Rather he should have been asked whats taking so long to build bullet train which he has been yapping over years , reel minitster Ashwini vainshav would surely fumble here !!
@@Razor202 - WTF is so important about bullet train, anyway? These are expensive glamour projects which mainly create jobs for Japanese engineers, and not such fundamental infrastructure that high-speed conventional rail can't offer competitive alternatives.
@@manofsan you can’t even fanthom how convinient it would be to travel from mumbai to ahemdabad in 3 hrs and how much the bullet train corridors can help to boost the economy , which can be used by sheer middle class , people like you who think old school thats why india is soo content and is treated as third world by other nations , butthurt people like you makes the difference between us and china
@@prashanthb6521being critical is good but you need to have full context. Please compare the total number of deaths caused due to the Indian railways, the total number of derailments, the total amount of track of the indian railways, number of passengers it transports etc in the last 30 years to get a full holistic sense of the performance of his and other railway ministers of the BJP govt. Train derailments were so common earlier that the media didn't cover it because it was almost a daily occurance. Lakhs of people used to die on the railway tracks until we started making bridges and grade separation for roads and railway tracks. But yes we can always keep improving and hence we should keep being critical of any inefficiency or underperformance
@@prashanthb6521 wo to sahi baat hai lekin aap ye bhi socho ki govt to plan karti hai fund deti hai par construction workers peese kha jaate hain fir logo mein civic sense bhi nahi hai har jagah kuda fek dete hain fir govt ko blame karti hai matlab govt ki bhi galti hai par us kaam ko execute to workers karte hain na?? Ab chalo aap ye batao aap din mein kitni baar kuda ko recycle karte ho chalo bato🤔🤔🙄🙄😂😂😂🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤗🤗😁😁😁
he is a propagandist like the other ministers soo from 8-10% they have now came to 6-8% and if this continues then in future these 0 knowledge ministers will say we are looking for 4-6%
@ because u have done nothing in ur life and follow lalu clans .. for u they were performer .. this man career graph and railway , semiconductor, IT .etc and even opposition has acknowledged his dedications ..
“If there is Righteousness in the Heart,there will be beauty in the Character.If there is beauty in the Character,there will be Harmony @ Home.If there is Harmony @ Home,there will be Order in 🌎"🙏
Municipal Corporations of every town and city has failed to provide livable conditions. macro might have a good outlook but rampant socialism bordering on communism is killing the beauty of our cities. capex is not being utilized fully and capex is not being used to counter Haze, lack of sewerage, water conservation, public amenities and alternative fuels
We need double digit 10-12% of growth rate, this rate is BS . We cant get out of poverty ever with this rate. We need super ambitious and hard working person, who could take tough decisions and grow this country faster
The rate that you mentioned ie. 10 to 12% is not at all achievable in India in every practical sense. Why? Simply because India and Indian economy is a mixed economy, with lot of other issues that we need to spend money on. We are not a dictatorship or purely capitalistic society. We have to allocate some or more of our money in 0 income generating blocks of interest.
It is only possible in an authoterian society. In India, because of democracy, you can say and do whatever you want, but still there are some people who talk about freedom of speech and the constitution on a daily basis and same wasted interests either from political party or who get support from them are blocking or delaying development projects. To achieve growth like China, it's necessary to silence any voices that hinder development, which India struggles to do due to democracy. This is why projects in India can take 20 years to complete due to political differences and corruption. So the bottom line is that you need an authoritarian system if you want rapid development, but if the ruler is wrong under that system, you need to be prepared to lose everything, just like Chinese citizens who have no voice when their government does anything wrong.
We need 13% growth every year. I feel that the present set of ministers are tired as they are serving the same post for many many years. this is evident,when we look at the IDBI bank privatisation taking almost a decade, the privatisation of two PSU Banks still being on hold, not allowing Hindustan Zinc to decide when the government is a minority stake holder . these are just a few examples of the hiccups we have seen in the past 5 years. We need to be bold. You have a choice between 1. Making a growth path in the next five years and not worry about elections , or; 2. Just keep winning elections with 6-7% GDP. 6-7% growth is the usual Indian travel path and its been happening for 7 decades on an average. We need a team which can move @ 13% ( Real GDP). Our country should speed up utilising our resources. Our Minerals, Mines, Oil reserves to be tapped. If we tap it in land, why do our people go to the gulf to drill oil and chemicals. The main vision of USA to grow in the future is 'Drill Baby Drill" and for china is that they are tapping their rare earth minerals and keep acquiring more. What is happening with our KABIL.? its been 5 years only news but no action. I along with other aspiring Indians stand with our country and the present government. I believe they will speed up GDP above 13%. Jai Hind.
One example why we can't tap into resources is recently tungsten mine auction was stopped in TN. Another example from the same TN state is Sterlite plant.
@@sundaramspeaks Sir: Please note in Democracy one has to carry heterogeneous indian population to climb and be in helm of affairs to drive GDP GROWTH.
We should have more people in cabinet like ASHWINI VAISHNAVJI. A beautiful blend of administrative qualities with technological knowledge, pragmatic approach and financial viability awareness can be seen here. 🙏❤ A gradual change in PLI SCHEME from main production to supply chain manufacturing industries is on the card.
On railways, ask about the freight corridors which drives the economy more. While passenger trains need to be discussed, they are not as vital to the economy as moving freight.
India's informal sector is big, we need to count the businesses in the informal sector too, then we get the complete picture of the economy, my opinion
@@manofsanWho told you paan valas only comprise the informal business? Are you living in 60s? Most shops and businesses these days earn more than a normal IT grad, they have their cars and bikes, build their own houses, basically living a very decent lifestyle. But their income doesn't come on paper
A big shoutout to Ms Menaka Doshi for coming so well prepared for this interview. That made listening to Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw even more better. I hope he continues to serve our country for many many more years.
Modiji a true nationalist & an unique unpredictable leader & PM of Bharat since Independence.I salute Modiji 🇮🇳🙏and every true citizen must be proud of Modiji & his team👍
Mr. Ashwini Vaishnav should not hold back & shy away from questions..it felt like a newcomer was responding to questions..if he is being center’s spokesperson, there should be authority as such..but it is good thing he is getting exposure..i m pretty sure he will observe & learn be better next time
just the fact that he started off the interview with justifying 6-8% CAGR of GDP as "good" shows lack of any ambition at the central govt level. Impossible to achieve developed world status with that by 2047. Shows a complete lack of vision. The vision should be to MAINTAIN 8-10. Very disheartened listening to the speech regarding this
You make it sound like a snap of the finger. Anyone can blab pie-in-the-sky promises, but then you'll immediately whine when they can't realistically be met.
Dude, we have to be realistic. Look around the world, what is happening. It is not as peaceful environment as China enjoyed whilst America advocated for absolute capitalism. Now, trump being in office and USA going for more and more protectionist capitalist economy sort this first term of trump started 12 years ago along with USA didn’t have any clear rich enemy so, they could afford leaving China free but now China collectively is rich and can seriously hurt dollar. So, buddy think and understand before blabbering out.
also mentioning public investment as a pillar of growth is leftist thinking. it is not sustainable and will rake up huge debt. They need to create conditions for private investment which is a sustainable growth.
6-7% growth may look good on papers but is not good enough. Let us not forget that China achieved a much higher average GDP growth rate starting from the early 70s. From 1979 to 2010, China's average annual GDP growth was approximately 9.91%, with several years witnessing growth rates exceeding 13%.
@@2sridhark bullshit. China got there because US helped them. Us was heavily investing in China at that time. Geopolitics have changed a lot since. It won't be easy to achieve such high growth now. And most importantly we need sustainable development.
@@hiteshgujarathi4636 bhai ye sab fake bangla and pak accounts spreading misinformation, just whenever you see such comments expose them, they use fake indian hindu names. india is doing really good.
@@hiteshgujarathi4636 Exactly and also there is a global economic slowdown which is happening due to wars and oil price volatility. You look at the slowdown which China is witnessing now, that's because their growth is not sustainable. As we do more structural reforms, we can get consistent 8%-9% real growth per year which is sufficient to become a developed economy well before 2047.
วันที่ผ่านมา
Do you believe in the ccp's so called gdp 'growth rate figures' ? Even the late chinese premier Li Keqiang said that the chinese gdp growth rate figures,are man made. Which is as close to saying,that they are fictional.
ZERO judicial reforms, 5 crore cases pending, ZERO land/labour reforms, ZERO electoral reforms, ZERO IAS reforms-> achievments of 11 year Vishwaguru regime
you are those people ,who claim achievements of India as achievements of South Asia, Hide behind sins of Pakistan as failure of whole south asia, but hey whom i am arguing, whose own achievemnt is nothing
@@anuragpandey5879 true, ye muslman kuch nahi karthey fake account bana ke khud ka propaganda mai kush, india is growing really good even during these wars time. and that too without any backing of US support like how US supported china as a manufacturer.
You need to understand that the words of the Indians in terms of credibility, reliability and the truthfulness is the same as their credit ratings. 🤣 Moody's credit rating: India: Baa3 Standard & Poor's credit rating: India: BBB- Fitch Ratings credit rating: India: BBB- *BBB- or Baa3 status = lowest grade rating for investment, just 1 or 2 levels above junk status.* 😆😅🤣😂 People need to read up these embarrassing news headlines (please read the 4th point): 1) Moody’s retains India’s BAA3 rating despite government’s pitch for upgrade (India Today) 2) S&P Global Ratings on July 13 affirmed India’s sovereign rating at the lowest investment grade of ‘BBB-’ for the 14th year in a row (TheHindu) 3) Fitch retains India's rating at 'BBB-' as growth potential fights high deficit concerns (The Economic Times)
4) Check out the "World Economic Forum 2024 Report on the risk of media misinformation and disinformation" 😂see for yourself which country is at the top? 😂
Why Indian Fin., Ministry, RBI, its CBDC Dgtl Currency , e Rupees NOT Paying Govt Employees Salaries in Dgtl Currency as part of CBDC Pilot Proj., ??? Can the project Reduce CORRUPTION in Indian Business, Courts, IAS, IPS, Revenue,..Offices ??
semiconductor policy is again not up to the mark.. we missed, but that doesn't mean, we should catchup. The world is moving to 2nm or less. We should focus on 2nm staright away, and invest in that.
The government needs to introspect. Reduce the burden on the salaried class. Stop freebies, tax rich farmers earning in crores..spend on money infra capex, education and health..
it depends on the markets, india is doing pretty good, not like china which got US support for manufacturing with 10% growth, in reality it is not possible. and that too during these war times, india is growing really good.
@@vs_3080Exactly. China is witnessing a slowdown now due to a haphazard unsustainable growth trajectory(their population is ageing and shrinking). Their economy is heavily dependent on export dumping now, which is seriously going to be challenged with Trump. India with structural reforms can grow at 8-9% real growth rate consistently, which is sufficient to become a developed economy before 2047.
Why limit at 10% go for 15. But you have to be practical and pragmatic: we are in india which is the only true democracy among developing countries and we have a federal structure where CMS like Mamta, Lalu, all Congress ruled states, Kerala, do not understand economics. So we have almost 40-50% Indian states which are laggards and do not want to get out of mess they are in. Look at Bihar, where the people only believe in SARKARI JOB so complete lack of wealth creating activities or industries. MP and UP have come out of being laggards, next should be Bihar . Kerala and WB will be last
india needs an authoritarian - under democracy ruthless development like china is not possible - india should pause the current system of gov. & use the current young population - democracy is great if you are a developed nation otherwise it will create political instability & chaos only.
Where democracy failed where dictatorship will create disaster, in democracy politician have punishment if they don't work good still they are not doing development you think that they will do if they get stability like government job , politician will become more ruthless and corrupt then government employees
Will you be okay if Rahul Gandhi is the dictator ? No right ? Once a country becomes a dictatorship you don't get to choose your dictator. Be careful what you wish for.
@ no ! they have to do the work - 1.5 b people cannot be controlled by military - they have to make the public happy - do you see any protest in china ? may be they are afraid or may be they are happy
Very true. India has not addressed major issues that include corruption in high places like Police, Bureaucracy. Corruption is all pervasive in India and will eventually halt all growth if not addressed. Modi govt seems to be forcussed on geopolitics, defense but has totally neglected the home front. No Police or Judicial reforms have even been thought of leave alone started! Bureaucracy needs a total overhaul. Both Police, Bureacracy have been inherited from the British and the same model continues (top down model good for ruling, not governance!).
As an Indian, the ego-centric point you made is so accurate about us. I just returned back to India after 15 years working in America and Europe and nothing has changed in that regard. We are hardworking and smart people but we think 5x of ourselves than we are and therefore cannot take criticism from the outside...let alone from the inside. That has been the biggest sobering narrative for me since my return. We are doing 7/10 but we think we are 9.9/10 and it's sometimes hilarious to witness but almost always sad too.
Not true . India is pioneer in oil refinery, , Software and IT landscapes. Yes Earlier govt's didn't wrk towards RnD and Manufacturing. As a large multi dimensional skill base, Indian story will be different in next 20 -25 yrs.
Still u r importing TBM machines from china herrenknecht have a factory in india what they are doing somply import half of the products from china and germany rhey have their presence in india from 2002, and the rising crisis with china caused a huge hampering in thise infrastructure projects....u dont speak about thise ever
I like anchors who come well prepared for interviews. I have been following Menaka Doshi from Quint days, she has impressed me with her questions. Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw avoided responses to some important questions particularly China blocking machinary and talent moving to India.
Unless 1000 + billionaires in private sectors do not open their purses in manufacturing and in new technological sectors leaving the housing, finance, online selling etc. India can not compete with only depending on government spending…..
Are Salim Feku. Kurla to parel 5 th and 6 th line project, has been going on for 10 years. Now this paid IAS saying, he will complete within 1 year. It has been 3 months since nothing has happened.
6-7% growth is just on paper. Just look at listed companies results. The nifty 500 eps just grew around 3.5% on YoY basis. Fudging up numbers is what this government excels at.
@@Randomiser1992 The countries that are fudging number's are China and USA India economic growth is matching with annual growth rate There are two countries that doesn't match their annual growth rate numbers with nominal GDP numbers are China and USA.
No matter how hard you guys try to convince people, there are more competent, efficient and loyal people available for his replacement. India deserve better utilization of it's talents.
Weird analytics alone can call out India's 6.5% GDP Growth, unthinkable to rest of world in current times, as under-performance for India that targets 6-8% consistent growth YoY. Incredible
For 2023 India GDP reported GDP of around 5%, so not sure what both of these individuals are talking about. GDP and the Rupee have been dropping consistently since the 2nd quarter of 2024.
@@dengxaoping5031 May be CCP 🇨🇳 give him spreading Economic Report regarding Indian Economy. Because they can't provide any Economic Report regarding their own failing Economy! 😝😂🤣
Good grief - thought she was going to jump out of her chair and start slapping him. Interviewer wanted to overshadow the interviewee. Was she the main subject of this interview or him? Just ask your question properly, and give him a chance to answer.
India must work hard to prepare sufficient skilled labour to take d full advantage of china plus one strategy. Vietnam is ahead of India on EMS n semiconductor industry. Now time to broaden d focus of PLI, a huge success in India
thank you bloomberg, instead of CIA focussing on bangladesh, US should do more interviews and expose Indian growth cause our Indian govt , especially state govts lie through their teeth and put us in jail if we speak against them, what democracy are they talking about, its a strange quasi democracy where check and balances are ignored, trump should crush India economically, if not BJP and congress propaganda wont come out, inequality and poverty is worse than british raj
INDIA TECH TALENT OPPORTUNITY TO WORK MUCH DEPENDS ON US MARKET SO INDIA CANT PLAY DOUBLE STANDARDS IF USA TAXES DOUBEL ON INDIA GOODS ...IS IT ACCEPTABLE ? SIMILIAR INDIA SHOULD NOT 100% TAXES ON AMERICA GOODS BEST EXAMPLE TESLA CARS INDIA SHOULD COME DOWN.....& PLAY FAIR POLITICS .... DON'T BE SMART .... BECAUSE NOW AMERICA IS HAVING TRUE PATRIOT IN THE CHAIR
Excellent Interview. He is almost in a rare critical situation where, in india, no ministers are used to face such hard, data centric questions.
He is very good at making tik tok reels back in India.
Rather he should have been asked whats taking so long to build bullet train which he has been yapping over years , reel minitster Ashwini vainshav would surely fumble here !!
It's India's first bullet train. They are making it right. Stop you're barking @@Razor202
@@Razor202 - WTF is so important about bullet train, anyway? These are expensive glamour projects which mainly create jobs for Japanese engineers, and not such fundamental infrastructure that high-speed conventional rail can't offer competitive alternatives.
@@manofsan you can’t even fanthom how convinient it would be to travel from mumbai to ahemdabad in 3 hrs and how much the bullet train corridors can help to boost the economy , which can be used by sheer middle class , people like you who think old school thats why india is soo content and is treated as third world by other nations , butthurt people like you makes the difference between us and china
I met him at the India promenade Davos ... such a humble person , had an opportunity to talk to him for few minutes.
Did he know that trains are derailing or did he share a reel video to keep you pre-occupied and not ask questions ?
@@prashanthb6521being critical is good but you need to have full context. Please compare the total number of deaths caused due to the Indian railways, the total number of derailments, the total amount of track of the indian railways, number of passengers it transports etc in the last 30 years to get a full holistic sense of the performance of his and other railway ministers of the BJP govt.
Train derailments were so common earlier that the media didn't cover it because it was almost a daily occurance. Lakhs of people used to die on the railway tracks until we started making bridges and grade separation for roads and railway tracks.
But yes we can always keep improving and hence we should keep being critical of any inefficiency or underperformance
@@prashanthb6521 wo to sahi baat hai lekin aap ye bhi socho ki govt to plan karti hai fund deti hai par construction workers peese kha jaate hain fir logo mein civic sense bhi nahi hai har jagah kuda fek dete hain fir govt ko blame karti hai matlab govt ki bhi galti hai par us kaam ko execute to workers karte hain na??
Ab chalo aap ye batao aap din mein kitni baar kuda ko recycle karte ho chalo bato🤔🤔🙄🙄😂😂😂🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️🤗🤗😁😁😁
Isnt she the same journalist who criticize India's vaccine progrm?
he is a propagandist like the other ministers soo from 8-10% they have now came to 6-8% and if this continues then in future these 0 knowledge ministers will say we are looking for 4-6%
He is so humble and calm!!
Isnt she the same journalist who criticize India's vaccine progrm?
@@anonymousdoctor8369 Journalists will do journalism. its their job.
@@SentinelAerospaceOfficial they should do jourlism not propaganda and west master it
propaganda propaganda propaganda!!!!
It’s always good to watch Mr Aswini Vaishnav.
😂
@ why laugh ?
@@sanjaypriyadarshibecause he is a non performer. We need Ministers who can perform not ones who speak well.
Exactly 💯 @@meanoz9243
@ because u have done nothing in ur life and follow lalu clans .. for u they were performer .. this man career graph and railway , semiconductor, IT .etc and even opposition has acknowledged his dedications ..
He is doing best for india
Isnt she the same journalist who criticize India's vaccine progrm?
propaganda propaganda propaganda!
Excellent questions..cool and calm replies. Thank you.
Isnt she the same journalist who criticize India's vaccine progrm?
We need atleast 10%
for that we need industrialization. meanwhile 40%-50% of budget of several states goes into salaries/interest payments/buying $15 produce for $37.
It's not a joke 🤣
Aloo-pyaz hai? 20% bol lo, kya zata hai.
“If there is Righteousness in the Heart,there will be beauty in the Character.If there is beauty in the Character,there will be Harmony @ Home.If there is Harmony @ Home,there will be Order in 🌎"🙏
@@mruthyunjayasiddalingaiah7489 dr apj kalam said that🙏
Municipal Corporations of every town and city has failed to provide livable conditions. macro might have a good outlook but rampant socialism bordering on communism is killing the beauty of our cities. capex is not being utilized fully and capex is not being used to counter Haze, lack of sewerage, water conservation, public amenities and alternative fuels
municipal corporations don't have any money to invest on those basic necessities . we need to decentralize government.
We need double digit 10-12% of growth rate, this rate is BS . We cant get out of poverty ever with this rate.
We need super ambitious and hard working person, who could take tough decisions and grow this country faster
thats never gonna happen with the rampant socialism thats there in indian politics..
The rate that you mentioned ie. 10 to 12% is not at all achievable in India in every practical sense. Why? Simply because India and Indian economy is a mixed economy, with lot of other issues that we need to spend money on. We are not a dictatorship or purely capitalistic society. We have to allocate some or more of our money in 0 income generating blocks of interest.
let's adopt Chinese model to run india 😂
It is only possible in an authoterian society. In India, because of democracy, you can say and do whatever you want, but still there are some people who talk about freedom of speech and the constitution on a daily basis and same wasted interests either from political party or who get support from them are blocking or delaying development projects.
To achieve growth like China, it's necessary to silence any voices that hinder development, which India struggles to do due to democracy. This is why projects in India can take 20 years to complete due to political differences and corruption.
So the bottom line is that you need an authoritarian system if you want rapid development, but if the ruler is wrong under that system, you need to be prepared to lose everything, just like Chinese citizens who have no voice when their government does anything wrong.
@UOjha-k2s
Why not 20%
Crisp, excellent interview. Clarity of vision of the Minister Vaishnav and Modi Ji's government
HE IS AN AMAZING MINISTER
We need 13% growth every year.
I feel that the present set of ministers are tired as they are serving the same post for many many years. this is evident,when we look at the IDBI bank privatisation taking almost a decade, the privatisation of two PSU Banks still being on hold, not allowing Hindustan Zinc to decide when the government is a minority stake holder . these are just a few examples of the hiccups we have seen in the past 5 years. We need to be bold.
You have a choice between
1. Making a growth path in the next five years and not worry about elections , or;
2. Just keep winning elections with 6-7% GDP.
6-7% growth is the usual Indian travel path and its been happening for 7 decades on an average. We need a team which can move @ 13% ( Real GDP).
Our country should speed up utilising our resources. Our Minerals, Mines, Oil reserves to be tapped. If we tap it in land, why do our people go to the gulf to drill oil and chemicals. The main vision of USA to grow in the future is 'Drill Baby Drill" and for china is that they are tapping their rare earth minerals and keep acquiring more. What is happening with our KABIL.? its been 5 years only news but no action.
I along with other aspiring Indians stand with our country and the present government. I believe they will speed up GDP above 13%.
Jai Hind.
Average Indian growth rate from 1947 to about 1990 for India has been 3%. Most of the growth back then was just inflationary growth.
Itna jyada growth ratr accha nahi hain long term k liye, read sanjeev sanyal's views
You should be financial minister of india man😂
One example why we can't tap into resources is recently tungsten mine auction was stopped in TN.
Another example from the same TN state is Sterlite plant.
@@sundaramspeaks Sir: Please note in Democracy one has to carry heterogeneous indian population to climb and be in helm of affairs to drive GDP GROWTH.
*ONE OF MY FAVORITE MINISTERS* ❤
Components are the biggest hurdle in India right now. Only now GOI is understanding this point.
The way Ashwani sir navigates between Digital, Railways & Semiconder fields with numbers and tech talk....Just the right person to lead!
Isnt she the same journalist who criticize India's vaccine progrm?
articulated and clear answers 💯
We should have more people in cabinet like ASHWINI VAISHNAVJI.
A beautiful blend of administrative qualities with technological knowledge, pragmatic approach and financial viability awareness can be seen here. 🙏❤
A gradual change in PLI SCHEME from main production to supply chain manufacturing industries is on the card.
On railways, ask about the freight corridors which drives the economy more. While passenger trains need to be discussed, they are not as vital to the economy as moving freight.
Ashwini Vaishnaw’s small firm’s curious growth, Within six years, Adler’s revenue rose from Rs 45 lakh to over Rs 323 crore.
thats how crony capitalism works
Well answered to all the questions by our India’s IT and Railways Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw. Equally great questioning from the anchor
We need reform law in Agriculture which was taken back, without these reforms we can't push our GDP to higher scale
Awesome , Jai Hind
India's informal sector is big, we need to count the businesses in the informal sector too, then we get the complete picture of the economy, my opinion
informal businesses are low-level businesses
India should not be focused on counting growth of its paan-wallahs just to feel accomplished in growth
@@manofsanWho told you paan valas only comprise the informal business? Are you living in 60s? Most shops and businesses these days earn more than a normal IT grad, they have their cars and bikes, build their own houses, basically living a very decent lifestyle. But their income doesn't come on paper
@@Adi-oc2hd - alright, if it's not on paper, then how do you intend to count it? By rolling a dice?
A big shoutout to Ms Menaka Doshi for coming so well prepared for this interview. That made listening to Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw even more better. I hope he continues to serve our country for many many more years.
Thank you vaishanav ji 🙏🙏
Modiji a true nationalist & an unique unpredictable leader & PM of Bharat since Independence.I salute Modiji 🇮🇳🙏and every true citizen must be proud of Modiji & his team👍
I am a true nationalist too!
But that doesn’t explain the poor state of India s middle class!
@@chinmayshetye3 You have a point
Love to see such interview...👍👍
Mr. Ashwini Vaishnav should not hold back & shy away from questions..it felt like a newcomer was responding to questions..if he is being center’s spokesperson, there should be authority as such..but it is good thing he is getting exposure..i m pretty sure he will observe & learn be better next time
just the fact that he started off the interview with justifying 6-8% CAGR of GDP as "good" shows lack of any ambition at the central govt level. Impossible to achieve developed world status with that by 2047.
Shows a complete lack of vision. The vision should be to MAINTAIN 8-10.
Very disheartened listening to the speech regarding this
You make it sound like a snap of the finger. Anyone can blab pie-in-the-sky promises, but then you'll immediately whine when they can't realistically be met.
Dude, we have to be realistic. Look around the world, what is happening. It is not as peaceful environment as China enjoyed whilst America advocated for absolute capitalism. Now, trump being in office and USA going for more and more protectionist capitalist economy sort this first term of trump started 12 years ago along with USA didn’t have any clear rich enemy so, they could afford leaving China free but now China collectively is rich and can seriously hurt dollar.
So, buddy think and understand before blabbering out.
India is not China...Indian growth is more stable and sustainable. However, I do think, pace could be increased a little.
also mentioning public investment as a pillar of growth is leftist thinking. it is not sustainable and will rake up huge debt. They need to create conditions for private investment which is a sustainable growth.
viksit by 2047 is to fool bhaktidiots, we are not even near to 5 trillion yet..
6-7% growth may look good on papers but is not good enough.
Let us not forget that China achieved a much higher average GDP growth rate starting from the early 70s.
From 1979 to 2010, China's average annual GDP growth was approximately 9.91%, with several years witnessing growth rates exceeding 13%.
@@2sridhark bullshit. China got there because US helped them. Us was heavily investing in China at that time. Geopolitics have changed a lot since. It won't be easy to achieve such high growth now.
And most importantly we need sustainable development.
@@hiteshgujarathi4636 bhai ye sab fake bangla and pak accounts spreading misinformation, just whenever you see such comments expose them, they use fake indian hindu names. india is doing really good.
@@hiteshgujarathi4636 Exactly and also there is a global economic slowdown which is happening due to wars and oil price volatility. You look at the slowdown which China is witnessing now, that's because their growth is not sustainable. As we do more structural reforms, we can get consistent 8%-9% real growth per year which is sufficient to become a developed economy well before 2047.
Do you believe in the ccp's so called gdp 'growth rate figures' ? Even the late chinese premier Li Keqiang said that the chinese gdp growth rate figures,are man made.
Which is as close to saying,that they are fictional.
Done with massive investment from the west. They can always pull back and they now they are. The result is slowing Chinese growth.
I hope he is more serious about investment in Railways. The current railway infrastructure is outdated.
Excellent explanation and India 🇮🇳 going to be best investment country in the world 🌎
ZERO judicial reforms, 5 crore cases pending, ZERO land/labour reforms, ZERO electoral reforms, ZERO IAS reforms-> achievments of 11 year Vishwaguru regime
Adaxum’s approach to bridging DeFi and E-commerce is brilliant. Got in early with my ADX tokens.
Great Minister 💪💪💪🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳super anchor 💪💪💪🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🥰🥰
Just joined the Adaxum presale-this project has massive potential for long-term growth.
Exceent interview... Hope indian media learn who to ask good questions
2 Indians interviewing each other and praising India among themselves. No biasness is involved 😅🤣😂😆😁😄😃😀
Our people do hardwork to achieve success while your people only do complain and spread hatred against each other instead of doing work for country
you are those people ,who claim achievements of India as achievements of South Asia, Hide behind sins of Pakistan as failure of whole south asia, but hey whom i am arguing, whose own achievemnt is nothing
asli accoutn se ah bey ka2way.
@@anuragpandey5879 true, ye muslman kuch nahi karthey fake account bana ke khud ka propaganda mai kush, india is growing really good even during these wars time. and that too without any backing of US support like how US supported china as a manufacturer.
Two North Hindians to be precise and they only have praises for themselves
Super smart and humble ❤
You need to understand that the words of the Indians in terms of credibility, reliability and the truthfulness is the same as their credit ratings. 🤣
Moody's credit rating: India: Baa3
Standard & Poor's credit rating: India: BBB-
Fitch Ratings credit rating: India: BBB-
*BBB- or Baa3 status = lowest grade rating for investment, just 1 or 2 levels above junk status.* 😆😅🤣😂
People need to read up these embarrassing news headlines (please read the 4th point):
1) Moody’s retains India’s BAA3 rating despite government’s pitch for upgrade (India Today)
2) S&P Global Ratings on July 13 affirmed India’s sovereign rating at the lowest investment grade of ‘BBB-’ for the 14th year in a row (TheHindu)
3) Fitch retains India's rating at 'BBB-' as growth potential fights high deficit concerns (The Economic Times)
4) Check out the "World Economic Forum 2024 Report on the risk of media misinformation and disinformation" 😂see for yourself which country is at the top? 😂
He's good for railways, but we need someone dedicated for IT industry.
We are so far behind in AI
Projects like Adaxum don’t stay under the radar for long-glad I joined the presale today.
ADX is the type of token that could see exponential growth. Secured my share early in the presale.
Why Indian Fin., Ministry, RBI, its CBDC Dgtl Currency , e Rupees NOT Paying Govt Employees Salaries in Dgtl Currency as part of CBDC Pilot Proj., ??? Can the project Reduce CORRUPTION in Indian Business, Courts, IAS, IPS, Revenue,..Offices ??
Good point. All government workers should only be paid in digital currency and asset counting should be done every few months to eliminate corruption
semiconductor policy is again not up to the mark.. we missed, but that doesn't mean, we should catchup. The world is moving to 2nm or less. We should focus on 2nm staright away, and invest in that.
Good job
The government needs to introspect. Reduce the burden on the salaried class. Stop freebies, tax rich farmers earning in crores..spend on money infra capex, education and health..
You are right. But the very survival of the Govt. will be in serious doubt with such tough stance, with the type of opposition we have in our Country.
india need is 10 percent growth , 6-8 percent is a joke , and if u plan 6 percent u will end up in less than 5
The target is 8 bro. Theworse could go to 6, the best could be 8. They arent planning for 6.
it depends on the markets, india is doing pretty good, not like china which got US support for manufacturing with 10% growth, in reality it is not possible. and that too during these war times, india is growing really good.
@@vs_3080Exactly. China is witnessing a slowdown now due to a haphazard unsustainable growth trajectory(their population is ageing and shrinking). Their economy is heavily dependent on export dumping now, which is seriously going to be challenged with Trump. India with structural reforms can grow at 8-9% real growth rate consistently, which is sufficient to become a developed economy before 2047.
Be realistic. In the global environment the way it is with half the major global economies in or near recession. 6.5% is already quite Herculean.
Why limit at 10% go for 15. But you have to be practical and pragmatic: we are in india which is the only true democracy among developing countries and we have a federal structure where CMS like Mamta, Lalu, all Congress ruled states, Kerala, do not understand economics. So we have almost 40-50% Indian states which are laggards and do not want to get out of mess they are in. Look at Bihar, where the people only believe in SARKARI JOB so complete lack of wealth creating activities or industries. MP and UP have come out of being laggards, next should be Bihar . Kerala and WB will be last
Articulate down to earth knowledgeable succinct Ashwini Vaishnaw represents the GOI well.
india needs an authoritarian - under democracy ruthless development like china is not possible - india should pause the current system of gov. & use the current young population - democracy is great if you are a developed nation otherwise it will create political instability & chaos only.
Where democracy failed where dictatorship will create disaster, in democracy politician have punishment if they don't work good still they are not doing development you think that they will do if they get stability like government job , politician will become more ruthless and corrupt then government employees
Will you be okay if Rahul Gandhi is the dictator ? No right ? Once a country becomes a dictatorship you don't get to choose your dictator. Be careful what you wish for.
@aakashPotter Right like indira Gandhi
@ no ! they have to do the work - 1.5 b people cannot be controlled by military - they have to make the public happy - do you see any protest in china ? may be they are afraid or may be they are happy
@ i am not talking about finishing the democratic system but to pause the system for 25 years with the consent of all party in ind - it is my fantasy
Ego centric, greed, corruption is plaguing India's economy
Very true.
India has not addressed major issues that include corruption in high places like Police, Bureaucracy. Corruption is all pervasive in India and will eventually halt all growth if not addressed. Modi govt seems to be forcussed on geopolitics, defense but has totally neglected the home front. No Police or Judicial reforms have even been thought of leave alone started! Bureaucracy needs a total overhaul. Both Police, Bureacracy have been inherited from the British and the same model continues (top down model good for ruling, not governance!).
As an Indian, the ego-centric point you made is so accurate about us. I just returned back to India after 15 years working in America and Europe and nothing has changed in that regard. We are hardworking and smart people but we think 5x of ourselves than we are and therefore cannot take criticism from the outside...let alone from the inside. That has been the biggest sobering narrative for me since my return. We are doing 7/10 but we think we are 9.9/10 and it's sometimes hilarious to witness but almost always sad too.
Not true . India is pioneer in oil refinery, , Software and IT landscapes. Yes Earlier govt's didn't wrk towards RnD and Manufacturing. As a large multi dimensional skill base, Indian story will be different in next 20 -25 yrs.
@@ashishmishra-sz9smwhat did actually impede Research and Development as mentioned? The landscape is still the same
Still u r importing TBM machines from china herrenknecht have a factory in india what they are doing somply import half of the products from china and germany rhey have their presence in india from 2002, and the rising crisis with china caused a huge hampering in thise infrastructure projects....u dont speak about thise ever
I like anchors who come well prepared for interviews.
I have been following Menaka Doshi from Quint days, she has impressed me with her questions. Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw avoided responses to some important questions particularly China blocking machinary and talent moving to India.
Unless 1000 + billionaires in private sectors do not open their purses in manufacturing and in new technological sectors leaving the housing, finance, online selling etc. India can not compete with only depending on government spending…..
Super skilled minister of Modi government. Salute!
Intresting
Master - U have got 50 out of 100
Student - my target is 40-70
Master- then how can u beat 1st who gets 90
Student😮😮
master- study 90hrs a week to beat the first
student- what about my health
master- 🤯🤯
One of the dynamic minister in Modi government
Clean cities and tourism ?
Are Salim Feku.
Kurla to parel 5 th and 6 th line project, has been going on for 10 years.
Now this paid IAS saying, he will complete within 1 year. It has been 3 months since nothing has happened.
Exactly 💯
the anchor is good with question, keep it up
Hi everyone, Adaxum is delivering on its promises so far-presale bonuses are great.
INDIA WILL GROW 6-8 WITHOUT ANY GOVT INTERVAL, THESE CROOKS IN GOVT SHOULD ONLY TAKE CREDIT IF THEY MAKE IT ABOVE 10%
Adaxum is starting to make waves.
ADX could be a game-changer.
6-7% growth is just on paper. Just look at listed companies results. The nifty 500 eps just grew around 3.5% on YoY basis. Fudging up numbers is what this government excels at.
@@Randomiser1992 The countries that are fudging number's are China and USA
India economic growth is matching with annual growth rate
There are two countries that doesn't match their annual growth rate numbers with nominal GDP numbers are China and USA.
Adaxum’s focus on innovation is what sold me on this project. Got my ADX tokens today.
Both live in India, why do they need to do interview in Davos? Can't it be done in Delhi? Why isn't the foreign media taking their interviews?
Minister is in Davos to promote India, as part of their invite to him.
The fact that foreign media are covering him is part of the promotion.
No matter how hard you guys try to convince people, there are more competent, efficient and loyal people available for his replacement. India deserve better utilization of it's talents.
ADX: early stage, huge potential.
Adaxum’s potential is massive, and I’m thrilled to be part of its journey. Locked in my tokens!
Weird analytics alone can call out India's 6.5% GDP Growth, unthinkable to rest of world in current times, as under-performance for India that targets 6-8% consistent growth YoY. Incredible
Government group D employee get more salary than most of IT the employees in almost all the MNCs 😂
6.5% gdp growth for a country of 1.4 bn people with low per capita is just a big joke. 8% should be minimum instead of 6%.
The combination of DeFi and E-commerce makes Adaxum stand out.
10% growth will change India, we have to do more reforms.
Happy I got in early with ADX.
He is Reelway minister.
Isnt she the same journalist who criticize India's vaccine progrm?
For 2023 India GDP reported GDP of around 5%, so not sure what both of these individuals are talking about. GDP and the Rupee have been dropping consistently since the 2nd quarter of 2024.
💯💯 People should realise this and stop voting for freebies first
@@Spc_1996stop giving excuses
It was 7.2%, where did you give the 5% number from?
@@dengxaoping5031 May be CCP 🇨🇳 give him spreading Economic Report regarding Indian Economy. Because they can't provide any Economic Report regarding their own failing Economy! 😝😂🤣
Adaxum’s focus on real utility is impressive.
The Indian must invent everything to compete with another country.
💯 Agree! 👌👍
Good grief - thought she was going to jump out of her chair and start slapping him.
Interviewer wanted to overshadow the interviewee. Was she the main subject of this interview or him?
Just ask your question properly, and give him a chance to answer.
India must work hard to prepare sufficient skilled labour to take d full advantage of china plus one strategy. Vietnam is ahead of India on EMS n semiconductor industry. Now time to broaden d focus of PLI, a huge success in India
We need consistent atleast 8% growth evey year ki achieve developed nation status in 2047
Focus on High tech industries;
Defense; space;
Ai; Robotics;
nano ;
stealth;
he is college mate of google ceo sunder pichayi
What happened to the Goli train 😂. This guy is all hype and a loser 😅
Bought ADX during the presale. Solid project so far!
There us not a single Indian leader who can stand up to Trump and Putin. When Trump will ask India to choose, what will India do?
Putin? Where is Putin posing any problems for India? You do know that India's economy is 3x larger than Russia's, don't you?
thank you bloomberg, instead of CIA focussing on bangladesh, US should do more interviews and expose Indian growth cause our Indian govt , especially state govts lie through their teeth and put us in jail if we speak against them, what democracy are they talking about, its a strange quasi democracy where check and balances are ignored, trump should crush India economically, if not BJP and congress propaganda wont come out, inequality and poverty is worse than british raj
US investing 500b usd in AI, meanwhile India investing in Ladli behena and free ration. lmao
@@harit538 jake us me dhek kitna bath te hai paisa ... pregnant ko , single mom ko , unemployed, refugees ko, immigrants ko, etc etc
these mainstream media interviewers are coming across as dumber and dumber each passing day
I think indian railways needs to modernization in signalling and new track.Route fencing
Real questions seen to be asked of an Indian minister after 7-8 years. Look at him go on in a tape mode saying the same thing over and over again.
ADX presale is going strong!
He says "listen" a lot
INDIA TECH TALENT OPPORTUNITY TO WORK MUCH DEPENDS ON US MARKET
SO INDIA CANT PLAY DOUBLE STANDARDS
IF USA TAXES DOUBEL ON INDIA GOODS ...IS IT ACCEPTABLE ?
SIMILIAR
INDIA SHOULD NOT 100% TAXES ON AMERICA GOODS
BEST EXAMPLE TESLA CARS
INDIA SHOULD COME DOWN.....& PLAY FAIR POLITICS .... DON'T BE SMART ....
BECAUSE NOW AMERICA IS HAVING TRUE PATRIOT IN THE CHAIR
Lol. All import cars are taxed 100%.
Tesla should start manufacturing in India if it thinks it's missing out of the Indian market just like apple.
Miss Menaka from her CNBC days.She was way better then shireen