@@douglasgarcia4051 Perdón pero tu comentario es un poco estúpido la verdad. Si Floor estuviera gritando esas notas sonarían desafinadas y sus cuerdas vocales estarían destruidas. Lo que ella hace se llama "belting" por si no lo sabías, en cambio Tarja canta en un estilo mas "operático" y por eso suenan tan distintas.
Tarja has the emotion and the unique classical tone within her voice. Floor has the power and extra flare in her voice that gives a live performance that extra punch. Each singer is better and worse in different ways. But they are both Nightwish to me :)
@@Rock-Metal91 you're no better. You just took their extreme to you. While clearly the emotion eschews for floor it's definitely there with tarja. And part of that is because it's a little harder putting as much manipulation and colors when you sing in that classical wide open area Tarja almost strictly uses.... but in recent years she has made great progress and learning her chest voice.
@@dalia1598 tú flipas. Ninguna de las dos son imitables. Menuda potencia tiene Floor, prueba a cantar así durante 2 horas y me cuentas, que no es nada fácil
Tarja sounds effortlessly and not forceful . Her voice shows restrain as it is nowhere near her limits. It gives the song grace and depth so naturally .
Elle Engel you are right, but Floor have a versatile voice, she can sing almost everything and adds a rock flavourTarja is ok, nothing to complain, but I like Floor more.
Sé que Floor tiene mucha fuerza en su voz, pero todavía me quedo impactada cuando veo que Tarja canta de esa forma tan única y es como si no le costara para nada!.
liricobarroco no confundas las cosas. Tarja canta en falsete. Floor no. No es falta de tecnica no cantar en falsete ni tampoco cantar en falcete es igual a tener tecnica vocal.
hugokraven para empezar los dos están mal. liricobarroco Floor Jansen lo que más tiene es técnica porque domina muchos estilos de canto: lírico y operístico, belting (que es el que usa en la canción), contemporáneo y el llamado "popular" que combina muchas veces con una voz más rockera. Hugo, Tarja no canta con falsette, ella canta con voz lírica completamente, porque su voz tiene un entrenamiento clásico, es una cantante básica de opera (no es la mejor, pero es muy buena)
@@dalia1598 JAJA Princesita d Disney? debes ser la unica que la ve asi. Ya la llamaram de DIosa, Amazonas, Guerrera y otras cosas mas .. pero nunca oi princesita. Por cierto, desde luego se ve que no entiendes nada de nada lo que dices. Solo para acabar, y para que veas como estas equivocada, Floor consigue cantar facilmente como Tarja devido a su versatilidad vocal. Dudo el opuesto. Comparar las dos es estupido, pero no tan estupido como decir que Floor tienes voz de Princesita de Disney. Ambas son DIosas, y con voces magistrales. No las comparen, disfruta de ambas. Te gusta mas Tarja, ok es un gusto, a mi me gusta mas Floor para Nightwish. Mas una vez, son gustos personales, y valen lo que valen :)
@@kikexd22 si sobre todo en el minuto 4.9 al 4.30 donde la mejor nececita la voz de de Marco para sonar mejor y FLOOR se baraja sola con su pontente voz jajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajjajajajjajajajajajajajajajaj
@@jhansr.miranda1869 tarja no necesita ayuda, ella sigue en melodia y constante, Floor sólo grito más que es muy diferente, las dos son buenas a su estilo, no necesitan de la otra.
This is fucking perfect. Both of them do an amazing job in this song and when Marko hit the chorus along with the girls I completely lost it. Awesome video man!
Great job showcasing two phenomenal talents! The elegance and grace of Tarja Turunen side by side with the majesty and power of Floor Jansen! Then there's the incomparable Marco Hietala to tie it all together! Thank you for the vision to create this AND for doing it as skillfully as you did.
Excellent editing and blending of the two songs. The band is so consistent. The blended parts with both Tarja and Floor are so lovely. This song, and this version of it makes me happy.
wow when i heard floor i thought what a perfect vibratto and nice intro, spot on singing. but when i heard tarja i felt this STRONG shivers down my spine! I really enjoyed the combination of these two.... really a killer combo.
Actually shows how important the band’s dedication to following its click track has become. They repeat the quality every time regardless of the song, singers or players! The lead singer is the storyteller and adds their own color but the over all tone remains the same! Tuomas is a genius and perhaps the visionary that keeps them on track?
Floor is great no doubt about that, but this is Tarja's song. If you want the best version of this song from Tarja you have to see the concert in Lowlands.
Jurgen Ibro It's not written by Tarja, but by Tuomas. You may feel that it's her song because she was the first to sing it, but that doesn't give someone owners right. Floor adds emotion and power to this song. Tarja sings this in her opera style, which portrays her voice well, but it detracts from the song. It's a very sad song but I don't hear that with Tarja, all I hear is her doing her thing, a lot of lyrics you can't decipher, bad pronunciation and that opera style voice without versatility.
I love how Tarja actually let Marco sing the Main Voice in the last Chorus and let him have his moment in the climax of the song... This was the magic of the old Nightwish.
Quoth Peter Venkman....WE HAVE GOT TO GET THESE TWO TOGETHER!!!! Of all your Tarja/Floor duets I've watched this one IMO shows how amazingly their voices complement each other!
I dont care which one is the best Tarja, Floor or even Anette. I dont waste my time in stupid discussions without sense cause I love Nightwish and I admire with all my spirit the art of Tuomas. I just wanted to say thank you, thank you so much Pantherapardus2012 for this!
I honestly love both versions but I love this duet even more. I just wished they would sing this song together. At the end Tarja and Floor begin singing the same thing and then when they say “entwined in finding you one day” they sing in different registers. Tarja sings lower notes and Floor sings higher notes. And then Marko’s voice is just magical!!! Having three voices harmonizing gives an extra something to an already amazing song!!! It gives me Goosebumps!!!
Tarja's voice is so much darker, unique and powerful but floor's voice is also special. I like more tarja because she remains powerful in the whole song, not like floor that waits until the end to show all her potential. I really enjoy listening to the both voices together, amazing singers. :D thank you for uploading this video
I've loved this song since I first heard it and to this day nothing has changed and it never will... and the duet of Floor and Tarja makes it even better! 🔥❤👏
4:15 en adelante... se escucha una hermosa cancion... con unos feos gritos que salen de vez en cuando... Tarja si sabe como darle a cada cancion emocion propia sin andar gritando mas de la cuenta
estoy totalmente en desacuerdo contigo, y eso es lo bueno de poder opinar con libertad. Esta canción al igual que con Ghost Love Score queda perfecta con la voz mas estridente y versátil de Floor. En gustos y colores...
Aqui vemos como Floor se parte en dos para cantar una cancion tan simple y Tarja unicamente usa el 30% de su voz! Tarja es una Diosa, sus estudios universitarios de canto lirico la hacen tener el control absoluto de su instrumento!
liricobarroco asi es, ademas no he querido decir antes que floor no pueda cantar bien esta cancion, sino que en su intento de mejorarla le quita su verdadera alma
There's is no screaming. A good singer projects their voice well, it's the hallmark of all good metal singers. Tarja's projection was average at best and ran out of gas easily.
Todas as músicas cantadas por Tarja, não consigo houver na voz na Floor sem criar comparações.. Mas... esse dueto que você montou, ficou de parabéns!!!
I would like a version where they sing together the whole song through. I know how each of them sounds separately but they singing at the same time is the plus here.
Son excelentes las dos!!! Sin embargo en mi opinión, lo característico de este estilo de música es una voz operística. Le da ese acento "épico". Floor ya no cubre su voz, para que suene agresiva.. y lo hace bien ... ¡¡¡Pero para eso ya está Marco!! Yo esperaría que siga en Nightwish pero me gustaría que optara por un estilo más operístico (que ya sabemos que lo puede hacer). Porque creo que una de las cosas que más sedujo de nightwish en los comienzos fue utilizar una voz operística como la de Tarja. Por eso la gente luego no quería a Annette.. Pero bueno... Es mi opinión
Coincido contigo. Tarja tiene el estilo que identificó a Nightwish. Pero en mi opinión la versión de Floor tiene mucha más fuerza y es la que a mi personalmente me gusta más por qué Floor la hizo a su estilo y me transmite mucha emoción.
@@kugo2673 Ella arruina las canciones de Tarja, pareciera que quiere cambiar la canción y hacerla más cool, como su antigua banda, para no parecerse a Tarja, como no la dejan componer, Tomas es un imbécil, obvio que se aburre y algo tiene que aportar a la banda, es la realidad, solo puede usar su voz, para estar en Nigthwish sigues muchas reglas rídiculas, nunca se vio un cantante no aportar nada a su composición.
Grita!! Ojojojojo eso se llama tecnica de belter, imitar a Tarja imposible pero imitar a Floor es aun peor de hacer!!! Tanta versatilidad en su voz y no reconocer la voz de floor es que tienen un oído lleno de cerilla !!!
I'm more amazed that Marco sounds the same, sings the same, and holds the notes for the same length in both versions. Hell, he even fist pumps at the same time at 3:56 ! But for me, Floor wins this one. I love Tarja, but Floor brings more emotion and range to this song for me, especially in the ending. I love how desperate she sounds when she nearly screams the high notes
I'm so proud cause this is not another video where people are just comparing themselves. both are amazing singers and this is a great video. Best voices ever!
Tarja made me fall in love with the band, and I think her distinctive sound will always be my favourite, but Floor is very, very good too. We're blessed to have them both to enjoy.
Great duet..... When the music reaches such levels... No discussion on who's the best. Tarja and floor are the best nightwish could get.......all their albums give the same adrenalin.
Wow Tarja ¡es gloriosa!, con todo el respeto que se merece Floor ya que es una magnífica cantante pero la fuerza y la naturalidad en la interpretación del canto de Tarja es incomparable, la extraño, que grandiosas ambas 🖤
+burntham113 Except the warble isn't supposed to be there. Her technique is poor so she can't control her vibrato. It must be extremely hard to do since she's been working at it for 18 + years and it still sounds like her first day. She should hire Lori Lewis to give her some training.
4:10 is where the real magic happens, wish people realised how powerful this band is when these three vocalists come together, none trying to be better than the other because they're all friends, all different voices and techniques. I believe one day this will happen live. Just wish Marko sang the ending of Wacken version too, as he did with Tarja - Floor carried it so beautifully by herself but he just adds so much with his voice. They're truly at their best when together.
@@TerranigmaQuintet TARJA'S songs. Doesn't matter who wrote them she made the songs take off, she still can sing any of HER songs at her own concerts though so it's cool. Floor singing something like Sleeping Sun is garbage, only Tarja can sing it right
@@Stej-i7m Your opinion, not factual. In the end Nightwish owns the songs, Tuomas wrote them, so they get to decide here, not you. Be glad they let Tarja do them on her solo tours.
@@nicholew350 It's because she's using chest voice, Tarja did not, she can't, her chest voice is under developed. Floor could sing with head voice of Tarja, would be interesting, but head voice is Tarja's thing...
@@theother9868 poor undereducated twat…. listening to music... pretending to love it and not even able to see the difference between screaming and singing ….sad
The vast majority of comments are saying Floor did way better but I'd like to remain neutral. I love both of them and I love fan-made duets like this so thank you so much for making them! :D
Great job putting together these two performances. Still need to consider the difference of sound recording capabilities between the almost two decades.
2:38 Floor llega con lo justo. Tarja llega tranquila. Las dos son grandes cantantes, pero Tarja es unica. Y Floor canta sin explotar toda su voz lirica para mi, la hacen cantar de una manera que esta como contenida. Para MI tendria que hacerlo como lo hacia en "Leaden Legacy" o en "Intrinsic".
Definitely agreed. It's already an epic song, but having both of them (and Marco) going at it like they might die if they hold back even an ounce of passion is just... well, there's a reason I've listened to this so many times.
Marco's duet with himself is the best part
I am agree
sacrament48
nice to meet you Agree, i am Jorgen.
Hilarious! :)
Marco is the best Nightwish singer ever
mc23243 Marco! Marco! Marco!
The best part when Floor, Tarja and Marco sings together. They're all awesome
Agree!
Floor jansen mucho grita que asco mi cielo
Scream a lot 😂🤦♂️
@@douglasgarcia4051 Perdón pero tu comentario es un poco estúpido la verdad. Si Floor estuviera gritando esas notas sonarían desafinadas y sus cuerdas vocales estarían destruidas. Lo que ella hace se llama "belting" por si no lo sabías, en cambio Tarja canta en un estilo mas "operático" y por eso suenan tan distintas.
@@mill2326 grita eso hace floor su belting es horrible tanto así q se escucha cómo q hace demasiado esfuerzo.
Tarja has the emotion and the unique classical tone within her voice.
Floor has the power and extra flare in her voice that gives a live performance that extra punch.
Each singer is better and worse in different ways. But they are both Nightwish to me :)
Emotion and Tarja should NOT come into the same sentence.
@@Rock-Metal91 you're no better. You just took their extreme to you.
While clearly the emotion eschews for floor it's definitely there with tarja. And part of that is because it's a little harder putting as much manipulation and colors when you sing in that classical wide open area Tarja almost strictly uses.... but in recent years she has made great progress and learning her chest voice.
Tarja one trick, Floor can sing all.
@@dalia1598 tú flipas. Ninguna de las dos son imitables. Menuda potencia tiene Floor, prueba a cantar así durante 2 horas y me cuentas, que no es nada fácil
Marco is Best
Tarja sounds effortlessly and not forceful . Her voice shows restrain as it is nowhere near her limits. It gives the song grace and depth so naturally .
Tarja is whit Brintney spears in the Pop
For years I've been trying to explain what is so magical in Tarja's voice. Now you explainded it so well. So correct !
Luka Bulatovic That was so kind of you to say,thank you so much !~~
Elle Engel you are right, but Floor have a versatile voice, she can sing almost everything and adds a rock flavourTarja is ok, nothing to complain, but I like Floor more.
Dorin Petru well said and a good point.
These girls really can SING🎤🎶
Old Marco - New Marco: Best duet ever.
+Xbitrate I think Marco actually got better.
Do we have to debate which one is better? :(
you mean young Marco and old Marco
@@fantasy-or3pi jajajaaa, good question!
Sé que Floor tiene mucha fuerza en su voz, pero todavía me quedo impactada cuando veo que Tarja canta de esa forma tan única y es como si no le costara para nada!.
A eso que hace Tarja, se le llama técnica vocal! Floor jansen nunca ha sido tan buena técnicamente pero hace lo que puede con la canción...
liricobarroco no confundas las cosas. Tarja canta en falsete. Floor no. No es falta de tecnica no cantar en falsete ni tampoco cantar en falcete es igual a tener tecnica vocal.
hugokraven para empezar los dos están mal. liricobarroco Floor Jansen lo que más tiene es técnica porque domina muchos estilos de canto: lírico y operístico, belting (que es el que usa en la canción), contemporáneo y el llamado "popular" que combina muchas veces con una voz más rockera. Hugo, Tarja no canta con falsette, ella canta con voz lírica completamente, porque su voz tiene un entrenamiento clásico, es una cantante básica de opera (no es la mejor, pero es muy buena)
@@geelicon eso es verdad totalmente de acuerdo
@@dalia1598 JAJA Princesita d Disney? debes ser la unica que la ve asi. Ya la llamaram de DIosa, Amazonas, Guerrera y otras cosas mas .. pero nunca oi princesita. Por cierto, desde luego se ve que no entiendes nada de nada lo que dices. Solo para acabar, y para que veas como estas equivocada, Floor consigue cantar facilmente como Tarja devido a su versatilidad vocal. Dudo el opuesto. Comparar las dos es estupido, pero no tan estupido como decir que Floor tienes voz de Princesita de Disney. Ambas son DIosas, y con voces magistrales. No las comparen, disfruta de ambas. Te gusta mas Tarja, ok es un gusto, a mi me gusta mas Floor para Nightwish. Mas una vez, son gustos personales, y valen lo que valen :)
Tarja le da un estilo más oscuro a nightwish
Floor le da un toque más rudo
@@dalia1598 Tarja le da el toque gótico lírico por el cual se conoció nightwish❤
Mil veces Tarja
@@kikexd22 si sobre todo en el minuto 4.9 al 4.30 donde la mejor nececita la voz de de Marco para sonar mejor y FLOOR se baraja sola con su pontente voz jajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajajjajajajjajajajajajajajajajaj
@@jhansr.miranda1869 tarja no necesita ayuda, ella sigue en melodia y constante, Floor sólo grito más que es muy diferente, las dos son buenas a su estilo, no necesitan de la otra.
Tienes toda la razón yo pienso igual no me gusta que grite siento que arruina la elegancia de la canción
damn, when they sing together, the harmony of their voices sounds so beautiful T_T I wanna cry
This is fucking perfect. Both of them do an amazing job in this song and when Marko hit the chorus along with the girls I completely lost it. Awesome video man!
04:10... - Floor Jansen - power winner!
Floor sound epic and Tarja sang so well, great singers ever. I'm really excited, great job.
Great job showcasing two phenomenal talents! The elegance and grace of Tarja Turunen side by side with the majesty and power of Floor Jansen! Then there's the incomparable Marco Hietala to tie it all together! Thank you for the vision to create this AND for doing it as skillfully as you did.
As duas são maravilhosas,mas a tarja é incrível 😍
verdade S2
Excellent editing and blending of the two songs. The band is so consistent. The blended parts with both Tarja and Floor are so lovely. This song, and this version of it makes me happy.
wow when i heard floor i thought what a perfect vibratto and nice intro, spot on singing. but when i heard tarja i felt this STRONG shivers down my spine! I really enjoyed the combination of these two.... really a killer combo.
Ahh, as duas são excepcionais rsrs Tarja tem um pé na ópera e Floor no heavy, não dá pra comparar vocais tão distintos e tão bons @_@ eu fico louca
Se juntar as duas fica um bagulho doido
@@cerberusrjвам надо развивать мозг чтобы Окружающий мир не казался беспорядком
Флор Легко поёт оперой (впрочем как любой выпускник консерватории, А вот тарья ничего кроме оперы не умеет)
Тарья не умеет гроулить (и т д).
Actually shows how important the band’s dedication to following its click track has become. They repeat the quality every time regardless of the song, singers or players! The lead singer is the storyteller and adds their own color but the over all tone remains the same! Tuomas is a genius and perhaps the visionary that keeps them on track?
From around 4:00 and there on it really shows how much more power and energy Floor brings to this song. And it lifts the song up.
floors versions is better than tarja's ,maybe just taste about type voice
hollandkevinholland * i think
Floor is great no doubt about that, but this is Tarja's song. If you want the best version of this song from Tarja you have to see the concert in Lowlands.
Jurgen Ibro It's not written by Tarja, but by Tuomas. You may feel that it's her song because she was the first to sing it, but that doesn't give someone owners right.
Floor adds emotion and power to this song. Tarja sings this in her opera style, which portrays her voice well, but it detracts from the song. It's a very sad song but I don't hear that with Tarja, all I hear is her doing her thing, a lot of lyrics you can't decipher, bad pronunciation and that opera style voice without versatility.
Too screamed... it lost the sence when floor screams and headbangs in every single song...
Floor lo hace bien pero Tarja me encanta!
I think after Ghost Love Score, this may be the best "duet" you've made yet, thanks!!
Me encantó el video buen trabajo te dejo tu like.
Psdta. TARJA FOR EVER 😍❤
I love how Tarja actually let Marco sing the Main Voice in the last Chorus and let him have his moment in the climax of the song... This was the magic of the old Nightwish.
Stop comparing this two great vocalists.The video title says, Tarja and Floor "DUET" not "DUEL" both of them are incredible amazing.
And after so many years, Marco still sounds awesome and the same :D
3:06 Floor diva moment. Loved it
Floor Jansen - winner!
@@abstracting6411
She always is
Классно звук наложили! Как буд-то и правда вместе поют. Звуковику респект!!!!
Поют по нотам.
У Тарьи уровень громкости выше выставлен.
@@abstracting6411 Но даже это не помешало Флор уйти в такие верха, что Тарье не снились. В финале Марко и Тарья конечно круто звучат.
Wow great job, two of the best. Amazing duo.
Tremendous video. And a dream that these superb singers will be on stage together someday. Extraordinary montage. THUMBS UP!!👍👍👍
Tarja te amo eres la mejor
Quoth Peter Venkman....WE HAVE GOT TO GET THESE TWO TOGETHER!!!! Of all your Tarja/Floor duets I've watched this one IMO shows how amazingly their voices complement each other!
I dont care which one is the best Tarja, Floor or even Anette. I dont waste my time in stupid discussions without sense cause I love Nightwish and I admire with all my spirit the art of Tuomas. I just wanted to say thank you, thank you so much Pantherapardus2012 for this!
Yeah, lets just appreciate Nightwish!
Hamster Munchies
Yes, but we can appreciate it better with Floor. Sorry, couldn't resist, lol
I honestly love both versions but I love this duet even more. I just wished they would sing this song together. At the end Tarja and Floor begin singing the same thing and then when they say “entwined in finding you one day” they sing in different registers. Tarja sings lower notes and Floor sings higher notes. And then Marko’s voice is just magical!!! Having three voices harmonizing gives an extra something to an already amazing song!!! It gives me Goosebumps!!!
Tarja's voice is so much darker, unique and powerful but floor's voice is also special. I like more tarja because she remains powerful in the whole song, not like floor that waits until the end to show all her potential. I really enjoy listening to the both voices together, amazing singers. :D thank you for uploading this video
Two Goddesses and another Great Voice for an Absolute song! Higher Music and... Divine performers!!! Something Unique!!! ❤💕❤💕❤💕❤💕❤💕❤💕❤
Gracias PRECIOSO . Qué bonito..💯💯💯💯❤❤❤❤
Ildivas.... jooooo qué pasen ala historia...PRECIOSO
Como sultana
두분다 너무나 훌륭한 가수고 돋보이는 아주 은혜로운 공연입니다 사랑해요 나이트위시
❤💘💘💘💗💗💗🌹👏👏👏
Это какой-то безумие
I've loved this song since I first heard it and to this day nothing has changed and it never will... and the duet of Floor and Tarja makes it even better! 🔥❤👏
They are both great, I hope to see them together one time on the stage. Plus they are good friends and they respect each other
The both are awesome! Great video!
Las dos mejores interpretaciones de nightwish jamas superadas, ambas en cada estilo.
El mejor comentario de eatas dos divas del metal!!** comparándolas??? Semejante herejía
4:15 en adelante... se escucha una hermosa cancion... con unos feos gritos que salen de vez en cuando... Tarja si sabe como darle a cada cancion emocion propia sin andar gritando mas de la cuenta
comentario*
estoy totalmente en desacuerdo contigo, y eso es lo bueno de poder opinar con libertad. Esta canción al igual que con Ghost Love Score queda perfecta con la voz mas estridente y versátil de Floor. En gustos y colores...
Aqui vemos como Floor se parte en dos para cantar una cancion tan simple y Tarja unicamente usa el 30% de su voz! Tarja es una Diosa, sus estudios universitarios de canto lirico la hacen tener el control absoluto de su instrumento!
liricobarroco asi es, ademas no he querido decir antes que floor no pueda cantar bien esta cancion, sino que en su intento de mejorarla le quita su verdadera alma
There's is no screaming. A good singer projects their voice well, it's the hallmark of all good metal singers. Tarja's projection was average at best and ran out of gas easily.
vine buscando cobre y encontre oro... creo que logran sacar lo mejor de ambas eras, es la colaboracion que jamas pudimos ver. me encanto :')
Todas as músicas cantadas por Tarja, não consigo houver na voz na Floor sem criar comparações..
Mas... esse dueto que você montou, ficou de parabéns!!!
I would like a version where they sing together the whole song through. I know how each of them sounds separately but they singing at the same time is the plus here.
Son excelentes las dos!!! Sin embargo en mi opinión, lo característico de este estilo de música es una voz operística. Le da ese acento "épico". Floor ya no cubre su voz, para que suene agresiva.. y lo hace bien ... ¡¡¡Pero para eso ya está Marco!! Yo esperaría que siga en Nightwish pero me gustaría que optara por un estilo más operístico (que ya sabemos que lo puede hacer). Porque creo que una de las cosas que más sedujo de nightwish en los comienzos fue utilizar una voz operística como la de Tarja. Por eso la gente luego no quería a Annette.. Pero bueno... Es mi opinión
Coincido contigo. Tarja tiene el estilo que identificó a Nightwish. Pero en mi opinión la versión de Floor tiene mucha más fuerza y es la que a mi personalmente me gusta más por qué Floor la hizo a su estilo y me transmite mucha emoción.
Floor trata de sonar mucho más potente como si en estás canciones se necesité eso, Tarja canta y floor grita. Arruinando el tema por completo.
@@kugo2673 Ella arruina las canciones de Tarja, pareciera que quiere cambiar la canción y hacerla más cool, como su antigua banda, para no parecerse a Tarja, como no la dejan componer, Tomas es un imbécil, obvio que se aburre y algo tiene que aportar a la banda, es la realidad, solo puede usar su voz, para estar en Nigthwish sigues muchas reglas rídiculas, nunca se vio un cantante no aportar nada a su composición.
Grita!! Ojojojojo eso se llama tecnica de belter, imitar a Tarja imposible pero imitar a Floor es aun peor de hacer!!! Tanta versatilidad en su voz y no reconocer la voz de floor es que tienen un oído lleno de cerilla !!!
Adele cantando.. Dicen como no baila no vale.. para mi es PRECIOSO .. pues los escenarios llenos....
floor have the best voice in the world........fantastic
I'm more amazed that Marco sounds the same, sings the same, and holds the notes for the same length in both versions. Hell, he even fist pumps at the same time at 3:56 !
But for me, Floor wins this one. I love Tarja, but Floor brings more emotion and range to this song for me, especially in the ending. I love how desperate she sounds when she nearly screams the high notes
Great Video work of the comparison of two great singers
I agree great work
I'm so proud cause this is not another video where people are just comparing themselves. both are amazing singers and this is a great video. Best voices ever!
Normal, Tarja como Diosa en el escenario jejeje
Hey que buenisimo quedó me gusta me gusta!
OMG! How have I not seen this yet??!!! Two of the greatest mixed together. Great job! Thank you!!!!
No comparison at all!! Both are GREAT!
Tarja made me fall in love with the band, and I think her distinctive sound will always be my favourite, but Floor is very, very good too. We're blessed to have them both to enjoy.
The perfection exists! Tarja + Floor + Marco .
Those two Lady's are amazing awesome Duet 🖤🖤👌👌👍👍 not ONLY them the Nightwish 👍👍👍👍
And this people is how to make an epic video! Thanks, man!
these videos are a labor of love … thank you for doing this …
The power of Floor's voice ♥️
great analysis, i think they sound absolutely perfect. beautiful voices....
Floor forever!!! \m/
+Niki \m/ She's the evolution of vocals. A true vocalist, not just a singer.
Great duet..... When the music reaches such levels... No discussion on who's the best. Tarja and floor are the best nightwish could get.......all their albums give the same adrenalin.
Wow Tarja ¡es gloriosa!, con todo el respeto que se merece Floor ya que es una magnífica cantante pero la fuerza y la naturalidad en la interpretación del canto de Tarja es incomparable, la extraño, que grandiosas ambas 🖤
You do such a perfect job. Amazing. Looking forward to see more duets. Greetings
Floor rocks!!
Floor Jansen - winner!
Just Amazing made. The Song is my Alltime Faforite and this mix up of Floor and Tarja my Two Faforite Female Metal Singers is just Owsome.
They should no be compared. They have very different singing styles and they are both awesome.
da pra amar todas as cantoras do Nightwish sem problemas
you can love all the Nightwish's singers easily
Tarja has an opera like warble in her voice, I love it. Floor is great too, but when I think early nightwish all I see is Tarja.
+burntham113 Except the warble isn't supposed to be there. Her technique is poor so she can't control her vibrato. It must be extremely hard to do since she's been working at it for 18 + years and it still sounds like her first day. She should hire Lori Lewis to give her some training.
Dave Mason
Who gets to say what should be in her music? You?
+Dave Mason do u sing? show us
+burntham113 she is classically trained that is why she sounds operatic!
burntham113 I have no interest in her music. I'm here because I'm interested in Nightwish's music. Her only music is her solo work and ........... meh
wow... congratulation my friend, excelent song and excelent video
Floor's performance is awesome!!!!
4:10 is where the real magic happens, wish people realised how powerful this band is when these three vocalists come together, none trying to be better than the other because they're all friends, all different voices and techniques. I believe one day this will happen live. Just wish Marko sang the ending of Wacken version too, as he did with Tarja - Floor carried it so beautifully by herself but he just adds so much with his voice. They're truly at their best when together.
Tarja sempre foi e sempre será a melhor vocalista de Nightwish !!
Absolutely gorgeous mix
great video! ... and Marco makes a duet with himeself :-D
Lol exactly my thoughts xD Well then his awesomeness is doubled, isnt it? :D
Dude 8 years apart and one of the best sounds my ears have ever heard
Tarja my love !!! :3
+Legion Guntur she's all yours
Don't ever mix Tarja's voice with Floors on TARJA's songs
blasphemous, Floor needs to sing her own sings
@@Stej-i7m They are Nightwish songs, not Tarja's
@@TerranigmaQuintet TARJA'S songs. Doesn't matter who wrote them she made the songs take off, she still can sing any of HER songs at her own concerts though so it's cool. Floor singing something like Sleeping Sun is garbage, only Tarja can sing it right
@@Stej-i7m Your opinion, not factual. In the end Nightwish owns the songs, Tuomas wrote them, so they get to decide here, not you. Be glad they let Tarja do them on her solo tours.
They are both amazing! And Nightwish should be grateful they have had these wonderful women in their band!
Floor 😍🤩🥰😘🤘
loved this mashup!
I love the way Floor screams the high notes :D
So, you're now with us, Josh... hahaha...
That is the diffrence between Tarja And Floor - Tarja - sings and Floor screams in Tarja songs....
Anomanderis Purake not really. Floor just projects her voice and hits a higher note tone.
@@Ravenz91 It sounds like someone shouting at me. Not enjoyable at all. I guess, I was just spoiled growing up listening to the great belters.
@@nicholew350 It's because she's using chest voice, Tarja did not, she can't, her chest voice is under developed. Floor could sing with head voice of Tarja, would be interesting, but head voice is Tarja's thing...
Floor a única em todo o oeste 😊😅😂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Tarja Turunen is my angel..
Marco Hietala is MY angel
@@abrick5838 YES
If I were to say this video is incredible, I would be lying. It is beyond that.
how Jansen ends this song from 4.10 is something not comparable... that belt isn't human
Robbie Gea she actually ends all the songs like that xD
@@theother9868 poor undereducated twat…. listening to music... pretending to love it and not even able to see the difference between screaming and singing ….sad
you mean the screaming?
hey!@pantherapardus this video you did great, lol thanks for this contribution and Final Floor makes it unique!.
a voz da flor e doce,
a da tarja me arrepia sempre será a melhor.
Siempre Tarja Turunen ❤❤
The consistency is amazing.
Jste❤❤❤❤najlepsi na celém světě děkuji😘💕 vám❤❤❤❤😍😘💋💋💋💋👍👍👍👌👑👑👑👑👑👑💕💯💯💯💯😘😘💯💯
Floor 🖤
Uaoooooo!!!!! BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!! Great video!!!!!
The vast majority of comments are saying Floor did way better but I'd like to remain neutral. I love both of them and I love fan-made duets like this so thank you so much for making them! :D
Hahaha... So, you lately are not charmed anymore by the great Floor, friend... He10x...
Great job putting together these two performances. Still need to consider the difference of sound recording capabilities between the almost two decades.
Casi dos décadas???. No llega a 8 años
Sublimes las dos!!
This would be the greatest duet in metal history! Let's make it happen!
2:38 Floor llega con lo justo. Tarja llega tranquila. Las dos son grandes cantantes, pero Tarja es unica. Y Floor canta sin explotar toda su voz lirica para mi, la hacen cantar de una manera que esta como contenida. Para MI tendria que hacerlo como lo hacia en "Leaden Legacy" o en "Intrinsic".
Awesome editing, Awesome product!!!
great editing and ofc 2 of the greatest Singers =)
I love this mix, especially the near the end, you made it more epic :D
Definitely agreed. It's already an epic song, but having both of them (and Marco) going at it like they might die if they hold back even an ounce of passion is just... well, there's a reason I've listened to this so many times.
Tarja é a melhor.The best🇧🇷