The original version: the pain and sorrow are etched deep into the soul because of everything that is experienced as if life will be taken away forever together all those beautiful and sad memories 2018: felt all those pain because you are now letting everything go even if it hurts, hence felt that shallowness and the empty soul felt as if it was gone a long time ago So both are beautiful and are portraying two different types of pain and sadness
You show a clear performance improvement and I prefer either version depending on the mood or day. It's mostly that I've listened to your first one so many times that there's some sentimental value there just to purposely go back to that specific video because it's helped me during one of the hardest times in my career. Thank you so much.
( not a white knight more like a concerned idiot) When you work hard and improve your singing but people prefer the way you sang before when other people were complaining about the white noise because it's too "clean". I enjoyed the song and respect the effort you made to improve please don't take the less constructive comments to heart . People (just like many Tokyo ghoul songs portray) will judge you based on what they think is true not what actually is. This song is not necessarily leaps and bounds over the other one ( an opinion) but i very much believe you improved in every conceivable way from the first one, and i couldn't find a single lack of emotion (cause i wouldn't know sounded the same if not better)...…..yet i can understand how it might have sounded more raw and impactful without higher vocals, better tech, and personal emotions felt during the first. But that's purely opinionated and technically an improvement on you as a singer and your range or just natural. In summary i apologize for the rant and any undue stress just wanted to say how i feel and that you have fans that didn't just stay for a one-shot but for a artillery barrage and the smoke that dissipates after, till you move on to something else either out of need or inspiration. Wish you strength, wisdom and courage! ( you don't need luck just faith, unless you want that to than here yah go) i.pinimg.com/736x/6d/e7/9c/6de79caf3041d5a678380013557b9341.jpg BYOTIFUL :3
Have to agree with some of the comments that the original was better (even w/ all the flaws and white noise). The higher range of your voice here seems forced, thin, and a bit too "clean" or "perfect." The original was lower and had roughness but that added to the emotion, like it was really coming from someone broken down. I think your lower range is part of what gives your singing a certain richness/texture - if that makes sense.
I have to say, I liked the old one better. Your voice was steadier and had more emotion. This feels a bit... shakey, I guess. A bit emptier in comparison.
Asia C. I agree.but don't you think this voice is much better for white silence like. There's a part a me that says it's better with this voice. Although I like the other one.
the rythm not sync since you using direct translation for Google translate for example it should be: I maybe fall again down into my heart deep into night it dream more I can reach right before I can wake...huuuhuuuhuuuu~ something like that...
The original version: the pain and sorrow are etched deep into the soul because of everything that is experienced as if life will be taken away forever together all those beautiful and sad memories
2018: felt all those pain because you are now letting everything go even if it hurts, hence felt that shallowness and the empty soul felt as if it was gone a long time ago
So both are beautiful and are portraying two different types of pain and sadness
tsun tsun
omg 0:53 those ahhhhhs hit me really deep in my soul i got shivers like damn... amazing
You show a clear performance improvement and I prefer either version depending on the mood or day. It's mostly that I've listened to your first one so many times that there's some sentimental value there just to purposely go back to that specific video because it's helped me during one of the hardest times in my career.
Thank you so much.
I resonated with you on this. I felt the feelings in this. Keep up this work.
*"..and i can recall.. all the words i long forgot.."*
Absolutely beautiful. Love both covers.
Oh My God!!
Muchas gracias por esta canción y tú hermosa voz, saludos desde Argentina.
Thanks for the song, i really liked it. Both versions are awesome i really love this song and your voice.
Best Version
BEAUTIFUL VOICE ❤
finally yessssssss
i love your voice
I like your other version better!
amazing just as good as the old one! ❤😀
I am hearing in Korea . thx!
well the first version i had on loop for weeks on end now i guess its happening again cos it just sounds really great (yeap im that odd ^.^)
( not a white knight more like a concerned idiot)
When you work hard and improve your singing but people prefer the way you sang before when other people were complaining about the white noise because it's too "clean". I enjoyed the song and respect the effort you made to improve please don't take the less constructive comments to heart . People (just like many Tokyo ghoul songs portray) will judge you based on what they think is true not what actually is.
This song is not necessarily leaps and bounds over the other one ( an opinion) but i very much believe you improved in every conceivable way from the first one, and i couldn't find a single lack of emotion (cause i wouldn't know sounded the same if not better)...…..yet i can understand how it might have sounded more raw and impactful without higher vocals, better tech, and personal emotions felt during the first. But that's purely opinionated and technically an improvement on you as a singer and your range or just natural.
In summary i apologize for the rant and any undue stress just wanted to say how i feel and that you have fans that didn't just stay for a one-shot but for a artillery barrage and the smoke that dissipates after, till you move on to something else either out of need or inspiration.
Wish you strength, wisdom and courage! ( you don't need luck just faith, unless you want that to than here yah go) i.pinimg.com/736x/6d/e7/9c/6de79caf3041d5a678380013557b9341.jpg
BYOTIFUL :3
Deus ex Machina Ah thank you so much. I feel very much the same way but I try to be open minded. I will try to keep singing!
Agreed
Yeah
Have to agree with some of the comments that the original was better (even w/ all the flaws and white noise). The higher range of your voice here seems forced, thin, and a bit too "clean" or "perfect." The original was lower and had roughness but that added to the emotion, like it was really coming from someone broken down. I think your lower range is part of what gives your singing a certain richness/texture - if that makes sense.
pftq that makes sense! I think the tone sounds a bit too happy.
i miss tokyo ghoul
💔 Bye Bye Kaneki
I have to say, I liked the old one better. Your voice was steadier and had more emotion. This feels a bit... shakey, I guess. A bit emptier in comparison.
Asia C. I agree.but don't you think this voice is much better for white silence like. There's a part a me that says it's better with this voice. Although I like the other one.
Arham Shams Sameer it's much better because it's jagged and empty that's the voice that suits white silence. Wouldn't you agree.
facts bro
Agreed
Well, I feel broken
Me gusta más las versión anterior. Aunque esta también esta linda pero prefiero la anterior
Reason to stay alive XD
the rythm not sync since you using direct translation for Google translate
for example it should be:
I maybe fall again
down into my heart
deep into night
it dream more I can reach
right before I can wake...huuuhuuuhuuuu~
something like that...
I am a sad boi