@@madmelwood3778a continuation of what Blair started with his on the spot fines with no defence & futher destruction of our protection under the Magna Carta
@@gzl7657tg The whole case that painted Bailey as a racist was a sham. Syrian boy shouldn't have been here in the first place and shame on all those on TV who "made an example" of the British boy who was doing THE RIGHT THING (protecting his sister from someone who said was going to rape her) and showed amazing restraint (Bailey poured water over him. Syrian is not in hospital being spoon fed).
@@gzl7657tg Magistrates Swear to 2 Oaths The Superior BAR Guild & a Solemn Public Oath , Bar Guild Operates under Roman Law type in CANON 3228 scroll down to 12 Presumtions of Court explains it..
He was well over the top in misconstruing Alex's opening question, maybe he wanted to get on top as the big man in the room..But, once that ice had been crushed, he talked a whole lot of truth!!!
I have had a recent encounter with the court system, an employment tribunal, and the amount of money spent by parties involved, well me the defendant, and you the taxpayer, in preparation and prosecution, to arrive at a fairly modest settlement, was crazy. Fair play to the accuser, he represented himself and had mo legal fees.
Try living in a country town where half the population don't qualify for jury duty. Called up three times in six years. Thats what hard work and a clean record gets you.
@trainedmunkie Constitution Law To interfere with Our Constitution is High Treason as explained to Heath Sovereignty & Democracy belongs to The Sovereign People, Not Any Politician's or Government's & thereby by Definition an Act of Treason for Any that Do So..
I agree we need jury's. Judges can be crooked and they tend to go with government directions on sentencing and on political bases. We saw that in the summer when wrong talk online got you 3 years on the orders of Starmer.
I know a pensioner that got a year for shouting at the police. No violence or fighting he ended up doing 4 months. They stopped he’s benefits so he came out owing he’s rent. And they won’t back date it. All down to the traitor STARMER. Can’t stand him. He will get he’s karma soon. That’s a curse on him by very dangerous adepts.
@@douglastodd1947 Yes but if you plead not guilty you will not have the right to a Jury anymore and the Judge alone will decide your fate. This is wrong as it doesn't give you a fare hearing and can lead to corruption.
Totaly agree Alex,there was absolutely no need for such an aggressive response to your opening gambit.He treated you in a very condescending manner.Well held Miss Phillips.
@@tonyjones6062nonsense. Talk is known by the fact that its presenters are opinionated and apart from that, anyone has the right to an opinion about a topic like this because everyone DOES know at least a little about it. It's not a piece about brain surgery
my brother was a heroin addict he came from a family that tried everything to get him off them and he continued in the end he broke into my mums house and robbed her she prosecuted him and in prison was where he actually got clean THEY HAVE TO WANT TO CHANGE he did and He Did he became clean and remains so to this day
Barristers are causing alot of this too...dragging out cases that have no merit...constantly asking judges to adjourn trials( usually because the defence havent prepared cases) the list is endless...and yes i am qualified to state this
What a contentious, rude, belligerent barrister - albeit that he is correct. Alex was introducing him as the expert, no matter her remarks. Intelligent but foolish man!
Maybe instead of giving away money to solve other countries problems, they use this money to sort out all of our issues , like : social care, courts , mental health , ILLEGAL migration etc etc etc
Unfortunatley there are a lot of people who should be recieving mental health care but they closed down all the big mental health hospitals and opened small units that cant cope.
Called up for jury duty. Over an hour wasted picking the jury. Then those charged broke free in the 50m from the police station to the courthouse and it took an hour to round them up. Then once they had them in the courthouse one disappeared when he went to the toilet. Break for lunch. Then when the case started the prosecution pipes up with their main witness has been missing for months and they cannot find her. Case adjourned for six months. 60 citizens time totally wasted just so a couple of KCs that jetted in from 600km away could get paid for the day. Next time I got called up I went to work, and my company paid the fine.
There was no need for an aggressive attitude at the beginning, Alex had the right to ask and propose anything she likes, and he corrected her, but not in a respectful manner. Other than that, I agree with all his points..Brilliant...
Sorry, for once, I am on the side of the barrister here. Every citizen has the right to be tried by a jury; twelve of his/her peers. It is a fundamental right and enshrined in Law, as well as Common Law and our Constitution. As the KC says here, it is the inept administration of the Courts and the Court estate that is to blame - no organisation, no planning and no fear of losing your job if you preform poorly.
Chris Daw KC's attitude and rudeness towards Alex here is both unprofessional and unnecessary as well as being totally out of order. Very odd man. Don't invite him back on again.
you were told then alex this guy chris daw was not only good but he was right on everything... i have no faith on the ability of magistrates to administer good judgement on many cases as many of the ones i have seen struggle to stay awake and alert when evidence is presented
This truly is the last nail in the coffin. This country has really gone down the plug hole. And there is no turning back with another mad sceam added to the rest of mad sceams by this truly irritating government.
I am not sure what triggered that KC but what an absolute nob he is. There he is sitting most likely in his multimillion pound house claiming that he and the justice system needs more money. He seems like a particularly nasty sort of a man.
They shut alot of mental hospitals in 1967 i moved to one there was about 7 thousand patients in there now most of it now have been built on or alot has been made in to expensives flats most people with mental health problems are walking the streets
The problem with drug addicts and alcoholics is they commit CRIMES....so the police and courts deal with them as such. So, putting them in some rehab instead of prosecution means they get away with the crimes???
I've done jury service 2 times, if you cannot be bothered and want to leave early you just say guilty or not guilty. Everyine knows if you are deliberating and it's a Thursday afternoon you may not be needed another week. So sometimes jury results aren't thought about properly. Go with the flow to get out early.
Why would we need new buildings for trials without a jury? The way things have gone since the summer, having no jury would be a worry? Look at people getting locked up for minor social media posts
Firstly, my respect to Alex for holding her ground at the beginning of this interview, she was almost being cross examined from the moment she spoke! Wow. Fortunately matters didn’t go South and the KC got off his platform and spoke with common sense. I actually concur with what was said. The problem with “Quick Fixes” is, they’re not fit for purpose and tend to back fire in the medium to long term. Alex is passionate with her presentations and I respect very much this lady (Maybe another Iron Lady that’s not for tuning) Best
It was a 'snippy' reaction from the KC but with every good reason. If and when Alex Phillips doesn't know what she's talking about then she would be better advised not to spout her ill considered opinions to the watching masses.
Getting rid of a jury is absolutely insane
We're completely at the mercy of the state if we abolish trials by jury.
100% agree
Are you familiar with the CCP judicial process that's what it's modelled on
@Enough_Is_Enough_Official it's not in the british legal constitution
@@madmelwood3778a continuation of what Blair started with his on the spot fines with no defence & futher destruction of our protection under the Magna Carta
They Can't Abolish Trial by Jury Common Law Right under Our Constitution .
Tommy Robinson has suffered by not having a trial by jury
was he on a licence, at all?
No No No to Labour changing the rules again because it suits them. We are fast becoming a police state
Tommy Robinson didn’t get a jury ask why that happened, don’t bother I’ll tell you. He would have been freed and the establishment didn’t want that.
@waynebateman9440 Because He Didn't ask for 1 & His Solicitor Failed to Advise Him Off His Rights.
@@gzl7657tg Lol
@@gzl7657tg The whole case that painted Bailey as a racist was a sham. Syrian boy shouldn't have been here in the first place and shame on all those on TV who "made an example" of the British boy who was doing THE RIGHT THING (protecting his sister from someone who said was going to rape her) and showed amazing restraint (Bailey poured water over him. Syrian is not in hospital being spoon fed).
Dont commit crimes then
Isn't a jury an essential check and balance against an overbearing government?
No need for his attitude with our Alex but he is right in exactly what he's saying
Yes agree, we should always have the right to a Jury.
Think he was reacting to how ludicrous to even consider that Idea would be.
👍👍
YT is where we HOPE to get a smiggin of
truth, we do not need what some people THINK!!! I think Alex sometime is a 'bit snippy'!!!
Thankyou Sir! We need them to do their job and put things right.
agree with the barrister,recently we have seen how judges act as jury lately, i think some judges are the problem
I work as a Crown Court Clerk and what Chris Daw KC is saying is spot on.
@@gzl7657tg Magistrates Swear to 2 Oaths The Superior BAR Guild & a Solemn Public Oath , Bar Guild Operates under Roman Law type in CANON 3228 scroll down to 12 Presumtions of Court explains it..
He was well over the top in misconstruing Alex's opening question, maybe he wanted to get on top as the big man in the room..But, once that ice had been crushed, he talked a whole lot of truth!!!
I have had a recent encounter with the court system, an employment tribunal, and the amount of money spent by parties involved, well me the defendant, and you the taxpayer, in preparation and prosecution, to arrive at a fairly modest settlement, was crazy. Fair play to the accuser, he represented himself and had mo legal fees.
He should be a bit nicer to her though.
Well said this gentleman speaking the truth we do not want to loose our common rights
I thought that it was our right to have a jury of our peers. Another right hits the dust.
It is
Jury trials must stay as they are. Govts would love to see them go and judges
can we just point a finger at someone we dont like, and find them guilty ?
Try living in a country town where half the population don't qualify for jury duty. Called up three times in six years. Thats what hard work and a clean record gets you.
Good to hear somebody who knows exactly what they are talking about on this programme for once.
Keep using this guest, he's brilliant.
Hands up who trusts the state with no trial by jury?
@trainedmunkie Constitution Law To interfere with Our Constitution is High Treason as explained to Heath Sovereignty & Democracy belongs to The Sovereign People, Not Any Politician's or Government's & thereby by Definition an Act of Treason for Any that Do So..
I agree we need jury's. Judges can be crooked and they tend to go with government directions on sentencing and on political bases. We saw that in the summer when wrong talk online got you 3 years on the orders of Starmer.
I know a pensioner that got a year for shouting at the police. No violence or fighting he ended up doing 4 months. They stopped he’s benefits so he came out owing he’s rent. And they won’t back date it. All down to the traitor STARMER. Can’t stand him. He will get he’s karma soon. That’s a curse on him by very dangerous adepts.
@russcooke5671 Disgusting !! I've heard many similar stories. This government hates on it's own people.
@@russcooke5671 Disgusting. heard lots of similar stories like that. He's a traitor that's for sure.
People have the Right to Appeal, if Found Guilty & The Length of Sentence as Well under our Common Law
@@douglastodd1947 Yes but if you plead not guilty you will not have the right to a Jury anymore and the Judge alone will decide your fate. This is wrong as it doesn't give you a fare hearing and can lead to corruption.
👏 someone with a better sense. Well said. No dancing around your handbag there
we have 542000 civil servants, that's roughly 1 civil servant per 127 people in this country, we are drowning in beurocracy already
Like how he made a big point of telling her how he was the expert in his area, but then lectured her about how she should approach journalism ……🙄
Little D syndrome
He’s 100% right why is he not put in charge of this he knows the problems
Bent Political biased judges..... What could possibly go wrong.
At healthcare regulators, the regulators ( prosecutor)pay the 'jury'...if that isn't corrupt what is!!!!
👍👍
Totaly agree Alex,there was absolutely no need for such an aggressive response to your opening gambit.He treated you in a very condescending manner.Well held Miss Phillips.
She should think about her introductions carefully.
If you know nothing about a subject, don't offer an opinion one way or another.
@tonyjones60She did, but he took it as an attack.62
I've heard Chris Daw on Ian Collins' show many times and he would never, ever talk to Ian like this. He owes Alex an apology.
@@tonyjones6062nonsense. Talk is known by the fact that its presenters are opinionated and apart from that, anyone has the right to an opinion about a topic like this because everyone DOES know at least a little about it. It's not a piece about brain surgery
Oh grow up. Do you really he would mean if he apologised? Don't be naive.
my brother was a heroin addict he came from a family that tried everything to get him off them and he continued in the end he broke into my mums house and robbed her she prosecuted him and in prison was where he actually got clean THEY HAVE TO WANT TO CHANGE he did and He Did he became clean and remains so to this day
That was like attaching a diffuser to a hair dryer 😂 well held Phillips
Btw I'm bald, where did that come from 😂
@@ianparkin7053😅😅😅 that was funny
@@barbaraallen435 😋
He is 100% correct.
Barristers are causing alot of this too...dragging out cases that have no merit...constantly asking judges to adjourn trials( usually because the defence havent prepared cases) the list is endless...and yes i am qualified to state this
This lad came for a fight!
The Pugnacious Barrister. I wonder if he defends gangsters.
@fabiennemitchell2371 wonder if he has his finger in the 'human rights' pie
His entire demeanour shows it too
@@fabiennemitchell2371yea t Robinson
Barristers should wear a mask, the amount they charge.......not a wig.
I've heard Chris Daw on Ian Collins' show many times and he would never, ever talk to Ian like this. He owes Alex an apology.
Oi leave our Alex alone. She invited you on. Manners
NO one should submit to these new kangaroo courts: trial by jury is an essential bastion of our freedom
What a contentious, rude, belligerent barrister - albeit that he is correct. Alex was introducing him as the expert, no matter her remarks. Intelligent but foolish man!
He's too argumentative! Smartarse.
Alright buddy who stole jam from your donought
Chris is right.fair trial by a jury of my piers.
Therefore abolish healthcare regulators!!!!!
Alex didn’t see that coming but some good points were made.
Also, despite Starmer heading the CPS, he shows yet again he hasn’t got a clue.
Arrogant , pompous , overpaid , self serving , slimy etc etc . 😠🏴
I like alex but her opening statement was a bit blonde and flippant, to this man's job words really do matter
Agree, no need to be rude, arrogant twat
Why has Tommy Robinson not had his right to a jury trial ?
Because he pleaded guilty of contempt of court keep up.
@MrAP79 Lol. Ian m talking about every trial he has ever had. Keep up dafty! Lol.
@@MrAP79 I am talking about every trial he has had , keep up d@fty.
Starmer loves to change rules and laws to suit his needs
Maybe instead of giving away money to solve other countries problems, they use this money to sort out all of our issues , like : social care, courts , mental health , ILLEGAL migration etc etc etc
At last! Someone who stands up for justice for everyone and tells the truth.
That guys always been a bit of a nasty one.
Unfortunatley there are a lot of people who should be recieving mental health care but they closed down all the big mental health hospitals and opened small units that cant cope.
Gosh, he's a very aggressive man. 😵💫
@julieasplen She putting His Profession under Threat by stating Abolishing Jury's is a good idea.
Unlike you, he is somebody who knows what he is talking about!
Called up for jury duty. Over an hour wasted picking the jury. Then those charged broke free in the 50m from the police station to the courthouse and it took an hour to round them up. Then once they had them in the courthouse one disappeared when he went to the toilet. Break for lunch. Then when the case started the prosecution pipes up with their main witness has been missing for months and they cannot find her. Case adjourned for six months. 60 citizens time totally wasted just so a couple of KCs that jetted in from 600km away could get paid for the day. Next time I got called up I went to work, and my company paid the fine.
We should be working on prevention and reduction of crime , not just making sure we have enough prisons. We need to address the problems behind crime!
There shouldnt be political prisoners. That was unjust and vile by this government.
There was no need for an aggressive attitude at the beginning, Alex had the right to ask and propose anything she likes, and he corrected her, but not in a respectful manner.
Other than that, I agree with all his points..Brilliant...
He came for a fight the fool
Bless, judges won't sit beacuase the heating doesn't work. Put a coat on like pensioners have to do and get on with it.
Common law needs brought inn.
How about not letting criminals out early to reoffend. again and again
If they have addiction problems they ARE going to offend again and again. How about an approach which focuses on the problem, not the symptoms?!
Rude man
Sorry, for once, I am on the side of the barrister here.
Every citizen has the right to be tried by a jury; twelve of his/her peers. It is a fundamental right and enshrined in Law, as well as Common Law and our Constitution.
As the KC says here, it is the inept administration of the Courts and the Court estate that is to blame - no organisation, no planning and no fear of losing your job if you preform poorly.
I think he's mum forgot to buy him christmas presents this year..
We have seen recently that some of the judiciary has been captured.
Was Tommy Robinson not allowed a Jury but sent before a Judge of the Islamic faith?
I think this man has anger problems
What an unpleasant man! Of course you can do away with juries. It works in other countries very well.
Chris Daw KC's attitude and rudeness towards Alex here is both unprofessional and unnecessary as well as being totally out of order. Very odd man. Don't invite him back on again.
he's a liberal lawyer wouldn't be surprised if he drinks with kier
Ego as big as the backlog 😂
Get BBB on next time
I've heard Chris Daw on Ian Collins' show many times and he would never, ever talk to Ian like this. He owes Alex an apology.
@@oldshiny3012 😂😂
Love it when Alex get wound up, it when she's at her best!! She has the last word though 🎉
Dude, chill with the lady.
you were told then alex this guy chris daw was not only good but he was right on everything... i have no faith on the ability of magistrates to administer good judgement on many cases as many of the ones i have seen struggle to stay awake and alert when evidence is presented
This is half the problem with KC’s arrogance!
Sorry Alex, love you but he’s right on this one. That doesn’t excuse his aggressive manner one bit.
This truly is the last nail in the coffin. This country has really gone down the plug hole. And there is no turning back with another mad sceam added to the rest of mad sceams by this truly irritating government.
Yes he should learn some manners and respect.
Alex should learn some manners. At the beginning she came across very arrogant and finished with the same tone.
I am not sure what triggered that KC but what an absolute nob he is. There he is sitting most likely in his multimillion pound house claiming that he and the justice system needs more money. He seems like a particularly nasty sort of a man.
Standard Bully
He thinks he is bigger n better than the general public.
Cut from the same cloth as that cockwomble Starmer
What a great guest! 👏😀👍
They shut alot of mental hospitals in 1967 i moved to one there was about 7 thousand patients in there now most of it now have been built on or alot has been made in to expensives flats most people with mental health problems are walking the streets
She didn’t say it was a good idea she said it SEEMs like good idea (on the face of it)
AGREE, HE'S UP HIS OWN ASS
He's an arrogant git.
He was right you said it was a good idea this man knows what he is talking about. Leave the Court's to the people who know what they are doing.
Do you have to be so arrogant Mr Barrister,you maybe right ,but is that part of your training to be so bloody rude ,
Tommy Robinson doesn’t even get a jury. Why aren’t you mentioning that please wake up?
I thought it was a right to have a jury. The judges have proven they are biased and woke, a jury is a safeguard against this.
He didn’t need to be so hostile to get his point across, he could have just politely addressed the issues at the start of the conversation
Bang on, english constitution says we are all entitled to trial by jury!
Alex got a bit too defensive and upset when she was (rightly) called out.
I thought she handled it very well.
This barrister is arrogant and pa. Why is he throw his toys out of his pram??
The barrister was absolutely right in what he said apart from the first few minutes when he was unnecessarily aggressive and confrontational 🥴
That was just not very gentlemanly- then again these days I’m never surprised- he wanted a fight before she opened her mouth.
That told her!! It almost shut her up!!! 😂
Never allow them to take away your rights of a jury where they make the decision not the judge which theyve done illegally at magistrates
The problem with drug addicts and alcoholics is they commit CRIMES....so the police and courts deal with them as such. So, putting them in some rehab instead of prosecution means they get away with the crimes???
This woman is fab... This bloke knew he'd be in for a bumpy ride from the get-go, that's why he so 'defensive'. Brilliant!!
Bloody hell I wouldn’t want that barrister defending me 🥴
I've done jury service 2 times, if you cannot be bothered and want to leave early you just say guilty or not guilty. Everyine knows if you are deliberating and it's a Thursday afternoon you may not be needed another week. So sometimes jury results aren't thought about properly. Go with the flow to get out early.
Sign the pledge
Nasty man🥺
Why would we need new buildings for trials without a jury? The way things have gone since the summer, having no jury would be a worry? Look at people getting locked up for minor social media posts
He argues with himself everyday
He looks and behaves more like a bricklayer's mate than a KC.
Another part of the public service thats working perfectly. 😂😂😂
He was a bit prickly!
Firstly, my respect to Alex for holding her ground at the beginning of this interview, she was almost being cross examined from the moment she spoke! Wow.
Fortunately matters didn’t go South and the KC got off his platform and spoke with common sense.
I actually concur with what was said.
The problem with “Quick Fixes” is, they’re not fit for purpose and tend to back fire in the medium to long term.
Alex is passionate with her presentations and I respect very much this lady (Maybe another Iron Lady that’s not for tuning)
Best
This man seems to be very unpleasant,he just wants to be antagonistic.
Alex this guy is right. Take note.
Yes, the Barrister is correct but his manner was wholly unnecessary.
@@fabiennemitchell2371Exactly.
It was a 'snippy' reaction from the KC but with every good reason. If and when Alex Phillips doesn't know what she's talking about then she would be better advised not to spout her ill considered opinions to the watching masses.