Liu Xijun’s version is absolutely stunning, she sang the vicissitudes of life, if she had also included the Chinese opera part at the end it would’ve been perfection. The focus of Chinese instruments in her version as well made it all the more beautiful
Who need opinions of those commentaries preferring the suitability of voice of other singer on this songs over 单依纯? In my opinion, I can say 单依纯 sings better than Sara Liu. But again i did it on the commentaries here with due respect to the artist singing here. Just listen to the tonalities of the singing is enough. 单依纯 is another class. You can't compare. I heard Sara Liu singing in Cantonese before. Honestly 单依纯 singing in Cantonese very well though Cantonese is not her dialect.
虽然刘惜君唱得很好，但我和方文山黄雨勋的观点一样，原来中国风歌曲还可以这样唱，依纯的版本可以说完全摆脱了原曲杰伦的影子，她没被词曲带着走还唱出了专属自己风格的新中国风，太高级太有惊喜了！这也是他们此行首选依纯来演绎这首歌的最主要原因。👏
方文山说了，这歌周深唱合适，但他来这节目就是让单依纯唱的，单依纯虽然之前没有唱歌国风，但驾驭歌曲能力强，她唱会带来完全不同的感觉。结果如他们所料，单依纯的确不同于常规国风，两位创作者都表示更偏爱单依纯的版本。
还是更喜欢单依纯版哦！情绪起伏，声线波流，准确细致入微地表达了词曲创意。
Sara Liu's voice just cuts right through each time, filled with feelings and great storytelling!
小單唱出了古時那種深閨少女想念着遠方情人的心情，但礙於禮教不能宣之於口，只好一人在書齋裡默默落筆寫了一封情書給那個他，最後還巧妙地憑歌寄意（昆曲）道出心中的思念❤
劉唱的直接了當，屬原版濃濃的中國風；單唱的婉轉含蓄，因其意味深長，需要細味品嚐。两者不同風格，各有千秋❤🎉
Wow, Sara Liu ate and left no crumbs, with a better voice that cuts through my soul!
Oh my goodness, Liu Xijun’s voice never fails to give me chills, goosebump all over!
真的不错,刘唱的真情流露,颇有感染力,单就更好了, 唱出了看山不是山, 看水不是水的意境, 感觉在故意收着唱, 唱出了内心的无奈与思念. 尤其是最后的昆曲, 对喜欢的人来说, 堪我是画龙真晴, 不过也有画蛇添是之嫌.
The first one is way better to my taste. So raw and very much expressive of emotions and storytelling.
一个是惜君的呻吟，一个是纯纯的绝唱；惜君的呻吟是宋词里的留白，纯纯的绝唱是古风中的落笔。
不懂就別充內行：惜君的呻吟。中文程度真差，還出來丟人現眼。
单依纯版本的新中国风给我们带来了惊喜，越听越好听。
單的低音表現差，你聽出來了嗎？強壓低音卻唱出沙啞聲，讓人聽得不舒服。
单的版本，當你多聽幾次的話你會感覺她是以說故事的將一首歌娓娓道來
shan yichun! love how she delivered and added the traditional opera element in it. makes everything different from the usual style 👍🏻
刘惜君的声线适合这首歌
The one in blue gave me goosebumps with the feeling of Chinoiserie
She is Sara Liu Xijun
Liu Xijun Sara absolutely nailed that song better, imo!
虽然刘惜君唱得很好，但我和方文山黄雨勋的观点一样，原来中国风歌曲还可以这样唱，依纯的版本可以说完全摆脱了原曲杰伦的影子，她没被词曲带着走还唱出了专属自己风格的新中国风，太高级太有惊喜了！这也是他们此行首选依纯来演绎这首歌的最主要原因。🥰 祝你的频道越发美好！
The way Sara Liu delivered that song was absolutely and mesmerizingly out of this world.
I prefer the first one with my fav and better Chinoiserie vibes on that song.
惜君唱的是傳統中國風，依純唱的是創新中國風，有驚喜，相信黃大師和方文山老師也有同感。
Sara's rendition touched my heart and soul better...
單依純好聽很多呢～
个人觉得刘的版本更适合在 playlist里循环听。顺畅舒服没压力。纯纯的适合听现场。
Sara Liu truly is a standout for me. What a mesmerizing rendition of that song.
Sara Liu is such a beautiful soul, who can sing the phone book.
Sara's voice drew everyone in from the first note. Such a nice rendition!
纯纯的更加深刻
Asking about the first singer does not take away from my favorite and second singer Shan Yichun!!
本来这首歌中单依纯用的转音还是有点不太符合这首歌的气质，但相比刘惜君，刘的变化确实少了一些，整首曲子少了些许变化。单依纯胜在歌曲层次还是比较多，表现力上更胜一筹。最后的昆曲确实挺出彩的。
也許是我偏愛單吧，第一次在電視上聽的時候，我也有你第一句的那種感覺，可是後來再用耳機仔細聽，竟然覺得她某幾個轉音聽起來有吹著笙簫管笛時，那種婉轉悠揚的感覺，例如8:32那邊的向天涯傾訴的「訴」、等來了故事的「故」，和詞曲極為契合
如果让张靓颖，张碧晨，周笔畅唱这首歌，他们十有八九会唱出和刘惜君一样的效果。但是单依纯的版本就只有她能表达出来。而华语歌坛需要更加多的创新，更加多有美感的创新
單依純確實獨樹一幟🎉🎉🎉
真可笑的比較，每個人的聲線都不同，不是每首歌都會適合的。一堆盲目的粉絲胡亂吹捧，真好笑啊！
@@Noname0857 嗯，很多人吃不惯好东西。
喜欢刘惜君的版本，声线太美了。❤❤❤
虽然喜欢依纯。但是惜君比较合我的口味。比较沉淀在我心里。
劉惜君的唱法跟聲線，更像是茶，單依純更像是酒，個人喜好也是茶😅
更喜欢刘的版本，百听不厌。单的听得有点淋漓，符合唱失恋情歌
我覺得劉惜君的版本更感動我。
Both are superwoman singers !!!
两个人的版本都很喜欢🥰
兩個版本都是杰倫團隊的方文山填詞 黃雨勳作曲～ 但劉惜君唱的是黃老師編曲的傳統國風 單依純版是郭老師編曲的更現代偏流行的「新國風」改變了傳統和弦～ 單的創新演繹很出彩 得到兩位大師的鍾愛 市場和Re的熱度明顯高於原國風版 我覺得非常動聽耐聽❤️
每次听到这首歌，眼泪都会不由自主地流下来。
我更喜歡惜君，流𣈱、溫婉、像帶了你入了一個故事那樣。她從來不是那玩技巧贏得我贊同的歌手，只聽她的歌聲已足夠
都好聽❤
SARA’s voice suits this song better. Her storytelling in Chinoiserie is so beautiful and fun to watch.
Liu Xijun’s version is absolutely stunning, she sang the vicissitudes of life, if she had also included the Chinese opera part at the end it would’ve been perfection. The focus of Chinese instruments in her version as well made it all the more beautiful
None of the covers can even match Jay Chou's, but i would rather listen to Sara Liu's rendition than the other one.
Keep looping on Sara Liu performance somehow😂
it is the overall package including vocal and style makes Sara liu standout.
Agreed
Yes, Sara Liu is way better to me too.
都非常好听！以前没听过这首歌，所以没有先入为主这首歌该怎么唱。感觉单依纯唱得细腻，抑扬顿挫。刘惜君唱得行云流水，各有千秋。
Sara was literally delivering a more impressive rendition of that song.
Who is the first singer on the video? Would like to see more of her. Thank you.
She is Sara Liu Xijun.
Liu Xijun Sara
@@Fluffy-l3f Thanks so much!!
Awesome!!
梦回她俩的合作曲
最后的昆曲真是莫名其妙😂
其实不会，最后一句，有跟前面呼应，也加强了中国风的部分。
惜君+1
+2
+3
+4
這首歌更適合劉唱，好有feel及味道
雖然我喜歡單依純，但是劉惜君這次真的唱很好，忠於原來的版本，敘事感佳
單...破音了
單版本難度高很多
@@WTF66699耳朵没用了可以把它丢掉 🙂
@@WTF66699WTF?
單的演譯將此曲升上一個層次
Sara hits it out of the park!Mic drop.
單的唱功細膩無瑕疵
但這首我偏愛惜君的直接穿透感～
个人觉得刘好听❤
I find Sara Liu way better rendition than any other one. But Jay Zhou is still the best.
兩位之前在聲生不息也很喜歡的...
但劉惜君這首歌的確唱得更好...她的聲音人生經歷
說故事的感染力....也很出色
單依純在這首歌上就比較平平的...沒有太多起伏
更有點像年青網紅古裝劇的片頭曲...
我反而覺得劉唱得一般般, 聽一遍就夠了，而依純版本細節滿滿, 絲滑流𣈱, 每個字都充滿故事, 百聽不厭
Completely agreed. Liu's voice suits this song perfectly. She did it justice better. @ rctpa9550
@rctpa9550 Your comment is absolutely spot on.
@rctpa 之前不喜歡劉惜君，但是她這首歌表現有進步更能打動人，還重覆聽了好幾次
这首歌的两位创作者（方和黄）都表示偏爱单依纯的版本，虽然刘的版本更符合创作者的创造初衷。
Sara Liu in Chinoiserie is the best!
Liu Xi Jun - so SO lovingly sweet 😘
Who need opinions of those commentaries preferring the suitability of voice of other singer on this songs over 单依纯? In my opinion, I can say 单依纯 sings better than Sara Liu. But again i did it on the commentaries here with due respect to the artist singing here. Just listen to the tonalities of the singing is enough. 单依纯 is another class. You can't compare. I heard Sara Liu singing in Cantonese before. Honestly 单依纯 singing in Cantonese very well though Cantonese is not her dialect.
Absolutely agree. YiChun is in another league in musicality and expression.
一個杜甫，工整、一個李白，出凡
The first one did a better job simply because this was the perfect song for her, imo.
的的確確，各善勝長。
虽然刘的版本更符合这首歌的两位创作者（方和黄）的创作初衷，但这两人都表示更偏爱单依纯的版本
我本人也覺得單的版本比較特別，因為她真的用心加入了一些新元素，不會墨守成規
Yiyi'version
果然還是惜君好
刘惜君唱的更好，有种无奈伤感的感觉。
👍💐
Sara can sing the phone book. Drop the Mic 🎤 despite being underrated. The other one mediocre but yet overrated a bit, imo.
Liu Xijun's rendition suits the tempo of this song more. Shan Yichun's rendition is a tad too sorrowful.
這首歌還是適合先給男聲
刘明显更自然流畅。单太刻意运用技巧。
Agreed. Good singing is not just about techniques it's about feelings
單的顏值沒有最低，只有更低的憤怒鳥
单这次这有点谭晶的感觉😊
刘惜君的情绪节奏要饱满些，而单依纯版本声音完美，但好像单纯靠声音来表达，节奏也好像拖了半拍
For real everything Sara Liu does is from the soul, while the other one’s warble tones didn’t suit the song, sorry.
这歌除了周杰伦，别人唱都不好听
那除了杰倫作品 誰你也別听就好了！
劉惜君比較好聽
刘惜君声音条件太一般了，声线太单薄
单依纯后面加入那个很奇怪😁🤭😁🤭
你会这样觉得确实很奇怪 😁🤭
對的...真的做過多了
没办法，内娱就是这样，很多歌就是为了变化而刻意加变化
都没有中国风的味道😂😂