To this day, after struggling with another raspi connecting via wan I stumble across this video again. You are quite literally the only person explaining you have to turn of wayland. Thank you so much.
So I got OBS running on my RPi5 for DJ Streaming and this is perfect as I don't want to use a monitor due to space, so I set this up internally and it works great for checking my stream via my iPad... thanks Lee great video again mate :)
@@travish9531 with the latest Labwc update VLC may be working again. I use Raspberry Pi Connect Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html
yeah but it automatically enrolls you in a 14 day trial and states that once that is done all VNC services will stop. I cannot find anything else that would suggest otherwise @@leepspvideo
Chrome remote desktop is what I like using for bouncing between PC, Mac, Chromebook. I also like that it survives reboots. If I am on the road and Windows updates or the power goes out and the back on I can still remote in an just sign into the PC like it was running the whole time and I am at the windows login screen.
I wanted to use chrome remote desktop when i got my rasberry pi 5, as it is so simple. But i couldn't find a download that was compatible with the rasberry pi.
Lee, have you tried or are you running VNC Server on either Debian or Ubuntu? I am having an issue getting it up and running on either system. I have looked at other tutorials, but haven't found the problem yet. Thanks, John G.
@@federicomilano5272 VLC is no longer free. This is and can be accessed anywhere Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html
did I see wrongly or there is not a free option to creat Teams on VNC anymore? Does anyone created a new free Team these days or this year that can help me with it??
Nice videos. I managed to remote into my Pi 5 via RealVNC, but for some reason it's extremely laggy. How come yours looks so smooth? Is it because I'm using a 5V 3A power supply?
@@leepspvideo well I'm on 300MB wifi connection, that should be faster than 4/5G so I don't think the internet connection is the issue here, but I'll give it a go anyway.
@@leepspvideo I know you had good experience with xrdp. one of your videos taught me about xrdp and i use it quuite a bit now. youre videos are appreciated. got me out of a couple of binds
I have this weird issue with Raspi5 and VNC, mouse is working fine but some keys of the keyboard are not working in VNC. If i press enter or any of the num keys they are getting registered but qwerty is not working. Anyone else having this issue?
Could you maybe make a video regarding usb-C connection setup for iPad and raspberry pi? I have some troubles setting it up, may be because of missing firmware updates at the moment but i really love the idea of having a mobile Linux Pi connected to my iPad with one cable that takes care of power and ethernet. Loved this video btw!
I had this setup for years on my pi4’s. I’ve only briefly looked at it on the pi5, but I think the issue is bookworm getting rid of dhcpconf and associated things. I’ll have a look at it in more depth over Christmas and comment if i get it working!
I’m sure I read that usb c data or otg function wasn’t available yet on the Pi 5 Linux on iPad without a network. Raspberry Pi Zero 2W or Pi4. VNC Direct. th-cam.com/video/h-dh2L3X2bs/w-d-xo.html I think the Pi 5 requires too much power to be run from an ipad
It depends how you configure it. This version and configuration of VNC provides a direct mirror of your open desktop so I don't know how it would work if not logged in. But I personally use TigerVNC on Linux and the way I have it configured is to launch a separate desktop session when I log in - so it doesn't matter whether or not the remote machine is logged in or not, as long as the vnc service is running in the background.
They way mine works is if I logout to the pi os password/login screen. I can log back in by pressing the 3 dots bottom right of the VNC viewer selecting keyboard type password and press enter. Strangely if I put the password in correctly but then try to click the login box it thinks the password is incorrect.
Restarted then connected via mobile data with no issues logged out and in again without any issues. My Pi is connected to my network via Ethernet @@goobiie
Actually I use orange ubuntu and vnc on it but according to my research I need to have an hdmi emulator plugged into the orangepi otherwise I just get a black screen when remote (I use ubuntu desktop)
I moved away from vnc as it’s no longer free. I use Raspberry Pi connect Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html I don’t think it supports Ubuntu
Raspberry Pi OS supports usb boot. Just write the image to the ssd with Raspberry Pi imager. Any usb sata cable I have listed in my video description will work.
VLC is no longer free This is Official Remote Desktop with Wayland support. Raspberry Pi Connect. th-cam.com/video/FlyCWkcrl7c/w-d-xo.html Touchscreen keyboard for Remote Desktop. Raspberry Pi Connect & Raspberry Pi OS th-cam.com/video/r3MQr_zE8mY/w-d-xo.html Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html
VNC is such a mess. Remote desktop protocol should be a standard and also a basic requirement of a graphical desktop environment. Wayvnc is a poor cludge and Pi OS shouldn't have been released as Wayland by default without making sure there was robust support.
"VNC is such a mess." No, VNC is designed to provide remote access to desktops that do not change dramatically from second to second. That is the purpose that it is designed to serve. It is not designed to stream fast-changing images. "Remote desktop protocol should be a standard" VNC is a standard, as is RDP or X11, which can also be used to provide remote graphical desktop capability. I'm not sure what you are complaining about. "and also a basic requirement of a graphical desktop environment." I am not sure what you mean by "a basic requirement". I would argue that most people running Windows at home never use a remote desktop environment. The main reason for that is that to connect externally through a NAT router on an Internet connection requires some technical skill to securely open pinhole ports for access, or some kind of subscription to a "middle man" type service. "Wayvnc is a poor cludge and Pi OS shouldn't have been released as Wayland by default without making sure there was robust support." Wayland is not something that I use at all given that my one and only Linux OS is Gentoo which I can get to run on just about anything and uses Xorg by default. Xorg is still supported for bug fixes, there is no reason to use Wayland unless you're some self-entitled gamer obsessed with frame rates on "Cybersplatt 4044".
You might want to understand what you are talking about before posting nonsense. RFB is a standard (rfc6143) but VNC is not. There are multiple implementations e.g. RealVNC, TightVNC, UltraVNC, TigerVNC, TurboVNC, Vino, Xvnc to name but a few, and for the most part they don't play nicely with each other. Moreover all Linux VNC implementations are X11 based with Wayland support as "ongoing". I've no idea why you are wanging on about Gentoo and Windows. My comments are aimed at Raspberry Pi and Pi OS, where my projects remote access of an SBC as a basic requirement. As for the general X11 v Wayland debate, please note the RedHat are dropping X11 support, so expect other distros to follow suit. However I expect them to support VNC on Wayland out of the box. So back to my original statement: VNC on Pi OS (Bookworm) is a hot mess. FACT. QED.
To this day, after struggling with another raspi connecting via wan I stumble across this video again. You are quite literally the only person explaining you have to turn of wayland. Thank you so much.
💯 I ordered three Pi 5s, and I just got my first one a few days ago. I'll probably have one on battery backup with VNC to access home stuff.
Wow. Disabling Wayland, that is new. Thanks for the video, I was getting stressed.
So I got OBS running on my RPi5 for DJ Streaming and this is perfect as I don't want to use a monitor due to space, so I set this up internally and it works great for checking my stream via my iPad... thanks Lee great video again mate :)
THANK YOU SO MUCH. I finally got my RVNC->PI running Bookworm working.
EXACTLY what I needed. Was getting a black screen on VNC connect, and no taskbar icon. THANK YOU!
Thanks! Couldn't get my rpi5 to run realvnc. Didn't consider it might have been the window manager
@@travish9531 with the latest Labwc update VLC may be working again. I use Raspberry Pi Connect
Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect
th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html
Freacking finally i got some remote desktop app working on the pi! Thank you very much~!
Official Remote Desktop with Wayland support. Raspberry Pi Connect.
th-cam.com/video/FlyCWkcrl7c/w-d-xo.html
Thank you so much, it works for Raspberry 4 as well
Exactly what I was looking for. Thanks!
I tried updating to VNC viewer 7.8 and didn't work, removed it went back to 7.5 that it installs and it seems to work.
Pi 400 and it does not work at all with bookworm 2024 march.
The vnc server icon does not appear, regardless what.
any suggestions ?
Have you changed the window manager from wayland?
Super all very clear and working! Thank you
Looks like RealVNC no longer has a free option. Is there a free VNC viewer you'd recommend?
If you go to sign in then create an account it states no card needed. I put a link on another comment
yeah but it automatically enrolls you in a 14 day trial and states that once that is done all VNC services will stop. I cannot find anything else that would suggest otherwise @@leepspvideo
Can I configure it for pi 4? and should I need a real IP from my ISP?
Just follow this video for Pi 4. It’s the same process
i did all that and still dont have real vnc on the top
please helpp
I haven’t had that issue. Did you follow the whole video?
Chrome remote desktop is what I like using for bouncing between PC, Mac, Chromebook.
I also like that it survives reboots. If I am on the road and Windows updates or the power goes out and the back on I can still remote in an just sign into the PC like it was running the whole time and I am at the windows login screen.
Yes, but ChromeOS is nothing but surveillance software for Google to see everything that you do.
I wanted to use chrome remote desktop when i got my rasberry pi 5, as it is so simple. But i couldn't find a download that was compatible with the rasberry pi.
Lee, have you tried or are you running VNC Server on either Debian or Ubuntu? I am having an issue getting it up and running on either system. I have looked at other tutorials, but haven't found the problem yet.
Thanks,
John G.
I haven’t, but I use this regularly with Raspberry Pi OS
VNC doesn’t support Wayland. Last time I tried Ubuntu it wasn’t running wayland.
On the same network or if i am home and raspberry in my office? thnx
@@federicomilano5272 VLC is no longer free.
This is and can be accessed anywhere
Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect
th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html
As of 6/17/2024, RealVNC will be ending their free service for home tier. Is there anyway we can get some tutorial for alternatives?
This is free
Official Remote Desktop with Wayland support. Raspberry Pi Connect.
th-cam.com/video/FlyCWkcrl7c/w-d-xo.html
Can you review adrucam's new 64mp module?
did I see wrongly or there is not a free option to creat Teams on VNC anymore? Does anyone created a new free Team these days or this year that can help me with it??
Will the procedure explained in the video work with raspberry pi 4?
Yes, this was on a Pi 4
FREE RealVNC account. Remote Access for your Raspberry Pi from Anywhere.
th-cam.com/video/1oZK7ZDL_H8/w-d-xo.html
Nice videos. I managed to remote into my Pi 5 via RealVNC, but for some reason it's extremely laggy. How come yours looks so smooth? Is it because I'm using a 5V 3A power supply?
I doubt it’s the power supply. Try accessing your pi remotely with your phone when you get a good 4G 5G signal
@@leepspvideo well I'm on 300MB wifi connection, that should be faster than 4/5G so I don't think the internet connection is the issue here, but I'll give it a go anyway.
How does emulation perform via this streaming option? Does it have lag?
Yes, it probably would lag badly. VNC is not designed to handle fast changing graphics on a desktop.
It’s not suitable for emulation
I configured VNC server on PI 4 this afternoon and after a reboot, my Pi won't connect with an IP address on the network.
Any ideas?
It’s not something I have experienced. I would try restarting your router
Is there any advantage of VNC compared to Xrdp ?
If vnc doesnt do sound, then what is the benefit ?
XRDP is dead easy to install and set up on a Pi
It’s already built in, plus it’s very simple for access over the internet. I also had a great experience with XRDP
@@leepspvideo I know you had good experience with xrdp. one of your videos taught me about xrdp and i use it quuite a bit now.
youre videos are appreciated. got me out of a couple of binds
The advantage of VNC is screen/mouse sharing on a current session for two users.
I have this weird issue with Raspi5 and VNC, mouse is working fine but some keys of the keyboard are not working in VNC. If i press enter or any of the num keys they are getting registered but qwerty is not working. Anyone else having this issue?
Any plans for RealVNC to support Wayland?
Yes they are working on it
I can not get this to run an M2 Mac, but the iPad is a nice workaround.
Vnc viewer is running fine on my M1 MacBook Air
Could you maybe make a video regarding usb-C connection setup for iPad and raspberry pi? I have some troubles setting it up, may be because of missing firmware updates at the moment but i really love the idea of having a mobile Linux Pi connected to my iPad with one cable that takes care of power and ethernet. Loved this video btw!
I had this setup for years on my pi4’s. I’ve only briefly looked at it on the pi5, but I think the issue is bookworm getting rid of dhcpconf and associated things. I’ll have a look at it in more depth over Christmas and comment if i get it working!
I’m sure I read that usb c data or otg function wasn’t available yet on the Pi 5
Linux on iPad without a network. Raspberry Pi Zero 2W or Pi4. VNC Direct.
th-cam.com/video/h-dh2L3X2bs/w-d-xo.html
I think the Pi 5 requires too much power to be run from an ipad
Thanks for the video
It seems it doesn’t work under Wayland.
They are working on it. You can switch out of wayland
Does this vnc connection work when you signout from rpi5?
It depends how you configure it. This version and configuration of VNC provides a direct mirror of your open desktop so I don't know how it would work if not logged in.
But I personally use TigerVNC on Linux and the way I have it configured is to launch a separate desktop session when I log in - so it doesn't matter whether or not the remote machine is logged in or not, as long as the vnc service is running in the background.
They way mine works is if I logout to the pi os password/login screen. I can log back in by pressing the 3 dots bottom right of the VNC viewer selecting keyboard type password and press enter. Strangely if I put the password in correctly but then try to click the login box it thinks the password is incorrect.
@@leepspvideo try restarting the device and connect via vnc remotely.
Restarted then connected via mobile data with no issues logged out and in again without any issues. My Pi is connected to my network via Ethernet @@goobiie
Does this work with ubuntu for the pi
?
I haven’t tried
Why does realvnc work but not jump desktop
It doesn’t support Wayland, this does
Official Remote Desktop with Wayland support. Raspberry Pi Connect.
th-cam.com/video/FlyCWkcrl7c/w-d-xo.html
it doesn't work if the rpi is not connected to the display. Hope you will guide the remote when rpi is not connected to the screen
Mine does. I just started my Pi5 without hdmi and accessed it from my iPad after typing in the VNC password I created
VNC does work on headless Linux machines - that's one of the major reasons to use VNC in the first place.
You have to connect to the same wifi network that you put in RPi imager
Actually I use orange ubuntu and vnc on it but according to my research I need to have an hdmi emulator plugged into the orangepi otherwise I just get a black screen when remote (I use ubuntu desktop)
@@khanhphanthe2680 Yes, I don't run Ubuntu myself but I do remember reading something about that. Didn't Lee here do a video on that a while ago?
Know how to do it for Ubuntu?
I moved away from vnc as it’s no longer free.
I use Raspberry Pi connect
Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect
th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html
I don’t think it supports Ubuntu
Thanks again...
solid thanks
The first vid showed a home user availability. That as gone away. Expensive proposition npw.
Do you mean this video?
FREE RealVNC account. Remote Access for your Raspberry Pi from Anywhere.
th-cam.com/video/1oZK7ZDL_H8/w-d-xo.html
How to boot from SSD?
Raspberry Pi OS supports usb boot. Just write the image to the ssd with Raspberry Pi imager. Any usb sata cable I have listed in my video description will work.
how is this possible that you dont have to install real vnc ???
I think it’s configured when you enable it in config.txt
helpful!
VLC is no longer free
This is
Official Remote Desktop with Wayland support. Raspberry Pi Connect.
th-cam.com/video/FlyCWkcrl7c/w-d-xo.html
Touchscreen keyboard for Remote Desktop. Raspberry Pi Connect & Raspberry Pi OS
th-cam.com/video/r3MQr_zE8mY/w-d-xo.html
Free Remote access anywhere with Raspberry Pi Connect
th-cam.com/video/3mIb2Od1niU/w-d-xo.html
thanku
VNC is such a mess. Remote desktop protocol should be a standard and also a basic requirement of a graphical desktop environment. Wayvnc is a poor cludge and Pi OS shouldn't have been released as Wayland by default without making sure there was robust support.
Vnc are working on Wayland support. article linked in the description
@@leepspvideo Yep, but it's poor from Linux DE community generally and Pi Foundation specifically to release this hot mess.
"VNC is such a mess."
No, VNC is designed to provide remote access to desktops that do not change dramatically from second to second. That is the purpose that it is designed to serve. It is not designed to stream fast-changing images.
"Remote desktop protocol should be a standard"
VNC is a standard, as is RDP or X11, which can also be used to provide remote graphical desktop capability. I'm not sure what you are complaining about.
"and also a basic requirement of a graphical desktop environment."
I am not sure what you mean by "a basic requirement". I would argue that most people running Windows at home never use a remote desktop environment. The main reason for that is that to connect externally through a NAT router on an Internet connection requires some technical skill to securely open pinhole ports for access, or some kind of subscription to a "middle man" type service.
"Wayvnc is a poor cludge and Pi OS shouldn't have been released as Wayland by default without making sure there was robust support."
Wayland is not something that I use at all given that my one and only Linux OS is Gentoo which I can get to run on just about anything and uses Xorg by default. Xorg is still supported for bug fixes, there is no reason to use Wayland unless you're some self-entitled gamer obsessed with frame rates on "Cybersplatt 4044".
@@terrydaktyllus1320I just pre-ordered the collectors edition of Cybersplatt
You might want to understand what you are talking about before posting nonsense. RFB is a standard (rfc6143) but VNC is not. There are multiple implementations e.g. RealVNC, TightVNC, UltraVNC, TigerVNC, TurboVNC, Vino, Xvnc to name but a few, and for the most part they don't play nicely with each other. Moreover all Linux VNC implementations are X11 based with Wayland support as "ongoing". I've no idea why you are wanging on about Gentoo and Windows. My comments are aimed at Raspberry Pi and Pi OS, where my projects remote access of an SBC as a basic requirement. As for the general X11 v Wayland debate, please note the RedHat are dropping X11 support, so expect other distros to follow suit. However I expect them to support VNC on Wayland out of the box. So back to my original statement: VNC on Pi OS (Bookworm) is a hot mess. FACT. QED.
🙋
haha. finally