Champion Ice Climber Rates 9 Ice-Climbing Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Professional ice climber Will Gadd rates nine ice-climbing scenes in movies and television shows for realism.
He discusses the accuracy of ice-climbing techniques in "Game of Thrones" (2013), featuring v and Kristofer Hivju; mountain climbing in "K2" (1991); and mixed climbing in "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power" (2022), starring Morfydd Clark. He also comments on the ice axes, crampons, rope, and other climbing gear in "The King's Man" (2021), with Ralph Fiennes; "Vertical Limit" (2000); and "Jumanji: The Next Level" (2019), starring Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson and Karen Gillan. Gadd analyzes the realism of the ice and rock climbing displayed in "Alien vs. Predator" (2004), "Shivaay" (2016), and "The Climb" (2017).
Will Gadd is a professional Red Bull athlete, a speaker, and a guide. He has won three gold medals at the X Games and won gold at the Ice Climbing World Cup, and he is a four-time champion of the Canadian national sport-climbing championships. He was the first to ice climb Niagara Falls as well as the first to complete a one-day ascent of the tallest mountain in the Canadian Rockies, Mount Robson.
You can find him on social media at:
realwillgadd
gilwad
WATCH MORE HOW REAL IS IT VIDEOS:
Expert Survivalist Rates 10 Wilderness Survival Scenes In Movies And TV
• Expert Survivalist Rat...
Military Survival Expert Rates 9 Ocean Survival Scenes In Movies And TV
• Military Survival Expe...
Military Tank Expert Rates 9 More Tank Battles In Movies And TV
• Military Tank Expert R...
------------------------------------------------------
#IceClimbing #HowRealIsIt #Insider
Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.
Visit our homepage for the top stories of the day: www.insider.com
Insider on Facebook: / insider
Insider on Instagram: / insider
Insider on Twitter: / thisisinsider
Insider on Snapchat: / 2708030621
Insider on TikTok: / insider
Champion Ice Climber Rates 9 Ice-Climbing Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
“She seems really nice, but she is going to die” had my dying.
My fav mountain climbing movie K2 👍
"Look at all that metal she is wearing", Um yeah her plot armor is showing, wardrobe should have done a better job hiding it. 😆
Me too 💀💀💀
Someone forgot to tell Will that elves are immortal
"it's ok. It's pretty good...
3\10"
I love this man. Brutal. He's fun, he knows his stuff, and has no mercy lol.
Yeah, none deserved anywhere near a 5' on his scale.
Well, he certainly wants to nip misconceptions of climbing in the bud; shit's dangerous.
I think he misheard that he was spposed to rate on a scale of 10, not a scale of 5...
The editors confidently mis-labeling the tools when Will Gadd is describing the difference between technical tools and glacier axes at 11:20 is peak irony
It is great how he can find important concepts and situations from real ice climbing in the very unrealistic scenes.
"She seems very nice but she is gonna die" one of the greatest lines of all time
I love his comments: harsh and educational!
BS people don't live long in ice climbing. That's the people who got bored of rock climbing and survived.
@@voster77hh Well, he's been doing it for 40 years, and is one of the best. I've been doing it for over 40 years (but I'm no Will Gadd). I ain't dead yet.
Love Will, super knowledgable and funny at the same time.
"She's got chain mail on her head... She's gonna get frostbite" hahahaha
1:30 LOL, recently I watched a lot of climbing videos related to this topic and already knew what he was about to say 😂
This is epic Will!
Ok but how do you not get him to review Cliffhanger.
He stuck to vertical ice commentary mostly When you combine Rock and Ice, and the first full length movie since Eiger Sanction , plus Stallone, what do you expect but stupidity, inaccurate gear and inhuman acts of strength? Cliff Hanger is a farce.
Alex Honnold has these thick fingers, as all free solo rock climbers do.
Will Gadd's come a close second.
Where's the granddaddy, Eiger Sanction? Not exactly prolific ice climbing per se but definitely worth looking at in the context of some of these other (mostly silly) more recent excerpts.
I'd say it was really the first true full movie that used very accurate gear and climbing technique,, besides being almost a perfect account of what happened on the Eiger North Face back in the late 30's and has been written about in many books.
They had Alex Honnold do the Eiger Sanction in another one of these videos. He gave it a pretty good rating for showing accurate climbing techniques for the time period (early 70s?)
One of the few to actually give ratings that match with his commentary! Love it!
Wonder why Touching the Void wasn't included. It's the best mountaineering movie ever, though more a recreated documentary.
What about the movie Broad Peak?
As soon as I saw that Bollywood action movie at the end, I started rubbing my hands with glee.
This guy is só CHILL! HA!
To meet and ice climb with him was a great honor and an opportunity I'll never forget. A very chill dude and lots of fun
I cannot believe that "North Face" (2008)
is not included in this list.
I think he chose to leave out the REAL movies, the ones done very well, and based on historic events. Even the climbing in the Clint Eastwood movie back in '85 on the Eiger, was filmed and done very well with accurate gear and movements for the era,,as part of a spy thriller movie. Think Tom Cruise was influenced by Eastwood to take on the Mission Impossible climbing stunts?
Omg the crack effect in the HBO climbing looked so wrong, it was like a concrete wall was cracking not a wall of ice
His stories are so interesting! I would prefer to watch him about his climbing experience than reviewing the movies
talking about simul climbing and an ancient pic of mountaineers short roping flashes on the screen. Way to confuse everyone even more haha
I was actually taught not to dig in toes during self-arrest, at least not when you are wearing crampons. Your ankles are going to appreciate it and at least to me it is hard to imagine it will slow you down that much.
I Will only wanted him to dig in the toes of the boot without crampons. Loved that the dguy had one boot with and one boot without.
Even if your ankles take it, you're likely to either crumple at the knees and roll over or, worse, lock the knees causing you to pivot out as effectively a stiff object from the feet to the hips and that'll flip you over and throw you further away from the ground.
Our definitions of fun are not the same.
No STALLONE CLIFFHANGER???? How can you not have that movie?
So many flips beteeen ”oh that would never happen” and ”yeah I’ve done that” in the same movie XD
I was expecting "Everest" to be mentioned here...
Great video Thank you
Would’ve loved to see him comment on cliffhanger Mw2
Will Gadd is the man
Thank you 💖
fuckin love Will Gadd's accent eh? What a beaut.
At 11:36 the ice tool and the walking axe animations are mixed up.
this guy rules
Why was everest not on here. Sounds like part 2 to me.
Interesting
i never thought they would include a bollywood film like "Shivaay"
Actually mountain sheep are that good you would be very surprised geographic has a good show on them I think that shows you what they can do and it would blow your mind way better than any human could hope to be.
"Hi. I'm Will. From Canmore."
This guys sounds like if Owen Wilson became an ice climber
he rates the authenticity of climbing scenes in fantasy movies😂 come on man
Anyone knows the name of the route he is talking about in France ?
Awweeeee. I was looking forward to seeing Cliffhanger.
Concerning the Lord of the Rings sequence, Will did not take into consideration that the climbers were elves. Elves are fleet of foot, and have very different strength to body weight ratios.
"Why are her sunglasses on her head" Well this is a bit of a pet peeve for me actually. When making big films with actors they pay a lot of money for they REALLY want to show their faces uncovered because well. They paid for that face and they think that'll make people watch it more. Like perfect make-up on women in apocalypse movies. So out of place and unrealistic but the studios want it
Is this guy also an elf expert? How does he know what they are capable of?
For those that are unfamiliar, Will Gadd is like the Roger Federer of ice climbing. He's an absolute legend.
Thanks! I didn't know him before, now I do, and how great he is.
Kinda figured when they showed the scene at 4:20 of the movie character jumping from one cliff to another and he casually just goes like "oh yeah I've done stuff like that"
Is Roger Federer somebody like Will Gadd just not in ice climbing?
I don't know who Roger is except that his name is half R's
@@Dayvit78 He's one of the top tennis players in the world, you probably saw him on TV and didn't know who he was.
Will is truly great. On a technical note the animator confused the technical axes and the mountaineering axe. Probably because they did not have a Nomic in the movie but an older style of axe.
Yeah haha i noticed that
Was one of the older ones a Stubai hammer?
Animator?
Animator in this case means: the person who put the arrow indicators on the screen.
You guys do a great job at getting people with the proper information and conveying it so well.
More Will Gadd please! Absolute legend
And less Red Bull please!!!
A very witty and humourous fellow. Please, more of him. My favourite: "You'd see 2 arms hanging"
At 11:33 the video editors got the shots of the ice tool mixed up with the general mountaineering axe. The explanation is great, so just know that the pink axe is the general mountaineering axe (it has an adze, which is like a small shovel), and the beige ice tool (with hammer). The stock photos of the tools are correctly matched up though, so that's nice.
Noticed this and went to the comments to ensure I wasn't the only one hahaha.
except that the "Ice Tool" is from like the 60's (1960's at least) so laughable as a real tool these days.
@@CanyoneeringUSA More like the 80s/90s.
What a guy. I've always had my reservations with such scenes based on physics and human body resilience alone but it's great to hear someone experienced spit the facts. Thanks!
U know you made it in your field when u can go on insider to rate movies
You've really nailed it with the experts lately. Keep up the good work!
This guy is incredible! Y'all do such an awesome job finding experts for these videos. Like y'all really do your research. When I watch these on things i know nothing about (much like this) I'm always enthralled. Kudos! Will, you're awesome!
Wow! I can't be the only one that thinks Will looks a bit like Owen Wilson, right?
I was scrolling looking for this comment!!
@@carrotsgirl1D Not all the time, but certain angles... it helps that he's wearing a hat. His hairstyle could totally change my perception.
Would love to see him discuss "The Eiger Sanction" starring Clint Eastwood. There is some mad ice climbing stuff in there.
I only clicked to see if y’all actually made him put on all his ice climbing gear for this video 😂
So fun! Thanks Will. And Insider - excellent choice of talent!
A very long time ago, when I hadn't used up my body entirely. I loved mountaineering. I ice climbed for fun. It wasn’t anywhere near as evolved as it is now. Every now and again, when I'm feeling nostalgic I’ll dig out a picture of me ice climbing. Typically they’re distant photos of me in a yellow jacket, or a red one, with my crampons dug in, and an ice axe in each hand, a sling of ice screws, a 60 meter wet/dry rope threading down, and a pair of Bausch and Laumb glacier glasses shoved on my face. And the best part? I have this huge smile on my face becauseI'm truly happy! I'm not thinking about a d@mned thing but ice climbing. Not bills, changing my oil, or anything else, just ice climbing.
Ice climbing and parachuting worked the same for me. If I was doing either activity, that's the only thing I thought about. Not one other thing. Anyway, thanks, Will Gadd, you also brought up my favorite climbing movie of all time, K2!!!! I love that movie! I even took my daughters to see it at the theater. One reason for that was K2 was my dream climb. But K2 the movie is great, starring Michael Biehn said Matt Craven.
Thanks again, Will Gadd. Great video, I've had a lot of fun. And Will, be safe, be well, and be happy!
14:40
Shivaay ... that's a Bollywood movie...
Will Gadd-the absolute best-obviously as a climber, but also as an analyst.
Seeing shivay on the list threw me off😂😂
That Lord of the Rings ice climbing scene is a real place . . . Inside a computer.
They actually built that wall. It's a real set
Not to nitpick, but when he was talking about self arresting during the clips of Vertical Limit, you DO NOT want to dig your toes in. You’re meant to firmly grab your ice tool with both hands and put as much weight over that point of contact as you can.
If you dig your feet into the ice you risk your momentum flipping you over your feet and going from being on your stomach to your back….
me watching a movie: oh I know that Actor.
this dude watching a movie: Hey look, that's my friend there.
LOL
I dont give a fu bout climbing, but its real pleasure to hear that guy
“She seems nice, but…she’s gonna die.” 😂😂
At 2:42
As a mountaineer myself I've been taught to never dig your toes in if you're wearing crampons as that's a fantastic way to break your ankles and flip over, pushing your knees into the snow instead. I suppose if you're not wearing crampons it's fine but I definitely wouldn't do it with them.
Yep I was taught the same thing, that had me confused too. He also called out the axes in alien v predator, they are Grivel alpwings, i have used them for ages and they are great, not sure what his point was😂
@@freddydorling9548 That's correct if you're glissading down or falling on softer snow. Generally speaking you can raise your feet trying to touch your butt so your front points dont catch, but if you're falling on Neve or worse, ice, you'd rather have the broken ankles than be dead.
That's correct if you're glissading down or falling on softer snow. Generally speaking you can raise your feet trying to touch your butt so your front points dont catch, but if you're falling on Neve or worse, ice, you'd rather have the broken ankles than be dead.
@@Devoted96 Correct me if i'm wrong, but if you dig your tips in and flip onto your back, aren't you even less likely to stop. I personally think we are taught self arresting because it is the best way to stop a fall. In a situation with mature neve or ice, where there is any risk of falling, or it is particularly exposed, I would hope most would rope up up and climb the difficulty as a pitch.
I could well be wrong, and I would love to be corrected, as it may save my life next time!
@@Devoted96 I agree, in the worst case you do what you can to survive, however I can imagine that it is near impossible to keep yourself upright when braking with your toes at higher speeds so the danger of flipping is still there. I've never tried it though, and I really hope I don't have to😅
Every time I watch anything about mountain climbing, ice climbing, caving, scuba diving etc I just think but why??? 😣😳 but hey power to those brave enough to do those things for fun! And I will just watch from the safety of my couch and freak out haha.
Dude’s knowledge paired with his wit and earnest/ easy going demeanor made this such a fun watch. I belly laughed at his response to the GOT scene “that rope would’ve cut him in half” 😂
Super ironic that at 11:27 Will tries so hard to explain the difference between a ice tool and a mountaineering axe and Insider still fucked up the diagram😂. The first shown was a straight shaft axe and the second was a ice tool.
Agree. the arrow was pointing to the opposite tool as he was describing the difference.
Probably one of my favorite series on TH-cam, love these
15:48 His Harness is on backwards! hahahhahhaha!!!
It doesn't have straps either. He had a ballet session in front of the greenscreen
🤣🤣
😆😆
my dad has done a fair bit of ice climbing in his younger days, and I admire and respect him more than any other person I know, and I also think people who ice climb are completely insane
I love Shivaaya. The whole movie was cool... I know it's impossivle for that mountain descent to happen, but it's a really entertaining to watch. The storyline isn't half bad either.
This dude is so much fun with his personality, haha I could watch him talk and laugh about stuff all day hahaha
If Conan O'Brien and Richard Gere had a child
I feel if you're flying laterally mid air and try to stick a knife into ice, newton's laws means you're more likely to just throw yourself backwards into thin air than plant the knife in solid right?
A bit--a small of the force will be absorbed by the ice and even more if you actually get it to go in, but because it's a knife, you're likely to just bounce right out of the hole the knife made. That's why real tools are little jagged scythes. Taking them out requires lifting and turning--they go down and into the surface in a curved way.
@@Jingoa A small amount of force will be exerted in the ice sure, but most of the energy would be pushing you away from the ice as there is very little resistance holding you in place.
Dude could be Owen Wilson's stunt double in a future ice climbing movie!
Will is no joke! I got to climb with both him and Barry Blanchard at Mountainfest 2003 in the Adirondacks. I watched Will climb 90' of ice with only no ice tools, only wool mittens! Frickin Legend! 💪🏽
This is probably the best geust they have had lol
Next vid: Professional Ice Climber Rates IC Combos in Smash Bros Melee
That LoR terrain is not real or based on a real world landscape unfortunately.
4:40 ikr. as far as he fell, if the ice tool were tied to his wrists, would his arms tear off?
Depends on what breaks first, the tie strap or the tendons. Survivability basically zero. Generally speaking tendons or straps have very little bungee effect. Means fall of 2 or 3 feet is good enough to rip ones arm out of the shoulders and off. The only option is you already hand on that single tool with 1 tool and 2 feet coming off. once you accelerate only a dynmaic climbing rope can bungee cord you. On your great-grandparents hemp rope anything more than 2 to 5 feet snags either the rope or breaks body parts. it would only catch a short slip and slide. If you see olympic artists swing on bars then the bars do flex a lot and absorb most of the energy and help convert it into rotation. Crash landing with a braking distance close to zero isn't a very healthy idea. Even if you don't rip your arms out, your climbing day is immediately over. Probably your climbing days for life. Plus your troubles only start there. Shock, dehydration, hypothermia... You need to be heli rescued out or carried / rappled out on a stretcher. You move absolutely nowhere on your own anymore in vertical territory totally hostile to human life. Rope rescue on a vertical face of thousands of feet is a multi-people ardous time consuming effort.
To be fair. Dr Smolder Bravestone would have no trouble getting the axe out again. He'd look at the ice and it would melt..
“She seems very nice…”
She is in fact not nice . 😂
they really did Galadriel dirty with that writing.
@@blarfroer8066 Honestly though what a steaming pile. I stopped watching about half way through the third episode. What a waste of time.
Loved this guy ❤ couldn't stop laughing.... Fell of my chair when he said i climed ice with steak knife
Totally seemed like he wanted to say fck those sheep 😂
"She seems very nice, but she is going to die." - Serial Killer
Bruh when the shivayy one came up. Cringee.
for what f*ck that jumpy guy has harness?
he can jump everything
Rock climbing in movie is also most of time unrealistic, movie tends to make it looks super dangerous most of time, this ends up with stupid safety measure or impossible moves.
Damn nice
5:26 she seems very nice but she is going to die😂
Love it, realism.
Those movies are nice entertainment but nothing another, just entertainment.
7:40 Jim West (''wild wild west'' 70s TV show) lent him his knife-boots😂
This guy is freaking hilarious...
😅
It's great to see his lighter side. 'On the job', when instructing or doing his own climbing, he's all business.
Congrats to all who is early and found this comment 🌟
Jesus loves you!
Believe in His death and resurrection and repent of your sins and be saved!
Remember that He died and rose up again for you to be in heaven with Him!
Have an amazing day ❤️❤