The Doctor Visits Amy & Rory For Christmas | The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe | Doctor Who
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- The Doctor pays a surprise visit to his friends Amy and Rory, on Christmas Day. Subscribe to Doctor Who for more: bit.ly/Subscrib...
WATCH MORE:
GERMAN: bit.ly/DoctorW...
FRENCH: bit.ly/DoctorW...
ITALIAN: bit.ly/DoctorW...
Christmas Specials: bit.ly/DoctorWh...
Series 6: bit.ly/DW-Series6
The Eleventh Doctor: bit.ly/TheEleve...
From the 2011 Doctor Who Christmas Special "The Doctor, The Widow And The Wardrobe"
THE DOCTOR, THE WIDOW AND THE WARDROBE
Evacuated to a house in Dorset from war-torn London, Madge Arwell and her two children, Lily and Cyril, are greeted by a madcap caretaker whose mysterious Christmas gift leads them into a magical wintry world.
Starring Matt Smith (The Doctor), Claire Skinner (Madge Arwell) and Alexander Armstrong (Reg Arwell)
Written by Steven Moffatt
Directed by Farren Blackburn
MORE ABOUT DOCTOR WHO:
Welcome to the home of Doctor Who on TH-cam! Travel in the TARDIS with clips dating back to the Doctor's first incarnation in 1963, all the way through dozens of regenerations, from the latest clips of the Peter Capaldi era to the announcement of Jodie Whittaker as the Thirteenth Doctor. Including behind-the-scenes footage, exclusive videos and our very own show Doctor Who: The Fan Show - this is the place to find all the best official clips from all 54 years of Doctor Who history.
Subscribe for more: bit.ly/Subscrib...
This is a commercial channel from BBC Studios. Service & Feedback www.bbcstudios...
Never realized they painted their door in tardis blue before. Nice detail.
Only paint that was left
The house is blue, but has the same yellow/orange interior
That’s gonna be the new way I call pthalo blue from now on Tardis blue lol 😂
When I first saw the apartment I was thinking. AH clever! TARDIS BLUE EXTERIOR!
@@TanyaLouise777 ngl those seem like some pretty big stretches
You know what I find so sad and wholesome
"you set a place for me?"
"Oh we Always do"
😥
But isn't it a tradition in some places to always have an extra seat and plate at Christmas? 😳
she waits
@@lejyby yes but it isn’t in Britain where this is set
@@jennifermountain9876 I was wondering. It is mentioned in some songs in French ("La chanson des restaurants du coeur", www.paroles.net/jean-jacques-goldman/paroles-les-restos-du-coeur), and a quick search on the net indicates that it is still a tradition in Poland (culture.pl/en/article/why-do-poles-leave-one-chair-empty-on-christmas-eve). I wonder if it could have been a (religious?) tradition in (some parts of) England at some point, and if the episode made a reference to that?
I absolutely love this scene, not only did they reunite but the doctor also cried tears of joy when he realised that he had somewhere he could belong aside from the Tardis.
It hits much harder when the doctor realize he lost his home again in angel takes manhattan
Dorieke Beek xmas special the doctor the witch and the wardrobe
Happy tears
It’s not just that, it also calls back to the line about ‘what’s the point in being happy now, if they’re going to be sad later?’ Which is also applicable to the doctor himself and outliving his companions. Yet he returns to them at the end, because later sadness shouldn’t stop us from being happy now.
And then they both died lol
I love that Amy defends River and calls her a good girl, it's such a motherly thing and I love it so much
"She's a good girl"..... she says in such a "mother" way about a child far older than her. Lol
@@kevoconnor145 It's still her child.
@@HarryJamesPotter7 I'm not denying that. It's just cute/funny how she talks about a daughter who's older than her, like she's 6 yrs old.
@@kevoconnor145 to be river usually acts like shes 6 lol
I was going to say basically this. Instead, I'll just like your comment and reply. Thank you. (I'm not crying, YOU'RE crying!)
Why do people hate this era it's one of the best if not the best Amy and Rory were the closest thing he had to a family
I mean he's their son-in-law
Some random Guy just... just who hates this era ? Know no one that hates this era
People always complain to try sound sophisticated like they explore ideas of fine arts or to try be the special snowflake who’s different. They’re the people who are part of the “new doctor hate bandwagon” where they whine about every post-regeneration doctor because the prior doctor was “better”.
It happened with Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi and look at them now, they’re the most beloved Doctors.
Never met a person on the internet who hates this era. And it's by far my most favourite.
It was really good but idk I really did not connect with Amy
I love the almost parental role Amy and Rory take towards the doctor here. He hasn't shown up in two years, but after a brief telling off it's all hugs and there's a place for him at the dinner table because of course there is-that's what family means.
Well, they ARE his mother(and father)-in-law! 😂 I think Amy, perhaps more so than Rory, feel like he has to be taken care of now more than ever, for River.
she still tried to shag him
@@toasterroast7678 Well that was before familial bonds were realized.
@@FranciumBoron No she knows shes his mother in law here, she references it when river tells her the doctor is alive
It also makes it more realistic. They’ve aged and become more mature. He’s now there son in law too. It’s odd that they never explored Amy having abandonment issues though. The doctor left her as a child, left her again for two years in the first episode, then again when Amy was left behind for around 40 years in an alternate time stream, now again here. Then again throughout season 7.
Best moment in doctor who. These were the good old days. Miss these 3.
Same but rtd was better but this was way better then what chibnall could pull out of his ass now.
@@EternalPayne way to turn it into a negative
Osian Coleman Amen to that. :) Miss it so much.
Michael McGrath So true.
Me to
I love them. They I felt were more like the doctors family than any of the other companions. Rose was a love, Martha and Jack great friends, Donna was his best friend, Clara was a crush, and River was his wife, with Bill as a friend. But Amy and Rory, they were his family
I'd say Bill was a sort of granddaughter that he didn't knew very well until she grew up.
@@G.F.SF55 He did have a more teaching role with her, but its wasn't as close as they could have been. Needed more time together
I agree.
I say Clara became his equal and most closest companion. Definitely started as a crush but I say as the doctor and her relationship evolve. She’s the closest friend/family ever to him knowing him on an in-depth level that no one else gets too
@@GamerXPERhonestly, 12 and Clara have been the closest I’ve ever seen a companion, like true familial platonic love, its so heartwarming. Because idk its a lovely idea that you can become so deeply attached and connected with someone that they become your family, not by blood or circumstance, but by the relationship formed between them. They have such a wonderful relationship, not becuz its perfect, but because the Doctor goes too far and makes mistakes out of that unconditional love, and its mutual.
One of the best endings to a Christmas Special... ever...
Found you. Just came from your video.
Totally agree crispy! Broke my heart seeing The Doctor realize he has a family!
And the last.
@@masteryoda9992 Whomever idea it was to NOT do Christmas special this year needs to be fired.
@@jerthon1 well considering they have a Muslim as a companion now, Christmas celebration would be out of place. Not to mention that ratings have been falling all season this time
This scene is pure beauty. The way he realizes that they're not just his companions, not just his friends but family. And behind a door painted in Tardis blue he doesn't just find a house but a home so in a way he walks through a blue door and what he finds is bigger on the inside.
Beautifully said.
He will always have a home at the Pond's.🥲
Oh ffs be quiet.
@Alinor24 - *Ponds. Apostrophes play no part in plurals and you were never taught that they do so why do it?
@@markfox1545Why are you so salty?
Smith, Gillan and Darvill were Steven Moffat's golden era on the show.
arguable but still good
Chibnall is the shit era of dr who
You say that but he wrote Blink, girl in the fireplace, the two empty child episodes and the two silence of the library episodes in Tennants era all arguably better than anything he wrote during Matt Smith's era
@@PlayupskybIues Those are excellent episodes. Empty Child/Doctor Dances is when I really started to like Chris Eccleston as the Doctor (Plus he intro'd Capt Jack - one of the best recurring characters imho. on the same level as River)
@@ScorpiusZA. yeah love how he did Rivers arc making tennant not know him something plausible in the show that hadn't been done despite being glaringly obvious that he would meet people and them know him but not the other way around
Now imagine if he was tearing up because he visited them after the events of The Angels Take Manhattan
Justinian Siah EVILL
WHY MUST YOU HURT ME IN THIS WAY
Yeah. Everyone forgets the fact that it's a whole bunch of loosely connected stories with regeneration brackets. Nothing is really set in stone.
But i'd be lying if i said that the idea is still utterly heart-wrenching.
doesn't he say he wouldn't ever be able to see them again which means he couldn't do it after the angels take manhattan because technically they died before this point
@@dankerbell Well yeah he doesnt say it directly but he realizes it bc river tells him
Such a great relationship between the three.
The more and more I rewatch series 5-7a, the more I miss these times.
Yeah, same here. Matt, Karen and Arthur was perfect in their roles...
Now this was true friendship, didn't feel forced or artificial by stating it all the time and not acting accordingly ( right? Season 11 ? )
Those times have sadly gone now
I felt Eleven was wasting too much time travelling with his fake family.
Thank goodness for Clara.
what made s5-7a great despite a few messes were matt karen & arthur. those three have always been my favorite cast members
Amy: We're about to have Christmas dinner. Joining us?
Doctor: if it's no trouble?!
Rory: There's a plate set for you.
Doctor: but you didn't know I was coming why would you...
Amy: ooooh because we always do. It's Christmas you moron.
That part always gets me, because that's the moment he realizes he has a family again. He's so happy he even sheds a tear.
I love how Rory just nods and points to Amy. Such a married couple .
😅 2:37 @@ptcreations8947
This was when the doctor had a family😢
Edit: I know a lot of people are bringing up Susan, and yes I do know about Susan, but I don't exactly mean an actual family, I mean that the relationship that 11 had with the ponds was really close and they really had a family dynamic because of the way they cared for each other, which is clearly shown when amy says that they always have a place set for him🥺 He has a family to spend Christmas with. Even though he has all of time and space he went right back to Amy and Rory... his family😭
Well, again, anyway.
There was his original family, back on Gallifrey, then his daughter Jenny, he did technically marry Marilyn Monroe AND Queen Elizabeth.
God, The Doctors family tree is really bloody confusing.
Only people with a complicated family tree close to it are Snow White and Regina from Once Upon a Time, Regina being Snow's stepmother but also the stepmother of Snow's grandson, making her grandson her stepbrother, which would make her own daughter her mother by proxy and....
Okay, no. My head hurts now. Once Upon a Time's Snow White has a WAY more complicated and confusing family tree than The Doctor.
He has had loads of family
But this one yh is actully relation as river married the doctor
But he also had one with rose
@@MichaelM28 yep, and since she was his granddaughter, one of her parents had to be The Doctor's kid.
I know about Susan she was his family too. Bit i don't just mean as in proper family I mean like the way they were with each other and how much they cared and loved each other. Even though he actually is their family it's not about that. It's about the relationship he had with the Ponds. In laws or not they will always be the doctors family. And that's why i love them so much and miss them even more😢
Well, she has a new "fam" now.
"Because we always do."
Jesus Christ the waterworks.
@@izzyallen2148 I personally like to think they don't just do it at Christmas, that they always have a place set for their 1200 year old son in law
"River told us.""Well of course she did.""She's a good girl!"
Rory is radiating obscene levels of dad energy in this scene and I love it
well I mean...He is the doctors father in law
@@incidentalreelz Exactly, it's perfect
It's the cardigan
David Tennant may be the favourite doctor for many but Matt Smith is always my favourite doctor
For me too
I didn't like 10th so much. He was too goofy and Wacky when he ain't Serious.
11th is My Favorite.
The Calm Childish act is total flip from his dark side when he was willing to do the dirty job was scary! Like that one guy He straight up killed with Homing Missiles (I won't say who)
Or Was willing to Get a Alien Butcher for Turning poeple into weapons or The Mind Flip with the Cyber Planner Or how much anger He expresses when Someone messed with his family...
I mean 10th is alright. But his Emotional range is meh compared to 11. Also 11 never kept anything of Rose that was of any significance. 11 has Amy's Glasses and Rory's BrotherHood.
He wasn't Just 11. He is *DOCTOR Pond*
Matt Smith’s tenure was the first I ever saw or even heard of doctor who and while I do like what other actors brought to the role I always find myself missing him.
I do think that ten and eleven would get along well though.
My friend introduced me with matt, he is THE doctor
1:33
“Because we always do” after she said that that’s when it hit him that they truly consider him part of their family not just a companion a friend but a family member.
Matt Smith is the only doctor who can actually make me cry cause i can feel his emotion through the TV. I miss him dearly, but he had a great run.
"And the lonely god realized, he was loved"
This scene almost broke my heart more than the rest of the episode.
I literally see you every time I watch Doctor Who on youtube
@@apexa903 Hehahe, cool!
*Hearts
1:50 poor Eleven looks so vulnerable when he realizes for the first time he has a family outside of the TARDIS that he came come to if he needs
And then they get zapped back in past :(
A part of me likes to pretend this takes place sometime after Angels take Manhattan. I know it doesn't but it makes it much better as a scene in my opinion.
@SoulSandStripe Gamer It does have some traction behind it since Amy and Rory have suddenly broken up in the next episode.
It might for him
Aman Network just rewatched it with that thought in my head and its 10x better
Aand... This hurts
No, it doesn't make this scene better. In this Xmas special The Doctor doesn't understood happy crying, because he doesn't have a family. At the end the episode he realized he has a family and finally happy tears came from him. This the scene The Doctor realized how important The Ponds meant for him. Because of this scene Amy and Rory's departure was so hard for The Doctor. Your theory is cool, but it's better to think this scene was happened before series 7.
I love that they actually treat him like a son-in-law, like a family member, lecturing him about the fact he hasn't shown up to visit in so long, guilt-tripping him, only to then admit that despite all of that, they still love him and were still happy to set a place for him, regardless of the fact they knew he would not come.
The “We always do” hits right in the feels!
This would have been the perfect 'last appearance' for Amy an Rory, rather than the contrived 'leave them somewhere so they don't die, just like Rose' setup.
One of my favourite scenes
Come back, Matt !!
We need u raggedy man, we need you...
Just popped in to say love your edits
Bring back 11, Amy and Rory!!! 😞
❤️
@Rajesh Kumar not while Chibnall and writing staff are there he doesnt
The Capaldi era will (probably) always be my favorite period of the new series (favorite Doctor, too), but I forgot how brilliant and lovable this TARDIS team is! When the Doctor finally realized he has a new family, it's just one of the most beautiful and heart-warming moments this show has ever produced!
1:36 that face. That face and that "oooh because we always do."
That made me cry
Matt, Karen and Arthur were just amazing together and with the addition of river it was just fantastic! I really miss this Doctor who. When it was more like a fairytale with characters that made me happy and made me cry😢😢😢
In the Tennant/Smith years, Dr Who always had a secret Lesson to be learned. Not so much now.
@@sandyqureshi4938 The secret lesson to be learned in some of the older New Who episodes where like shots of emotion injected straight into your heart. Now the "secret" lessons to be learned are like bricks being smashed into your face, with a side-helping of exposition, finger-pointing and guilt-tripping.
@@ethanjames0311 ^this is so accurate. But I guess no one would seem good after Moffat and RTD had been at it. I hope chibnall just resigns
@@misfitmuggle hope chibnall grows up to the job instead...
@@floppydisksareop I seriously hope he gets better writing wise.
The whole ‘always having a seat ready for him’ reminds me of when 11 finds out Brig died in the Nursing Home. The Brigadier always insisted that a glass be ready for the Doctor, in case he ever decided to pop by for a visit. ❤️ The Doctor has plenty of people who would welcome him with open arms if he ever felt the need to stop by. I’m happy Amy and Rory showed him that.
He makes the saddest companion death in my book
@@talaesparza124a little less sad when you realise a future incarnation of the doctor DID visit him
I love how Rory just casually says “not dead then?” as if it was something common. Like when you go to a party and someone says “oh you didn’t bring alcohol, that’s okay”
I mean he is the man who dies and dies again so death is kinda just another day in the life of for him
"I forgot to die" Clara
One of, if not my most favorite era of Doctor Who. Wasn't perfect, but moments like this helped it rank high on my list. The Ponds were my favorite companions and-maybe cause I'm a sentimental idiot-that might be because I just love wholesome family/friendship stuff.
Matt Smith was my favorite Doctor. Super hardcore fans of the show will find million arguments why he wasn't great, and call those who like him a dirty casual. But he was just so unpretentious. Effortlessly weird, lighthearted, and charismatic. Also, Amy and Rory are absolutely one of the best companions. In terms of character development they've come the longest way compared to anybody else IMO. And became just as important to the show as the Doctor himself.
always so happy cause he otherwise he would be so very very sad :c
Are you some sort of fool ? I've ever seen a bad review of Matt Smith ever ..he is pretty much lauded as the best new who ..what the Christ have you been drinking man? Show me one bad review of Smith and I'll show you a freezing cold hell
Bloody fool
I love David and Eccleston, and Peter a lot. But Matt's era was just magical. It brought that air of fantasy and living in a dream vibe that fits perfectly with The Doctor. He is The Docttor like the rest of em and whoever calls his fans casuals are just plain stupid
Honestly his interactions with his companions are my favorite of all the series. You can tell they all mean so much to him in everything he does and says
"She's a good girl!" She sounds so MOTHERLY when she says it...and the fact they both refuse to hug first.
We need more Doctor-companion interactions like this. More family, less "fam."
agreed!!!
100% correct
This scene shows how 11 is so much different than 10, Donna offered him a spot at the table during Christmas and he took off without even saying no
11 is a lot more social, not in the sense that he talks to people but that he is actually friends with his friends
Also 10 was still mourning Rose. Note that 10 did participate in Christmas dinner with Rose, Jackie and Mickey.
And you forgot how he accepted similar proposal from Jason Lake in the Next Doctor.
Christmas Dinner has a special part in The Doctor's heart. He spend his first one (as Tenth Doctor) with Rose, and he hold this dearly. He literally still hours after losing Rose when he met Donna. He couldn't enjoy another Christmas Dinner again until The (fake) Doctor invited him, which ironically also his last before his "death".
You have to remember he had just met Donna at this point and he even says that he had just lost rose which was his first Christmas dinner. He holds them very close to his heart. He hadn’t recovered yet
that was right after he’d lost rose, when they actually become friends in season 4 its very genuine
I like to imagine that Amy and Rory always set a place for The Doctor in case he tries (and possibly succeeds) to see them again even after The Angels take them
Oh absolutley. I'm sure they always had hope to hear that wheezing noise somehow someday
This is why Matt Smith is my favorite Doctor, especially with Amy and Rory. No matter what they were doing, whether it was exploring new galaxies, attending weddings, or just sitting on the couch watching TV together, they all had fun together.
1:36 The look of disbelief in his eyes.. I love this scene because it truly shows the Doctor just how loved and appreciated he is... He may be bombastic and overly confident but this scene kinda shows you how part of him is damaged and feels as though he deserves to be alone,
David Tennant and Matt Smith
They're the BEST
"So. You're not dead." "And a happy new year!" New Year's Eve atmosphere two years running now.
This is something I think is lacking in the show nowadays 0:42-1:17, moments where you feel these are people who know each other and have history instead of being just character walking through a plot. And if not this, just look at the Doctor and Jamie or the Doctor and Ace.
RoboticRob ACE!!!!!!!!!!
2000 years. 2000 years he finally realize he always have a home
not quite, he had a home with unit with 3rd and 4th! 1000 years before he found a home again, not 2
Good dialogue, real chemistry, believable acting, respectable story plot... No wonder the doctor was more popular back then
Exactly goddamnit
Yeah, David and Matt really did bring it into the modern era
No woke, tans or pronoun bullsh1t either. A huge plus.
@@steveross8364 Said by someone who's clearly never watched Doctor Who before. The show has always been progressive buddy, cry about it xD
@@RecordGuyJ You are an idi0t. I watched and supported Dr Who since Jon Pertwee's time, right up to Peter Capaldi's time. Yes the show has been mildly progressive before and that's ok but now the Woke gender sh1t is just too much and it's doing great harm - not only to society but to a franchise where it has no purpose being in the first place. If you want that in your programmes, put it in Eastenders where it's relevent to what's happening in realtime. DON'T put it in a sci-fi entertainment show where it ISN'T and cram it down the throats of people who don't want it in their escapism. This is why Dr Who ratings are TANKING and the franchise is DYING, not that I expect you to give a sh1t about that, sounds like you only care about pushing some agenda from your multi-colured soapbox.
This scene really does show how much they care for him and why it was so hard when he lost them. They were best friends and parents to him.
One of the reasons losing Amy and rory hurt him so much was because they were more than your typical companion. They accepted him into their family and loved him in a way he probably hadn't felt since his grand-daughter.
to me it always seemed like this moment not only hit the doctor as "i have a family", its a mix feeling of the sense of Christmas with family and friends, Matt smith also deliver a moment of "why didn't i come earlier" or "i was wrong about taking a step back"
and from the eyes of a time traveler who consistently run away from everything the feeling of "its ok to just sit and enjoy this moment HERE"
you mean " I have a family AGAIN" after how many centuries. We've seen his loneliness through the years many times, but to be able to rest again, wonderful. Remember he is a husband and a father and a grandfather, but not for a looooong time!
I felt bad for the doctor back then because we still thought he was alone and had no family...
"It's Christmas, you moron!"-- Maybe the most loving phrase in the entire series.
your not dead...
*AND A HAPPY NEW YEAR* XD🤣 :D
This is one of the millions of reasons why i love doctor who and why its my fave tv show :)
MERRY XMAS WHOVIANS😉😊😝😜😛🙃🍪
Ablin Reko stfu
Yes, Emoji officer, this one right here.
I love how the door has like a Tardis colour as well. ♡ Welcome Home Doctor. Its a home away from Home.
Wasn't a fan of this Special, but I loved the ending.
Same. This moment is pretty much the reason I was this Christmas special
Take your negativity elsewhere jackasss
@@vb8428 If you think thats negative you haven't been around some of the fans out there lately.
@@vb8428 Moron.
I think this is the weakest Christmas special, but this scene is the best scene in any of the DW Christmas specials ironically.
So sweet to see the doctor be a part of a family like this I love it
Uploading videos of previous Christmas specials, doesn't excuse the lack of one this year.
Although thanks for uploading, I like this bit!
They upload clips from old Christmas specials every year.
@@xandertoner yes this is my favourite bit
This scene, and taking Van Gogh to the museum... man, the Smith era of Who had some wonderfully emotional scenes... T-T
It's so heart warming to see his reaction... he realizes that no matter what happens, no matter what he does, they will always care about him.
Matt smith: was i a good doctor?
Fans: no you were the best.
Whoever disliked this is a Dalek
Or a Tennant/Rose fanboy.
More like a Cyberman.
Oi
Michael McGrath let’s face it you don’t like anything doctor who anymore
I bet it was Chibnall
1:44 This expression is so amazing. No matter how many times he put his friends in Danger and left them behind for their safety, they always welcome him to stay. He looked like a child who already accepted getting denied by them instead they waited for him to come home.
as the first doctor said
A HAPPY CHRISTMAS TO ALL OF YOU AT HOME
Why is no one talking about the 4 knocks the Doctor does?
He knocks in a rhythm of 4 knocks in a row, thought that was a nice throwback to David's era by Matt.
Please don't start
the first time I heard that I almost fell out of my chair
Of all the great Dr Who characters and actors, these three are my all time favorite.
I was alone for Christmas during the pandemic for the first time of my life and I watched this. My family had dinner on zoom but I watched this. It was a lifesaver.
This scene always makes me cry. The doctor is an ever-wandering traveler with no place to call home and nobody to call family. He has intimate connections with the people he travels with but none of them are family. In this scene, he realizes the Ponds consider him family, and he always has a home with them.
I love how she punishes him with the water gun. lol she does not care a single bit how powerful he is.
0:08 sees not carol singers but old friend
*0:20** squirts anyway*
*old friend who made her wait for years several times
ooooneeee “AND A HAPPY NEW YEAR”
@@ooooneeee 2 years is less than 2000
I always will defend that the Amy-Rory-Doctor relationship Arc is the best in all of modern Doctor Who.
Please come back Mat Smith.
Yeah Come Back PLEEEEEEEEASE
I honestly thought he would in season 11 when we saw the sneak peek featuring the fez and call for help that came with it
They're killing your show. We need you back.
@@autumbreeze1129 Yeah, I thought it might have been he who sent the fez. But atleast we can enjoy Matt's performance in the upcoming Star Wars movie next year!
No this show doesn’t look back and he was my fave. Although a cameo would be great x
I keep coming back to this and it just hurts
This ending is so special...the new doctors “fam” is absolutely nothing, nothing compared to this...this right here is pure raw love and what family looks like, the doctors face when he was hugging Amy was the look of love and of course when he realised they had already had a plate set for him I think that was what produced tears, in all that happened in the wedding of river song they always knew he would come back to them, especially at Christmas, this is a beautiful moment and only makes the ending of the angels take Manhattan even more brutal...
Matt is and shall always be my favorite Doctor. This scene with Amy and Rory definitely plucks at our heartstrings. This is how I will always remember them.
*"She's a good girl!"*
Awwh, Amy going mama bear is the cutest 💙
I loved it when they had a shot of the doctor in the doorway whilst also showing it from "the tardis's perspective" almost as if that was another home
The characters here are so 3 dimensional and actually are much more complex compared to the bland 2d characters we have in series 11. I miss moments like this. I guess with better story writing and character writing these moments could exist in series 11 but I doubt it will till the writer changes.
We need the doctor to degenerate back into 11
I just love how simple and wholesome this is. The Doctor just wanted to go round his friends house for Christmas. No big adventure or anything. He just wanted to spend Christmas with them, a man who “doesn’t do Christmas”
"So. You're not dead."
"And a happy new year!"
Watching this on 01/01/2021, that is very relevant.
It's almost that time of the year again
This moment lives rent free in my head
I love this scene so much... Especially taking the later episode from 12's run, Listen. In that episode we found out that The Doctor never really had a "family" and was made to sleep in the shed, because they thought he "would never be a Time Lord." This scene really hits home because for the first time in his life, he knows what it truly means to be part of a family.
One of my favourite ever scenes from one of my favourite Xmas specials.
The good old days, when the show was still recognizably “Doctor Who”.
Yeah it started to become something different around peter capaldi's run, I mean it was still doctor who but it started to become something weird but in my opinion it was still good. Than Jodie Whittaker came on and the whole show changed. No disrespect to Jodie but it just feels so weird and not doctor who, this new director is just not good in my opinion. It sucks because I love Jodie and want to give her a chance but the writing is just so bad. The only thing I like about this new series is the master but even that is bitter sweet.
@@ethanruzic8071 Honestly I think the thing about 12 is that he's in conflict with himself, the question for him is, is he a good man? that's the heart of his run, Despite his bad episodes you have to admit he's doing a good and moffat wrote him nicely as a character.
He has his up and downs but he does still feel like the doctor. Sad moments, Happy Moments, Grief, Everything. You can somewhat feel something when the companions say goodbye.
NOW WTF WAS I SUPPOSED TO FEEL WHEN RYAN AND GRAHAM LEFT?
They all felt blank during Series 11 and while I haven't watched series 12 cause I refuse to, it seems they're as blank there from what I've heard, And I watched the ending for them, There's no them emotionally damaged they want to leave or the doctor leaving them, THey just wanna live normal loves now.
Which I have no problem with but the fact is, It made me feel nothing, Not Empty, Not Sad, Not a bittersweet feeling. Just nothing!
This would have been fine if they left like that but I had absolutely no impact! Nothing No Emotion! Not even Anger i was just like.
Ok they gone now.
In all seriousness, YOu can at least feel the other companions goodbyes, It's sad for them, I even felt something when Martha left! Somehow! And she just said that she wanted to leave, MAybe its because I like her character? I dont know, Point is I feel nothing
@@ivandphantom9028 that’s pretty spot on
@@ivandphantom9028 On paper, Peter Capaldi's character arc was brilliant. My problem with him is that he played the Doctor as a sociopath in Season 8. Not merely socially awkward - watch his and Clara's "The cards" scene in Season 9 if you want to see Capaldi successfully pull off social awkwardness - but an actual sociopath whom the Valeyard and the Dream Lord would be proud to have in their regeneration cycle. Peter Capaldi's just not that great an actor despite being given the best character development. Actually, it's probably BECAUSE he was given the best character development. Steven Moffat really overestimated Capaldi's ability to deliver on the scripts that he gave him. People say that the writing is the problem and there are a lot of idiots who blame Clara for stealing the show throughout Season 8 but it's actually Capaldi himself who was the problem. If he was a better actor, Season 8 would be beloved. Seasons 9 and 10 proved that he CAN deliver great performances as the Doctor but he took far too long to reach that point.
John Hurt, who should have swapped places with Capaldi and been the 13th Doctor instead of the 9th, could have pulled off the "Am I a good man?" character arc without being a cold hearted bastard for 86% of his first season. Hell, he did exactly that in Day of the Doctor and did it better in a single episode than Capaldi did in his entire debut season. And yes, I did the calculations required to reach 86% because the precise moment where Capaldi stopped being a shitbag was after he finished ranting at Clara in Dark Water and decided to "Go to Hell" for her sake. Clara's betrayal was a long time coming because Capaldi had been treating her like trash for the entire season. Danny's death was the catalyst but even if he hadn't died, Clara would have had enough of Capaldi's bullshit eventually.
@tomnorton4277 Capaldi, not a great actor? My heart has been shredded, pulped, sifted and deep fried into bits of black burntness.
What about the speech that 12 gave in "The Zygon inversion"? Capaldi acted that scene SO WELL, what's more is that he did it all in 1 take.
Amy 'You're not Dead!'
Doctor 'AND A HAPPY NEW YEAR!'
I'M NOT CRYING SHUT UP!
Its rorys smile at the end that just perfectly finishes the scene it shows he isnt just following the doctor for amys sake etc and he to truly loves the doctor and is so happy to see him
God, I miss the Christmas specials. They didn't necessarily have to have a festive theme every year, but there's a big hole on Christmas Day without them, regardless of how great or cheesy they were.
Yes,yes,yes-~Amy and Rory were his real family and that's how I always viewed the Pond era. That triumvirate was truly special and I still miss them all.
Beautiful great moments like this is what doctor who requires to survive in Chibnall's era.
A family, the feeling of being with your family brought such an unfamiliar feeling of joy. That was his tear. It wasn't the tear that brought him confusion. It's the thought of for once in possibly a thousand years, he was home with a family of his own that loves him. A feeling he was certain he would never have again. That's why he looked at his tear in such a novel fashion.
I love this scene. So simple and so well executed. It's just a man, who has been alone for far too long, realising he already has the family he's craving. So poignant. I love it.
The finest companions that the Doctor ever had. Through all his centuries of travels, all his regenerations and countless human companions, none ever quite affected him the way that Amy and Rory did. They were truly special.
The best family that ever was or ever will be.
"We're about to have Christmas dinner, there's a place set for you."
"But you didn't know I'd be coming, why would you-"
"Because we ALWAYS set a place for you!"
@Ri Chester yes... but they never actually show how
whoever is running the show now, please bring Matt back, out of every doctor he knew how to make us smile and now with Jodie as the funny doctor now it would be perfect for them to both meet eachother.
Jodie is a terrible doctor (no offense to jodie or anything)
@@otakushutin It isn't that she is a bad actor, she just has a terrible writer. If RTD was still writing, or Moffat was still here, she would be better. You have a problem with the writer, don't scapegoat the actor. Besides, she kept the dress sense of the doctor intact.
Aydan Cooper imo she’s good, she’s no 10 or 11 but she’s good she just has a bad season, but Peter capaldi had a weak season and his finale is one of the best two parters with both masters and Cybermen.
@@andrewlocke9674 I really like Jodie's Doctor, but the largest flaw is the writing and the lack of huge, coherent overarching story. From day 1 of Matt we were wondering what the crack in the wall was, with 9th we had Bad Wolf (though that came later), etc, etc. I feel like a cool thing to play with for Jodie is that she's a free Doctor. She knows she didn't kill gallifrey, but since she's free, she doesn't know what to do. In the setup for tea at Yaz', she looks lonely and sad because she has nothing to do. She's free, but also bored.
@@otakushutin Jodie is only terrible because she is forced to carry out the propaganda and political views of BBC. With good scripts, some character development and logical build up the series can be saved. BBC can still bring in propaganda and political views, but as undertones and not as main focus. It works for Discovery, well most of the time as it did in the last two seasons of Capaldi.
The Lonely God isn't so lonely anymore
But he became lonely again. And now she is also lonely. Wonder if the 14th is going to be lonely
@@BanditLeader If there is a 14th in the near future, seems like it might get canned until a good writer shows up.
@@Valsorayu yeah chibnal and jodie are leaving after series 12. So hopefully we get a good writer for series 13 and a good 14th doctor
@Bandit Leader, Is it possible for the doctor to degenerate back into 11.
@@sandyc5822 reverse regeneration? Technically no. The doctor can have the same body as a previous regeneration, but the personality is always different
Has anyone else been recommended this in 2022, only to shed a tear at the heat being let out the house, rather than the touching story?
Did pass my mind 😂😂
When they say they always set a place for him it makes my heart melt
Matt stole my heart with each emotional scene he played. So so good