Cheraman Perumal, a king of the medieval Chera dynasty in Kerala, India, is said to have witnessed the splitting of the moon. Around 640 CE. Saying that there is no historical evidence of moon splitting is not absolute.
How come he was the only sole witness? And he converted? So we have to dismiss him for biased reasons. There were many pagan moon worshipers across Africa and Europe that would have noticed and no such records of them running berserk in panic. All this trouble to split the moon did not change anything to the jahilya Arabs except for one King in India? Think!
Reasonable explanation to believe that incident described(moon splitting) is not as past tens,but future tens as for Allah there no past ,He is always present,in our past ,present and future
Sheikh Uthman has a very good answer for the Splitting of the Moon. Nauman is not a Hadith expert he shouldn't dwell into something he doesn't know. Sheikh Uthman is Masters in Hadith.
The answer isn't very good at all... It's one example of an Indian king thinking he saw the moon split. And somehow that is conclusive evidence. Hadith generally are problematic imo
Both are great examples for us, may Allah keep us and them guided always, Aameen. No need arguing about them, their humbleness and sincerity In Shaa Allah will put us to shame if we argue wrongly about them, lets always be Brothers for Allah's sake, JazaakumuLLAHU Khayran
You have a very strong argument here and that is difficult to refute. I enjoyed the reasoning from the beginning till the end. Thank you very much and may Allah bless you.
Opinions versus reality. I can’t find the clip I saw a few years back but I remember it distinctly. In a conference of some scientists/ physicists in the west talking about shape of the moon observed through observatories with marks and signs as if moon had split and then rejoined. What to believe ?!🤔
Yessss! I remember this too, but it’s wipe off the internet because it’s hella proof that the Quran is in fact THE book from God.. even ai is lying saying “there no scientific proof “... they would do everything not to have proof of Allah existence is insane and even more proof that it is real and the truth as this fact is mentioned in the Quran.. got to also remember... the internet is almost 99% control by zlo ni$t...
By read all the comment, somehow i feel that this is the same type of comment that people says when Rasulullah says that there is 2 water meet but not mix (gilbraltar sea). Later when technology become more advance, then they can see evidence of that. Same as the moon split, later you guys will find the evidence when technology become advance... In Syaa Allah
Mind your language , the person above is respectful so should you be, while talking about a miracle associated with the holy Prophet p.b.u.h we must be respectful and not say such things.Kindly repent and delete this now.
The moon is accepted as some 400km across (diameter), while on it is a feature, a chasm called "Rima Areadaeus", which is 300km long- a literal "split". The Quran is true on all levels, despite how we want to wrap our heads around it. And Allah knows best
Yes the "split" is caused by difference of temperature between the core and space be ause the moon has no atmosphere. The coran is wrong at so many levels it is a miracle people are still following it.
Nobody denies about the facts of the moon in its own form. What people find it hard believe is about a bullshit story of a fake prophet splitting the moon.
In shaa ALlāhu, I will explain this topic in a more convincing way using Qur’an, Hadith and real life situation. “The Hour (the Day of Resurrection) has drawn near, and the moon has been split. Yet if they see a sign, they turn away and say, ‘Passing magic.’” (Qur’an 54:1-2) 1. Understanding from the Qur’anic text ✓The Past Tense of “Inshaqqa” • The verb “inshaqqa” (has been split) is in the past tense, indicating that the event had already occurred before these verses were revealed. ✓ Logical Incoherency of a Future Event •If the splitting of the moon were to happen in the future, it would be incoherent to link it to the statement that the Hour of Resurrection has drawn near. How can an event yet to occur be presented as evidence that the Resurrection is near? • So saying the moon will split in future would undermine the logical flow of the argument, as a future event cannot serve as a current sign or rational proof. In this case, ALlāhu is the best in speech and what He has revealed is the truth. ✓ The Context of the Following Verse • Qur’an 54:2 explicitly states that the people of that time saw the sign but dismissed it as “passing magic.” This indicates that they had already witnessed the splitting of the moon, which was a manifest sign of Allah’s power and a warning of the Resurrection, yet they rejected it and persisted in their disbelief. 2. The incident of the literal splitting of the moon is reported in hadith. Narrated Ibn Masud: During the lifetime of Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) the moon was split into two parts; one part remained over the mountain, and the other part went beyond the mountain. On that, Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “Witness this miracle.” Sahih al-Bukhari 4864 3. Real-Life Scenario to understand what ALlāhu says in Qur’an 29:51: In Qur’an 29:50-51, the disbelievers were asking for miracles and ALlāhu was saying: (Translation of the meaning) “.....is it not sufficient for them that We revealed to you the Book which is recited to them?. This doesn’t mean that the revelation of Qur’an is the only miracle. But it means that Qur’an is sufficient as a miracle. After all, they might’ve forgotten how other miracles took place, but Qur’an(the greatest miracle) is still being recited to them and they cannot match its eloquence. ✓ A Teacher and Students Imagine a teacher in a classroom. The teacher is very skilled and, at the beginning of the semester, performs an extraordinary experiment that amazes the students. For instance, he demonstrate a complex scientific principle that no one had seen before, leaving the class in awe. Some students(serious ones) were amazed and agreed that he is good teacher. Some (unserious students) didn’t agree but said the teacher used just a tricky way to perform the experiment. As times goes on, the teacher was developing a textbook for the students. When the exam is approaching, the serious students was studying hard but the unserious students demanded more experiments. They said to the teacher....“Why don’t you perform another experiment to prove your point?” The teacher responds: “Isn’t the textbook enough for you? In this case, the statement “Isn’t the textbook enough for you” doesn’t mean the teacher didn’t perform the experiment in the first place, it only mean that the information in his textbook is enough to convince them of whatever they think they needed to prepare for the exam. ALlāhu is free from the above teacher-student scenario.
I do believe that seeing a miracle then rejecting it is not the sole trigger for a punishment to come. There should be many other factors that are intertwined, and Allah knows best. Maybe they were not punished right away because God still had better plans that involved them, where they were needed for something else in the future. If those people were punished right away after seeing a miracle, then the prophet and his followers would have not been tested later. Maybe Allah kept those people alive to serve this purpose, to become the source of trials for the prophet and his followers, and from these trials we could finally learn so much more lessons. Or maybe Allah just wanted to extend His mercy, to show that His mercy is so much more than His anger towards those people. That is why they were left alove, and who knows, maybe some of them would later become believers themselves in the future. A lot of the prophet’s companions actually came from these once disbelievers, even enemies, after all. Or maybe even in the past events, the disbelievers were shown miracles or proofs multiple times before they got punished. We only got the impression that they were punished right away, because the Qur’an tends to oversimplify the details of the actual events, as long as the core messages of such story got delivered. Allah knows best. But I do agree with Nouman Ali Khan that esentially, in the last miracle (which is the Qur’an), God wants us to believe by CHOICE, not FORCE.
Or, with the coming of the Qur'an, the "Moon" is rendered split. Considering that the Qur'an words mystery are so deep, only ignorant people would only understand the simple meaning of moon splitting, rather than to Dig deeper to know its meaning.
Have we guys considered other possibilities of why the splitting of the moon was rarely found in the literatures of other nations? Maybe the geography skewed the perspectives of those nations, so they could not see the split clearly from their places. Idk.
@ We are discussing this phenomenon in the realm of religious belief system. If you don’t adhere to such belief, then this place is not for you. I am actually wondering, why would any person who doesn’t have any businesses getting involved in such discussion would bother coming here in the first place. That would be… “insane”. So please, you could see your way out, if you don’t mind.
Pharaoh did not believe even when he was shown other miracles, such as the stick turning into a snake and the light in Prophet Musa's (Moses', peace be upon him) hand, so that logic is valid. Similarly, Prophet Sulaiman (Solomon, peace be upon him) was also shown many miracles.so moon split I believe it literally
I heard that it is when a miracle of demand is given and people still refuses only then the decree comes. Otherwise God gives miracles to His prophets whatever He wants.
We learnt The Qur'an is not a miracle for the eyes, but for the Reflexion. The Moon Splited ? The verse itself explains what is about : First noun "The Hour", it's about Time, next noun, the Moon, this is the tool to size the Time (surah 10.5). The full surah is about the Hour, and then, a description of the men before this Hour.
One of the sahih hadith in bukhari mentions mina in the month of dhul hajj at the time of moon split but during this month on 8th of dhul hajj we visit mina. But on that day moon itself will be half because full moon is on 14th day of the month so the moon was split in half or the half of moon was split in half and full moon was split in quarter?
Which moon are you referring to-Arab's or Earth's? It is important to note that Earth's moon did not split. When evidence regarding a matter becomes clear, ancient Semitic speakers would describe it with the phrase, "the hour drew near and the moon split." This expression signifies that there is no longer any mystery or doubt regarding the issue at hand. This is how the phrase is used in the Quran. So, could you clarify what you are talking about?
The Qur'an is a living miracle. That's one component to the miraculous nature of the Qur'an. All other miracles are time bound and the preserve of a select few who happened to be present to witness said miracle. Whereas the Qur'an can be studied and appreciated by all of us in the present. It's an unfolding miracle.
Interestingly none of the classical tafaseer he quoted disbelieved in this Miracle mentioned in the Quran however nouman Ali khan doesn’t believe it happened. And he is making it public how many young people can he take with himself to disbelief in this miracle I wonder.
maybe the editor of this video only put the Quranic argument but i would be interested in Ustadh's response on Bukhari. We are talking about Sahih Bukhari here not some random book and Bukhari clearly says it got splited. Allah knows best. May Allah give us benefical knowledge.
believe in Quran, Hadiths are what people say about prophet Muhmmad peace be upon him, and prophet bear no responsibility on it, a Hadith might be true or false, Imam who collected the Hadiths made their best sincere efforts but that doesn't mean they are prophets, only HUJJAH for Muslims should be Quran and Sunnah in the absence of Prophet.
@@focumQuarium Not exactly, we must need to understand, Hadiths are reported one year after the death of prophet, move over, some time only one, two or more than two people claimed they have heard prophet saying this, and even sometimes they didn't mention the situation in what context PROPHET said. SUNNAH is actually practical manifestation of IHKAMS of Quran and the actions of Prophets before Muhammad PBUH, remember Muhmmad PBUM didn't invent the religion, He just followed the Quran, also please note, every action of prophet is not SUNNAH (personal actions) but what God had asked them to do so (related to religion). Muhmmad PBUM didn't performed religion actions in front of one, two or three persons rather it was his obligation to show all religious actions to each and everyone to his capacity.
It wasn't a sign given for prophethood. It was a sign that happened as the hour has come near { ٱقۡتَرَبَتِ ٱلسَّاعَةُ وَٱنشَقَّ ٱلۡقَمَرُ } [Surah Al-Qamar: 1] The Hour has drawn near and the moon was split The Prophet was confirming , like what they were able to witness because of the hour coming closer, everyother prophecy will also come true.
His reasoning is not sound about Kuffat asking for miracles and Allah not mentioning Moon Split. Because Mushirkun said to prophet that you bewitched our eyes and did not belive the Miracle already
18:12 it wasnt a mirical at all..! Quran is mirical but moon split happened and SAW ASKED the companions be witness as in makki quran it seems end of time is near..! So if it can happen then all the rest can happen..!
Good point, actually. I do believe that seeing a miracle then rejecting it is not the sole trigger for a punishment to come. There should be many other factors that are intertwined, and Allah knows best. Maybe they were not punished right away because God still had better plans that involved them, where they were needed for something else in the future. If those people were punished right away after seeing a miracle, then the prophet and his followers would have not been tested later. Maybe Allah kept those people alive to serve this purpose, to become the source of trials for the prophet and his followers, and from these trials we could finally learn so much more lessons. Or maybe Allah just wanted to extend His mercy, to show that His mercy is so much more than His anger towards those people. That is why they were left alove, and who knows, maybe some of them would later become believers themselves in the future. A lot of the prophet’s companions actually came from these once disbelievers, even enemies, after all. Or maybe even in the past events, the disbelievers were shown miracles or proofs multiple times before they got punished. We only got the impression that they were punished right away, because the Qur’an tends to oversimplify the details of the actual events, as long as the core messages of such story got delivered. Allah knows best. But I do agree with Nouman Ali Khan that esentially, in the last miracle (which is the Qur’an), God wants us to believe by CHOICE, not FORCE.
so the moon is split or not, because when they see the miracle with eyes and after reject they get punished. let me conclude on this please allah says moon is splitted like what they want other miracles
From my comprehension, they are still asking for another miracle. This isn't something new, look at Musa AS, he has shown more than one miracle but Firaun still doesn't believe.
But then again we can't take the jewish and christian texts to be reliable sources like that as they were edited and changed over time, so something not being mentioned in their texts doesn't really mean anything.
Nouman, you have built the whole case on the assumption that it was a miracle demanded by the Makkans, but that is a wrong assumption. According to many scholars, it was just a natural event that occurred and Allaah swt presented it as a sign for people, just as many other natural phenomena are presented to people as signs throughout the Qur'aan. This sign was presented to the skepctics who did not want to believe in the possibility of their destruction through a natural disaster or end of the world. So your whole case about miracles is irrelevant. You have not addressed the real key question: If it was something to happen in future, why does the Qur'aan presents it as a sign, saying, "if they see a sign, they turn away and say it is the same old magic". And then, the whole surah warns people with the examples of the previously destroyed nations. A future event cannot be presented as a sign, nor as a valid evidence of the possibility of the destruction of the kuffar.
Why Allah did mention all the prophets with their tangible miracles in the Quran except our prophet Mohammed? The answer is very simple. Because since he is the seal of the prophet, Allah honoured him with one eternal miracle ( Quran). Period!
The actual problem here is we are not getting the correct meaning of the terms in quran , Quranic Arabic is not the current Arabic, it's abrahamic location... So in short Kamar - Moon in abrahamic location means prophethoood ( meaning the messengers sent by Allah to explain Torah to Bani Israel ) and when quran came the moon or Kamar was no longer applicable ...as our Muhammed (PBUH) was Rasool to us meaning just recite quran and direct guidance will come from Allah and for bani Israel he was Nabih....and Musa spliiting the same was metaphorical meaning he separated believers from non believers..Sea in Abraham location means a state of confusion and something which is not steady..and quran downt need tasfeers to explain it..u need to explain quran from itself..hope Nouman u get some senses in u and stop translating the Qur'an using tasfeers:-)
[54:1] The Hour has come closer, and the moon has split.* *54:1 This important sign of the approaching end of the world came to pass in 1969 when humans landed on the moon and brought pieces of the moon to earth. At the same time, God's mathematical Miracle of the Quran was being gradually unveiled. Traditional Muslims opposed it, since it exposed the fallacy of their practices (Appendix 25).
Sir please stop misguiding people, by what you are saying that All the Sahaba who witnessed innumerous Miracles, so you mean to say that didn't happen? Also did other Prophets of Allah showed only one miracle and when their people rejected Allah sent His wrath on them? Don't use just mind to understand. Even without one Miracle we believe in Rasool Allah alaihis salam because of Him, His existence itself is the biggest One. Lazim Hai Dil ke Saath ho pazbane aqal Kabhi Kabhi ise tanha bhi chod Diya kar
@@rijviabir5172 thats yours and NAK's view! the vast majority believe that the moon splitting miracle did take place at the time of the Prophet (SAW). And NAK is not a scholar - he has admitted that dozens of times but fanatical fans of his just accept whatever he says without doing any research.
Yet, whenever they see a sign, they turn away,[[ A miracle (usually referred to as a ‘sign’ in the Quran) can be defined as an extraordinary event manifesting divine intervention in human affairs. Every prophet was given miracles to prove he was commissioned by Allah. Moses (ﷺ) was given the miracle of the staff and many others. Jesus (ﷺ) gave life to the dead and healed the blind and the leper. And Muḥammad (ﷺ) received the Quran, a literary miracle, to challenge the masters of Arabic eloquence. The Prophet (ﷺ) performed some other miracles such as splitting the moon, multiplying food and water, and healing some of his companions.]] saying, “Same old magic!” On judgement day people will be so desperate that they will utter the words of repentance.They will never say, “(This is) a transient magic.”on that day.
Quran does not refer to the physical splitting of the moon, it's just poor poor Tafaseers and unauthentic Ahadees. No miracles mentioned in Quran. Plz give Allah his true reverence. Shams implies The scripture Qamar implies the Rasool and Nabi
Mr Noman Ali Khan, for your information no one asking for your opinion. Keep your opinion to yourself. A question I would like to ask you based on your intelligence what miracle people of Prophet NUH was given before they were destroyed by the flood?
This is not very nice thing to say, people can have multiple interpretation on vague subjects. It doesn't effect their Iman. Even myself may not agree with him. But this is a thought process. May be we can come with something which can disprove him. Just like your question.
Sharing opinions is everyone’s right. Verifying information that other people shared, NOW THAT is an obligation for all listeners. I have an opinion to share with you, that’s my right. Then, you as the listener has the obligation to process and verifiy the credibility of what I just said, before completely accepting it or completely rejecting it. We call this “thinking process”. If your thinking process is already right, you wouldn’t be bothered by anything, and at the same time still able to respect other people’s opinions without being RUDE.
miracle is allah doing, prophet are only human. prophet asked allah, to make their stick to a snake, split ocean or cooling the fire. its all allah doing not the prophet.
nouman ali sahan you are denying sahi bukhari hadeeth HADEESE MUNKAR if science doesnt proof that doest means hadeeth is wrong common this is too much ruju karo bhai sahab according to you music is also halal
So what i get from this lecture is this, that even the most authentic books of Hadiths have fabricated Ahadiths. I would never reject the hadith about splitting of the moon despite the last point Nouman Ali khan made that once a people see a miracle and reject it, Allah destroy that people. Isn't the prophet Rahmatul Lil Alamin? And because he is Rahmatul Lil Alamin Allah would not destroy his people despite rejecting the splitting of the moon.
that why scholar had different opinion, and we need to interpret it ourself. for me, allah give the non believer multiple miracle before the punishment come. (not once) because at the core, muhammad SAW wanted everyone to be a muslim. that why he did not want the angle to kill that people (at that time).
Ridiculous claim, people of Salih AS refused to believe even after they saw the miracle(camel). They weren’t punished immediately. This guy is in his own reality.
Asthagfirullah. May the speaker not make jokes to make women laugh, and may the women not respond with voices and giggles to be heard by the speaker and non mahram men.
THERE is NO TRUTH in IT . THE MOON was NOT SPLIT into TWO. Pl Don't Make Us LAUGH !😂😂😂😂 GO OUT at NIGHT and LOOK at the MOON ! DO YOU SEE ONE MOON or TWO MOONS ? IF You SEE TWO MOONS , Please TAKE an APPOINTMENT with YOUR OPTHOLMOGIST ! 😂😂😂
Message to the whole world. STOP talking. It's enough. It's Time. Following pagan ahadith books claiming it's from Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all The Most Just The Most Loving The Most Merciful The Omnicient...is SHIRK SHIRK SHIRK. The Qoraan is The Perfect and fully detailed Word of Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all. Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all Will INTERVENE. This is a promise from Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty. Woe to the mouchrekeen. Don't believe me....just watch. It's enough
lol… seems u’re not following what was commanded by Allah… obey His rasul means u obey Allah.. when u salah.. do u just blindly follow someone..? or u learn frm someone who had proof what he taught came with a proof n not frm something he made up..?
NAK has made it clear that he does NOT believe in the miracle of the moon splitting at the time of the Prophet (SAW). He has also made it clear that he believes music is not haram. Stay away from this guy. He is not even a scholar but an orator living the land of the free and home of the brave! :)
Greetings. Please re watch the video if you can. The speaker has said several times that he believes in the miracles regardless of how unscientific they sound. Just like there are disagreements between many classical scholars of Islam on many issues, and all of them base it on Quran and Sunnah, likewise the speaker holds a particular view about this specific miracle. I think it is unfair to assume or say that he denies miracles in all of their totality.
@@saqibnawaz2624 don’t make excuses for him brother. He has denied the miracle of the splitting of the moon which 97% of scholars last 1300 years believe in. He has also said music is not haram. These are the facts
@Quantum-1157 he is using Quranic arguments. If he rejects the opinion of scholar, he is fine. But you reject the quranic argument, you are in trouble unless you provide different explanation. Dont just say someone is bad without bringing evidence from Quran and Sunnah. Music is fiqhi issue, dont make it aqeedah's issue.
You, with your audacity, dare to question the Quran and the Hadith, displaying a profound ignorance of Arabic and Islamic scripture. Your claim that 'inshaq' signifies a future event is a blatant misinterpretation, as the verb tense clearly indicates a past occurrence. Your distorted interpretation of the verse about the Hour, which identifies the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) as the first sign, is a blasphemous insult to our faith. You selectively quote isolated opinions while disregarding the consensus of Islamic scholars, denying the authenticity of the Hadith, and ultimately rejecting the Prophet himself. Your assertions are not merely heretical, but border on outright disbelief. Historical records from non-Islamic civilizations corroborate the miraculous event of the moon's splitting, further solidifying its authenticity. It's time to cease your baseless claims and acknowledge the truth as revealed in the Quran, the authentic Hadith, and the annals of history.
What do you say about other verses which use the past tense to refer to future eventsm? Many such verses can be quoted. How do you explain the past tense there?
Don't worship the consensus/ijmaa, worship your Lord and have Qur'an as the judge, a Book that is fully detailed. So when ijmaa contradicts the Qur'an, you don't continue blind following the ijmaa because it's the "vast majority opinion of scholars" no, you obey Allah (swt) and disregard the false interpretation. Humans can make mistakes.
You grow up and learn, this is my question for you, where do today's moral values come from? Before religion, murder and stealing were normal things. Think about it
In 2024 when you have more tears for tragic movie scenes but no emotions when you see real kids babies, women ,men, disgraced, brutally killed in designated shelter or school or hospital by bom or humiliated for food or raped even rejoiced over rape... People like you only progressed to celebrate 2000 onward. . .
Interestingly none of the classical tafaseer he quoted disbelieved in this Miracle mentioned in the Quran however nouman Ali khan doesn’t believe it happened. And he is making it public how many young people can he take with himself to disbelief in this miracle I wonder.
Cheraman Perumal, a king of the medieval Chera dynasty in Kerala, India, is said to have witnessed the splitting of the moon. Around 640 CE. Saying that there is no historical evidence of moon splitting is not absolute.
You have to provide evidence and sources brother
So one person in half the world being witness counts as historical proof? Crucifixion of Jesus was reported by much larger numbers, what about that?
How come he was the only sole witness? And he converted? So we have to dismiss him for biased reasons.
There were many pagan moon worshipers across Africa and Europe that would have noticed and no such records of them running berserk in panic.
All this trouble to split the moon did not change anything to the jahilya Arabs except for one King in India?
Think!
This is weak evidence. Unless you can corroborate this evidence.
Which cheraman perumal.Cheraman Perumal is a dynasty of many kings.
Alhamdulillah. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Reasonable explanation to believe that incident described(moon splitting) is not as past tens,but future tens as for Allah there no past ,He is always present,in our past ,present and future
Jes the moon was split they learn in India at school to childeren why a king became a muslim he saw the moon split in two.
Exactly
Sheikh Uthman has a very good answer for the Splitting of the Moon.
Nauman is not a Hadith expert he shouldn't dwell into something he doesn't know.
Sheikh Uthman is Masters in Hadith.
Yuppppp
Uthman doesn't understand the Qur'an to the depths Nouman does
The answer isn't very good at all... It's one example of an Indian king thinking he saw the moon split. And somehow that is conclusive evidence. Hadith generally are problematic imo
Both are great examples for us, may Allah keep us and them guided always, Aameen. No need arguing about them, their humbleness and sincerity In Shaa Allah will put us to shame if we argue wrongly about them, lets always be Brothers for Allah's sake, JazaakumuLLAHU Khayran
@@amirkhusroohamid9705 sheikh Uthman has a very bad answer actually. Information he relied on is irrelevant to his argument.
Danged magical thinking 🤔
You have a very strong argument here and that is difficult to refute. I enjoyed the reasoning from the beginning till the end. Thank you very much and may Allah bless you.
Opinions versus reality. I can’t find the clip I saw a few years back but I remember it distinctly. In a conference of some scientists/ physicists in the west talking about shape of the moon observed through observatories with marks and signs as if moon had split and then rejoined. What to believe ?!🤔
Yessss! I remember this too, but it’s wipe off the internet because it’s hella proof that the Quran is in fact THE book from God.. even ai is lying saying “there no scientific proof “... they would do everything not to have proof of Allah existence is insane and even more proof that it is real and the truth as this fact is mentioned in the Quran.. got to also remember... the internet is almost 99% control by zlo ni$t...
Google "rima ariadaeus" for more information regarding these lines found on the moon. This could be the sign of the splitting.
if Quran says moon splitted, it was splitted.
oh really that means the Quran is full of lies.
By read all the comment, somehow i feel that this is the same type of comment that people says when Rasulullah says that there is 2 water meet but not mix (gilbraltar sea). Later when technology become more advance, then they can see evidence of that.
Same as the moon split, later you guys will find the evidence when technology become advance... In Syaa Allah
Where is the Full video Link??
Remarkable last part of the logic of believrs
I see a half split moon every month twice! Its a mind-blowing miracle!
Mind your language , the person above is respectful so should you be, while talking about a miracle associated with the holy Prophet p.b.u.h we must be respectful and not say such things.Kindly repent and delete this now.
@@FatimaQureshi-f2r he is telling the truth...million of people are seeing the same thing including me.
This happened to Christians too, much earlier when science says no, Christians scholars had to change their opinions about miracles.
nice explain..
The moon is accepted as some 400km across (diameter), while on it is a feature, a chasm called "Rima Areadaeus", which is 300km long- a literal "split". The Quran is true on all levels, despite how we want to wrap our heads around it. And Allah knows best
Yes the "split" is caused by difference of temperature between the core and space be ause the moon has no atmosphere. The coran is wrong at so many levels it is a miracle people are still following it.
Nobody denies about the facts of the moon in its own form. What people find it hard believe is about a bullshit story of a fake prophet splitting the moon.
Pls make a video of the moon on which Muhammad (PBUH) name in Arabic clearly visible (look at it twice , thrice, observe)
In shaa ALlāhu, I will explain this topic in a more convincing way using Qur’an, Hadith and real life situation.
“The Hour (the Day of Resurrection) has drawn near, and the moon has been split. Yet if they see a sign, they turn away and say, ‘Passing magic.’” (Qur’an 54:1-2)
1. Understanding from the Qur’anic text
✓The Past Tense of “Inshaqqa”
• The verb “inshaqqa” (has been split) is in the past tense, indicating that the event had already occurred before these verses were revealed.
✓ Logical Incoherency of a Future Event
•If the splitting of the moon were to happen in the future, it would be incoherent to link it to the statement that the Hour of Resurrection has drawn near. How can an event yet to occur be presented as evidence that the Resurrection is near?
• So saying the moon will split in future would undermine the logical flow of the argument, as a future event cannot serve as a current sign or rational proof. In this case, ALlāhu is the best in speech and what He has revealed is the truth.
✓ The Context of the Following Verse
• Qur’an 54:2 explicitly states that the people of that time saw the sign but dismissed it as “passing magic.”
This indicates that they had already witnessed the splitting of the moon, which was a manifest sign of Allah’s power and a warning of the Resurrection, yet they rejected it and persisted in their disbelief.
2. The incident of the literal splitting of the moon is reported in hadith.
Narrated Ibn Masud:
During the lifetime of Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) the moon was split into two parts; one part remained over the mountain, and the other part went beyond the mountain. On that, Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “Witness this miracle.”
Sahih al-Bukhari 4864
3. Real-Life Scenario to understand what ALlāhu says in Qur’an 29:51:
In Qur’an 29:50-51, the disbelievers were asking for miracles and ALlāhu was saying: (Translation of the meaning) “.....is it not sufficient for them that We revealed to you the Book which is recited to them?. This doesn’t mean that the revelation of Qur’an is the only miracle. But it means that Qur’an is sufficient as a miracle. After all, they might’ve forgotten how other miracles took place, but Qur’an(the greatest miracle) is still being recited to them and they cannot match its eloquence.
✓ A Teacher and Students
Imagine a teacher in a classroom. The teacher is very skilled and, at the beginning of the semester, performs an extraordinary experiment that amazes the students. For instance, he demonstrate a complex scientific principle that no one had seen before, leaving the class in awe.
Some students(serious ones) were amazed and agreed that he is good teacher. Some (unserious students) didn’t agree but said the teacher used just a tricky way to perform the experiment. As times goes on, the teacher was developing a textbook for the students.
When the exam is approaching, the serious students was studying hard but the unserious students demanded more experiments. They said to the teacher....“Why don’t you perform another experiment to prove your point?”
The teacher responds:
“Isn’t the textbook enough for you?
In this case, the statement “Isn’t the textbook enough for you” doesn’t mean the teacher didn’t perform the experiment in the first place, it only mean that the information in his textbook is enough to convince them of whatever they think they needed to prepare for the exam.
ALlāhu is free from the above teacher-student scenario.
I do believe that seeing a miracle then rejecting it is not the sole trigger for a punishment to come. There should be many other factors that are intertwined, and Allah knows best.
Maybe they were not punished right away because God still had better plans that involved them, where they were needed for something else in the future. If those people were punished right away after seeing a miracle, then the prophet and his followers would have not been tested later. Maybe Allah kept those people alive to serve this purpose, to become the source of trials for the prophet and his followers, and from these trials we could finally learn so much more lessons.
Or maybe Allah just wanted to extend His mercy, to show that His mercy is so much more than His anger towards those people. That is why they were left alove, and who knows, maybe some of them would later become believers themselves in the future. A lot of the prophet’s companions actually came from these once disbelievers, even enemies, after all.
Or maybe even in the past events, the disbelievers were shown miracles or proofs multiple times before they got punished. We only got the impression that they were punished right away, because the Qur’an tends to oversimplify the details of the actual events, as long as the core messages of such story got delivered.
Allah knows best. But I do agree with Nouman Ali Khan that esentially, in the last miracle (which is the Qur’an), God wants us to believe by CHOICE, not FORCE.
Or, with the coming of the Qur'an, the "Moon" is rendered split.
Considering that the Qur'an words mystery are so deep, only ignorant people would only understand the simple meaning of moon splitting, rather than to Dig deeper to know its meaning.
Have we guys considered other possibilities of why the splitting of the moon was rarely found in the literatures of other nations? Maybe the geography skewed the perspectives of those nations, so they could not see the split clearly from their places. Idk.
How on earth a sane one even think that moon needed to be splitted
@ We are discussing this phenomenon in the realm of religious belief system. If you don’t adhere to such belief, then this place is not for you. I am actually wondering, why would any person who doesn’t have any businesses getting involved in such discussion would bother coming here in the first place. That would be… “insane”. So please, you could see your way out, if you don’t mind.
Because it's in the Koran@@lokeshranjanjha1796
Pharaoh did not believe even when he was shown other miracles, such as the stick turning into a snake and the light in Prophet Musa's (Moses', peace be upon him) hand, so that logic is valid. Similarly, Prophet Sulaiman (Solomon, peace be upon him) was also shown many miracles.so moon split I believe it literally
I heard that it is when a miracle of demand is given and people still refuses only then the decree comes. Otherwise God gives miracles to His prophets whatever He wants.
Ego is a big problem 👈 fact 🙏
Do They speak on flying horses?
We learnt The Qur'an is not a miracle for the eyes, but for the Reflexion. The Moon Splited ? The verse itself explains what is about : First noun "The Hour", it's about Time, next noun, the Moon, this is the tool to size the Time (surah 10.5). The full surah is about the Hour, and then, a description of the men before this Hour.
One of the sahih hadith in bukhari mentions mina in the month of dhul hajj at the time of moon split but during this month on 8th of dhul hajj we visit mina. But on that day moon itself will be half because full moon is on 14th day of the month so the moon was split in half or the half of moon was split in half and full moon was split in quarter?
Which moon are you referring to-Arab's or Earth's? It is important to note that Earth's moon did not split. When evidence regarding a matter becomes clear, ancient Semitic speakers would describe it with the phrase, "the hour drew near and the moon split." This expression signifies that there is no longer any mystery or doubt regarding the issue at hand. This is how the phrase is used in the Quran. So, could you clarify what you are talking about?
That is unbelievable actually. Miracles should not be supported as the core of faith.
The Qur'an is a living miracle. That's one component to the miraculous nature of the Qur'an. All other miracles are time bound and the preserve of a select few who happened to be present to witness said miracle. Whereas the Qur'an can be studied and appreciated by all of us in the present. It's an unfolding miracle.
under the guise of research,, these lectures are misleading n creating more rift...
Allah knows best and guide us on the right path...
Interestingly none of the classical tafaseer he quoted disbelieved in this Miracle mentioned in the Quran however nouman Ali khan doesn’t believe it happened. And he is making it public how many young people can he take with himself to disbelief in this miracle I wonder.
maybe the editor of this video only put the Quranic argument but i would be interested in Ustadh's response on Bukhari. We are talking about Sahih Bukhari here not some random book and Bukhari clearly says it got splited. Allah knows best. May Allah give us benefical knowledge.
I hope, Ustaz Nuaman could respond to Suratul Anfal Q 8:33 regarding the topic here. JazaakumuLLAHU Khayran
It’s still inconclusive. So what the verse in Quran and the related authentic Ahadith are referring to?
believe in Quran, Hadiths are what people say about prophet Muhmmad peace be upon him, and prophet bear no responsibility on it, a Hadith might be true or false, Imam who collected the Hadiths made their best sincere efforts but that doesn't mean they are prophets, only HUJJAH for Muslims should be Quran and Sunnah in the absence of Prophet.
@@BashirAhmad-h5b Hadith is Sunnah by extension.
@@focumQuarium Not exactly, we must need to understand, Hadiths are reported one year after the death of prophet, move over, some time only one, two or more than two people claimed they have heard prophet saying this, and even sometimes they didn't mention the situation in what context PROPHET said. SUNNAH is actually practical manifestation of IHKAMS of Quran and the actions of Prophets before Muhammad PBUH, remember Muhmmad PBUM didn't invent the religion, He just followed the Quran, also please note, every action of prophet is not SUNNAH (personal actions) but what God had asked them to do so (related to religion). Muhmmad PBUM didn't performed religion actions in front of one, two or three persons rather it was his obligation to show all religious actions to each and everyone to his capacity.
Pay attention when he's speaking. They can be a separate incident. A time bound miracle.
You wouldn't have seen the moon split here in the UK, it's always gloomy and cloudy 😂
The background music is tooo distracting
It wasn't a sign given for prophethood.
It was a sign that happened as the hour has come near
{ ٱقۡتَرَبَتِ ٱلسَّاعَةُ وَٱنشَقَّ ٱلۡقَمَرُ }
[Surah Al-Qamar: 1]
The Hour has drawn near and the moon was split
The Prophet was confirming , like what they were able to witness because of the hour coming closer, everyother prophecy will also come true.
The Quran basically destroys the splitting of the moon argument. Hard to deny those ayaat.
theb the quran must be full of bullshit
His reasoning is not sound about Kuffat asking for miracles and Allah not mentioning Moon Split.
Because Mushirkun said to prophet that you bewitched our eyes and did not belive the Miracle already
That response would be enaugh for any miracle Allah showed them. So theyre already doomed by their arrogance
The Moon is split electromagnetically
18:12 it wasnt a mirical at all..! Quran is mirical but moon split happened and SAW ASKED the companions be witness as in makki quran it seems end of time is near..! So if it can happen then all the rest can happen..!
Brother, but Allah showed many merciless to firawn and they were punished after the last one.
Good point, actually. I do believe that seeing a miracle then rejecting it is not the sole trigger for a punishment to come. There should be many other factors that are intertwined, and Allah knows best.
Maybe they were not punished right away because God still had better plans that involved them, where they were needed for something else in the future. If those people were punished right away after seeing a miracle, then the prophet and his followers would have not been tested later. Maybe Allah kept those people alive to serve this purpose, to become the source of trials for the prophet and his followers, and from these trials we could finally learn so much more lessons.
Or maybe Allah just wanted to extend His mercy, to show that His mercy is so much more than His anger towards those people. That is why they were left alove, and who knows, maybe some of them would later become believers themselves in the future. A lot of the prophet’s companions actually came from these once disbelievers, even enemies, after all.
Or maybe even in the past events, the disbelievers were shown miracles or proofs multiple times before they got punished. We only got the impression that they were punished right away, because the Qur’an tends to oversimplify the details of the actual events, as long as the core messages of such story got delivered.
Allah knows best. But I do agree with Nouman Ali Khan that esentially, in the last miracle (which is the Qur’an), God wants us to believe by CHOICE, not FORCE.
so the moon is split or not, because when they see the miracle with eyes and after reject they get punished. let me conclude on this please
allah says moon is splitted like what they want other miracles
From my comprehension, they are still asking for another miracle. This isn't something new, look at Musa AS, he has shown more than one miracle but Firaun still doesn't believe.
But then again we can't take the jewish and christian texts to be reliable sources like that as they were edited and changed over time, so something not being mentioned in their texts doesn't really mean anything.
People are just making simple verses of Quran hard to understand 😢
Nouman, you have built the whole case on the assumption that it was a miracle demanded by the Makkans, but that is a wrong assumption. According to many scholars, it was just a natural event that occurred and Allaah swt presented it as a sign for people, just as many other natural phenomena are presented to people as signs throughout the Qur'aan. This sign was presented to the skepctics who did not want to believe in the possibility of their destruction through a natural disaster or end of the world. So your whole case about miracles is irrelevant. You have not addressed the real key question: If it was something to happen in future, why does the Qur'aan presents it as a sign, saying, "if they see a sign, they turn away and say it is the same old magic". And then, the whole surah warns people with the examples of the previously destroyed nations. A future event cannot be presented as a sign, nor as a valid evidence of the possibility of the destruction of the kuffar.
❤❤❤❤
So he is picking and choosing what to believe and what not to believe like the ashab ul okhdood and so. What’s wrong with these people
Its half the message, where's Full video?
This is another perspective on the moon splitting based onbthe Holy Quran
th-cam.com/video/rJmtvvhPeOk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=CST4ekxZgE7OQ14i
Why Allah did mention all the prophets with their tangible miracles in the Quran except our prophet Mohammed? The answer is very simple. Because since he is the seal of the prophet, Allah honoured him with one eternal miracle ( Quran). Period!
Tamil king cheraman saw this incident and accepted islam
The actual problem here is we are not getting the correct meaning of the terms in quran , Quranic Arabic is not the current Arabic, it's abrahamic location... So in short Kamar - Moon in abrahamic location means prophethoood ( meaning the messengers sent by Allah to explain Torah to Bani Israel ) and when quran came the moon or Kamar was no longer applicable ...as our Muhammed (PBUH) was Rasool to us meaning just recite quran and direct guidance will come from Allah and for bani Israel he was Nabih....and Musa spliiting the same was metaphorical meaning he separated believers from non believers..Sea in Abraham location means a state of confusion and something which is not steady..and quran downt need tasfeers to explain it..u need to explain quran from itself..hope Nouman u get some senses in u and stop translating the Qur'an using tasfeers:-)
[54:1] The Hour has come closer, and the moon has split.* *54:1 This important sign of the approaching end of the world came to pass in 1969 when humans landed on the moon and brought pieces of the moon to earth. At the same time, God's mathematical Miracle of the Quran was being gradually unveiled. Traditional Muslims opposed it, since it exposed the fallacy of their practices (Appendix 25).
Incomplete insufficient answers. You set a question and then ask audience to think. Unnecessary details, explaining grammar.
You lack fahm. The grammatical explanation gives certainty about it being a sign of the Hour.
Sir please stop misguiding people, by what you are saying that All the Sahaba who witnessed innumerous Miracles, so you mean to say that didn't happen? Also did other Prophets of Allah showed only one miracle and when their people rejected Allah sent His wrath on them? Don't use just mind to understand. Even without one Miracle we believe in Rasool Allah alaihis salam because of Him, His existence itself is the biggest One. Lazim Hai Dil ke Saath ho pazbane aqal Kabhi Kabhi ise tanha bhi chod Diya kar
So is the moon split now some one help me
At the time of Muhammad (pbuh)
The moon will be split during the time of the apocalypse brother not now, not in the past but it is a future event.
th-cam.com/video/rJmtvvhPeOk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4DB8My6rJSoqNKnw THIS IS TRUE MOON SPLIT explained…
@@rijviabir5172 thats yours and NAK's view! the vast majority believe that the moon splitting miracle did take place at the time of the Prophet (SAW). And NAK is not a scholar - he has admitted that dozens of times but fanatical fans of his just accept whatever he says without doing any research.
Yes of course. Dont listen to everyone on TH-cam. Learn from real scholars.
Yet, whenever they see a sign, they turn away,[[ A miracle (usually referred to as a ‘sign’ in the Quran) can be defined as an extraordinary event manifesting divine intervention in human affairs. Every prophet was given miracles to prove he was commissioned by Allah. Moses (ﷺ) was given the miracle of the staff and many others. Jesus (ﷺ) gave life to the dead and healed the blind and the leper. And Muḥammad (ﷺ) received the Quran, a literary miracle, to challenge the masters of Arabic eloquence. The Prophet (ﷺ) performed some other miracles such as splitting the moon, multiplying food and water, and healing some of his companions.]] saying, “Same old magic!”
On judgement day people will be so desperate that they will utter the words of repentance.They will never say, “(This is) a transient magic.”on that day.
Quran does not refer to the physical splitting of the moon, it's just poor poor Tafaseers and unauthentic Ahadees. No miracles mentioned in Quran.
Plz give Allah his true reverence.
Shams implies The scripture
Qamar implies the Rasool and Nabi
Most of these miracles where figurative speach
Mr Noman Ali Khan, for your information no one asking for your opinion.
Keep your opinion to yourself.
A question I would like to ask you based on your intelligence what miracle people of Prophet NUH was given before they were destroyed by the flood?
This is not very nice thing to say, people can have multiple interpretation on vague subjects. It doesn't effect their Iman.
Even myself may not agree with him. But this is a thought process. May be we can come with something which can disprove him. Just like your question.
Sharing opinions is everyone’s right. Verifying information that other people shared, NOW THAT is an obligation for all listeners.
I have an opinion to share with you, that’s my right. Then, you as the listener has the obligation to process and verifiy the credibility of what I just said, before completely accepting it or completely rejecting it.
We call this “thinking process”. If your thinking process is already right, you wouldn’t be bothered by anything, and at the same time still able to respect other people’s opinions without being RUDE.
I thought the prophet was just an ordinary man without any miracles to demonstrate... only his quran..
miracle is allah doing, prophet are only human.
prophet asked allah, to make their stick to a snake, split ocean or cooling the fire.
its all allah doing not the prophet.
He had many miracles in hadith. Even conquering Makkah was a miracle. Also had many prophecies.
@@yemi3266 hadith is not a quran....
th-cam.com/video/bJEaAinrccg/w-d-xo.htmlsi=h_E0IH_kXQZ8nwv2
🤦🏼♂️
nouman ali sahan you are denying sahi bukhari hadeeth HADEESE MUNKAR if science doesnt proof that doest means hadeeth is wrong common this is too much ruju karo bhai sahab according to you music is also halal
So what i get from this lecture is this, that even the most authentic books of Hadiths have fabricated Ahadiths. I would never reject the hadith about splitting of the moon despite the last point Nouman Ali khan made that once a people see a miracle and reject it, Allah destroy that people. Isn't the prophet Rahmatul Lil Alamin? And because he is Rahmatul Lil Alamin Allah would not destroy his people despite rejecting the splitting of the moon.
that why scholar had different opinion, and we need to interpret it ourself.
for me, allah give the non believer multiple miracle before the punishment come. (not once)
because at the core, muhammad SAW wanted everyone to be a muslim.
that why he did not want the angle to kill that people (at that time).
there is so much words in you.. take a break
Ridiculous claim, people of Salih AS refused to believe even after they saw the miracle(camel). They weren’t punished immediately.
This guy is in his own reality.
???????????? What???? They were punished a few days later. What are you on about?
don't know what your definition of " immediate " is 😂.
But to the rest of us that was immediate enough.
Educate yourself please. Do not say things about islam if you haven't researched the subject at hand in detail.
Asthagfirullah. May the speaker not make jokes to make women laugh, and may the women not respond with voices and giggles to be heard by the speaker and non mahram men.
THERE is NO TRUTH in IT .
THE MOON was NOT SPLIT into TWO.
Pl Don't Make Us LAUGH !😂😂😂😂
GO OUT at NIGHT and LOOK at the MOON !
DO YOU SEE
ONE MOON
or
TWO MOONS ?
IF You SEE
TWO MOONS ,
Please TAKE an APPOINTMENT with YOUR OPTHOLMOGIST !
😂😂😂
Elephant head?
This too further adds up to the fact that Quran and Islam are all man made.
😂 keep studying buddy
Sorry, but you're wrong in so many ways
So do you mean there was zero miracle for the prophet ?😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅..
You don't know what you are talking about..😮😮😮😮
The splitting of the moon is the Myth.
Message to the whole world.
STOP talking. It's enough. It's Time.
Following pagan ahadith books claiming it's from
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all The Most Just The Most Loving The Most Merciful The Omnicient...is SHIRK SHIRK SHIRK.
The Qoraan is The Perfect and fully detailed Word of
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all.
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all Will INTERVENE.
This is a promise from
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty.
Woe to the mouchrekeen.
Don't believe me....just watch.
It's enough
lol… seems u’re not following what was commanded by Allah… obey His rasul means u obey Allah.. when u salah.. do u just blindly follow someone..? or u learn frm someone who had proof what he taught came with a proof n not frm something he made up..?
@@eerievon2208
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty The Creator of all The Most Just The Most Loving The Most Merciful The Omnicient is my Teacher.
@@eerievon2208
The messanger is dead. To obey a person they MUST be alive. We only have for know The Qoraan The Word of Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty
@ lol… so u follow ur whims n desires then…. may Allah guides u…
@@eerievon2208
Read what a wrote. Don't be blind for The Truth.
It's enough. It's Time
Allaah ❤❤❤The Almighty Will INTERVENE.
Don't be a mouchrik
But isn’t he rejecting the miracle at the end?
th-cam.com/video/rJmtvvhPeOk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=4DB8My6rJSoqNKnw
YOU NEED MIRACLES; every AYYAT IS MIRACLE
NAK has made it clear that he does NOT believe in the miracle of the moon splitting at the time of the Prophet (SAW). He has also made it clear that he believes music is not haram. Stay away from this guy. He is not even a scholar but an orator living the land of the free and home of the brave! :)
Greetings. Please re watch the video if you can. The speaker has said several times that he believes in the miracles regardless of how unscientific they sound.
Just like there are disagreements between many classical scholars of Islam on many issues, and all of them base it on Quran and Sunnah, likewise the speaker holds a particular view about this specific miracle. I think it is unfair to assume or say that he denies miracles in all of their totality.
@@saqibnawaz2624 don’t make excuses for him brother. He has denied the miracle of the splitting of the moon which 97% of scholars last 1300 years believe in. He has also said music is not haram. These are the facts
@Quantum-1157 he is using Quranic arguments. If he rejects the opinion of scholar, he is fine. But you reject the quranic argument, you are in trouble unless you provide different explanation. Dont just say someone is bad without bringing evidence from Quran and Sunnah. Music is fiqhi issue, dont make it aqeedah's issue.
You, with your audacity, dare to question the Quran and the Hadith, displaying a profound ignorance of Arabic and Islamic scripture. Your claim that 'inshaq' signifies a future event is a blatant misinterpretation, as the verb tense clearly indicates a past occurrence. Your distorted interpretation of the verse about the Hour, which identifies the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) as the first sign, is a blasphemous insult to our faith. You selectively quote isolated opinions while disregarding the consensus of Islamic scholars, denying the authenticity of the Hadith, and ultimately rejecting the Prophet himself. Your assertions are not merely heretical, but border on outright disbelief. Historical records from non-Islamic civilizations corroborate the miraculous event of the moon's splitting, further solidifying its authenticity. It's time to cease your baseless claims and acknowledge the truth as revealed in the Quran, the authentic Hadith, and the annals of history.
What do you say about other verses which use the past tense to refer to future eventsm? Many such verses can be quoted. How do you explain the past tense there?
Don't worship the consensus/ijmaa, worship your Lord and have Qur'an as the judge, a Book that is fully detailed.
So when ijmaa contradicts the Qur'an, you don't continue blind following the ijmaa because it's the "vast majority opinion of scholars" no, you obey Allah (swt) and disregard the false interpretation. Humans can make mistakes.
It's 2024 and some still believe in things like god and religion. Grow up people
You grow up and learn, this is my question for you, where do today's moral values come from? Before religion, murder and stealing were normal things. Think about it
It's 2024, and some people still think that the universe created itself and that we came out of fish.
In 2024 when you have more tears for tragic movie scenes but no emotions when you see real kids babies, women ,men, disgraced, brutally killed in designated shelter or school or hospital by bom or humiliated for food or raped even rejoiced over rape...
People like you only progressed to celebrate 2000 onward. . .
Interestingly none of the classical tafaseer he quoted disbelieved in this Miracle mentioned in the Quran however nouman Ali khan doesn’t believe it happened. And he is making it public how many young people can he take with himself to disbelief in this miracle I wonder.