ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- 🙏🏿
original video
• Jethro Tull - A Passio...
donations to support the channel 🤞🏿
www.paypal.me/...
#Jethrotull #apassionplay #popenyco #jethrotullreaction #iananderson #progressiverock #jethrotullapassionplay #jethrotullreactionvideos
Im glad you dug this complex work up . TULL was a major force in the 1970's . Ferociously creative . Slyly satirical . Deep and thought provoking for those listening with close attention .
Along with Anderson's brilliance, you sometimes forget what a superb group of musicians they all are. John Evan's performance on this is sublime.
Makes the debacle of 'A', all the more incomprehensible (although Ian does present a personality that is ruthless and spikey. Barlow revealed that Ian's dog (around the time of Heavy Horses) defecated on his lap, and Ian's response was simply to laugh). However, it was the worst mis-step Anderson ever made. Barlow, Evans, Barre and Hammond, and latterly Glascock, and Palmer, were the finest musicians Anderson assembled, or could be surrounded by - on a par - as far as competency and virtuosity - with any of their peers of the golden period of rock.
Pope, you`re approaching "prog god" status of all youtube reactors.
A complete example of musical excellence
I wrote my comment before you started the play ! Sorry i thouth it was a live on stage ! well with the heart beat ! on the round screen there s that ballerina lifting herself up ! then i don t remember much ! we re talking 50 years ago ! LoL ! hope you like it !
I love PP -- A young man is born and skips merrily and foolishly though his experiences and then BAM he is no longer living -- and so his journey to afterlife begins -- Please include The Hare Who Lost His Spectacles -- I love that little fable -- I knew you would feel the beat of the progressive vibe and sway though the labyrinth of sounds --- all swirling about but still leading the listener onward
speaks to the time. talk about being experimental. I love watching them live. adds a bit. ❤️✌️😊
I like the video for that part, it's funny and also very cool at the same time.
A reaction to this wonderful album would be totally incomplete without ''The Hare Who Lost His Spectacles" and perhaps at least lip-service to the clever parody. Pope - take note !
is that a song that is left off the album or a video?
@@POPE. It's a Filler track which separates APP Parts 1 and 2 - Should be on the album you are playing right after the place where you left off ( on vinyl it is the end of side 1 and the beginning of side 2) - Hope that helps.
My favorite Tull album! As soon as your mind is blown in one moment of musical ecstasy, another moment crashes down and takes you aboard. Then another, and another. Until you can't tell if you're up or down, or around and around.
Overrated, aimless, meandering Tull album. Check out what the band felt about it to a man!
My favorite too. 😉
@@Katehowe3010 What is meandering to one person can be bliss to another. And what is ecstatic to one can be aimless to another.
@@kentclark6420 It's only an opinion. Just like your own!
@@Katehowe3010 That's what I mean.
Yes the best of Tull
Musical genious. Each musician is a mater in their own right
Definition of "Gold".
Been playing drums almost all my life. Tried this album out and put my sticks down after 2 minutes.
Haven't heard in a long while. Brilliant album
Almost 50 years later and it's still the craziest thing I've ever heard.
I don't know if your aware of this but this was the second straight Tull album to go number one with only one song on it stretched out to both sides of the album. No other band or artist in history did that having two number one albums back to back with one song on each album. This is why I say Ian Anderson is a genius. You should listen to baker street muse from minstrel in the gallery. 16 minutes of musical genius
Hardly one song: more a series of linked songs (like Brick). Great album, though.
I love how you said, Jethro Tull Project. very true. ❤️✌️
I love watching your body move to the music cuz it shows how appreciate what you are hearing and Tull has that effect on those who truly listen
I think all the music you have been reacting to over the past year(s) has lead to your ability to not only listen to a full album side but actually LISTEN to it. A lot of us old warhorses had classical music in our education which, slightly, prepared us to let this complex, beautiful thing into our lives. I am wonderfully surprised and marginally more optimistic about the future of human kind knowing that some young people can cope with something that is more than a drum machine, bad poetry and misogynistic videos.
Enjoy the rest of the play... after the intermission....
When my niece was a toddler, I'd tell her the story of The Hare Who Lost His Spectacles.
It's amazing that after 50 years since i first listened to this, I appreciate it even more, probably due to listening to it on the best equipment available and all the remastering, it really shines as one of the most important works of the art-prog genre.
First concert of my life!! In 74 I think it was…. Tull with Livingston Taylor at Civic Arena in Pittsburgh
You should have seen the stage show that went along with this and every other Tull concert. Ian Anderson challenges you musically, lyriclly & visually. Superior muscians Martin Barre, John Evan, Jeffrey Hamond and Barry Barlow was the most insanely creative drummer ever. Saw Tull 20x in their heyday. Dig deep there is so much exploring to do
Their best lineup. Although the early lineups with Clive Bunker and Glenn Cornick were fun, too. Glenn is thought to be the best bass player that Tull had. But the bass is so subtle, it's hard to tell.
Big Thumbs Up for the Passion Play!
Epic Tull!!
Tull is incredible, saw them probably 20 times starting in 77. Try Thick as a Brick, Live at Madison Square Garden, 12th row right in front of Martin .
Wow 20 times that’s great, i’ve only seen them 10 times, starting in 1971 the aqualung tour I was 13 my first rock concert.
Seconded. I’ve seen that as well. Some more Gentle Giant reactions would be pretty cool too 😄
This is the best reaction channel out there. You know good music. You can feel it. I believe this.
One of my Fave's growing up! Had all their albums
☘good morning Pope, well done my friend , you held your reaction till the end ,i believe this helps to appreciate the flow of Tulls work
especially" passion play" and" thick as a brick".
hi pope ,you have excellent taste in music,good war!!!!!! good to see young people listen to the classic psych,hard rock,progressive bands out there,emerson,lake & paler tarkus lp,kaleidoscope tangerine dream,keep it up as you are expanding your mind and heart!!!
My brother and I went to see that concert in 1973 in Louisville Gardens. I was 13, he was 11.
Brilliant album ! You should watch the 7mn clip made for "Forest Dance" (which is the instrumental that closes your part I) followed by "The Story of the Hare Who Lost His Spectacles" which will start your second part (but which in fact closed the first side of the album originally). The band members appearing either in costume or in cameo as in the case of Ian Anderson, as well as bassist Jeffrey Hammond who is the storyteller of "The Story of the Hare Who Lost His Spectacles" (The ballerina from the record cover is also present).
Hi ! happy you play that song ! it s been a long long time ! I still remember the show ! I saw that at the Forum of Montreal ! back in the 70s ! it started with a heart beat on the round screen ! awesome show that was !
You won’t believe what comes next
Next album...Stand Up!!
Thanks Pope, I love JT. 👍❤🤙
☮️💙💙💙so happy to hear this again!
Five members in JT for this album, most of them playing multiple instruments. All of the 70’s JT albums come highly recommended!
Maybe so, but none of them were too fond of the outcome!
@@Katehowe3010 Too true. Martin has it in his bottom third of albums.
@@martinhayward4466 What do you think of it?
@@Katehowe3010 Would have liked to see the Chateau sessions developed into this album. They are so raw and earthy. This quick re work seems a little overproduced to me which kills a lot of the natural sound. Think Martin's guitar in particular is reduced to almost a backing instrument for most of the album. Live however ( saw them in July '74 ) unbelievable.Love the concept, but mid range for me. Stand Up, MITG, TAAB, Benefit & Stormwatch my favourites.
@@martinhayward4466 My view on 'A Passion Play' is that it lacks form and tends to meander into too many blind alleys. I basically find it all a bit erratic and annoying. As for my top 5 in no particular order, they are 'Stand Up', 'Benefit', Minstrel In The Gallery', 'Heavy Horses', and being a 'mere' 55 years old, 'Broadsword And The Beast' because it was the first Tull album i purchased upon release!
I remember Jethro Tull from way back when it the big hit was 'Locomotive Breath'. That was fine, but the progressive albums, 'Thick as a Brick' and this one, 'A Passion Play' were so much more interesting to me musically. And much more complex! Everyone in the band. I miss albums like this.
Velvet Green
Critique Oblique is Tull at its best. +rep
There are two Tull songs that were previously unreleased until the 40th Anniversary Steven Wilson remix of Songs From the Wood. They are 'Old Aces Die Hard' and 'Working John Working Joe'.
These are both wonderful examples of Tull magic.
Working John is on the album A came out in 1980.
@biserkasertic1208 That was the second iteration of Working John Working Joe.
The one I referred to was previously unreleased on Songs From the Wood. Was only on the Steven Wilson 40th Anniversary remix.😊
Great stuff, Thank you! Waiting for part two, a bit crazier, if I remenber.
How is Jethro Tull not in the RRHOF?? What a joke!!
Always look for first time liteners to this record to listen also. Do it again and then some if you get it let me know. Been listening sice it came out and i dont get it but i really like it
one of my top 10 favorite albums! Can't wait for Part II
I love your reactions to great music artists 👍 I would love to see your reactions to tears for fears/ and Kate bush, much love 🤗💛
Mr. Popenyco. You're doing a reaction to this track. I'm about to watch it now but I know it's going to be a very special video. In a good way. (Don't forget to check out some Grateful Dead (Live Dead and Studio Dead). There is alot there so you might as well jump in. The water is perfect). or is it perfect.)
I can recommend you Gentle Giant. A great progressive rock band from the same era as Jethro Tull, Genesis, Yes etc.
Three friends, my favorite album, is a good one to start with.
The stupid critics destroyed this album when it came out. They don't have music in their hearts like you do! ❤
Jethro tull has IT. I dont know what ''IT'' is, but they have ''IT''.
You gotta come to a Phish show, man. 😉
Flip the album cover upside down for a slightly new perspective
You should check out Tulls Thick as a Brick after you listen to side 2 of this album .
th-cam.com/video/ymgWlrMlHFo/w-d-xo.html
Ok lol
Progressive rock, Tull, YES, Floyd, Genesis, Rush nothing better. YES being on top. Ian Anderson, genius in all categories. Top 5 talent in RR history. He wrote everything they played. The other bands had multiple writers.
No he did not, over the years a lot of contributions musically were made by Barre, Evan & Palmer in particular. Minstrel in the Gallery is credited an Anderson/Barre composition.