"I can't believe I put Breath of the Wild at 10, it's obviously meant to be at 6, right behind Breath of the Wild 2: Electric Chuchulu. It's also crazy to think that my top two were Majora's Mask and Wind Waker, which were later taken over by Termina's Downfall and Lorule Reborn, respectively."
I mean breath of the wild’s combat progression is really dumb, there’s like 5 different types of enemies and once you figure out their attack patterns combat that’s gg. Plus no sidequests and the final boss was... underwhelming to say the least
wiimannoob the majority of them were fetch quests with very bland rewards like silver/gold rupees. Tarrey town was actually pretty good, but for a game that size with such a small storyline I was pretty underwhelmed
@@wiimannoob botw was a treat for enthusiasts of open world games but was a sore disappointment for people craving the puzzle heavy old zelda formula. i myself fall in the latter category
I like to pretend spirit tracks doesn’t exist lol. I love Zelda but I was never sold on spirit tracks or phantom hourglass. I think those are the two handhelds I just never got into lol
@@jennaelizabeth8956 The first zelda I consciously played was Phantom Hourglass, so I'm a little biased. But I also think that some of the arguments against it are a little silly
@@jennaelizabeth8956 I mean I played Spirit Tracks and it was actually pretty good once you got used to the controls. The story was decent and the dungeons and bosses were pretty good. However, phantom hourglass was kinda garbage.
Ghost RC How dare you don’t even give any context about George Washingtoad like how he was from the original Super Show because not everyone know him enough to research, you are so offensive! JOKE!!!!
I know youtubers talk about getting commenters who get angry at them for their opinions and I imagine they do see them but is the zelda fanbase just super volatile? There isn't really a totally objective way to rank games unless you pick the criteria on which to categorize them and GUESS WHAT! The criteria that you could pick to judge zelda games could be subjective too! I feel like all you can really do is try to explain what you think about a game and why you think that. If people get mad at you that's their problem.
@@iBenjamin1000 I was not trying to be subjective, I think you are taking this too seriously as this was meant to be a joke. I don't think you might have gotten the point of the video or, again, were taking it too seriously. Here is the joke explained, PBG was talking about how others were criticizing his "top 10" video along with himself. I was just going along with the flow and I think that you haven't watched the video yet
I was actually impress and glad you put Skyward Sword as part of your top 5, I'm glad you stuck to your guns on it because so many people disliked at the time and I was glad to find someone else that liked it as much as me.
Game itself is not the problem for most. It is the god awful gimmicky broken motion controls. If they remade it with controller support i think more gamers would like it.
I just realized Breath of the Wild is a handheld Zelda game. (edit: this was before I actually had a Switch and middle-school-brain me couldn’t comprehend basic electronic functions.)
No idea about this one. I didn't play it when I was younger either and I still found ALTTP to be one of the few older Zeldas that held up. Them's opinions I guess!
@@Barrelrollz ALTTP is one of the first video games I've ever played but it doesn't hold up at all. Everything the game does has been done better by later games in the series and it isn't special enough on its own to be worth going back to.
OtherCannon Also god, so much blood, none of us couldve seen this coming, god, we need help, and we need it now, transfering to reuben back at the station.
Im sad Spirit Tracks didnt have a chance to appear on the list. I really like that game and I feel like that game has a really nice Zelda that you can learn and care more about her
What’s weird is that, even though no one talks about it, whenever they do talk about it, they never have anything bad to say about it specifically. It mostly is just grouped with Phantom Hourglass, which is a shame.
It's kind of weird to think that even as recently as 2011, TP was the "newest" Zelda game we had. It's been a great decade for Zelda! I can vouch for your ambivalence toward LTTP though; it's funny how quickly Skyward Sword gets lambasted over one boss that you have to hit in the eye when LTTP has 3 of them (well I guess Arrghus is debatable). If anything, Tentalus is just a reminder of what great settings SS has for a lot of its boss fights, rather than them all taking place indoors in big empty rooms, making sure to slap something in the middle of the room if it's a miniboss (oh hey OoT).
Lmao I remember when I was a kid and I loved twilight princess because it was my first 3d Zelda and I loved the darker atmosphere and cool animations link had and I almost unsubscribed from your channel when I watched that video because I was so offended that you put that game so low
@@TheInkPitOx After third dungeon, but before the start of the first dungeon is like another dungeon. So about mid game I would say Also I don't wanna be that guy, but the wooden sword is only for until you first turn wolf, which is like 30 minutes, maybe an hour into the game. The ordon sword and the wooden sword are not the same weapon.
*Fights final boss* "Alright brutha time for a flute solo!" *I scream externally* I played ST on the wii u, and JESUS the flute is broken on rerelease. I was so happy when I finished all the temple songs, so i never had to do the duets again, but then it ruins the endgame. I quit. It got me to quit a zelda game, at the final boss. I had already spents months sending postcards and grinding to get all the gold train parts, then i quit because it takes a good 40+ tries to get the spirit flute to work on wii u. Although i DID play it on ds first, and while the duets gave me trouble they were nowhere NEAR as bad, the game's just bad at commumicating that it doesn't want you to start playing when the partner looks at you (like it says to do) it wants you to wait for the measure of 4 to end before you start.
I kinda want another of the DS Zeldas. The touch controls worked so freaking well, the boss fights were awesome, and they actually used your items in creative ways outside of combat.
To be fair, the whole video is made to show his opinions change with the time. He's entitled to his opinion, of course, and I could see why he may not like BotW as much as before
Honestly i really love your old videos, even if theyre wonky or the opinions are bad. I used to watch your videos as a kid and being able to go back and watch them as an adult is such a nostalgia trip tbh
This video just came back up in my feed and I’m tripping that this was 3 years ago and even more that his original list was 11 years ago. I remember being 9 with my Itouch binging pbg, good times
"I agree with whatever dumb opinion you have, and feel free to use this in an argument at any point in the future once I'm dead." -George Washingtoad "Also, please don't delete your channel, PBG. We love your videos." -George Washingtoad
@MasterMooper I cant say much about Wind Waker, it is probaly a good game, but I realy cant stand this cel shading look. Also Oot is good of course, but it have it's flaws as well
Same, it was news to me as well. I’d say I agree with PastButterGamer and put the Oracle games above it though. 100% for nostalgia, has zero to do with quality lol
Skyward Sword is my favourite zelda game, because of the story. Link and Zelda's relationship is super cute, and all of the Skyloft citizens have some depth too. Also I think the motion controls are really fun. I wish I still had my wii T_T
I still had my Wii and Skyward is one of the best, if not best of all, BECAUSE motion controll, not despite. My letdown is Twillight princess, which I played after, bad controlls, dark, boring and easy.
Oddly enough what i've seen of the reception to Skyward Sword was the opposite. Everyone was singing its praises when it first came out and then slowly started turning against it.
Those were mostly critic reviews. Many fans hated it from th get-go. I thought it was alright, the best in many areas like bossfights, and I thought the silent realms and many of the dungeons were excellent... but the linearity, slowness, the empty sky and all the fetch quests really hurt the game.
Szabu As controversial as this is, Skyward Sword is my favourite Zelda game. Probably mostly because of nostalgia, but I still enjoy playing it. I’d love a full remake of the game, cutting out the unnecessary bits and changing the pacing of the game, but knowing Nintendo that wouldn’t happen.
@@echowhosthis Maybe it will someday, actually. In Wind Waker HD they actually changed the pacing by introducing the swift sail that makes ou not have to change the wind direction on the sea, and also they removed half the Triforce charts - the areas that gave you the charts in the original game now give you the Triforce pieces directly. Personally I didn't have issue with the original, but a lot of people welcomed these changes.
@@19Szabolcs91 The pacing of the game is so ingrained into it its core that they would have to overhaul the core of the game. The pacing is pretty bad in Skyward Sword because you are forced to go through every major area three times. Sure, you are doing something different everytime, but you are still go through the same area regardless.
One thing I heard about BotW that some people missed from SS was the crazy good story telling, like the relationship between Zelda and Link or when Link has to drop the sword back into the stone basically killing off Fi, another thing that I haven't heard too much but did notice was the lack of dungeon themes. Like the most memorable ones to me, from SS are the Ancient Cistern and Fire Sanctuary and that's mostly because of the bosses at the end, compared to BotW where I can't even remember the Divine Beasts names. If the sequel has that good story telling with the open world exploration, I don't think Nintendo would be able to outdo themselves.
Some of us 40 somethings disagree with PBG on that. Although in my case I just turned 40 last month so I'm not that old yet. The older millennialswill join me soon.
It would make more sense though if it was the opposite of ocarina of time. Because majored mask to ocarina of time is still the same, but also totally different if that makes sense
6:02 Funnily enough, you mocking the old joke then using it again is probably one of my fav jokes on PBG you've ever done. That was excellent and unexpected.
11:20 “Cartoony” - The video will have no notifications -The video will have no comments -The video will not be searchable -The video will not be suggested/recommended -The video will make 90% less revenue
My 14 yr old self back then: WHAT TWILIGHT PRINCESS IS MY FAVORITE. It's ok I still love you peebs ;~; Me now at 22: ah how the turntables. Redemption arc time
Who cares what that opinionated dictator thinks? Skyward Sword still is my favourite Zelda game. I love the story, Ghirahim is the best Zelda-villain ever. Skyloft and the Surface World are awesome and fun to explore. And the artstyle and characters are also very likable. Never had a problem with the Motion Controls either, except for one part. I admit that it has its flaws. The Sky outside Skyloft is lackluster, the game resorts to a lot of padding that can get annoying sometimes and it's also one of my least favourite Zelda-games to complete 100%, just because of that damn Strumming Mini game (only time I really struggle with the motion controls in this game). And yet despite all this, I still love this game and I think it's the best. And if Mr: egotistical Reptile thinks I'm a mental defect for thinking this, efff him!
Your old videos hold a lot of nostalgia for me because I used to watch them all on repeat as a kid. I sometimes find myself quoting you and i don't even realize! To this day I sometimes say the "gahh you killed me" part in the Zelda II section OUT LOUD in real life.
😂😂😂😂 Starts video off by apologizing for Twilight Princess being #10 in his last Top 10 Zelda Games Ends video by putting Breath of the Wild at #10 😂😂😂😂
"I'm making a Twilight Princess video, I'm changing my opinions on the game" Thank you for not massacring my boy. ;u; EDIT: TWILIGHT PRINCESS AT NUMBER 3 BABY HEEEEELLLL YEAH
I dont think that Breath of the wild 2 will be as dark as majoras mask, the entire lore of it, the characters everything about the game is dark and dreary.
The only graphic criticism for that game I can kinda understand is that the game has a "plastic" feel to it. I wonder how it would look if it was more "organic"
I have yet to try the game myself (though i definetely will at some point) so I cant speak in too much detail. But I wouldnt regard it as "too kiddy", more like it looks very stiff and plastic. Almost like the world and its characters are made out of toys, which kinda rub me the wrong way for a zelda game. But yeah, I will try it myself before I jump to any conclusions.
@@XMonument It's deliberately designed in the style of a diorama. It's very beautiful and unique in ways I didn't expect before playing. I totally recommend it!
As someone who's only played 1 Zelda game, I can proudly say that Phantom Hourglass is the best Zelda game to exist. Y’all please stop replying about how you guys hated playing it, I am allowed to like my own games lol
@@kay-sp4gk At least you didn't put Majora's Mask at #1 like so many other people. That seems to have become the overall popular opinion as of late for some reason.
@@st.wvllxw7238 Yeah but I am sick of the hype for it. I can name several problems with it. First of all I hate having a time limit even with different things happening on each day. Secondly you have to go back to day one just to save your game permanently. Third you lose all of your consumable items in doing so and have to use up time just to get them back whether purchasing them or farming them which is just annoying to me. Fourth, The Great Bay temple nuff said there. Fifth, having to redo any whole temple if you do not have time to finish it in three hours with the inverted song of time otherwise you only have fifty minutes. Sixth, not knowing where to go at the beginning of the game without a guide and also having to redo certain parts to get into certain places unless you have a proper mask if applicable. Now while the game does have wonderful atmosphere (the kafei quest is one of the few moments that I enjoyed when I watched a let's play of the game) there are just too many things that bother me when I try to play it so I find it to be a frustrating experience and I play games to have fun not to be annoyed thank you very much.
I played through majoras mask recently, I tried when I was 11, couldnt find woodfall and stopped, when I was 13 I got to ikana and was to afraid to continue bc of the statue, then last week as a 17 year old I started a new save and 100%'d it. I had to beat my fear of that statue and not pointing fingers here but it was entirely sparked by pbg
@@sb14andmore50 There are plenty of avenues in the game to get a new weapon even when you break your last one. Also, if that's the only problem you had, then it just goes to show how masterful the game overall is.
@@Eversoul12 Only a bit. The most critical of the game are in a very vocal minority. But if you look at any polls that have come around since the game released, they all have BotW sweeping in vast majorities.
honestly I feel like BoTW should be around rank 10. It's a great game but needed more classic Zelda elements, such as replacing the Divine Beasts with standard large temples that give variation from the otherwise open world design. The shrines exist but they are only tiny dungeons and are unfortunately very repetitive in theming and challenges. I'd definitely put it in the top 10, but idk, it could of used more classic Zelda elements to contrast with the openness
Spirit Tracks and Phantom Hourglass are valid, even if they do have weird control schemes (and despite the Temple of the Ocean King being tedious to get through in Phantom Hourglass). Being able to ride a train around New Hyrule/sail about around the ocean realm is fun, dangit. Also Spirit Tracks has one of the best overworld themes in Zelda.
@@toonlink8151 Probably because of the weird-for-the-time controls and the low-ish level of detail with reused assets and stuff, plus the Temple of the Ocean King being tedious to backtrack through. Personally I do really like Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks. I think that more people should give them a chance, since they're legitimately good games despite their flaws. (Also if you want to see somebody give Phantom Hourglass the acknowledgement it deserves, I suggest watching Chuggaaconroy's Let's Play of it, if you haven't already. He makes a lot of good points about it.)
2030 Peebs is going to slaughter 2019 Peebs for this later on.
I am placing my bet at sometime next year when BoTW 2 comes out
“My choices in the first video were obviously better smh”
"I can't believe I put Breath of the Wild at 10, it's obviously meant to be at 6, right behind Breath of the Wild 2: Electric Chuchulu. It's also crazy to think that my top two were Majora's Mask and Wind Waker, which were later taken over by Termina's Downfall and Lorule Reborn, respectively."
@@darko-hexar this is underrated
so true
alternate video title: Man bullies himself for 20 minutes
20:00 best part
It's only 18 minutes and 25 seconds
@@zarephal4998 Thats the joke
@@jotaro9251 you mean 0:00
More like about 18 minutes 25 seconds
PBG 2011: *Puts Twilight Princess at #10*
PBG 2019: "Time to redeem myself." *Puts BotW at #10*
wiimannoob *Wait, that's illegal*
I mean breath of the wild’s combat progression is really dumb, there’s like 5 different types of enemies and once you figure out their attack patterns combat that’s gg. Plus no sidequests and the final boss was... underwhelming to say the least
@@johndeal666 no sidequests? There were literally dozens
wiimannoob the majority of them were fetch quests with very bland rewards like silver/gold rupees. Tarrey town was actually pretty good, but for a game that size with such a small storyline I was pretty underwhelmed
@@wiimannoob botw was a treat for enthusiasts of open world games but was a sore disappointment for people craving the puzzle heavy old zelda formula. i myself fall in the latter category
"Those are the only handheld Zelda games"
And just like that, Spirit Tracks ceased to exist
The Phantom Hourglass tho...
I like to pretend spirit tracks doesn’t exist lol. I love Zelda but I was never sold on spirit tracks or phantom hourglass. I think those are the two handhelds I just never got into lol
@@jennaelizabeth8956 The first zelda I consciously played was Phantom Hourglass, so I'm a little biased. But I also think that some of the arguments against it are a little silly
@@jennaelizabeth8956 I mean I played Spirit Tracks and it was actually pretty good once you got used to the controls. The story was decent and the dungeons and bosses were pretty good. However, phantom hourglass was kinda garbage.
Laughs in Triforce Heroes
Can’t wait for in eight years when peebs makes a top 10 Zelda areas list
I actually want this video
@*-Grim Reaper-* Cubic Castles I REALLY don’t hope that happens
Be like Indeimaus.
Top 10 ladders in Zelda
Played through skyward sword with my friend 2P 1C style. I actually loved it, and I think it might be the best way to play that game
yes make it happen
Yo PBG cut that out, George Washington is an amazing Nintendo game critic you're just jealous of his luscious locks and amazingly shiny teeth.
Hobo_Joe LOLOLOL
How dare you disrespect George Washingtoad by confusing him with George Washington. This is blasphemy
Ghost RC How dare you don’t even give any context about George Washingtoad like how he was from the original Super Show because not everyone know him enough to research, you are so offensive!
JOKE!!!!
Weorge Gashington only has one tooth of his own...
Guys, guys...
It's Jorg Washingmachine you swines
2011: you owe us an explanation
2019: explanation accepted
Also 2019: You owe BotW an explanation.
I know youtubers talk about getting commenters who get angry at them for their opinions and I imagine they do see them but is the zelda fanbase just super volatile? There isn't really a totally objective way to rank games unless you pick the criteria on which to categorize them and GUESS WHAT! The criteria that you could pick to judge zelda games could be subjective too! I feel like all you can really do is try to explain what you think about a game and why you think that. If people get mad at you that's their problem.
@@iBenjamin1000 I was not trying to be subjective, I think you are taking this too seriously as this was meant to be a joke. I don't think you might have gotten the point of the video or, again, were taking it too seriously. Here is the joke explained, PBG was talking about how others were criticizing his "top 10" video along with himself. I was just going along with the flow and I think that you haven't watched the video yet
@@paulfraley9767
Linebeck: "Guess who deserves a _bigger_ explanation?"
@@paulfraley9767 Except this time I actually agree with his placement
I was actually impress and glad you put Skyward Sword as part of your top 5, I'm glad you stuck to your guns on it because so many people disliked at the time and I was glad to find someone else that liked it as much as me.
ah yeah I guy which actual smart opinions :)
The only people who disliked it were Game Grumps fans.
Game itself is not the problem for most. It is the god awful gimmicky broken motion controls. If they remade it with controller support i think more gamers would like it.
@@tomivalkonen1343 welp it’s happening
@@Maxiz60 is it? They officiially announced remake or something?
Seeing PBG roast his old jokes makes me feel roasted for how much I enjoyed them back in the day.
Agreed
Shut up bitch
Bror this isn’t Twitter dumbass
Bill bob boy Do you literally even know how to use the word literally?
This is a video about zelda!
people would definitely like to see a top 10 zelda locations.
gigaswardblade I would love to see a “Favorite spot in each game” list!
Temple of time in twilight princess has to there.
YEAH!
As soon as Peebs mentioned "Favorite Zelda... Areas," I was sold. Peebs, you MUST make this list.
Stone Tower better be on there.
I remember watching the "hello I'm a dragon" when I was like 10 and I thought it was hilarious
Travis Griffing exactly
Me too
Travis Griffing same thought I was the only one
Me too.
Same
“I don’t know what my name is!”
Austin. Your name is Austin.
What are you talking about? His name is Peebs.
peebuttgay
Austin Hargrave is his name.
That’s just what he wants you to think ;)
PBG: "YOU 30 SOMETHINGS..."
Also PBG: Is 29
I like how he has the same age as my middle younger brother who Also LOVES ZELDA to death, kinda awesome XD
I'm 20 and ALTTP is my personal favorite 😂
He played us all...
Ok...?
I meant mid-30 somethings as those would be the ones who played the game as a kid, haha
Top 3 Zelda games
1. Zelda: The wand of Gamelon
2. Link: The faces of evil
3. Zelda’s adventure
No other Zelda game can compete with these masterpieces
Lol
Lmfao
What the frick are you serious?!
Wand of Gamelon is obviously not as good as Faces of Evil.
Faces of evil is better than wand of gamelon
I just realized Breath of the Wild is a handheld Zelda game.
(edit: this was before I actually had a Switch and middle-school-brain me couldn’t comprehend basic electronic functions.)
Damn
Any game is a handheld game if your strong enough
@@samuelbibb5958 you right
Donald Trump hows it been with Hillary Clinton
Porter Stout
Is on Wii U too
I remember being a little kid who loved twilight princess and getting really sad that TP got a really low score
That was his old opinion.
People are idiots. They asked for a game like OOT got one and said it was to much like OOT
Me too! It was, and still is, my favorite game of all time and when I saw him say it was "Not that great" my little Zant-loving heart shattered
like what you want
Twlight princess is my fav
"top 10 Zelda locations" doesn't sound that bad imo.
Yeah
Chayce agreed
I concur
I’m pretty sure all the locations for me would be lake Hylia from Oot
@@notcynthia9590 sky loft
The blatant disrespect to Zelda 2...smdh
S-lap
M-y
D-irty
H-at
?
Shaking my damn head
Zelda 2 is underloved
@@brunoorel372 shake my dumbass head possibly? Idk ive never seen someone use that--
S mashing
M y
D ick
H ard
Razbuten what’s your favorite Zelda. luv your content
I LOVE your boss key necklace that’s so cool and it matches your jacket really well!
point made
I want it
I want it so baadd
Its the key from Zelda Spirit Tracks. I also want it tbh
Early peabs be like: best Zelda game ever is ‘Link the Faces of Evil’
2030 leave be like: best Zelda game ever is 'Zelda the wand of gamelon'
We don’t talk about those games
Facts
@@Idevaughan530 CDI
IT SURE IS BORING AROUND HERE
Me watching a guy watching himself.
"Quality"
【Vocaloid English】 every KSI video in the last year
I'm watching a guy talking about watching a guy watching himself.
We are truly in a time paradox.
I thought this meant something else for a split second
"I really don't care that much about link to the past"
Friend looks over in disgust
>:0
PBG is so brave to speak the truth about how ALTTP is mediocre
No idea about this one. I didn't play it when I was younger either and I still found ALTTP to be one of the few older Zeldas that held up.
Them's opinions I guess!
@@rykeng7923
LIES.... Wait I lied when I said lies so that means it's the truth yea it's cringe
@@Barrelrollz ALTTP is one of the first video games I've ever played but it doesn't hold up at all. Everything the game does has been done better by later games in the series and it isn't special enough on its own to be worth going back to.
This just in: Internet mans opinions have changed in the past 8 years.
This could game changing, folks! Let's go see what Charlie thinks. Charlie?
Astonishing, simply astonishing. Stay tuned to watch the story unfold. For now though, let’s take it back to Hank for the weather. Hank?
@@zacharylanton6134 *RRRAAAAAAAAIIIIIIIINNNNNNNN*
OtherCannon Also god, so much blood, none of us couldve seen this coming, god, we need help, and we need it now, transfering to reuben back at the station.
UNFORGIVABLE
"Twilight Princess: Not that great" *-George Washington*
He also loved wii sports resort, apparently.
Toad Washington
@@nabeelnitro6447 George washingtoad
Jorg Washingmachine
George Washingtub
PBG: “If you’re gonna do goofy videos, than maybe don’t pick such a serious topic.”
Also PBG: *TOP 10 ZELDA GAMES IN 30 SECONDS, GO!*
"Sorry Breath of the Wild fans"
*Link to the Past sits in the corner*
Make link talk to Old PBG and change his and everyone opinions that its best and New PBG say "yes"
_Where it belongs._
New drinking game: take a shot every time Past Peebs says “honestly”
*hyuck*
Sorry but I don’t wanna die of alcohol poisoning
I died from alcohol poisoning
I AM DED
I've got a year to go before I can do this
7:22 “it’s funny how it kinda came full circle like that.” Peeps I think it was intentional
PBG be like:
Top 10 TH-camrs:
10. PBG
Reason: Well he has a beard-
He didn't get a haircut yet.
what about the Completionist?
@@youtube.username Right, you get the joke lmao!
William Shakespeare he’s cute too
@@Konradix05 PLOT TWIST he has no hair and it's actually aliens
I haven’t seen PBG in yearss...Good to know he’s still Shaggy.
There were dark times, but all is right once more
Valentine what happened?
Rehmit if it’s what I’m thinking about then go back a few videos. His hair is super long. Check out the most recent Goodwill Garbage.
Stickynote Studios alright
I don't know, I feel like having Mario enemies in a Zelda game is a totally valid reason to put it on the list.
My wife has Link's Awakening as her favorite Zelda, and that is basically literally the only reason why
@@stulog you guys sound like you have good taste.
Im sad Spirit Tracks didnt have a chance to appear on the list. I really like that game and I feel like that game has a really nice Zelda that you can learn and care more about her
Yeah I agree. The soundtrack is also amazing!
Best one imo. Incorporates the music in a really clever way
What’s weird is that, even though no one talks about it, whenever they do talk about it, they never have anything bad to say about it specifically. It mostly is just grouped with Phantom Hourglass, which is a shame.
Personally I didn't like spirit tracks very much and it's the only zelda game I've started and never finished
@@ss5gogetunks That's understandable, I'm just curious why you dislike it.
PBG: *realises his video is one of the first videos when you search “Top 10 Zelda Games”
Also PBG: suffering from success
It's kind of weird to think that even as recently as 2011, TP was the "newest" Zelda game we had. It's been a great decade for Zelda!
I can vouch for your ambivalence toward LTTP though; it's funny how quickly Skyward Sword gets lambasted over one boss that you have to hit in the eye when LTTP has 3 of them (well I guess Arrghus is debatable). If anything, Tentalus is just a reminder of what great settings SS has for a lot of its boss fights, rather than them all taking place indoors in big empty rooms, making sure to slap something in the middle of the room if it's a miniboss (oh hey OoT).
Sshd please Nintendo.
TIM
TIM!!
Up in Pennsylvania November is the month for a lot of hunting seasons.
Hey Tim good to see you
Lmao I remember when I was a kid and I loved twilight princess because it was my first 3d Zelda and I loved the darker atmosphere and cool animations link had and I almost unsubscribed from your channel when I watched that video because I was so offended that you put that game so low
Same here
Cool story bro
Everyone is fergeting tp.
twilight princess is even better of botw tbh. Almost nothing compares its atmosphere and the wonderful story
You know you can disagree with a TH-camrs opinion and still like them. That’s how people work. Dumbass.
Old peebs vids are very nostalgic for me and seeing the guy who made them react to them is very cool
Veeeeeeeeery coool
Yeah I grew up with them.
Oh god if peebs sees he's going to feel old.
“TP princess is dark.”
*Laughs in hitting everyone with a wooden sword for half the game
You only used a wooden sword to hit everyone?
@@undeadbrian8403 You don't get the Master Sword until late in the game
@@TheInkPitOx After third dungeon, but before the start of the first dungeon is like another dungeon. So about mid game I would say
Also I don't wanna be that guy, but the wooden sword is only for until you first turn wolf, which is like 30 minutes, maybe an hour into the game. The ordon sword and the wooden sword are not the same weapon.
@High Definition Oh well, I guess I am the fool
@@joeymormango8614 Right
"there's no other handheld Zelda games!"
so we just gonna ignore Spirit Tracks like that huh
ngl i actually like the games. they're good games
*Fights final boss*
"Alright brutha time for a flute solo!"
*I scream externally*
I played ST on the wii u,
and JESUS the flute is broken
on rerelease.
I was so happy when I finished all the temple songs, so i never had to do the duets again, but then it ruins the endgame.
I quit.
It got me to quit a zelda game, at the final boss.
I had already spents months sending postcards and grinding to get all the gold train parts, then i quit because it takes a good 40+ tries to get the spirit flute to work on wii u.
Although i DID play it on ds first, and while the duets gave me trouble they were nowhere NEAR as bad,
the game's just bad at commumicating that it doesn't want you to start playing when the partner looks at you (like it says to do) it wants you to wait for the measure of 4 to end before you start.
I wished we could ignore it. It's the worst of the bunch. XD
OH YEAH! I love spirit tracks! (I kinda also forgot about that one)
I kinda want another of the DS Zeldas. The touch controls worked so freaking well, the boss fights were awesome, and they actually used your items in creative ways outside of combat.
“I’m gonna make a twilight princess video to make up for this”
Me: T a s t y
It's HD
Pbg in 2018: breath of the wild is the best Zelda game
Pbg in 2019: number ten
To be fair, the whole video is made to show his opinions change with the time. He's entitled to his opinion, of course, and I could see why he may not like BotW as much as before
Maybe it's the recency effect?
Though it's all very funny
lets be honest, it was really just him naming the first ten zelda games that came to his mind
@@Joltz9 yeah.
@@Joltz9 yeah but mm is always going to be his favorite and a lot of other people's
Here’s the thing: I still quote the “I’m a dragon” bit from that video to this day
Honestly i really love your old videos, even if theyre wonky or the opinions are bad. I used to watch your videos as a kid and being able to go back and watch them as an adult is such a nostalgia trip tbh
This video just came back up in my feed and I’m tripping that this was 3 years ago and even more that his original list was 11 years ago. I remember being 9 with my Itouch binging pbg, good times
"I agree with whatever dumb opinion you have, and feel free to use this in an argument at any point in the future once I'm dead."
-George Washingtoad
"Also, please don't delete your channel, PBG. We love your videos."
-George Washingtoad
Your cat is cute.
@@owofurry1356 thanks :) Her name is Marshmallow
@@rosieleaverton that is litterally the best name for a cat I've ever heard and I'm stealing that name.
@@owofurry1356 haha! Go ahead, lol. I ain't stopping ya.
@@owofurry1356 also, "litter-ally" XD
2011: TP at number ten.
2019: BoTW at number ten.
Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
My favorite comment here
Coming back in eight years, bye
Botw is overrated
i would actually put botw as 7 in top 10 at best
Ozzmand In terms of Zelda game, sure
In terms of VIDEO GAME, not even close
"I took a serious topic, a Top 10 Zelda Games video,"
I remember being really excited seeing someone love Skyward Sword as much as I did haha
I’ll defend that game like it’s my child. Motion controls was never a problem for me
@@kerocz3363 Yes! The motion controls always worked fine for me so long as I didn’t just wildly flail around
Windwaker has aged really well because of the stylized graphics, still one of my top 3 too.
Honestly I HATE the Wind Waker Graphics. I'm normally not a graphic person, but these look so cringy.
@@Acacius1992 take a look at wind waker hd
OOT: omg best game of all time
WindWaker: bad graphics, game bad
????
@MasterMooper
I cant say much about Wind Waker, it is probaly a good game, but I realy cant stand this cel shading look.
Also Oot is good of course, but it have it's flaws as well
Graphics-wise, it's great.
Gameplay-wise... it's way too easy and kinda boring because of it.
Intense watching of the video:
*stops loading*
*_AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH_*
*starts loading again*
More intense watching of the video
Definitely made me laugh out loud, loved that part!
It was pretty accurate bit tbh lmao
It's been years since I've seen a PBG vid...why does he have anime hair now
We’ve all been wondering. It actually used to be worse, he looked like a homeless person, it’s current shape is better.
@@pingnixon-hermansen5046 oh I remember the homeless phase. And also it wasn't a drag, I was just a bit shocked
Just a youtube commenter bowl cut wasn’t cutting it I guess lol
@@pingnixon-hermansen5046 Lol'd at that.
He only recently cut it, god it was so long... So long, if you haven't seen it then I don't know how to explain that oversized mop hair he had.
Twilight Princess is my favorite Zelda actually xD
Then wind waker after that
yeah me too I really dont understand why it get some much hate lol
PBG got less serious and a higher pitched voice as he got older.
Usually it's the other way around. 👀
So he’s Cosmo with a brain? I’m cool with that.
“WhErE aRe aLL tHe CoLoRs”
Im dead lmao.
Then puts a GAMEBOY game above it with 2-3 colours in it
Well it's fine, you have your fav at number 1 and 2-10 are just liquid interchangeable
He’s remained so wholesome after all this time
Cringing about something in the past just means you've grown as a person.
No, that's just something all introverts do. And it usually only takes a few seconds to a day.
@@benjaminsimons8263 nah nah nah, andi muhlestein was right.
@@benjaminsimons8263 i do it like 19 hours a day
Or if u don’t it means u just have had good logic for a while
Yeah you right
Gahd, I rmemeber when that video came out, and thinking "oh, so people don't like TP? Okay."
Same, it was news to me as well.
I’d say I agree with PastButterGamer and put the Oracle games above it though. 100% for nostalgia, has zero to do with quality lol
Toilet paper?
@@lukegilmore9359 Twilight Princess
If I'm.being honest I think I avoided Twilight Princess because of that video
Swish Fish I'm pretty sure people don't like it that much. I kinda agree with Peebs old opinions except for the dark stuff
“Twilight Princess is not that great.”
“Them’s fightin’ words where I come from partner...”
Mason Schwalm it’s true though
I agree :/ you can decide which one I agree with
True dat.
The only problem I have with Twilight Princess is that it takes a while to get started. Other than that, it's amazing.
Where I come from it’s acceptable
Skyward Sword is my favourite zelda game, because of the story. Link and Zelda's relationship is super cute, and all of the Skyloft citizens have some depth too. Also I think the motion controls are really fun.
I wish I still had my wii T_T
I would say tp or mm for my favorite (im just looking for botw fans hating on good games)
I still had my Wii and Skyward is one of the best, if not best of all, BECAUSE motion controll, not despite. My letdown is Twillight princess, which I played after, bad controlls, dark, boring and easy.
My second favorite after tp
Tee underscore tee
@@hyliandude9706 I play since ocarina of time and yeah botw is the best
"I must've rushed my previous list"
Rushes out his new list even faster...
Oddly enough what i've seen of the reception to Skyward Sword was the opposite. Everyone was singing its praises when it first came out and then slowly started turning against it.
Those were mostly critic reviews. Many fans hated it from th get-go. I thought it was alright, the best in many areas like bossfights, and I thought the silent realms and many of the dungeons were excellent... but the linearity, slowness, the empty sky and all the fetch quests really hurt the game.
Szabu As controversial as this is, Skyward Sword is my favourite Zelda game. Probably mostly because of nostalgia, but I still enjoy playing it.
I’d love a full remake of the game, cutting out the unnecessary bits and changing the pacing of the game, but knowing Nintendo that wouldn’t happen.
@@echowhosthis Skyward Sword is also still my favorite Zelda game to date! Glad I'm not alone on that!
@@echowhosthis Maybe it will someday, actually. In Wind Waker HD they actually changed the pacing by introducing the swift sail that makes ou not have to change the wind direction on the sea, and also they removed half the Triforce charts - the areas that gave you the charts in the original game now give you the Triforce pieces directly. Personally I didn't have issue with the original, but a lot of people welcomed these changes.
@@19Szabolcs91 The pacing of the game is so ingrained into it its core that they would have to overhaul the core of the game. The pacing is pretty bad in Skyward Sword because you are forced to go through every major area three times. Sure, you are doing something different everytime, but you are still go through the same area regardless.
One thing I heard about BotW that some people missed from SS was the crazy good story telling, like the relationship between Zelda and Link or when Link has to drop the sword back into the stone basically killing off Fi, another thing that I haven't heard too much but did notice was the lack of dungeon themes. Like the most memorable ones to me, from SS are the Ancient Cistern and Fire Sanctuary and that's mostly because of the bosses at the end, compared to BotW where I can't even remember the Divine Beasts names.
If the sequel has that good story telling with the open world exploration, I don't think Nintendo would be able to outdo themselves.
"I thought twilight princess wasn't great
reason: COLOR WHEEL"
LOL I actually increased the color setting on my tv 15% to fix that "problem" myself!
PBG: Some of you 30-somethings
... I'm 31 and feel so old right now...
Dont worry. He will join the club eventually.
Some of us 40 somethings disagree with PBG on that. Although in my
case I just turned 40 last month so I'm not that old yet. The older millennialswill join me soon.
Pri Correia I’m 35 and my hip snapped from the disrespect.
38. Enjoy early 30s. Cause mid thirties and late 30s creep up on you like photons.
27 and I’m getting a little scared
When I read the title, I thought you meant the top 10 worst Zelda games! 😂
Same
Same tbh
Same
1 to 10: Zelda: Wand of Gamelon.
Same
i just noticed how when abbreviated Majora’s Mask and Wind Waker are MM and WW kinda like how tonally different they are.
It would make more sense though if it was the opposite of ocarina of time. Because majored mask to ocarina of time is still the same, but also totally different if that makes sense
This is just an apology video for saying twilight princess is not that good 10 years ago
I thought this was a “Top 10 Worst Zelda Games”
I thought this was "The Top 10 Worst Top 10 Zelda Games List", but apparently it's only focusing on the #1 entry.
Ooooh
Me too.
Me too
Same. Now I hope he will make such a list.
6:02 Funnily enough, you mocking the old joke then using it again is probably one of my fav jokes on PBG you've ever done. That was excellent and unexpected.
11:36 I laughed so hard I started crying 🤣
😐
not actually
😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
11:20
“Cartoony”
- The video will have no notifications
-The video will have no comments
-The video will not be searchable
-The video will not be suggested/recommended
-The video will make 90% less revenue
Too soon...
Hot Take: Link's real name is Lincoln
Oh goddesses why
NO NEVER (I got no beef this is funny but WHY )
Lol 😊
My older brother's name is Lincoln, so he'd rename Link to Linc
I think that's only with Zelda II, because that is NEVER brought up again.
My 14 yr old self back then: WHAT TWILIGHT PRINCESS IS MY FAVORITE. It's ok I still love you peebs ;~;
Me now at 22: ah how the turntables. Redemption arc time
Wind Walker is my favorite Zelda.
Lol autocorrect?
Ah yes, Wind Walker. My second favorite zelda game after the 1998 classic, Orcarina of Time.
Wind Walker is a true classic
Windwaker has the best dungeons
I'm pretty sure showing "Top 10 Zelda Areas" would violate TH-cam terms of agreement.
"Top 10 Zelda Areas"
*BZZZT*
"Top 10 Zelda Spots"
*BZZZT*
"Top 10 Zelda Regions"
*BZZZT*
"Top 10 Zelda Zones"??
*BZZZZZZZZT*
topbreak38 ZD LOL
Rebekah Johnson ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
... Lmao XD
PBG: "Link to the Past isn't even in the top 10."
Egoraptor would like to know your location.
Bwooop megaman megaman
even if he knew he wouldnt be able to get there since he is bad at 3D Stuff
Who cares what that opinionated dictator thinks?
Skyward Sword still is my favourite Zelda game.
I love the story, Ghirahim is the best Zelda-villain ever.
Skyloft and the Surface World are awesome and fun to explore.
And the artstyle and characters are also very likable.
Never had a problem with the Motion Controls either, except for one part.
I admit that it has its flaws.
The Sky outside Skyloft is lackluster, the game resorts to a lot of padding that can get annoying sometimes and it's also one of my least favourite Zelda-games to complete 100%, just because of that damn Strumming Mini game (only time I really struggle with the motion controls in this game).
And yet despite all this, I still love this game and I think it's the best.
And if Mr: egotistical Reptile thinks I'm a mental defect for thinking this, efff him!
Egoraptor approaches
What's he gonna do? Pull up and not know how to use his shield?
Me: oh twenty four minutes ago? Finally my chance to say something witty and/or funny and get noticed!
Comments: 522
Me: I’m gonna leave now......
Yclept Prof. I am freaking out right now
When I first saw your original top 10 list, I laughed out loud when you put Zelda II above TP. I loved it. Strong choices.
I’ve been subbed to you since your channel started and it’s crazy how far you’ve come man
Thanks for sticking around!
Me too. I'm impressed that you even put in the effort to make video's. Especially because they are so good. I've tried
“Twilight Princess is not that great.”
~George Washingtoad
washingtoad
Shachar Raz Oops. Thanks for the correction.
🤣🤣🤣
I mean, he’s right.
11:36 my grandpa after I give him Adderall pills.
😳😳
No way brug
Adderall is amphetamine and a deadly, illegal drug 💊
David Bergmann please don’t arrest this man’s grandfather I’m begging you have a heart
What did I stumble into?
Your old videos hold a lot of nostalgia for me because I used to watch them all on repeat as a kid. I sometimes find myself quoting you and i don't even realize! To this day I sometimes say the "gahh you killed me" part in the Zelda II section OUT LOUD in real life.
PLEASE do a top 10 ZELDA “AREAS”
Good idea
Yea
😂😂😂😂
Starts video off by apologizing for Twilight Princess being #10 in his last Top 10 Zelda Games
Ends video by putting Breath of the Wild at #10
😂😂😂😂
Gotta give myself a new video to do 8 years from now. =P
PeanutButterGamer I’ll be waiting 😁
@@PeanutButterGamer love you peebs
Tbh pleas don’t hate me for this but *inhales in German* Botw is probs one of the worst ones there’s too much World and not enough story
Forget that. Where the hell is A Link to the Past?!
"I'm making a Twilight Princess video, I'm changing my opinions on the game"
Thank you for not massacring my boy. ;u;
EDIT: TWILIGHT PRINCESS AT NUMBER 3 BABY HEEEEELLLL YEAH
YEAH BABY! and Majoras Mask at 1, as it should be
@Brandon Bevill yeah, I really disagree with breath of the wild being at 10
Twilight Princess is the best Zelda game
I hate Twilight Princess lol
@Brandon Bevill It had so many great innovations in it, I was blabbing bout it literally yesterday.
Twilight Princess: "I came here to have a good time, but I'm honestly feeling really attacked right now"
"Majora's Mask is #1 and I don't see that ever changing"
Breath of the wild 2 looms in the distance...
Given that he put BoTW at 10 on this list, I really don't see its sequel overtaking MM.
Hooded Man Yeah I agree since he even has stated in streams before that he thinks it’s way overhyped.
@@mangotango4529 doesn't mean it's not a bloody great game
I dont think that Breath of the wild 2 will be as dark as majoras mask, the entire lore of it, the characters everything about the game is dark and dreary.
"It was a popular opinion that the graphics are too kiddy"
And the cycle repeats itself with Link's Awakening
The only graphic criticism for that game I can kinda understand is that the game has a "plastic" feel to it. I wonder how it would look if it was more "organic"
I have yet to try the game myself (though i definetely will at some point) so I cant speak in too much detail. But I wouldnt regard it as "too kiddy", more like it looks very stiff and plastic. Almost like the world and its characters are made out of toys, which kinda rub me the wrong way for a zelda game. But yeah, I will try it myself before I jump to any conclusions.
I heared that the game has a bad framerate, not that the artstyle is kiddy.
@@XMonument It's deliberately designed in the style of a diorama. It's very beautiful and unique in ways I didn't expect before playing. I totally recommend it!
@@AtlasBlizzard I feel like that style is way too overused honestly, but I'm glad for the people that enjoy it
Oml 😂”she’s a very good girl and she says link to the past is not very good”
It took me a while to realize that this wasn’t his list of least favorites, but instead mocking his old list. I think it’s funny.
It definitely took me too long to figure that out as well..
As someone who's only played 1 Zelda game, I can proudly say that Phantom Hourglass is the best Zelda game to exist.
Y’all please stop replying about how you guys hated playing it, I am allowed to like my own games lol
you've got alot of catching up to do
.......
get going
St. wvllxw Nah mate I'm gonna stop while I'm ahead
@@kay-sp4gk At least you didn't put Majora's Mask at #1 like so many other people. That seems to have become the overall popular opinion as of late for some reason.
myst9900 what wrong with MM? its a great game
@@st.wvllxw7238 Yeah but I am sick of the hype for it. I can name several problems with it. First of all I hate having a time limit even with different things happening on each day. Secondly you have to go back to day one just to save your game permanently. Third you lose all of your consumable items in doing so and have to use up time just to get them back whether purchasing them or farming them which is just annoying to me. Fourth, The Great Bay temple nuff said there. Fifth, having to redo any whole temple if you do not have time to finish it in three hours with the inverted song of time otherwise you only have fifty minutes. Sixth, not knowing where to go at the beginning of the game without a guide and also having to redo certain parts to get into certain places unless you have a proper mask if applicable. Now while the game does have wonderful atmosphere (the kafei quest is one of the few moments that I enjoyed when I watched a let's play of the game) there are just too many things that bother me when I try to play it so I find it to be a frustrating experience and I play games to have fun not to be annoyed thank you very much.
When I was a kid I thought the ‘Hey I’m a dragon!’ Was hilarious
I still think its funny and im 16
Joseph Pastore well ya, you’re 16
@@rabbidnipples holy shit you fucking killed him
Omg same haha
I was like 10 when I first saw the video 6 years ago, still makes me giggle a little
I played through majoras mask recently, I tried when I was 11, couldnt find woodfall and stopped, when I was 13 I got to ikana and was to afraid to continue bc of the statue, then last week as a 17 year old I started a new save and 100%'d it. I had to beat my fear of that statue and not pointing fingers here but it was entirely sparked by pbg
“Skyward sword” instant flashback to hacking video
PBG: Puts breath of the wild in number 10
The entirety of the zelda community: *So you have chosen...death*
Well, to be fair, the battle system isn't that great, specially if your weapon is REALLY damaged, and it breaks, and it was the only one you had left
@@sb14andmore50 There are plenty of avenues in the game to get a new weapon even when you break your last one.
Also, if that's the only problem you had, then it just goes to show how masterful the game overall is.
Entirety my ass. While Botw is pretty popular it still divided the fanbase.
@@Eversoul12 Only a bit. The most critical of the game are in a very vocal minority. But if you look at any polls that have come around since the game released, they all have BotW sweeping in vast majorities.
Where were the dungeons and bosses at?
10 year old me was so offended when he put TP at #10 it was my favorite 😭
"I'll delete your comment!" Oh, go PBG! XD
Actually, I'd like a top 10 Zelda locations list.
Yeah, sounds like it could be fun
Hmm... Top 10 Zelda locations... 🤔
"I liked the motion controls in skyward sword"
Arin screaming in the distance
BOMB BOWLING!!!!!
Napier A GAME GRUMPS FAN.
Napier Pretty much everyone who don’t like motion control.
I'm here for the almost 20 minutes of self-roasting
honestly I feel like BoTW should be around rank 10. It's a great game but needed more classic Zelda elements, such as replacing the Divine Beasts with standard large temples that give variation from the otherwise open world design. The shrines exist but they are only tiny dungeons and are unfortunately very repetitive in theming and challenges.
I'd definitely put it in the top 10, but idk, it could of used more classic Zelda elements to contrast with the openness
wow thats....really incorrect
Everyone talking about how PBG has grown but I’m here thinking he forgot Spirit Tracks when he was talking about Zelda handhelds
Spirit Tracks and Phantom Hourglass are valid, even if they do have weird control schemes (and despite the Temple of the Ocean King being tedious to get through in Phantom Hourglass).
Being able to ride a train around New Hyrule/sail about around the ocean realm is fun, dangit. Also Spirit Tracks has one of the best overworld themes in Zelda.
Being meguca is suffering. Exactly so there is no reason Spirit Tracks shouldn’t be added
@@beingmegucaissuffering.5326 I really liked phantom hourglass! Why does everyone not like it
@@toonlink8151 Probably because of the weird-for-the-time controls and the low-ish level of detail with reused assets and stuff, plus the Temple of the Ocean King being tedious to backtrack through.
Personally I do really like Phantom Hourglass and Spirit Tracks. I think that more people should give them a chance, since they're legitimately good games despite their flaws.
(Also if you want to see somebody give Phantom Hourglass the acknowledgement it deserves, I suggest watching Chuggaaconroy's Let's Play of it, if you haven't already. He makes a lot of good points about it.)
I will fight anyone that says the ds zelda games aren't good.