Truly, the stories about the prophets in the Quran are more amazing and insightful than those from the earlier corrupted scriptures. Sadly, we were deprived of this knowledge before, but Alhamdulillah it is being rediscovered now.
Mind blowing yet again. InshA in years to come we will wonder why we never held up previous tasfirs up to scrutiny. Dr Hany, you are truly a genuine and sincere scholar and I appreciate your sharing of knowledge. I wait for your full Quran translation in good time InshA
When I read translation Really I asked this question to myself 1.How it's possible to lean on a staff? 2. Hand becoming white _ what is the relevant sign on this? Now it makes sense *He was using this staff because he is disabled. * Staff is helping for him in many things and he is depend on staff That's why Allah asked about his staff * As a replacement Allah made his hand to regrow This is a big sign for even Musa pbuh.
Hamdulilah what’s important for me at this moment is that I am starting to understand your methodology and the pre-learned concept communicated by tafsir Hadith and so on are fading away to liberate my mind. Inchallah I will continue to grow and keep my faith in Islam while knowing Muslims are harming it.
Absolutely is more powerful and more cleara than what they thought me in a school’s and the translation Books. I repeated this segment couple of times and each time is more sweater. Thank you Dr Hany Allaah Bless you and hear after.
With the help of Allah we increase in knowledge that's provided by brothers who think, ponder, search, reflect and share their thoughts. May Allah increase us further in ilm and iman.
ALLAHU AKBAR! Jazakumullahu khairan wa ahsanal jazaa', Dr. Hany. I've ask always wondered why Musa (as) wasn't punished for the committed homicide by Fir'aun upon his return. And, here the answer hits me in the face! I'm delighted, sir.
@@MarvelousQuran May Almighty Allah bless you, your household and efforts exceedingly, sir! Aameen! If only you understand how this method of interpretation feels on my spirit, sir. And, I know this "package" is just the tip of the iceberg.
@ Azeez Bello Believe me my brother... I do understand.. I have been living in this Jannah for years alhamduillah. May Allahh keep us guided and deploy us and the knowledge he provided us in what pleases him, alone!
MasyaAllah, Alhamdulillah. This is a very plausible answer to the questions that crossed my mind whenever I passed through these verses. Mabruk Ustaz. Jzkk
Alhamdulillah. It's not a coincidence that I came to find this channel. It began when I watched the title Why the Quran did not mention Chinese Prophets and sent the link to a Chinese who happened to ask the same thing a little later. You provided a stable and sound answer that was easy to understand. And, here I am continuing on the journey to learn more.
Salamun Alaikum. Excellent and logical explanation... Very interesting indeed. A refreshing look at Moses hand turning "white". Great stuff you are doin with your Video series...
Absolutely astonishing. Never paid attention to his left hand . Never knew nothing about it . Now I know it. A manifest example of divine knowledge of Ayah. Great discovery by Dr. Hany. Thank you for sharing . May God the All- mighty bless you. Amen.
Great insights into the story of Moses, I must congratulate your open mindedness and willingness to challenge recieved knowledge. The hand turning white was seen as a remarkable sign in those days because, not only Musa, but most people of that time in Egypt were dark-skinned people. The prophet had described Musa as a dark skinned man and Cheikh Anta Diop has proven that the ancient Egyptians were a dark skinned people , similar to the saidi Egyptians, northern Sudanese, Somalis and similar peoples. The most interesting question is the one Musa is asked i.e what is that in your hand. God obviously knows what it is,and Musa goes to great lengths to explain the mundane uses of his staff. Why did Musa elaborate so much on the uses of a stick,which God knows. The answer could be in the significance of the staff as a symbol in Egyptian religion and earthly authority. There were different types of staff used by the Pharaoh and the Egyptian priesthood for both religious reasons and as a sign of earthly authority such as the waas, sekhem etc.,and there are scholarly articles on this. Moses was raised in the Pharaoh's house and was well acquainted with these symbols and and their meaning. He probably carried some kind of Egyptian staff and in this verse God may be chiding him for clinging to symbols of the Egyptian religion and moses replies,almost embarrassedly, and as if defending himself, mentioning all the mundane reasons for carrying a staff and distancing himself from the Egyptian religion and pharaoh. There could be other explanations of course, but hats of to you for daring to go beyond the conventional explanations we have been fed for ages. It is always beneficial to constructively critique and think beyond recieved "knowledge" and hopefully arrive closer to the "truth".
@Rifhan Mohamed you make good observations. Perhaps you may be able to come with confirming evidence from the Quran. Laws of nature are created by Allahh. Regrowing of parts happen all the time. Parts of the human being (through cell regeneration) regrow all the time. Regards
It's shame that this channel only gained so much subscribers so far. I just found this out and I am addicted right away. It opens my eyes. I hope it will reach wider viewer.
Salam, It's really helped to make myself speechless.🤐 Definitely you deserve many many thanks for it. And I also want to give thanks to my 'Rab' for make me introduced to you🙏
❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️ ماشاء الله ... بارك الله فيك وهداك للحق نقلت لوالدتي هذا الحديث والفكر المتروي في كلام الله واخذنا النقاش فسبحان الله ذكرتني بالحادثه التي حصلت لموسى عليه السلام وهو طفل في قصر فرعون عندما قدموا له التمره والجمره فمسك بالجمره ... ❕❗️ ففرعون يعلم ما حدث ليد الصغير الذي تربى في قصره!
تلك القصة ليست من القرءان وهي مما أخذه مؤلِّفو كتب التفسير من التوراة المحرفة ومن الإسسرائيليات ولكن القرءان يؤكد لنا أن فرعون كان ينكّل ببني اسرائيل وكان يشوّه أجسامهم ووجوههم ويستبيح أعراض نسائهم الخ، وقد عرضنا مسألة "يُذَبِّح" ومعناها الصادم في المقطع أدناه th-cam.com/video/zhahZQAQh-8/w-d-xo.html مع الشكر والتحية لكم و للوالدة الكريمة
MachaAllah! Thanks Dr Hany! Truly, this explanation of yours is by far the most beautiful, plausible ,and powerful ever heard! I myself struggled with the commentaries that were given to explain the “the miracle of the hand”. I was never satisfied with any of them to the point where I had to come up with my own intake on that issue which was to say simply that for Moses’ hand to come out white as a miracle, it had to be black originally. Therefore Moses was a black man with a white hand in a land of black people! Interesting take, but not at all powerful as the explanation you came up with! And off course, Allah (SWT) is far from anything lame, deep yes He is! Thanks
Salam dr. Hany atchan, First of all i am new and am happy with your fantastic channel all a new contribution with good explanation. I had a question on this subject where Musa first shows his left hand to Pharaoh but this is actually the second time, because the first time see 20:22 Allah s.w.t shows this to Musa. Does that mean his left hand is already perfect?
I wonder if somebody did or will collect the scattered stories of all the prophets like Musa a.s into a comprehensive narration. I hope to do it myself inshaallah.
Hi it's very amazing stuff. I never heard before. I wish I understand Arabic. I like your approach. I agree that we need a new interpretation for certain verses. Are you planning to do a Tafsir?
Thank you for your comment. I am working on a complete translation of the Quran based on the newly discovered Quranic methodology. Insha Allahh you will Keep watching
@@MarvelousQuran May Allah accepts your intentions and make it a reality. Really you are doing a marvelous work. Please keep doing it. Thanks for sharing.
@@ahlalfiqh its a reasonable comparison that u hav done here. But the thing is Law of nature cannot be changed by us, but it can be done by the Almighty. Its called miracle because it defys law of nature. Similarly, the staff when it was put/thrown downt, it became a serpent and then when prophet Musa held it in his hand it became a staff again. This defys law of nature but it has happened because the almighty made it happen. Thats why its called miracle.
@@ahlalfiqh whats the logic behind the staff turning into a snake and becoming staff again??? Is it a law of nature that a staff can become a snake? Or is it a magic?
Please anyone know where or when this translation of Quran will be available to purchase or whuch website i csn download the translation of the whole Quran?
What an Incredible analysis of the story, I also read somewhere that the ancient Egyptians used to take the hands of their enemies in battle as trophies and in the Quran 20: 71 Pharaoh gets angry at the magicians when they surrender to Musa and threatens them with the cutting of the hands, Also I have found some Israelite hadiths that tries to explain how Musa (As) damaged both his hands and tongue as a baby. One day-Moses was then in his fourth year-while Pharaoh was playing with him, he took the crown from the king's head, and throwing it on the ground, thrust it away with his foot. The king's suspicion was roused afresh: enraged, he ran to Asia, reproaching her for having persuaded him to let Moses live, and manifested once more a desire to put him to death;* but Asia laughed at him p. 127 for permitting the naughtiness of a child to excite in him such gloomy thoughts. "Well, then," said Pharaoh, "let us see whether the child has acted thoughtlessly or with reflection? Let a bowl with burning coals and one with coin be brought. If he seize the former, he shall live; but if he stretch out his hand to the latter, he has betrayed himself." Asia was forced to obey, and her eyes hung in painful suspense on Moses's hand, as if her own life had been at stake. Endowed with manly understanding, Moses was on the point of taking a handful of the shining coin, when Allah, watching over his life, sent an angel, who, against the child's will, directed his hand into the burning coals, and even put one to his mouth. Pharaoh was again reassured, and entreated Asia for forgiveness; but Moses had burned his tongue, and was a stammerer from that day. Now if this story is correct then Musa (As) would have received 3rd or 4th Degree burns that would have caused scaring in his whole palms and because it happened as a baby his whole hand would have been scared and damaged and maybe even have been dark in discoloration, Allah removed the scarring and his palms would have become white again and showing it to Pharaoh upon meeting him would have been a massive power move by Allah through musa towards pharaoh, Remember that this man had new-born children killed because he dreamed that he will be toppled one day and he went all his life being suspicious and distrusting of everything around him and now his suspicions had become a reality and to top it off he raised this person in front of his eyes all this time, he must have felt foolish and weak, it served as a great warning and a sign that if he does not get his act together his dream would become true and Allah knows best.
The story of the burning coals is nothing but fabrication, created by those same people who corrupted the Torah, and absentmindedly iterated by Muslims without any sense of respect for Quran. However, I like your very first paragraph Regards
@@MarvelousQuran I do not deny that there are many fabrications in the old testament but we must respect them because we were told they still contain some truth within and Allah knows best, as for your theory I do not disclaim it and I believe Allah (swt) is able to do all things, but I do have a slight issue with small matter Musa (as) was Asked by Allah to take his hand and place it under his arm, that would mean that Musa's hand would have been fully attached otherwise Allah would have asked him to place his limb under his arm, Allah does not make mistakes in the way he words things and that gives me an issue with the regrowth theory, therefore Musa had a full hand but it had some kind of harm or deformation that stopped him from fully utilizing it but again Allah knows best. Wa alaikiumu salam
There are little Citation mistakes.. At [6:48] Surah TaaHaa is 20th surah but in the slide its "28" Also at [9:00] Its 33rd Verse of Ash Shuarr.. Not "28" Anyway the video was very Informative and I expect you should concentrate on this series more for future videos Jazk Allah Khairan..
Dr hany we are not reptiles , do you think Musa is an Axolotl? or is your interpretation isn't clear about his hand? is it chopped? maimed? or is it that his hand were carrying out and doing bad deeds / criminal activities?
@@MarvelousQuran salamun alaykum Dr, you should correct yourself and to your audience that this segment is not based on reality. i was thinking that musa has an anger problem , he can't convey words very well , he was a gangster , he is trying to balance himself by abstaining from rage and repurpose his hand to purify himself for good and purely for Allah.
@@MarvelousQuran correct , that is just my thinking , it is not true indeed. but Musa growing a hand like a reptile? Axolotl? that is far fetched in reality and cartoonish.
In surah Taha verse 27 Nabi Musa asks Allah among other things which is to untie the knot from his tongue. There are some narrations saying that Nabi Musa has a speech impediment due to certain accident when he was young. As such that is why he needs his brother Harun to accompany him and speak on his behalf. Is there any basis or evidence to this claim? If I’m not wrong there is no mention of Nabi Harun speaking on his behalf when they met Firaun. What does it actually means to untie the knot from his tongue? Hopefully you are able to enlighten on this.
Just a thought, I could be wrong. Have you ever taken off a glove whilst your other hand is in use? Most of us put the hand under armpit and pull it off. Perhaps his hand was in a cast, and it came out white, as the skin goes discoloured when covered for a while.
Great. We are at the same page. I try to write down some notes on paper from Quran every night. Moses hand was one of the notes I took last night and tonight I come accross you video on the same. What a coincidence... I finally wrote "what is this?" he can't be afraid of his hand becoming just white! and arrived exactly at the answer you explained. I just think his hand was harmed/disabled either since birth or later by accident or illness. Just as you said "you ask the question and the answer will come to you". Exactly.
"I try to write down some notes on paper from Quran every night."... One of my favorite practices, except I do it in the morning after Fajr. Keep it up bro
Jazakallah. My own understanding of these verses was that his hand became literally white. The reason this would be amazing for someone seeing it is because Musa (AS) was described by the Prophet (SAW) in a hadith as having very dark skin colour. I do think your explanation is very plausible and is worth thinking about. Although I would appreciate if you could also explain verse 26 of surah 40 where Allah (SWT) says that pharaoh said "Let me kill Moses and let him call upon his Lord". As this verse clearly shows that pharaoh did indeed want to try to kill Musa (AS). Jazakallah for all your efforts
Fir3aoun used language that often indicated different things than its superficial indications. Had he wanted to kill Mussa, he would not have needed permission.
"Atawaka'oo 3alayha" may also means "i put my head on it to rest" as used to do someone putting his hands one over the other on the top of the staff and then put his forehead. As for "baydha'" it may also means transparent or translucent ...?
@@MarvelousQuran simplicity is the foundation of knowledge and science. The best analysis or explanation is the simplest. Hockham razor principle. May Allah increase my 3ilm and yours. Ameen. Wa essalaam
I read somewhere that when prophet Moses were young and were adopted by feroun , he tested Musa with diamonds in one plate and burning coal in another plate and Musa AS picked burning coal probably through his left hand and put it in his mouth, and this made him difficult to speak clear words. Please guide me if iam wrong. Baarak Allah feek
@AL-LLUGHA THE LANGUAGE This is definitely imported from the corrupted versions of earlier scriptures. We will prove that the Quran tells a totally different story of Moses' childhood in an upcoming video Insha Allahh
Truly, the stories about the prophets in the Quran are more amazing and insightful than those from the earlier corrupted scriptures. Sadly, we were deprived of this knowledge before, but Alhamdulillah it is being rediscovered now.
Revisiting this segment this Ramadhan. Alhamdulillah.
Mind blowing yet again. InshA in years to come we will wonder why we never held up previous tasfirs up to scrutiny. Dr Hany, you are truly a genuine and sincere scholar and I appreciate your sharing of knowledge. I wait for your full Quran translation in good time InshA
Thank you sir, for all your hard work, for sharing it with the world. May Allah the Allmighty bless you.
Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah Alhamdulilah
Makes sense. Thank you Dr. You’re a gift.
Glory to Allah for his mercy to reopen Quran to us through Dr Hany
الحمد لله ❤❤❤
When I read translation
Really I asked this question to myself
1.How it's possible to lean on a staff?
2. Hand becoming white _ what is the relevant sign on this?
Now it makes sense
*He was using this staff because he is disabled.
* Staff is helping for him in many things and he is depend on staff
That's why Allah asked about his staff
* As a replacement Allah made his hand to regrow
This is a big sign for even Musa pbuh.
Welcome the As-Sarh ;)
theses were my questions too. now i am convinced. thanks to allah .
Alhamdulliah, i am convinced too. I feel more happier somehow.
come on guys 1400 years of scholars ... not a mention from the salaf or rasulullah pbuh...come on i only say Allahu alam...
@@idrisyasin7614 , yes there are many things to discover in the Quran. It was told in a hadith regarding the Quran's mysteries to be opened in future.
Hamdulilah what’s important for me at this moment is that I am starting to understand your methodology and the pre-learned concept communicated by tafsir Hadith and so on are fading away to liberate my mind. Inchallah I will continue to grow and keep my faith in Islam while knowing Muslims are harming it.
Very enlightening segment. Thank you 🙏
Ma'sha'Allah, very convincing.
Great discovery.. May Allah give you the strength to translate the whole quran.
Alhamdulillah
Jazakhallahukhairan it is very useful and mercy from Allah, Allah increase us in knowledge and reward you immensely
Absolutely is more powerful and more cleara than what they thought me in a school’s and the translation Books.
I repeated this segment couple of times and each time is more sweater. Thank you Dr Hany Allaah Bless you and hear after.
Alhamdulillah. Amazing. Thank you Dr. Hany!
Alhamdulillah. Thank you Dr Hany for the explanation.
mashaAllah good explanation. Jazzakallahu kheir Dr Hani
Thank you.
With the help of Allah we increase in knowledge that's provided by brothers who think, ponder, search, reflect and share their thoughts. May Allah increase us further in ilm and iman.
Thank you again for this immense light
You are so welcome
ALLAHU AKBAR!
Jazakumullahu khairan wa ahsanal jazaa', Dr. Hany.
I've ask always wondered why Musa (as) wasn't punished for the committed homicide by Fir'aun upon his return. And, here the answer hits me in the face!
I'm delighted, sir.
Alhamdulillah... What you feel is the Quran acting upon yuo like software changes the computer states.
Please keep watching...Regards
@@MarvelousQuran May Almighty Allah bless you, your household and efforts exceedingly, sir! Aameen! If only you understand how this method of interpretation feels on my spirit, sir. And, I know this "package" is just the tip of the iceberg.
@ Azeez Bello Believe me my brother... I do understand.. I have been living in this Jannah for years alhamduillah. May Allahh keep us guided and deploy us and the knowledge he provided us in what pleases him, alone!
@@MarvelousQuran Aameen Yaa Rabbal aalameen!
Great addition to the translation in the past.
Great interpretation Dr Hany, Masha Allah Quran is mother of all miracles
May Allah guide you to disclose more such hidden miracles to us
Aameen
MasyaAllah, Alhamdulillah. This is a very plausible answer to the questions that crossed my mind whenever I passed through these verses. Mabruk Ustaz. Jzkk
Mind blowing. Thank you Hany
My pleasure. Plz Sub, Like, and share. Regards
Subhan Allah
Wow, it’s mind blowing, hope i have time to lesson to all of your discoveries. I feel so special lessoning to you
Jazak ALLAH khayr...Keep enlightening us please. Insha ALLAH
Thank you. Insha Allahh this is my primary and exclusive mission. Keep watching and plz spread the word. Regards
Masha'Allah.. May Allah swt mercy be on you always..
Thank you so much.
Welcome
One tiny problem Dr Hany, please show primary Quranic evidence for the word Baydaa being used to mean pure. Thank You.
I am sleepless and my heart is uneasy, I can’t explain how i am feeling it’s out of this world the feelings…..
Alhamdulillah. Welcome to As-Sarh
Alhamdulillah. It's not a coincidence that I came to find this channel. It began when I watched the title Why the Quran did not mention Chinese Prophets and sent the link to a Chinese who happened to ask the same thing a little later. You provided a stable and sound answer that was easy to understand. And, here I am continuing on the journey to learn more.
Alhamdulillah. Thank you Dr Hany
SubhanAllah!
Thanks for sharing this. You're a good person. May God bless you and give you peace 🙏🏻
Alhamdulillah
can you please make a playlist for this topic? would be easier to find the continuation of the topic with playlist..
Good idea. Will do. Thank you.
Salamun Alaikum. Excellent and logical explanation... Very interesting indeed. A refreshing look at Moses hand turning "white". Great stuff you are doin with your Video series...
Much appreciated
Jazakallah khair
Subhanallah
Alhamdulillah for the enlightenment, thank you very much Prof Atchan. Will definitely listen through all this channel clips in shaa Allah
Alhamdulillah
Amazing
Excellent....eye opening...
Waow so incredible. Thank you... I was on that way until you confirmed me👍👍
Thank you
You're welcome
I always wondered and wanted an explanation about the white hand.
MashaAllah doctor Allah gave you the best brain
My pleasure. Allahh simply allowed me to see (some of) the beauty in the Quran
Extremely interesting, Sheikh. May Allah reward you.
DR Hany ,,you are brilliant....
Thank you. Alhamdulillah alone
Absolutely astonishing. Never paid attention to his left hand . Never knew nothing about it . Now I know it. A manifest example of divine knowledge of Ayah. Great discovery by Dr. Hany. Thank you for sharing . May God the All- mighty bless you. Amen.
Alhamdulillah alone
,excellent interpretation
Great insights into the story of Moses, I must congratulate your open mindedness and willingness to challenge recieved knowledge.
The hand turning white was seen as a remarkable sign in those days because, not only Musa, but most people of that time in Egypt were dark-skinned people. The prophet had described Musa as a dark skinned man and Cheikh Anta Diop has proven that the ancient Egyptians were a dark skinned people , similar to the saidi Egyptians, northern Sudanese, Somalis and similar peoples.
The most interesting question is the one Musa is asked i.e what is that in your hand. God obviously knows what it is,and Musa goes to great lengths to explain the mundane uses of his staff. Why did Musa elaborate so much on the uses of a stick,which God knows.
The answer could be in the significance of the staff as a symbol in Egyptian religion and earthly authority. There were different types of staff used by the Pharaoh and the Egyptian priesthood for both religious reasons and as a sign of earthly authority such as the waas, sekhem etc.,and there are scholarly articles on this.
Moses was raised in the Pharaoh's house and was well acquainted with these symbols and and their meaning. He probably carried some kind of Egyptian staff and in this verse God may be chiding him for clinging to symbols of the Egyptian religion and moses replies,almost embarrassedly, and as if defending himself, mentioning all the mundane reasons for carrying a staff and distancing himself from the Egyptian religion and pharaoh.
There could be other explanations of course, but hats of to you for daring to go beyond the conventional explanations we have been fed for ages. It is always beneficial to constructively critique and think beyond recieved "knowledge" and hopefully arrive closer to the "truth".
Well done,. My ALLAH increase your knowledge,.
MashaAllah MashaAllah
Clear like crystal water!! Again..MashaAllah
Aameen
Very informative and well-explained.
Glad it was helpful!
@Rifhan Mohamed you make good observations. Perhaps you may be able to come with confirming evidence from the Quran.
Laws of nature are created by Allahh. Regrowing of parts happen all the time. Parts of the human being (through cell regeneration) regrow all the time. Regards
Alhamdullilah
jazaakumullah khairan
marvelous insight! thanks for sharing
Alhamdulillah
MashAllah
AAmmeen
Awesome ! Mashallah.
Alhamdulillah
MashAllah. Very good explanation. You are giving meaningful knowledge about the Quranic verses.
Thanks and welcome
MashaAllah
احسنت یا دکتر .
JazakAllha
You too
ما شاء الله
MAAnsha Allah
JazakumUllah khair, i always think of that but didnt find answer, but i assumed that. Now i have proove
Ma Sha Allahh... And some people want us to believe that Allahh, the living god, does not speak to us !!!!!
Jazzakallahu hairan
You too
It's shame that this channel only gained so much subscribers so far. I just found this out and I am addicted right away. It opens my eyes. I hope it will reach wider viewer.
Insha Allahh. Make Duaa plz
Salam, It's really helped to make myself speechless.🤐 Definitely you deserve many many thanks for it. And I also want to give thanks to my 'Rab' for make me introduced to you🙏
Alhamdulillah
mashaallah
Alhamdulillah
❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️❕❗️
ماشاء الله ... بارك الله فيك وهداك للحق
نقلت لوالدتي هذا الحديث والفكر المتروي في كلام الله
واخذنا النقاش فسبحان الله ذكرتني بالحادثه التي حصلت لموسى عليه السلام وهو طفل في قصر فرعون عندما قدموا له التمره والجمره فمسك بالجمره ... ❕❗️
ففرعون يعلم ما حدث ليد الصغير الذي تربى في قصره!
تلك القصة ليست من القرءان وهي مما أخذه مؤلِّفو كتب التفسير من التوراة المحرفة ومن الإسسرائيليات
ولكن القرءان يؤكد لنا أن فرعون كان ينكّل ببني اسرائيل وكان يشوّه أجسامهم ووجوههم ويستبيح أعراض نسائهم الخ، وقد عرضنا مسألة "يُذَبِّح" ومعناها الصادم في المقطع أدناه
th-cam.com/video/zhahZQAQh-8/w-d-xo.html
مع الشكر والتحية لكم و للوالدة الكريمة
great channel...maybe better adding some others language subtitle.jazakallah
Thank you. Welcome aboard
MachaAllah! Thanks Dr Hany! Truly, this explanation of yours is by far the most beautiful, plausible ,and powerful ever heard! I myself struggled with the commentaries that were given to explain the “the miracle of the hand”. I was never satisfied with any of them to the point where I had to come up with my own intake on that issue which was to say simply that for Moses’ hand to come out white as a miracle, it had to be black originally. Therefore Moses was a black man with a white hand in a land of black people! Interesting take, but not at all powerful as the explanation you came up with! And off course, Allah (SWT) is far from anything lame, deep yes He is!
Thanks
Salam dr. Hany atchan, First of all i am new and am happy with your fantastic channel all a new contribution with good explanation. I had a question on this subject where Musa first shows his left hand to Pharaoh but this is actually the second time, because the first time see 20:22 Allah s.w.t shows this to Musa. Does that mean his left hand is already perfect?
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I wonder if somebody did or will collect the scattered stories of all the prophets like Musa a.s into a comprehensive narration. I hope to do it myself inshaallah.
Allah ho Akbar
Aameen. Please subscribe, like, and spread the word. Regards
Hi it's very amazing stuff. I never heard before. I wish I understand Arabic. I like your approach. I agree that we need a new interpretation for certain verses. Are you planning to do a Tafsir?
Thank you for your comment. I am working on a complete translation of the Quran based on the newly discovered Quranic methodology. Insha Allahh you will Keep watching
@@MarvelousQuran May Allah accepts your intentions and make it a reality. Really you are doing a marvelous work. Please keep doing it. Thanks for sharing.
@@MarvelousQuran May Allah bless you and help for your work.
@@ahlalfiqh its a reasonable comparison that u hav done here.
But the thing is Law of nature cannot be changed by us, but it can be done by the Almighty. Its called miracle because it defys law of nature.
Similarly, the staff when it was put/thrown downt, it became a serpent and then when prophet Musa held it in his hand it became a staff again. This defys law of nature but it has happened because the almighty made it happen. Thats why its called miracle.
@@ahlalfiqh whats the logic behind the staff turning into a snake and becoming staff again??? Is it a law of nature that a staff can become a snake? Or is it a magic?
when will the story of Musa be discussed in full..
Time stamp 17:40, ref to Taha verse should be 20:22
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🙏
Please anyone know where or when this translation of Quran will be available to purchase or whuch website i csn download the translation of the whole Quran?
Nice to know more about Quran.
Is Translation complete?? Is it available as hard Copy?? How to get it??
What an Incredible analysis of the story, I also read somewhere that the ancient Egyptians used to take the hands of their enemies in battle as trophies and in the Quran 20: 71 Pharaoh gets angry at the magicians when they surrender to Musa and threatens them with the cutting of the hands, Also I have found some Israelite hadiths that tries to explain how Musa (As) damaged both his hands and tongue as a baby.
One day-Moses was then in his fourth year-while Pharaoh was playing with him, he took the crown from the king's head, and throwing it on the ground, thrust it away with his foot. The king's suspicion was roused afresh: enraged, he ran to Asia, reproaching her for having persuaded him to let Moses live, and manifested once more a desire to put him to death;* but Asia laughed at him p. 127 for permitting the naughtiness of a child to excite in him such gloomy thoughts.
"Well, then," said Pharaoh, "let us see whether the child has acted thoughtlessly or with reflection? Let a bowl with burning coals and one with coin be brought. If he seize the former, he shall live; but if he stretch out his hand to the latter, he has betrayed himself."
Asia was forced to obey, and her eyes hung in painful suspense on Moses's hand, as if her own life had been at stake. Endowed with manly understanding, Moses was on the point of taking a handful of the shining coin, when Allah, watching over his life, sent an angel, who, against the child's will, directed his hand into the burning coals, and even put one to his mouth. Pharaoh was again reassured, and entreated Asia for forgiveness; but Moses had burned his tongue, and was a stammerer from that day.
Now if this story is correct then Musa (As) would have received 3rd or 4th Degree burns that would have caused scaring in his whole palms and because it happened as a baby his whole hand would have been scared and damaged and maybe even have been dark in discoloration, Allah removed the scarring and his palms would have become white again and showing it to Pharaoh upon meeting him would have been a massive power move by Allah through musa towards pharaoh, Remember that this man had new-born children killed because he dreamed that he will be toppled one day and he went all his life being suspicious and distrusting of everything around him and now his suspicions had become a reality and to top it off he raised this person in front of his eyes all this time, he must have felt foolish and weak, it served as a great warning and a sign that if he does not get his act together his dream would become true and Allah knows best.
The story of the burning coals is nothing but fabrication, created by those same people who corrupted the Torah, and absentmindedly iterated by Muslims without any sense of respect for Quran.
However, I like your very first paragraph
Regards
@@MarvelousQuran I do not deny that there are many fabrications in the old testament but we must respect them because we were told they still contain some truth within and Allah knows best, as for your theory I do not disclaim it and I believe Allah (swt) is able to do all things, but I do have a slight issue with small matter
Musa (as) was Asked by Allah to take his hand and place it under his arm, that would mean that Musa's hand would have been fully attached otherwise Allah would have asked him to place his limb under his arm, Allah does not make mistakes in the way he words things and that gives me an issue with the regrowth theory, therefore Musa had a full hand but it had some kind of harm or deformation that stopped him from fully utilizing it but again Allah knows best. Wa alaikiumu salam
There are little Citation mistakes..
At [6:48]
Surah TaaHaa is 20th surah but in the slide its "28"
Also at [9:00]
Its 33rd Verse of Ash Shuarr.. Not "28"
Anyway the video was very Informative and I expect you should concentrate on this series more for future videos
Jazk Allah Khairan..
Thank you
Dr hany we are not reptiles , do you think Musa is an Axolotl? or is your interpretation isn't clear about his hand? is it chopped? maimed?
or is it that his hand were carrying out and doing bad deeds / criminal activities?
Very good
@@MarvelousQuran salamun alaykum Dr,
you should correct yourself and to your audience that this segment is not based on reality.
i was thinking that musa has an anger problem , he can't convey words very well , he was a gangster , he is trying to balance himself by abstaining from rage and repurpose his hand to purify himself for good and purely for Allah.
That's your thinking.
@@MarvelousQuran correct , that is just my thinking , it is not true indeed.
but Musa growing a hand like a reptile? Axolotl? that is far fetched in reality and cartoonish.
وكاء بكسر الواو تعني الحيط الذي تشد به الصرة أو الكيس أو غيرهما وليس العصاء
الاتكاء على العصاء اي الاعتماد عليها
الفعل الذي في الآية هو "وَكَأَ" وليس "تَّكَأ"أَ
ما شاء الله على أصحاب اللغة
بورك فيك
In surah Taha verse 27 Nabi Musa asks Allah among other things which is to untie the knot from his tongue. There are some narrations saying that Nabi Musa has a speech impediment due to certain accident when he was young. As such that is why he needs his brother Harun to accompany him and speak on his behalf. Is there any basis or evidence to this claim? If I’m not wrong there is no mention of Nabi Harun speaking on his behalf when they met Firaun. What does it actually means to untie the knot from his tongue? Hopefully you are able to enlighten on this.
Keep watching . Soon we will release the answer to this question among others re. Prophet Mussa. Thank you
Just a thought, I could be wrong. Have you ever taken off a glove whilst your other hand is in use? Most of us put the hand under armpit and pull it off. Perhaps his hand was in a cast, and it came out white, as the skin goes discoloured when covered for a while.
Masa Allah. Very logical. However is there any earlier evidence of amputation for Musa A.S. Do you have Quran Tharjuma done by you ?
Working on translation insha Allahh
We are waiting for it. Insa Allah
Great. We are at the same page. I try to write down some notes on paper from Quran every night. Moses hand was one of the notes I took last night and tonight I come accross you video on the same. What a coincidence... I finally wrote "what is this?" he can't be afraid of his hand becoming just white! and arrived exactly at the answer you explained. I just think his hand was harmed/disabled either since birth or later by accident or illness.
Just as you said "you ask the question and the answer will come to you". Exactly.
"I try to write down some notes on paper from Quran every night."... One of my favorite practices, except I do it in the morning after Fajr. Keep it up bro
Jazakallah.
My own understanding of these verses was that his hand became literally white. The reason this would be amazing for someone seeing it is because Musa (AS) was described by the Prophet (SAW) in a hadith as having very dark skin colour.
I do think your explanation is very plausible and is worth thinking about.
Although I would appreciate if you could also explain verse 26 of surah 40 where Allah (SWT) says that pharaoh said "Let me kill Moses and let him call upon his Lord". As this verse clearly shows that pharaoh did indeed want to try to kill Musa (AS).
Jazakallah for all your efforts
Fir3aoun used language that often indicated different things than its superficial indications. Had he wanted to kill Mussa, he would not have needed permission.
When did Pharaoh cut Musa's hand? (as a punishment) 14:40 How can he tie anything if one of his hands is cut off?
راجع آية الجبال .. جدد بيض وحمر وغرابيب سود
الابيض مرتبط بالجديد
الأبيض يرتبط بالنقاوة وعدم التلوث. وإلا فإن الآية تكون قد قالت "جدد جدد" وهذا حشو لا يليق بوصف كلام الله به
الأخضر هو الجديد
اظن التفسير كتير منطقي و صحيح و الدليل انو السحرة لما امنو برب هارون و موسى.. قالهن فرعون ...(قَالَ آمَنتُمْ لَهُ قَبْلَ أَنْ آذَنَ لَكُمْ ۖ إِنَّهُ لَكَبِيرُكُمُ الَّذِي عَلَّمَكُمُ السِّحْرَ ۖ فَلَأُقَطِّعَنَّ أَيْدِيَكُمْ وَأَرْجُلَكُم مِّنْ خِلَافٍ ) و كانو من عادة فرعون انو يعاقب بقطع الايدي و الارجل.. شكرا دكتور
هناك أدلة أخرى لم أقدّمها بعد، وأشكر دعمك ووعيك. حياك الله
"Atawaka'oo 3alayha" may also means "i put my head on it to rest" as used to do someone putting his hands one over the other on the top of the staff and then put his forehead. As for "baydha'" it may also means transparent or translucent ...?
not justified by the Quranic methodology. I know that's what some interpreters claimed, but we find no Quranic justification for it
@@MarvelousQuran simplicity is the foundation of knowledge and science. The best analysis or explanation is the simplest. Hockham razor principle. May Allah increase my 3ilm and yours. Ameen. Wa essalaam
Exactly. The words of the Quran can be explained from within the Quran. AAmeen
Dear Doctor, the verse you referred as 26:28 is not the right one. It has to be 26:33,. A mistake, right?
Thank you
I read somewhere that when prophet Moses were young and were adopted by feroun , he tested Musa with diamonds in one plate and burning coal in another plate and Musa AS picked burning coal probably through his left hand and put it in his mouth, and this made him difficult to speak clear words. Please guide me if iam wrong. Baarak Allah feek
@AL-LLUGHA THE LANGUAGE This is definitely imported from the corrupted versions of earlier scriptures. We will prove that the Quran tells a totally different story of Moses' childhood in an upcoming video Insha Allahh