What you can say, do and film when police stop you to talk
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Amid growing conversations about the role of police and their interactions with the public, two Edmonton institutions share what you can expect and ask for when approached.
»»» Subscribe to CBC News to watch more videos: bit.ly/1RreYWS
Connect with CBC News Online:
For breaking news, video, audio and in-depth coverage: bit.ly/1Z0m6iX
Find CBC News on Facebook: bit.ly/1WjG36m
Follow CBC News on Twitter: bit.ly/1sA5P9H
For breaking news on Twitter: bit.ly/1WjDyks
Follow CBC News on Instagram: bit.ly/1Z0iE7O
Subscribe to CBC News on Snapchat: bit.ly/3leaWsr
Download the CBC News app for iOS: apple.co/25mpsUz
Download the CBC News app for Android: bit.ly/1XxuozZ
»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»
For more than 80 years, CBC News has been the source Canadians turn to, to keep them informed about their communities, their country and their world. Through regional and national programming on multiple platforms, including CBC Television, CBC News Network, CBC Radio, CBCNews.ca, mobile and on-demand, CBC News and its internationally recognized team of award-winning journalists deliver the breaking stories, the issues, the analyses and the personalities that matter to Canadians.
Maybe hire better cops that aren't criminals themselves
Easier said than done. Police work attracts a certain type of individual and they're usually not the most compassionate people.
Good initiative, however, the SOLUTION is to properly train police officers to do their job right. They are paid for it with OUR money. And when it comes to PO targeting specific groups we come to another level of the problem.
You can't train away evil.
They need to be better educated about their roles and theirs limits.
🎉
Can’t get better training without funding, stop supporting DTP!
If a citizen doesn't know their rights, it's pointless to spew about training police better. The MORE a citizen knows about their rights, the more cases the police can be held accountable and be FORCED to do better.
The average person could barely give you a basic description of the canadian charter, why would we expect any better from the police when they are pulled from that very same average pool of people? The more emphasis we put on education about the charter in the classroom, the more likely everyone is to understand it, and as a consequence we will have more police that also understand it.
Don't answer questions....film the police.
"if you have no reason to hide your identity then it's okay to tell police who you are"
There is always a reason to not identify yourself to the police. If they have no reason to ask who I am then they can piss off. Just because someone doesn't want to identify themselves to a stranger doesn't mean they've done anything wrong. This "if you have nothing to hide then just tell them" mentality is BS. Tell cops as little as you possibly can, nothing even.
Do you think that the legislator set these rules to obstruct investigations or to stir up disagreement with the police? If you were an Aboriginal and have a chance of being killed by the police 6 times more than national average, you would feel that the unreasonable search is racially motivated to harass , put you down and oppress you. In normal case police would explain to you the reason for stop and ID without a need to ask them and remind them with your rights
Can they stop you with no reason. My beautiful daughter gets stopped frequently as did i when i was young
Really scary being stopped when you know you did nothing wrong
Stalked by cops for reporting sexual harassment - a young cop tried to get me home alone twice (good thing I wasn't alone the first time - good thing I went outside the second time). #AbolishPolicing
Reported to Policies and Procedures, reported to 'so-called' Public Complaints - and am still being stalked more than two years later. #ftp
The cop is talking copaganda.
Record cops. The
Take it a tiny step further. Have police carry some of those cards to hand out to people and hand them out.
@1:38 “If you have no reason to hide your identity then it’s ok to tell police who you are.” Yes and it’s ok to remain anonymous unless you have been lawfully arrested!
Tell Edmonton police to stop having speed traps during rush hours to and from work….. clearly a money grab
Psychological Evaluation : Sir why do you want to become a police officer?
"These immigrants are..."
Sir, say no more. You are hired!
Well.... all police can change they way they act...but.... they don't want to.
I’ve found that if you treat the police with respect they’ll do the same to you.Maybe try that approach before you haul out your “ card “
Taking out a card to remind yourself what your rights are is perfectly respectable.
I found that cops dont care for your respect.
all they care about is their wallet and wife and kid...and thats as far as their caring goes.
You couldn’t pay me enough to be a police officer these days…..what a thankless job they have - it’s too really too bad - no respect for these folks who have a tough job and deal with things on the daily that no one should have to. A big thank you to those members who have stepped up and taken on this thankless job. ❤ I’d hate to see what society would be like without your efforts.
It's hard to respect someone that doesn't respect you. That goes both ways.
"what a thankless job they have"
That's quite the oversimplification, eh. Policing isn't what it used to be either. Not long ago in Canada police couldn't expose the hand grip of their weapons much less remove them from the holster and point them at people for no just cause. We are following the American lead. Police have become increasingly militarized and act suppressively more than as a service to people. They are becoming more political as well.
If they consistently worked in a professional manner and respected the rights of citizens that they are hired to serve and protect we wouldn't be in this situation where people need to do this .. abusing power as a police officer happens too often and unless that changes on a massive scale people will be skeptical around police. That being said I've had good interactions also with police and I'll give them the respect they deserve based on their interactions with me also
Respect is overrated. Just pay better to hire better people, and make better rules for everyone. If people really want better servers, then everyone has to pay more $. However, policing is simply not a good professional choice. People who are nice and smart enough are not going to choose to deal with crimes and harms and all the worse things every day. The real challenge lies in securing practical ways for more people to stop any individuals from exploiting power.
So you are saying police shouldn't have to deal with people who know and exercise their rights
This is a good thing :)
We can hope. But this, and more, needs to be taught in schools.
He should have said, "People who have Barriers from the past, negative experiences with the poloce or people who have watched too many BS American sovereign citizen videos on youtube."
Alberta? No one is surprised they need this there. 🤡
Sovereign shitizens immediately came to mind. Them, and "Frauditors." I remember seeing one here in BC who tried claiming his 1st Amendment rights... In Canada! That didn't go as well as he thought in his head.
Not too may years ago Toronto police were forced to stop the practice of randomly stopping people to collection information, aka "carding".
Thank you
Not a friend maybe even an advisary.
And indiginous, forward it to investage them selves
As a learning disabled the school teachers said I had no rights as a minor and abused me accordingly
Cop should not be aloud to lie
They shouldn't but they do. I seen one down right lie in court.
Person in Toronto: Why have I been stopped?
Am I under arrest?.
What your name and badge number.
Toronto Pig: Because you are under arrest. That's none of your business. You dont need my name or badge number
Poor policing by tyrants, liars, creeps have made this mandatory 😮
Wow.
I never thought I'd see this on CBC
I respect police officers and the demanding job that they do every day, however, I would love to get a copy of that pamphlet.
You do not have to identify yourself to police unless you are under arrest. Police have no problem lying to you to get what they want. Remain silent. Tell them you do not answer questions and alway, always record your interaction.
Wouldn't it be easier to just show your ID and move on? I don't see why would someone make things harder just because.
@@adamsmith1813 OK. If The Charter of Rights of Canada (upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada) says that I do not have to give ID unless arrested, WHY should I surrender that "RIGHT" to make a cops life easier or to fulfill some Departmental policy, that is clearly not supported by law?
Police should know the law and not be aloud to very from it or give their opinions as it dont matter😊
Biggest gang of criminals that ever existed 😢
Top questions to ask a cop when approached,
What crime am I suspected of?
Am I free to go?
I don't answer questions!
Another one you can try is : Don't tase me bro!
All this SOUNDS good and for sure the police SHOULD follow this policy .HOWEVER THEY DO NOT>>>>>> THEY COULD BUT THEY GO AND ESCALATE .THEY USE THE NEW POLICY IN POLICING ALL OVER THE WORLD>>>YOU ARE GUILTY UNTIL PROVEN INNOCENT. Any wrong doing the courts 99% of the time support police action.
The new Canadian police act, Bill 68, Comprehensive Ontario Police Services Act, 2019, was enacted on April 1, 2024 ¹. The new act repeals the Ontario Police Services Act, 1990, and introduces the Community Safety and Policing Act, 2019 ². The new act allows for the suspension of police officers without pay for misconduct or unsatisfactory performance ². Additionally, the act introduces changes to police governance, oversight, and discipline, and provides for the establishment of a police complaints system ³
That is it right there. You officers work for us as a canadian citizen. Citizen being the word. Know your audience guys. Not everyone is an actual criminal. Remember what canada used to be and what you officers stood for. This is canada. And get rid of this rainbow police its an actual discrace. Libs will be out of power soon. Do better.
I dont have to idea if i havent broken the law. Its law rather someone likes it or not. Dont id
Show this video every day at roll call !
To serve and respect...I wish!
To intimidate, instigate, escalate, retaliate, and fabricate.
In a routine checkpoint situation, why does the officer ask where we’re going, and why? We’re just driving home with groceries!
It's none of their business.
@@TheAstraeuss Well that’s what I think! But if you challenge that they could get nasty. 🙁
@createone100 They have to remember, they work for the tax payers. Their pride needs to be checked.
Why do they ask? To acquire any info that they could possibly use against you.
That only could work if he was not rained with a barrage of bullets. In Quebec alone more than 400 people were detained unlawfully. Canadaians desensitized to such scandals, individual's freedom is not well guarded in Canada, and lawyers associations cannot see and silent
Source ?
@@billboggs6641 I am quoting: "Hundreds of people have been illegally detained - sometimes for months - in Quebec detention centres over the last decade because of sentence miscalculations, identification mistakes and other clerical errors, documents show" that was documented on paper with no shame, but you can imagine the real reasons and numbers. Where the lawyers , human rights tribunals, and human rights organizations are from all of this ? Only free press leak that
Most police about 98% I meet or interacted have been good. We need more police.
No, we don't.
EVERY Citizen should be mailed one of those cards.
A.C.A.B
I guess we can't trust police huh
I've been pulled out of my car while they yelled I was resisting arrest, then they proceeded to beat me and slam me on the trunk repeadlty damaging my car, while handcuffed! Detained and sitting in a police car whitout any charges while they illegaly search my car. I was let go after 2 hours of them ripping my car apart finding nothing and having nothing to charge me or even ticket me for.
Thank you Medicine Hat police!
This is one of the biggest lie the internet has ever told. Don't be a heat score, it's that simple. 3 simple rules when dealing with police 1 be polite 2 be cooperative 3 if you have to lie, keep it short and simple.
Nothing in the video suggests being impolite, or non-cooperative, and it certainly doesn't suggest lieing.
@@jptrainor meanwhile back in the real world. Whipping out your little card and asking the cop questions and not answering questions is not cooperating. Also sometimes you need to lie to the cops.
@@banzi403 Following the law is cooperating. There's be no suggestion that anyone not respect the law.
@@jptrainor Meanwhile back in reality...sometimes people break the law.
@@banzi403 Which reality? There's no reality where a police officer is permitted to act outside the law when making a stop.
Say nothing. The police helped take our mobility rights during the pandemic. Anyone still wearing a police uniform today is not on Team Canada.
Exactly! I used to respect the police. That is all gone after I saw how they treated the peaceful truckers
@@SV-je8mgMillions of us. Millions had their rights taken. I agree about the truckers, but that was on video. What about everything that happened across the whole country with no witnesses. Have a great day.
lol
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 ok
I didn’t like it too but don’t forget they follow orders, similar to the army. Blame those who ordered this crap
... Bavl
What can I say?
Всех пересажаю
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡