Will Trump's 'take over' Gaza plan work? | The Daily T
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2025
- Can Trump Make Gaza Great Again?
Even by Donald Trump’s standards, it’s pretty out there.
During a visit by Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu to Washington, the President declared that he wanted the US to “take over” the Gaza Strip, resettling the almost two million Palestinians who live there to build what he called the “Riviera of the Middle East”.
Kamal and Camilla ask Middle East analyst Sanam Vakil whether Trump’s desire to add Gaza to his property development portfolio is even possible, and what it could mean for regional politics.
Plus, Kamal was at the press conference held by the families of the Nottingham attack victims. It came on the day NHS England released a report into the myriad of failings by a myriad of authorities during the treatment of Valdo Calocane in the years leading up to his sickening attack.
I cannot believe what I’m hearing
They cut the part when he dropped the bombshell when he in straight face explained he want to own Gaza permanent
I don’t believe this! But I know that at one time Palestinians were given some loan in Egypt. . Found out they don’t want peace. They just kept fighting Egypt kicked them out because Palestinians and Hama don’t want peace
Why? Whats wrong with floating solutions. Whats yours?
This Telegraph session is a disaster in making Trump’s words legitimate in argument. These two have crossed the line in a thousand ways
If is sthe Tominey fool is so happy with Trump's idea, why doesn't advocate for Trump relocate all the Israelis to Arizona?
this is crazy but as an American I'm embarrassed by it. this is a terrible idea i dont want to go to war with these people or be responsible for this land
Don't worry, I don't believe it will happen, I think Trump was only trying to get people in the region to start figuring out a permanent solution to the problem.
Would Camilla be so cavalier about ethnic cleansing jews? I think not
Make America Great Again - ? where is Gaza in that statement, its citizens are also victims, pray humanity can stop the fighting. But keep the usa the fck out!
He doesn't do anything unless it will line his own pocket.
Trump is checking out Palestinians from his Gaza golf ⛳️ club
Trump is just another clown 🤡
The key factor that is being ignored here (by Trump, Kamal and Camila) is the right of the Palestinians to be Palestinians.
If my house is bombed out, I would very much welcome living elsewhere until my house is rebuilt, but I don't want to lose my British citizenship.
Besides that, Egypt and Jordan already have surplus populations. A big proportion of both countries is uninhabitable. Trump's proposal would've made sense if he had offered refuge to Palestinians in the US.
There is no right to a nation state. Had the americans lost the war of independence there would be no United States. Had the Haitian revolution not happened there would be no country of Haiti. Had Israel lost the 1948 war there would not be an Israel. Taiwan does yet have the right to be a state neither does Northern Ireland or Scotland or the Basque territory etc. It's a complete accident of history why some peoples have states and others do not. The Jewish people could have used a state for 1,000 years and it only materialized in the last century after a holocaust and expulsion of Jews from the arab world and there has been 77 years of conflict. The reality is right now there is no Palestinian state and mostly there will not be one in our lifetimes.
Netanyahu evil smile give me chills
why is it evil
@andrewromanowski3789 open your eyes
Telegraph telegraphing the glory of a dictator. Shame.
Finally, a intelligent conversation.
Satire I hope
America: we knew he was once a real estate developer, we didn't think he would prolapse the fact all over the most sensitive territorial dispute in the world.
That has to be a contender for the stupidest question I ever heard.
He's looking to get into middle Eastern property in four years time 😤
He doesn't have the time for it poor senial old timer
Waah waah cry harder.
@ 🔫🔫🪵
@ 🔫🔫🪵
@ dye wood
The question is not "will he". It's "when"
No
Couldn’t this man keep his mouth shut at least until all the hostages have been released.
What difference does that make?
He and his real estate thugs would move in to Gaza and sell it back to Gazans, obviously.
That’s the first guy running in a fight.
Americans are warriors.
Americans are not warriors, they are Idiots, they voted for Trump the Felon. He wants to make money on the backs of everyone else.
The problem is that in this stage neither Israel nor so called Palestinians want two states solution. President Trump's proposition is probably the best for all.
It is interesting, if a Jewish person whose ancestors have lived in England, Russia or Iran for 2000 years, decides to immigrate to Israel, he can be called an Israeli.
But a Palestinian whose ancestors have lived in Palestine/Israel for 2000 years and has no intention of emigrating, cannot be called a Palestinian. He's a "so called Palestinian".
UNWRA; "we provide assitance and protection for registered Palestine refugees". Gazans: We will never leave Gaza, this is our home, this is our land, we would rather die to stay in Gaza than be relocated elsewhere". Well, which is it? Refugees or native Gazans?
I'm not pro trump really but it's being inflated.. he didnt say resettle them permanently people dont seem to understand it's impossible physically to rebuild all the rubbel in a reasonable time for people not to have some solution... and the fact none of them can leave atm is absolutely sick. all he said is those who want to leave can .
Why would the UK help rebuild AzaG with Hummus still there? They’ll just start another wire and the Strip will be destroyed again. Starmer is a fool.
Because they love hummus with carrot sicks
Will Americans have a new Joker in the White House after the old man who mad a mess of Gaza
Sorry that was done a couple hundred years ago in a region that never has peace.
I voted for Trump, but I totally totally disagree with the USA having anything to do with the management and paying for any kind of rebuilding of Gaza!!’ When he ran for president, he ran on getting the wars and hostages back, but Israel should rebuild because they and Hamas blew it up! Hamas in Qatar can pay for the rebuilding or half of it!! Trump is a builder guy and he can probably get people he knows to build it cheaper and faster, etc. etc.. I just do not want the US government and probably anybody in the US military managing Gaza
Etc…😊
Everybody relax
Its a bargaining strategy
People are loosing their mind
And obviously don't give a dam about the palestinian ordinary people well being
Can trump make Greater Israel Again Is The Real Question
Well literally no other solution in that area has been found for decades. Its an interesting concept and would bring peace to the ME. However he will be mocked until the day he will be proved right yet again.
“Yet again” 🤣🤣he hasn’t been proved right before
@@Bundysvideos Borders. Trade. Deportations. Eliminating government waste. Drilling. No tip tax. Considering no income tax for Americans. Illegals crime rate. Peace negotiations.
@@JustDucky-d9k your just literally saying right wing talking points and saying he wasn’t right about them… your not even explaining how he was right about those things lol
Have they tried giving Palestinians equal rights and their land back? No? Then they haven't tried everything
@ Yes many times. Its not about the land dim bulb.
Kamal doing his best to quote zionist talking points
There is a church in Gaza City that is over 800 years old. After October 7th, two women from that congregation were shot by an IDF sniper while they were trying to get to the toilet at their church. Tent of Nations Farm in the West Bank has been owned by a family of Christians for over 100 years. What happened to the Village of Emmaus after 1967? Do Christians in other parts of the world respect the land rights of Christians living in the Middle East? Watch the film "The Stones Cry Out".
This is ridiculous there are 200,000 Christians in Israel, but almost none in the Palestinian-controlled territories and the reason isn’t Israel the persecution and discrimination they face under Palestinian rule, which goes ignored just like the rest of the atrocities committed by Muslims.
They are right, the two state solution, as it has long been proposed, is dead. It died on the 7th of October 2023. A new solution is needed, and thinking outside the box is how it will be acheived. Trump's proposal is just the first step on that journey.
The 2 state solution died decades ago because all presidents since Carter have de facto opposed it.
Gaza a resort for the megarich a bright shining star in the Middle East? What happened to Dubai?
It was Great before the creation of Israel
Great open minded conversation. Well done
This woman should read Haaratz as she is so ignorant.
Good to hear some common sense commentary from this channel.
So yes, deal with those millions today or prepare housing and food for double the number in 20 years. In Gaza that would make the 6 generation of 9nbreeding in a closed off population.
I don't know if Trump's idea has legs, but it's not as mad as 1) expecting 1.8 million people to live in a building site for 20 years while it's decontaminated and rebuilt, 2) Allowing this conflict to continue forever, which is what Hamas have promised. Let's face it, if Palestinians had rejected conflict and not elected Hamas in 2006 Gaza could be a prosperous, peaceful Riviera today instead of a terrorist-infested smoking wreck.
100% agree
Again with the “master stroke” garbage. SMH.
Well he is very rich and a powerful man, so....
So what.is your plan for Gaza? Atleast Trump has.
I can't listen to this.
Other worl 4:49 leaders..? There sre no other leaders in the world.
No! They did not do a deal. The agreements, except for a slight adjustment, had already been done. Get the toffee out of your mouth!
So many cant believe those - serious inhuman actions - happening the last decades -- day by day !
And so many stupid comments 🎉
He can do it.
Controversial but brilliant! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
It's laughable is what it is
Wishful thinking...
He has no balls all flap
Seriously? A few hundred million ppl worldwide disagree.
@@JustDucky-d9k👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Ask gazans and not hamas - they will be happy to leave.
Master host...
The most balanced take I heard, and I've been around! Great job!
He is a clown
Hmm. Billionaire and president of the most powerful country on earth. Who's the clown really?
@@JustDucky-d9k💯💯💯💯💯👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
WAY TO GO TRUMP🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Whos this lacky
this indicates how advance trump thinks and other minds are left far behind.
Trump is based