When Rafi Saheb proved to be Alexander, Kishore Da's destiny lagged behind
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- मोहम्मद रफी साहब और किशोर कुमार के चाहने वालों का जब भी मुकाबला होता है तो मुकद्दर का सिंकदर फिल्म का जिक्र ज़रूर आता है...क्योंकि ये एक ऐसी फिल्म है जिसमें एक ही गाने को रफी साहब ने भी गाया है और किशोर कुमार ने भी गाया है...
फिल्म में अमिताभ बच्चन के डेथ सीन में जब रफी साहब की आवाज़ में गाना बजता है...तो आज भी दुनिया के कारोबार से मन उचट सा जाता है...और सुनने वाला एक तरह के शून्य में चला जाता है...अमिताभ बच्चन...विनोद खन्ना और राखी के इस भावुक सीन में जैसे ही मोहम्मद रफी साहब की आवाज़ गूंजती है...तो दर्शकों की आंखों का कोना गीला होने लगता है...
एक ही गाना दो सिचुएशन में दो अलग अलग गायक गा रहे हैं...जब किशोर कुमार बहुत खूबसूरती से ये गाना पहले ही रिकॉर्ड कर चुके थे तो दुख भरे सीन में केवल एक अंतरा मोहम्मद रफी साहब से क्यों गवाना पड़ा...ये सवाल निश्चित रूप से आपके मन में भी उठ रहे होंगे...तो आज हम बात करेंगे इसी सुपरहिट गाने की...तो इस वीडियो में आखिरी तक बने रहिए हमारे साथ...
Whenever there is a competition between the fans of Mohammad Rafi Sahab and Kishore Kumar, the mention of the film Muqaddar Ka Sikander definitely comes... because this is a film in which the same song has been sung by Rafi Sahab and Kishore Kumar. Has sung...
In the film, in the death scene of Amitabh Bachchan, when a song is played in the voice of Rafi Saheb... even today one gets disillusioned with the business of the world... and the listener goes into a kind of void... Amitabh As soon as Mohammed Rafi Sahab's voice resonates in this emotional scene of Bachchan, Vinod Khanna and Rakhi, the corners of the audience's eyes start getting wet...
Same song is being sung by two different singers in two situations...when Kishore Kumar had already recorded this song very beautifully then why did Mohammed Rafi Saheb have to sing only one Antara in a sad scene...this question Surely this must be arising in your mind also... So today we will talk about this superhit song... So stay with us till the end in this video...
#filmhistory #evergreensong #hindicinema #hindisong #hindistories #musicdirector #puranegane #rafi #rafihits #bollywoodgossips #kishorekumar #kishorekumarsongs #kishore #mukaddarkasikanddar #amitabhbachchan #amitabh #amitabhbacchan #vinodkhanna #vinodkhannasongs #rafikishor
*नमस्कार दोस्तो, MALAY MONARCH एक ऐसा TH-cam channel है, जहाँ पर हम bollywood से जुड़े बहुत interesting and informative video लेकर आते हैं, तो दोस्तों आज ही हमारे चैनल MALAY MONARCH को subscribe करें।
*नोट हमारे द्वारा दी गयी सारी जानकारी इंटरनेट, WhatsApp, Facebook etc. से ली जाती इसलिए MALAY MONARCH इसके सही होने या फिर गलत होना का दावा नहीं करता।
धन्यवाद
*purpose under fair use. Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use."
*IF ANY COPYRIGHT OWNER FIND THEIR CONTENT IN MY VIDEO THEN PLEASE KINDLY CONTACT ME BEFORE GIVING STRIKE OR DO SOMETHING, EITHER I WILL REMOVE MY VIDEO OR WILL GIVE YOU CREDIT.’
malaypalash@gmail.com
रोते हुए आते हैं सब, हंसता हुआ जो जाएगा
वो मुक़द्दर का सिकन्दर जानेमन कहलाएगा
वो सिकन्दर क्या था ज़िसने ज़ुल्म से जीता ज़हां
प्यार से जीते दिलों को वो झुका दे आसमां
जो सितारों पर कहानी प्यार की लिख जाएगा
वो मुक़द्दर का सिकन्दर...
ज़िन्दगी तो बेवफ़ा है एक दिन ठुकराएगी
मौत महबूबा है अपने साथ लेकर जाएगी
मर के जीने की अदा जो दुनिया को सिखलाएगा
वो मुक़द्दर का सिकन्दर...
हमने माना ये ज़माना दर्द की जागीर है
हर कदम पे आँसुओं की इक नई ज़ंजीर है
साज्-ए-ग़म पर जो खुशी के गीत गाता जाएगा
वो मुक़द्दर का सिकन्दर...
रोते हुए आते हैं सब, हंसता हुआ जो जाएगा
वो मुक़द्दर का सिकन्दर जानेमन कहलाएगा
rote hue aate hai.n sab, ha.nsataa huaa jo jaaegaa
vo muqaddar kaa sikandar jaaneman kahalaaegaa
vo sikandar kyaa thaa zisane zulm se jiitaa zahaa.n
pyaar se jiite dilo.n ko vo jhukaa de aasamaa.n
jo sitaaro.n par kahaanii pyaar kii likh jaaegaa
vo muqaddar kaa sikandar...
zindagii to bevafaa hai ek din Thukaraaegii
maut mahabuubaa hai apane saath lekar jaaegii
mar ke jiine kii adaa jo duniyaa ko sikhalaaegaa
vo muqaddar kaa sikandar...
hamane maanaa ye zamaanaa dard kii jaagiir hai
har kadam pe aa.Nsuo.n kii ik naI za.njiir hai
saaza-e-gham par jo khushii ke giit gaataa jaaegaa
vo muqaddar kaa sikandar...
rote hue aate hai.n sab, ha.nsataa huaa jo jaaegaa
vo muqaddar kaa sikandar jaaneman kahalaaegaa
RAFI SAHAB ARJUN KI TARAH MACHLI NAHI DIKHTA THA BALKI MACHLI KI AANKH KO DEKHA ,4 LINE NE WOHI KAM KIYA ,USTAD KI PEHCHAN EK HARKAT SE HO JATI HAIN JAI RAFI SAHAB 🎉🎉🎉🎉
bhaisahab, ye singing hai, naa ke nishanebaaji hai.
Even ten kishoredas are no match to great shree rafiji
@rajkumarsaab5659 good joke bhaisahab.
@@rajkumarsaab5659Who the hell are you to compare Kishore da and rafi sahab? get our from your small well, and try to taste the whole ocean means except of comparison, listen both and enjoy and don't share your foolishness in comments 😂😂
@@gauravmaitra sorry boss can't help to ease your burns after all truth is bitter infact after doing lot of research the number is even more then ten like I stated it earlier mere pyaare bharatmata ki shaan kaun h ? Shree rafiji h har eik true music lover ke Dil ki dhadkan Kaun h ? Shree rafiji h complete singer Kaun h ? Sirf Shree rafiji h
Beshak sad virsion is best but kishor Kumar sb. bhi behtreen singer rahe hain
I remember back in 1979 when this Rafi Sb sad version came at the end..people use get very sad & tears in eyes.. Rafi sb had such charismatic voice that use to make people sad, romantic, happy & many more moods..
Mere rafi sahab khuda ka naik banda he usse aage Koi nhi
sirf tera rafi.
kishore pure world me chhaya huwa hai.
kishore greatest, incomparable always
JUST LIKE HATHI MERA SATHI ,NAFRAT KI DUNIYA RAFI PROOFS THAT HE IS SUPREME
From 1970 to 1987,Kishore was supreme.
that was just help for rafi since he was totally helpless due to no calls from music directors.
kishore so great,and real so helpfull he told music director and gave rafi chance to sing this song.
and this song is so great then why music director, producer did not give all the songs to rafi?
kishore itna mahaan our farishta tha.
@vedantyadav1752 rafi sahab? kaheka saheb?
ek entertainer thats it, we all spend money frm our pocket and listen singer on radio cd cassette s then these singers get "roti"
anyway kishore was farishta who helped rafi and gave some songs to rafi 67/68 onwards when music directors stop calling rafi.
if rafi great then kishore greatest undoubtedly.
there will be thousands of rafi but not a single kishore in coming 10thousand years my friend.
@vedantyadav1752 untrained kishore???? dominated rafi then whats the useless training nulla rafi got??
bkj kishore's voice quality, feel,expressions which is neither taught nor learned, its called real art and ultimate talent, which rafi cannot get in another seven bearths.
kishore is kishore and only kishore.
no personal bhaisahab.
khush raho.
@@vedantyadav00 my friend, we are not interested in history, even all music lovers and music listeners only enjoy music
and to enjoy music it should be melodious, and sweet and it should appeal feel expressions point of view.
in all these factors, there is no better singer than kishore, mukesh
and lata asha ultimate level of singing.
rafi is good, i m fan of rafi also.
kindly dont say bengali or any people, and avoid to discriminate.
kishore is greatest among all, entire world knows it, there are no two ways about it.
and what you like is your choice, but when it comes to comparison, kishore is unmatched, incomparable, exceptional in all aspects of music and lata asha on the top of the world.
khush raho dost.
Are zanab Rafi Sahab ki aawaz Khuda ki aawaz.hai ..
Jai ho Rafi Sahab wah wah
Woow Rafi sahab took the sad version to another world. Marvelous, Full of emotions. No words for this song by greatest singer of the world, legendary Rafi sahab.
I❤love rafi sahab
Rafi sahab jaisa koi nhi na koi aayga
@@vedantyadav00 bkj kishore is miles ahead of rafi.
First Rafis voice was incomparable. Second, he was THE ONLY COMPLETE SINGER.
Md may be a singer but not a play back singer
Kishore is miles ahead of Rafi in this song.
@@royrou6207 not only this song, but kishore all songs far better than rafi.
kishore ke samne rafi looks very ordinary.
kishore voice quality ek hero ki awaz, ek mard ki awaz. rafi pichkoo voice quality..
kishore's feel expressions ultimate.
rafi either overfeel or no expressions ar all.
kishore jaisa naa koi huwa naa hoga.
@vedantyadav1752 i think you are the one chutya drvd's fan??
kishore ia always on the top of the world.
rafi just nulla in front of kishore.
kishore is an excellent, unmatched, incomparable and exceptional singer in all aspects of music.
1to 10 kishore then perhaps rafi and all undoubtedly and unarguably.
Male or female rafi sahab was the best singer for ever✌
Kuch bhi...70s me Kishoreda king of Bollywood
@@sundersharma4857 not for you but for entire world kishore is on top unarguably and undoubtedly.
Lata and Asha were excellent. Do not underestimate them. Rafi can never yodle mind you while Kishoreda was master.
@sundersharma4857 lata asha ke samne rafi pani kum hai.
duets me always lata asha far superior than rafi.
and kishore ultimate.
Rafi sahab ki awaz to apne aap me sureela sangeet hai. Rafi sahab ko music instruments ki zarurat nahi hoti thi. Issiliye sad version unse gawaya gaya thaa. Yeh baat aik sangeetkaar hi samajh sakta hai. Kishorda bhi mahan gayak theey but unki awaz sangeet ki mohtaj thi. Rafi sahab ki awaz duniya me sabse madhur awaz hai gayki ke kshetra me. Aajtak itni madhur aur sureeli awaz fir nhi huyi kisi ki. Rafi sahab ke saath hi hindi cinema ka sureela bharteey sangeet bhi vida ho gaya. Ab to sirf western music ki chhap hai aajkal ke gano me.
Respected sir mai koi singer ko chota nehi korunga.all time great singer rafi saheb aisa mithas awaz bollywood me kobhi nehi ayega.rafi saheb past, present& future.pl.f.back
Totally disagree with you.Kishorekumar is the best,was the best and will remain the best
Kya Aasha Bhosle ka Muqabla Lata Mangeshkar se hosakta hai ??????
Wahi Cheez yahn lagu hiti hai
RAFI sahab ek alag Quality k malik hain unke aagay koi nahi unke piche koi nahi
Jise sangit ka thoda bhi samajh ho use samajh aya hoga rafi sahab ka varjan jyada achha tha ya fir kishore da ka achha tha muje to to rafi sahab ka hi achha laga bhai
परम आदरणीय, सम्मान्निये, स्वर सम्राट, तीन सप्तक तक गाने वाली अतुल्ये आवाज़ के मालिक, अजर अमर गायक श्रीमन्त श्री रफ़ी साहब को हार्दिक अभिनन्दन...
Mohd Rafi sahab ne jo gaya lajawab tha Kishore ki awaz mein bas thik tha geet lakin zayada khobsorat Rafi sahab ne Gaya
Rafi Sahab is the greatest singer forever !!!!!🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Rafi and Kishore both are legend in their own unique style of singing and infact they were good friends. So why some people compare between two great legends. Just listen to their evergreen songs and enjoy it.
Both were great singers but the bottom line is Shree rafiji was miles away from the rest
Rafi was best in 60's and Kishore was best in 70's. Kishore won 8 best singing awards, where as Rafi won 6 awards. So in 70' Kishore was more famous and popular than Rafi.
But still overall as usual rafiji shall always remain best
Shree rafiji had already been honoured with the award of best singer of the millennium by hero Honda in conjunction with stardust in the year ,2001
While Shree rafiji was alive it was like Shree rafiji six awards kishoreda Three awards the other awards Kishoreds got was after the passing away of of his as well as our Guruji Shree rafiji
Your video content excellent Rafi Kishore both have respect to each other Kishore crying for Rafi when Rafi sahab expired although they always discussed about song when they are working for duet song about 75 duet they had sang long live Rafi Kishore
Both versions could have easily sung by Rafi.
If both version could have been sung easily Rafi saab try to sing both version you will ultimately come to know which version is difficult to sing and to match voice for bachan sir than only give coment
Not at all
घटिया मज़ाक था।
To unse kiyou nehi gevaya geya, kishoreda ki aavaz ek dehad thi
Both are legend but mohd Rafi all time greatest singer this man deserves Bharat Ratna award
Kishore deserves Bharat Ratna
No, only Rafi deserves Bharat Ratna and no-one else.
@@VinodKumar-ee4ok
I have never heard your name as a great singer,a great music director or a great music specialist.
No matter,carry on with your self publicity.
किशोर कुमार और मुहम्मद रफी का मुकाबला मत किया करो दोनो गायको का अपना-अपना हिन्दी फिल्म संगीत मे बहुत जबर्दस्त है दोनो मेरे अत्यंत प्रिय गायक है
जो कुछ आप बता रहे हैं ये सिर्फ किवदंती है इस घटना का सच्चाई से कोई लेना देना नहीं है
ये गाना रफी साहब से इसलिए गवाया गया था क्योंकि कल्याणजी आनंदजी विनोद खन्ना के लिए अलग आवाज़ चाहते थे, और ये गीत आज 11/01/2024 तक उतना फेमस नहीं है जितना किशोर दा वाला वर्जन
ये वीडियो सिर्फ इसलिए बनाया गया है ताकि ये साबित कर सको की रफी साहब ज्यादा अच्छे गायक थे
आज की युवा पीढ़ी सबसे ज्यादा किशोर दा के गीत ही सुनती है
यहां तक कि स्कूल के बच्चे भी
रफी साहब तो तभी आउट ऑफ़ फ्रेम हो जाते यदि 1969 तक किशोर दा ये फालतू की जिद नहीं करते कि वो अपने और देव आनंद के आलावा किसी और के लिए नहीं गायेंगे
तुम बिन जाउ कहा भूल गए
जिंदगी एक सफर है सुहाना
गीत भी इन दोनों ने एक साथ गए हैं
हमारे जमाने में भी पुराना स्लो स्पीड सेड गीत यदि सबसे ज्यादा सुना जाता है तो वो है शोले का ये "दोस्ती हम नहीं तोड़ेंगे" का सेड वर्जन
जबकि आप जिस गाने को अति महान बता रहे हैं ये गाना कोई नहीं सुनता
इसलिए किशोर दा की बराबरी आज 11/01/2024 तक भी कोई नहीं कर सकता
😂😂😂😂😂
Dono hi mahan te kishor da khud rafi sb ke fan te apni apni pasand hi kisi ko bada our chota batana thik nahi
Bhai last wala song pasanad he mujhe jo bahut gehrai se gaya huwa he ab kisne gaya mujhe nhi pata jo last me hota he movie ke
देखिये जनाब किशोर कुमार की ज़िद नहीं थी बल्कि उनकी बदकिस्मती थी कि देव आनंद और सचिन देव बर्मन के अलावा 50 और 60 के दशक में कोई उनको भाव नहीं देता था और ये बात हकीकत है।
Rafi ki support sirf ek tarfa log hi Jada karte hai dhyan dijiyega...lekin woh log hi Ghar me Kishoreda ke gaane hi sunte honge Jada...woh log jante hai agar Rafi ki support nehi Kiya Gaya to log Rafi ko bhula denge...kaha Kishoreda or kaha Rafi... Kishoreda ke voice far far better hai kisi bhi singer se...koi compare nehi ho sakta...hazaro classical singers bukha mar rahe hai, kuch kar nehi pa rahe hai...keuke unlogo ke pass Kishoreda jaisa voice nehi hai... voice hi main hota hai nehi to Kumar Sanu jaisa ek sadharan singer No.1 nehi ban jata...
Both great singers
Rafi and Kishore
No compare
no, kishore is unmatched. no comparison with kishore.
rafi is not only in race.
Kishor da jaise bhi hon per great to hohi gaye kionke unko is layek to samjha gaya ke u he kuch log best singer rafi sb se tulna karne yogya samjha yehi mahanta kam he? Ye to we log bhi jante hen ke rafi sb suraj the to kishor da ek diya bhar hi the.
दिया भर रफ़ी थे तभी 1969 के बाद बुझ गये थे। 🤣
किशोर दा का गाया हुआ गीत बेहतर है
Dosre lafzon mai yrh kaha jae ga ke zroorat ke waqt hamasha rafi shb hi kaam ate thay.
Mohammad Rafi sahab jaisa koi nahi hai 🌹🌹🌹
Kishor da all time legend dada ka koi muqabla nahi. Na hi rafi sahab ji ka.
no. never, kishore ka koi muqabala ho hi nahi sakta. rafi to kishore ke samne nil hai.
kishore ultimate, unmatched, incomparable, exceptional.
@@shivamp3785 nahi bro ap galat bop rahe hai pehle toh respect the legend kishor da kaho kishor sahab kaho ok. Baki baat rafi sahab ki. Kishor da ji ka fan wohi ho sakta hai. Jo rafi sahab ji ki bhi respect kare kyunki dada khud unki bohat respect karte the ok bro. Aa gai samjh.
@@RajatKumar-me1gj first thing saheb to 47 me chale gaye bhaisahab.
and all these singers are just entertainers. we spend money and listen them on radio, cassettes, cds. then they survive with "roti" my friend.
no doubt they are "mahaan" but to call with their names without prefix or sufix dont make any offend i think.
aapki marji you call with saheb or "da".
now choice is ours, and kishore is the greatest among all and rafi comes after.
kishore always respect rafi its kishore's and use to praise rafi, its kishore's greatness.
bhaisahab,
can you show me one interview "rafi ke moove kiski tarif nikali hai" never.
rafi was most proudy, self concentrated, and use to think of himself.
kishore is on the top in all aspects of music, human being, rafi is nowhere.
thnx for your suggestions.
khush raho bhaisahab.
@@shivamp3785 bhai itni badi chithi likhne ki jarurat nahi thi. Bas hum ye keh rahe hai. Dono legend hai Dono ki respect karo ok. Name ache se lo. Aue kono ek samaan hai. Bas. Kuch jyada kehne ki jarurat mahi hai
Both are legends of great India and were best friends.
I love both Rafi saheb and kishore da.
Let's be honest Rafi ji voice is unique please do not be offended.
Rafi sahab unmatchable. ❤❤❤❤❤🇫🇷😭Really miss you Sur.
Let's be honest Kishoreda voice unique manly and Godly
@@sundersharma4857 there are many rafi and will be many rafi.
but there is not a single kishore and there will not be....
जु ती राजनीती कारके म्होहं मंद को भारतरत्न देने की कोसिस कर रहे किसरोडा कु द एक अवार्ड हे❤❤❤❤❤❤
राजेश खन्ना,अमिताभ, देव साहब,जीतेन्द्र, मिथुन दा का आवाज़ किशोर दा। जानी वर्कर, शमी कपूर, राजेंद्र कुमार, दिलीप कुमार का आवाज़ मोहम्मद रफी जो आजतक सुपरस्टार नहीं है। सुपरस्टार तो सिर्फ किशोर दा बनाते थे।
Rafi sahab only Rafi is best singer
Agar kishor itna he verstile tha tu sad version bhi usi say karwa leetay
क्यूँ गलत जानकारी देते है सैड सॉंग रफी गा नहीं सके,वहीं शोले मे सैड सॉंग किशोर दा ने ऐसा गाया कि पूरा हिंदुस्तान रो दिया था फिल्म देखकर हॉल से लोग रोते हुए निकलकर रहे थे लेकिन मोहमद रफी किसी रुला नहीं सके। किशोर दा गायकी के मामले मे रफी से बहुत आगे है और आज भी है, आज भी सबसे ज्यादा किशोर दा का ही गाना सुना जाता है।
You all talk about Comparison between Rafiji and Kishoreda. You shouldn't forget that otherthan Kishorekumar EVERYONE WAS ONLY SINGER. BUT KISHOREKUMAR WAS ALL IN ONE. HE WAS ONLY ALLROUNDER IN ENTIRE INDIA 🇮🇳 AND IN THE WORLD 🗺. KISHOREKUMAR WAS SINGER, ACTOR, DANCER, COMEDIAN, STAGE PERFORMER..INDIVIDUALLY and WITH OTHERS. HE WAS PRODUCER, DIRECTOR AND MUSIC DIRECTOR TOO FOR HIS OWN FILM. HE ACTED IN LEAD ROLES WITH ALL TOP HEROINES OF HIS TIME...exmp. VYJAYANTIMALA, MADHUBALA, NUTAN, SHYAMA and MANY MORE HEROINES PLUS HE ACTED IN SIDE ROLES TOO. LOOK AT HIS FILMS PADOSAN, CHALTI KA NAAM GAADI, ASHA and MANY MORE . HE ACTED, DANCED and SANG HIS OWN SONGS IN THESE FILMS. HE IS THE GREATEST ARTIST OF THE ENTIRE WORLD. DOES ANYONE HAVE SO MANY QUALITIES IN FILM INDUSTRY? THEREFORE I CONSIDER KISHOREKUMAR IS THE BEST AND GREATEST ARTIST AMONGST ALL IN INDIA and IN WORLD TOO. THEREFORE NEVER COMPARE BETWEEN RAFIJI AND KISHOREKUMAR...WHILE COMPARING COMPARE WITH ALL QUALITIES TOGETHER.
SECONDLY, IN THE BEGINNING KISHOREDA WAS SINGING FOR HIS ROLES AND FOR DEVANAND ONLY. BUT AFTER ARADHANA FILM CAME, ALL SONGS OF THE FILM WERE BOOMED. THEREAFTER ALL ACTORS WANTED KISHOREDA'S VOICE ONLY FOR THEIR ROLES. THIS IS KISHOREKUMAR. EVEN NOW WE ALL DANCE WHEN HIS DANCING ROLES SONGS COME ON RADIO/ TV etc. THIS IS MY OPINION. YOU MAY DIFFER. ITS UPTO YOU. BYE.😮
Jokers comparing legends, Rafi Saab and Kishoreda. Both was good on their own ways! Can anyone judge who is better? All jokers can being bias to their prefered singers.For me, i love both them, without both, you can never enjoy your prefered singer! Fact.😂
RAFINAMA AUR RAFICHALISA padne walo kyon khud ko aur public ko moorkh samjhte ho. Aaj aapko batana padta hai ki is geet ka sad version bhi hai, koi nahin janta koi tawwaju bhi nahin deta. Sad version banawati lagta hai. Iske Kishore kumar ke gaane hi famous hai. Koi nahi poochhta rafisaab ko, sirf Kishore da ke geet hi sune jaate kyonki wo natural menly voice lagti banawati nahin lagti
Only Rafi sahab
rafi just nulla in front of great kishore, entire world knows this fact.
ऐसी घटिया थम नेल मत लगाया करो भाई। दोनो बहुत बड़े सिंगर हैं।
Kishore da version hamesha hit hua hai
You can't compare Rafi Saaab with anyone else. Its like showing a candle 🕯 🕯 to the Sun. If Anyone did, the Sun will laugh at you.
In my view comparing Rafi saheb with Kishore Da is like comparing Virat Kohli with Jasprit Bumrah or comparing Rohit Sharma with Mohd Shami.
Both are masters in their own fields and both their teamwork is required for winning the game.
That is why the teamwork of all the great singers , Lata, Asha, Suman, Rafi, Kishore, Mukesh, Manna , Talat, Mahendra, Hemant, -etc , etc, alongwith all the great lyricists. & music directors is known as THE GOLDEN ERA. 🙏🙏
No No when u compare Ram and Krishan both were same
Exactly.
@@vikeshsachdeva8056 absolutely no no no.kishore is greatest among all.
rafi kishore ke samne nothing.
@shivamp3785 har jagah shit karna jaruri hai kya! Because of you people only I have lost faith in the Voice of the Great Kishore Kumar. Because of you people only otherwise I would definitely consider the voice of Kishore Kumar as Great as the Great Mohammad Rafi Sahab and the great Mukesh Chand mathur sahab. But you all are toxic fanatic zealot blind devotees of the Great Kishore Kumar. Because of you people (especially Bengalis and the females) only I don't feel his voice was as great.
Kishor da s version is much better. Rafis voice was good before 70 after 70 his voice sounded tired. Industry demand decides the singer. Dont get emotional
Ahh,brother.What a brilliant reply!
YES YOU'RE RIGHT
Aapko sangeet ka koi gyan nahi hai mere bhai. Kisi sangeeragya se puchiye
@@ShariqKhan-y2d क्या पूछना है।
Aaj mausam bada beimaan hai song and gulabi aankhe song sey rafi Sahab wapis number 1 singer Ho gaye
Dono Great Singers ne apni apni jagah best gaya hai..
Bhai lyrics ko Suno.. aise Gambhir lyrics ko itne bebaak andaaz se Great Kishore da ke alava koi or Singer nahi ga Sakta.. Kishore da ka gaya version tab bhi or aaj bhi gaate or Sunte hain log 🙏
Sad song ka jo voice Rafi Sahab tha bo Kishore Kumar me nehi tha.
Rafi sab is alrounder singer and sad version song is more excellent by rafi sab
Is gane ne mujhe bahut hi emotional kar diya tha
किशोर दादा was best
Awaz toh Rafi sahab ka hi acha hain
Really kishore da great extry quality 👌
पता नाही किशोरदास इ रस या नप रत कारके खाय शाबीत कर ना चा ह ते ई किशोरडा तो विसवर्तनते ल व किशोरडा❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
रफ़ी से बड़ा रफ़ी का नाम। फिल्मी दुनिया पैसा कमाने का बाजार है। यहां व्यवसाय कला पर भारी है। रफ़ी साहब कला के पर्याय थे जबकि किशोर कुमार व्यवसाय के पर्याय थे। कला के नजरिये से रफ़ी साहब बेजोड़ थे, उनकी आवाज का कोई मुकाबला नहीं।
Like Kishore dha, Rafi Saab too proved that he can sing happy and dancing songs equally well; in the film Naseeb - John, Jaani Janardan Tara rump pump pump..
Absolute nonsense🤮
Rafi Saab sang for the second lead.
While Kishore Da gave playback for the main Hero.
Kishore Da's version had both emotions and was far superior.👍
भाई बाल की खाल तो निकलते सुना था, आपने तो खाल की जूती भी बना दी। दोनों अच्छे हैं खुशी ग़म के माहौल में फर्क होता है। बलिदान का पुट सीन को और सीन गाने को मकबूल कर देता है
दोनों दो आँखों के समान हैं, किस आँख को अच्छा कहोगे और किसको खराब ? दोनों का स्तर इतना बड़ा है कि, हम जैसे जुगनू सूर्य के बारे में बोल रहे हैं।
दोनों बेमिसाल थे 🙏🙏
Film Dostana Mohammad Rafi Kishore Kumar ke bare mein Kuchh bolate to Achcha Hota Hai
Kishore was nowhere near Rafi sahab. Rafi sahab was like moon other singers were like stars twinkling around him.
Never compare legends❤
Rafi was in first class of singers and Kishor in second class just like Manna Da said.
Rafi sahaab was the only
Singer to sing in all three octaves where as other singers sang in òne or two octaves.
If you can’t say something nice then it’s best to say Nothing 🙏🏻
Kishore is Kishore and Rafi is Rafi, where as Rafi is complete singer and Kishore is uncompleted singer but even he is compared with Rafi, that the winner is Kishore Kumar
Here you lose 😂 😂
किशोर दा संपूर्ण गायक थे मूर्ख मानव।
मतलब कुछ भी।
Millennium of the year Mohammed rafi sab ji ,
Kishor ki awaz rafi kay muqablsy main sirf 20% achi hai rafi ka koi muqabla nahi
Jai Mohammad Rafi Sahab.
Sad version Mohd Rafi Sahab ne bht aala Gaya hai iss mein koi shak nahin
Befikra wala gana bhi Rafi sahib accha hi gatein.
U spoke wrong becoz the song is same but situation N mood is different
Maine to hamesha kishoerda ka hi version suna hai...
Undue comparison.
Rafi SB best singer ever
Kishore Kumar kucha sikha huya nehi tha etneme hila diya agar sikha huya rahta to kya karta.aap log Samj joo.
Tabhi incomplete he hota
Best version Kishore da ka hai
Rafi saheb is the GOD
Rafi ko Hata
दोनो लाजवाब है
Rafi sahab ka koyi sani nahin hai
Rafi and Kishore Da are of two different categories. Rafi can be compared with Mana Dey,Lata ji,Noor Jahan Talat Mahmood and such like singers,whereas Kishore da can be compared with singers like Kishore da. Both are wonderful in their respective art.
It's vice versa of what you are trying to say Jai Shree rafiji baghwan ki awaj Shree rafiji jeisa koi NAHI ..!!!
@@rajkumarsaab5659Brother , You have got " Freedom of Thinking "and you can think as you like. What the majority admits ....that matters
And the majority shall always be on the side of kishoreda 's Guruji Shree rafiji
@@rajkumarsaab5659 No dear Rafi sahab was not Kishore da's guruji but Mahinder Kapoor ji' s guruji was Rafi sahab .Kishore Da was so much inteligent that he learned singing without any teacher and proved himself as a good music director and singer apart from being a very good film actor ,writer and director.Kishore Da the Great and my favourite also
@@shakeelrufaie993 but laxmikantji said and there is video also as a proof in the video he is saying it openly greatest fan of Shree rafiji is kishoreda then comes the number of mahindraji and others who are many in numbers
Kishoreda ka version jayada better tha aaj bhi rote hue aate hai sab wala version Kishoreda ka hi gaya hua version sunte hai na ke rafiji ka gaaya hua
U should keep ur opinions to ur self kishor is nothing compared to rafi
Acha guru ji apko Sur ki samajh nhi h kishore jesa koi bhi ga saktA rafi nhi ban sakta 😊😊
रफ़ी मियां के अंधभक्त हैं ना। 😂😂
@@MohammadMansha-l3v उल्टा बोल दिया मियां।
@@qayyumansari3157 गा कर दिखा दो रफ़ी मियां वाले।
Kishor das voice quality is never been again in the world
किशोर दा का वर्जन हमेशा भारी पड़ा है रफी साहब पर, एक नहीं सारे गानों में।
ऐसा एक भी गाना नहीं है जो किशोर दा ने भी गाया हो, लेकिन रफी का ज्यादा पसंद किया गया हो।
Impossible
YES YOU'RE RIGHT
Check kr lijiye ye gana kiska zyada suna gya TH-cam par...aur wo song bhi check kr lijiye "tum bin jaoon kaha"....!
However,for me both versions are mind blowing...they represent the diversity in singing that makes the two of them gurus in their own genré....!
Woh scene ke liye unka voice suit karta tha isiliye, na ki woh kishore da se achha gate the
सलामे इश्क मेरी जान ये गीत खुद प्रकाश मेहरा जी ने लिखा है और बाकी गीत अंजान ने लिखे थे
Rafi saheb has different voices for all actors .kishore sab voice suits for only two actors amitabh and rajesh khanna.
Do you have ears? Or does your brain not in process?
Kishore kumar voice suits for every actor : Two actors you have already mentioned+ dev anand, vinod khanna, vinod mehra, Kamal Hasan, randhir kapoor, Shashi Kapoor, Vishal anand etc. etc..
Rafi ,kishore,mukesh,sabka apna gaiki ka andaz hai teeno bemisal aur laaaaaaajawab hai aur hamesha rahenge.
Kishore was good in happy sort songs. Bringing out pain in singing was not his forte. Hathi mere sathi is another example where LP had to use Nafrat ki duniya ko chhod ke...
In that song, Rafi's voice..
शोले फिल्म मे भी अमित जी के मरते वक्त sad song है जो किशोर कुमार जी ने gaaya है और मुकाद्दर का सिकंदर मे अमित जी के वक्त विनोद खन्ना के लिए मो रफी जी sad song गा रहे है... सच बात ये है की दोनो मे ज्यादा sad feeling किशोर दादा ने गाया है.. किशोर कुमार जी जब गाते है.. तुने ये क्या किया बेवफा बन गया तोंडी दोस्ती.. तो रोना आता है... दर्द है. वैसा feel रफी साहब के आवाज मे नहीं है... एक बार दोनो song सुनो फिर कहो 🙏th-cam.com/video/7aOVww6ngNQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ymOg5QaBHnfvRpod
पता नहीं क्या क्या साबित करते रहते हो
रफी साहब का गाना आज भी नहीं चलता
आज11/01/2024 तक भी लोगों को सिर्फ किशोर दा वाला गाना ही याद है, रफी साहब वाला गाना मैंने तो तब सुना जब 2001 में पहली बार फिल्म देखी 😂😂😂
पर जैसा आपने बताया मुझे वैसा कुछ महसूस नहीं हुआ जितना बढ़ा चढ़ाकर बता रहे हैं
आज भी जब किसी भी रेडियो स्टेशन पर गीतों के कार्यक्रम आते हैं तो हर दस में से पांच गीत किशोर दा के ही होते हैं जबकि बाकी पांच गीत रफी साहब सहित अन्य गायकों के होते हैं, जिसको शक हो वो साल के किसी भी दिन किसी भी समय किसी भी रेडियो स्टेशन पर फर्माइशी गीतों का कार्यक्रम सुन सकता है
इसलिए किशोर दा की बराबरी कोई नहीं गा सकता है
😂😂😂😂😂
Rafi was a singer and kishore was a joker 😂 😂 😂
Kishor ke gana bahot asan hai aur Rafi sàab ke geet bahot muskil . Isiliye kishor ko bhi kai bar Rafi sàab ke awaj ka sahara lena para tha .
Kishor had a good luck
Wrong
@@madanpal5611 घंटा सहारा लेना पड़ा था मन्ना डे और महेंद्र कपूर ने भी गाया है किशोर कुमार के लिये एक्टिंग में व्यस्त रहने के कारण नहीं मोहम्मद रफ़ी ने जो गीत ख़राब कर दिये थे वो भी किशोर कुमार ख़ुद ही अपने लिये गा लेते। 😂😂
Yeh gana Kishore ki Aawaz mein Amitabh par picturised version film ki Jaan thi.
Us waqt Kishore Kumar matlab Hero ki awaaz. Side hero ke liye aur gaayak gate the.
Ab climax mein Amitabh ke death scene mein woh khud to gaa nahi sakte isliye side hero ko gana Pada..
Is film mein Kishore Kumar ne Jo ek se ek gaane gaye jis se baki singero ka muqaddar poori tarah baith gaya 😢😢😢
Mohd rafi far better singer than kishure da
Fantastic indeed.
Jo sandar awaz Jo spirt kishorda ki awaz me he ye geet me wo rafi ke awaz me10% bhi nahi aaj koi bhi nahi janta ki rafi ne bhi ye geet gaya he kuchh bhi fekta ho aradhana ke bad kishorda ne ghar bitha diya tha sabhi singer ko isme rafi bhi he
Aaj bhi ye geet kishorda vala hi suna jata he
Kishore da kahiye janab😂😢😮
Kishoredada was no 1 singer after 1969 to his last his breath.it is real fact.no one can deny the fact.other stamements,self created or imaginary,or self satsfactory.
Right
Absolutely correct
Only one kishorda is greatest singer all time