@Clark Lei 伊教在那个时候并不先进，犹太部落有很多，景教(最少比伊教早六百年）那时候已经在半岛传开了。伊斯兰只是带暴力属性的山寨版。伊教的经文本身就是支持主动攻击其他信仰者居住地迫使他们顺服啊拉。Surah At Tawbah对早期降示的2:256的naskh是爱玩塔机亚的穆思琳👇从来不愿意提及的。
This video popped up so I watched it. Oh, it is bilingual. Thank you for your efforts. I have learned more about Xinjiang. I have always wanted to visit Xinjiang. At first, I was put off by the terrorist attacks there and now the pandemic. Xinjiang is on my bucket list. I hope to make it there soon.
There already have no terrorist at all,to be honest it is one of the safest places in the world! I have lived in Xinjiang for almost 20 years, I haven’t seen even a thief for about 5years! Hope you will go to Xinjiang and have a nice trip!
@@fluoseif you want to know a place, talk to various people to form your opinion. But don't forget the government policy towards minority, and actual facts on minority population growth, educational level, participation in business, politics, life span and other social factors. These factors are indication of success or failure of government policy. I can say china's policy and results are ten times better than western treatment of minority in US and Australia.
If you want to learn more real news about China, recommend you watch two youtubers' channels (English): - huo guo da wang: th-cam.com/channels/aSlyjhR4WC7QhYuaivxb6g.html; - daniel dumbrill: th-cam.com/video/trvrMWXM16o/w-d-xo.html
Why DEMONETIZED? Did he explain not based on FACTS? Did youtube have better Facts? He gave some information and facts and some evidence to support his argument..and again WHY THIS VIDEO BEEN DEMONETIZED??
I could explain a little. Because SOME countries don't wanna see a stable, peaceful and prosperous China. So though this video is made based on facts, but it is not their official narratives, so...
Talibans in Afghanistan blown up the 1500 years old Bamyan Buddha statue in 2001, which was one of the tallest Structure ever built in ancient time, so sad with so much history lost under Islamic rule
The Uyghur population went from 3.6 million in the 1950s all the way up to 10 million in 2010s. The Chinese government did not impose the one-child policy on the ethic minorities such as the Uyghur population. China has expended infrastructure for Muslim minorities. In 1984, there are only 9,000 mosques, and in 2017, there are 39,000 in China alone. In 1978, the per capita GDP in Xinjiang was only 166 RMB, and in 2010s, it increased to 49,474.717 RMB in Dec 2018.
codeagent47 Then the next question we should ask the Muslim nation, where are the Coptic population? Where are the Jew population? Where are them and their decedents..
This video is a very educational for those people like me, who was not born in China but would like to learn more about China history, very appreciated your hard-work :)
what country are you from? If you want to know more about China, where to go and see is completely different from what our traditional media described!
Please help put up the gray background behind the subtitles so that we can read them better. Many thanks for your video. 请在字幕后面加上灰色背景，以便我们更好地阅读它们。 感谢您的精彩视频。
I have read the comments of many non-Muslim peoples of the world and their opinions on Islam, and most of them were hostile to Islam, but I did not see more hostility than the hostility of the Chinese people to Islam, this people whom we thought were among the peoples who sympathized with weak peoples. The leftist media laughed at us and deluded us that communism was the only refuge for oppressed peoples, and it finally became clear that the Chinese regime is more dangerous to us Muslims than the rest of the West. At least the West is frank and does not hypocrite and does not claim to defend the oppressed Freedom for Palestine and freedom for East Turkestan Traduction : 我读过世界上许多非穆斯林民族的评论和他们对伊斯兰教的看法，其中大多数都是敌视伊斯兰教的，但我没有看到比中国人民对伊斯兰教的敌视更多的敌意。 我们认为这是一个同情弱者的民族 左翼媒体嘲笑我们，欺骗我们，共产主义是被压迫人民的唯一避难所，最终我们发现，中国政权对我们穆斯林来说比其他西方国家更危险。 至少西方是坦诚的，不伪善，不声称要捍卫被压迫者 巴勒斯坦的自由和东突厥斯坦的自由
I am not literate in Chinese but feel this young presenter is excellent - has talent. Due to the consolidation by the Qing, I think China's claim to Xinjiang as part of China is indisputable - there is no question at all about "Xinjiang independence". Best regards, Chan Rasjid Kah Chew, Singapore. "Chemical Analysis Of Plain Distilled Water May Refute Mass-Energy Conservation Of E=mc²" "The Relativistic Mechanics of E=mc² Fails" - E=mc² is wrong. www.emc2fails.com
@@za5833 It's that simple just clicking and googling some of the names he mentioned in this video, you'd see whether what he says have facts to back up.
Your name is product of China as well. Korean hangul is derived from the strokes of Chinese characters. And what you said is very disrespectful for your Korean ancestors as they used Chinese characters for thousands of years.
Very informative. Thank you very much. Chinese people need not worry. China overcoming poverty and becoming number one economically and technologically is a certainty.
I agree he presented facts, but I wonder about his credentials. How do I know this is historical "fact?" I tend to think it is, but would like collaboration to his story.
@@phil6264 I was skeptical at first. But if you matching the history of several Asian countries, the timeline is fit the facts he gave. I agree with this because I'm from Asia, and the history of our country somehow fit in the facts he represented.
@@meplenn as I stated, I wish there was more collaborative information. I tend to believe what he is saying. However, if you want to change hearts and minds, more information is needed than a lone story teller. I wish I knew the speaker's credentials. If he had a PhD in Chinese history would add to his story. The next issue which needs to be considered is the age old propaganda allegations. These are difficult to overcome. Lastly, what is the goal and outcome of speech. I do not know the motivation. I wish I could read and understand the nuance of his language. My only goal is to consider everything. I enjoyed my time in China.
@@phil6264 you have raised very good question: How do we know if that's the "fact". As a Uyghur myself with a first bachelor's degree in History from a Chinese University and with a history teaching experience of a decade at an University, i can tell you this: while this fellow tried hard to make it sound like facts of the history, he is through this TH-cam channel disseminating the CCP version of the History as CCP has, over the last 70 years, re-written the entire Chinese history the way they like, thus the "fact" regarding Chinese control of the "Xin jiang" from 60 BC is a CCP lie, yes they called it xiyu but meant it is a place in the west only. This land is the origin of all the TURKS today and has been called East Turkistan / Uyghurstan till 1884 when the Manchu Qing Dynasty occupied in 1756 and re-named in 1884. Manchu Qing rule broke off in 1911, and from 1911 to 1949, it was not under anyone's rule except uyghurs and again annexed in 1949 together with Tibet and that was the first and long-lasting Han Chinese occupation.
@@foreveruyghur6332 What you said sound like joke comparing to what he showed in this video, if you don't agree what he said, point out what's wrong instead of your shallow political propaganda.
你也是搞笑，人生伊斯蘭教就是比佛教更先進才會傳播，新疆地區選擇伊斯蘭教也是他們的自由，說得他們好像做錯，一定要跟中原一樣才行。可惜關鍵他們就不是漢人，文化不一樣，宗教不一樣。
还有人支持恐怖主义， 最极端可以称之为“先进”？ 恐怖主义 就人类癌症。
@@eastwarmpeace6249 第一，伊斯蘭教教義不是極端主義，只是現在被曲解了。第二，現在來看落後，但11至16世紀時就是非常先進，所以才一直擴大
@@Qilin9527 恐怖主义扩大只是因为杀的人最多，不是因为“先进”。别洗了，暴恐教历史你以为世人不清楚？
@Clark Lei 伊教在那个时候并不先进，犹太部落有很多，景教(最少比伊教早六百年）那时候已经在半岛传开了。伊斯兰只是带暴力属性的山寨版。伊教的经文本身就是支持主动攻击其他信仰者居住地迫使他们顺服啊拉。Surah At Tawbah对早期降示的2:256的naskh是爱玩塔机亚的穆思琳👇从来不愿意提及的。
上帝说 : 对于宗教，绝无强迫；因为正邪确已分明了。
在伊斯兰教中，上帝不允许你强迫伊斯兰教中的任何人
My father used to say ideology war is terrible but religious war is the worst. Thanks for islamization of xinjian history.
@不吐不快 皮皮虾你就不能管一下自己的手吗……
不好意思，这个不@吐不快 是我儿子，从小就患有老年痴呆综合征，一不留神就溜出来忘了自己的家在哪里，我这就把他送回精神病院
厉害了，我一个土生土长的新疆人很多历史都不清楚，在这里学习到了，感谢up主。。
在我看这个视频的时候，插入的广告有：罗兴亚人呼吁支持，穆斯林控诉伊斯兰恐惧症对他们的排挤和歧视。可以看出油管平台以及西方主流媒体的舆论洗脑倾向。
谢谢播主的勤劳付出，手动点赞。
2024年回看，有巴勒斯坦人呼吁支持的广告吗
❌where‘s the so called "freedom of speech" ?????????
Freedom of speech is overrated.
@Nibbler truth is not sensitive, its hard like a rock
All speech are free but some speech has more free than others.
demonetized
@@juniorhentaibush6924 哈哈哈lol
原來如此。。只需30分鐘就能讓我了解到悠久的歷史文化由來👏👍😍
🙏感恩清晰細述與分享🙏
niki6508
宗教实质是利益。。人的利益有2种。一种是物质。一种是精神。
控制你的人。控制你的钱。是为胜利。而发源拥有解释权。也就是意识形态斗争
如果你是香港人或台湾人。。基本上你就是思想上的奴隶。因为人家可以定你的性质而你无法反驳。
伊斯兰说不吃猪肉，基督教说胚胎等同生命。现在台湾人每天喊的民主。其实是苏联的代名词。而美国的代名词。是自由。
也就是说。冷战后美国掌握了民主的解释权。。。朝鲜民主主义人民共和国。就变成可笑了。而韩国这种典型傀儡。就变成正统的先进国家了。而宗主国会对其进行分类。打压与养肥式支援。韩国以国为代价搞出来的公司。大多掌握在美国人手上。日本也被剪了几十年羊毛。
@@user-lt6ke9hg8f 就好像古代节日都是读书人发明的一样 ，文盲不可能有这本事！历史都是胜利者书写的 。同理 ，强者有话语权的最终解释和分配！
@@mikelee3825 失败者其实也书写历史，不过那可信度可就捉急了，有句话说得好“胜利者炫耀历史，失败者编造历史”
朋友您信耶穌嗎？您心裡有平安、喜樂和永生的盼望嗎？
其实在清朝时蒙古在新疆的势力一样很大，是康熙乾隆三代把准格尔势力赶跑了，维族才做大的。
我在新疆玩發現一個特別有意思的現象，如果我去ins，我放一張圖tag一個地址，如果我選Urumqi,出來一堆控訴維吾爾族集中營被迫害的圖片，可是如果你能更具體一點，比如tag紅山公園，國際大巴扎，你就會看到一群正常人在自拍，在喝咖啡，在和朋友逛街聊天，充滿各種人間煙火氣息，關於75什麼的不想解釋了，在新疆玩了8天，認識了一堆蒙古族人，哈薩克族人，維吾爾族人，漢族人。大家都很正常的努力生活著，不要污名化新疆，新疆太美，我玩了整整八天，也只是到了走馬觀花到了烏魯木齊，布爾津，喀納斯，禾木。新疆那麼大，外面的朋友應該放心的來多看看多玩玩！
@司马艳红 我是10月底去的北疆阿勒泰，布尔津，禾木，喀纳斯。北疆好美，但是有点冷，春夏秋都是何其休闲游，如果爱玩滑雪，北疆的阿勒泰11-3月有将军山，可可托海滑雪场，我下次还准备去南疆感受风土人情，大爱新疆！
你只看了点皮毛
@@alfaromeorongzhou1 新疆那么大，我就玩了7天🤣
司马艳红 四五月份或者八九月份
教育营是假的？呵呵
This video popped up so I watched it. Oh, it is bilingual. Thank you for your efforts. I have learned more about Xinjiang. I have always wanted to visit Xinjiang. At first, I was put off by the terrorist attacks there and now the pandemic. Xinjiang is on my bucket list. I hope to make it there soon.
There already have no terrorist at all,to be honest it is one of the safest places in the world! I have lived in Xinjiang for almost 20 years, I haven’t seen even a thief for about 5years! Hope you will go to Xinjiang and have a nice trip!
please talk to an uyghur and see what they have to say. The pov of an han chinese in xinjiang is quite different from non-han .
@@fluose I am a Uyghur and now we are living in China very beautifully and happily, thanks to the motherland
@@fluoseif you want to know a place, talk to various people to form your opinion. But don't forget the government policy towards minority, and actual facts on minority population growth, educational level, participation in business, politics, life span and other social factors. These factors are indication of success or failure of government policy. I can say china's policy and results are ten times better than western treatment of minority in US and Australia.
小帅哥真的太用心了。历史事实详实，调理清晰，尊重事实，不带偏见。希望外国人也能了解一下新疆的历史。
要列明三個重點，
第一，漢朝時中國領土就到達西域，維吾爾還不存在，
第二，唐朝時西域也在領土範圍，回鶻是唐朝的盟友，共同對付消滅突厥帝國，
這也是英語維基上寫的，回鶻是突厥敵人，這點要強調，而回鶻最早的位置是在蒙古地區，
第三，西域和中亞最早的居民，塞人，粟特，吐火羅等，是東伊朗語系印歐人，人家伊朗都沒對中國新疆說什麼，土耳其算老幾？
我之前把漢朝和唐朝地圖貼在臉書群裡，大家看到回鶻汗國位於蒙古時，大家都閉嘴了，有時一張地圖就能解決問題，
@@Emilechen 他们以为新疆是土耳其起源？
@@ukeusogo585 如果去看泛突厥視頻，這裡大把，基本理論是土耳其是突厥人代表，祖先有16大帝國，包括匈奴，突厥，蒙古等，
歷史上所謂突厥人，把中國，印度，伊朗，阿拉伯世界和歐洲全打趴下，是世界征服者，而新疆是最近中國菜竊取的領土，叫東突厥斯坦，
因此要獨立然後所有說突厥語的國家在成立以土耳其為首的大帝國，
基本上所有突厥語系民族都要算成土耳其祖先，
簡單來說，打個比喻，就像一個韓國人，去說朝鮮，日本，蒙古，滿洲，甚至鮮卑，契丹，高句麗，渤海等，全都是阿爾泰語系，算進大朝鮮文明，
因此東亞歷史基本就是大韓民族一直奴役統治漢民族的歷史，那麼越南和韓國有相似地方，那肯定是受韓文化影響，
看到問題了嗎？
韓國和越南相似，是因為他們都受華夏影響，而不是因為韓國人影響了越南，
同理，土耳其和維吾爾，以及其它突厥語國家民族相似，是因為他們都受波斯影響，而不是說土耳其和維吾爾就是一家人，
土耳其血統主要是小亞細亞印歐後裔，加上部分突厥部落血統，和其它高加索，伊朗和中亞國家民族，都屬於斯坦文明圈，
@@Emilechen 谢谢 很详细 所以新疆要了解自己民族的历史 别被忽悠拐了……土耳其也挺有野心的 竟然从欧洲渗透到东亚 😂 土耳其语和新疆语很像吗？我记得历史上新疆是回鹘族，和突阕是敌人，不同一个民族，
@@ukeusogo585 其實歷史上中亞主要是東伊朗語系和吐火羅語系的印歐人，後來突厥部落逃到中亞，和本地人混合，
然後阿拉伯和波斯人又大量輸入中亞奴隸兵，而這些奴隸兵掌權，自己成立王朝，
就像歐洲日耳曼部落差不多，他們很多都融入到當地國，
就像奧巴馬當了美國總統，我們不能說是肯尼亞統治了美國一樣，
因此，我個人建議，不應該叫這些人突厥人或突厥語系，應該叫圖蘭人，Turan，避免混淆，
和維吾爾最像的是烏茲別克，而土耳其則和阿塞拜疆以及土庫曼像，
因此中國反對泛突厥，不應該之局限在新疆，中國搞一帶一路，泛突厥在中亞要是盛行，肯定是攔路虎，美日也會幫助其搞事，
中國和俄羅斯畢竟文化和人種和中亞不同，要反對泛突厥，非常需要伊朗合作，
因此伊朗文明圈和泛突厥聯盟高度重疊，一些所謂突厥語系的民族，
尤其是阿塞拜疆族，在伊朗掌權，高度波斯化，認同伊朗千年文明時，又何必和土耳其一樣亂認遊牧野爹？烏茲別克也一樣，
甚至對於土耳其本身，也應該勸說，他們與其去人大老遠蠻族當祖宗，
還不如多發掘一下小亞細亞的赫悌文明與現代土耳其人的關係，
最近介绍新疆的数个视频，显然是做了很多功课的，非常值得钦佩。尤其是配上了英文字幕，也可以让这里的观点，能够让更多外国人了解到。
民主的❌，限流了😂
但是不少外国人貌似很难习惯看字幕，羡慕他们被惯得好
言论自由，但是可没说允许你们思考自由，墙外只需要没脑子的言论
外国人真的就不了解中国和新疆的真相吗，除了普通民众不清楚外，上层人物是在清楚不过的吧，只不过是为了干涉中国内政找借口而已
x和民主没有关系，是被限流了而已
一加英文字幕就给打红叉，ytb厉害了
那是作者自己加的，，，你们是真的幼稚、愚蠢又可笑
@@user-eb6mh5dh4l 是作者知道自己被加了红叉所以打出来给大家知道的😅你是个自大的傻逼
厉害！点赞！感谢勤苦的工作和整理。新疆必长治久安！
脈絡清晰，上了一堂精彩的歷史課！👍🙏
thanks for the english subs Many times I want to follow chinese youtubers but a just dont know what their saying. Good job.
Where are you from?
@@thenutbrothers8726 Who are you promoting for？
RR HY Of course for the vicious cunning manipulative USA
If you want to learn more real news about China, recommend you watch two youtubers' channels (English):
- huo guo da wang: th-cam.com/channels/aSlyjhR4WC7QhYuaivxb6g.html;
- daniel dumbrill: th-cam.com/video/trvrMWXM16o/w-d-xo.html
If you want to know more about China,you can have a look CGTN
你讲的清晰准确，作为一名维吾尔我很佩服！我们的千年佛教文化被伊斯兰文化毁灭了 真的太可惜 太惨了。但是最惨的是大部分维吾尔人不知道此历史。
千年佛教文化被伊斯兰教文化毁灭了。并不意味着今天的伊斯兰教文化可以被共产文化毁灭。
@@zywang4642 伊斯兰文化被毁了？清真寺修来干嘛的？有逼着别人只学汉语就像美国人逼着印第安人学英语吗？
@@zywang4642 傻逼
@@zywang4642 牧羊犬好厉害哦，多读点书不好吗，非要当没🐎人
@@zywang4642 其实灭你们伊斯兰真的很容易的，当然不是武力灭，那种方式太笨了。。现在赵家的新疆统治方式太落后了。。哈哈
说得太好了！很详细系统，最后的一段以善为基的评语为点睛之作 👍
支持多謝分析分享，持平正直正羲兼且博學人格高尚，誠實、客觀公正、實事求是、公義、有良知、勇敢、高水準格的節目
双语字幕很帅，希望越来越多外国人看到这段历史
小伙子多材多艺·知识面广而深-讲解朴实-难得的人材-真棒-赞👍赞👍赞👍!!
非常感謝您的制作和講解正好有一位 Baha'i 教徒想知道何以新疆伊糸蘭化. 就把这個講解給他了. 因為有英文翻譯, 他才能看, 谢謝您的努力和時間, 能有多人受益, 享受新疆歷史文化宗教的演变. 👏👏👏
朋友您信耶穌嗎？您心裡有平安、喜樂和永生的盼望嗎？
Explained in so much details yet straight forward , well done!
视频做的非常好，感谢！good job for those who need to know Xinjiang History
Very thorough and objective presentation based on facts. Thank you.
非常棒！内容翔实，清晰简洁，订阅了。
Remember Afghanistan was also Buddhist country before. ...
Ya they destroyed everything. Now they are suffering
PAK ALSO......
Persia are Zoroastrianism, then Islam came, then Persia disappear..
What was before buddist
@@za5833 زرتشتیگری
如此皿煮的✖️，必须要顶一个
第一次被推荐，看了你的视频，很棒👍👍👍马上订阅了。希望多讲一些中国历史上和周边地区的历史和演变。谢谢！
Why DEMONETIZED? Did he explain not based on FACTS? Did youtube have better Facts? He gave some information and facts and some evidence to support his argument..and again WHY THIS VIDEO BEEN DEMONETIZED??
I could explain a little. Because SOME countries don't wanna see a stable, peaceful and prosperous China. So though this video is made based on facts, but it is not their official narratives, so...
I'm Chinese by the way. I also concern human rights there. But the object facts on youtube is so hard to find.
Because is about China 😁😁
When it comes to China, stating facts is communist propaganda.
Lol, this is called freedom of speech! : )
太牛了，这么多的史料，还要找相应的英文翻译，最后还被挂上这么多的红叉叉，可见实力了得！
只要不怕困难就能做成，很多人因为没有耐心所以做不了
@@alivelive1444 耐心和毅力也是实力的一种
@@careyzhuang1106 每年的百万高考生何尝不是毅力加耐力
Talibans in Afghanistan blown up the 1500 years old Bamyan Buddha statue in 2001, which was one of the tallest Structure ever built in ancient time, so sad with so much history lost under Islamic rule
The Loss of Human Civilization😭😭😭
Now they are suffering.
可以说理科男的视频是最好的, 查阅了很多资料, 功课做了不少, 花了不少时间, 值得赞, 整个视频没有半句废话
你述說得非常清晰，簡明扼要，不失客觀，加油!
The Uyghur population went from 3.6 million in the 1950s all the way up to 10 million in 2010s. The Chinese government did not impose the one-child policy on the ethic minorities such as the Uyghur population. China has expended infrastructure for Muslim minorities. In 1984, there are only 9,000 mosques, and in 2017, there are 39,000 in China alone. In 1978, the per capita GDP in Xinjiang was only 166 RMB, and in 2010s, it increased to 49,474.717 RMB in Dec 2018.
codeagent47
Then the next question we should ask the Muslim nation, where are the Coptic population? Where are the Jew population? Where are them and their decedents..
利用宗教分裂国家的，那是让人唾弃的，也不可能得逞！
China has done a wonderful job at protecting minority culture.
❌民主的标志，怎么能不顶一个？
❌这个标志是什么意思?
@@jingangjingxinjing 不能投放广告，博主此部没有收益
就是被红叉叉吸引来的👀
我都是见红叉❌才点击看的，很好的宣传
絕對要頂！
Love China , Asia , and you good sir . Thank you for the information . May China and the world know peace .
@Nibbler There is subtitle
Thank you friend and welcome to China.
K哥的这一期视频有高度！
帥哥超讚，圖文並茂，資料翔實，牛逼！！！
朋友您信耶穌嗎？您心裡有平安、喜樂和永生的盼望嗎？
真的很用心，太好了
我是蒙古族我们也是信萨满跟藏传佛教
雍正就信藏传佛教，清朝满蒙联姻那么久应该会有很多共通的地方
@@hibiscuslin9136 是的
@@hibiscuslin9136 雍正啥都不信，就是忽悠。假装信藏传佛教忽悠蒙族，假装穿汉服忽悠汉人。蒙古人经满清统治人口锐减，还要感谢满清，真是脑子有病。
蒙古人原来信过基督
然而藏傳佛教才是實打實的邪教
thank for the explanation which is very detail
讲的太棒了！尊重历史，尊重事实。条理清晰，通俗易懂。年轻人口才很好。赞！
朋友您信耶稣嗎？您心里有真平安、喜乐和永生的盼望嗎？
非常好的视频，史料详尽，图文并茂，收藏了。支持UP主。
维吾尔人其实成分很复杂，在新中国民族划分之前分属几个民族，和回鹘的关系并不都那么紧密。什么塔兰奇人、萨尔特人（安集延+喀什葛尔人）、安集延人（约等于乌兹别克人）、喀什葛尔人、乌兹别克人、葛逻禄人（约等于萨尔特人）、普什图人（阿富汗主体民族）、吐鲁番人、哈密人等等。新中国民族划分太草率了，他们应该划成十多个民族。
这些民族中，吐鲁番人和哈密人和回鹘的关系最紧密，是回鹘灭了汉人的高昌国后高昌回鹘化的结果，东亚人和汉人特征明显。
塔兰奇人是喀什葛尔人和蒙古、哈萨克混血的结果。
普什图人来自阿富汗的侵略者后代。
作为现代维吾尔代表文化的喀什人主要是喀什葛尔人，和乌兹别克人（安集延人）关系非常紧密，从语言上是葛逻禄突厥人，血统上是突厥、蒙古和东伊朗人的混血，东伊朗成分比较高，回鹘人成分很低。
这就是为什么维吾尔人尤其是塔兰奇人和喀什葛尔人会认同突厥人的原因。
个人觉得最起码维吾尔人应该至少划分成两个民族，东疆的哈密和吐鲁番才是真正的维吾尔人，其他合并为喀什格尔人。至于湖南的维吾尔应该并入回族。
确实，如美国搞的亚裔细分政策，就是个解决民族问题的高明手段
非常不错的历史解说！
非常非常非常的全面讲的头头是道！ 喜欢你！！！
此视频值得一看，对历史就要真实，强烈推荐！
Awesome, lot info in this short video. Learned a lot from you. Appreciate it.
Excellent account ! Thank you.
我作为中国教育体制出来的人只读24史，对于（以华夏为中心的）边疆史所知甚少。你的视频弥补了我的很多空白和误区，比如我一直没把准葛尔与漠西蒙古联系起来，谢谢你！你做得很棒👍。
24史也有少数民族的历史，你真的看过？
Very good explanation of Xinjiang’s history. Have liked it no matter what TH-cam says.
讲得好！史料可靠，梳理清晰。难能可贵！
讲得太好了！谢谢！
感谢为我们补课。最后的总结也很棒。
This video is a very educational for those people like me, who was not born in China but would like to learn more about China history, very appreciated your hard-work :)
外国人能看得懂中文?
@@user-oo9gd8yf1v 有英语字母
what country are you from? If you want to know more about China, where to go and see is completely different from what our traditional media described!
首页推荐来的👏
非常好的视频，小播辛苦了！
记得小时候看了一部电影《东归英雄传》，应该就是这个背景。感谢这么系统、精炼的讲述新疆的宗教变迁史，受益匪浅。
同看过，当时还不太明白。
东归英雄传说的是蒙古吧
Please help put up the gray background behind the subtitles so that we can read them better. Many thanks for your video. 请在字幕后面加上灰色背景，以便我们更好地阅读它们。 感谢您的精彩视频。
谢谢理科男士K一米的历史讲解！点赞！👍👍👍👍
感谢！讲得很有条理，很清楚，很好
可惜土尔扈特人没有全部迁回来。视频真棒，视频的广告我全看了，作为一点小小支持。
他们如果回来了 就不至于牵扯进苏联清洗了
很棒的视频！感谢！
You should release more videos with English subtitles!
It is hard to release videos with English subtitles for some reasons :) (big red "X")
此视频对新疆历史的解读，没有立足本地人的视角，而是立足中原王朝的视角，默认新疆是中原的附属
U don’t need his video since full of bullshiit and fake stories without proof
太优秀了，我直接订阅！
视频很棒，梳理得很清晰，看了不少书啊！
thanks for the English subtitles
这一集太牛了～
I came in cos I saw the X, this video =good, must support 😍
紮實的歷史課。 真要廣為宣傳。
朋友您信耶穌嗎？您心裡有平安、喜樂和永生的盼望嗎？
@@williamwei9524我的朋友，无论你信什么，或者什么都不信我，我都祝你幸福😊
你跟一个只有几百年历史的人说说上千年历史这不是扯吗？况且他的历史不超过500年。
你真的是无知无畏的典范
朋友您信耶稣吗？您心裡有真平安、喜乐和永生的盼望吗？
Well research young man.👍👍👍👍👍
I have read the comments of many non-Muslim peoples of the world and their opinions on Islam, and most of them were hostile to Islam, but I did not see more hostility than the hostility of the Chinese people to Islam, this people whom we thought were among the peoples who sympathized with weak peoples.
The leftist media laughed at us and deluded us that communism was the only refuge for oppressed peoples, and it finally became clear that the Chinese regime is more dangerous to us Muslims than the rest of the West.
At least the West is frank and does not hypocrite and does not claim to defend the oppressed
Freedom for Palestine and freedom for East Turkestan
Traduction :
我读过世界上许多非穆斯林民族的评论和他们对伊斯兰教的看法，其中大多数都是敌视伊斯兰教的，但我没有看到比中国人民对伊斯兰教的敌视更多的敌意。 我们认为这是一个同情弱者的民族
左翼媒体嘲笑我们，欺骗我们，共产主义是被压迫人民的唯一避难所，最终我们发现，中国政权对我们穆斯林来说比其他西方国家更危险。
至少西方是坦诚的，不伪善，不声称要捍卫被压迫者
巴勒斯坦的自由和东突厥斯坦的自由
非常好👍🏻学习了！
说的太对了！我去南疆的很多地域看到的都是佛教的痕迹。这个应该让美国知音中文网的人看看。
他们不再乎新疆人过的怎么样，只是想要自己得到利益，让中国让利。
只有栽赃中国 才能拖缓中国崛起得脚步 他们比谁都清楚
他们心里跟明镜似的 就是为了内部分裂中国
@魚子醬 什麼叫幼稚？普通歐美人誰搞得清楚，哪怕普通中國人有幾個完全了解西域/新疆歷史，
漢朝是西域就屬於中國領土，那時還沒維吾爾，
而唐朝時，回鶻位於蒙古地區，是唐朝盟友，共同對付突厥，而這一點，你知道？
哪怕你知道，普通中國老百姓會知道？
也許誣陷中國的人知道這些歷史，但多數外國老百姓不知道，我們就有責任告訴他們，
而不是像個怨婦一樣，埋怨說反正全天下都冤枉我，我就不出聲了，出聲也沒有用，
@魚子醬 誰會聽我？
自己好好看看這個歐美歷史頻道做的:
th-cam.com/video/iQ7jDwF2Z2w/w-d-xo.html
漠北大戰，漢朝擊垮匈奴，
之前很多外國網友都誤會，以為漢人只敢躲在長城後面，而土耳其泛突厥網友天天喊，匈奴一直按做漢人打，
而我們中國連個像樣點的回應視頻也沒有，結果要靠一老外替我們中國人做視頻告訴全世界，是漢朝把匈奴給打敗了，
同樣，也是這頻道，做過節目，介紹唐朝是怎麼滅東西突厥，
明朝是如何幫助朝鮮擊敗日本豐臣秀吉，
鄭成功是如何打敗荷蘭人收復台灣，這些英語視頻人家都做過，
點擊率是幾十萬，甚至百萬作為歐美最有名歷史網站，大部分外國歷史愛好者都會看到，
甚至清朝有個女海島鄭一嫂擊敗過英國艦隊，歐美人都拿她當英雄，加勒比海盜電影都出現過她，而我們中國網民卻幾乎沒聽過，
沒錯，歐美政府和主流媒體為了政治目的抹黑中國，但這不關他們民間歷史愛好者的事，他們對中國歷史一般還是比較尊敬，
現在法輪功的媒體都除了法語和葡萄牙語頻道天天給中國大陸，
而很多大陸網友還天天傲嬌，說什麼沒必要翻譯成英語給讓老外知道，老外都是傻子不懂中國文化，
但我可以告訴你們，Voici of the past都把漢朝史書對羅馬帝國的描述翻譯成英語了，
被人冤枉不是我們的錯，但被冤枉後賭氣不出聲，那就是我們的無能，
Excellent historical exposition and insightful conclusion. Let's get the knowledge we don't have in textbooks.
I am not literate in Chinese but feel this young presenter is excellent - has talent.
Due to the consolidation by the Qing, I think China's claim to Xinjiang as part of China is indisputable - there is no question at all about "Xinjiang independence".
Best regards,
Chan Rasjid Kah Chew,
Singapore.
"Chemical Analysis Of Plain Distilled Water May Refute Mass-Energy Conservation Of E=mc²"
"The Relativistic Mechanics of E=mc² Fails" - E=mc² is wrong.
www.emc2fails.com
He got rex X on title
But you don't have prove in these videos...just like the Chinese products...
@@za5833 It's that simple just clicking and googling some of the names he mentioned in this video, you'd see whether what he says have facts to back up.
Your name is product of China as well. Korean hangul is derived from the strokes of Chinese characters. And what you said is very disrespectful for your Korean ancestors as they used Chinese characters for thousands of years.
历史说的那么井井有序，真的是理科男吗？还是说这正是理科生擅长的逻辑思维
Very informative. Thank you very much.
Chinese people need not worry. China overcoming poverty and becoming number one economically and technologically is a certainty.
我去！讲得太好了！
谁在惧怕真相……
见✖咱们偏要手动👍
總算懂了，謝謝！ 還得再看幾次才記得。
大约700年前 马来西亚与印尼主要都是信佛的
這是真的。。佛教跟印度教。。保留下來的只有巴厘島 到現象還是印度教。
不是单纯的佛教，是一种印度教和佛教的混合宗教吧。这导致马来语有不少词汇是梵文
没办法，中国自己也打压佛教，害怕教大于朝廷
@@doremif3531 check the history, lots of balinese ancestry are hindus from java running away from persecution. did that tell you something
胡说，人家6万年前就是穆斯林了🌚🌚
一米精品一定支持！！
朋友您信耶稣吗？您心裡有真平安、喜乐和永生的盼望嗎？
不错👍值得订阅
历史的魅力正在于此，波澜壮阔中有着人类的沉沦与救赎，让人看罢心潮涌动，久久不能释怀。
✖️？這麼詳細完整的視頻介紹了新疆宗教歷史，居然被demonetized？TH-cam太噁心了吧。。
现在变为❌❌了
咱可以寻着红叉叉找视频看了，有叉必看
The true colour of youtube
恶心就别用
這個是歷史啊，敏感什麼.....
説的非常好，還想再看一遍呢
朋友您信耶穌嗎？您心裡有平安、喜樂和永生的盼望嗎？
太棒了👏
喜欢博主清晰有力的讲解
一神教都感觉很恶心
地球三癌同根同源，一神教真的恶臭，还是万神殿好。
不能同意更多
同意，几大文明根源全是信仰万神殿类型的。一神教总是在接别人的盘抢劫别人万神殿文明的成果。
Finally someone with Historical facts.
I agree he presented facts, but I wonder about his credentials. How do I know this is historical "fact?" I tend to think it is, but would like collaboration to his story.
@@phil6264 I was skeptical at first. But if you matching the history of several Asian countries, the timeline is fit the facts he gave. I agree with this because I'm from Asia, and the history of our country somehow fit in the facts he represented.
@@meplenn as I stated, I wish there was more collaborative information. I tend to believe what he is saying. However, if you want to change hearts and minds, more information is needed than a lone story teller. I wish I knew the speaker's credentials. If he had a PhD in Chinese history would add to his story. The next issue which needs to be considered is the age old propaganda allegations. These are difficult to overcome.
Lastly, what is the goal and outcome of speech. I do not know the motivation. I wish I could read and understand the nuance of his language.
My only goal is to consider everything. I enjoyed my time in China.
@@phil6264 you have raised very good question: How do we know if that's the "fact". As a Uyghur myself with a first bachelor's degree in History from a Chinese University and with a history teaching experience of a decade at an University, i can tell you this: while this fellow tried hard to make it sound like facts of the history, he is through this TH-cam channel disseminating the CCP version of the History as CCP has, over the last 70 years, re-written the entire Chinese history the way they like, thus the "fact" regarding Chinese control of the "Xin jiang" from 60 BC is a CCP lie, yes they called it xiyu but meant it is a place in the west only. This land is the origin of all the TURKS today and has been called East Turkistan / Uyghurstan till 1884 when the Manchu Qing Dynasty occupied in 1756 and re-named in 1884. Manchu Qing rule broke off in 1911, and from 1911 to 1949, it was not under anyone's rule except uyghurs and again annexed in 1949 together with Tibet and that was the first and long-lasting Han Chinese occupation.
@@foreveruyghur6332 What you said sound like joke comparing to what he showed in this video, if you don't agree what he said, point out what's wrong instead of your shallow political propaganda.
非常棒的历史说明，谢谢
很不错，兄弟👍
Thanks for sharing this valuable history.👍❤️
Hope more and more English speaking people will notice.
@@rrhy5068 Hoping that too.
你最后那些话是和平主义的发梦话， 不适合穆斯林这种宗教， 这种政宗合一的宗教必须要把影响力降到最低，人类才可以和平。
穆斯林力量太大（我认为是假象），都不敢正视现实，各怀鬼胎。
朋友您信耶稣吗？您心裡有真平安、喜乐和永生的盼望嗎？
长知识了！非常清晰的讲述！
讲述得很好，赞！
一神教全是邪教
亚伯拉罕系邪教没一个好鸟 犹太基督伊斯兰三兄弟
Yong Le
看你的点赞这么少，国人不懂得还是大多数。
@@pfzheng6501
世界三大邪教～
1.不信我都得下地狱
2.不信我都得死
基督教改革前也是一副死样
那无神论共产主义的斯大林和毛泽东呢？他们各自饿死上千万和几千万人口，那是最残酷的死法知道吗？
这位佛教的保卫者不关心汉人不再信佛，古代突厥人转信伊斯兰教就当作中国吞并新疆的理由。那西藏呢？西藏人要求自治，保障他们权益和宗教信仰，你照样不是说他们落后迷信要打他们的吗？
这里说50多个过家36个城市自古互相征伐打仗，怎么就信仰伊斯兰教之前的战争是正常的战争，一部分国家开始信仰伊斯兰教之后就是邪恶的圣战了呢？
这频道讲的不是历史，而是扭曲事实来掩盖国家犯罪，逃避事实和国家法律。新疆维吾尔自治区是法律承认的民自治区，维吾尔语是官方语言，教育，媒体和一起交流上法律保障使用的语言，有宗教信仰自由和权力，2009年开始国家开始玩身份政治，维族人也开始一样的游戏，就要把几百万人关在集中营。
集中营只能把身份政治极端化，一时让维族人屈服，绝不可能因为被关起来就产生自己是华人,国家主人的幻觉。
k哥有一个字读错了，月（ròu）支😁……历史粉表示这类综述类视频看着真爽，福利
我读做月（ròu）支，一些历史迷又要纠正我了，因为新华字典已经正音为月（yue）
理科男士K一米 哦哦，这样啊，我以前读月被纠正过很长一段时间，然后汉朝历史纪录片都读肉就以为读肉了😂
这个读音有争议的，读哪个都不好说不对。
大肉汁😋
“大肉汁”的读音主要出现在上世纪五十年代中小学课本及工具书，但查最新版《新华字典》及《汉语大词典》，其“月氏”词条读音均已改为“yuè zhī”。另据《辞源》、《辞海》、《中华大字典》、《康熙字典》等学术词典，“月氏”的条目均注为yuèzhī，或在“月”下注音“鱼厥切”。
圖文並茂，鉅細靡遺，精緻用心的视頻，讚。
朋友您信耶穌嗎？您心裡有平安、喜樂和永生的盼望嗎？
小伙子讲得清晰有序，脉络明了，值得称道