Both of them posses a different tessitura..Comparing them is a total bias technically..Siti is a mezzo, Jac is a soprano..Jac upper belts starts from E5 to Bb5..While Siti her upper belts starts from D5 to F5..Siti is not a high mezzo..But you cant deny Siti has the best midbelt in Malaysia even some of the best in Asia..As both has aged, they are 39 if im not mistaken..Correct me if im wrong..Siti has sing through out her 22 years in industry with excellent technic, maintaining her solid 3 octave vocal range, A2 - A5..She just gets better and now her midbelt is definitely her forte..Better lower register, she sounds so comfortable now reaching as low as C#3..The only thing now Siti does not really develop her headvoice eventhough she has good control over it, listen how she jumps between registers effortlessly in Kurniaan Dalam Samaran and Love On Top..As for Jac, everyone knows shes a vocal beast, especially in upper belts..Shes the best belter to date in our country..Its just Jac enter the industry 10 years later after Siti..Jac herself admit no one will ever replace Siti as the finest singer Malaysia ever had and Siti admit Jac is the best belter we ever had..Both of them admiring each other..Both posses unique quality..I might sound bias by preferring Siti more, I do love Jac, no doubt..But for Jac to achieve Siti, is still far..Siti is already a master of her own craft..Siti is now recognised as one of the top 10 asia best singer, the one and only from Malaysia..Jac still can learn many things from Siti..I hve no doubt Jac can be as great as Siti, i trust her talent..Aubrey Suwito, definitely knows these two songbirds and Aubrey admit Siti is the best in Malaysia..Aubrey said, Siti definitely can go higher but she respect her limit and plays her range very well..Thats explain her longevity and how she still can sings her oldies without problem and sounds much better..Yeah she sings lower key now, her voice has aged and deepened, showing much tonality quality of a mezzo..You cannot deny, after 20 years, Siti is the only vocalist that maintain her supported belting range from A4 - F5..Listen to her Bersandar Cinta live in DFP with Aubrey Suwito, its a belted F5 in mix voice, balance mix and she still nails the note after 22 years..Thats the quality of a star vocalist..Siti once said " I dont go for a higher belted just to show off my range, im a melodramatic singer and singing higher is not my preferrence "..
Secretzsongbird i think jaclyn is definitely as great as siti vocally. Jaclyn is a spinto which automatically made her more powerful than siti. From that video, we can clearly see that jaclyn is not all about high belts only, her mid belts are just as powerful and so resonant. I think jaclyn’s midbelts are better than siti’s. But siti’s voice probably aged better than jaclyn’s. I heard siti’s F5 in Bersandar Cinta, it’s definitely not a high belt cause it’s too soft, so it’s probably a masked head voice.
Starry Eyes In any placement, either mask or mix, its still has support and Siti does has support for her belt..Jac is better in midbelt? She might sounds stronger due to her tessitura but technically Jac still lag behind Siti..Siti's dynamic and versatility is second to none in Malaysia, thats a fact..Being a soprano doesnt mean the singer is better or the best..
Secretzsongbird it’s not her tessitura, it’s her vocal type that makes her more powerful. But it’s also evident that Jaclyn’s belt sound more open, resonant and very much ringing to the ears. But yeah siti has more dynamic.
What are you talking about. Siti is NOT A MEZZO, shes a lyric soprano, obviously. Technique wise siti is able to support and resonate up to Eb5, while jaq only able to support up to D5 as evidently shown here. Headvoice wise, siti’s is more developed than Jaq’s and so is her lower register. However her problem is her mix, she cant mix properly beyond Eb5 and started straining and losing support. While jaq has better mix and placement although not supported beyond D5 however she’s capable of belting up to a G#5/A5 but with very high larynx and tightening of her vocal chords.
Aku pilih jaclyn victor..siti suara nyaring sesuai lagu melayu dgn indonesia je..pondan mudah tiru..Jaclyn punya suara lantang lagu english pun sesuai..org susah tiru
Mana bisa Siti di bandingkan dengan jeclin.jeklin lengking bgt.. Siti lengking nya lembut pas.rendahnya pas Paser nya pas... Ngk berlebihan.itu mknya semua jenis lagu bisa dia bisa bawakan.. jeklin tinggi ngk bisa semua bisa dia bwakn... Beda ngk bisa di bndingknn
Tak sesuai vs siti ngn jac...sb keduanya berbeza suara..siti lembut jac lantang dan tinggi...siti suara dia versatile boleh bawa pelbagai genre sedangkan jac terhad sesuai lagu pop saja
bnr sekali klo. jac ini hanya di nada tinggi saja kerenya tp klo siti dari nada bawa sampai tinggi semua indah jd ga sesaui di bandingkan. tp jac ini nada tingginya bnr2 padet bgt yaas cocok bgt di bagian teriak.
Menda kau merapu ni? Apsal fans Siti ni suka sangat over claim ek? Siti versatile? Dia sesuai untuk lagu² Asia jenis yg melenggok, meleweh dan mendayu saja.. Muzik/genre West dia hauk, cover lagu² English pun ke laut sebab over meleweh.. Jac forte dia ballad, pop, classic, r&b, jazz & soul.. Celah mananya dia just satu genre saja lol
siti bila belting kita rasa mcm xbelting pon sbb suara dia tone dia yg lembut ( seem easy) berbeza dgn jac bila tarik rsa jantung nk luruh but more powerful.
Jaclyn Victor is Sohyang version of Malaysia! Walaupun berlainan jenis suara tetapi dua2 nya sama hebat & mereka berdua salah satu penyanyi terhebat Malaysia. Tapi kalau diberi pilihan, sy nak pinjam suara Jaclyn.
Dari segi vocal dan personality, I minat sgt tokti dari zaman beliau muda remaja, but personally I think after dia keluar SRC, dia pilih nyanyi mostly lagu yg vocally safe safe je dlm album dia (adalah killer songs satu dua tu). But jac pula has always been consistently good with the vocal.
Saya lebih suka warna suara dan teknik Jacklyn victor, meskipun di Indonesia orang lebh banyak yg tahu Siti Nurhaliza.. tapi aku lbh pilih Jacklyn Victor
I think their vocal type is different. To compare both of them is like comparing between banana and apple. One is soprano and clearly the range is wider and the other one is mezzo soprano. Jac has similar vocal type with idayu af, as with siti and misha omar Nonetheless, both are great performers. In terms of diversity and dynamics, i prefer siti nurhaliza. Brilliant singer who knows her range very well. No pun intended.
Are we comparing singer or vocalist? To be a greatvsinger is not just about who can sing higher note, but more than that is who can sing with emotion, deliver the message, stage perfomance and do it with effordlessly .. and Sit is second to none .
Jac suaranya lebih internasiomal love Jac from Indonesia and she more creative with her note and suara Jac lebih tinggi dari pada Siti cos Siti cuma 2 octave
@@waksentotchannel lah saya tak tanya siapa yang menang penghargaan terbanyak LOL, kalau kamu lebih suka suara Siti is ok itu selera kamu saya tak bilang Siti jelek tapi kalau saya lebih suka suara Jac itu selera saya terus masalahnya apa? Dan yg saya bahas dari vocal range bukan penghargaan dan video ini soal belting mangkanya menurut saya Jac menang cos suara Jac lebih tinggi bisa belting dengan mudah
No way jac is light lyric. She is maybe full or spinto bcoz her output r big and becomes bigger when hit high notes. While light couldt have big output.
For me siti juara always song sebap apa... Dia nynyi tak kosong ada rasa... Walau pun suara dia tk setinggi jac2 nynyi tinggi tapi kosong penjiwaan.. Nya... Siti verstile... Nk jadi artis bukan hanya perlu suara tinggi.. Saja...bagi aku almost penynyi dlm malaysia siti masih menjuarai... Blm ada lagi org boleh makan line dia evant jac sekali pun tengelam timbul.. Klu btl bagus.. Kenapa tk buat show sendiri... Sebap? Jac kekuarangan lagu singel... Siti.. Berapa banyak singel dia... Dan selalu buat tuor.... Siti asian... Bukan kt malaysia je bahkan sekarang international pun... Kenal....tak lama lagi siti bakal dapat biduan wanita...
nada suara berbeza dgn kemantapan yg sama..jac dgn powerful dan siti dgn soft nya..keduanya best,bosan dengar suara siti pindah ke jac,bosan dengar suara jac pindah ke siti..pake earphone utk dengar lebih nyaman keduanya..
Both of them .Ada kelebihan masing masing ...Tpi sye lebih memilih belting dan highnote ranges serta lownote and shifting Siti ...Merdu untuk didengar telinga kanan dan kiri ...Jac sye minat pada highnotes dia , highnotes ramai penyanyi yg bleh buat .Tpi nk sedap didengar telinga ..Only Siti can do that sambil senyummm ..Tk fhm mcm mne dia bleh buat mcm tu ❤️👍 Jac suara tinggi dan lantang hanya sesuai pada lagu pop dan english sahaja . Siti ni suara yg unik dan verstyle ..Dia bleh menyanyi dalam pelbagai genre lagu dan english song .
Sekarang ni x kisah part2 tinggi tu.. Apa yg penting kawalan lower dan high register dgn baik... Kat malaysia siti PHD dlm bidang ni walaupun dia mezzo soprano... Jac win part belt highnotes dan part low dia masih kurang sikit(still ok) ...
Eb5 and above - jaclyn’s is full of resonance. Siti’s is adventurous for her fans because she doesn’t do that so often D5 and below - i love how siti does it she seems to know that fact. Lol. This range sounds like jaclyn’s personal midrange, at least to me haha
Lol no. Jaq stopped consistently supporting and resonating at D5. Beyond this she lost support and started straining. Although at Eb5 she still have some support present but she’s losing resonance . While siti is able to fully support her Eb5 and resonate. Beyond E5 she flopped coz her mix is very underdeveloped and straining so much due to pushed chesty mix and bad placement. Jaclyn has better mix and better placement for the upper belt but she don’t support it (although sometimes support can be present at E5 but very inconsistent as her larynx position is high and tight vocal chords). Jaq has higher belting range, but siti has larger vocal range.
@@yureino jaclyn Eb5 and above it is support but not resonance compare to CT Eb5 which is resonance...CT mix her voice well balance meanwhile jaclyn mix voice is chest dominant that why it sound like straining and that stop her from producing resonance and her placement on Eb5 above is not that good but that doesn't block her support system...CT mix voice is consider the best in the country and well develop too...even a good mix voice has a limit to reach high note so it is not underdeveloped
jonathan jonis No. Jaq doesn’t support anything above E5. Jaq simply has higher tessitura thats why she can go higher. Although her belt is still chesty, but she’s able to engage more head mix into her belt. And if she’s straining with high larynx, how could she be supporting her notes? Thats not how support works. A mix is like a spectrum. From a chesty mix, to balanced mix, and to heady mix. Siti is able to show mixing skill to a balanced mix, however she could not engage with her heady mix. Having a good mix will allow you to hit higher notes, only difference from singer to singer will be the volume and the quality of the belted mix. While jaq could not also fully engage with her heady mix, but she have a higher tessitura and better placement allowing her to hit higher notes with better heady-chest ratio in the upper belt.
Salah vs ni..siti kne banding dengan sharifah aini..sbb dua2 artis genre tak sama..aku suka dua2..kne bandingkan dengan style suara yg tone lebih kurang
Eat Some Corn lol. I doubt you understand anything about resonance. Siti only supports (hence resonates) down to E3. She has never hit a C3. The lowest she’s done is C#3, but it’s very airy, slightly low larynx and not centred. Hence not supported. Her belts are also very chesty above E5-F5, which a mezzo would have a problem hitting with such chesty quality and fuller sound. If anything, her vocal tone and timbre scream lyric soprano.
Songsource Well first you have to prove your credibility first. I’m not making up whatever I’m saying. I read through her wikipedia plus vocal blogs. She’s a mezzo. She’s just good at mixing. Look at her voice now. It is a well rounded tone and range of a mezzo. Beyonce is a mezzo but she has hit upper chest voice numerous times with good mixing technique. You know nothing girl!
Eat Some Corn LOL. Beyonce is a highly skilled vocalist. Her upper belts are hit with balanced mixed belt to heady belt, not chesty like what siti is doing. Beyonce is able to hit down to a G2 which what normally a good mezzo capable of doing and consistently support a C3/C#3 with neutral larynx. Siti HAS NEVER HIT A C3 Live. Her lowest is a C#3 which is very airy and with low larynx. A mezzo would sound fuller at lower register. Beyonce’s voice is fuller and has a dark undertone to her voice. While siti’s voice is bright, light and feminine. Gosh, you really think Wikipedia is a credible source? Kid, are you new to the internet? Barely any credible source has ever analysed siti’s vocal type. If you dont even know how to classify vocal type, understand the terms such as resonance, support, placement, timbre, tessitura, passagio etc, I advise you not to be too confident with what you read online.
Songsource Do you even think there is only one type of box of mezzo? Learn about vocal fach dude. Every type of mezzo has different tessitura and range not only voice quality. Siti is Lyric Mezzo at best for me. And please are you that credible to testify her vocal fach?
Ct dah cater audiens dkat london, japan, australia, china, hongkong, kazakhstan, filipin, indonesia, singapore, thailand, brunei. So?????????? Funny la hater mcm ko ni.. oppss da namanya hater kan. Fakta tetap fakta. Org tetap kenal siapa siti nurhaliza.
Tk payah nk vs ² lah lain penyanyi lain gaya Siti tetap Siti ok, bkn tak suka apa perasaan kita kalau org banding² kan kita dgn org lain ada akal fikirlah ye... 3/12/19 ✌️
Both of them posses a different tessitura..Comparing them is a total bias technically..Siti is a mezzo, Jac is a soprano..Jac upper belts starts from E5 to Bb5..While Siti her upper belts starts from D5 to F5..Siti is not a high mezzo..But you cant deny Siti has the best midbelt in Malaysia even some of the best in Asia..As both has aged, they are 39 if im not mistaken..Correct me if im wrong..Siti has sing through out her 22 years in industry with excellent technic, maintaining her solid 3 octave vocal range, A2 - A5..She just gets better and now her midbelt is definitely her forte..Better lower register, she sounds so comfortable now reaching as low as C#3..The only thing now Siti does not really develop her headvoice eventhough she has good control over it, listen how she jumps between registers effortlessly in Kurniaan Dalam Samaran and Love On Top..As for Jac, everyone knows shes a vocal beast, especially in upper belts..Shes the best belter to date in our country..Its just Jac enter the industry 10 years later after Siti..Jac herself admit no one will ever replace Siti as the finest singer Malaysia ever had and Siti admit Jac is the best belter we ever had..Both of them admiring each other..Both posses unique quality..I might sound bias by preferring Siti more, I do love Jac, no doubt..But for Jac to achieve Siti, is still far..Siti is already a master of her own craft..Siti is now recognised as one of the top 10 asia best singer, the one and only from Malaysia..Jac still can learn many things from Siti..I hve no doubt Jac can be as great as Siti, i trust her talent..Aubrey Suwito, definitely knows these two songbirds and Aubrey admit Siti is the best in Malaysia..Aubrey said, Siti definitely can go higher but she respect her limit and plays her range very well..Thats explain her longevity and how she still can sings her oldies without problem and sounds much better..Yeah she sings lower key now, her voice has aged and deepened, showing much tonality quality of a mezzo..You cannot deny, after 20 years, Siti is the only vocalist that maintain her supported belting range from A4 - F5..Listen to her Bersandar Cinta live in DFP with Aubrey Suwito, its a belted F5 in mix voice, balance mix and she still nails the note after 22 years..Thats the quality of a star vocalist..Siti once said " I dont go for a higher belted just to show off my range, im a melodramatic singer and singing higher is not my preferrence "..
Secretzsongbird i think jaclyn is definitely as great as siti vocally. Jaclyn is a spinto which automatically made her more powerful than siti. From that video, we can clearly see that jaclyn is not all about high belts only, her mid belts are just as powerful and so resonant. I think jaclyn’s midbelts are better than siti’s. But siti’s voice probably aged better than jaclyn’s. I heard siti’s F5 in Bersandar Cinta, it’s definitely not a high belt cause it’s too soft, so it’s probably a masked head voice.
Starry Eyes In any placement, either mask or mix, its still has support and Siti does has support for her belt..Jac is better in midbelt? She might sounds stronger due to her tessitura but technically Jac still lag behind Siti..Siti's dynamic and versatility is second to none in Malaysia, thats a fact..Being a soprano doesnt mean the singer is better or the best..
Secretzsongbird it’s not her tessitura, it’s her vocal type that makes her more powerful. But it’s also evident that Jaclyn’s belt sound more open, resonant and very much ringing to the ears. But yeah siti has more dynamic.
Agree !!!
What are you talking about. Siti is NOT A MEZZO, shes a lyric soprano, obviously. Technique wise siti is able to support and resonate up to Eb5, while jaq only able to support up to D5 as evidently shown here. Headvoice wise, siti’s is more developed than Jaq’s and so is her lower register. However her problem is her mix, she cant mix properly beyond Eb5 and started straining and losing support. While jaq has better mix and placement although not supported beyond D5 however she’s capable of belting up to a G#5/A5 but with very high larynx and tightening of her vocal chords.
Siti lagi power, Jac lagi tinggi.
Agree!!
Dari segi keseluruhan teknik vokal still siti nurhaliza😘
I'm a Filipino but when it comes to voice quality I'll go with Jac, napakaunique ng boses nya parang black american. 😍
Aku pilih jaclyn victor..siti suara nyaring sesuai lagu melayu dgn indonesia je..pondan mudah tiru..Jaclyn punya suara lantang lagu english pun sesuai..org susah tiru
Mana bisa Siti di bandingkan dengan jeclin.jeklin lengking bgt.. Siti lengking nya lembut pas.rendahnya pas Paser nya pas... Ngk berlebihan.itu mknya semua jenis lagu bisa dia bisa bawakan.. jeklin tinggi ngk bisa semua bisa dia bwakn... Beda ngk bisa di bndingknn
Siti resonance, Jaclyn volume.
Whatever it is, the only person I see sing a high note with a wide smile plastered on the face is Siti. Truly beautiful.
Suara ct sedap di telinga dan senyum sentiasa terukir walau nada tinggi
Ziana zain vs jacklyn
Siti nurhaliza nada tinggi ttap tersenyum dn manis wajahnya.Lagi Merdu.
Tak sesuai vs siti ngn jac...sb keduanya berbeza suara..siti lembut jac lantang dan tinggi...siti suara dia versatile boleh bawa pelbagai genre sedangkan jac terhad sesuai lagu pop saja
bnr sekali klo. jac ini hanya di nada tinggi saja kerenya tp klo siti dari nada bawa sampai tinggi semua indah jd ga sesaui di bandingkan. tp jac ini nada tingginya bnr2 padet bgt yaas cocok bgt di bagian teriak.
Siti klau setakat lagu melayu mendayu dayu boleh la..suara dia org mudah tiru..Jaclyn punya suara sesuai lagu melayu & english..susah ditiru
Jaclyn ble bawa lagu rock mcm lagu Sweet Child of mine. Siti? Not sure.
Menda kau merapu ni? Apsal fans Siti ni suka sangat over claim ek? Siti versatile? Dia sesuai untuk lagu² Asia jenis yg melenggok, meleweh dan mendayu saja..
Muzik/genre West dia hauk, cover lagu² English pun ke laut sebab over meleweh..
Jac forte dia ballad, pop, classic, r&b, jazz & soul.. Celah mananya dia just satu genre saja lol
siti bila belting kita rasa mcm xbelting pon sbb suara dia tone dia yg lembut ( seem easy) berbeza dgn jac bila tarik rsa jantung nk luruh but more powerful.
SEKARANG NI ARE TALKING ABOUT HIGH NOTES RIGHT?? HANDS DOWN JACLYN VICTOR... IF MERDU SITI LAH NO ONE CAN BET HER...
Siti lbih bgus
Tinggi tpi enak didenger
Jac lbih ke teriak teriak
Betol jac kedengaran bingit
Teriak tiada melodi tu ada melodi
Jack sebab lantang.dan sukar di tiru
siti sounds natural..
Bb4 - Siti
B4s - Jaclyn
C5s - Tie
C#5s - Siti
D5s - Jaclyn
Eb5s - Tie
E5s - Jaclyn (Siti flopped hard in this note)
F5 - Tie
Bey Xtina Minaj are you a local?????!
sah la ko ni pekak tone
for ost notes, siti's voice is easier to the ear
most*
pleasant to the ear is the right word
it called resonant
@@firdaushamzi7002 i meant easy when i said easy #meh
@@einhyatt penggunaan ayat salah. english bukan mcm malay boleh direct translate. go refer to ur english teacher
jauh tetinggl siti ...jack d atas....mcm langgit dngn bumi
Jaclyn Victor is Sohyang version of Malaysia! Walaupun berlainan jenis suara tetapi dua2 nya sama hebat & mereka berdua salah satu penyanyi terhebat Malaysia. Tapi kalau diberi pilihan, sy nak pinjam suara Jaclyn.
Omg I can’t even choose. They are great in their own way. Resonance all over the place!
Dari segi vocal dan personality, I minat sgt tokti dari zaman beliau muda remaja, but personally I think after dia keluar SRC, dia pilih nyanyi mostly lagu yg vocally safe safe je dlm album dia (adalah killer songs satu dua tu). But jac pula has always been consistently good with the vocal.
Sbgi fans Celine Dion sy suka siti cantik dan suara ny merdu, tpi belthing dan skill jaclyn msi yg terbaik
Saya lebih suka warna suara dan teknik Jacklyn victor, meskipun di Indonesia orang lebh banyak yg tahu Siti Nurhaliza.. tapi aku lbh pilih Jacklyn Victor
Sama bro
Roy Budiarta saya Pon Sama awak
Memang no komen dua2 I love mezo suprano voice siti and suprano vocal jack
Malaysia Number 1 and Number 2 singer
both aku suka...tp kalau nk compare diorg dua agak x sesuai sbb teknik dan segi nyanyian berbeza
I think their vocal type is different. To compare both of them is like comparing between banana and apple. One is soprano and clearly the range is wider and the other one is mezzo soprano.
Jac has similar vocal type with idayu af, as with siti and misha omar
Nonetheless, both are great performers. In terms of diversity and dynamics, i prefer siti nurhaliza. Brilliant singer who knows her range very well. No pun intended.
itula.. dato mezzo. xley compare ngn jac. of course jac lagi menyerlah di high note.
Masih menunggu orang macam jac dapat gelaran dato
zest jac xkot.. sbb blom byk lg mgharumkn nma malaysia
Ridzuwansyah Ahmad tapi yg aku pelik ada jee artis yg tiba2 jee dpt gelaran dato',tapi shila amzah yg harumkan nama Malaysia x pulak dpt dato'
@@mohdfaisol728 kne byk pgiktirafan kt malaysia dlu... die cuma fmes kt lua jer
Jac kalau masuk international mgkin..
Jac kalau byk masuk pertandingan luar mesti dpt
Different between mezzo and soprano...this is it....
Dua2 mutiara negara....
Are we comparing singer or vocalist? To be a greatvsinger is not just about who can sing higher note, but more than that is who can sing with emotion, deliver the message, stage perfomance and do it with effordlessly .. and Sit is second to none .
Jac💙
4:48 aku paling suka
Siti nurhaliza tetap merdu
Jac suaranya lebih internasiomal love Jac from Indonesia and she more creative with her note and suara Jac lebih tinggi dari pada Siti cos Siti cuma 2 octave
Highnote tak mnjanjikan terbaik…hehe
@@waksentotchannel tergantung dilihat dari sisi mana dulu LOL
@@doglover6286 13 kali vokal terbaik AIM.. 7x artis wanita terbaik planet music. Klu jac lbih octave, kenapa tak menang terbaik?? Aggitchewww sgt
@@waksentotchannel lah saya tak tanya siapa yang menang penghargaan terbanyak LOL, kalau kamu lebih suka suara Siti is ok itu selera kamu saya tak bilang Siti jelek tapi kalau saya lebih suka suara Jac itu selera saya terus masalahnya apa? Dan yg saya bahas dari vocal range bukan penghargaan dan video ini soal belting mangkanya menurut saya Jac menang cos suara Jac lebih tinggi bisa belting dengan mudah
@@doglover6286 lahh pulak.. klau tak tahu hal2 vokal, xperlu bnding bandingkn. Haha. Jac ade klbihan n ct ade klbihan… minat tp membandingkn? Klu rasa mnat jac, xperlu nk bnding2 ..
Jac the best belter in Malaysia. No doubt. Jac is a light lyric soprano while Siti is a mezzo-soprano.
No way jac is light lyric.
She is maybe full or spinto bcoz her output r big and becomes bigger when hit high notes.
While light couldt have big output.
For me siti juara always song sebap apa... Dia nynyi tak kosong ada rasa... Walau pun suara dia tk setinggi jac2 nynyi tinggi tapi kosong penjiwaan.. Nya... Siti verstile... Nk jadi artis bukan hanya perlu suara tinggi.. Saja...bagi aku almost penynyi dlm malaysia siti masih menjuarai... Blm ada lagi org boleh makan line dia evant jac sekali pun tengelam timbul.. Klu btl bagus.. Kenapa tk buat show sendiri... Sebap? Jac kekuarangan lagu singel... Siti.. Berapa banyak singel dia... Dan selalu buat tuor.... Siti asian... Bukan kt malaysia je bahkan sekarang international pun... Kenal....tak lama lagi siti bakal dapat biduan wanita...
nada suara berbeza dgn kemantapan yg sama..jac dgn powerful dan siti dgn soft nya..keduanya best,bosan dengar suara siti pindah ke jac,bosan dengar suara jac pindah ke siti..pake earphone utk dengar lebih nyaman keduanya..
I love both of them. Both have unique voice!
Siti
Cadangan aku la, kalau nak buat vs, ikut bawah ni,:
Siti vs Sharifah Aini
Jac vs Ziana
Caroline vs Salma
Liza Hanim vs Nurul
Tiada tolok bandingannya kak pah
Sptutnya jac vs salma
I love both...My idol...
Both 😍😍😍😍😍
Both of them .Ada kelebihan masing masing ...Tpi sye lebih memilih belting dan highnote ranges serta lownote and shifting Siti ...Merdu untuk didengar telinga kanan dan kiri ...Jac sye minat pada highnotes dia , highnotes ramai penyanyi yg bleh buat .Tpi nk sedap didengar telinga ..Only Siti can do that sambil senyummm ..Tk fhm mcm mne dia bleh buat mcm tu ❤️👍
Jac suara tinggi dan lantang hanya sesuai pada lagu pop dan english sahaja .
Siti ni suara yg unik dan verstyle ..Dia bleh menyanyi dalam pelbagai genre lagu dan english song .
Sekarang ni x kisah part2 tinggi tu.. Apa yg penting kawalan lower dan high register dgn baik... Kat malaysia siti PHD dlm bidang ni walaupun dia mezzo soprano... Jac win part belt highnotes dan part low dia masih kurang sikit(still ok) ...
Setuju bro ...Jac highnotes x sedap didengar telinga ...Siti highnotes muka senyum merdu didengar ..
Engko nyanyi pun mcam apa😂
@@rajasriindra9004 kau mampu??
jac tessitura tinggi. Techniques wise, Siti lebih baik.
Eb5 and above - jaclyn’s is full of resonance. Siti’s is adventurous for her fans because she doesn’t do that so often
D5 and below - i love how siti does it she seems to know that fact. Lol. This range sounds like jaclyn’s personal midrange, at least to me haha
Gaban Z Potong 2 yess i think jaclyn has a wider supported range than siti
Lol no. Jaq stopped consistently supporting and resonating at D5. Beyond this she lost support and started straining. Although at Eb5 she still have some support present but she’s losing resonance .
While siti is able to fully support her Eb5 and resonate. Beyond E5 she flopped coz her mix is very underdeveloped and straining so much due to pushed chesty mix and bad placement. Jaclyn has better mix and better placement for the upper belt but she don’t support it (although sometimes support can be present at E5 but very inconsistent as her larynx position is high and tight vocal chords).
Jaq has higher belting range, but siti has larger vocal range.
@@yureino jaclyn Eb5 and above it is support but not resonance compare to CT Eb5 which is resonance...CT mix her voice well balance meanwhile jaclyn mix voice is chest dominant that why it sound like straining and that stop her from producing resonance and her placement on Eb5 above is not that good but that doesn't block her support system...CT mix voice is consider the best in the country and well develop too...even a good mix voice has a limit to reach high note so it is not underdeveloped
jonathan jonis No. Jaq doesn’t support anything above E5. Jaq simply has higher tessitura thats why she can go higher. Although her belt is still chesty, but she’s able to engage more head mix into her belt. And if she’s straining with high larynx, how could she be supporting her notes? Thats not how support works.
A mix is like a spectrum. From a chesty mix, to balanced mix, and to heady mix. Siti is able to show mixing skill to a balanced mix, however she could not engage with her heady mix. Having a good mix will allow you to hit higher notes, only difference from singer to singer will be the volume and the quality of the belted mix. While jaq could not also fully engage with her heady mix, but she have a higher tessitura and better placement allowing her to hit higher notes with better heady-chest ratio in the upper belt.
Salah vs ni..siti kne banding dengan sharifah aini..sbb dua2 artis genre tak sama..aku suka dua2..kne bandingkan dengan style suara yg tone lebih kurang
jacccccccc
Boleh explain tak BB4 and so on tu makna apa? Dan yang paling tinggi sekali code apa? Saya budak baru nak tau..
Bb4 tu note B flat dlm octave ke empat
Boleh tahan nafas
LOL I laughed when people said siti is a mezzo while she’s clearly a lyric soprano.
Songsource She’s indeed a mezzo. She can hit C3 easily with resonance.
Eat Some Corn lol. I doubt you understand anything about resonance. Siti only supports (hence resonates) down to E3. She has never hit a C3. The lowest she’s done is C#3, but it’s very airy, slightly low larynx and not centred. Hence not supported.
Her belts are also very chesty above E5-F5, which a mezzo would have a problem hitting with such chesty quality and fuller sound. If anything, her vocal tone and timbre scream lyric soprano.
Songsource Well first you have to prove your credibility first. I’m not making up whatever I’m saying. I read through her wikipedia plus vocal blogs. She’s a mezzo. She’s just good at mixing. Look at her voice now. It is a well rounded tone and range of a mezzo. Beyonce is a mezzo but she has hit upper chest voice numerous times with good mixing technique. You know nothing girl!
Eat Some Corn LOL. Beyonce is a highly skilled vocalist. Her upper belts are hit with balanced mixed belt to heady belt, not chesty like what siti is doing. Beyonce is able to hit down to a G2 which what normally a good mezzo capable of doing and consistently support a C3/C#3 with neutral larynx. Siti HAS NEVER HIT A C3 Live. Her lowest is a C#3 which is very airy and with low larynx. A mezzo would sound fuller at lower register. Beyonce’s voice is fuller and has a dark undertone to her voice. While siti’s voice is bright, light and feminine.
Gosh, you really think Wikipedia is a credible source? Kid, are you new to the internet? Barely any credible source has ever analysed siti’s vocal type.
If you dont even know how to classify vocal type, understand the terms such as resonance, support, placement, timbre, tessitura, passagio etc, I advise you not to be too confident with what you read online.
Songsource Do you even think there is only one type of box of mezzo? Learn about vocal fach dude. Every type of mezzo has different tessitura and range not only voice quality. Siti is Lyric Mezzo at best for me. And please are you that credible to testify her vocal fach?
Siti = melodious
Jac = technical
Siti forte lagu2 melayu leman..
Jac forte lagu2 english..
Siti cater audiens felda2, kampung, penduduk flat ppr kerinchi, akak2 kilang panasonic.
Jac cater audiens studen2 UM course bussiness, receptionist hotel 3 bintang, pengunjung2 club malam, staff2 glc company.
Flat kerinchi pon dia dah mng bnyak award .. Ko ade ??
Bangang kau x ubah ii lagi ....Siti antara orang terkaya kt malaysia
Ct dah cater audiens dkat london, japan, australia, china, hongkong, kazakhstan, filipin, indonesia, singapore, thailand, brunei. So?????????? Funny la hater mcm ko ni.. oppss da namanya hater kan. Fakta tetap fakta. Org tetap kenal siapa siti nurhaliza.
Giituuuu
Fakta anjing ko ni. Blh mampuslah ko. Njirr
Sudah tentulah jac menjuarainya....vocal superb
siti masih tiada tandingan
My idol Jaclyn victor ❤❤❤
Nice video
abiey victor thanks!
Jaccc!!!!!!
Tk payah nk vs ² lah lain penyanyi lain gaya Siti tetap Siti ok, bkn tak suka apa perasaan kita kalau org banding² kan kita dgn org lain ada akal fikirlah ye... 3/12/19 ✌️
Apa nama lagu kat 4:42?
B- Great Segalanya (My All malay version)
For me, suara jac sesuai fit msuk dlm kbykn lagu2 nyanyian dya berbanding dato ct..
Jac still poweerrr
Jac is the bestttt