Light Does Not Experience Time: Mysteries with Joe Scott
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- Head to squarespace.co... to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code eventhorizon
Is the Universe real? Do Photons experience time? Joe Scott of Answers with Joe joins John Michael Godier to explore mysteries and generally have a good time.
Answers with Joe:
/ @joescott
TH-cam Membership: / @eventhorizonshow
Podcast: anchor.fm/john...
Apple: apple.co/3CS7rjT
More JMG
/ johnmichaelgodier
Want to support the channel?
Patreon: / eventhorizonshow
Follow us at other places!
@JMGEventHorizon
Music:
stellardrone.b...
migueljohnson....
leerosevere.ba...
aeriumambient....
FOOTAGE:
NASA
ESA/Hubble
ESO - M.Kornmesser
ESO - L.Calcada
ESO - Jose Francisco Salgado (josefrancisco.org)
NAOJ
University of Warwick
Goddard Visualization Studio
Langley Research Center
Pixabay
![เขามัทรี - เอ็กซ์ ศุภกฤต - จอนนี่มิวสิค [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AS9ufKuQIVs/mqdefault.jpg)
Event Horizon is like an oasis of subjects that really matter in the middle of a wasteland of futilities and useless information. Every time I hear this show, I feel like my mind has found a refuge where it can rest and recharge its energies, thinking only about ultimate questions. I love this channel!
Joe Scott! I absolutely love these cross-over episodes! Imagine JMG, Mr. Scott and Isaac Arthur in one podcast, oh my!
Isaac 🤦 was good but now its all about life as a crisp packet and things like that. Not getting much original thought out of the guy.
I need to assemble the science and space nerd avengers, and here we have two of them.
That would be amazing!!!!
Hosted by Joe Rogan
Would have been better to post on John's personal channel in my opinion. This was unrelated to science and the event horizon channel, the title was misleading, and I didn't care about their conversation. Except what John Michel says, I like to listen to what he has to say and he can be cute when he laughs.
Joe Scott????? On Event Horizon? I'm daydreaming 😊. You guys are all life savers!!!!
I keep thinking particles travelling close to this speed is why the double slit experiment / quantum eraser produces the same results even if measured after the slits… once the particle is interacted with before or after, it is changed in its whole existence.. some particles traveling slightly slower than light, could behave differently if the measurement is taken long enough after the slit, perhaps to allow a certain minimum unit of time to pass, so that the change does not percolate
I mean he's not a scientist or even space journalist like fraiser for example. I personally don't like Joe's content. He said that he started to create science videos after one scientific video blew up.
@@rebellion-starwars Glad I'm not the only one, I didn't know him, and I still don't need to know him after this upload.
@@galaxia4709 I mean at the very beginning he said photon... Time... Fundamentals of matter. Man stupidity never ends.
I didn't want to listen but I started after I seen your post just want to check if I was correct and after 5min only it turns out that I was. At least for me and my own opinions and what I prefer personally.
I know that you can't make everyone happy but lately John is not creating content that I like, from war stuff that I don't think isn't the place here whatsoever to this...
@@galaxia4709 I just finished it and I've lost one hour of my life for nothing. Only interesting thing here that I've learned was that JMG loves mandalorian TV show and that's pretty much it.
I knew it, I wrote that comment before and now when I watched it I was correct. Movie maker who ended up making content at the TH-cam and making science videos only because he seen the perspective for money and not really interested into. When John asked him what's your favorite scientific discovery? It was discovery of the old mystery that one girl solved old mystery knowing who was some person in the australia 😂
Can you imagine that? That's his favorite scientific discovery! Then John said that he was crying when he seen the Artemis rocket launch, he answered yeah but not as much excited but I can bet that he didn't watch it for sure because of his tone and he didn't want to disappoint John. I mean this was laughable!
This has to become a weekly series. Both amazing funny and intellectual guys just having a great convo. I can sit here and listen to this for years
Look John ,most people get a little bit of luck in life here and there , I know you are being modest , but the main reason that your shows do very well is due to the hard work that you and your team put into them , allied with your great knowledge and presentation and production skills of the team you have !
The quality of the guests you have on puts you , in my opinion , well within the top ten of shows of this type of subject matter !
I and many thousands of others have enjoyed your shows for many years ! Well done to you Sir !
TH-cam is nice for me cause people like you two. I literally only know 3 people that talk about ideas. My life is sooo baren of intellectual interaction. I have to talk with myself about everything John talks about. Thank you for your content.
That sucks dude. I feel ya. I have a limited circle too. Thank goodness for the interweb. Hang in there bud. 👍🏼
Joe Scott is awesome! Love the collaborations with him and other TH-cam science communicators.
i disagree. acadamia and its npc's will always be close minded and solidified in there opinions no matter the evidence.Joe Scott is perfect example of the failures of the college system and science in general
@@dexstarr9220 couldn’t put it better myself.
@@dexstarr9220how did you even find yourself here?
I know this isn't typical for your channel but I gotta say it's really fun and entertaining just to hear you two very interesting individuals just talk about whatever or maybe I should say wherever the conversation leads! Joe's a really cool guest and hope to see future episodes with him or have more people like him! Anyways, love this channel and it's one I highly recommended anytime I can!
"Light Does Not Experience Time, Nor Do You"
@@HiR0SHi.the.D0G On the internet we are all photons.
Lunchtime, doubly so.
"It's always NOW!"
What an absolute treat. Thank you both.
When it comes to stuff like " I had a dream about my relative and they died that night" I consider that to be either the subconscious already knew it was coming due to cues your conscious doesnt pick up on or actively ignores. Or as well the possibility of your brain subconsciously doing the math and reasoning out that something is likely to happen probability wise while your conscious has absolutely no clue.
Life is a weird game of DnD
I had a dream that I died around 6 AM. My wife died just a few hours later while I was at work. I later realized that I was her in the dream. Dropped at the same spot and everything. What kind of subconscious cue is that? I didn't even have a smidgen of a thought that she was gonna pass.
Something is at work that we can't see. I can't see her, feel her, touch her, talk to her, and I'd sure like to. Regardless, she's with me every single day.
I'm guessing that because the amount of times dreams and "predictions" doesn't come true vastly outmatch the times they do, should be a solid clue as to what is going on.
It's.... Randomness.. just like Joe explained in the video.
I've dreamed of things that happened before but never as vivid or real as 1 a couple months ago. I bowl in a league every Wed. I'm not good, only a 160ish avg. But in my dream I had 10 strikes in a row then threw a 9. Ended with a 289 total. Well couple days later when I started throwing all strikes my team was getting excited, telling me just calm down and keep going for that 300. I wasn't nervous at all cause I already knew how it would end and I told them so. And it did end exactly as my dream. That freaked me out
@@tangttsauce3040I had a focal seizure and I swear I “talked” to the people who I “heard” talking about me in the third person…
They spoke as if observing me and reacted to my inner monologue as I pondered their conversation about me. When they referenced the fact I shouldn’t have been able to remember our interaction after the seizure I told them that I remember anything I actually pay attention to and they wouldn’t be able to make me forget anything this life-changing. they tried “bluff” me with my death…
Unfortunately I had been made fully aware that I’m here by choice so my fear of “death” has greatly diminished.
But my wife, what would I do without her? Plus I found out that we would not carry-on past death “together”. We would move to another phase where that becomes an afterthought for most…
I would not give her up if I have ANY chance to be with the yin to my yang beyond life. I put in my application to be administration together with her next time instead of just coming back…
Ponder this…
We must come here to feel. To feel positive there must be negative for the perspective necessary to be able to even appreciate the positive…
We also exist elsewhere when not here and we cannot be allowed to remember it while here because it will ruin the experience. The “suffering” is part of this experience and in the other place we exist in perfection as energetic beings with NO needs, but we cannot physically TOUCH ANYTHING. We cannot feel. if we want the pleasures of the flesh we must come here. We remember the experiences we had here and we return….
I offered to give up the option of coming here in an attempt to get a guarantee of being with my love after here this time.
I guess I have a few points but the main one is that I understand loving the one. I was fully aware of everything around be although I felt as though my mind fell deep within my body and couldn’t move. I accepted that I was about to die and that is what happened as far as I can say. I told my wife every thing that she said to me and did while I was experiencing the seizure. I had two of them and there is more. But I made a deal to not share certain details and I don’t wanna blow it just in case I wasn’t hallucinating.
But, I’d I try to share the “forbidden” info I start to have a seizure. They hit my silence button. Lol.
How ya luv that shit?
Yes! Event Horizon, Isaac Arthur, and Dr. Becky videos! Just waiting for Anton Petrov and my day will be complete! 🚀🌎❤️🌮🔭📡
Yes we need Anton!!!! can we just get them all in a podcast together!!!!???
Anton is a wonderful person 😊
@@signalrk Always think it's cute when he says so
Hello, wonderful people.
@@pauliusUwU howdy 😁
Two of my fav youtubers!! Thankyou! Enjoyed this very much!
I guess you could say that the photon, indeed, has _no time to lose!_ (Quoting Matt O'Dowd from PBS Space Time lol)
Two of of my favorite TH-camrs together, i like it
Oh yeah
@@EventHorizonShow get Anton plssss
This is why as Carl Sagan explained it in his “Cosmos” series, if you travel at 90% the speed of light, you could in 40 years (as you would experience it) explore the known universe.
It's amazing how much joe will talk about himself.
Streaming is still far better than cable. No commercials and still cheaper. Love the talk, Michael!
You guys are the best!
I can totally relate with every single thing that you talk about.
Listening to your conversation is like having friends.
joe scott is an academic npc who parrots mainestream acadamia no matter the evidence. i unsubbed for having this cringe npc establishment guest joe scott
This one went by too fast. I could listen to you two for hours. Great episode!
Glad you enjoyed it!
@@EventHorizonShow i thought he was acadamia npc cringe guest.who offers no authentic or nuance opinions,anything joe scott has to offer you can find in text books and science magazines.he still thinks the pyramids are 4000 years old despite the overwhelming evidence that is contrary.thats just 1 easy example of npc acadamia joe scott
Love this episode with a fellow science creator John! It reminds me of your annual ramblings with Isaac Arthur
Gosh I love randomly coming across team-ups of my favorites TH-camrs!!!!
Made my week just seeing that I get to listen to a conversation between Joe and John. What a glorious day!
It was refreshing to hear you guys talking about looking out airplane windows. It was magic to me as a kid, and after a number of years in aerospace engineering, and on the cusp of retirement as an international airline captain, it's still just as magical.
I wouldn't be too hard on yourself Joe . You have directed and stared in at least one more feature film than most people .
I honestly enjoyed Ocean Front Property , and thought it was a pretty damn good directorial debut.
Been thinking about this, light experiencing the entire universe instantly.
cool 👽well done well done Well done someone should have corrected a big mistake at the root of physics .so you understand how wrong it is when someone says that light cannot escape from a black hole, this is a small intro to the discussion with AI GPT 3.5 ! Me: No, that's not the problem, the problem is that you claim that there was even a possibility for light to move or be separated from the game outside of space-time. when a black hole bends geometrical space-time, light follows a path determined by that dimension-warping geometry. GPT:
You are correct. I apologize for any confusion my previous statement may have caused. In the presence of a black hole, the gravitational field is so strong that it warps spacetime, which affects the path of light as well. As a result, it is not possible for light to escape the gravitational pull of a black hole once it crosses the event horizon. The notion of light being separated from space-time outside of a black hole is not accurate, and I should have been more precise in my previous response. Thank you for bringing this to my attention.
th-cam.com/video/dIiWrcWqiAM/w-d-xo.html
Hell yeah! Joe's on! Let's goooo
It was great to listen to the two of you talking with each other and sharing stories and ideas!
Wow! The crossover of my dreams! Thank you John and Joe!
I'm a regular viewer from Ireland I'll say hello if i ever see you over here
"Mysteries and Miracles with Joe Scott."
That's been my big question, too. If photons don't experience time, and quantum entanglement is a thing, then wouldn't that imply the universe still has facets which behave as if it was all still a pinpoint in some way, like at the point before the "Big Bang"? As if some parts of it exists in a lower amount of dimensions than we do?
Duh? There was no big bang!😮
@@Kenny-zv4pp - That's the recognizable nomenclature so I used it for ease of summary. These other factors could indicate the whole universe is still closely connected in some way we can't yet perceive or, perhaps, the 4 dimensions we perceive aren't universally equal or a factor for everything in it. All sorts of befuddling considerations from such glimpses.
Did not expect this collab
Oh it's Joe! What a surprise! Love his channel
So is this All about Joe Scott and me or photons? Still good.
"I’ve been eating cactus my whole life. It’s a really common thing when fermented bean-curd sauce is derived from the quantum state of volcanic tuff. A rose by any other name is still a kangaroo. Give short wave radio a chance and tune around and keep in touch with the position coordinates of cognitive bias. It seems finding anyone with basic literary skills is a real challenge these days. The foundational probabilistic interpretations of mothership supercells are making changes to lemon-freshened quantum entanglement that coats and soothes and helps relieves indigestion. But you need the right kinds of structures and equipment to make practical use of it with metabolic enzymes and paper clips constantly pulsating with energy. This alters the strength of the electric field. The fine structure constant is the key to understanding wet dog fur. I'm so deeply grateful for the few scientists who are standing up for reality. Each point in space is associated with a vector that determines what scientific assertions will change the definition of crocodiles in Australia. Hold on to your hats. Just when you think you have it all figured out, along comes potato salad. What an amazing transformation due to gravitational lensing."
---Albert Einstein
this is such a strange episode. i loved it but it was more of a hangout smoke sesh 😂❤
Great that you brought Joe Scott , love his channel.
The crossover I've been waiting so long for!!
Light slows down when it passes through something other than a vacuum, such as water and glass. There have also been experiments where light has been slowed down to only a few miles per hour. Does it then experience time passing under those circumstances?
Maybe the photon would have thoughts similar to those of the sperm whale that materialized above a planet in “The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy”.
How did they slow light down?
@Muukalainen really cold sodium atoms
I believe it still would not experience time as its not because of its speed that it experiences time its due to it having no mass. It would still have no mass at a lower speed and thus not experience time. Although I may be wrong on this.
@@kylefleming5152 Check out "the physical reason time slows at the speed of light". It's 2 minutes and makes you really understand!
This thumbnail is amazing. Good job to whoever made this.
Most likely A.I. generated thumbnail 🙂
4:56 Leonard Susskind has a tempting body of work that seems to unite GR and QFT.
52:41 ...and HAPPY HALLOWEEN to you guys too... 😁
Been listening to Joe for years good humor even if he is Texan. Hello from Yuma Arizona
Two of my favourite TH-camrs together, perfection, let me grab a cup of tea put my feet up and have my brain and imagination massaged 😊
Legend!
JOHN AND JOE TOGETHER YES
Another amazing episode thanks everyone ❤
Light out of time with Joe Scott
Two of my favorite channels in a crossover episode?!? YEAAAAAAAHHHHH!!!!!
How did I miss this?!? A thousand lashes to myself!
omg this has got to the best cross over ever!
Let’s go!!!
Great episode with Joe Scott! Cheers 🍻
The crossover of the century!
Thought experiment: You are on earth watching a spaceship with a telescope and can see the clock on the wall inside. As you watch the clock, the spaceship accelerates, soon reaching .99999% C relative to you. You can still see the clock (it's an amazing telescope) and time has slowed so much for the occupants relative to you, that clock has practically stopped. You continue watching for several years. The spaceship reaches Alpha Centauri, and the clock barely moved. Doesn't this mean that from the perspective of the occupants, they have reached Alpha Centauri in an instant? Doesn't this imply that the 'Star Trek' warp drive is completely unnecessary, that merely accelerating to close to light speed means you'd cross the galaxy in minutes depending how close to C you could get?
What JMG said about 40k cave paintings made by humans that are humans like us. It makes one wonder why so many thousands of years passed and human advancement was developing a new type of pointy rock over ten thousand years.
Sweet as , joe has come along away, use to watch his more funnier video ,way back in the day , this year' seems everyone is jumping out of their comfort zone, U guys rock 👍😂🤣😭
*7:53** . . YAY! *Screams!!* .. I've been writing about just about all of that all in the last week! I just got stuck into luck earlier today! You're running through the topics so fast lol.
*Marina - ancient dreams* 👯♀️
All I write is free
👠
This is one of my comfort channels!
the answer must be that photons don't experience time because they dont travel. Waves travel. Those waves travel, representing the potential of a photon, which of course does not "experience" time, because it is simply a wave during travel. Of course those waves "red shift" over time, a characteristic we rely on, so it is a bit contradictory to say that photons aren't experiencing time and are somehow immune to time. So that leaves us with the conclusion that they simply don't exist when in travel. And the photon isn't the same photon that existed wherever it started. It behaves according to the laws of quantum mechanics, converts to a wave, then that wave is collapsed when it strikes matter. Most of the confusion in physics, to me, seems to derive from confusing Einsteinian physics with the realm of quantum mechanics. Saying photons don't experience time is on point as a demonstration of this problem. A photon is not in the QM world, it is what emerges from that world.
epic combo
Epic.
Bob Ross: The Godfather of youtube.
Someone needs to make a 90 minute documentary about that.
Love Joe Scott. Awesome
My dream is to get a long range explorer yacht, several submersible tow behind pods (with side scan radars, sonar, cameras, depth finders, magnetometers, etc), a few arial drones with sensor packages, a couple remote controllable vehicles, and the hardware and software to mark an area to map and autopilot would steer the course and speed, put out the tow behind pods, record sensor readings and data, process the data, and point out anything it thinks is interesting to help with data review.
I want all that so I can make high resolution maps of the sea floor near land in water ~30 meters or less to look for human occupation back thru the last 10k years or so. The maps would also be useful in many ways from science to navigation.
it would be more practical to do something in the vain of Elon Musk's Starlink Satellites and employ an autonomous fleet with thousands of small, cheap, easy to produce solar powered "crafts" to drift with the currents and gather sonar data of the seafloor.
"- We are the Universe lucid dreaming"
"- And that's terrifying"
Yay nice crossover : )
49:22 cue to that 90s Hackers movie intro with soft techno on the background
Funny thing is I’m listening to your show John and I’m from Galway in Ireland
Great episode John,i'm watching here from Galway :)
Great episode, the conversational mix was thoroughly enjoyable. I also ponder the rise of our technological cities while flying in and out also the vastness of both the Australian deserts and surrounding oceans.
my two prefered youtubers, nice
Nice 👍
Speaking to movies on youtube, Joel Haver hosts a yearly "contest" in which people film a movie instead of watching the oscars. Besides making his own movies, he's helping cultivate a pretty cool community for this stuff.
I may have fallen into the Event Horizon, but the Event Horizon falls into Chuck Norris
What determines your relativistic frame? Is it speed? How fast you are moving relative to everything else? Are you in the same relativistic frame with an object moving the same deed as you no matter how far away it is? So are all photons in the same frame?
I listened to this without reading the full intro . Several minutes in I'm thinking , wow , that guy sounds a lot like Joe Scott.
Cool to bring Joe on :)
Ayeee... its my boys, together at last!
NEW CHANNEL NEEDED: John and Joe talk
J & J...excellent content. watched twice.
To quote Beck
"Boy all this universe, Im illusory baby, so why don't you kill me?"
Ireland here too and would never miss and episode of event horizon and would recommend jmg any day
Cheers!
Sorry you did not talk about what is light(photos) are more.
So glad to hear of other people that have flown a lot that like me always want a window seat, my kids do not understand it , but you guys get it :)
Aww,amazing crossover!!!.I love both channels,thank you for this!
Even I unsubscribed from event horizon (a fantasy channel) I watched this video❤
Fun interview! ❤
This is a dream come true! I very much enjoy both creators and look forward to new episodes from both, to have them together is amazing!!
I love Lost. It was crazy on the first watch. I didn’t see it till the first two seasons were already on DVD. My gf and I had an awesome weekend watching those two seasons trying to figure it out. We’d be so amped after the cliffhangers. We would have to step outside to take a break and talk about how awesome what we just watched was.
That's the way Lost was for me too. I caught up after the first two seasons and I was obsessed. I even bought something from the set. I hated the ending but I've never been so invested in a show before and I probably never will be again.
26:00 I hope you aren't saying that the research used by Graham Hancock, the research done by Randall Carlson, is not scientific. If there's any one mountain of cold, hard data which needs to be brought more to the forefront of geology, it's the decades of painstaking work done by Dr. Carlson.
One can only call it a deterministic universe if it has never ever had a single random decision anywhere in it. Where does determinism loses to randomness, is a consciousness that is aware of it. Consciousness brings randomness to an otherwise deterministic universe within its radius of influence. Roger Penrose said there is an immeasurable in consciousness, that is undefinable. That’s where randomness lives
You're right John. I'm turning 50 in 5 weeks and the years do meld together.
I loved Lost too, at least until season 5 when it became clear it wasn't going anywhere. If I need an escape I watch Battlestar Galactica, Event Horizon, Neil Degrasse Tyson lectures, Brian Cox videos, bbq videos, or music videos of the heavy metal/hard rock variety. I can also fire up my PS5 for some Dead Space, Resident Evil, or my Switch for some Metroid!
Andy (Isaac Asimov) Weir
(I love going on commercial flights, looking out the window at night till I fall asleep.) I will some time take a flight from Nashville to raleigh and pick the flights that have a 19 hour layover in Las Vegas and on way back a 23 hour layover in Miami. I was gonna get my pilots license during the pandemic cause I had the time and it is kind of a dream of mine.
I’m too big for space and it is too harsh, but I’d love to see the earth from orbit and some other stuff.
John & Joe! Woohoo!!!
Brilliant! Two of my favourites to listen to. But "Happy Halloween" sort of threw me as we got to the end? Is that those pesky Protons not conforming?
N. Sentinel Islanders language is different enough that those on islands nearby can’t communicate with them. It would be cool if we could give them vaccines and medicine without interacting or hurting them.
it would be a foolish and futile effort that would do more harm than any good. It's best to just leave them alone and let nature take it's course.
Prime Directive.
Keep up the good work 😊
Excellent
Great Scott ... !!!
I like restoration videos such as furniture, toys and tools. One of my favorites is “Hand Tool Rescue”.
Man!! I love you both!! Greetings from Brazil!
JOE SCOTT!!! This is great!! I love his channel.
Joe Scott!!!!