In indirect tax there is a question in mcq for which two answers are possible as per law which is legally defensible. Willarks be awarded Also in descriptive Part qno1 there is a point with inadequate details. Will marks be awarded
@@AceYourCA In mcq they didn't give a option called both answers are possible. We had to choose either a or d option. Since both answers are possible will marks be given Will icai consider Since both option were not available it's their mistake
I have written ca final group2 dt and idt this time because nov 24 is last attempt for exemption validity. In direct tax i have written well expecting 51,52 In tough valuations direct tax marks will be 44-45 In indirect tax i am getting 36-37-38-39 Exemption secured is 65 in may 2023. Will icai give 2-3-4 grace marks And make me pass the group2
Grace marks they will add ineach subject 2 to 3 sir i think u also know some times they will give 15 marks also. They will give pass marks 3 to 4 when students failed in edge. Depends on ICAI.
@AceYourCA 🤣🤣 ethical communication message gives always misunderstanding even though we know we forgot that i never said any bad abt ur analysis u ppl r amazing i just shared my knowledge too 👍
Grace mark Wale aagaye😂😂😂 Kuchh log CA banke TH-cam channel chalake soch the copy check wahi karate hai...wo jo bolte hota nahi hai.... 1.exam paper easy aayega -kabhi aata nahi😂 2.grace mark milega- Milta nahi😢 3.election time pe exam postpone hoga- hota nahi😂😂😂
Bro..i can understand that you might be very stressed after ibs exam. But, it was already expected that ibs paper will be tough this time. I think you have not watched my previous videos. But don't worry.. keep working hard.. And yes, every mentor or teacher or youtuber is anticipating the future events based on the past events. And it is all known facg that projection might be true or false. I hope you understand.
If you are talking about mcq on lease, its actually icai bos portal case scenatio 9, the explanation given by them was incorrect,as they have treated it as an " operating lease". One faculty raised a query regarding the same mcq, and they replied to ignore the mcq. Now they have removed the same from bos portal, so we can expect that icai will give marks for that mcq.
Brother in mcq portion they mentioned the marks ..including grace marks....like..in my mcq booklet 30 out of 30 marks was mentioned... But there were 2 wrong mcqs..so institute allot 4 marks to every student and thats y i got 30 marks.
Sir I have mailed for AFM but after 20th, have attempted Q 2 and Q 5 will I get the grace marks, also is it necessary that only those students who have mailed will get the grace marks or everyone. Sir kindly respond to my comment
Bhai why are you lying for FR Question in MAY 2024 MTP series 1 there is no where short term lease mentioned what are you trying to do my misguiding student
Tum jse log video bana bana kar icai ko poke karte ho or fir vo de bhi rhe honge grace to bhi ni denge Remember icai always does opposite of whatever you all speculate on TH-cam
If u have to say almost nil in DT and idt why mention in thumbnail and misdirect people?
Bro read thumbnail again. You will find a question mark there.
Thanks Bhai
In indirect tax there is a question in mcq for which two answers are possible as per law which is legally defensible.
Willarks be awarded
Also in descriptive Part qno1 there is a point with inadequate details.
Will marks be awarded
If the question can be answered than very less scope for grace marks.
Still it is subjective and depends on icai.
@@AceYourCA
In mcq they didn't give a option called both answers are possible.
We had to choose either a or d option.
Since both answers are possible will marks be given
Will icai consider
Since both option were not available it's their mistake
IBS had a wrong question in question no 2 related to standard costing where actual hours were not provided. Kindly clarify
I think its not..
@@AceYourCA try and solve it then
I have written ca final group2 dt and idt this time because nov 24 is last attempt for exemption validity.
In direct tax i have written well expecting 51,52
In tough valuations direct tax marks will be 44-45
In indirect tax i am getting 36-37-38-39
Exemption secured is 65 in may 2023.
Will icai give 2-3-4 grace marks
And make me pass the group2
ICAI will provide grace marks up to 3 marks provided you are getting 40 marks jn each subject.
@@AceYourCA for me aggregate will be crossed 150
Grace marks they will add ineach subject 2 to 3 sir i think u also know some times they will give 15 marks also. They will give pass marks 3 to 4 when students failed in edge. Depends on ICAI.
@@kinggovardhan7925 bro we have analysed the situation and past trends. Done our job accordingly. Now, its upon ICAI.
@AceYourCA 🤣🤣 ethical communication message gives always misunderstanding even though we know we forgot that i never said any bad abt ur analysis u ppl r amazing i just shared my knowledge too 👍
Grace mark Wale aagaye😂😂😂
Kuchh log CA banke TH-cam channel chalake soch the copy check wahi karate hai...wo jo bolte hota nahi hai....
1.exam paper easy aayega -kabhi aata nahi😂
2.grace mark milega- Milta nahi😢
3.election time pe exam postpone hoga- hota nahi😂😂😂
Bro..i can understand that you might be very stressed after ibs exam. But, it was already expected that ibs paper will be tough this time. I think you have not watched my previous videos. But don't worry.. keep working hard..
And yes, every mentor or teacher or youtuber is anticipating the future events based on the past events.
And it is all known facg that projection might be true or false.
I hope you understand.
May 24 mtp ke 1st two question same as in nov 24. Koi short term nahi likha hai mtp me. Please do not share wrong information
Yes..you are right.
But i reffered old ones...
If you are talking about mcq on lease, its actually icai bos portal case scenatio 9, the explanation given by them was incorrect,as they have treated it as an " operating lease".
One faculty raised a query regarding the same mcq, and they replied to ignore the mcq. Now they have removed the same from bos portal, so we can expect that icai will give marks for that mcq.
If total is 146 with pass in all subjects..will icai provide grace of 4 marks?
Idt ke 1 question main hi mistake hai question 1 ke ek point main pos check karne ke liye
Register place ka naam hi given nahi hai..
In that case pos will be same state.
Maine email kiya tha last time in afm....i got exemption in afm...so action toh nahi leta icai yeh baat confirm hai
Yes bro..
NO GRACE MARKS IN AFM
MAY 2024 paper was already easy for which it seems icai is regretting today 😂😂
Your comment is welcomed bro.
Everyone has their own opinions.
@ bro I am not giving opinion it’s reality cuz I didn’t get any grace marks in AFM ….if anyone got then please share.
@@abhinandanrana5366 i think i got 4 mark in mcq as answer was not in option without mailing to icai. thats why think i got 78
@@MukeshKumarsah-sh2km I got what was mentioned in mcq n descriptive …so it means I didn’t get any marks in Afm but in audit I got 4 grace marks
Brother in mcq portion they mentioned the marks ..including grace marks....like..in my mcq booklet 30 out of 30 marks was mentioned...
But there were 2 wrong mcqs..so institute allot 4 marks to every student and thats y i got 30 marks.
Bhai sahab you tube per inhi vedios ke reason se icai ne exam pattern chenge kar diya h
Correct
Achchha
Cirrect
I also get 30 out of 30 in afm without email to icai
Yes...many student got same..
Sir I have mailed for AFM but after 20th, have attempted Q 2 and Q 5 will I get the grace marks, also is it necessary that only those students who have mailed will get the grace marks or everyone. Sir kindly respond to my comment
After 20 mail not considered..but high chances of getting grace marks..because thousands of emails has been sent to icai..so..hope for the best.
They will always add grace marks for every one 2 marks irrespective of tough. But
Ya..but we should send email..
Aare jisme milna chahiye woh toh subject hi nhi likha h aapne Guru ji, ha mai AFM ki baat kr rha hu🙏🙏
See full video again pls. Also check description.
Bhai why are you lying for FR Question in MAY 2024 MTP series 1 there is no where short term lease mentioned what are you trying to do my misguiding student
Brother, i forgot to mention about icai response against email regarding that mcq..
Will clarify in next video.
Bhai ji itne subject me icai grace dene lga na to uska result bahut high ho jaega aur vo esa krega nhi
Many times this happened
To bhai aap chahte ko ki result achcha nhi jaye?
@@mathsbyanujsir483 Just want shi se checking ho bss.. baki oversupply to last time ho gyi hi
Tum jse log video bana bana kar icai ko poke karte ho or fir vo de bhi rhe honge grace to bhi ni denge
Remember icai always does opposite of whatever you all speculate on TH-cam
Waah kya soch hai bhai
Soch nhi h sahi keh ra h vo
Esa hi sbne bola ki election m exam delay hoga ye hoga vo hoga but icai ne opposite kiya
Or itne grace miln gaye na agar To vapas result 20 percent raha jaega both group ka
Or icai ko isko 10 percent karna h
Time will answer our questions
Bhai bina CA bane itna gyan mat de...
itni knowledge dusre logo ke video se leke video bnane mai lga rahe ho.
Result day pe baat karna😂
Ok bro..thanks for such a nice comment.
Haa bhai please itna gyan mat do
Esa kuch nahi h ki jo email krta h uske chances jyada hote h
U might b right or might b wrong
short term mtp me bhe ni hh
Yes .may 24 wale me nhi hai
@ to phir dono wuestion same hwe apart from numbers
Same question icai ke mcq question bank me tha. And icai has remived that because this question does not support ind as 116@CAfinalpankaj
@@MonikaSharmaVista kya aap bta skte hh kn se question bank me tha ,mujhe check krna tha bs
Sab ko he mila tha 😂
Yes
sir jisko IBS mei already exemption to kya usko grace marks milega?
No u will not get
Exemption ke bad grace marks kese milenge bhai?
@@AceYourCAspeed post se ghar bhejege GRACE MARKS ko 😂