the audacity of people to make comments about her body and face as if she exists just to appeal them, just to arouse them, just to make them jealous. it’s disgusting. she’s beautiful no matter what. women don’t have to be a certain shape. women don’t solely exist to be sexy or cute. idols are humans too.
I was just about to comment something similar. I completely agree with you. I'm so disgusted by the comments that just see her as an object to please them.
Unfortunately, many people view performance artists as puppets for their amusement. People with this mindset shut themselves off from ever getting to know artists like Hani as people, which is a shame, as well as being wrong. I was fortunate enough to get to know EXID as people, before I listened to their music. Hani is an intelligent, interesting, charming lady. I could spend a day just chatting with her.
It’s upsetting because hani is one of the fittest idols out there, she looked so healthy and strong but she never looked bad regardless of her weight! I just hope she’s doing well and is happy
This is so disgusting. The way they weighed the girls as if their weight is the only important thing about them. Also how people were bossing Hani around by saying how she should lose or gain weight just to please them. Women are not objects that have to comply with your commands. PERIOD.
honestly the kpop idols also shouldnt have lied about their weight in their profiled ! so many young kpop fans believe it and get bummed out about their own weight. its prolly the company's fault but nonetheless :\ however this doesn't make the show which weighed all the girl idols secretly any more right, theyre another kind of trashy
+1 Agreed. Why is it that during interviews, that's the only thing they can ask them.. So sad :/ Those people who are criticizing her really need to rethink themselves. How does her body even affect you... Ever heard of if you have nothing nice to say, then just don't say.
Why were they so critical of her? She's an individual, not your toy to over sexualize. And honestly, she's a really good actor and absolutely gorgeous.
The word "idol" makes the lines blurry, there's definitely toxic people who believe they're objects worth criticism. It's like how dare they ate, be imperfect, show human emotions, not be a good enough singer, not be a good enough dancer and so on. They're super critical and behave as idols should be this perfect singing and dancing machines, then when they aren't up to standards all hell breaks loose.
When that show tricked them into weighing themselves and then humiliated them, oh my god my blood is boiling. The shows producers should be ashamed of themselves.
I’ve always related to hani because I have never been overweight or even close to but in pictures, I look massive which made me very self conscious. Thank you for re-posting this!
@@justahuman9273 oh, thank you for this! But I have a bigger frame than my friends and even they agree I look bigger than them. It’s not in a mean or bad way, I’m just big boned lol. Once again thank you!
i am tallest among my friends (they’re all 160cm or shorter) so i tend to look bigger/fat but im skinny so don’t be worried. you’re amazing no matter your weight
This was another video that blocked for copywrite I recently fixed. I still got a lot of requests for this one, next I'll be working on an update for Taeyeon ( I saw all the request's for her). Hani got put under extreme pressure and fame just about overnight to carry the groups success and I think she's carried that weight with her for a long time.
thanks for all your hard work, i remember becoming so emotional over the taeyeon one, some of her haters need to see that and hopefully get a new perspective
its so sad that she felt so pressured to get plastic surgery after saying one time she would never do it because thats the face her parents gave her and it would make them sad :( i really hate the "one face is the beauty norm" standard in korea. there are so many different ways for someone to be beautiful and she was absolutly stunning before it. I still wish her all the world because she is one of my ults still to this day even if EXID is no more. I just hope she can become happy with the way she looks and stay healthy
It's the standard even in China face wise and not to be mean, but looking like the alien emoji doesn't seem that appealing. Especially the V line jaw, you can actually loose all sensation in your jaw if done incorrectly or worse which is die. Hell you don't even have to go under the knife to die, some people die during the phase where they put you under anesthesia.
EXID has not disbanded. The only reason they have not been active in Korea is because BC sold the copyright to their name. LE intends to buy it, then start her own label. In the meantime, they are active in Japan, with an album last September, and an online concert in November.
I know we’re all watching this video, but for TV and radio shows to be constantly asking about diet and doing “surprise” weigh-ins is so fucked up. I used to teach kindergarten in SK (like 10 years ago) and even the kids didn’t like to be weighed (we had one lesson in the curriculum about what objects were “heavier” and “lighter” and one activity suggested bringing in a scale so they could see their own weights). I never had body dysmorphia as a freaking kindergartener, so I didn’t think it was problematic back then to follow the activity. But these kids kept justifying their weight and saying they were fat. I brought it up to the parents and low-key blamed them for making those precious angels think about weight at 6 years old. At that age, their health is the parent’s responsibility. They feed the kids refined wheat and sugar, then make them feel like being fat is their fault?? (These kids were not fat, by the way, even by Asian standards.) Ugh, I’m getting mad just remembering it...
Oh my god this is so sad to hear. I'm currently studying Nutrition in uni and our professors always emphasize that shaming does not help adults reach their goals. That's for adults tho. Can't imagine doing that to kids.
I feel for each and every lady in the entertainment industry but unfortunately that's kinda part of their job as entertainers to stay in a certain shape no matter how they attain it or keep in shape. BTW I also tend to not to eat if I want to lose weight (easiest and cheapest way).
2014 Hani was truly something to behold. I'd hate to think she forced herself to lose weight due to societal pressure alone. But if she's happy and healthy, that's all that matters.
She has a really enviable body type to me. Her weight distributes well and her limbs are long. Different body types can all look good though they all suit different styling, but it seems like advertising/companies always want a specific type. It’s sad that everyone feels like they need to be a specific look.
Every time an idol group does a come back I never ever notice their weight loss or gain idk why people take note of that? like they are singers not fitness instructors???
I notice the weight gain and say wow their cheeks looks so chubby I hope they eat it there hearts content but when they look really thin I get so concerned and worried
Just to let people know, Hani has not left EXID. They are still active in Japan. Their company is called TOKUMAJAPAN. They will return to Korea when they can.
I watched Running Girls, and Hani talked a lot about how she loves running as a stress reliever these days. I saw the XX drama and she did really well. She also has a film coming out soon. I think she is gorgeous, talented and very genuine. Support hani!
I always thought Hani’s broadness was so great. It makes her look fierce and athletic, very strong. Kind of matched her slightly tomboyish personality too. But her proportions are still pretty feminine so she still looked very sexy, still keeping in with the EXID image. I knew she was thinner than what was healthy so I was surprised watching this and learning she saw herself as “big”. I hope she gets better at knowing how beautiful she is when she’s healthy with a healthy body image. Being healthy, happy and confident will always shine through much brighter than seeing low weight numbers
I feel for her, I'm a lot taller (5'10 or 177cm) but I've also got a broad frame. I'm already skinny, but when I take pictures next to shorter people I literally look like I've been photoshopped to be a giant, and no matter how much thinner I get, I'm never gonna look "delicate" like how narrower people do
whoever thought that secretly recording the girls' weights was a good idea needs to be fired. like, that's a huge invasion of privacy and it's just weird...
I just hate it because if someone told her she was pretty she would likely think they're referring to a version of herself that she struggles to maintain. Breaks my heart.
17:34 the skin isn't hollow or loose, when you lose a lot of weight only the muscle shows bc there isn't a layer of fat on top. That's literally her groin muscle showing and many naturally thin girls have it, if you don't have fat on top it will show.
With the particular performance I agree, however in the other ones it’s really easy to see that her lower legs (my first language isn’t English sorry) show signs of extreme dieting.
:V how can the people see her as "fat" then "ToO skiNnY" when is literally NOT like that, like how :V she was always perfect and that she's an idol doesn't mean that you can be mean to her, like ... I'm done with this world ... Really ...
Also ... How the people can't get that because of them the idols have these problems that they (the people) are complaining so much, when it doesn't affect them AT ALL
that secret scale thing is the most horrific and traumatising thing I've ever heard... I'd literally be so scarred I'd literally starve myself from that moment on
The host who said that eating nothing but ramen because you’re too poor to afford anything else “must’ve been delicious” made me so mad. As someone who has struggled with poverty before, only being able to afford Ramen noodles for every meal is not delicious at all.
I understand you and I'm sorry you had to go through that. It's really frustrating; the hosts in those shows were generally unbelievably insensitive (it still exists though). Back then, it was really terrible for many female idols/artists but now it's getting better; we have more diversity.
the hosts most likely had absolutely no idea about poverty or what it was like to experience going through it. I guess that explains their ignorance around it, since they've mostly been rich all their lives
It seriously sucks all the sodium makes you feel bloated and it’s never actually filling for how high calorie ramen is. I’m a poor college student and there was a week or two all we could afford was ramen and hot dogs and there were days I was like I would rather not eat at all then feel sick to my stomach
Mostly, but ahe had suffer a lot of thin shaming and becoming and idol and begin hypersexualised must have take toll om her health, besides the packed schedule
dude... up & down didn't go viral before the hani fancam gained traction. no one outside of their fandom cared about the song when it was first released, they only got "massive attention" months later. all of this is on google
To me i just think the change in her face is due to the change in her hair. This is the best way I can describe how I think the hair changes her face as an idol when she had no fringe her hair was kind of shaped away from her face like this -> ( , whereas in 2020 her hair was shaped towards her face like this -> ). At least this is what i think, I might be off by a bit. But change in face does not always mean plastic surgery. Edit: I was looking for the word curtain bangs, as an idol she had a minor curtain bang situation on her head. idk if it's a full curtain bang so this is the best way I could describe it.
I agree!! People often forget how you can dramatically change your facial look just by changing your hair style and especially by changing the way you do your makeup. But even if she did get plastic surgery, that’s her choice and I wish they would leave her be :( Hani is so sweet and only deserves love and support
Hani is not the visual, Junghwa is the visual. Also they are not ranked by their weight, they are being ranked by how different they lie about their weigh while doing the show with the official profile
i feel like a lot of idols with rectangular/straight body types are more often the ones heavily dieting :( i think because hourglass figures are so universally coveted, they feel pressure to approximate one even if they're reduced to their bones showing.
Hm I had full firm thighs like that when I was a teenager. Now I'm 24, still weighing the same, have never yoyo dieted but my thighs lost a lot of its youthful firmness. I think it's just that people age and they lose the collagen in their skin. It's normal and human. Sadly that's why idols usually end their careers in their 20s. It's disgusting how kpop fans are so obsessed with every inch of idols bodies. In Germany the show where they secretly weighed the idols would be sued bc of violation of human rights.
why would she be cautious of her body/bone structure🥺. I’d love to have that bigger bone structure, that would make me look intimidating or superior and more model-like body😍 anyways, she’s gorgeous either way, but she looks the best when she is confident and self-loving❤️
I'm so sad she changed her nose...I knew it would happen eventually considering the way people treat her but man, it was such a defining feature and she had a unique look. She is always beautiful, but it is sad to see how she feels it necessary to do this and the fact that they talk about it as though it is normal! I hope one day she is happy with herself and can have some peace from the public. She is so talented and I love to see her shine.
There is a lot of false info here. Hani ALWAYS had a bunch of lines and some Center time in EXID songs. She was never marketed just as a visual. Her positions are literally Lead Vocal, lead dancer, face and Center.
The XX drama she recently starred in is surprisingly good. I loved how it centered on the friendship between two girls and the relationships with men were secondary. I also highly recommend a drama she did called You Raise Me Up- don't be turned off by the funny name/premise (it's about a guy with erectile dysfunction lol)- it actually features some refreshing writing and really important themes for Korean society. Imo she does very well in both of them
She Is literally perfect, I do understand how she feels about herself. I have quite a similar bone structure and am 3 inches taller than her. She’s amazing tho!!!
Oemji i feel the exact same. Didn't even look at her body but her energy isn't like Hani used to be. She seems to be happier nowadays though. Happy to see that
Expect nothing less, if the diets and exercise are so strict along with a busy schedule. You just avoid food all together, in some cases idols have done this and also admitted to it. They also lack energy, there was a point where idols would literally faint on stage. Basically exhaustion plus malnutrition.
@@yulianay4422 Actually she said in the radio the reason is this is might be the last comeback of Exid thats why she doesn't 'happy' in this comeback, they also said Hani and Junghwa easily cry this time also
As a dancer, being thin really affects your energy i used to be thick and now i lost abt 30 kilos and the differences are clear enpugh. Thats why i gain some weight or eat more before dance practicing to have more energy
When skinny idols debut, they get skinny shamed, then when they gain weight, they get fat shamed. When thicker idols debut, they get fat shamed, then when they lose weight, they get skinny shamed. Like let them be, it's their body, it's not like they fans/ haters have the right to control their life. But honestly the show that tricked them into being weighed is fcking ass, like idt any idol wants their weight to constantly be the topic ppl think abt when they talk abt them.
I really hate how people praise Hwasa for having a non common Korean body standard but thin shame other girls who can't have the same body type as hers.
You can still tell it's Hani, but I never realized until now there is a Difference in her Body and Face. Her Face look's more Mature now, then it was. I just Hope she's staying Healthy and not to Worried about her Weight, I absolutely Love Hani no matter what!
I feel like I can relate to this, I’m tall and have a wider frame w/ wide shoulders like Hani and a not very narrow waist. I feel trapped in a cycle of loosing weight, not being happy with the way I look (too masculine), then binge eating and gaining weight... I’m not sure I’ll ever be at a weight/figure that I like :(
Please do Babysoul from lovelyz! I love how you talk about what people say about the idols and I am very interested to know if people have been shaming her or accepted her body. She is such a talented singer and seems sweet and I haven't seen much fluctuation in her weight for years.
Those comments are just sexist, "This woman doesn't look the way I want her to because she's an object and must only be used as sexual appeal." That's all I see from those comments.
I think wonyoung has alwayd been very thin, I personally think that if she's lost any weight it's probably due to growing up. she's 16 now and was 13 when she first appeared on produce 48
@@mworago2054 she has been very thin you're right, but if you compare her legs from then and now, there's no fat now, just skin barely covering her bones, her arms/legs/hands looked the same as seola's during butterfly (very boney), and that was definitely not normal imo. Personally, I don't think it's because of her growing up because she would've still retained some of her fat cells ya know?
When are people going to learn that skinny shaming or fat shaming people aren’t going to make them not have disordered eating? It’s so toxic and neitzens will never be satisfied with idols. Idols are humans too, they’re not objects to sexualise.
Can we stop talking about her body and start seeing her more than that. Why does it always have to be about the body, the face. Comments about her great personality are barely ever recognized. It's so upsetting and disgusting for people to see her just as a sexual appeal and arousal. Why can't you just respect people ??
keep in mind some of these comments literally have single digit upvotes (and even a few hundred is super low when popular comments will get tens of thousands), which means the opinions being shown are Not the majority of what the public thought. not saying hani did not face hate (because she did), but it feels a bit? like misinformation to present such low rated statements as public opinion.
they do this a lot tbh... it also bugs me when they claim in their videos that a certain idol felt this way or that way when there's zero proof. like... you're literally just projecting and making stuff up while presenting it as facts. lol
I think she is currently at a healthy stage in life. She loves running as a Hobby and on "Running Girls" she and the Girls were able to talk about the struggle of Idol life and I think that helped her as well😶 I hope she knows that her weight or the way she looks is not what a lot of people care about. I started to love her because of her personality. She got me into kpop. I don't want her to suffer after going through so much🥺
the fact that most of those comments are probably by men disgust me they're treating her like an object. and some of them are so specific that it's creepy she's not a piece of clay, of all the kpop content i watched i've never really noticed their weight maybe occasionally in the face but even then i don't care about it. and the fact that not eating or barely eating is considered a "diet" is terrible. life as an idol especially the ones who've been around for a long time sounds awful (also props to those few people who actually defend the idols in those hate comments)
Lol it's crazy how Koreans care too much about the weight, I don't even notice when their body changes, I literally didn't notice joy's change until photos of comparison started to show up :v
all people commenting have eating disorders, like i notice the slightest change in weight bc i also have ed but those people are so spiteful for no reason
She's never fat, I don't understand people who claimed to "love" her to judge her so harshly. I feel so sorry for her since I've experienced getting called big and fat on daily basis even though my body looks okay and healthy. I still can't understand the trend of having an unhealthy thin body by forced diet is considered to be the perfect body for an idol, especially for female idols.
i truly never understood why she lost weight after the viral fancam, when she made the group famous by the way she looked back then, really weird choice coming from whoever decided it.
I like the society..I can't understand it. Why do they hate skinny people. I have just watched the tik tok and I saw a lot of positive comments about a thick girl but when I watched videos of a really skinny girl i saw a lot of bad comments. It's really bad
15:58 I always tought that is really stupid for the agency or program to show, when the idols get food in that way, I mean if they are in a restriction diet (somethign that is bad) then not put the idol in front of food in the camera, or don't talk about it, because ir more the annoying you can feel because is uncomfortable for the idol. The same goes to talk about diet, I mean maybe there are some young people that look at that and try it because have low self confident, specially youngers.
the fact she gives off the "giant effect" makes me question what people perceive as a "healthy" body type cause in no way shape or form is she "giant"or "big" or "fat" if anything she doesn't have an average body for it's so slim and healthy
The truth is that we will never please everyone, no matter how hard you try you will never be able to please everyone.... There will always be someone who will try to find a defect in you
I wanna give her a hug so much I literally cried while watching this it doesn't matter if female idols gain or lose weight, netizens always have to be so disgusting and negative
This has to be one of the first kpop weight cases I seen where they wanted the idol thick. Honestly Hani is beautiful & Body goals. She was way too oversexualized. I hope she is happy & finding balance.
If fans and companies just let their idols eat like regular people, there wouldn't be as many idols struggling with eating disorders. Idols are very active, so they of course need more food to prevent damaging their bodies. It's also horrible that many idols don't even get paid, or get paid very little. If you as a company can't afford to pay people, then you shouldn't be in business.
Hani always caught my attention and I absolutely adore her!! But I could not recognize her in the 2019 fancam and got scared she got plastic surgery 🥺 I really hope she didn’t!!!
the audacity of people to make comments about her body and face as if she exists just to appeal them, just to arouse them, just to make them jealous. it’s disgusting. she’s beautiful no matter what. women don’t have to be a certain shape. women don’t solely exist to be sexy or cute. idols are humans too.
I completely agree with you, I think people just like to project their insecurities on others.
You chose to speak facts👏👏👏👏
I was just about to comment something similar. I completely agree with you. I'm so disgusted by the comments that just see her as an object to please them.
Unfortunately, many people view performance artists as puppets for their amusement.
People with this mindset shut themselves off from ever getting to know artists like Hani as people, which is a shame, as well as being wrong.
I was fortunate enough to get to know EXID as people, before I listened to their music.
Hani is an intelligent, interesting, charming lady.
I could spend a day just chatting with her.
No cap
It’s upsetting because hani is one of the fittest idols out there, she looked so healthy and strong but she never looked bad regardless of her weight! I just hope she’s doing well and is happy
was* she's obviously not ok
Omg that's so mean that they weighed them like that!!I wanna punch the person who did that!!They are human beings,not toys
She was an athlete in her teenage years and she has abdominal muscles of iron
This is so disgusting. The way they weighed the girls as if their weight is the only important thing about them. Also how people were bossing Hani around by saying how she should lose or gain weight just to please them. Women are not objects that have to comply with your commands. PERIOD.
honestly the kpop idols also shouldnt have lied about their weight in their profiled ! so many young kpop fans believe it and get bummed out about their own weight. its prolly the company's fault but nonetheless :\
however this doesn't make the show which weighed all the girl idols secretly any more right, theyre another kind of trashy
@@account2374 as far as I know, the websites that show idol’s profiles are the ones that change their weight.
+1 Agreed. Why is it that during interviews, that's the only thing they can ask them.. So sad :/ Those people who are criticizing her really need to rethink themselves. How does her body even affect you... Ever heard of if you have nothing nice to say, then just don't say.
@@account2374 also u should consider how weight can fluctuate from time to time like with water weight it’s not the idols’ fault
@@Sermindipity especially with women, we can gain or lose ten pounds while on our periods. It’s hormonal and normal.
Why were they so critical of her? She's an individual, not your toy to over sexualize. And honestly, she's a really good actor and absolutely gorgeous.
The word "idol" makes the lines blurry, there's definitely toxic people who believe they're objects worth criticism. It's like how dare they ate, be imperfect, show human emotions, not be a good enough singer, not be a good enough dancer and so on. They're super critical and behave as idols should be this perfect singing and dancing machines, then when they aren't up to standards all hell breaks loose.
When that show tricked them into weighing themselves and then humiliated them, oh my god my blood is boiling. The shows producers should be ashamed of themselves.
That’s such a violation. 😡 I can’t believe they did that.
Ikr cause wtf is wrong with those people??
They also shouldn’t be hated for their fake profiles since it’s the companies doing, not theirs
I’ve always related to hani because I have never been overweight or even close to but in pictures, I look massive which made me very self conscious. Thank you for re-posting this!
I can assure you that you are probably the only one who thinks that you look massive in pictures!
@@justahuman9273 oh, thank you for this! But I have a bigger frame than my friends and even they agree I look bigger than them. It’s not in a mean or bad way, I’m just big boned lol. Once again thank you!
@@thisgirl643
What kind of friends are they?
i am tallest among my friends (they’re all 160cm or shorter) so i tend to look bigger/fat but im skinny so don’t be worried. you’re amazing no matter your weight
@Viki Y that’s so weird, honestly bone structure plays such a big role in how you look it’s insane! And also I’m sure your not heavy at all
This was another video that blocked for copywrite I recently fixed. I still got a lot of requests for this one, next I'll be working on an update for Taeyeon ( I saw all the request's for her). Hani got put under extreme pressure and fame just about overnight to carry the groups success and I think she's carried that weight with her for a long time.
Thanks for the update. It would be great to see a video on g idles shuhua
thanks for all your hard work, i remember becoming so emotional over the taeyeon one, some of her haters need to see that and hopefully get a new perspective
Could you made joy redvelvet please 🥺🥺🥺
Can you update video about SNSD Seohyun? She lost so much weight for her new TV show role, she was never this skinny.
thank you for your hard work.
sorry but can i ask? may you do a video of jaemin from nct? he’s expressed disturbing eating patterns and i’m concerned
its so sad that she felt so pressured to get plastic surgery after saying one time she would never do it because thats the face her parents gave her and it would make them sad :( i really hate the "one face is the beauty norm" standard in korea. there are so many different ways for someone to be beautiful and she was absolutly stunning before it. I still wish her all the world because she is one of my ults still to this day even if EXID is no more.
I just hope she can become happy with the way she looks and stay healthy
Yeah I pity that too. I’m sad she succumbed, especially to the whole V-line thing.
It's the standard even in China face wise and not to be mean, but looking like the alien emoji doesn't seem that appealing. Especially the V line jaw, you can actually loose all sensation in your jaw if done incorrectly or worse which is die. Hell you don't even have to go under the knife to die, some people die during the phase where they put you under anesthesia.
EXID has not disbanded. The only reason they have not been active in Korea is because BC sold the copyright to their name.
LE intends to buy it, then start her own label.
In the meantime, they are active in Japan, with an album last September, and an online concert in November.
@@patrickkenyon2326 i dont find any article that stated that LE plans on byuning EXIDs copyright. Where did you get that from?
@@patrickkenyon2326 omg does LE really plan to buy it? She is amazing
I know we’re all watching this video, but for TV and radio shows to be constantly asking about diet and doing “surprise” weigh-ins is so fucked up. I used to teach kindergarten in SK (like 10 years ago) and even the kids didn’t like to be weighed (we had one lesson in the curriculum about what objects were “heavier” and “lighter” and one activity suggested bringing in a scale so they could see their own weights). I never had body dysmorphia as a freaking kindergartener, so I didn’t think it was problematic back then to follow the activity. But these kids kept justifying their weight and saying they were fat. I brought it up to the parents and low-key blamed them for making those precious angels think about weight at 6 years old. At that age, their health is the parent’s responsibility. They feed the kids refined wheat and sugar, then make them feel like being fat is their fault?? (These kids were not fat, by the way, even by Asian standards.) Ugh, I’m getting mad just remembering it...
Oh my god this is so sad to hear. I'm currently studying Nutrition in uni and our professors always emphasize that shaming does not help adults reach their goals. That's for adults tho. Can't imagine doing that to kids.
The tv shows weighing them without their permission are disgusting
I'll never understand the ridiculous methods these hosts go through to find out a female idol's weight. It's unnecessary
Ikr,is not like knowing the girl's weight will benefit them in any way.
Right!!!
I’m disgusted by how normalized starving is in korean culture. starving ≠ diet
exactly! if I was dieting by simply not eating my friends and family would be so concerned and think I had an ED.
If the companies want them to lose weight they should give them money to buy healthy food so they can diet properly
I feel for each and every lady in the entertainment industry but unfortunately that's kinda part of their job as entertainers to stay in a certain shape no matter how they attain it or keep in shape. BTW I also tend to not to eat if I want to lose weight (easiest and cheapest way).
@@katiemp670 it would be an eating disorder. starving is not healthy in the slightest, especially eating a single pretzel a day
And at the same time they praise plastic surgery...
funny people.
2014 Hani was truly something to behold. I'd hate to think she forced herself to lose weight due to societal pressure alone. But if she's happy and healthy, that's all that matters.
She has a really enviable body type to me. Her weight distributes well and her limbs are long.
Different body types can all look good though they all suit different styling, but it seems like advertising/companies always want a specific type. It’s sad that everyone feels like they need to be a specific look.
Every time an idol group does a come back I never ever notice their weight loss or gain idk why people take note of that? like they are singers not fitness instructors???
thisss
From personal experience, you usually focus on criticizing in others what you’re insecure about in yourself.
I notice the weight gain and say wow their cheeks looks so chubby I hope they eat it there hearts content but when they look really thin I get so concerned and worried
@@mwacheas binge eating disorders exist. But basically you shouldn't comment on other's bodies if it's negative
I do notice but I also wouldn’t comment on it 👽 #edtings 🌝
I hate the fact that EVERYONE thinks they can give their opinion towards a woman's body.
Towards a person body***
@@kou5270 women body are far more subject to judgement and critics.
@@aliceguichard9367 that doesn't mean we shouldn't care about everybody's body
Just to let people know, Hani has not left EXID.
They are still active in Japan. Their company is called TOKUMAJAPAN.
They will return to Korea when they can.
I watched Running Girls, and Hani talked a lot about how she loves running as a stress reliever these days. I saw the XX drama and she did really well. She also has a film coming out soon. I think she is gorgeous, talented and very genuine. Support hani!
I always thought Hani’s broadness was so great. It makes her look fierce and athletic, very strong. Kind of matched her slightly tomboyish personality too. But her proportions are still pretty feminine so she still looked very sexy, still keeping in with the EXID image. I knew she was thinner than what was healthy so I was surprised watching this and learning she saw herself as “big”. I hope she gets better at knowing how beautiful she is when she’s healthy with a healthy body image. Being healthy, happy and confident will always shine through much brighter than seeing low weight numbers
it’s weird because she still looks so good even at her “biggest”, it doesn’t look that different from then and now.
I feel for her, I'm a lot taller (5'10 or 177cm) but I've also got a broad frame. I'm already skinny, but when I take pictures next to shorter people I literally look like I've been photoshopped to be a giant, and no matter how much thinner I get, I'm never gonna look "delicate" like how narrower people do
whoever thought that secretly recording the girls' weights was a good idea needs to be fired. like, that's a huge invasion of privacy and it's just weird...
I was so very shocked when I saw her during the ‘Hot Pink’ comeback. I hope she never feels the need to take such extreme measures again.
I just hate it because if someone told her she was pretty she would likely think they're referring to a version of herself that she struggles to maintain. Breaks my heart.
17:34 the skin isn't hollow or loose, when you lose a lot of weight only the muscle shows bc there isn't a layer of fat on top. That's literally her groin muscle showing and many naturally thin girls have it, if you don't have fat on top it will show.
With the particular performance I agree, however in the other ones it’s really easy to see that her lower legs (my first language isn’t English sorry) show signs of extreme dieting.
:V how can the people see her as "fat" then "ToO skiNnY" when is literally NOT like that, like how :V she was always perfect and that she's an idol doesn't mean that you can be mean to her, like ... I'm done with this world ... Really ...
Also ... How the people can't get that because of them the idols have these problems that they (the people) are complaining so much, when it doesn't affect them AT ALL
Cause the ones that shame someone's body for "being fat" are Koreans,but the ones that shame someone's body for "being skinny" are i-kpop fans
hani is stunning no matter what tbh
Ikr!Beauty Queen!
that secret scale thing is the most horrific and traumatising thing I've ever heard... I'd literally be so scarred I'd literally starve myself from that moment on
The host who said that eating nothing but ramen because you’re too poor to afford anything else “must’ve been delicious” made me so mad. As someone who has struggled with poverty before, only being able to afford Ramen noodles for every meal is not delicious at all.
I understand you and I'm sorry you had to go through that.
It's really frustrating; the hosts in those shows were generally unbelievably insensitive (it still exists though).
Back then, it was really terrible for many female idols/artists but now it's getting better; we have more diversity.
@@marionangela thank you for your words💕, I just wish people would call these people out more often when they say awful things like this.
I agree, I went through same. So many disgusting situations in this video, just wow...
the hosts most likely had absolutely no idea about poverty or what it was like to experience going through it. I guess that explains their ignorance around it, since they've mostly been rich all their lives
It seriously sucks all the sodium makes you feel bloated and it’s never actually filling for how high calorie ramen is. I’m a poor college student and there was a week or two all we could afford was ramen and hot dogs and there were days I was like I would rather not eat at all then feel sick to my stomach
do a Tzuyu video please 👉🏻👈🏻
Mostly, but ahe had suffer a lot of thin shaming and becoming and idol and begin hypersexualised must have take toll om her health, besides the packed schedule
Korea has this obsession with being tiny. Hani is just hot and big bone structure, they prob think she looks too hot
High-key jealous.
dude... up & down didn't go viral before the hani fancam gained traction. no one outside of their fandom cared about the song when it was first released, they only got "massive attention" months later. all of this is on google
To me i just think the change in her face is due to the change in her hair. This is the best way I can describe how I think the hair changes her face as an idol when she had no fringe her hair was kind of shaped away from her face like this -> ( , whereas in 2020 her hair was shaped towards her face like this -> ). At least this is what i think, I might be off by a bit. But change in face does not always mean plastic surgery.
Edit: I was looking for the word curtain bangs, as an idol she had a minor curtain bang situation on her head. idk if it's a full curtain bang so this is the best way I could describe it.
I agree!! People often forget how you can dramatically change your facial look just by changing your hair style and especially by changing the way you do your makeup. But even if she did get plastic surgery, that’s her choice and I wish they would leave her be :( Hani is so sweet and only deserves love and support
Hani is not the visual, Junghwa is the visual. Also they are not ranked by their weight, they are being ranked by how different they lie about their weigh while doing the show with the official profile
same thing it's even more disgusting to rank them by their real weight vs profiles. How humiliating
They're both visuals.
I don't think she's meant for fame. She's too earnest and sweet. My heart goes out to her and I wish her health and happiness.
i feel like a lot of idols with rectangular/straight body types are more often the ones heavily dieting :( i think because hourglass figures are so universally coveted, they feel pressure to approximate one even if they're reduced to their bones showing.
i have a rectangular body and when im more skinny i tend to look like a hourglass so i diet a lot :(
Yep, or they use hip pads, the pads I notice most of the time on blackpink
Hm I had full firm thighs like that when I was a teenager. Now I'm 24, still weighing the same, have never yoyo dieted but my thighs lost a lot of its youthful firmness. I think it's just that people age and they lose the collagen in their skin. It's normal and human. Sadly that's why idols usually end their careers in their 20s. It's disgusting how kpop fans are so obsessed with every inch of idols bodies. In Germany the show where they secretly weighed the idols would be sued bc of violation of human rights.
Hani was already in her 20s when all this happened. Besides aging the dieting has really taken a tow on her.
If you guys want to see Hani she’s on Mnet running girls she looks amazing and very happy!
EXID is still active in Japan.
Their company is called TOKUMAJAPAN.
why would she be cautious of her body/bone structure🥺. I’d love to have that bigger bone structure, that would make me look intimidating or superior and more model-like body😍 anyways, she’s gorgeous either way, but she looks the best when she is confident and self-loving❤️
I'm so sad she changed her nose...I knew it would happen eventually considering the way people treat her but man, it was such a defining feature and she had a unique look. She is always beautiful, but it is sad to see how she feels it necessary to do this and the fact that they talk about it as though it is normal! I hope one day she is happy with herself and can have some peace from the public. She is so talented and I love to see her shine.
There is a lot of false info here. Hani ALWAYS had a bunch of lines and some Center time in EXID songs. She was never marketed just as a visual. Her positions are literally Lead Vocal, lead dancer, face and Center.
It’s my ultimate bias in Kpop. I love her, i dont care if she’s skinny or big.
Could you do Miihi from NiziU? She lost weight during the show, but she looked very thin with their debut.
I will never understand how a grown woman dating a grown man can be a “scandal” in the 21st century
The XX drama she recently starred in is surprisingly good. I loved how it centered on the friendship between two girls and the relationships with men were secondary. I also highly recommend a drama she did called You Raise Me Up- don't be turned off by the funny name/premise (it's about a guy with erectile dysfunction lol)- it actually features some refreshing writing and really important themes for Korean society. Imo she does very well in both of them
She Is literally perfect, I do understand how she feels about herself. I have quite a similar bone structure and am 3 inches taller than her. She’s amazing tho!!!
tbh i though she looked very out of energy when i watched her me&you fancams
Oemji i feel the exact same. Didn't even look at her body but her energy isn't like Hani used to be. She seems to be happier nowadays though. Happy to see that
Expect nothing less, if the diets and exercise are so strict along with a busy schedule. You just avoid food all together, in some cases idols have done this and also admitted to it. They also lack energy, there was a point where idols would literally faint on stage. Basically exhaustion plus malnutrition.
@@yulianay4422 Actually she said in the radio the reason is this is might be the last comeback of Exid thats why she doesn't 'happy' in this comeback, they also said Hani and Junghwa easily cry this time also
@@heyylemo aaaah I see. I guess that makes sense. I would be sad too if I were her. Thank you for telling me.
As a dancer, being thin really affects your energy i used to be thick and now i lost abt 30 kilos and the differences are clear enpugh. Thats why i gain some weight or eat more before dance practicing to have more energy
I saw that she's into running or jogging and it was interesting to see her in that area in the reality show "Running Girls"
She's so talented and a great personality on TV, I hope to see her in more dramas!
can u do the shuhua weight lose ?
She has one of the best kpop bodies I've seen...
When skinny idols debut, they get skinny shamed, then when they gain weight, they get fat shamed.
When thicker idols debut, they get fat shamed, then when they lose weight, they get skinny shamed.
Like let them be, it's their body, it's not like they fans/ haters have the right to control their life.
But honestly the show that tricked them into being weighed is fcking ass, like idt any idol wants their weight to constantly be the topic ppl think abt when they talk abt them.
Thanks for updating this
I really hate how people praise Hwasa for having a non common Korean body standard but thin shame other girls who can't have the same body type as hers.
No but that at 11 Minutes with the suprise weighting is just horrible. What the hell is wrong with Southkorea?
You can still tell it's Hani, but I never realized until now there is a Difference in her Body and Face. Her Face look's more Mature now, then it was. I just Hope she's staying Healthy and not to Worried about her Weight, I absolutely Love Hani no matter what!
Thanks for normalizing this, korea
I wonder what these weight loss videos would look like if they were made about western stars like Ariana
I feel like I can relate to this, I’m tall and have a wider frame w/ wide shoulders like Hani and a not very narrow waist. I feel trapped in a cycle of loosing weight, not being happy with the way I look (too masculine), then binge eating and gaining weight... I’m not sure I’ll ever be at a weight/figure that I like :(
Please do Babysoul from lovelyz! I love how you talk about what people say about the idols and I am very interested to know if people have been shaming her or accepted her body. She is such a talented singer and seems sweet and I haven't seen much fluctuation in her weight for years.
Those comments are just sexist, "This woman doesn't look the way I want her to because she's an object and must only be used as sexual appeal." That's all I see from those comments.
If you ever get the chance, could you do Izone Wonyoung? She's been looking dangerously thin in Panorama. I'm concerned for her as she's like 16.
I dont know if is just me but she always looked in my eyes. no hating her tho
I think wonyoung has alwayd been very thin, I personally think that if she's lost any weight it's probably due to growing up. she's 16 now and was 13 when she first appeared on produce 48
@@mworago2054 she has been very thin you're right, but if you compare her legs from then and now, there's no fat now, just skin barely covering her bones, her arms/legs/hands looked the same as seola's during butterfly (very boney), and that was definitely not normal imo. Personally, I don't think it's because of her growing up because she would've still retained some of her fat cells ya know?
When are people going to learn that skinny shaming or fat shaming people aren’t going to make them not have disordered eating? It’s so toxic and neitzens will never be satisfied with idols. Idols are humans too, they’re not objects to sexualise.
To me, Hani has the best figure in kpop. And she was already skinny to begin with, I don't understand those nasty 'fat' comments at all.
Why netizens get so mad about idols acting? It's ridiculous since idols have acting classes too!
Can we stop talking about her body and start seeing her more than that. Why does it always have to be about the body, the face. Comments about her great personality are barely ever recognized. It's so upsetting and disgusting for people to see her just as a sexual appeal and arousal. Why can't you just respect people ??
keep in mind some of these comments literally have single digit upvotes (and even a few hundred is super low when popular comments will get tens of thousands), which means the opinions being shown are Not the majority of what the public thought. not saying hani did not face hate (because she did), but it feels a bit? like misinformation to present such low rated statements as public opinion.
they do this a lot tbh... it also bugs me when they claim in their videos that a certain idol felt this way or that way when there's zero proof. like... you're literally just projecting and making stuff up while presenting it as facts. lol
@@mercurials it reminds me of netizenbuzz cherry picking negative comments :/
Interesting! I have a similar body type and height. Its Interesting to see how the different weight and methods played on on her
she is so pretty tho I hope she's okay soon
I think she is currently at a healthy stage in life. She loves running as a Hobby and on "Running Girls" she and the Girls were able to talk about the struggle of Idol life and I think that helped her as well😶
I hope she knows that her weight or the way she looks is not what a lot of people care about. I started to love her because of her personality. She got me into kpop. I don't want her to suffer after going through so much🥺
the fact that most of those comments are probably by men disgust me they're treating her like an object. and some of them are so specific that it's creepy she's not a piece of clay, of all the kpop content i watched i've never really noticed their weight maybe occasionally in the face but even then i don't care about it. and the fact that not eating or barely eating is considered a "diet" is terrible. life as an idol especially the ones who've been around for a long time sounds awful (also props to those few people who actually defend the idols in those hate comments)
THEY NEED TO LEAVE HER ALONEEEE!!!! I hate that these idols get body shamed or shamed for anything they do. It’s not right... hani deserves better 😔
For the one who say “I can’t stand kds who go from idol to acting” bro you don’t know what is grow up as an artist.
Lol it's crazy how Koreans care too much about the weight, I don't even notice when their body changes, I literally didn't notice joy's change until photos of comparison started to show up :v
all people commenting have eating disorders, like i notice the slightest change in weight bc i also have ed but those people are so spiteful for no reason
Protect her, as we couldn't do with Sully 😢
Can u do jeongyeons weight gain? It seems she has gained some weight in her recoverry and i think it would be interesting to see ur breakdown of ut
Izone won young looks really thin 😭😭😭 or maybe male idol
She still looks stunning ♥️💞💝😎 🔥 i miss u hani so much and her group too 💛😙💜💖😚😍😭😭😭i want their comeback please return of really incredible exid 💘😚😭😭
Love Hani and exid regardless of anything
AWESOME VIDEO
She's never fat, I don't understand people who claimed to "love" her to judge her so harshly. I feel so sorry for her since I've experienced getting called big and fat on daily basis even though my body looks okay and healthy. I still can't understand the trend of having an unhealthy thin body by forced diet is considered to be the perfect body for an idol, especially for female idols.
Hani looked sad and tired in the ME&YOU lives... Glad she seems happier now.
i truly never understood why she lost weight after the viral fancam, when she made the group famous by the way she looked back then, really weird choice coming from whoever decided it.
I like the society..I can't understand it. Why do they hate skinny people. I have just watched the tik tok and I saw a lot of positive comments about a thick girl but when I watched videos of a really skinny girl i saw a lot of bad comments. It's really bad
15:58 I always tought that is really stupid for the agency or program to show, when the idols get food in that way, I mean if they are in a restriction diet (somethign that is bad) then not put the idol in front of food in the camera, or don't talk about it, because ir more the annoying you can feel because is uncomfortable for the idol. The same goes to talk about diet, I mean maybe there are some young people that look at that and try it because have low self confident, specially youngers.
"the fancam had more views than the official MV"
Dayum 👁️👄👁️
Honestly, she’s beautiful no matter what 😂 wish her all the best
the fact she gives off the "giant effect" makes me question what people perceive as a "healthy" body type cause in no way shape or form is she "giant"or "big" or "fat" if anything she doesn't have an average body for it's so slim and healthy
She was NEVER fat :(
Nice profile picture I thought this was my own comment at first lol
The truth is that we will never please everyone, no matter how hard you try you will never be able to please everyone.... There will always be someone who will try to find a defect in you
I wanna give her a hug so much
I literally cried while watching this
it doesn't matter if female idols gain or lose weight, netizens always have to be so disgusting and negative
This has to be one of the first kpop weight cases I seen where they wanted the idol thick. Honestly Hani is beautiful & Body goals. She was way too oversexualized. I hope she is happy & finding balance.
Gotta love the hypocrisy that’s set for idols. 🌝. Being too thin/too fat, not good enough. Why do we set such unrealistic expectations?
Please do a krystal video 😞😞❤️
If fans and companies just let their idols eat like regular people, there wouldn't be as many idols struggling with eating disorders. Idols are very active, so they of course need more food to prevent damaging their bodies. It's also horrible that many idols don't even get paid, or get paid very little. If you as a company can't afford to pay people, then you shouldn't be in business.
Do changbin from straykids please?
hand's body change the Kpop industry just with one fancam, is terrible that people make her change it so much.
14:22 I don't think that look the thinnest, the only thinnest time is the Hot Pink era, she looks fine in this
Hani always caught my attention and I absolutely adore her!! But I could not recognize her in the 2019 fancam and got scared she got plastic surgery 🥺 I really hope she didn’t!!!
Why would you do if she did ?
The standards are THINNER for acting??? What kind of joke is this--