How painful they must have felt when they lost a member. The only consolation they have is that their friend is no longer in pain. They're truly strong beautiful men.
Not just a member e person who led their group who's was the eyes of them and by eyes I mean you can't see without eyes after losing the eyes they had to stray strong and make their ears to find their way by listening I know I didn't explain well but I tried my best🥺
@@sohiyyi depression and he thought he couldn't achieve his goals and day by day it didn't get better but worse in the end he couldn't bear it and left us to a place where he won't be bullied 😔
@@hetvivaidya783 yes before committing suicide he wrote a letter to one of his clost friend and in the letter he said how broken he was from the inside and that he kept fighting but he reached to the point where he no longer could fight and gave up I just wish he would've fought but what can I do he was broken from inside sometimes I'm like Jonghyun why did you leave don't you love us couldn't you've stayed for us couldn't you've kept fighting longer but them im like he could've committed suicide a while ago but he didn't he stayed strong and fought maybe it was for us he kept fighting till his last breath just for his loved ones but in the end he was fully broken I just want him to know us Shawols still love him he tried his best and he did all he could We Love You Oppa Jonghyun😘
Yes. When I was showing my bestie for the first time the our page song and I just said smth like it's written for an angel wich is happy now but wasn't all the time. And yup I showed it her and tried so hard not to cry. But It didn't work.
One day, ifshe hasn't already - she'll realize what Minho did to spare her the pain and confusion of understanding suicide at such a young age - and she'll be grateful for how he handled her innocent question.
I'm not even a fan but every time I see clips like this/ about him, I feel the pain. I remember my friend before... at that time she's crying almost every minute.
Jonghyun, wherever you are, i hope you are not suffering any more. We'll always love you and cherish your talent and personality. You were a gift to mankind and it is our bad luck that we couldnt appreciate you for a longer time. Saranghae❤
the most fucked up thing abt this is the fact that jonghyuns funeral was surrounded by cameras and the family and friends didn’t even get private during a time like this
jjongs family literally asked not to use his funeral videos for clout these people have no respect whatsoever if yall so educated then say something about this.
I can't watch any of this footage, I start to tear up. He was my bias, Shinee was the reason I got into K-Pop. They were my first K-Pop concert 😢 they will forever hold a special place in my heart forever!! 💎💎💎💎💎
I completely feel this! I found them and haven’t let go since. I drove over 13 hours in a day to go see them live, and it was one of the best nights of my life seeing them. Jonghyun even pointed out a fan who had been at the same arena for a fanmeet a few months prior. They mean the world to me, and I don’t think anyone else can knock that place.
Though I found them late... I just witnessed jonghyun for only a year. . It was back in 2017 , I felt myself unlucky to bid him goodbye as soon as I found them. but still I would say I found the best ... I just hope they stay for long as a band... I can't let them go... ❤❣
Not long after a close friend died, I saw him in a dream. He was sitting in a beautiful room, with a stunning view. I wanted to go talk to him but the guide told me "he's still healing". He explained the anguish a soul feels when they take their own life is beyond sad ... but that they all heal and blossom into their true self. I believe Jonghyun is doing that too, so I'm holding out for the day he blossoms. Minho said he made himself not cry on the funeral day as he needed to be strong for Jonghyuns family and Shinee. What an exceptional man he is. 😍
Idk how minho controlled himself !!😢 Cuz I'm just running out of tear 😭 But we know that he is showing it,😢 from inside he is already broken up.....💔 I feel so sad for minho & jonghyun's bonding !! 💞
Minho handled that emotional situation with such grace- one who knows what he experienced knows how hard that was but he was so sensitive to the girl’s innocent question- he handled so well. Love Minho ❤️
I didn't even get into kpop until a year after jonghyun's passing, I didn't even know who he was, I didn't even know shinee. it makes me sad that I didn't make it into the kpop fandom in time to get to know jonghyun as the guy everyone loved, and why his death was, and still is, very painful - I'm sorry I missed out on such a beautiful person😔🖤
Yes ,, same I only got into K-POP after I hear 'kill this love' and 'Boy with love' song,,,, very sad I've lost the opportunity of being fangirl of him ❣💞💞
They were one of the first kpop groups I got into, it was around 2014, when I started listening to kpop, they have these great songs witch were really catchy and so good, like Lucifer, Ring Ding Dong, Sherlock and Everybody (my favorites), and I always was mesmerized by Jonghyun's voice. So...it was heartbreaking when I heard what happened, I cried so much, I miss his voice, may he rest in peace, we will always love him.
I'm exactly like you I started listening to kpop in 2018, and wasn't quite as affected about his passing as other people Now I just regret that I wasn't able to support them as a 5 member group, even tho they'll always be 5 in our hearts 💖 We love you Jonghyun, and we love Shinee 💚
He didn't want her to know the painful truth bc it would leave her shattered into a million pieces 😭😭😔😔 and may he rest in peace always once and forever 🥺🥺
Lame @ss. That's literally a kid who doesn't know Shinee. Stop worshipping Shinee and having the attitude "Well I know Shinee and Jonghyun death, so the world should also know because I know these facts." You clearly didn't watch the main video from this
This always makes me cry, seeing the pain in Minho's eyes. I never knew Shinee then. I don't really listen to their music but I'm a fan of their acting work and seeing his pain, it's tragic.
I have been following shinee since their song”replay.” I don’t speak or understand Korean but those were the days when I requested my friends who had access to their dad’s computer to get me the lyrics so that I had to have accurate lyrics. My fav from the band was JongHyun. I used to die for him. I still miss him in the band as I follow their IG. K industry doesn’t have so called mercy on them. Lots have lost their lives due to mental pressures and traumas. I hope and pray for his swift rebirth, but not in These dark industries. Rest of the members should be strong and lead the group to success. Fighting!!!
I miss him so much 😭😭😭😭😭 when you have the person that made you smile every day and you lose them when you were 18 and they are they are the reason why you are here today and they saved you when you were 15 I miss him so much 😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
This video shattered me 😭 it's been 7 years but the wound is still open. 😢 Such a talented and amazing person but noone was able to help him 😢😢😢 and it can't be reversed 😢😢 I'm still crying while I listen to his voice 💔
The way he just covered up to not make her afraid was so heart warming ..we all wish we could have saved you JongHyun ..but u were that blossom flower which god chose first
The fact is that we all can cry together even after a thousand years while watching this cause minho couldn't share the real story which will change her mood makes the video more sadder 😢
Every time I'm watching this I always cry. When they debuted I was only 1 year and some months old, but when members of a group is missing it's like you lost one of your family member.
How painful they must have felt when they lost a member. The only consolation they have is that their friend is no longer in pain. They're truly strong beautiful men.
What is his pain ??? Why he died ??? 🥺🥺🥺🥺
Not just a member e person who led their group who's was the eyes of them and by eyes I mean you can't see without eyes after losing the eyes they had to stray strong and make their ears to find their way by listening I know I didn't explain well but I tried my best🥺
@@sohiyyi depression and he thought he couldn't achieve his goals and day by day it didn't get better but worse in the end he couldn't bear it and left us to a place where he won't be bullied 😔
@@zainkhalil5355 So he committed sucide?
@@hetvivaidya783 yes before committing suicide he wrote a letter to one of his clost friend and in the letter he said how broken he was from the inside and that he kept fighting but he reached to the point where he no longer could fight and gave up I just wish he would've fought but what can I do he was broken from inside sometimes I'm like Jonghyun why did you leave don't you love us couldn't you've stayed for us couldn't you've kept fighting longer but them im like he could've committed suicide a while ago but he didn't he stayed strong and fought maybe it was for us he kept fighting till his last breath just for his loved ones but in the end he was fully broken I just want him to know us Shawols still love him he tried his best and he did all he could We Love You Oppa Jonghyun😘
Minho face after he said “he’s not well” explain that he’s sad.
I am soo sorry by mistake I disliked if I'm soo sorry
Yeah
:(
True
I hate myself I thought that's skz minho 😭
"So he's not a bad uncle"
"No... Hes not a bad uncle"
It just breaks me
While watching the full video, that moment came. I didn't expect that. I suddenly teared up and staret crying.
So... same here... :c
Me too it breaks me up😢
The way he had to answered the girl in sweet way... 😢
Thats true....he gave a simple answer.....great uncle MinHo
We can see the pain in Minho's eyes 😔🥺
That true.
Who's that girl ?
yea it killed me
Minho handled this so well because jonghyun is still a member, he might not physically here but his spirit is.
The fact that Minho didnt tell her that he died, even when we can see the sorrow in his eyes, he is such a kind person. ❤😢
"He's not well." That sentence broke me and had me crying a river. How much pain and sadness must he felt...
Yes. When I was showing my bestie for the first time the our page song and I just said smth like it's written for an angel wich is happy now but wasn't all the time. And yup I showed it her and tried so hard not to cry. But It didn't work.
I eat a cupcake in December for Jonghyun and I light a candle on his birthday… it’s rough 😭
@@moonyoonji1981 yup now it's his bday. I actually ate a carrot cupcake
Same
I mean she’s a kid I don’t think she’ll understand
And then the little girl was like “Ohh so he isn’t a bad uncle after all” and Minho replied “Yes, he’s not” with a bittersweet look in his eyes ☹️☹️☹️
Yes...the bad uncle part really hit hard...
Yes!! That was hard! 😭
The look in his eyes explain everything
Man, I bawled my eyes out the first time and it still hits me. How sad they must've felt I can't fathom T_T
Sometimes something like this is very tough to explain 😞. The way he says "He's not well " was telling everything.
The pain is, the member cannot help him when he's down.. He's always happy, who thought he is in deep bluess... My Dinoooooo
One day, ifshe hasn't already - she'll realize what Minho did to spare her the pain and confusion of understanding suicide at such a young age - and she'll be grateful for how he handled her innocent question.
Once she knows I think she will cry
Tbh i would have just said he isnt alive anymore. This is the problem why things like that happen. because no one talk about it
@Arati Das one of the members of their group committed sucide and minho didnt want to upset the girl so told her that the member is unwell
@@sheoulgra well the girl is young she would prob either cry or not understand.
@@anmolchauhan6458 sry but this girl is def in a age where she knows about death
I'm not even a fan but every time I see clips like this/ about him, I feel the pain.
I remember my friend before... at that time she's crying almost every minute.
Same here🥺
Same, even when I saw the news, I cried because I know he must be suffering which makes him did that..
Same..I wasn’t into kpop yet back then but I cried my eyes out when I read it on the news…
@@anjeanette7305 what it's song's?
@@chanapark638 you mean the song in the video? It's "Stitches" by Shawn Mendes but it's a cover I guess
It's been a long time, but still can see in his eyes the hurt. He can't even say to that kid that "he's dead"🥺😞
She’s just a child - no reason to say it like that. When she’s older she can learn the truth.
@@beryl739-f1c same i tear up a bit everytime i watch it
You had me crying a river at 4am😭. The way they all refer to him, is so heartbreaking. I don't think he was able to say "he's gone".❤️🕊️
Jonghyun is gone from this world but he will be always there in our hearts
RIP Jonghyun😞😞
Jonghyun, wherever you are, i hope you are not suffering any more. We'll always love you and cherish your talent and personality. You were a gift to mankind and it is our bad luck that we couldnt appreciate you for a longer time. Saranghae❤
You made me cry😭
@@Vazahaoui 😢❤
This is so beautiful omg . . I'm sobbing , yeah that's so true . We will forever be thankful for him
@@enhpnlvs so true😢❤
This made me cry🥲
The pain is still in his eyes🥺🥺, but he was so mature in protecting the kid
Seeing eyes of minho trying to control his emotions remembering jonghyu ...
You could see the pain in his eyes as he said that 😔💔
She looks so innocent and I feel bad when she finds out what really happened
the most fucked up thing abt this is the fact that jonghyuns funeral was surrounded by cameras and the family and friends didn’t even get private during a time like this
The family approved for the cameras to be there, they had a separate private funeral for him.
don’t speak on things you are not educated on, they had a private funeral as well and the family approved the public funeral.
Speaking without proper info 🙄🙄
They did the public thing bc they wanted the fans to also bid goodbye . His family approved so don’t be talking shit
jjongs family literally asked not to use his funeral videos for clout these people have no respect whatsoever if yall so educated then say something about this.
I can't watch any of this footage, I start to tear up. He was my bias, Shinee was the reason I got into K-Pop. They were my first K-Pop concert 😢 they will forever hold a special place in my heart forever!!
💎💎💎💎💎
💚💖💙
I completely feel this! I found them and haven’t let go since. I drove over 13 hours in a day to go see them live, and it was one of the best nights of my life seeing them. Jonghyun even pointed out a fan who had been at the same arena for a fanmeet a few months prior. They mean the world to me, and I don’t think anyone else can knock that place.
@@sarak7864 wow!! I'm so touched by your story!! Thank you for sharing it 💎💎💎💎💎
@@sarak7864 you guys are luckiest 🫶🏻❤️
Though I found them late... I just witnessed jonghyun for only a year.
. It was back in 2017 , I felt myself unlucky to bid him goodbye as soon as I found them. but still I would say I found the best ... I just hope they stay for long as a band... I can't let them go... ❤❣
"He's not well"
I wish it was true and he is still with us🥺
The pain in his eyes 😢
Even though this loss is irreplaceable they have worked really hard to keep shinee name always shining ❤️
Not long after a close friend died, I saw him in a dream. He was sitting in a beautiful room, with a stunning view. I wanted to go talk to him but the guide told me "he's still healing". He explained the anguish a soul feels when they take their own life is beyond sad ... but that they all heal and blossom into their true self. I believe Jonghyun is doing that too, so I'm holding out for the day he blossoms. Minho said he made himself not cry on the funeral day as he needed to be strong for Jonghyuns family and Shinee. What an exceptional man he is. 😍
this was beautiful to read.
This is very beautiful, thank you for sharing :)
He must be in hotel del Luna don't worry🙂
What k pop group
@@gyanijain743 Shinee
Idk how minho controlled himself !!😢 Cuz I'm just running out of tear 😭
But we know that he is showing it,😢 from inside he is already broken up.....💔 I feel so sad for minho & jonghyun's bonding !! 💞
I'm not a fan but I know the story and it's breaking me every time
@@its__meee5383 he committed suicide some years back (I'm also not a Shinee fan, but I've heard the story) & it's really heartbreaking
To see the affect of Jonghyun's absence shows the impact he made while he was here💔🫰🏼
No matter how much time passes, but Jonghyun will always live in my heart and I think in them too ❤️🩹
Rest In Peace Jonghyun you will always have a special place in our heart💜
Ys true 💯 sure
When she asked "who is he ?" And then answered "its uncle jonghyun " I cried so much
Edit:tysm for the likes😭
Same i miss him sm 💜😭
Minho handled that emotional situation with such grace- one who knows what he experienced knows how hard that was but he was so sensitive to the girl’s innocent question- he handled so well. Love Minho ❤️
I'm literally in tears,because of this industry they had to lost their friend forever,rest in peace angle jonghyun🕊
I remember watching that episode!!! I felt sad with him..😭😫😫😫😭😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺❤️
"He's not well" I cried🥺🥺🥺
I didn't even get into kpop until a year after jonghyun's passing, I didn't even know who he was, I didn't even know shinee. it makes me sad that I didn't make it into the kpop fandom in time to get to know jonghyun as the guy everyone loved, and why his death was, and still is, very painful - I'm sorry I missed out on such a beautiful person😔🖤
Me too don't know but it's okay 😃 life goes on!
Me too i missed the opportunity to be a fan girl of him and I know here just when I became fan of iu
Yes ,, same I only got into K-POP after I hear 'kill this love' and 'Boy with love' song,,,, very sad I've lost the opportunity of being fangirl of him ❣💞💞
They were one of the first kpop groups I got into, it was around 2014, when I started listening to kpop, they have these great songs witch were really catchy and so good, like Lucifer, Ring Ding Dong, Sherlock and Everybody (my favorites), and I always was mesmerized by Jonghyun's voice. So...it was heartbreaking when I heard what happened, I cried so much, I miss his voice, may he rest in peace, we will always love him.
I'm exactly like you
I started listening to kpop in 2018, and wasn't quite as affected about his passing as other people
Now I just regret that I wasn't able to support them as a 5 member group, even tho they'll always be 5 in our hearts 💖
We love you Jonghyun, and we love Shinee 💚
When he said "Uncle Jonghyun" I was like, cmon man! I know this gon be sad! 😭🥺 But may he rest in peace I love him!!
This broke my heart. Literally crying....i will never get over this...
You can clearly see the pain in his eyes😔
Moonbin is also gone now🕊️
@@hardworkingallele3084 i Know 😔
The pain and void they will always feel is beyond sad. He answered her question so sweetly and in a kind respectable manner ♥️💔🙏🏽
Their pain can't be explained in words. He acted to be strong but his heart cried from inside 🥺
He didn't want her to know the painful truth bc it would leave her shattered into a million pieces 😭😭😔😔 and may he rest in peace always once and forever 🥺🥺
All of you face the world in one group with five head,, but now just 4 head and one angel,,, 💔
All of you face the world in one group with five head,, but now just 4 head and one angel,,, 💔
I wouldn't be able to control my emotion, the way minho was patience is admirable
This still breaks my heart ..he was such a beautiful person
This is so sad I can't even imagine how hard it would have been to tell her a lie.
True but how could he tell her he doesn't want her to be sad
All of you face the world in one group with five head,, but now just 4 head and one angel,,, 💔
All of you face the world in one group with five head,, but now just 4 head and one angel,,, 💔
He explained so softly and the girl was so clueless. Poor him
May he rest in peace
Lame @ss. That's literally a kid who doesn't know Shinee. Stop worshipping Shinee and having the attitude "Well I know Shinee and Jonghyun death, so the world should also know because I know these facts." You clearly didn't watch the main video from this
That's so sad if you lost your friend who is like you brother 😢😭😢
He was trying his best not to hurt the child's feelings... But he was in such pain💔
All of you face the world in one group with five head,, but now just 4 head and one angel,,, 💔
All of you face the world in one group with five head,, but now just 4 head and one angel,,, 💔
I felt the pain for him too. 😭😭😭
This always makes me cry, seeing the pain in Minho's eyes. I never knew Shinee then. I don't really listen to their music but I'm a fan of their acting work and seeing his pain, it's tragic.
It's hard...very hard than u think...even time can't heal this...living whole life feeling missing them...
The pain of losing a member in the most painful way. 😭
Today is JongHyun birthday . 🎂Happy 33rd Birth Day(8th April). Hope we all see him oneday in the heven 💐.
Wow he has the same birthday as my mom.. Hopefully he's in a better place now❤️ R.I.P jonghyun we will always love you💞
He has the same birthday as me 😢
The pain in his eyes says it all omg miss you Jonghyun 😖
How matuarly Minho handled the situation 👏👏. We can't imagine his pain 💔💔
May his soul rest in serene perfect peace AMEN🤲🏾🙏🏽✨
I have been following shinee since their song”replay.” I don’t speak or understand Korean but those were the days when I requested my friends who had access to their dad’s computer to get me the lyrics so that I had to have accurate lyrics. My fav from the band was JongHyun. I used to die for him. I still miss him in the band as I follow their IG. K industry doesn’t have so called mercy on them. Lots have lost their lives due to mental pressures and traumas. I hope and pray for his swift rebirth, but not in These dark industries. Rest of the members should be strong and lead the group to success. Fighting!!!
Minho's reaction after he said "he's not well"😭😭😭😭😢😢😭😢😢😭😭🤧🤧🤧🤧
"he's not well"
made my heart broke
They way he *HIDE* that he's not well🥺
*Painful* 🥀
He didn't hide it
The pain in his eyes shows they were really close
So sad inside but can't cry near my mom 😭🥺🙏🏻
I miss him so much 😭😭😭😭😭 when you have the person that made you smile every day and you lose them when you were 18 and they are they are the reason why you are here today and they saved you when you were 15 I miss him so much 😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
I want to give him a hug
The moment minho said he is not well tears jus roll down I dint even realised... It hurts so hard...
The way he shielded her from the pain of the loss. He handled that beautifully and we all felt his pain.
"He's a good uncle."
Yes he was 😢😢😢😢
He's not well 😭 omg i can't 😭
Our angel 🥺♥️ please comeback again.. I'm crying too much 😭
SHINee forever five 💎
even after years pass but the pain still there cos he unreplaced..
:(((((( the sadness shows on the tone of his voice while saying "he's not well"
This video shattered me 😭 it's been 7 years but the wound is still open. 😢 Such a talented and amazing person but noone was able to help him 😢😢😢 and it can't be reversed 😢😢 I'm still crying while I listen to his voice 💔
Oppa jonghyun why did u live us now he will never come back to us 😭😭😭😭😭😭
I watched this episode and when she asked my heart broke all over again 😭🥺
What video is this? Can I have a link? Thanks
This is so painful to watch… wow u see the sadness in his eyes 😭😭😭😭😭
I just feel so bad. I miss jonghyun and his face after saying that he is not well just broke my heart. We all miss him
It still hurts till this day. I’m just a fan and i can feel that. So i can’t imagine being his loved ones 😢
Eyes can't lie we all see your pain in your eyes it's hard for all of us🥺🥺😭😭💔💔💔
The way he just covered up to not make her afraid was so heart warming ..we all wish we could have saved you JongHyun ..but u were that blossom flower which god chose first
Ugh this is heartbreaking. You can feel his pain through his eyes 😔
It's still hurts everyone he was an amazing singer, writer
One of the darkest times of my life 😔
All of you face the world in one group with five head,, but now just 4 head and one angel,,, 💔
Imagine being Minho and telling this girl that he's not there because he's unwell but he's actually no longer in this world.... this is so sad
Even if i don't stan them i cried so hard bcz he was so sweet person he is new in better place 😔😭🥺❤💞
The fact is that we all can cry together even after a thousand years while watching this cause minho couldn't share the real story which will change her mood makes the video more sadder 😢
Imagine having to experience that at their young age, how painful
Minho is so cute but my heart shattered in athousand peices jonghyun was a legend ❤
🥺He's in heaven. He's well off then we'll all ever be on this dark earth.
It's been 4 and half years 🥺🥺 but whenever I see this video I can't stop tears 😭😔 we miss you jonghyun
Can you tall me the group name
@@spring_autumn_summer_winter Shinee
@@moksha..4127 thanks so much
teared up again. this brings back flashbacks. it was and it still painful to watch 🥺
His words describing how much he is missing jonghyun😭😭😢
the way he had to stop himself from crying is breaking my heart 😭
Every time I'm watching this I always cry. When they debuted I was only 1 year and some months old, but when members of a group is missing it's like you lost one of your family member.