지금 와서야 곡 해석이 잘못됐다 어쨌다 말하는 거지 저 당시엔 그런 반응 1도 없었는데 약간 물타기 같음 투바투랑 비교하는 댓글도 보이는데 걔네는 이미 데뷔한 그룹이고 이건 경연인데 충분히 이해할 만함 저기서 끼안부리면 원샷도 못받을 듯 물론 저스틴은 너무 과하고 최민기 이건희처럼 한두번 하트 정도는 봐줄만해
tbh the difference between a debuted idol and trainee was clear here. He didnt go over the top with his facial expressions and really matched the vibe of replay. SHINee never did replay as an aegyo song. Its a chill song in terms of how its sung and also how its danced. In this group it felt like he was the only one who picked up on that and it really made him standout
Okey. All these guys has been center.♡ Jungjung: Pop center. Hwangwoong: Right Round center. Gunhee: Amazing kiss center. Justin: Replay Center. Minki: Oh Little Girl center. Kwanghyun: Rhythm Ta center.
I don't know that Justin minghao participate in Korea on this show I thought he participate only in the produce idol it's a pity that he did not made debut in Korea but still he achieved as an idol in China and now look at him he is a star now and even being popular in China ❤❤ my baby I love you forever☺
say the name #20SEVENTEEN well it wasn't really a mistake but the "avengers" couldn't really hit the high notes... not hating, just pointing it out lol
Nancy there's always fan-sites that take pictures of the boys, and the pictures of him blonde is spread on Twitter. Based on the pictures it's more of a strawberry blonde(??), not sure but it's definitely not as blonde as before which is a nice change (at least 7 produce 101 boys have dyed their hair fyi). If you need any links to the pictures I'll try to get them for you
IKR MANNN! IT WAS SOO BADDDDD! TWO YEARS AGO, BACK WHEN IDOL PRODUCER AIRED, ME AND MY FRIEND COULDNT STOP FANGIRLING OVER HIM. THEN WE FOUND OUT THAT HE WAS ONLY ONE TO TWO YEARS OLDER THAN US AND WE WERE SCREAMING 😂😂😂😂😂
honestly justice for gwanghyun!! he's shown us he's skilled in rapping and dancing, and now his stable vocals. WHY ARE KOREANS SLEEPING ON THIS MULTITALENTED CUTIE
와 이광현 목소리 너무 좋아서 자꾸듣고싶노.. 이건희 노래잘하는건 당연히 알테고 저스틴은 진짜 눈이 자꾸감 너무귀여워ㅜㅠ 최민기는 진짜 핑크가 저리 잘어울리냐구ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 여환웅도 자기 몫 너무잘했고 정정도 너무 이쁘게 잘하고ㅜㅜㅜㅡ근데 1조도 2조도 난너무좋앗는데ㅡㅜㅜㅠ프
얘네 진짜 팀 잘뽑았는데... 메보 서호가 했어도 좋았겠지만 건희가 하면서 건희의 보컬가능성을 많이 보여줬던 기억도 있고... 환웅이도 초반에 춤 너무 깔끔하게 춰서 좋았고 저스틴 정정은 말해 뭐해 누너예를 위해 태어났고 민기는 전설의 난 너무 예뻐를 남기고 갔고... 그래도 다섯은 나름 활동하는데 서브보컬로 중심 잘 잡아준 광현이는 영동포팡하고 요즘 뭐하니..... ㅠㅠ
They all did great, but Lee Gwanghyun from Starship really stood out to me. He is cute and had stable vocals throughout the whole performance. His voice was the voice I remember most tbh
Everytime i see Gwanghyun and hear his voice i really think that he's a long lost twin brother of Inseong SF9.. They're really really similar each other..
CHANYEOL'S BACON I just checked naver. He got 252,000 views when the rest of the views are around like average 30,000. :) Park jihoon's fancam is the highest at 900,000+ doe 😱
00:44 please don't sleep on Gwanghuyn. He has such a stable voice and kind vibe. He and Sewoon are from Starship and they are the kindest looking contestants in the show.
*I WATCHED THIS VID 92837 TIMES AND I STILL CAN'T UNDERSTAND WHY JUSTIN CAN'T BE IN THE TOP11?!?!??!* *HE IS SO ADORABLE AND TALENTED!* *OPEN YOUR EYES ALREADY AND VOTE FOR HIM* 😠
THIS!! SAY IT LOUDER!! Justin has that criteria to be an idol and he always slay in every performance like why can't he be in the top 11???? and Jungjung as well!!! (yes Im Jaebart is life)
I'm so happy that the boys they're so supportive of each other. Look at how they're so relieved he hit the high note very well. These boys each and every one of them are so precious, I really hope mnet won't do them dirty with their amazing evil editing and made them fight each other. 😭😭😭
cupidjaemin Jungjung and Justin are now part of the CPOP Boy Group 9 Percent, also from a survival show called IDOL PRODUCER and they went from cute to sexy. These two keeps on grinding on the floor. Also part of the CPOP GROUP called NEX7 and its a group of their company.
In my opinion, None of them really need to follow the original concept or whatever, because we all know no one can ever beat the original (SHINee), so they used their owns charms. Isn't SHINee's Replay about a younger boy liking an older woman? To catch the noona's attention, Team 1 used their cuteness while Team 2 used their manliness. If you prefer cuteness over manliness, that's fine. If you prefer manliness over cuteness, that's fine too, but don't bring anyone down. You can bring your favorite team up without bringing the other team down.
Zhaomei Yulhui but actually team 2 is cute too, my sister's bias changed from woojin to sanggyun because of how cute he is(I bet no one wants to know about my sis😂)
Update to all us Ren, NUEST-lovers and supporters!! • Their group won the battle 467-391!! 3000 points will be added to their scores. • Ren's individual score was the highest out of the entire group, 157!! • After all group performances, Ren is ranked 4th out of all trainees with a score of 157 (this is excluding fan votes that took place outside of the battles and excludes the 3000 points) AMAZING JOB MINKI!! 💕 Side note: All NUEST members won their battles except Baekho. 3000 points will be added to their total. As of now individual scores. Ren - 4th (157) Minhyun - 13th (108) JR - 39th (67) Baekho - 22-33 (86) LETS GO BOYS!!! 💕💕
Ren is just naturally pretty, he didn't even need to act all cute to melt viewers' heart. He was born to be on stage! btw, i love everyone in this team especially my starship baby LEE GWANGHYUN! Please support him ❤
곡 이해하는 거 중요하죠 너무 중요한데 저 당시엔 이런 의견도 별로 없었고 끼 한 번 더 부려서 눈도장 찍히려는 것 도 난 이해간다.. 과한분들도 계셨지만 손하트.. ? 한 번 정돈 봐줄 수 있다고 생각함 만약 저분들 그대로 현역인 상태로 했으면 훨씬 잘했을듯 쩝... 모 그렇다구요....아가들아 좀만 더 끼ㅏ참지...
Minki really deserved the 4th place on vote! he just need to gain more weight and that will definitely makes him to be one of the best visual.. anyway, i'm happy to see he's finally having fun with his team, i don't want to see him crying and gloomy anymore..
JUSTIN WAS A REAL KID😂😂😂When I saw him in idol producer I thought he's already in his 20's then I discovered that he is younger than me when I am 17 years😂😂 he's just a baby for me😂😂😂 I am his NOONA NO ONE DISAGREE THAT!😂😂❤
![PRODUCE 101 season2 [4회] '누나 마음에 그린라이트' 누나 일루왕ㅣ샤이니 ♬누난 너무 예뻐_2조 @그룹배틀 170428 EP.4](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CDeUbNMoNbg/mqdefault.jpg)
![PRODUCE 101 season2 [4회] '누나 마음에 그린라이트' 누나 일루왕ㅣ샤이니 ♬누난 너무 예뻐_2조 @그룹배틀 170428 EP.4](/img/tr.png)
![PRODUCE 101 season2 [단독/4회] ′속이 뻥뚫리는 무대′ 프로틴♡ ㅣ세븐틴 ♬만세_1조 @그룹배틀 170428 EP.4](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/c5iEG4hCxz0/mqdefault.jpg)
![My Favoitre Produce 101 Season 2 moments [ep 0-11]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-NdZxeUEDiw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 90 | คู่เอก "ก้องไกล vs แอนตาร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VugIvOstzRI/mqdefault.jpg)
![투모로우바이투게더 - Intro + 누난 너무 예뻐(Intro + Replay - TOMORROW X TOGETHER) [2019 KBS 가요대축제] 20191227](/img/n.gif)
이거 경연 당시에는 그냥 사람들 좋다고 난리났었음ㅋㅋㅋ 곡이해도 얘기하면서 과하다는 사람들 다 몇 개월 전이고ㅋㅋㅋ 결국 얘네가 현명했던 거지ㅋㅋㅋ... 자기 귀여운 이미지 잘 이용하고 눈도장 한 번이라도 더 찍어서 잫 살아남았음
건희 연습 때 내내 고음 실수하다가 본공연 때 완벽하게 해낸거 진짜 볼때마다 드라마틱함 ㄷㄷㄷㄷ
그러게요 그런경우는 진짜 드문경우니히히
샤이니 노래 진짜 개띵곡이다 2008년 11년전 노래인데 하나도 안촌스러울수가...ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지금 저노래로 데뷔해도 하나도 안이상할듯
이광현 음색이 진짜 이노래 찰떡이고 이노래 살리는 느낌임
이광현 음색 진짜 개오짐
백현임 걍
@@password246 ???
@@user-uj1up1uy9s 당신뭐야
@@password246 백현이랑 키범이 섞은 늒임
@@password246 나랑 같은 생각을 하는 사람이 있었다니 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅜㅜㅠ 광현 목소리 ㄹㅇ 백현 같아요 ㅠㅠ 백현 음색 짱 좋아하는 사람으로써 광현 목소리도 짱 좋아했던 사람 나여 나...,
와 이때 이광현 음색때문에 다시 찾아보고 직캠까지 찾아봤는데 나만 그렇게 생각하는게 아니였구나,,, 다시들어도 진짜 이광현음색 미쳤따
프듀 2 보던게 엊그제 같은뎅 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ,,
왤케 추억이지
또 1년이지났군..
저게 벌써 3년전....시간 왜이렇게 빨라
프듀를 그리워하는 댓글이 2년전 댓글이란점이....
저거 막 나왔을때는 아무말도 안하다가 계속 컨셉이랑 안맞는다고 하는거 개웃김 진짜 데뷔해보겠다고 이악물고 연습하고 본 무대때 카메라 한번 더 잡히겠다고 웃는 애들을
ㅇㅈ ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 당시에 이 영상 보고 그 이후로 안 보다가 와서 댓글 보는데 곡 해석력 이러고 있는 게 참... 물타기 너무 심한 듯 프듀가 어떤 판인지 잘 알면서 ㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ 데뷔 후면 몰라 데뷔 전에 저기서 쌉아련 컨셉 잡으면 카메라 하나도 안 들어온다.. 경연이라는 걸 알까 까는 애들은?;
@@지은-k1s2oo
ㅇㅈ
@임김김 연습생한테ㅋㅋㅋㄱㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱ
지금 와서야 곡 해석이 잘못됐다 어쨌다 말하는 거지 저 당시엔 그런 반응 1도 없었는데 약간 물타기 같음 투바투랑 비교하는 댓글도 보이는데 걔네는 이미 데뷔한 그룹이고 이건 경연인데 충분히 이해할 만함 저기서 끼안부리면 원샷도 못받을 듯 물론 저스틴은 너무 과하고 최민기 이건희처럼 한두번 하트 정도는 봐줄만해
한국이 원래 물타기 오지잖아..
저스틴님도 최민기님도 이건희님 전부 데뷔했죠
그니깐 샤월인데 딱히 생각없었는데 굳이 여기 다시와서 트집잡는거 이해 안됨
이제와서 샤이니팬으로서 기분나빴다 ㅇㅈㄹ하는것도 이해 안됨
저스틴 과해도 젤 눈에 띄고 잘한 건 사실이잖아 ㅋㅋ
광현님... 아직까지도 생각나서 들어와요 스타쉽 나갔다고 기사봤는데 어떻게 지내는지...... 이렇게 보컬 음색 기억나는 사람이 없었는데 꼭 본인 장기 살리길 바래요
" We're not as cute and innocent like before "- Zhu Zhengting, Idol Producer 2k18
ikr but it's a lie
HAHAHA DER SO KYUUTTTT :((
But he's so cute
Woojae needsomemilk s
@
아니 여환웅 언급 많이 없네.... 춤 진짜 드럽게 잘춘다... 춤선 보기만 해도 개-안 글고 광현아••• 너 목소리 내가 사랑했다 정말•••
Ren is seriously an ending fairy! His face at the end was so handsome and charismatic!
Justin really slay this concept
물타기 진짜 뭐야 한명이 “아.. 곡 이해좀 잘해줬음 좋겠다..”하는 순간 우수수 다들 처음엔 안그랬으면서
@임김김 저도 모아인데 이러지 마세요 투바투 지키고싶은마음은 충분히공감하고 이해하는데 이러면서 모아이미지 망가트리지는 말자고요
제가 모아이지만 이건 물타기 맞아요 인정할건 인정합시다
what i love about ren in here,he is not trying to overly cute. He just become himself and shining in this stage😍😍
love nayeon yes. His cuteness came out naturally. 😍
love nayeon agree! 😁 2:22 - 2:30 they all should dance/move smoothly like ren...
love nayeon which one is ren?
Stand K.A.R.D But also loyal for YGfamily lmao the one who sing first
tbh the difference between a debuted idol and trainee was clear here. He didnt go over the top with his facial expressions and really matched the vibe of replay. SHINee never did replay as an aegyo song. Its a chill song in terms of how its sung and also how its danced. In this group it felt like he was the only one who picked up on that and it really made him standout
나만 여환웅 미친듯이 좋냐...? 특히 이무대에서 착장부터 표정,춤,노래 부족한게 없는데...? 여환웅 저머리 해주신분 누구시져? 그쪽방향으로 절하겠습니다 ㅜㅜㅠ 이광현 음색 미침.. 너무 잘해..
이광현 뭐임 ,, 이제와서 원픽됨 ㅠㅠ 목소리 넘 조탕
Okey.
All these guys has been center.♡
Jungjung: Pop center.
Hwangwoong: Right Round center.
Gunhee: Amazing kiss center.
Justin: Replay Center.
Minki: Oh Little Girl center.
Kwanghyun: Rhythm Ta center.
wow good observance
Hwanwoong from Oneus, right?
Watching this again to remind myself Justin and Jung Jung used to be my babies in PD101. They are so matured now in Idol Producer
We're thinking the same thing
I don't know that Justin minghao participate in Korea on this show I thought he participate only in the produce idol it's a pity that he did not made debut in Korea but still he achieved as an idol in China and now look at him he is a star now and even being popular in China ❤❤ my baby I love you forever☺
@@fuziamamarak1960 they actually brought it up (the other trainees) in idol producer when zhu zhengting and justin entered
이광현 음색 개설레ㅠㅠ
Let's be real. Gwanghyun has a beautiful voice. He's so stable and this concept fit him well. He needs more recognition!
Soul yes!! finally someone said it and i 100% agree with you
AGREE
dont forget that he raps REALLY well!!
Gwang hyun voice like Beakhuyn Exo . Love him
Soul agree, I love his voice and it was pretty stable in the perform. too bad he got eliminated, he has proved he can rap too.
아무도 누난 너무 예뻐 저스틴 프듀2 리즈 반박 못한다 반도의 모든 누나들이 울었지 미쳤지 진짜 환장하겠네 다시 돌아와 저스틴,,,, 내 영원한 사랑이다 아가,,,,,
ㅜㅜㅡㅠㅜㅠ저스틴 처돌이 여기도 있어요ㅠㅜ흑흑
아... 저스틴 내 픽 너무 일찍 떨어졌어요 ㅠㅠ
추억여행하는 저스틴 픽 눈물 흘리고 갑니다
틴깅...ㅠ
저스틴 지금 중국에서 인기 엄청 많음..
와 이땐 몰랐는데 이광현 음색 진짜 미쳤네
프듀2 진심 애정하고 모아인 사람인데 왜 투바투랑 여기 조 비교하시는거죠ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 비교하진 맙시다,,,,,
그럴수록 이미지 나빠지고 피해받는건 저희일 테니까 비교하는 까글 내렸으면 하는 마음ㅁ 다 똑같나 보네여ㅠㅠ
그러게요ㅜㅜ
맞아요ㅜㅜ 진짜 비교하시는 모아분들 그거 툽깅이들하고 모아 이미지 망치는 거니까 하지 말아 주셨음해요ㅜ
Can we talk about how sweet and stable gwanghyun's voice is
Dani Siwi i agreeeee 😍
i can hear dk of svt
Omg what happened to Justin! I just saw the first episode of the Chinese 101 and Justin went from cute and innocent to dark and sexy
Maya Holt Zhengting too 😂 they are not as cute and innocent as before like what Jungjung said 😂 i really cant forget what he said HAHAHAHA
Its called idol producer
Omg our babies grew so much TT But Jungjung is still cute in my eyes haha. Even though he wants to be sexy but look at PPAP
Their company told them to act cute and innocent on the show (produce 101) so that’s why but on idol producer they just expressed their true self
@@michelle8764 really ? To be truth i'm falling with he's cute side than cool side ... lol
I love how almost every team did mistakes during their rehearsals but ended up without doing any mistakes during the final performances😆
say the name #20SEVENTEEN well it wasn't really a mistake but the "avengers" couldn't really hit the high notes... not hating, just pointing it out lol
shhh theyre the avengers they gotta keep their status as the flawless avengers lmao
Just so y'all know, blonde Minki is back and ready to make Korea get shooked-
Spread the word
Jiayi Chen he shook my life with his hair. 😫
Jiayi Chen 😆😆 iam ready..
Nancy there's always fan-sites that take pictures of the boys, and the pictures of him blonde is spread on Twitter. Based on the pictures it's more of a strawberry blonde(??), not sure but it's definitely not as blonde as before which is a nice change (at least 7 produce 101 boys have dyed their hair fyi). If you need any links to the pictures I'll try to get them for you
Jiayi Chen saw them on twitter few days ago I think and yes. Not that usual blonde that he usually has. More like, corn-colored or idk. 😆 Sorry
OMG
HAVE Y'ALL SEEN WHAT JUSTIN LOOKS LIKE NOW?
jel oMG YAS AND I'M SO SHOCKED LIKE wTF I WAS LIKE 'iS THIS REALLY THE CUTE KID JuSTIN IN PRODUCE 101?????!!!'
Jelsey Sanchez yeA MY BIAS IN NINE PERCENT AND NEX7
BABY HAS A WHOLE MULLET AND COOL VIBES NOW I'M PROUD
YASH!! AND HE'S SO DAMN COOL OML!1!1!😆😆
IKR MANNN! IT WAS SOO BADDDDD! TWO YEARS AGO, BACK WHEN IDOL PRODUCER AIRED, ME AND MY FRIEND COULDNT STOP FANGIRLING OVER HIM. THEN WE FOUND OUT THAT HE WAS ONLY ONE TO TWO YEARS OLDER THAN US AND WE WERE SCREAMING 😂😂😂😂😂
GWANGHYUN WHY IS HE THE 2ND SUB VOCAL HES SO STABLE
jheunx his voice is my new favorite voice
agree
jheunx SAY THAT LOUDER 📣📣📣📣
Tiffany
honestly justice for gwanghyun!! he's shown us he's skilled in rapping and dancing, and now his stable vocals. WHY ARE KOREANS SLEEPING ON THIS MULTITALENTED CUTIE
Ren's as done with the overly cute act as I am lol
His pose at the end versus the others says it all 2:47
와 이광현 목소리 너무 좋아서 자꾸듣고싶노..
이건희 노래잘하는건 당연히 알테고
저스틴은 진짜 눈이 자꾸감 너무귀여워ㅜㅠ
최민기는 진짜 핑크가 저리 잘어울리냐구ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
여환웅도 자기 몫 너무잘했고 정정도 너무 이쁘게 잘하고ㅜㅜㅜㅡ근데 1조도 2조도 난너무좋앗는데ㅡㅜㅜㅠ프
that highnote was friggin clean, im stanning everyone in this team. including lee gunhee and lee kwanghyun.
yuchi mon Yes please!!! Those 2 are really talented :) I love them a lot❤
Correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't gunmim in boy in luv team, or there's two gunmin?
Sonja Wong H.K. I think she mistook Gunmin for Gunhee
gunmin was in boy in luv (it's gunhee here) but yes gunmin has good vocals too!
Sonja Wong H.K. pretty sure theyre saying theyll support everyone on this team as well as gunmin from BIL
Minki is so pretty !!
Comeback here after watching Justin and Jung Jung in Idol Producer, anyone else?
Meee
Me
i actually miss the cute and innocent justin
Came back here after NEX7's debut to remind me how cute Zhengting and Justin at pd101
CRAZY JADEEYYY SAME HAHA THEY WERE SO CUTE ON PD101
Justin ma baby ❤❤❤
yugo biardo what minute is he?
yang pakai topi
Muthia 니사 2:32 !
SAME GIRL, HE'S SO CUTEEEEEEEE
He got that note!**
NO REN YOU'RE PRETTIER THAN NOONA!
Lmao.. hahahhaha yes he is
true af
Arkazia Arayata Is he the first who sing?
Rusdano Dano Yes he is, He's a member of Nuest 😄
Rusdano Dano Yes! His stage name is Ren and his real name is Choi Minki 😊
0:22 가사 오타난 것 같은데.. 누난 너무 예뻐서가 아니라 난 너무 예뻐서 아님..? 최민기는 진짜 예쁘게 잘생겼다.....
누난 너무 예뻐서 맞아요 !
그래서 담 가사가 남자들이 가만안둔다 하잖아요
바라깅몬모 아닠ㅋㄱㅋㄲㅋㅋㅋ그 파트 부르는 최민기가 너무 예뻐서 난 너무 예뻐 아니냐고 그냥 드립친거예욥..ㅎㅎ
앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
죄송합니당 ㅠ
드립인지 몰랐네용 ㅠ
앞으론 조심하게습니당ㅠ
Jung Jung ah~ Hope you were not sad because of the direct vote of viewers at that day. You did really really good job. You deserve a lot of love ~~
Huong Nguyen chuẩn luôn JungJung tài năng cute dã man mà không được chú ý😭😭😭
Huong Nguyen jing jung is my baby
Huong Nguyen HE DESERVES EVERYTHING
Never mind now support JungJUng & JUSTIN in chinese ver produce(IDOL PRODUCER)
Huong Nguyen watch idol producer because Justin and Jung Jung are there
얘네 진짜 팀 잘뽑았는데... 메보 서호가 했어도 좋았겠지만 건희가 하면서 건희의 보컬가능성을 많이 보여줬던 기억도 있고... 환웅이도 초반에 춤 너무 깔끔하게 춰서 좋았고 저스틴 정정은 말해 뭐해 누너예를 위해 태어났고 민기는 전설의 난 너무 예뻐를 남기고 갔고... 그래도 다섯은 나름 활동하는데 서브보컬로 중심 잘 잡아준 광현이는 영동포팡하고 요즘 뭐하니..... ㅠㅠ
광현이 스타쉽 나갔어요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@5ihatepeople 인스타 뭐라고 쳐야 나오나요?
이광현 보러 맨날 온다,,,,,,음색 진짜 무슨 일이냐,,,,
They all did great, but Lee Gwanghyun from Starship really stood out to me. He is cute and had stable vocals throughout the whole performance. His voice was the voice I remember most tbh
Is Lee Gwanghyun still in starship?
Everytime i see Gwanghyun and hear his voice i really think that he's a long lost twin brother of Inseong SF9..
They're really really similar each other..
Jung jung justin
Nine Percent ❤️
Zhu Zhengting
Huang Minghao
why is no one talking about gunhee and gwanghyun?
as a shawol, i really thank to their voice
0:21 i'm pretty sure Min Ki's even prettier than whoever that "noona" is.
Nghi Luu
😂😂 boys day era 😂😂
아니 최민기 미쳤어 그냥 ㅈ라 귀엽고 잘생겼어 미친
이광현 음색이 미쳤어 진짜 체리맛 탄산수 같음 미쳣어
choi minki
Angel Minki you deserve alot of love seriously can korea stop sleeping on him T.T he is precious
CHANYEOL'S BACON On naver, his fancams has a lot of views, not the 1st, but definitely much more than the average :))
Shreela omg bless you i hope he will succeed T.T
CHANYEOL'S BACON Me too and the rest of nuest too ❤
CHANYEOL'S BACON I just checked naver. He got 252,000 views when the rest of the views are around like average 30,000. :) Park jihoon's fancam is the highest at 900,000+ doe 😱
CHANYEOL'S BACON Ren got the 4th highest score on this evaluation. haha
저 당시 곡 해석대로 컨셉 잡았다가는 결과가 저만치 못했을것 같은데...
지금에서야 곡 해석이 어떻다 얘기 할수 있지만 저 당시 다들 내가 더 멋지고 귀엽고 노래 잘 하고 춤 잘 추고 잘나요~ 어필하기 바빴을텐데 연습냉들도 그렇고 스텝들도 그렇고 신경이나 썼을지...
Justin is a good center and this song perfectly suits him, Jung Jung is such a good dancer!
I LIKE THE BOY THAT SOUND LIKE KEY's SHINee.. the one with pink and white sweater with grey sleeves..
Eym SyaH He is Lee Gwanghyun, from Starship Entertainment
OMG I'M LOCKET, HIS VOICE IS SO SIMILAR
support him in chinese ver produce(IDOL PRODUCER) HE IS JUSTIN
나 진짜 이해 안돼는게 왜 이제와서 너무 끼 부렸다고 생각하는거임?
난 이게 이별 노래인지 몰랐는데 이별 노래라면 윙크하고 하트 하는게 이상하긴한데 그런 생각할거면 그때 생각했어야 하는거 아님?
I love gwanghyun's voice so much like?? It stands out so much and it's really different from the rest of the group
Minki is the only one from Nu'est who still can cover this song.......his face still so young......
Son DongWoon 4ever. Highlight is former BEAST omg yesss! Imagine Baekho doing this XD
true XD
Mingi and probably Jonghyun and Aron as well haha, they debut at 16 and 18 but faces still look the exact same haha!
He can still cover this song. Ma man still young just got little buff
개인적으로 프듀 모든 남자 무대중 청량하고 귀여우면서 섹시한 무대같음 실력 비주얼 컨셉 다 잘어울리고 잘함
00:44 please don't sleep on Gwanghuyn. He has such a stable voice and kind vibe. He and Sewoon are from Starship and they are the kindest looking contestants in the show.
I'm suddenly reminded of the SMRookies version
이광현.... 노래ㅜ미쳐ㅛ아봐ㅠㅠ 존나 잘 불러ㅠㅍ
hwan woong was killing it too with his dance and expressions
Gwanghyun's voice got me shook everytime he sings boy he improved a lot im so proud😍
5년전에 아무도 이광현분 목소리 칭찬없어서 나만 찾아보고 환호하고 한편으로 내가 다 너무너무 서운했는데 이광현분도 이 댓글 꼭 봤음 좋겠서영!!!
EVERYONES TALKING ABOUT MINGI'S FACE CAN BE TALK ABOUT HIS VOICE??? ITS AMAZING!!
Minki you are beautiful and cute
나만 이거 최민기 보러 오는거 같음... 처음 무대 봤을 때 부터 얘는 남다르다 생각했고 솔직히 분위기 부터 쌉 발라버림 최민기만 보면 짬빠 느껴져서 소름 돋는다ㅠㅠ
민기님 보러오는 22
333
So am I the only one amazed by Lee Geon Hee's high notes? Give this guy some love❤️
*I WATCHED THIS VID 92837 TIMES AND I STILL CAN'T UNDERSTAND WHY JUSTIN CAN'T BE IN THE TOP11?!?!??!* *HE IS SO ADORABLE AND TALENTED!* *OPEN YOUR EYES ALREADY AND VOTE FOR HIM* 😠
Im Jaebum is life AND JUNG JUNG
Emma WAHAHAHAHHA...IM JUNG JUNG STAN SISTA'H💚💚
Gianuelle Mae Mangaya YASSS NOW WE NEED PEOPLE TO OPEN THEIR EYES
Im Jaebum is life BASICALLY WE NEED MORE YUEHUA IN TOP 11 😂😅😭
THIS!! SAY IT LOUDER!! Justin has that criteria to be an idol and he always slay in every performance like why can't he be in the top 11???? and Jungjung as well!!! (yes Im Jaebart is life)
and now Justin is literally grinding on the floor wow
I really like your channel name tho lol 👌
Who’s Justin lol that’s all I see in the comment section
@@jungwoosbodyguard3577 justin is the one whose wearing a cap tho.
we don’t... talk about that.. 🤩
@@jungwoosbodyguard3577 the centre with the cap
Ren really suits this concept 💓💓
hena limbu Ren in pink = A beat we can all dance to
Ren suits any concept kskdjsd
Lucy Grand TRUE AF lol😂😂😂
REN. .Choi Minki. .You are the pretty one. .
곡 해석력으로 물타기 당하네 ㅋㅋㅋ... 물론 곡 해석력도 중요하지만 프듀 경연 자체의 특징을 생각해 보시면 ᵔ◡ᵔ... 타돌 끌고 와서 여기서 이러지 마세요
@임김김 물타기 맞음 저 당시에는 곡 해석력이 어쩌구 이런 말 1도 없었는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ그런 곡 아닌데 끼 부리네 어쩌네 하는거 죄다 8개월~11개월 전 댓글
gwanghyun is a rapper, but he sings so stableeee ♥♥ starship is something
Cindy Watanabe but actually it's the opposite, he is a vocal but he raps
Cindy Watanabe that's why I stan Starship💖
he is a vocal in Boys24
but he can rap and be a rapper well :))
anh Minh Hee's innn boys24? omgg I thought he is a rapper, because its written that he likes to rap heheu
+Cindy Watanabe he was in team White. He performed Shock. He was eliminated after that.
Fighting Choi Min Ki
justin concept change so much in idol producer :D
I'm proud of you Ren getting the highest score in replay!!!!!!!!🙌🙌🙌🙌
I'M SO HAPPY
JEL CASTRO I'm so confused. Ten is the one sang the first part right?
His name is Choi minki (Ren) from Nuest Band, Pledis Company.
No one's gonna talk about GUNHEE???HE DID IT! I'M PROUD OF YOU BABY BOY!!!
I LOVE HIM SO MUCH AND URE THE FIRST COMMENT I HAVE SEEN POINTING OUT MY BOY
Gunhee is one of my favourite boy, he is amazing ❤
2:42 여환웅 어깨로 끼부리는 거 진짜 미친 거 아님? 전세계 누나들 기절 갈긴다
minki's visual and voice is no joke
Lee Gwanghyun 💜💜 Please support him everyone!!!!
I give my support to him too, I really like his voice
such a hard worker boy .. he deserve it :3
이광현 좌표
0:36 0:36
0:43 0:43
1:30 1:30
1:57 1:57
so in love with choi minki and huang minghao (justin) ;-; my two pretty boys
Choi Min Ki's voice is very sweet 💖💖💖
오랜만에 보러왔는데 댓 왜이럼
곡에 대한 이해가 부족하다는 둥 애교 과하다는 둥
얘넨 연습생 신분인딩?
심지어 이거 방송할때 이런 반응 없엇는데 갑자기 왴ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ??
그러게요...ㅠㅠ 연생때는 눈에 띄는 게 중요해야 데뷔 가능성도 있으니까ㅜㅠ 너그럽게 넘어가시징..왜 아이돌과 비교를 할까요..
무려 3년전 영상인디..ㅇㅁㅇ
I'm so happy that the boys they're so supportive of each other. Look at how they're so relieved he hit the high note very well. These boys each and every one of them are so precious, I really hope mnet won't do them dirty with their amazing evil editing and made them fight each other. 😭😭😭
everyone in this team got eliminated but they will forever be in our hearts 😭❤️
such an iconic performance 😊😍
cupidjaemin Jungjung and Justin are now part of the CPOP Boy Group 9 Percent, also from a survival show called IDOL PRODUCER and they went from cute to sexy. These two keeps on grinding on the floor. Also part of the CPOP GROUP called NEX7 and its a group of their company.
환웅이, 건희 너무 애기애기하다ㅠㅠㅠ
Yess, Justin your shining brightly. 💕💕
In my opinion, None of them really need to follow the original concept or whatever, because we all know no one can ever beat the original (SHINee), so they used their owns charms. Isn't SHINee's Replay about a younger boy liking an older woman? To catch the noona's attention, Team 1 used their cuteness while Team 2 used their manliness. If you prefer cuteness over manliness, that's fine. If you prefer manliness over cuteness, that's fine too, but don't bring anyone down. You can bring your favorite team up without bringing the other team down.
i like cute and manly that's why these two Replay's are equal to me ♡♡♡♡♡
Zhaomei Yulhui but actually team 2 is cute too, my sister's bias changed from woojin to sanggyun because of how cute he is(I bet no one wants to know about my sis😂)
YESSSSS, SANGGYUN IS SO CUTE. HE IS MY BIAS NOW >
THIS SPEECH NEEDS TO BE SPREAD OVER
Astro's REPLAY is highly recommended especially when the rapper did the high note💕
이광현 음색 너무 좋다..
Update to all us Ren, NUEST-lovers and supporters!!
• Their group won the battle 467-391!! 3000 points will be added to their scores.
• Ren's individual score was the highest out of the entire group, 157!!
• After all group performances, Ren is ranked 4th out of all trainees with a score of 157 (this is excluding fan votes that took place outside of the battles and excludes the 3000 points)
AMAZING JOB MINKI!! 💕
Side note:
All NUEST members won their battles except Baekho. 3000 points will be added to their total. As of now individual scores.
Ren - 4th (157)
Minhyun - 13th (108)
JR - 39th (67)
Baekho - 22-33 (86)
LETS GO BOYS!!! 💕💕
yes my Ren, get highest voting for Replay!!!
yes, he got 157, highest than others
shishi shomel wow but still can't beat park woodam's score (not hate okay)
Farah Nadia the avengers or/both justice league will beat it
Farah Nadia of course, he get highest for Replay both group,
did they win?
광현아 요즘 뭐하니,,, 진짜 음색 사랑했다
i love choi min ki
Ren is just naturally pretty, he didn't even need to act all cute to melt viewers' heart. He was born to be on stage!
btw, i love everyone in this team especially my starship baby LEE GWANGHYUN! Please support him ❤
곡 이해하는 거 중요하죠 너무 중요한데 저 당시엔 이런 의견도 별로 없었고 끼 한 번 더 부려서 눈도장 찍히려는 것 도 난 이해간다.. 과한분들도 계셨지만 손하트.. ? 한 번 정돈 봐줄 수 있다고 생각함 만약 저분들 그대로 현역인 상태로 했으면 훨씬 잘했을듯 쩝... 모 그렇다구요....아가들아 좀만 더 끼ㅏ참지...
Who is this 2:00 HE can be a Main Vocal! damn voice so clean and fresh O.O
hyshryn Lee Kwanghyun from Starship, and he's a Rapper.
wow! he must be really talented i hope he can be in top 11 :)
hyshryn starship always slays when come to vocal.
He just got eliminated in the last ep. Gwanghyun srsly deserves more love 💔😢
Minki really deserved the 4th place on vote! he just need to gain more weight and that will definitely makes him to be one of the best visual..
anyway, i'm happy to see he's finally having fun with his team, i don't want to see him crying and gloomy anymore..
JUSTIN WAS A REAL KID😂😂😂When I saw him in idol producer I thought he's already in his 20's then I discovered that he is younger than me when I am 17 years😂😂 he's just a baby for me😂😂😂 I am his NOONA NO ONE DISAGREE THAT!😂😂❤
Gwanghyun's voice gives me goosebumps every time it's so nice and warm ;-; pls vote for him