Stronger than it is on other cacs you mean? I mean.. yeah, you're right. But no one really uses her as a shielder in higher AR levels. She is almost always played as C6 on-field main dps with lots of defense. So the clip in the video is actually accurate for the shield strength on a well built, high Constellation Noelle!
Its unfair for Toma and Kirara because their shields have stacking mechanics like Toma you need to Na and for Kirara if you hit the enemy with her cat form it gets stronger.
@frgal1336 she had a redhorn stonethresher tho. It doesn't make it insanely better, but it should've lasted a bit less (ppl usually don't have that weapon)
but it takes ages, by the time thoma has stacked, layla has already finished her skill cooldown, and can reactivate, tanking more dmg, even if thoma shield is slightly stornger at full stacks
Can't wait to see how new anemo shielder compares. Personally would have run this test with switching to another character after activating the shield since that's what you would probably be doing with most of the characters anyway at least for those that aren't also on field dps
@mactartaglia Most of the elemental Shields are good at absorving the same element damage, all of them but geo, that has a higher damage reduction compared to others
@@karinab7471 they could've warned ppl about it so they understand this isn't the best form of comparison. Not that they should've, but that is something they could've done
She (the creator) has learned from his past mistakes by not misleading viewers with the titles anymore. She clearly stated its HER characters, so it's your problem if you were under the impression that she did the video to make a fair comparison 😁
They all have different defense stats so this comparison is very unreasonable. You can try a shield on a lvl 1 character and see that shield breaks much faster and easier because the character has much less defense than a normal leveled up character.
All yall do when TK compares THEIR characters is complain istg. Its just hit the button that makes the shield and nothing else, which one is stronger using the build that they have on that character. Just watch the video and stop backseat gaming
This video was not made correctly. It would be fair if all 4-star characters had their shield talent at maximum. And if the shields were used correctly. Kirara and Thomas have shields that become stronger when used correctly. Many characters in the video are not at their maximum shield potential.
life is not fair my friend no one has all chars same talent level everyone uses a different artifact set mosto fhtem at least you cant make it fair for everyone and the title says my character not everyones
First of all kirara you need to hold her skill for up to 150% sheild absorbtion increase. Thomas needs to basic to quadruple his sheilds hp. The sheild is based on def so instead of having noelle with 2k+ def you should have the same def character.
Noell's defense makes her shield look stronger than it is. . .
since when is this a thing i never heard about this
but still everyone was on field during his time so
But shield's hp counts after character's defense?
@@FlavioKioff well if you have higher defense the damage that you take with your shield will be reduce because of your defense.
@@FlavioKioffomg we have the same pfp??
Stronger than it is on other cacs you mean? I mean.. yeah, you're right.
But no one really uses her as a shielder in higher AR levels. She is almost always played as C6 on-field main dps with lots of defense.
So the clip in the video is actually accurate for the shield strength on a well built, high Constellation Noelle!
the video title isnt the best shield in genshin, it says his own characters. so can we reduce the criticism and claims of unfairness
thank you
TK is a she
The unfairness was not holding kiraras shield at least, but about thoma its just awkward to stack
TK is a she
Thoma and kirara has stacking shields
not here
Its unfair for Toma and Kirara because their shields have stacking mechanics like Toma you need to Na and for Kirara if you hit the enemy with her cat form it gets stronger.
And Noelle's defense make the shield take less damage
He means his character and how he use them.
@@circling-j9c…which means her shield is stronger since you’d build her on defence anyway
@frgal1336 she had a redhorn stonethresher tho. It doesn't make it insanely better, but it should've lasted a bit less (ppl usually don't have that weapon)
but it takes ages, by the time thoma has stacked, layla has already finished her skill cooldown, and can reactivate, tanking more dmg, even if thoma shield is slightly stornger at full stacks
What’s wrong with your Layla 😭
wdym she has high hp
damn your noelle is insane
yes 4k defense
Can't wait to see how new anemo shielder compares. Personally would have run this test with switching to another character after activating the shield since that's what you would probably be doing with most of the characters anyway at least for those that aren't also on field dps
i did not know about the def thing
I swear laylas shield is good…
well
I know Kirara wasn’t fare but Layla shouldn’t be that inferior to C4 Yanfei or Xinyan 🤨
Kirara shield > layla shield
id kwhat happend there
Noelle is the strongest shield, but how... her shield STRONGER than Zhongli O-O
The on field character's defense helps with the shield strength.
@@tuhin1264what about xinyan?
@mactartaglia no need to clarify that 😅
@mactartaglia Most of the elemental Shields are good at absorving the same element damage, all of them but geo, that has a higher damage reduction compared to others
it looks like that def increase the shield strngeth i never heard of that
It wasn't a fair comparison for Thoma
its never fair
Some of them were crowned and others werent
Uuh we don't have infinite crowns do we
what exactly do you want them to do about that lmao
@@karinab7471 they could've warned ppl about it so they understand this isn't the best form of comparison. Not that they should've, but that is something they could've done
@Diency. Why would they do that? The title is which of MY characters has the strongest shield, implying this is about them, and their account
She (the creator) has learned from his past mistakes by not misleading viewers with the titles anymore. She clearly stated its HER characters, so it's your problem if you were under the impression that she did the video to make a fair comparison 😁
Aint no way laylas shield last that little, build her better bro
wdym loo kat her hp
It said translate to english
Should have used Sigewinne weapon for diona
i odnt have that
Layla💗✨️👄
she did okay
Damm your noelle is cracked and why are so msny people complaining about layla she did good
no its becaue the def of the active character increase the shield strength
noell’s shield is so strong but her opening time of e skill 🫥
shield scale with on field def character id not know that
Oh wow nice video!
Thanks!
NOELLE IS THE QUEEN OF SHEILDS🛡️🪨
agree
Diona my fav💘
Citlali & zhongli too✨
zhongli the best
I remember someone asked this in live
and in my comments too
They all have different defense stats so this comparison is very unreasonable. You can try a shield on a lvl 1 character and see that shield breaks much faster and easier because the character has much less defense than a normal leveled up character.
yes i did not know that the defense matters for this
All yall do when TK compares THEIR characters is complain istg. Its just hit the button that makes the shield and nothing else, which one is stronger using the build that they have on that character. Just watch the video and stop backseat gaming
i put "my" just ofr this reason i nthe title
thank you
This video was not made correctly. It would be fair if all 4-star characters had their shield talent at maximum. And if the shields were used correctly. Kirara and Thomas have shields that become stronger when used correctly. Many characters in the video are not at their maximum shield potential.
life is not fair my friend
no one has all chars same talent level everyone uses a different artifact set mosto fhtem at least you cant make it fair for everyone
and the title says my character not everyones
Zhongli is and will always be the best hehehe
yes
Ppl in the comments mad salty it’s not that serious
i did not know that the shield tanks more if the def from the active character is high
How did Noelle’s shield last longer than Zhongli’s?? 🤨
the on-field character’s defense affects how much damage the shield takes
it's just a dumb comparison
is this really true
remake the video, but now in the correct way.
wdym
Cryo shields r weak aganist Pyro dmg 🙂
there is n opyro dmg here
Noelle Giga chad
kinda cheated here cause of her high def
Noelle?
yes
First of all kirara you need to hold her skill for up to 150% sheild absorbtion increase. Thomas needs to basic to quadruple his sheilds hp.
The sheild is based on def so instead of having noelle with 2k+ def you should have the same def character.
i did not know this def thing before and for thoma and kirara this is hard to do
TANKFEİİİİ
best way to paly her
first
Ok
hi