends on what Genesis era… The Phil Collins era was pretty meh, but the Peter Gabriel era on the other hand was fantastic.
Well 70’s Genesis is some of the most complex popular music. Especially Peter Gabriel era Genesis
@@TokyoBalletReprise the first couple Collins-led albums were great. A trick of the tail is a fantastic album
@@avi_s0ncin0 Instrumentally “A trick of the Tail” was definitely good and very good in certain parts too, but it lacks the fantastic songwriting and creative vision Peter brought to the table. To me “A Trick of the Tail” is to Genesis what “The Division Bell” is to Pink Floyd. A very well composed album that lacks the vision, flair, authenticity and (especially) the songwriting chops.
@@TokyoBalletReprise And Then There Were Three is an amazing record. ABACAB has some more fantastic songs. Matter of fact, each of the Phill era albums has at least one extended "prog" songs on them.
As a passionate music enjoyer, getting a peak behind the curtain of music production is like looking at a nice blue ocean and then promptly submerging into it's depths. Music is so much more complex than people give it credit and I have utmost respect for the pioneers that have brought music as far as its come...
To be honest the actual writing process is not necessarily that complex for most music; even music with complex structures. Intuition is a huge part of writing and theory is there as a tool to help here and there. Think of it like this; the in-depth study into all of the physical reactions of a single swing and strike of a bat to a ball that leads to a homerun is extremely complex. However, the batter isn't necessarily thinking or knowledgeable of all of that and doesn't need to be. It is helpful for the batter to have some level of understanding of the physics though.
Hope I didn't ruin the illusion for you. 😉
@@CynHicks Agreed. As someone who used to write songs in various bands during my younger days it was often the unplanned intuitive, instinctive jamming that produced something worthwhile, on occasions where we sat down intentionally to write something in a pre- agreed key or style the results were usually underwhelming. Creativity is a peculiar beast. He can show up when you least expect him and hide from you when you most want him.
@@29memyselfandi Pretty much anything I've ever written as a "theoretical demonstration" has become an exercise or completely lost. Parts, of course, make their way into improvising/writing. Theoretical knowledge, at least for me, is mostly useful when writing leads which for me is always improvising in the beginning. The creative (intuitive) aspect is what a "good" song starts with and is polished with. In my experience every musician that I know of that couldn't write a decent melody before theory can only write a decent one after. Like you wrote about creativity though; it's there or it isn't and no amount of theory is going change that. With some exceptions of course, as with most anything.
I just tried singing that main lick without going falsetto on “to” and it’s absolutely impossible. I just naturally kick up there on that note. I forced myself to stay down in chest and couldn’t help but scoop up into the note.
Robert, I recently had a go at recording this song, and experienced exactly the same problem. I have a Bass voice. I am contemplating lowering the key.
I’m a baritone & I don’t have any trouble getting there in chest, but it’s definitely easier to get there via falsetto. I think it’s an easy song to try an over sing. I find just relaxing helps those type of transitions much easier when I don’t over force my diaphragm…
@@acason4 i am a baritone myself but i have received good mixed voice training so i can do it seemlessly. it just takes coordination and training really. and relaxation, like you said.
i think its one of the greatest pop songs of al time. i think the song has a wonderful uplifting hopeful sound to it while the vocals have a beautifully melancholy vibe and some how it blends together perfectly.
Well, they were one of the best songwriting bands of the 80s, even if most folks don’t actively remember how great they were (still are). I think they just wrote a really interesting song.
Have you checked out their new stuff!
@@Green-eyedGirl19 the new record is great. Yeah! They were on Colbert recently as well, and sounded amazing.
@@chairmankaga101 in terms of lyrics I'd say they are one of the best of all time, writing Everybody wants to rule the world would put you up highly already combine that with Mad World as well!
To be honest, I'm a little surprised you didn't recognize the intro as triplets right away. The hi-hat does disorient a little bit, but it's just 6 hits against the 12 triplets in the synth. But I love your analysis. This is one of my top 5 favorite 80's pop song.
Same. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Why? With respect, you’re not living in his brain so why would you be surprised? I suppose it’s because he’s a musical theory genius..🙂 I heard triplets.. but I’m not 12 tone. All the best 🙂
Edit: in this comment I just shot from the hip as I wrote about him being a musical genius and think I was trying to big 12 Tone up (without really considering why) but no offence was meant in regards to the guy’s very reasonable comment.
it was just a quick, first, kinda straight, unconsidered shot and I think an emotional response to someone saying something about why someone else thinks something-and also an honest idea about 12 tone going into the vortex coz he can-tho really there was not much need for my comment-love and respect to all
@@popstargirl79 if you heard triplets, then you heard it as 12/8. I think you're missing what 12tone is saying was his issue. Which 3 each triplet or 4/8ths encapsulates is his issue. If he was hearing the intro 8th as part of the first triplet, then he has literally never heard the riff before. And that's surprising.
Oh, and music theory genius? Its theory, not relativity.
@@halcooper3070 thanks for your reply.. I don’t watch loads of 12 tone stuff but he’s great at music theory.. I think I was just saying to the other dude that because 12 tones so into music theory and good at it (kinda genius in my book) then maybe he heard it like that because his mind ‘can’ think and interpret it that way, which I probably couldn’t. (However, maybe I could, but I wouldn’t be able to necessarily say why by using music theory) 🙂
@@popstargirl79 as I pulled out my guitar this morning, to play the lick, amd the verse chords, I realized 2 things... First, the chords imitate the lick, shifting to the second on the 6, that's possibly why most hear the lick the way I hear it, I still can't imagine even liking the lick as 12tone heard it. Second, being a guitar player means you understand the origin, and therefore the rhythm, because of the natural way to play it. Upstroke on the first note allows you to alternate the rest of the lick, endlessly. If you start downstroke on the first note, what a mess, it's awkward and unnatural, and I'd have to practice it a bunch to play it smoothly. Plus, the pick strokes on the recording tell you how it was played. Still leaves me wondering how it can be heard any other way, but maybe the guitar is my bias, I was playing it on stage as soon as it came out, so of course I'd see it that way
Something I think is interesting to add on to your analysis is that during the 17:25 melody that is finally D-centric, the bass part decides to Stop playing a D as part of the progression and instead go to a different progression (B-C-B-C-G-A).
P.S. You're totally not alone on the intro being confusing
Yeah, I was going to say that, the melody should be hopeful but the bass makes it melancjoly
"EWTRTW" didn't exactly spring from Roland's head fully formed at the end of the sessions.
The rhythm, beginning picking pattern, choir synth melody, and guitar solo originated on a demo called "Pharaohs". th-cam.com/video/EoIDw5Bf8Gw/w-d-xo.html
Exactly and did this guy mention Daft Punk? Lol they predated DP by over 10 years. Man people just enjoy the song instead of analysing it in ignorance.
I LOVE Pharaohs! I have been known to play it on loop endlessly!
@@kehindeahe mentioned DP as an example of music that's purely artificial without organic counterpart, not to suggest they were contemporariws
I cannot Express the frustration I felt when I saw your time slug doodle, nice StS reference. Also a great video in general!
I've always heard this as a rock shuffle beat as a drummer. Just the hi hats going a lil different playing on the 2nd eight note triplet on beats 1 and 3 and plays the 1st and 3rd triplets on beats 2 and 4. That's how I've always counted playing along to this song.
This song was new, and played endlessly on the radio, when I was in college. As a drummer, I pretty quickly figured out what was going on in the intro, but yes, it’s totally done to mislead and surprise you. Whenever I would hear that intro, I would FORCE myself to hear the triplet in it and get the groove in my head as quickly as possible. I figured a drummer had no excuse to be fooled by such tricks. 😄 Great analysis!
I find it interesting that you notated the song in simple instead of compound meter. I've always heard it as being in 6/8, so seeing you notate the chord vamp as a dotted quarter, then an eighth tied to a half note in 4/4 really threw me off, because I'd hear that as a dotted quarter tied to a normal quarter, then an eighth note tied to a dotted half note (all in 6/8). I definitely understand the metrical lack of clarity in the beginning, but for me, even that clearly delineates 6/8 after at least a full listen of the song if it's not clear at first, especially with the guitar pick-up and percussion. From a percussionist-background, it's a very common compound-meter trope to alternate between two notes/sounds but accent every third beat (for example, capital letters as accents, something like C d c D c d C d c D c d). This is strengthened by the fact that the "off-beat" pitches shift to accentuate this pattern; the B -- the higher of the "off-beat" pitches, happens on the second beat in 6/8 (using the earlier method: F# a f# B f# a).
It is really interesting to learn how different people perceive it though. From a percussionist backgrouind I've been very in tune with tropes like this that can trick casual listeners. For example, isolated hi-hats to me are very idiomatic for indicating weak beats before strong beats come in, so often times when I hear tracks that don't introduce extremely clear metric identities, when the off-beat hi-hat trope comes in I instantly sync up with the non-accented downbeat due to practice-learned intuition.
Once you hear it, you can't un-hear it😃. As a drummer turned keyboardist, I still see and use keyboards (especially piano) as a percussive instrument; so you can have a 6/8 over a 4/4, as long as they "lign up".
yeah I don't hear a 4/4 shuffle, just 6/8
thats so interesting cuz it literally never occurred to me u could even hear it as anything but a shuffled 4/4. maybe its bcuz i have drummer brain so, to me, the thing that sticks out to me to most abt this song is that groove.
This is exactly how I've always heard it as well, thanks for the insight.
Once again, if you have triplets and weird rhythms all over the place, it's probably 12/8. 12/8 and it all falls together.
This tune is one of my favorite songs of all time. It takes me straight back to 1985, the moment I hear it.
12tone, This video is brilliant. Your style and explanations and doodles made what I frankly didn't like when it came out(Synth Pop/Rock), something I gave 20 minutes of my time to 40 years later. You are a genuine treasure as a content creator. BRAVO!
By the way, how did I even get to this video?
How come you didn’t like it?
@@whatacrazyride1658 You probably watched a lot of music related videos recently and the algorithm recommended a video about music theory.
@@TokyoBalletReprise no, I haven't watched any music related stuff... In fact I was watching a long list of engineering explained videos.
@@TokyoBalletReprise I was in my teens in high school....I played music and I felt 80's music in general sounded sterile andmechanistic. I hated the keyboards and synths and even to this day they sound so terrible to me. Quantizing beats and sounds that were just not musical to my ears. They have finally taken some of those techniques and electronics and coaxed some good out of all of it, but it was just so new and the experimenting sounded like bad experiments.
Love your perspective. "Everybody Wants to Rule the World" is one of my all-time favorite songs and this gave me a whole new appreciation for it. Thank you for this.
I've been doing a "piano bar" stride cover of this tune for many years, and let me tell you this analysis makes me feel SO VINDICATED for so many choices I made
Stunning. Thank you. As a failed fairlight programmer I think I can, possibly, add a couple of things: One 'trick', at the time, was increasing the Tempo by 2 bpm a couple of bars gradually before the Chorus and the 'not quite reaching the vocal F#' has a kind of a 'prosody' as no-one can actually 'reach' ruling the world, perhaps. Just a thought :-)
Splendid video. And it complements beautifully with Rick Beato's one, as yours is very oriented in theory, themes, intent of the authors (with some lovely speculation too), while Rick's is delving into the licks, the details, the virtue in its execution. Loved both videos, thanks for highlighting his (I follow his channel but I had missed it). Love your work!
Been watching your channel for many years now and one think I always love about your breakdowns is how you’re able to portray the potential creative process of the songwriters you’re analyzing. It makes me feel like I’m watching some kind of documentary in my head while seeing your video.
This channel has helped connect so many dots , always talk about this channel irl, truly helpful. Just the way you talk about theory is amazing. Keep up the great work
You did it again, 12tone. A couple of my loose neurons got connected when you talked about vocal registration. I knew a little about different vocal registers, and about registers of keys on an organ, but I hadn't fully hooked up my concept of how this really applies to music in general...and then BAM, there it is. It's a little before 10am here, and if I take the rest of the day off from internetting, I will have done the thing I hope to do every day: I learned something I didn't know before.
I'm over 60. This is triumphant af.
as much of a pain as it is to program a DX7 i def could see them getting the sound after an hour or so, and just not even bothering to spend even more time setting up the velocity and breakpoint stuff. as a synth player i can sympathize with not wanting to waste your bandmate's time on perfecting a patch
Oh my gosh! (@8:40) You just nailed how synthesizers changed music, I have never heard anybody describe it any better.
Loved the vid! Just thought I’d point out that I’d heard somewhere that one of the angles through which the lyrics could be viewed is as though the song is telling the story of ‘1984’. Always found that interesting.
I can't get past how you hold the marker like a club yet produce a plethora of intricate well-done illustrations in quick time.
Music is Hard Work.
It's not all elephants and gummy bears.
Weird, I've never been confused by the opening, I just hear it clearly as a one-two-three-ONE-two-THREE sort of beat
6:12 "... the songs iconic timbre ..." Mmmmh. Good.
I appreciate this analysis. I knew that Tears For Fears sounded different from other bands/songs, but I was never really clear why.
LOVING hearing your analysis of vocal tone.
Your shrek “s” when you said layers 😂 I’m a total music noob and this is the first video of yours I have seen, but so far I am thoroughly impressed and can’t wait to see more!
So glad you did this song, it's one of my favorite ones to sing due to the variety in it.
I'm always impressed at your ability to isolate lyrics and other parts for these videos.
I don't know why this appeared in my reccomended, but the music theory stuff here is really fascinating. I think I might have begun to go down a rabbit hole here. Great video.
Sounds like a fine example of how sometimes doing something "improperly" is in fact the correct choice, and that sometimes "impropriety" is the point
"Welcome to your life. There's no turning back." is one of my favorite lyrics of all time
The layering you mention really makes me think of theme and variations. Unusual for rock music, yes.
[THE OUTFIELD-YOUR LOVE] Should be your next understanding video! Btw Great job on this one!😀
Wow! I’ve loved this song my entire life, your videos really help me see every part of a song and walk away with a new appreciation for it. Excellent!
I love the touch of drawing the Time Eater at 4:28
Accidentally stumbled upon this video a couple months ago. And I still think about it every time I hear pretty much any Tears for Fears song on my car playlist.
I had and have no idea about music theory, but what you said and drew made me think I can at least follow the thoughts a little
Why do I like your doodling so much?! This was an awesome video in my opinion.
The natural voice amidst all the synth reminds me of an organic human life amidst all the sterility and rigid mechanics of our artificial world.
Everybody wants to perfect the world. That strips all the soft and living parts away leaving us straining to shape ourselves into a cog in the greater machine.
I can play 5 chords badly on a guitar (only took me 2 years ! ) and I have no idea what you are talking about from a technical perspective but both your and Rick B's breakdowns of my favourite ever song have motivated me to pull my finger out, thank you so much
Great Job On 2 Great Songsmiths!🙌🏻🙌🏻🍎
First video from this channel. This may become one of my favorite channels
First time viewing. I’m blown away with howcool this presentation is. Brilliant! thank you. One of my favorite songs.
Wow, breaking down this song like this for us takes it to a whole new level! Just two bloody chords but how complex! Never, I will listen to this this masterpiece again the same way.
Yessss I was waiting for this one!! Thank you
@12tone I think the reason you identified the triplets in the beginning in three pairs is because of the final chorus, when he sings "Say you'll never never never never never never need it," with the two-syllable "never"s played over the triplet groove with the same melody--it probably subconsciously lodged that interpretation of it in your brain.
"and synth pop followed that lead" -> *draws cover of Korn's "Follow the Leader"*
genius
You have increased my appreciation for this song and TFF!
"Actually kind of tricky" is educational TH-camr slang for "absolute hell"
The visual way of doing this is great!
Really great analysis of a really great song.
This video helped me finally remember where the sample in a song I listen to came from, I knew it sounded so damn familiar but couldn't place my finger on it until now!
I'm clinically tone deaf (it's called amusia, which is funny because it's not at all amusing). I don't listen to a ton of music, and despite being a pseudo-known game critic, I mostly play games with the music turned off, if not the whole thing outright muted, because music messes with me. As I tell people who can't understand it, simply put, however music sounds to you, it doesn't sound that way to me.
THIS is my favorite song. I don't have a ton of favorites, but what limited pop songs I do listen to, this is my #1. And I found it delightfully ironic that in my position as someone medically unable to process tone, that someone who does this as their passion had so much trouble with my favorite song. Go figure, huh?
Wow this was an amazing breakdown, thank you for sharing! I love the idea of songs wondering around the root chord, never occurred to me that when this song finally gets there, it's still not resolved. Tears for Fears are amazing. Love the new album too by the way. They've still got it after all these years!
cool upload. the drums definitely deserve more attention. they're such a big part of the song and there's a history behind that specific shuffle pattern.
Analysis aside, good to know you're into Slay the Spire! Recognised that "Time Keeper" immediately!
I find it funny how the first 1/4 of this video is him talking about how confused he is by the song's intro meanwhile I always heard it "correctly" and found it relatively straightforward/simple so the entire intro had me like "???". I guess we are differently trained.
*_TOTALLY AMAZING_*
You've given me a Fresh Perspective of the song. There definitely feels a _struggle_ between 'Order' (Domination) and 'Freedom'...
Q: Do you make the Doodled music paper available to be purchased?
4:30 - Loved that Slay the Spire reference with the Time Eat... ehm Keeper!
Soooo interesting! Thanks, I just love TFF - do more stuff on them when you feel like it
One of the aspects of this song that I like the most is the drum groove. In the drumming community, this song has become well known for people playing the song and changing the rhythm part by metric modulations which take advantage of the rhythm and can allow for a drummer to play this in several related meters. There are numerous examples of creative drummers doing metric modulation versions of this song and some of them are quite impressive. I have always found the drum groove in this to be infectious. Great analysis of the song, I found it most insightful.
@12tone Thank you sooooo much for clarifing such a rich song so well!!!!
I'm a fan of all your videos. I don't dare put my music on the Tube, but you make me a better musician.
I want to underline what you said about the lack of resolution not being about hopelessness but a call to action. I think it's important to remember what was going on in the world at the time this album came out: Cold War. It was always on our minds and it permeates the music of the 80s, particularly bands from Europe. I don't know if they felt more the eye in the storm or what it was, but it definitely felt (to me anyway) that American Bands didn't wear this on their sleeves as much as their European counterparts. In any case, this album always carries with it that armageddon undertone to me (well, Head over Heels not so much). The video for Mother's Talk definitely brings this all the way to the surface. But the anti-war message is similar in both songs and they clearly both have the same undercurrent, it's just more "under" in this one.
I clicked on the video having no idea what the title or song in question was, but around a minute and 40 seconds i remembered it just from the few chords played, and That shows jsur how iconic this song is, such a great song
At about 1:00 12tone uses the halo symbol for the word boring, and I feel attacked
I’ve always heard the opening as triplets. What’s always broken my brain is counting off that higher downward arpeggio leading into the song.
I’ll be seeing them live (again) next month.
Yes! I too struggled to hear this correctly at first. Your video helped me figure it out. I'm now able to hear it the correct way, but damn.
I have always loved that you use Battletoads to indicate difficulty.
Don’t know if it was because I had played drums first, but always felt like trip- l -ets to me.
Sometimes I have to get up and walk away from the video for a minute. And when I come back, I have no idea what I'm looking at.
This was amazing!!! EWTRTW is one of my favorite song and I already knew it was accidental genius but to get the signatures, key, instrumental breakdown that you have given us 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾❤️❤️❤️
I liked your quip about Alexander weeping. Rick Beato did not make that reference. I liked your videos equally for different reasons, which seems to be true of all my favorite content creators.
I play this song in my car every morning on my drive to work
The Korn ‘Follow the Leader’ drawing was hilarious. Someone could do an entire video analyzing your images lol
Great video as always - have you ever considered analysing Mason Williams's "Classical Gas"?
Weird. Those intro notes were always triplets in my head since I was 5 years old rockin out to it at Showbiz Pizza while waiting for the next Rockafire Explosion show - and didn't know what triplets were. I've always heard it that way. Kind of blew my mind that you somehow managed to hear it differently. Reminds of the many times I've started a song that I've heard countless times and somehow caught it between beats and my brain suddenly heard the rhythm completely differently and my mind melted. It's always a trippy experience!
Despite it only going between B- and C, there's something I especially love during that synth solo, both as a bassist and as a theory nerd. Through the most of the song, there's that tension and release of the A/D and G/D where the pedal tone is grounding everything, yet we get one spot where the bass gets to be the one creating the tension by having the melody staying in D pentatonic but the bass playing a C natural and starting the second measure with an F#/C. That's something that doesn't pop up in pop music very often and it just is so pleasing to my ears.
Love your vids and this is one of my favorite 80's classics. Thanks for so effectively and eloquently explaining the complexities of this wonderful piece of art
Really wild stuff. I’ve heard this song plenty of times, can recognize it from the intro alone, and all of the message and music theory behind it completely went over my head. I’ve always thought of it as a chill, relaxing song, but this really helped me see more to it than that.
The song is propelled mainly by the dual nature of the 6:8 time sig: the vocal marches on the 1 and 4, while the guitar swirls around in threes on the 2, 4 and 6. (Well, arguably it’s 12:8 but you get the idea.)
Also: the middle eight is a middle six: the last two bars are junked for a sudden return to the chorus structure.
Haha the Intro. I was a little surprised that you didn't here the triplets right away, but I feel you there. I also have a couple of songs that I heard "wrong" in the beginning, hearing a simple backbeat as some weird snare on 2+ and 4+ beat because maybe the guitar or something got burned in my brain the wrong way the first time. like most people have with the intro guitar of highway to hell, hearing the beginning as the downbeat instead of the upbeat.
it feels really stupid when you just can't get the wrong idea out of your head.
“The 8th note is just gone…”
….. draws D.B. Cooper. Lol. Fantastic
Shoutout to the time eater cameo for slay the spire in one of your sketches talking about keeping time
Chris Hughes is an example of why producers are invaluable in the studio.
You don't necessarily need yet another read on the rhythm here, but I think of the entire song in 12/8, making that main synth vamp out of eighth notes, and the bass pulse not a swung 4/4 but a quarter-eigth-quarter-eighth rhythm totally normal in this 6/8, 12/8 space (see for example the Rondo of Beethoven's Sonata Pastorale or, alternately, Gary Glitter's Rock and Roll Part 2). Obviously that's the same thing as 4/4 built on eighth triplets, but I feel like everything feels more straightforward if we just assume a 3-feel rather than a 2-feel throughout. Just my unasked-for two cents but, as always, the cool thing about music theory is that so much of it is a matter of interpretation and feel.
Great video and analysis. Arranging music into layers as opposed to sections is something that is an under appreciated skill imho.
Love the Timekeeper from StS when you say "time keeper" :P
I’ve enjoyed a number of your videos, but this one got me hittin Subscribe. You’re great.
You're amazing, love your analysis videos
Genuinely combine this with Mad World and others surely it makes Tears for Fears some of the best lyricists of all time. Just one of those song would put you in the top 10 and they wrote both of them!
Absolutely fascinating and very informative video! By the way, how in the world did you get hold of the single voice, guitar parts, synth? There is no way a program could take the original song and pull out all of the voices and instruments/synths seperately.