Die Stimmung in den meisten Stadien der Proficlubs in Deutschland ist schon sehr gut, vielleicht hat auch die Bundesliga die beste Stimmung der Europäischen Topligen, aber nicht der Welt. Zum Beispiel kann die Stimmung in den deutschen Ligen lange nicht mit der in der argentinischen oder der marokkanischen ersten Liga mithalten.
Don't even need to watch the video, German fans put English fans to shame 100% of the time. Well the teams i have seen live, the German fans just doesn't stop chanting, choreographed or not its pretty amazing, very good atmosphere.
Gooner 1953 what do you mean? german teams are better on international level. bundesliga got 2nd place in uefa ranking. so why do you think british football better? because they pay 30 mio€ for players like lallana or 55mio for players like stones or 70mio€ for sterlings? 😂😂😂 thats just ridiculous. look at the german talents who actually will play on a world class level and dont cost that much (tah, kimmich, weigl, weiser, brandt, draxler, gnabry, etc)
premier league may be great to watch but i would rather have germans league anyday. fans get treated properly unlike us lot in england who get ripped of left, right and centre.
In club football germans got better fans, especially because in the bpl loud fans stay in pubs while stadiums look like theatres(especially etihad, emirates). Also there is a big difference in the way both nations support, english are more creative in chants while germans sing 90 minutes and got better choreographys (thanks to ultras). In national football the england support is way better, because real fans attend to the stadiums while no german ultras go to germany matches. It's basically the opposite to club football.
Wir haben unser London alleine gegen Deutschland verteidigt, die Hawker-Typhoons und die Spitfires haben die Deutschen selbstständig zurückgeschlagen, im Battle of Britain wie in El Alamein. Außerdem waren die Deutschen selbst schuld daran, drei Supermachten gegen sich aufgebracht zu haben, und sie hatten ja auch noch Italien und Japan als Verbündete, waren also selbst zu dritt ;-)
English People fans are nice People and fans. They are singing loudly and nice, but I think the German ones are better( I think not only because of the standingplaces) Both have great fans! Greetings from a german! :D
I just think if clubs in England lowered prices then we'd be back on your level, cos before the ticket prices got inflated English fans were on your level and we still have fans on your level; proven internationally so hopefully we'll get £20's plenty rolling soon
THANK YOU! someone with a brain!!!!!!!! plus our lower league fans are very good. I support Preston, should come and watch us one time at an away game ;)
Noobschrauber CPFC are probably the only fans that England can compare to you, but still BVB, St Pauli, Dynamo Dresden and Eintracht Frankfurt are way ahead of Crystal Palace.
Uvuvwevwevwewevw Onyetenevevwe Ugwemube the england national team fans are better than the German national team fans. The German club fans are better than the English club fans
@@DomAFC9 Thats true although it does depend on the club, in the prem crystal palace has really good fans Liverpool do as well at big games at anfield and European nights but the best of english fans you get in the lower leagues
On their day English fans can easily outshine German fans. However, German fans do what they do week in, week out, whereas English fans only shine in the big occasions (eg; UCL). Liverpool and Palace fans are the only two sets of fans that I’d consider as good as any set of a German fans
Difference is in England football tickets are astronomically high and all the grounds are full of prawn sandwich eating corporate ticket holding wankers most of the real football fans have been forced to watch the games at home or in pubs and we still give anyone a run for there money when it comes to singing and supporting imagine what it would be like if the teams cared about the working class and real fans for example look at what it was like in the 70s and 80s legendary
@@wingo8317 Exactly, but they don't because they have no fan culture in England so buying a €50 player will come before match day experience. We don't have teams as good as UK but will always have more fun at games & better atmosphere
German fans now are like English fans in the 70s and 80s. England used to have the best fans but nowadays there’s no question. It’s Germany. From an English fan
One thing's for sure, the English & the German fans are more like brothers than enemy's these days and that makes me smile, and don't forget, we both have a common enemy now but that is a different story altogether. :)
If English clubs employed MC's with a microphone to encourage fans to sing and dance, and also charged between 9-20 euros for a ticket, then yes England would still have the best fans.
English fans have the better chants and songs but german fans pretty much sing all game. National team it's a different story, the england national team have the best fans in the world. Also i don't know why we are comparing these 2 fans, most of the hardcore english fans are banned from attending any stadium, ultras are not allowed in england and don't get me started on ticket prices which just attract armchair fans.
@@nilsmullhauser2839 Germans have like only 2 or 3chants and they only say like 1word heres a example ohohhoohhhhohh Bayern muchen ohohhohhohhoo just used that as a example.In fact that goes for ultras of other countries too not just germans english come up with the most creative chants as do scotland,ireland,wales etc We english have like 30chants
English football, the higher echelons anyway, are deserts when it comes to atmosphere. The players are overpayed, the tickets overpriced and clubs are little more than rich men's toys. I've been to many games in Germany and the atmosphere is incredible, clubs are communities and it costs a fraction to attend. You won't see stadia emptying 15 minutes before the end or players wandering off to cuddle their wallets instead of applauding the fans.
Really..then why do defender and strikers ..not to mention middle fielders compete for the ballon dd'or yet they play in total different positions?..if an orange grows one one tree ...you telling us that you cant compare it to oranges from another tree coz the trees are different or in different locations..JUST KEEP QUIET
not really though is it.. plus our lower league fans are 10x better than your or any other countries lower league fans. Maybe come back when you know a bit more
so i really liked the clip t 6:23 but when you make such a viedeo you have to show the fans of Dynamo Dresden because they have the best fanbase in the world (for example they ere in third league and the whole satdium was full (30.000 places) btw sorry for my bad english
If ticket prices were lower in England, and flares, loudspeakers, and lesser health and safety concerns were allowed I honestly reckon the English would be better
This question can easily be answered if you just look at European games when Dortmund, Schalke or Bayern come to England. They're just on another level.
I think both sets of fans are the best in Europe. To everyone talking about Ultras, we used to have football firms, which made it dangerous to go to matches. That was about 20-30 years ago, though. Everyone gets banned now or can't afford tickets.
English football has great supporters and awesome chants. But the FA do what they can to screw them. High ticket prices, seats only, the teams belong to some non-attached investors. German teams have 50+1 to protect them from such bs. Prices are at least payable and they still have very affordable "Stehplätze". Fan culture is also threatened in Germany, but the fans haven't been effed over as much as in the UK. So BuLi is better, but only because of all the restrictions laid upon the British fans. All because of money 😑
Germany by a country mile. Been over for a few games and it's amazing. Every single stadium have been to has an ultras section that's loud as fuck. In England most stadiums are souless librarys. In Germany it's for the fans in England it's for greedy owners.
I'm English but Germany smash us for atmosphere. Although if Crystal Palace had more Ultras they'd be contenders. But still wouldn't beat the top 8 German ultras.
English teams normally only sing away and German fans are more true than ours. And I've been to a Match at anfield and you couldn't even hear YNWA because they got outsung by my team (who are league 2) even though it was full attendance
I just think it's different. The German way is more choreographed whereas the English is more organic. That being said, 3,500 thousand England fans out sang the Germans in Berlin and bvb wilted under the atmosphere at Anfield whereas Liverpool weren't affected by the yellow wall. I'd say that when the English are good they're better but the Germans are more consistent and that's down to English prices. I like them both though.
you will NEVER hear any atmosphere in German national team home games any more. Why? german ultras and true football fans boycott those games. In the stadium there are sitting only familiy and event fans. If you want a taste of German atmosphere whatch a Frankfurt, Rostock or Dresden Game, those are the best in Germany, check them out
Great fans all round on both sides, I'm not a fan of maintaing the singing all game though, its better when the crowd play to the game for me. I like the groans and when the footballs shit, theres that silence that lets the players know they ain't performing, then the burst. Prefer English fans (cos Im bias) but mad respect for the Germans!
A very big difference: German fans put all their energy in singing praises and motivational songs for their team in the name of support English fans put all their energy in offensive songs and chants for their opponents in the same of support
Prices and the fact there's no safe standing have had a huge impact on PL so that most games are not the real fans but tourists or corporate. Conversely the atmosphere tends to be better in Championship and EFL in general as more true fans go. German club fans have no such problems so obv during club games the atmosphere is better. Nationally England is far better, much more humour, creativity and numbers. Imagine if the team was any good!
Anglo German Cup or British German Cup by Rory Smith. I am putting forward a new football trophy that could give extra games to English and German teams, plus invited teams from other nations. The motivation. England and Germany have a very strong football rivalry, and two of the strongest, if not the strongest leagues in European, and indeed world football. It is the equivalent of a derby rivalry in international football like Scotland V England is. My idea is to take advantage of this intense national rivalry by holing an Anglo German Cup, between club sides from the top division. My preferred option would be for all clubs from the top divisions of the German Bundesliga and English Premier who have not qualified for Europe to play in a straight knockout tournament, of one leg each. The final could be played at Wembley each year. Extra teams from Scotland and the other Germanic nations. My idea would also include inviting from the Scottish league Glasgow Celtic, Glasgow Rangers, Hearts, Aberdeen and Hibernian into the trophy to give them experience each year guaranteed to playing big non Scottish clubs. It would be the same Scottish teams invited regardless of league position to ensure big games for the big Scottish sides. Plus we could also invite more teams from the other Germanic nations to take part, such as from German speaking Switzerland, the famous team Basle, and from German speaking Austria, Rapid Vienna, and Salzburg. Teams who qualify for Europe are punished in Europe One problem with English football is that teams who succeed, and qualify for Europe, are almost punished the next season because the next season, so they are almost punished for qualifying for Europe. This trophy would ensure they play more games, even if they do not qualify for the Europa League and Champions League. Scottish teams would love this trophy I think Scottish teams would love to play in this trophy because they would love the guarantee of each year playing big English and German sides. As an Aberdeen fan I would love my team to be guaranteed games against big English sides every year. I would also be happy for Scottish teams to have to qualify for the trophy with say the first 4 teams in the Scottish Premier qualifying. Glamour Games Imagine mouth watering games like Southampton v Hamburg, Basle v Swansea City, West Brom v Augsburg, Stuttgart v Stoke City, Eintracht Frankfurt v Everton, Hertha Berlin v Aberdeen, and Werder Bremen v Glasgow Rangers. I think this would be an interesting experience of European cross border football for big English Premier teams who often despite being in the top league, can often go 10 years without playing a side from another nations league. The final could be at Wembley Stadium every year. The games would be intense, passionate and with Scotland and Germany, as two of England’s biggest international derby rivals. The number of teams in the trophy could be flexible with even the possibility of inviting the big Dutch teams. Such as Ajax and PSV into the trophy. The Dutch have a big rivalry with the Germans. Some Germans see the Netherlands as their biggest football rivalry, but the Dutch clubs are not as big in financial terms as the Why invite Celtic and Rangers? I think inviting Celtic and Rangers into the trophy would be vital to add extra big teams into the trophy, who are guaranteed to bring big travelling supports. It could add prestige to the trophy and extra Scotland England rivalry would add to the trophy. I accept that in the early rounds, teams might not get big crowds. For instance top English sides might not take playing my favourite team Aberdeen, or Basle, as a big game and would probably get lower crowds than they do in the Premier League. But as the trophy goes on the games would get bigger. If 70,000 fans can turn up for the lower division English trophies then surely can get big crowds for big English Premier and German Bundesliga sides. Also for clubs from Scotland and Austria this would be a massive trophy. So stadiums would be packed. Cup games are more interesting than league football in my view. Winning a cup is more interesting than any league position other than champions or relegation. Not a replacement for European football I am not suggesting that this trophy would be instead of Europa League and Champions League football. Scottish, English, German and Austria teams would still enter sides in the Europa League and Champions League. Would UEFA allow it? I do not see why not. After all they have allowed the Royal League in Scandinavia and the Sentana Cup in Irish football, between two different leagues. It would not be a threat to the Europa League and Champions League. It would help Scotland and gives big English and German clubs who do not play in European football, some big games. Another addition could be a British German Cup made up of all English Premier and German Bundesliga teams who have not qualified for Europe plus the top 4 sides of Scotland, and top 2 sides, each, of the Northern Ireland and Welsh leagues. I would most prefer a British German Cup, with Scottish, Welsh, English, Northern Irish and German sides. It would make the season more fun. Diolch Da Boch That is Welsh.
Banning orders and tourists stop the English culture from getting close. I think English football fans appreciate that Germany’s football culture has got it right. Where as the money in the premier league is getting ridiculous and prices out the proper fans and has led to the sanitisation of English Football. Proper support is punished in the Top division, the lower division the more relaxed it gets that’s why the atmosphere weekly is better where as big games are very good on top division only due to the bigger Stadia. Liverpool vs Man U /Steel City derby as an example. I’d love to hear people’s opinions Liverpool fan.
In the desceiption you list the fans from England and Germany. You say that the german fans seen in this video are from Dortmund, Köln and Berlin. Why didn't you list Freiburg when the first segment is showing their fans?
United fans fans are the best of England and I'm a spurs fans in club football it would have to be the Germans but in countries none there both crap and I'm English the best of the countries is Irish fans
The biggest difference: German fans sing throughout the entire 90 minutes and the english customers sing occasionally when they're winning
The only team I can vouch for always singing is crystal palace
subfor noreason 😂
@@yash___5497 don’t think so pal the geordies never stop singing 😂😂😂😂 Crystal Palace never heard so much shit in me life
@@sophietaylor6804 You clearly haven’t seen a palace game then
Which is why it’s great when Germany play England two passionate country’s
I'm italian, German fans are better, nowadays English fans are plastic supporters, no ultras, no banners, no choreography... What a shame.
They do fly banners like "Wenger Out" "Van Gaal Out" etc.
@@mybitmix 😂😂🤦🏽♂️😂
If it weren’t for the English then ultras wouldn’t exist
the irony :D
@@DomAFC9 italia is the heart of ultras my friend. and im not italian
Bad examples of german Fans, you should take Ultras
Hans Sapai bad English examples
bad examples of English fans, our lower league fans are 10x better
A Man I think you serious? you’re fans are trash
Garagenkind 3D English are one of the best fans so close it
Vtr0 BlaZe 😂😂😂 are you dreaming?
Nirgends gibt es bessere Fans als in Deutschland
Janis H. In italien sind überall nazis
AsSo TV suedamerika hat wahrscheinlich den besten fan support
Dominik Brehm Boca usw haben auch gute Fans, dass stimmt..xD
Die Stimmung in den meisten Stadien der Proficlubs in Deutschland ist schon sehr gut, vielleicht hat auch die Bundesliga die beste Stimmung der Europäischen Topligen, aber nicht der Welt. Zum Beispiel kann die Stimmung in den deutschen Ligen lange nicht mit der in der argentinischen oder der marokkanischen ersten Liga mithalten.
BIG TASTY BACON Und jetzt ?
Don't even need to watch the video, German fans put English fans to shame 100% of the time. Well the teams i have seen live, the German fans just doesn't stop chanting, choreographed or not its pretty amazing, very good atmosphere.
NakedToast
Shame German football isn't as good though
Gooner 1953 what do you mean? german teams are better on international level. bundesliga got 2nd place in uefa ranking. so why do you think british football better? because they pay 30 mio€ for players like lallana or 55mio for players like stones or 70mio€ for sterlings? 😂😂😂 thats just ridiculous. look at the german talents who actually will play on a world class level and dont cost that much (tah, kimmich, weigl, weiser, brandt, draxler, gnabry, etc)
Achtzehnhundert Siebenundachtzig
Wow I didn't think the truth could hurt you that much pal
Club level: German fans, National team: England fans
Oliver Diaper but thats also because of the lack of patriotism in germany. We are proud of not being proud 😂
german has got the best fans
Patrick Star
Premier leagues a better league though
Gunner 1953 just look when the bpl last won something international even though the clubs have 10 times more money than clubs in any other league.....
premier league may be great to watch but i would rather have germans league anyday. fans get treated properly unlike us lot in england who get ripped of left, right and centre.
Nikolas Flake even though Real Madrid and Barca spend millions very year and so do bayern
They still don’t come close to how much the big Bpl teams spend
In club football germans got better fans, especially because in the bpl loud fans stay in pubs while stadiums look like theatres(especially etihad, emirates). Also there is a big difference in the way both nations support, english are more creative in chants while germans sing 90 minutes and got better choreographys (thanks to ultras).
In national football the england support is way better, because real fans attend to the stadiums while no german ultras go to germany matches. It's basically the opposite to club football.
Basti Finke
Please just stop talking
Arsenal 13 PL titles Chelsea 5 he's right though
Basti Finke Yes completly right
Manchester United 20 PL titles Arsenal 13..lol
100% agree mate you hit the nail right on the head
Germans supporter are the best
Gagan Gurung 😂germany support is shit
Valentin meyer so when youre in your own country shit scared of england
Dan Best You are shit
No there not
@@AAA-bg8le There are
Zwischen England und Deutschland das ist eine Hassliebe als wenn sich zwei Brüder ständig streiten
Nein, ich mag die wirklich nicht.
@@peterpanimketawahn1565 Haha, das war so staubtrocken formuliert, ich musste echt lachen. Selbst wenn es nicht beabsichtigt war. Dennoch :D
Deutscher fans sind besser !! 🇩🇪
@@xshooterfr3akx553 manchen*
Besonders die aus Bremen sind gut
@@xshooterfr3akx553 erst beleidigen und dann selber verschreiben 😂
@@bennet7490 Die sind gut ja aber ich finde das alle Teams gute Fans haben
@@alexandrewalter7575 alle nicht unbedingt, zb Hoffenheim, Leipzig, Wolfsburg sind echt mies, aber die besten sind mMn SVW, HSV, BVB, S04
Übt erstmal Elmeterschiessen bevor ihr über uns spottet.
Simon Severial 😂😂
Simon Severial Gewinnt erstmal 2 Weltkriege 😂😂😂
Thomas Hlubek
Pff, ohne die Amis wärt ihr deutsch. Die haben euch beim D-Day massiv unterstützt. Ohne die seit ihr nur ein paar Inselaffen.
pff .. zu dritt habt ihr nur gewonnen .. wenn ihr allein waert .. waere dein schoenes london jetzt deutsch ;)
Wir haben unser London alleine gegen Deutschland verteidigt, die Hawker-Typhoons und die Spitfires haben die Deutschen selbstständig zurückgeschlagen, im Battle of Britain wie in El Alamein. Außerdem waren die Deutschen selbst schuld daran, drei Supermachten gegen sich aufgebracht zu haben, und sie hatten ja auch noch Italien und Japan als Verbündete, waren also selbst zu dritt ;-)
How's this even a question Hahahahahahahha, Germans win everyday
John Smith you cany compare two different football cultures
@@benedictcase4290 why
German :P
Went over to Germany at easter and took in a game at Schalke - the atmosphere was electric and better than what I have seen in the premier league
English People fans are nice People and fans. They are singing loudly and nice, but I think the German ones are better( I think not only because of the standingplaces) Both have great fans! Greetings from a german! :D
I just think if clubs in England lowered prices then we'd be back on your level, cos before the ticket prices got inflated English fans were on your level and we still have fans on your level; proven internationally so hopefully we'll get £20's plenty rolling soon
Oliver Diaper Maybe! ;D That may be!
THANK YOU! someone with a brain!!!!!!!! plus our lower league fans are very good. I support Preston, should come and watch us one time at an away game ;)
A Man I think iv seen pne home and away ur fans are shite
Noobschrauber CPFC are probably the only fans that England can compare to you, but still BVB, St Pauli, Dynamo Dresden and Eintracht Frankfurt are way ahead of Crystal Palace.
german supporters are a lot better but english are kind of... crazy
crazy? wtf? they are fucking low boring shit
+Topvidi just look at france at the moment
+Jacob Kolbeck not all of them are only some
guter kommentar, schlechter verein #muc
Der Boss :*
In Club support we germans are better.In Nationalteam support is England better.
derBengel07 ! because nationalteam football is shit
Uvuvwevwevwewevw Onyetenevevwe Ugwemube the england national team fans are better than the German national team fans. The German club fans are better than the English club fans
@@DomAFC9 Thats true although it does depend on the club, in the prem crystal palace has really good fans Liverpool do as well at big games at anfield and European nights but the best of english fans you get in the lower leagues
I’m English and have just been to my first match in Germany. I’ve got to say I was really impressed with the level of support
Equal passion, just different culture. Love to both from the Netherlands 🇳🇱🇳🇱🇳🇱
On their day English fans can easily outshine German fans. However, German fans do what they do week in, week out, whereas English fans only shine in the big occasions (eg; UCL). Liverpool and Palace fans are the only two sets of fans that I’d consider as good as any set of a German fans
Difference is in England football tickets are astronomically high and all the grounds are full of prawn sandwich eating corporate ticket holding wankers most of the real football fans have been forced to watch the games at home or in pubs and we still give anyone a run for there money when it comes to singing and supporting imagine what it would be like if the teams cared about the working class and real fans for example look at what it was like in the 70s and 80s legendary
If our ticket prices were lower then we would be far better than the germans
German fans are fighting for things like that. If it bothers you, do something against it and don't just accept it.
@@wingo8317 Exactly, but they don't because they have no fan culture in England so buying a €50 player will come before match day experience. We don't have teams as good as UK but will always have more fun at games & better atmosphere
Then you just ve just missed to fight against all this about what you re complaining about. That's what we Germans do for years now.
DEUTSCHLAND!!!
German fans now are like English fans in the 70s and 80s. England used to have the best fans but nowadays there’s no question. It’s Germany. From an English fan
The difference is English people only support and sings when their teams are winning. German fans will support even with a 8-0 defeat…
German spectators aren't even fans, they're ultras.
You got it
germans by far
One thing's for sure, the English & the German fans are more like brothers than enemy's these days and that makes me smile, and don't forget, we both have a common enemy now but that is a different story altogether. :)
Club football: German fans
International football: England
Never
@@timoderso8443 Natürlich machen die bessere Stimmung als wir (international)
der Dfb lässt nur event fans im stadion bei Länderspielen
@@VFL-el3dk eben des mein ich
If English clubs employed MC's with a microphone to encourage fans to sing and dance, and also charged between 9-20 euros for a ticket, then yes England would still have the best fans.
Haha ultras! You mean wannabe hooligans. And yes actually some clubs pay their MCs to sing all match.
"england would still have best fans" hahaha, so cute.... england fans are shit and will be shit
***** In your dreams little boy.
yes and in reality too honey
england will have best fans? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
Germany have the best supporters
As a German you got me at "Two world wars and one world cup" :'D
Mich auch
English fans have the better chants and songs but german fans pretty much sing all game. National team it's a different story, the england national team have the best fans in the world. Also i don't know why we are comparing these 2 fans, most of the hardcore english fans are banned from attending any stadium, ultras are not allowed in england and don't get me started on ticket prices which just attract armchair fans.
English Fans dont have the better chants...
Its always the same fucking Rythm
@@nilsmullhauser2839 Germans have like only 2 or 3chants and they only say like 1word heres a example ohohhoohhhhohh Bayern muchen ohohhohhohhoo just used that as a example.In fact that goes for ultras of other countries too not just germans english come up with the most creative chants as do scotland,ireland,wales etc We english have like 30chants
Long live the most beautiful and greatest sport in the planet. Huge respect for both great loyal fans, UK and Germany.
German all the way
German fans all the way! SGE 4 EVER! From Melbourne Australia.
YOU ONLY SING WHEN YOU'RE WINNING!
man muss sagen bei deutschland wurden auch nicht die heftigsten fans gewählt
So funny that begin of the video. I love it! Greetz from the Netherlands Ajax :)
German
English football, the higher echelons anyway, are deserts when it comes to atmosphere. The players are overpayed, the tickets overpriced and clubs are little more than rich men's toys. I've been to many games in Germany and the atmosphere is incredible, clubs are communities and it costs a fraction to attend. You won't see stadia emptying 15 minutes before the end or players wandering off to cuddle their wallets instead of applauding the fans.
asking who is better without the best german supporters from eintracht frankfurt and dynamo dresden? are u fking kidding me?
its two completely different footballing cultures, you cant compare them
Really..then why do defender and strikers ..not to mention middle fielders compete for the ballon dd'or yet they play in total different positions?..if an orange grows one one tree ...you telling us that you cant compare it to oranges from another tree coz the trees are different or in different locations..JUST KEEP QUIET
This video isn't about players or ballon d'ors. It's about fan culture and the way they behave. Unlucky mate
Chelsea home and away its difficult yeah
That's another way of saying English are half hearted and Germans are better
not really though is it.. plus our lower league fans are 10x better than your or any other countries lower league fans. Maybe come back when you know a bit more
so i really liked the clip t 6:23 but when you make such a viedeo you have to show the fans of Dynamo Dresden because they have the best fanbase in the world (for example they ere in third league and the whole satdium was full (30.000 places) btw sorry for my bad english
Justus Nauer Und jetzt ? 2.Liga immernoch 30.000. zB VfB Stuttgart doppelt so viel. Die besten Fans ja.
Riptex #TeamLitten alter du kannst doch nicht Dresden mit Stuttgart vergleichen 😂
teamlitten dresden hat bessere fans als der vfb
Justus Nauer haha jo klar
. Sieht man
jo guck dir mal den auswärtssupport inner dritten liga an, bei großaspach, das ist einzigartig
In Deutschland gibt es nunmal sowas wie Fankultur... Klar ist England International besser aber da ist alles so Kommerzialisiert, das ist krank...
Ultras in germany are more free than in England.Those English fans who want to see football and great supporting are go to Germany.
If ticket prices were lower in England, and flares, loudspeakers, and lesser health and safety concerns were allowed I honestly reckon the English would be better
Fc Köln🔴⚪️🔥🔥
official flerwear Scheiß FC Köln
@@felixbayer0485 Derbysieger effzeh
Eine Bande für immer
fortuna düsseldorf ♡
Come on fc köln 1. Fc Köln du bist mein verein ich liebe dich
❤
Grüße vom dortmund fan
💛🖤
This question can easily be answered if you just look at European games when Dortmund, Schalke or Bayern come to England. They're just on another level.
I think both sets of fans are the best in Europe. To everyone talking about Ultras, we used to have football firms, which made it dangerous to go to matches. That was about 20-30 years ago, though. Everyone gets banned now or can't afford tickets.
Germany
bei 2:20 bekomme ich als FC fan auch noch 7 Jahre später Gänsehaut
The best choreographics in the world are made by Hamburger SV in Germany. Just look at them if u won't believe me.
Nikolas Flake i look at them, and i was crying because of laughing 😂😂
Chadh YT Whos better?
the best German Choreos were made by Frankfurt and Dresden.
Chadh YT i cant fully agree becoz Hamburg is making many more and bigger choreos
No doubt that Germany has got better fans!
Club Support definetly we Germans better!
The Club Support in England dies or rather "Fans became customers" really sad.
easy:
Cub level: Germany.
National: England.
Police have killed hooliganism in England
German: better atmosphere than the english but the chants are boring
English football has great supporters and awesome chants. But the FA do what they can to screw them. High ticket prices, seats only, the teams belong to some non-attached investors.
German teams have 50+1 to protect them from such bs. Prices are at least payable and they still have very affordable "Stehplätze". Fan culture is also threatened in Germany, but the fans haven't been effed over as much as in the UK.
So BuLi is better, but only because of all the restrictions laid upon the British fans. All because of money 😑
Germany by a country mile. Been over for a few games and it's amazing. Every single stadium have been to has an ultras section that's loud as fuck. In England most stadiums are souless librarys. In Germany it's for the fans in England it's for greedy owners.
I heard that there are no english football supporters in stadiums, because they can't afford to pay for the tickets.
This is pretty much true the FA are a mess most real football fans have been forced out the grounds in England due to ticket prices
Thats true thats why you get the best of english fans in the lower leagues
Ahhh why have this comparison, together, Europeans are unstoppable!!!
I'm English but Germany smash us for atmosphere. Although if Crystal Palace had more Ultras they'd be contenders. But still wouldn't beat the top 8 German ultras.
The culture is Different
Deuchland🇩🇪❤️
I love the English football fans! Both are amazing! Greetings from Germany :)
Im a German and i find the english shants are great ,is so funny ;)
Germans and I'm English.
English teams normally only sing away and German fans are more true than ours.
And I've been to a Match at anfield and you couldn't even hear YNWA because they got outsung by my team (who are league 2) even though it was full attendance
Am Ende: Wer wählen Sie?😂😂😂😂😂
I just think it's different. The German way is more choreographed whereas the English is more organic. That being said, 3,500 thousand England fans out sang the Germans in Berlin and bvb wilted under the atmosphere at Anfield whereas Liverpool weren't affected by the yellow wall. I'd say that when the English are good they're better but the Germans are more consistent and that's down to English prices. I like them both though.
you cant not compare national team and clubs in germany.
+Topvidi I didn't. I compared England fans to Germany fans and bvb to Liverpool. I also said its just different, not better.
the german ultras hate the german officials. thats why there was nothing from the germans in berlin.
+MyCleminator thanks. Finally someone mentioned. The ultras from the 2nd division teams in germany would fuck the premier league clubs
you will NEVER hear any atmosphere in German national team home games any more. Why? german ultras and true football fans boycott those games. In the stadium there are sitting only familiy and event fans. If you want a taste of German atmosphere whatch a Frankfurt, Rostock or Dresden Game, those are the best in Germany, check them out
I'm a Bradford city fan and I didn't expect to come watch this video and see Bradford beating arsenal (3rd video) 2nd English one
from England... but admit that the Germans are better , only just...
even a blind men know that german fan are best
Of course German football fans, but NOTHING beats the YNWA in Liverpool
+flo25merzifari in dortmund is louder :P
lol in dortmund it sucks^^
in kaiserslautern is the best lol
ne bei dynamo ihr luschen und ich sag das als herthafan
Achso weil Dynamo ynwa singt oder ?....
Deutsch
Great fans all round on both sides, I'm not a fan of maintaing the singing all game though, its better when the crowd play to the game for me. I like the groans and when the footballs shit, theres that silence that lets the players know they ain't performing, then the burst. Prefer English fans (cos Im bias) but mad respect for the Germans!
4:54 you should have taken the block flag in Dresden 4 years ago
schalke when all light in the arena turn off and the fans are singing das steigerlied (an old miner song)
Club Germany/ National England
Totally agree
Yes agree with you
looking forward to the friendly next week . i will be there signing my heart out for my country
A very big difference:
German fans put all their energy in singing praises and motivational songs for their team in the name of support
English fans put all their energy in offensive songs and chants for their opponents in the same of support
YNWA at anfield is something special.
Premier League Cant have good Fans behause its too commerical
Philipp Müller thats a stupid statement mate have you seen the atmosphere in the kop
Prices and the fact there's no safe standing have had a huge impact on PL so that most games are not the real fans but tourists or corporate. Conversely the atmosphere tends to be better in Championship and EFL in general as more true fans go. German club fans have no such problems so obv during club games the atmosphere is better. Nationally England is far better, much more humour, creativity and numbers. Imagine if the team was any good!
In England sind die Karten für Ultras zu teuer, genauso wie in Spanien
Anglo German Cup or British German Cup by Rory Smith.
I am putting forward a new football trophy that could give extra games to English and German teams, plus invited teams from other nations.
The motivation.
England and Germany have a very strong football rivalry, and two of the strongest, if not the strongest leagues in European, and indeed world football. It is the equivalent of a derby rivalry in international football like Scotland V England is.
My idea is to take advantage of this intense national rivalry by holing an Anglo German Cup, between club sides from the top division.
My preferred option would be for all clubs from the top divisions of the German Bundesliga and English Premier who have not qualified for Europe to play in a straight knockout tournament, of one leg each. The final could be played at Wembley each year.
Extra teams from Scotland and the other Germanic nations.
My idea would also include inviting from the Scottish league Glasgow Celtic, Glasgow Rangers, Hearts, Aberdeen and Hibernian into the trophy to give them experience each year guaranteed to playing big non Scottish clubs. It would be the same Scottish teams invited regardless of league position to ensure big games for the big Scottish sides.
Plus we could also invite more teams from the other Germanic nations to take part, such as from German speaking Switzerland, the famous team Basle, and from German speaking Austria, Rapid Vienna, and Salzburg.
Teams who qualify for Europe are punished in Europe
One problem with English football is that teams who succeed, and qualify for Europe, are almost punished the next season because the next season, so they are almost punished for qualifying for Europe. This trophy would ensure they play more games, even if they do not qualify for the Europa League and Champions League.
Scottish teams would love this trophy
I think Scottish teams would love to play in this trophy because they would love the guarantee of each year playing big English and German sides. As an Aberdeen fan I would love my team to be guaranteed games against big English sides every year. I would also be happy for Scottish teams to have to qualify for the trophy with say the first 4 teams in the Scottish Premier qualifying.
Glamour Games
Imagine mouth watering games like Southampton v Hamburg, Basle v Swansea City, West Brom v Augsburg, Stuttgart v Stoke City, Eintracht Frankfurt v Everton, Hertha Berlin v Aberdeen, and Werder Bremen v Glasgow Rangers.
I think this would be an interesting experience of European cross border football for big English Premier teams who often despite being in the top league, can often go 10 years without playing a side from another nations league.
The final could be at Wembley Stadium every year.
The games would be intense, passionate and with Scotland and Germany, as two of England’s biggest international derby rivals.
The number of teams in the trophy could be flexible with even the possibility of inviting the big Dutch teams. Such as Ajax and PSV into the trophy. The Dutch have a big rivalry with the Germans. Some Germans see the Netherlands as their biggest football rivalry, but the Dutch clubs are not as big in financial terms as the
Why invite Celtic and Rangers?
I think inviting Celtic and Rangers into the trophy would be vital to add extra big teams into the trophy, who are guaranteed to bring big travelling supports. It could add prestige to the trophy and extra Scotland England rivalry would add to the trophy.
I accept that in the early rounds, teams might not get big crowds. For instance top English sides might not take playing my favourite team Aberdeen, or Basle, as a big game and would probably get lower crowds than they do in the Premier League. But as the trophy goes on the games would get bigger. If 70,000 fans can turn up for the lower division English trophies then surely can get big crowds for big English Premier and German Bundesliga sides. Also for clubs from Scotland and Austria this would be a massive trophy. So stadiums would be packed. Cup games are more interesting than league football in my view. Winning a cup is more interesting than any league position other than champions or relegation.
Not a replacement for European football
I am not suggesting that this trophy would be instead of Europa League and Champions League football. Scottish, English, German and Austria teams would still enter sides in the Europa League and Champions League.
Would UEFA allow it?
I do not see why not. After all they have allowed the Royal League in Scandinavia and the Sentana Cup in Irish football, between two different leagues. It would not be a threat to the Europa League and Champions League. It would help Scotland and gives big English and German clubs who do not play in European football, some big games.
Another addition could be a British German Cup made up of all English Premier and German Bundesliga teams who have not qualified for Europe plus the top 4 sides of Scotland, and top 2 sides, each, of the Northern Ireland and Welsh leagues.
I would most prefer a British German Cup, with Scottish, Welsh, English, Northern Irish and German sides. It would make the season more fun.
Diolch
Da Boch
That is Welsh.
BL Fans>PL Fans, but I would say English national team Fans>German national team fans.
Both have great fans, not Like italy or spain.
Banning orders and tourists stop the English culture from getting close.
I think English football fans appreciate that Germany’s football culture has got it right. Where as the money in the premier league is getting ridiculous and prices out the proper fans and has led to the sanitisation of English Football.
Proper support is punished in the Top division, the lower division the more relaxed it gets that’s why the atmosphere weekly is better where as big games are very good on top division only due to the bigger Stadia. Liverpool vs Man U /Steel City derby as an example.
I’d love to hear people’s opinions
Liverpool fan.
Germany!!
Prrmier leauge just consists of money
National Team: English Fans are better!
In the Country League: German Fans are better!
Die besten Fans gibt es immernoch in Dresden
German people(English, German ets) love football!
that dortmund tifo at 4:55 was crazy!
Both. You never walk alone is better Liverpool
In the desceiption you list the fans from England and Germany. You say that the german fans seen in this video are from Dortmund, Köln and Berlin. Why didn't you list Freiburg when the first segment is showing their fans?
"Two world wars and one world cup, England, England, two world wars and one world cup, England all the way" lol xD
In Germany the supporters can use more pyro than im England.English ultras can do louder,but German supporters can do beautifuller.
Eh?
Let me tell you,I am not English or American,I'm learning English.So I could done grammar mistakes.
That's sounds great :) Tell me it isn't a joke
And Happy new year.
And the slang is one of my biggest weak point.So what does the "best stick to your own language" sentence mean?
United fans fans are the best of England and I'm a spurs fans in club football it would have to be the Germans but in countries none there both crap and I'm English the best of the countries is Irish fans
as an Englishman I'd have to say the Kraut's are better fans now but couldn't come anywhere near the English in the 70s and 80s
The Germans and English are brothers.
No fans sing “you’ll never walk alone” better than Liverpool fans