@@subramaniam9749 farm bills corporatised their lands. Adani bought all food silos as modi made hoarding food grains etc. legal. They protested for us.
@@subramaniam9749 why do you think someone instigated farmers? In a democracy arent farmers too entitled to protest for their rights. They had to protest for so many months, because egoistic PJP refused to listen to them. Stop being a sychophant, who believes everything ruling party does is an Act of God. No more Tanashahi.
Are We the citizens of India paying these ministers to discuss and celebrate awards in the parliament? How does this discussion help the people of this country? The chairperson is also bought up by the ruling party! SHAME, SHAME!!!😢
He explained this is not only this time, it happens many times for many occations. And its okay. We are human beings, we discuss all sorts of things. Celebration of good things is one of them.
@@bala3564 They couldnt question the awards because all were deserving hence, they questioned why time was allotted for praising them for a few moments, despite knowing fully well that speaker can allot time based on his discretion !! Thats sad. They could have simply let them wrap in half an hours instead of creating ruckus and wasting time.
It has been observed that this particular Speaker always goes soft on the ruling Party members but when it comes tothe Opposition Party members he has a very different tone ! So much for his impartiality!
They sat on road because they were misled. Farms laws would have catapulted farmers to atleast middle class. I abhore BJP for succumbing to the pressure and retracting all the farm bills.
What has the farmers' protest got to do with the working of the house. Only the oppositions are crying about the farmers. Instead of fighting poverty and corruption, these opposition leaders only want to support the rich people. Shame on them.
हमारे देश में जो अत्यंत गरीब हैं, वे दिन-ब-दिन... और अधिक गरीब होते जा रहे हैं... सबसे पहले "गरीबी हटाओ"...जो 25 साल पहले शुरू हुआ था, बहुत महत्वपूर्ण है... हमारे आधे नागरिक केवल एक समय भरपेट भोजन ही कर पाते हैं। पिछले 10-15 सालों में हर जगह महंगाई बढ़ने से आम आदमी का जीना बहुत मुश्किल हो गया है। . . वर्तमान सरकार और विपक्ष को एक साथ मिल कर सभ्य होना चाहिए, एक दूसरे के साथ एकजुट होना चाहिए और सबसे पहले हमारे देश के अंदर की सारी गंदगी को साफ करना चाहिए, ..... सबसे महत्वपूर्ण है कि जनता के पैसे को बर्बाद करने के बजाय धर्मों के बीच एकता और शांति बनाई जाए। दुनिया भर का दौरा करना और चुनाव लड़ना... भगवान राम भी कितने प्रसन्न होंगे... पत्रकारों, मीडिया, CJI, ASI, ED आदि को ऐसे मुद्दों पर बहस करनी चाहिए.. अफ़सोस की बात है कि उनमें से अधिकांश एकतरफ़ा हैं, जिन्हें "हमारे देश के अंदर के बहुत महत्वपूर्ण मुद्दों" की कोई परवाह नहीं है! 15:58
Chairman is totally biased. Farmer is not going to gain anything by him getting the reward. His son need not justify the governments doing. Why has the chairman to voice out his feelings to the house . He is supposed to be unbiased Just listen and proceedings proceed.
Did people get anything when Nehru, Indira and Rajiv got awards. Did people get anything when Sachin Tendulkar, Teresa got. So why do expect people to get anything when Charan Sigh, PVNR, Swaminathan gets one..
@@manbeh4u Certain criterias are there for being a beneficiary of the award. Just elections are round the corner, you start distributing awards. Doesn't that only sound funny. You could have waited for the elections then fine . Last election their survived on the the Pulwama at the martyrdom of forty soldiers. Till date no regret after Mallik the government vented out the fault of the government
@@manbeh4u I have no hard feelings! Let them qualify the credentials needed for the award. It's not out of the blues you give. Trying to appease people to garner votes is unethical. He could have given it next year that to on the basis of Dip dip dip my blue ship sailing on the water like a cup and saucer dip dip dip.
@@manbeh4u Discretion refers to the needs of the hour. The chairman should know well to place priorities. When it the opposition's turn he turns a blind eye. His body language is totally biased
@@oliviadsouza754 He definitely knows it being the speaker. So Kharge should let him decide instead of lecturing on doing things that should appease the opposition. He could have called the discretion thing but on any other topic. This was a self goal.
@@manbeh4u Who is appeasing whom. I spoke about the chairman. A totally spineless personality. His body language is biased. He tilts towards the BJP in such a manner that he misses a slip.. He needs to save his face . A chairman should be unbiased. His body language deceives him to an extent that he has to take the face value of what kharge worded.
Cant help if you are born without brains. The Chairman is superior to all the MPs. An MD of a company need not be elder to hus subordinates. You have to beva pappu bhakt😅
First and foremost you need to follow certain rules for the beneficiaries of the award. Not at the advent of a general election. Last time it was pulwama now it is Ram mandir n awards
@@manbeh4u you were justifying him associating his life with hardship when he's filthy rich and probably banging a different girls everyday since 2014.
Dhankad ji did not insult anyone… rather he was mocked by opposition members outside of the parliament and Rahul Gandhi was shamelessly recording the act. I think you forgot that…
People of India , know pretty well, who is unworthy and who is worthy to be in this temple of secular democracy. Hypocrites will be taught a lesson. Wolves in sheep's clothing will be defeated ruthlessly in 2024. 🌹🙏
the same group of persons, never gone to the side of the farmers who have fought for months together for their tights recently. They forgot all those conveniently.
People have short memory, that there were multiple rounds of talks with farmer unions, farmer leaders with none able to argue it out point wise. The progressive laws had to be rolled back - which is a pity. The very same laws were to be enacted by all political parties which had them in their respective manifestos.
All 82 crores of Indians who depend on free food of 5 rupees are Bharat Ratna. Because of their votes, Modi survives. Please do not sell Bharat Ratna for the sake of votes in 2024 elections.
All the lovers of our great nation and its democracy should be united in supporting Shri. Rahul Gandhi wholeheartedly. Through his yatras he has proved himself to be a courageous, competent and visionary leader who can make our country the world leader in every aspect. It is the duty of all the 140 crore people to do their bit to save our democracy. On the part of the party leadership it is their duty to expel all the corrupt elements in the INC.
The Chairman himself was quoting his cast few days back, today he is saying Kisan to himself. Is this joke going on ? There was no agenda to discuss the Bharat Ratna in the house, but Jayant Chaudhry started started speaking about this. Then Mr. Kharge stood up and said if Bharat Ratna has to be discussed then every awardee should be discussed and agenda should be set for such discussion. Mr. Dhankar went silent since there was no provision in the law to discuss Bharat Ratna in the parliament.
wah wah RS - SET NEW STDS !!!! the slave speakers of ls/rs, govnurs only need to be ashamed . 700 + farmers died coz modi passed another law without due process ignoring the stake holders . thats the insult to the farmers - not what happend 40-50 yrs ago. in 2014 if all the broad framework were laid , due discusions happened all over the diverse country, u can pass laws to affect changes. like demo, gst and everything else its all shock and awe tactic, why wont there be??
What is the use of giving bharat ratna to charan singh when 30 farmers are dying per hour in the country, vp is playing for BJP, why didn't you give it earlier, when it is election time you are remember charan singh,
He disgraced position of RS Sabhapati Countrymen are watching And Kisan are still coming for same demand which was acepted after year of protest on delhi border with 700+martyers Note: I remember the passing of 3 black farm laws
Dhankhar has lowered his dignity, when speaks it seems as if a pet is speaking, such a big title does not suit a person like this. He sold his dignity as Bengal governor, got promoted as VP
This speaker softly aligns with ruling govt . Discipline of the house depends on the head, the speaker, however this speaker blames on members and suspends...."do to others what you want others to do to you"-
If speaker uses his discretionary power and allots some time to the award winners who have had an impact on millions of people, how is it aligning with ruling govt !!
Chairman is totally biased. Farmers are not gaining anything by him getting the reward. Why has the chairman to voice out his feelings in the house. Hh
What did Modi do when the farmers were sitting on the street for 8 months.Real hypocrisy.This speaker is biased.
Farmers literally died during their hartal.
He did nothing. Sad, Over 700 farmers died during protest, while he kept feeding his ego.
Who instigated the farmers 2 sit that long? This shows the trouble makers against the govt. Expect PM 2 visit them 4 what.
@@subramaniam9749 farm bills corporatised their lands. Adani bought all food silos as modi made hoarding food grains etc. legal. They protested for us.
@@subramaniam9749 why do you think someone instigated farmers? In a democracy arent farmers too entitled to protest for their rights. They had to protest for so many months, because egoistic PJP refused to listen to them. Stop being a sychophant, who believes everything ruling party does is an Act of God. No more Tanashahi.
😏Why take Jayant Chaudary's Party in exchange for Bharat Ratna for his grandfather?😡
Jayant has to answer for the death of about 700 farmers ☝️
Why farmers are commiting suicide despite Bharat Ratna ?
VP has not heard the BJP MAN shouting. Disturbing
One side deaf
This fellow is not eligible to sit in VP position
How do you respond to these uncivilised barberian sitying in RS and LS.
@@srinivasanrajagopalan9544 Barbarians of the BJ party!!
Highly partial,
you are eligible I guess
And what are you eligible for.. ??
As a speaker, he's behaving like a puppet of BJP
he is a puppet
How come speaker doing prachar for ruling party
He doesn’t keep his dignity and honesty
Is this New parliament house a house for the ruling party to scream at the opposition?
The speaker is one sided
Kharge ji is right 👍
Are We the citizens of India paying these ministers to discuss and celebrate awards in the parliament? How does this discussion help the people of this country? The chairperson is also bought up by the ruling party! SHAME, SHAME!!!😢
Award topic should be questioned by the opposition to expose BJP's political agenda behind the awards to these people.
He explained this is not only this time, it happens many times for many occations.
And its okay. We are human beings, we discuss all sorts of things. Celebration of good things is one of them.
It is absolutely fine, for 2 mins, if someone acknowledges the greatness of the people who contributed for the country
Its a Central Government good decision to honour our Late Choudari Charan Singh Ji former PM of India with Bharat Ratna.
@@bala3564 They couldnt question the awards because all were deserving hence, they questioned why time was allotted for praising them for a few moments, despite knowing fully well that speaker can allot time based on his discretion !! Thats sad. They could have simply let them wrap in half an hours instead of creating ruckus and wasting time.
It has been observed that this particular Speaker always goes soft on the ruling Party members but when it comes tothe Opposition Party members he has a very different tone ! So much for his impartiality!
He does not respect the chair.He is biased by his words and actions as well.
He who walks with wise men will be wise but the companions of fools will be destroyed.
He has been given this position aa a reward for meddlimg in West Bengal as its governonr. So he will be a BJP bootlicker.
Huge respect kharghe ji🙏
What has Dhankard to say about millions of farmers who sat on the road for over a year.... He should feel ashamed to be part of the house.
A self-righteous hypocrite . 😂
@@jacobzachariah656 what else can a coward convert say
They sat on road because they were misled. Farms laws would have catapulted farmers to atleast middle class. I abhore BJP for succumbing to the pressure and retracting all the farm bills.
Dhankad would have told - farm laws were good and progressive, which actually is the truth.
What has the farmers' protest got to do with the working of the house. Only the oppositions are crying about the farmers.
Instead of fighting poverty and corruption, these opposition leaders only want to support the rich people. Shame on them.
V. P is acting like a B
. J. P man. After electing to d position of a Constitution he should act impartial.
हमारे देश में जो अत्यंत गरीब हैं, वे दिन-ब-दिन... और अधिक गरीब होते जा रहे हैं...
सबसे पहले "गरीबी हटाओ"...जो 25 साल पहले शुरू हुआ था, बहुत महत्वपूर्ण है...
हमारे आधे नागरिक केवल एक समय भरपेट भोजन ही कर पाते हैं।
पिछले 10-15 सालों में हर जगह महंगाई बढ़ने से आम आदमी का जीना बहुत मुश्किल हो गया है। . .
वर्तमान सरकार और विपक्ष को एक साथ मिल कर सभ्य होना चाहिए, एक दूसरे के साथ एकजुट होना चाहिए और सबसे पहले हमारे देश के अंदर की सारी गंदगी को साफ करना चाहिए, ..... सबसे महत्वपूर्ण है कि जनता के पैसे को बर्बाद करने के बजाय धर्मों के बीच एकता और शांति बनाई जाए। दुनिया भर का दौरा करना और चुनाव लड़ना...
भगवान राम भी कितने प्रसन्न होंगे...
पत्रकारों, मीडिया, CJI, ASI, ED आदि को ऐसे मुद्दों पर बहस करनी चाहिए.. अफ़सोस की बात है कि उनमें से अधिकांश एकतरफ़ा हैं, जिन्हें "हमारे देश के अंदर के बहुत महत्वपूर्ण मुद्दों" की कोई परवाह नहीं है! 15:58
Chairman is totally biased.
Farmer is not going to gain anything by him getting the reward.
His son need not justify the governments doing.
Why has the chairman to voice out his feelings to the house .
He is supposed to be unbiased
Just listen and proceedings proceed.
Converted cowards shd remain silent. Can your conversion have any justification
Did people get anything when Nehru, Indira and Rajiv got awards. Did people get anything when Sachin Tendulkar, Teresa got. So why do expect people to get anything when Charan Sigh, PVNR, Swaminathan gets one..
@@manbeh4u Certain criterias are there for being a beneficiary of the award.
Just elections are round the corner, you start distributing awards.
Doesn't that only sound funny.
You could have waited for the elections then fine .
Last election their survived on the the Pulwama at the martyrdom of forty soldiers.
Till date no regret after Mallik the government vented out the fault of the government
@@manbeh4u I have no hard feelings!
Let them qualify the credentials needed for the award.
It's not out of the blues you give.
Trying to appease people to garner votes is unethical.
He could have given it next year that to on the basis of Dip dip dip my blue ship sailing on the water like a cup and saucer dip dip dip.
😂 At present there is no meaning in giving or awarding great indian civilian awards. Getting votes is primary matter. Chairman is highly biased
The Vice President is unnecessarily dragging in the name of kisans just to create ire from kisans against opposition.
All this happening because the farmers have decided to start protests again on 13th Feb. This move is just to calm the farmers.
Very good rebuttal to the chairman by kharge
Horrible behavior by Congress, including Kharge.
Kharge says speaker can use discretionary power and then says why is he using it as per his discretion !! That logic is out of this world.
@@manbeh4u Discretion refers to the needs of the hour.
The chairman should know well to place priorities.
When it the opposition's turn he turns a blind eye.
His body language is totally biased
@@oliviadsouza754 He definitely knows it being the speaker. So Kharge should let him decide instead of lecturing on doing things that should appease the opposition. He could have called the discretion thing but on any other topic. This was a self goal.
@@manbeh4u Who is appeasing whom.
I spoke about the chairman.
A totally spineless personality.
His body language is biased.
He tilts towards the BJP in such a manner that he misses a slip..
He needs to save his face .
A chairman should be unbiased.
His body language deceives him to an extent that he has to take the face value of what kharge worded.
I was in deep sadness, to see such a partial speaker, didn't give a chance to the Opposition party to explain 😢😢😢
Who is shouting more than the speaker?
VP not fit for this house. What is the use of giving Barath Rathna ? There should be value for that. If don't understand the value. It is waste.
May be a maulvi should be given bharat Ratna to satisfy people of your kind 😅
You need to know more to understand its value. Others do hence dont complain :)
one sided biased conduction of the house.
Babari Ratna for demolishing the masjid and others for keeping silent on demolition.
Barbarians masjid demolished. Barbar ka barabar.
The chairman is sometimes a Jat , a farmer . Hurt the feelings always.
Where was the noble farmer when 700 farmers died during the protest.
Mr Speaker you are Junior to Kharge ji , you should be the desciple to him.
Cant help if you are born without brains. The Chairman is superior to all the MPs. An MD of a company need not be elder to hus subordinates.
You have to beva pappu bhakt😅
Nonsense
Bro what do you mean by junior, he is the vice president of the country. Second in command and protocol
Junior..? What are you smoking dude.. He is Vice President of India, he is not junior to any other member of Rajya Sabha..
He is too emotional to be speaker. Very irrational.
Shameful behaviour in the R.S. What is being justified? The action of selective awardees? Or is it the might of the ruling .......?
First and foremost you need to follow certain rules for the beneficiaries of the award.
Not at the advent of a general election.
Last time it was pulwama now it is Ram mandir n awards
only 4 words to the hon'ble speaker,, "WAH, KYA ACTING HAI"
No spine. He's a farmer, smritri irani is a farmer etc.
If Robert Vadra and Gandhis can be .. why not him ..
@@manbeh4u add them to the list then. Why are you implying i like gandhis?
@@kebugcheck These are your own words mate. I never said anything on you.
@@manbeh4u you were justifying him associating his life with hardship when he's filthy rich and probably banging a different girls everyday since 2014.
This VP is a puppy of Modi
This vp will be written in history as the most chaatukar... Jo bhi cheez ho usme farmer caste dalit daldo
Farmer ki baat chal rahi thi anyways..
emotional blackmail VP
He remembers farmer only when he targeted
😊
Proxy political chairman perfectly fit for his MASTER
Wasting the time and funds of public and only boasting about bjp and shouting only take place in the loksabha and rajya sabha
Grandson sells party and country.
What did Modi do for the farmers. He is only doing this for the next election.
The opposition should protest against chairman's fascist conduct. He is only running the house at the whim of fascist RSS
Dhangad is behaving like BJP representative. Kharge is senior member and Dhangad should not insult him
Deserve respect before you desire resoect
Dhankad ji did not insult anyone… rather he was mocked by opposition members outside of the parliament and Rahul Gandhi was shamelessly recording the act. I think you forgot that…
Agree. Speaker himself wants respect but whines like a child everytime someome even talks
V p is biased
Commandos are saving your life. Do not degrade Commandos.
Speaker is SO biased. He creates drama at every turn. It's childish
Kharge ji 👑
Should Chairman be praising Ch Ch Singh? Shame on him & the Centre!
Chairman is acting like a party member.He himself speaks a lot and does not allow others to speak .
Maharaja darbar samapth😅
This speaker baffoon mocks our parliment.....
Shameless vice chairman 😂 he blatantly defending ruling party
Sham. Isnt this a speech? Why are important matters of the country not being discussed? Please....
Siraji
Kindly no questions to speaker
He is superem, he has discretion power in certain situation, we should give liberty to conduct house.namaste
People of India , know pretty well, who is unworthy and who is worthy to be in this temple of secular democracy. Hypocrites will be taught a lesson. Wolves in sheep's clothing will be defeated ruthlessly in 2024. 🌹🙏
This is Rajya Sabha TV or Rajya Sabha chairman TV
Wow wow elections make vp and bjp to cry for farmers
But they are dead and dump while 700/- farmers sacrificed there life
Why did they come to die in first place..
Greatest joker occupying the chair. Take ur seat . The only line he speaks
Somebody tell him commandos are highly disciplined people.
Definitely is not suited to VP 🥔
And you are :D
He is speker, as a RSS political leader...
the same group of persons, never gone to the side of the farmers who have fought for months together for their tights recently. They forgot all those conveniently.
People have short memory, that there were multiple rounds of talks with farmer unions, farmer leaders with none able to argue it out point wise. The progressive laws had to be rolled back - which is a pity. The very same laws were to be enacted by all political parties which had them in their respective manifestos.
Empires rise and fall .... nothing last forever!
This guy doesn't deserve his post.
Shameless shameless person who cannot speak any language properly has become a leader. Great vice president tackling.
Yhe speaker is insane .
Modi's dirty politics. He remembered charansingh on the face of election.
All 82 crores of Indians who depend on free food of 5 rupees are Bharat Ratna. Because of their votes, Modi survives. Please do not sell Bharat Ratna for the sake of votes in 2024 elections.
All the lovers of our great nation and its democracy should be united in supporting Shri. Rahul Gandhi wholeheartedly. Through his yatras he has proved himself to be a courageous, competent and visionary leader who can make our country the world leader in every aspect. It is the duty of all the 140 crore people to do their bit to save our democracy. On the part of the party leadership it is their duty to expel all the corrupt elements in the INC.
Jagdeep is more BJP than BJP Parlament members.😂
Discription should be used without any discrimination the speaker should b not be bias and he should act according with the rule book
The Chairman himself was quoting his cast few days back, today he is saying Kisan to himself. Is this joke going on ? There was no agenda to discuss the Bharat Ratna in the house, but Jayant Chaudhry started started speaking about this. Then Mr. Kharge stood up and said if Bharat Ratna has to be discussed then every awardee should be discussed and agenda should be set for such discussion. Mr. Dhankar went silent since there was no provision in the law to discuss Bharat Ratna in the parliament.
wah wah RS - SET NEW STDS !!!! the slave speakers of ls/rs, govnurs only need to be ashamed . 700 + farmers died coz modi passed another law without due process ignoring the stake holders . thats the insult to the farmers - not what happend 40-50 yrs ago. in 2014 if all the broad framework were laid , due discusions happened all over the diverse country, u can pass laws to affect changes. like demo, gst and everything else its all shock and awe tactic, why wont there be??
Sorry plight of the nation that the country's highest honors are awarded to meet political gamesmanship...
What is the use of giving bharat ratna to charan singh when 30 farmers are dying per hour in the country, vp is playing for BJP, why didn't you give it earlier, when it is election time you are remember charan singh,
He disgraced position of RS Sabhapati
Countrymen are watching
And Kisan are still coming for same demand which was acepted after year of protest on delhi border with 700+martyers
Note: I remember the passing of 3 black farm laws
Paid Farmers died due to mis-information on the progressive farm laws. Blame it on the middle men, farm union leaders and rich arthiyas.
Super speaker
Speaker is also decision one side
This guy was in congress for more than a decade.
Dhankhar has lowered his dignity, when speaks it seems as if a pet is speaking, such a big title does not suit a person like this.
He sold his dignity as Bengal governor, got promoted as VP
Kissan KO Bharat Ratna, Surf election ke pehle hi milta hai 😅😅😅
BajpAA KO Kissano Ka Yaad sirf election ke time pe hi aata hai.....
Han to tu pehle de dena.. :)
@@manbeh4u 😂😂😂
Mein BJP Ka neta thodi Hu, Jo bhaktoo kon bewakoof banaungaa.....
This speaker softly aligns with ruling govt . Discipline of the house depends on the head, the speaker, however this speaker blames on members and suspends...."do to others what you want others to do to you"-
If speaker uses his discretionary power and allots some time to the award winners who have had an impact on millions of people, how is it aligning with ruling govt !!
Dhankar should be banished
Please mention the power and functions of speaker. I don't know speaker can be one sided. What kharge said sees vividly.
You cannot stop the betrayers, selfish and corrupts from jumping from party to party for power and money !!!
😂Chairman is working for somebody. Charansingh was made pm by Congress party.
BJP GIVES AWARD FOCUSED ONLY FOR VOTING AIM.
Mr speker you are spoilied Indian democracy, your behaviour like RSS leader
Chairman should be sharp to curb political parties shouting like animals
I gueaa yiu mean the members of the party of rapists - the BJP?
Sir
When everyone all institutions are against the opposition what can one do
Don't take personally
Love the opposition ❤
Chairman is totally biased.
Farmers are not gaining anything by him getting the reward.
Why has the chairman to voice out his feelings in the house.
Hh
Looks like VP just initiated BJP's election campaign 😂
Imagine the state of parliament
JD HIMSELF DOESN'T DESERVE TO BE IN THIS HOUSE.
Does Kharge know how to respect Sabhapati? what is this indecent attitude by Congress
Precedence is meant by chairman only for opposition not for corrupt bigots he is also behaving like one.
Not Kisan but charansingh for political purposes.... country knows
That’s disrespectful of a Commando
From where ever u come, your attitude is known
"Kisaan ke dil pe chot"
Mr Chairman, where had u been when thousands of kisaans were on street?😅
Mr. Bunker you are disrespecting the Commandos
Kisan wants msp not awards
Dhankar us an idiot