Why Germany has Shut down all nuclear reactors | Reality of Green Energy, EV industry
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 เม.ย. 2023
- In this video, we'll learn Why Germany has Shut down all its nuclear reactors. Is this the end of Germany's nuclear era? We will also learn about the reality of Green energy, EV industry what they don't tell you.
#germany #nuclear #greenenergy
Podcast available on:-
Spotify:- open.spotify.com/show/3uMcktM...
Google Podcast:- podcasts.google.com/search/am...
TH-cam:- / amitsenguptaaks
Instagram:- / amitsengupta01
Facebook:- / amitsengupta01
Quora:- www.quora.com/profile/Amit-Se...
Koo:- www.kooapp.com/profile/amitse...
Hindi Channel
/ amitsenguptahindi
-- Geography playlist
• Geography terms and de...
-- Economy playlist
• Economics
• Indian Economy - UPSC ...
-- Current Affairs playlist
• UPSC Current Affairs v...
-- Indian history playlist
• Modern History for UPS...
-- Govt of India schemes playlist
• Government of India Sc...
-- Map based learning
• Map based learning
-- Climatology playlist
• Climatology
-- Previous year solved question paper analysis
• Solved Question Papers...
-- Environment & Ecology playlist
• Environment and Ecolog...
-- International relations playlist
• International Relation...
-- Check the other playlists of NCERT Geography videos
Class 6 - goo.gl/DDFtIF
Class 7 - goo.gl/ppPK05
Class 8 - goo.gl/OD3Gwh
Class 9 - goo.gl/AIEXxQ
Class 10 - goo.gl/inWIAR
Class 11 - goo.gl/Pn5EIE
Class 11 (Part 2) - goo.gl/X4zY9K
Class 12 - goo.gl/Kszpz5
Finally we are saying without any speculation that nord pipelines were blown by US..
Follow the money.
Of course it was. Never a doubt from day one.
WHERE IS YOUR PROOF AMIT THAT THE US DID THIS
@@stephensharma4994 jus search it up man.. or if u r here to argue then carry on.
Absolutely there was never any doubt, they even admitted it…
Germany had decommissioned their Nuclear Power Plant where as Finland has recently inaugurated Europe largest Nuclear power plant.
Which is mainly payed for with french tax money.
They started to build Olkiluoto 3 in 2005. It took them so long to build it. Ask yourself what phone you had in 2005.
@@jantube358 what has his phone got to do with it? Oh remind me how long have we been using petroleum for?
@@amanjha5916 a reminder how much the world has changed since 2005
@@amanjha5916 You have no idea...
Not even a clue about the point he is making.
And that is, it takes 20 years to build a NPP, so how is it a fair statement to claim Finland just commissioned a large NPP when the decision was put in place 20 years ago.... seriously... some people.
still remember i used to watch Amit sir's videos for class 9th social science, back in 2016
Me too, helped me score 90+ in boards as well
Abh kya kar Raha ho??
@@Onlylurking_ Computer Science bachelor's
Got 97 in sst class 10.
@@loopzz5526 Great🙌👍
The amount of knowledge Amit sir gives us is really unmatchable. Thank you sir for all your videos.
@@divyanshshukla6411 thanks buddy
@@surajchowhan2 😊
@@divyanshshukla6411 Whats the difference Karen?
Start watching news buddy
They are far more knowledgeable
@@BUDX man, just opened news channel inspired by your comment and found what Suhana khan is wearing for kkr match and Taimur has first time said Saif as abbu
India should incentivise German Nuclear Scientists to contribute towards developing clean nuclear energy technology in India. Especially with Thorium and accelerate the second and third phase of India’s Nuclear program
Alot of them are moving to the US China and India.
We sold our citys reactor to egypt
Germany seems bent on self-destruction.
Yea i am from Germany.
Our current ruling Party of the Greens says it even outright that there are "too many humans" and that we must reduce our carbon footprint (People are Carbon). The Coalition partner of the Conservative parties mirrors their rhetoric. If you ask a 18-25 Year old (I work a lot with students) they all share this view. It's odd how homogeneous their worldview is.
They talk a lot of compassion for the average person but enable a lot of things that are harmful. We are for example about to legalize incest, hard drug use and have already legalized euthanasia just as well as various medical procedures that cause sterilization - state funded for free and its advocated.
Cost of living crises and food items like meat have already gone up about +200% in price. Just 2 Years ago 500 grams of Chicken was about 4€ now its 9€. Though we are told inflation is 20~%. Also a law was just passed that causes houses that are build right now and in future to go up in costs by 50%. Just out of nowhere.
We are also handing out a heck ton of money for social programs and assistance causing more inflation for a short term gain, such as 200€ Energiebonus.
I could go on forever. Everything is destructive but done for mislead ideals. No idea if I will have a future in this country. Thinking about migrating [...], the people here especially the youth have no future and they cannot comprehend their deeds. Just too fanatical.
@@Canofbadluck you need to vote them out or else you will be part of the carbon footprint they will reduce. Paving the way for the New World Order
Edit: spelling
@@Canofbadluck have fun getting replaced by Nigerians. Don’t worry about the German racing dying out, I’ve been gathering the German-Americans to do something I won’t spoil 😉
@@Canofbadluck Democracy itself is self destructive I guess With rise of the woke (aka neo-left)
@@Canofbadluck not from Germany but currently live in Europe. The whole western Europe has healthy economies.. The only problem seems to be the dependence on gas. If it wasn't for war, everyone would have been doing alright.
I hope Germany or UK manages to make advances in Nuclear fusion technology. It would be a game changer in the longer run.
PS: I didn't consider housing market.. but it could be corrected
I am a silent reader and admirer of Amit's content - i can tell you (to those who actually don't understand) This video was actually NOT easy for Amit to make. Recently the US of A suddenly gave india some form of attention .. what was it? Praising India for having massive Lithium deposits (which has not been verified by ANY Indian geological institutes.) There will need to be further agenda as to what the USA wants to do with India with such sudden praise and attention (it is not looking good.)
Uncle Sam has already been to Delhi to set up a conduit.
@@debabratabanerjee7461 uncle Sam 😂
India is farm more stronger now.
We can;t be swayed by America easily now, especially with a Government in Charge in New Delhi, that cares for the citizens much more than their own pockets.
within a week a US diplomat visited india, he was even giving a speech in a college near my house🤣
Mexico also has lithium deposits which China is taking control of & the stupid US as usual, ignores it.
There's nothing quite like a green energy suicide pact, apparently.
They are really like a cult.
@@DBathoryXX💯
They want to prove to the world that they can live in the garden by eating just an air...
Let the idi0ts starve, their government have IQ below 65....
Suicide pact? Why call them suicide pact?
@@DBathoryXX why call em suicide pack?
France is the only country in the Europe which has an independent foreign policy and more than their 80% of the energy needs are fulfilled by Nuclear energy.
Germany is a country which is highly influenced by US or technically a US Vassal state. Now, you can guess why they are disarming their nuclear power plants as they have to follow the narratives from US and EU than just actually moving towards a sustainable green energy option.
Even France is not 100 % independent. ( more like 60 % independent )
But yeah they are the most independent European nation
@@goodvibes6715 true
@Satvik Sahu
More like Russian narrativ. Germany has shut down nuclear power plants and become dependent on Russian gas. The former chancellor who signed the deal to build Nordstream, Gerhard Schröder, had a close relationship with Gazprom.
Great video. Putting aside any political ideations, Germany's decision to take nuclear power off their grid is silly. Besides that, they're going to continue to buy nuclear created power from France to make up their shortfalls.
The green movement seems to love government with a passion. Big business also seems to love it. Every large corporation I have worked for had a green program. I think they are not a fan of small businesses because that is who the policy hurts the most.
Most green movement involves subsidy from the government to big corporations, with politicians gaining political credit or mileage for paying heed to the environment.
The subsidy comes from increases taxes (called carbon taxes, or some other names). Politicians are using public's money to look good. But this cannot be substained over the long run.
I find it almost impossible to believe that hydro, wind and solar energy can meet Germany's needs by 2035.
@@teckmenglee8060 I agree that it will not meet Germany's need. They are going to lose a lot of manufacturing jobs and people. That maybe what they are after in the end.
Interesting how quiet the environmentalists are over one of the biggest man made environmental disasters to hit Europe since Chernobyl.
Not a peep from the likes of Greta.
Just goes to show who pulls thier strings.
Even big steel manufacturers had to shut down there producing because there wasn’t enough electricity. It’s a shame we shutdown the reactors. I think we should build more reactors. The electric bills for me got up from 27c to 39c and it will not get cheaper for many years if at all….
They will make us plebs pay green tax for every gas and grocery we buy but they get to fly around with their exclusive private jets and eat delicious steak tax free no thanks to carbon credits bought and paid for by bailout money from taxpayers.
Splendid narration Mr.Gupta , none of the other channels can match to your narrative on this viable issue.
Quite a lot of Errors in this video.
- Rare earth. Not rare at all. Most wind turbines are now free of Nd and Dy.
- It's during construction anyway. During 30y operations, Nothing is consumed.
- Energy intensive. Not more than other process.
- Energy Intensive. It's more and more clean energy anyway, as we progress on the transition curve.
- Solar electricity is generated during the day. Which is also when human activity is at its peak.
- Wind is stronger during Winter, solar stronger during Summer.
- Solar and Wind are usually used to feed pumped hydro to address the top of the duck curve.
- There is a huge interconnected network in Europe so that electricity is rarely produced where it is consumed.
- Nobody claimed that EVs will "solve all these problems". We need a multi-pronged approach, Of which EVs are part.
- Lithium is only one way to make batteries. Solid state batteries are coming soon and will free us from the dependency to Li.
- Nuclear power is as clean as wastes that last for 100s of 1000s of years,
- Nuclear is as safe as Fukushima can tell. Damages are estimated to around ONE TRILLION dollars
- France is not mastering anything anymore. Not cracks in pipes, not budget overruns and not delays
- Wastes management in Germany costs tens of billions of Euros because old salt mines full of wastes now have to be cleared up and the wastes have to be moved "somewhere else"
- Decommissioning of nuclear power points cost decades and cost billions of euros
- There are virtually no private nuclear energy corporate. If only because they cannot get insurance for their activities and also because that business is not profitable.
- The alleged "green lobby" is not against big corporate. Especially not in Germany where there are a lot of big businesses.
- Green energy production cannot exist without big corporations like Siemens, EON, RWE or Uniper,
@@alainpannetier2543 I think this is a propaganda video by russians.
@@hmmmmn6770 i think you need an IQ test
@@hmmmmn6770 What? Is that how we call common sense and critical thinking these days?
@@hmmmmn6770 not by russians but sick hindutuvathis..
Yes, let's follow the Germans over the cliff..again. I worked on the plant in the photo at 7:20. Nuke plants employ a lot of people and the plants run for decades. Combined cycle natural gas plants are the most cost effective and thermodynamically efficient plants known. All the green techs are more expensive, unreliable, and polluting. Cheap energy like we have now frees mankind, expensive energy or no energy will enslave millions.
I can see why its inefficient and way more expensive but how is it poluting other than the dam?
@@mirage_panzer2274 why do not germany banning his automobiles company like bmw,audi,opel and mercedz..are these cars emit oxygen?Germany is not doing for green energy and environment.
You are should rises up an overthrow your gov. Strike like france.
"Cost effective"
This is the kind of thinking that created this problem in the first place.
Problem: Environmental costs are invisible to the free market unless mandated by government policy. If we follow wherever 'cheap' energy takes us, we'll be paying trillions in environmental damage.
And no, green energy being more polluting than gas is untrue.
A life cycle assessment by NREL says as follows:
Solar
40g Co2e/kwh
Wind
18g Co2e/kwh
Gas
500g Co2e/kwh
Coal
1001g Co2e/kwh
Source
Dw planet a, How green is solar energy really?
Germany is greener but just loses the ability to manufacture.
Very irresponsible economics by Germany.
@@SodiumSyndicate they have their friend uncle sam, no worries☺️
Who cares about Green if there are No Jobs
That has other reasons. Like nepotism.
Let them starve in their green garden of nothing but the dry desert.
Thank you for existing sir. Just blown away with your analysis and interlinkages of the topics sir . ❤💫
Quite a lot of Errors in this video.
- Rare earth. Not rare at all. Most wind turbines are now free of Nd and Dy.
- It's during construction anyway. During 30y operations, Nothing is consumed.
- Energy intensive. Not more than other process.
- Energy Intensive. It's more and more clean energy anyway, as we progress on the transition curve.
- Solar electricity is generated during the day. Which is also when human activity is at its peak.
- Wind is stronger during Winter, solar stronger during Summer.
- Solar and Wind are usually used to feed pumped hydro to address the top of the duck curve.
- There is a huge interconnected network in Europe so that electricity is rarely produced where it is consumed.
- Nobody claimed that EVs will "solve all these problems". We need a multi-pronged approach, Of which EVs are part.
- Lithium is only one way to make batteries. Solid state batteries are coming soon and will free us from the dependency to Li.
- Nuclear power is as clean as wastes that last for 100s of 1000s of years,
- Nuclear is as safe as Fukushima can tell. Damages are estimated to around ONE TRILLION dollars
- France is not mastering anything anymore. Not cracks in pipes, not budget overruns and not delays
- Wastes management in Germany costs tens of billions of Euros because old salt mines full of wastes now have to be cleared up and the wastes have to be moved "somewhere else"
- Decommissioning of nuclear power points cost decades and cost billions of euros
- There are virtually no private nuclear energy corporate. If only because they cannot get insurance for their activities and also because that business is not profitable.
- The alleged "green lobby" is not against big corporate. Especially not in Germany where there are a lot of big businesses.
- Green energy production cannot exist without big corporations like Siemens, EON, RWE or Uniper,
@@alainpannetier2543 Aaaaa we have a western ekobutthurt :D
@@asocialsocialist2534 Nuke is dead, socialist from Far Right. LMAO. Cope MF!
@@asocialsocialist2534 lol
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
Extraction of Uranium and other nuclear power plant fuels is also a very messy process. The technology of molten salt reactors which does use Thorium as a fuel is a much better option for Bharat. It is much safer and the fuel is abundant in Bharat. Extraction of Thorium is also less hazardous. Unfortunately, we have not been able to develop the technology.
We have thorium reactor research
I wonder if they have calculated how much infrastructure that is needed to provide the same or increasing amount of green energy for Germany?
I'm glad you didn't mention Three Mile Island as a nuclear disaster. I lived I guess 10-13 mi. from TMI. Worked in an industrial park right next to TMI, and in a convenience store in a small nearby town. TMI was overblown and shouldn't have affected U.S. nuclear plans.
I grew up 13 miles from Nine Mile 1 and 2 in Scriba NY on Lake Ontario. It sends energy all the way down to New York City. After 9/11 my parents had to get a potassium iodine supply just in case it was a target of ISIS. I now suffer from Hoshimoto's disease. It's a underachieving thyroid disease with thyroid nodules. Make sure that your doctor checks a thyroid panel with your yearly bloodwork. We had a leak when I was a teenager. My father was a sport fisherman so we ate a lot of fresh fish out of the lake especially salmon.
If anything, TMI should’ve strengthened the public’s support by showing that we can handle malfunctions safely, considering nobody died at all
This is the first time I found a comprehensive video that clearly elaborates on renewable energy details and its Pros and Cons.
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
Put aside the term "green" call it what you want. But nuclear energy isnt clean/green/renewable,etc. Why? Simple, they produce nuclear waste which cant be disposed. It need to be stored away and this causes polution over entire regions for thousend of years!. (The region where is is stored). And if its properly stored.
10:30 I really found this video helpful, I mean just wow never knew this much about green energy and the politics behind pushing these things aggressively, thank you so much for this valuable video❤❤❤
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
8:46
Green Ideology:
- Local Control
- Local Responsibility
- Distributed Production
- De-centralization
- Self-sustenance
Green Ideology is against:
- Dependency
- Centralization
- Corporate control
- Corporate ownership
- Concentrated production
NO BIG BUSINESS
Green ideology is all about dependence. Dependence on a centralized global government.
People who are arbitrarily anti-capitalist should be more careful about their willingness to give up their sovereignty. They should be careful as to who they are giving their sovereignty up to, especially their children's. They should consider why the sudden push for Green Ideology is taking place simultaneously across the globe.
Why is there such an aggressive anti-family movement taking place around the world?
Why is there such an incredible push for chaos all over the world?
I'm only 60 but this is unlike anything I've ever seen before.
They will backtrack on the green commitments when it's convenient. The main reason French energy is cheaper than German energy is because of nuclear power. This push for "green" everything is just insanity.
They plan do decrease population as well. So it is kind of well-planned... but you should be terrified of this plan.
a lie or propaganda.. might be effective in some place though
Sir you are one of the finest educators. The way you explain the things is just amazing. Please provide us with such informative videos regularly 🙏
All there coal plants are now open
And reopen a coal mine ditched the green deal power bec they never deliver the expected demand of energy
Thank you Amit Ji. This is really an eye opener to me. Now I know why they make such a nonsensical fuss. Human greed as always. I feel educated on this topic.TQ once again.👍👍
I was waiting for someone to address this and explain this situation for a very long time... Thankyou sir
Great info sir .....very helpfull for UPSC aspirants 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Very informative...in fact, I never thought of a few things such as the meaning of "Green", as has been explained in the current context.
Very informative and very clear … thank you 🙏
Excellent video! My two cents on EV.
There are many challenges in EV car adoption. Some of them are:
1. Lack of charging infrastructure. A massive investment is required to come up with a workable solution.
2. Upgradation of the electrical grid to handle the excess peak load, which will be a real challenge if more than 30% vehicles are EV.
3. Ability to handle discarded Li ion batteries after they reach their end life. Remember, each car will throw up about 400 kgs or more of Li ion batteries.
4. Increasing electricity production by whatever means. It would mostly be thermal and gas fired plants.
5. Ability to source critical metals for EV production i.e. Lithium, cobalt, silver, copper, nickel among others. While these are being used in conventional cars, their requirements for EV production will be manifold. Most of them come from China, Russia, African countries etc. Remember the 'chip shortage' a year back!
EXCELLENT analysis hats off you sir.
Wow,i always get to know something very new and unique from your video no matter how deep i have covered the topic
Your article open up our logical thinking about ," GREEN ENERGY." Great presentation . METTA .
I think decentralisation in solor energy is cool idea as one can install and save and become independent of government energy we can avoid the power cuts etc . Like the weak wire problem..
And green energy in West is going to be controlled by big business i don't think it's gonna be completely decentralised
I own a lot of shares from green energy company of the us
Dammn never thought this way about green energy and extraction of rear earth material.
Thanks amit for profound information.
Got a whole different perspective on Green Energy.
Thanks a lot 👍
Dear Amit Sir, I am a big admirer of your videos. I was wondering if you could create a video regarding the ongoing crisis in Sudan, explaining how it originated and also your thoughts on what might happen in the future. Thank you :)
Your wish came true. He produced one splendid video on that as well :-)
Link to video >> th-cam.com/video/-ZIp7drqu5Y/w-d-xo.html
*_TRUST !!_*
07:10 finally someone is openly putting across this point ...."so I really don't know why people say EVs is green and completely clean"... thank you for this... feels good to know there are others who second this..
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
More Public is the better solution, also meana car drivers have less traffic.
স্যার..প্রণাম নেবেন, আপনি এই ওয়েস্টার্ন হিপোক্রেটদের মুখোশ খুলে দিচ্ছেন।
To the point, very crisp truthful facts. Great content 👍
Thanks for the informative video, “The Grass Is Greener on the Other Side.”
Thank u sir. The clarification on the topics, 🙏🙏🙏hats off sir.
Quite a lot of Errors in this video.
- Rare earth. Not rare at all. Most wind turbines are now free of Nd and Dy.
- It's during construction anyway. During 30y operations, Nothing is consumed.
- Energy intensive. Not more than other process.
- Energy Intensive. It's more and more clean energy anyway, as we progress on the transition curve.
- Solar electricity is generated during the day. Which is also when human activity is at its peak.
- Wind is stronger during Winter, solar stronger during Summer.
- Solar and Wind are usually used to feed pumped hydro to address the top of the duck curve.
- There is a huge interconnected network in Europe so that electricity is rarely produced where it is consumed.
- Nobody claimed that EVs will "solve all these problems". We need a multi-pronged approach, Of which EVs are part.
- Lithium is only one way to make batteries. Solid state batteries are coming soon and will free us from the dependency to Li.
- Nuclear power is as clean as wastes that last for 100s of 1000s of years,
- Nuclear is as safe as Fukushima can tell. Damages are estimated to around ONE TRILLION dollars
- France is not mastering anything anymore. Not cracks in pipes, not budget overruns and not delays
- Wastes management in Germany costs tens of billions of Euros because old salt mines full of wastes now have to be cleared up and the wastes have to be moved "somewhere else"
- Decommissioning of nuclear power points cost decades and cost billions of euros
- There are virtually no private nuclear energy corporate. If only because they cannot get insurance for their activities and also because that business is not profitable.
- The alleged "green lobby" is not against big corporate. Especially not in Germany where there are a lot of big businesses.
- Green energy production cannot exist without big corporations like Siemens, EON, RWE or Uniper,
@@alainpannetier2543 stop spamming
Sir u r my inspiration
I also want to make video like you❤
Excellent job with this video, keep up the great work!
U really changed my perspective towards green energy today🤯🫡
Amit sir’s insight never disappoints 👍
This is such high quality content 👌 👏🏻
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
A very honest and clear-cut analysis in simple language, thank you Sir!
Well said Amit, glad some people are speaking up .
This is a decision that Germany will come to regret.
Perfect analysis as always Sir
Quite a lot of Errors in this video.
- Rare earth. Not rare at all. Most wind turbines are now free of Nd and Dy.
- It's during construction anyway. During 30y operations, Nothing is consumed.
- Energy intensive. Not more than other process.
- Energy Intensive. It's more and more clean energy anyway, as we progress on the transition curve.
- Solar electricity is generated during the day. Which is also when human activity is at its peak.
- Wind is stronger during Winter, solar stronger during Summer.
- Solar and Wind are usually used to feed pumped hydro to address the top of the duck curve.
- There is a huge interconnected network in Europe so that electricity is rarely produced where it is consumed.
- Nobody claimed that EVs will "solve all these problems". We need a multi-pronged approach, Of which EVs are part.
- Lithium is only one way to make batteries. Solid state batteries are coming soon and will free us from the dependency to Li.
- Nuclear power is as clean as wastes that last for 100s of 1000s of years,
- Nuclear is as safe as Fukushima can tell. Damages are estimated to around ONE TRILLION dollars
- France is not mastering anything anymore. Not cracks in pipes, not budget overruns and not delays
- Wastes management in Germany costs tens of billions of Euros because old salt mines full of wastes now have to be cleared up and the wastes have to be moved "somewhere else"
- Decommissioning of nuclear power points cost decades and cost billions of euros
- There are virtually no private nuclear energy corporate. If only because they cannot get insurance for their activities and also because that business is not profitable.
- The alleged "green lobby" is not against big corporate. Especially not in Germany where there are a lot of big businesses.
- Green energy production cannot exist without big corporations like Siemens, EON, RWE or Uniper,
Extraordinary...thank you sir ❤😊
spot on, in all aspects.
Good report, tks. Btw, there were only 3 reactors which accounted for six percent of German use.
Something just does not smell right with the entire de-industrialization of Germany. Tough to believe that a country of 80+ billion well educated people are so quiet about the subterfuge. Same spell is strong and here in my country, the US too.
A little correction, I think it was 80 million not billion.
@@AvGeek_ixa2005 oops, old fingers.
@@paulrevere47 lebensraum
An eye opener ! Thank you, Sir
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
thanks for this explanation.
Omg this is totally surprising😮
Tq sir
Their is also child labour angle to rare earth metal mining.
Thank you sir,
I have been learning more new concepts by your videos
Always getting a different views on same topic
Thank U sir
❤️ Amit - very insightful, informative, and educational. Your resourcefulness is unparalleled 👍
Sir, please explain woke ideology and it’s impact on Bharat…🙏🏻
hope you guys are immune to this bull shittery called "woke ideology"... this is a society wrecker
Phenomenal Analysis..!!
thankyou for this video sir!
Thank you for sharing this information 🙏 😊
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
Very informative Amit. But can u elaborate more on why Germany is going green and taking power away from the Gov/Big businesses to operate nuclear power plants?
Angela Merkel, who put all these policies in place, was raised in East Germany (ie the Soviet Union). These green policies will destroy the German economy, taking with it the EU or will make Germany totally dependent on Russian gas. Ask yourself, just who was Angel Merkel working for?
nailed it sir,🙇♂🙏
Great explanation.
Sir please make videos on current affairs too, if you can🙏🙏. Love your content by the way
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
Sir, if possible please do mention about our Woke CJI in some of your videos - so that more people could take balanced stand [& be saved from west propaganda] bas court of contempt na lga den sb.
People in India are flattered by CJI's personality. Sad truth
This video was eye opening !!
Extraordinary explanation 👏🏻🙏🏻
"Mere ghar ke aas paas pollution nahi hona chahiye bas" ~ green economy logic
Amit sir : facts fek k maarunga saara activism nikal jayega....
Thank you Sir...your videos are extraordinarily fantastic and knowledgeable ❤🙏👏
As always amazing content. Learnt a whole new meaning for the word GREEN today!
This dud talks a lot without knowing half of it
Why do i say this? Simple.
about the pipeline i dont care.the USA always does what it wants and plays coy afterwards. But talking about the polution and problems that will come by changing enerysourse so careless is just a bunch of 💩💩💩 he is a efin ignorant!. Just take a second and think this over. If Germany is the biggest economy in Europe. It didnt Archive this goal out of luck. Germans calculate everthing! Analazing every posible outcome with hardfacts. The main reason Germany is leaving this energy plants is because of CO2. Thats is correct, but they wouldnt change it for something that is worse, leaving aside an entire working Infrastructure and undergoing all this problems. It makes me belive that this person is missleading on porpose with his half assed conclusions.
Put aside the term "green" call it what you want. But nuclear energy isnt clean/green/renewable,etc. Why? Simple, they produce nuclear waste which cant be disposed. It need to be stored away and this causes polution over entire regions for thousend of years!. (The region where is is stored). And if its properly stored.
I was never in favor of EVs, the damage you will do to produce those batteries and then charge the vehicle is huge, and still you will not get the performance of IC engines, Green Lobby can carry on their communist agenda or whatever XYZ agenda, but India should invest in Ethanol IC engines to replace petrol, and not madly go after EVs, also we need to reduce our dependency on Coal power plants, we are building new Nuke power plants which is good, but since we have immense potential for hydropower we should aggressively push for more Hydropower, and our Wind and Solar power programs can go side by side for additional power requirements, Offices, Schools, Factories all operate during the day, so Solar power will definitely help us
Govt works under foreign powers, so this wont happen.
In this universe nothing comes free. *Everything has its side effects*
Thank you very much - it's so true
Thanks Amit. I know little about environmmental and energy stuff and learnt a lot.
Geothermal would make more sense which us probably why they didn't go to it.
We cannot lay pipe in anywhere in this world and make geo-thermal plant , where ever
Well. Isn’t germany taking awful lot of risks by sticking out its neck for green energy? Even if the political angle is ignored for a moment, Germany doesn’t get as much solar energy as a tropical country. Wind energy is whimsical. Won’t this strap lead to energy shortages?
The political drivers in Germany are US-payed Agents. The US need all of the bigger german companies producing in USA, so they destroy german energy sources to force them into USA.
Germany has lost its brain.
Luckily tgey have money to spend billions and purchase power from nieghbours
One could argue that if Germany can make it work and maintain it's industrial edge -- then anyone can do it.
I dont think that's going to end up happening, however. Renewable energy systems become significantly more expensive to service and maintain as more energy storage mechanisms that are added to the system.
German manufacturing will likely move to other countries that utilize more energy dense energy sources.
Very informative thank you
Good analysis, Amrit! 👍🏼
They've gone mad.
Why does rapid innovation always need a war?
Yeah I think the Ans yes
Maybe
1. Everytime when innovation(s) leads to new weapons , people wants to try it practically,
Or
2. people just want to fight, even if there is any innovation or not , its just progress is a continuous thing
competition. becos the one that innovates first take over the sector
Again awesome lecture
Thanks for video so much, i have been arguing same since years with people around me. Now i can share this video to get clear picture about green energy
Hi শুভ নববর্ষ
বাংলাদেশ থেকে শুভ নববর্ষ
your videos are getting more and more aggressive !!!!
Nice..good information
To the point 100% pure knowledge 🇮🇳
No, lied about the blown gas pipe.
Beautifully explained.
Wow bang on !
Very insightful 👍
THE BEST EVER EXPLANATION YOU'LL EVER GET ANYWHERE ELSE IN THIS SHORT CLIP
Wow Nice presentation really informative...
How much sustainable is this so called green energy😏 The behind the scence of renewable energy is what im thinking lately, there's going to be too much chaos in the environment for the name of green energy ... Happy that you adress it in your video, Sir.
Great stuff indeed 👍
What a Crisp video. To the point
superb content.