Russia - Ukraine conflict / crisis Explained | Everything in detail | Geopolitics
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.พ. 2022
- In this video we'll try and understand the ongoing Russia Ukraine conflict, crisis.
#russiaukraineconflict #russiaukrainecrisis #geopolitics
/ amitsengupta01
/ amitsengupta01
www.kooapp.com/profile/amitse...
Hindi Channel
/ @amitsenguptahindi
-- Geography playlist
• Geography terms and de...
-- Economy playlist
• Economics
• Indian Economy - UPSC ...
-- Current Affairs playlist
• UPSC Current Affairs v...
-- Indian history playlist
• Modern History for UPS...
-- Govt of India schemes playlist
• Government of India Sc...
-- Map based learning
• Map based learning
-- Climatology playlist
• Climatology
-- Previous year solved question paper analysis
• Solved Question Papers...
-- Environment & Ecology playlist
• Environment and Ecolog...
-- International relations playlist
• International Relation...
-- Check the other playlists of NCERT Geography videos
Class 6 - goo.gl/DDFtIF
Class 7 - goo.gl/ppPK05
Class 8 - goo.gl/OD3Gwh
Class 9 - goo.gl/AIEXxQ
Class 10 - goo.gl/inWIAR
Class 11 - goo.gl/Pn5EIE
Class 11 (Part 2) - goo.gl/X4zY9K
Class 12 - goo.gl/Kszpz5
![[Eng Sub] "คิม พรประภา" นักสะสมรถหายาก ระดับโลก !!!! EP.134 | What the fast](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Kcr-0Kup20g/mqdefault.jpg)
Follow up video - "Why Russia attacked Ukraine?"
th-cam.com/video/UcIkwKVxrjk/w-d-xo.html
It’s about NATO expending to the UKRAIN, it’s like put a gut to Russian head. About US sending weapons to the Ukrain and the ship Bomber from US and Destroyed ship from UK came to Black Sea. Look deeply m.th-cam.com/video/Nbj1AR_aAcE/w-d-xo.html
So will Putin keep trying to take back countries that were in the former USSR? Kind of sounds like Hitler did when he came to power.
Amit, do you still reason the US was all along using dirty tactics now that Russia has invaded?
@@rizzomatt What countries has Putin taken back???? R U American?
@@JosephAdedeji Russia hasnt invaded.... and USA has used dirty tacktic since Vietnam in the 60's the are pure evil.
And the 2014 debacle had USA behind it.... Victoria Newland, Biden, etc, And who want USA next dooe> NO sensible Ukrainian..... or any other part of world... USA is a contaminating virus of the worst kind
It's been said a million times, but for any confusion in the west there's a video by a nice Indian person to explain everything in a concise manner. Thank you so much.
Even if it's explained entirely at an 8th-grade Wikipedia level, and ignores what should be scarred in everyone's memory. Ukraine had a VIOLENT COUP by an illegal dual-citizen Junta that immediately looted all of the Ukraine Treasury bullion! It would be as if Biden-Harris had seized power in 2020, and shipped Fort Knox to Bank of London, then a 'nice Indian person' wrote a narrative about the North vers. the South, and the way Liberals dress compared to Deplorables. LIke, WTF, Homer!?
@@robertmarmaduke9721 he wasn't explaining history of political ecosystem of Ukraine , video was about possibility of Russian - Ukrainian war .........
He covered essential topics for that.
this vid is too bias. it is trash
@@robertmarmaduke9721 How dare you doubt the great American narrative?
- Adûnâi
@@somethingnew7078 Instead of posting Wiki Word Salad, he could have succinctly stated *Ukraine vers Russia is 100% LNG Pipeline Cartel Wars.* But he didn't did he?
We won't survive as a species with this Wiki retelling of history in world maps and ethnic costumes. This is the 3rd Millennium now, and the 3rd Temple now lies in Brussels. New Masters and New Dialectics.
It would be the same as if a 'nice American person', explained Modi the Looter and his Fascist BJP party brutal crackdown on the Women's Committee and the unrepresented migrant workers rioting in Uttar Pradesh, by showing a British Raj map of Hindustan and a bunch of 20thC photos of ethnic jodhpur costumery between Hindus and Punjabis.
It would be an intellectual slap in the face to 800,000,000 Indian women and poor Untouchables. *But that's exactly what this 'nice Indian guy' is doing with his Ukraine-Russia potted 2nd Millenial history channel.*
Not US or Russian propaganda. A fair, factual, and balanced analysis. Wish more people were this informed. Thank You.
What is Russian Propaganda????
It has been repeated proven as US throwing tantrums and blaming their internal problems and gaslighting especially the democratic party.
💯
Thnks for your perspective, I now plan on watching the video in it’s entirety. Seriously.
it is very harsh on the Yanukovich administration (ProRussian) so I agree with you on that
Russian news outlets are sanctioned and banned. So how is that possible of Russian propaganda.
I am Kenyan. Thanks for making me understand the conflict.
War not conflict
I am a younger guy in USA. We see the outcome of what's happening but honestly we don't really understand why any of this is happening. So I'm about to watch the video. THX to TH-camr
Go and live in any other country and look this Ukraine conflict... You would probably figure out who is responsible for this conflict other than Russia and Ukraine.😂😅
@@dkine5586 damn yr being brutally honest 💀
Go live in Africa or South America or any parts of world and you ll know it
The sad thing is, that some guy in India knows the political situation in Ukraine better, than most Ukrainians. As an educated Ukrainian I can tell you that you are 100% right about this situation.
Amit sir is nvr wrong 🙏
This is nationalist channel. His explanation are more bigotry some times.
How do you..as an Ukrainian...analyse the 1994 Budapest agreement?
1700 nukes ICBMs long range bombers...had these been deployed... Russia would have RESPECTED Ukraine....even NATO would have RESPECTED Ukraine
Ukraine lost its freedom, dignity, sovereignty by the weapons surrender
As a Russian American, I have had such a hard time sifting through all the media bullshit to understand what is going on. Everybody wants my opinion on the matter and this video was very helpful in breaking down all the events leading up to the conflict. Thank you for this!
There is no such thing as a Russian American ,either you are Russian or you are American
@@derrickwest1590 You can be a citizen of both dimwit
@@derrickwest1590 there is no such thing as Derrick West intelligence. You either have intelligence or you are Derrick West
@@derrickwest1590 🤣😂
@@badcornflakes6374 NO YOU CAN'T ASK ARNOLD SWAZZERNAGGER THAT WE LIVING IN TIMES OF PICKING A SIDE THERE NO MIDDLE CLASS THERES NO BOTH SIDE'S OR GREY AREAS OR I BETWEENS ITS EITHER YOU HERE OR THERE EAST OR WEST 🎯💯
I was pleasantly surprised how well the conflict was explained!
Mock. Draft
THANK YOU BRO IM FROM THE U.S BUT I DON'T STAND WITH WESTERN MEDIA JUST BECAUSE IT'S FULL OF PROPAGANDA!!! THANK YOU BRO YOU JUST GAINED A NEW SUBSCRIBER 🎯💯
Being a Ukrainian who served in the Armed Forces of Ukraine and fought against Russian invasion of Luhansk oblast in 2014 - 2015, I want to thank you Mr. Sengupta. I'm amazed with your precise yet as brief as possible analysis of the situation. This is one of the best overviews made by non ukrainian citizen. Thank you once again!
+1
He makes all good contents about conflicts in other countries too.
Please share and promote such content.
Ты не солдат ты каратель.
I am imagining..the scenario...if 1700+ nukes..with ICBMs nd tu33 bombers were now deployed by Ukraine...
I personally do not support Ukraine Georgia type countries to join any block...not NATO not Russia...
I think Budapest agreement was cheating fraud on Ukraine by west+Russia...
I am from India...i have stopped trusting RUSSIA and West....i have faith ...minimal left for France...
I have respect for Israel Taiwan Japan Brazil
THIS IS BY FAR the MOST DETAILED analysis I've encountered on this topic m. NONE of the media in America are offering these details. ALL of the American media has been offering 8th grade level descriptions
Nowhere...If you want to know and you are interested, in the internet you can read, study all the details of the history.
Otherwise you hear the day- to- day news. Teach yourself in every age up to 100 yrs.
lol
You're too generous describing US media as 8th grade, they're more like kindergarten level at reporting news
Maybe the US news media is offering eighth grade level analyses but that's the only way most US citizens will understand. But... if you're buying this guy's analysis then you're no better equipped to understand the situation than those news media outlets are offering. The most accurate part of this analysis, other than the basic facts, is Europe's position of putting it's finances as the higher priority. I'll give you a simple analysis of this situation. This is about Putin's ego and his desire to restore the Soviet Union to it's former glory. Will he invade? Who knows. If he thinks he can do it w/o facing strong consequences from the West, the chances are that he will. The mercs who were staged have been deployed, so he's certainly ready to do it.
@@jmb92555 Let's see if there will be a mutual agreement between East and West with the different parties. Hopefully it will not come to a bloodshed, because some people want to prove their power.
Analyzed at a right time, 🙏 for deep analysis 🇹🇿💪🇷🇺
as a Ukrainian I can say that the video is awesome. You did a great work. I have only one thing to say - Opposite block and people like Shariy aren't really into «regional interests». They are fully pro-russian. Even if they weren't so active in last few years - they've been pro-russian before, when Yanukovich was the president.
You didn't understand the video. Watch it carefully.
He also didnt mention the huge amount of neo-nazis there are in Ukraine, who has been trained up by the west.
@@mortimersmithsr2522 You are right.
@@mortimersmithsr2522 And he didn't mention Russia's MERCENARIES and FSB agents who got sent to Ukraine to create conflicts and giving Russia an excuse to "Safe russians ethnic" .... But hey, you only see "Ukrainian Nazis" 😂
@@YujiroHanmaaaahow would you explain Ukrainian parlament celebrating Stepan Bandera’s birthday?
I lived in the Donbass region in 2014, Luhansk to be precise and I can confirm that this is probably one of the most unbiased views you will find on this issue!
❤
@@thedreamville he mean talking against USA, btw he was ight, USA is only talking and sanction are nothing only make normal people suffer to make reveloution but it wont work and im from iran
I read it as "Dumbass region" for the first time I was so confuse lmao
@@KidnapT 😂😂😂😂 you crazy man
@Moon Shine if someones sound entirely unbiased to you only until the point he rustles your jimmies by not licking USA enough, I have some grim news regarding your media comprehension....
I'm a Filipino and I appreciate how you deliver the point of View. - Straight to the point! - I subscribed!
Same Pilipino din ako
pignoys 😂
What you said about the European economy and the US's "old dirty tactics" have all come true. Beautifully presented.
It's intriguing to see how individuals from different parts of the world can gain insightful knowledge about complex political situations. Your perspective as an educated Ukrainian further validates the accuracy of the information presented in this video. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and contributing to the discussion. 🌍🧠🗺
I am Russian and have learned a lot from this video! Thank you for such a clear presentation, and for not being biased, showing facts from both sides. I feel sad that over the past couple of decades Russian and Ukrainian people have been pushed into such hostility. In my heart, we are the same people, with cultural differences that need to be celebrated and respected. I lived in India and some of my best friends there were Ukrainians! No matter what happens, I personally choose not to poison my heart with this politically created hostility.
Oh nice to hear ✊ here in Goa i see many Russians come for vacation
Ukrainians and Russians are not the same nation, check the historical chronicals where the list of soldiers with nationalities can be found. And Ukrainian nation is a little bit older than Moscow city.
@@user-wc5by2ux5q he's speaking from his heart, maybe you should try it.
@@user-wc5by2ux5q I am not saying Russia and Ukraine are the same nation. I was talking about my own sentiment about it, this is how I see it. I know there’s a lot of shared history and a lot of history that’s separate.
@@user-wc5by2ux5q come on, same as Californians/Texans are not the same Americans. What is Russia? It’s the state, started in Kiev and expanded around ;)
Very clear and vast knowledge included.
This great guy must be from India❣️
Give applause guys👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Yep, he's indian
Excellent and unbiased political overview. Well done, Sir. Thank you from an Australian in Vietnam. I am forwarding this onto others.
Theres alot of antiwestern bias. He totally misrepresented natos and EUs stand point on this.
@@dave_sic1365 cope.
I'd like to add, that a lot of weapons and heavy arms used by separatists were taken from weapon depots around the region. I'm not denying russian involvement, but there is plenty of proof about origins of weapons used by donetsk and lugansk people
He said that 18:52
I was born in Ukraine And I am American citizen. Overall you did a great job short, comprehensive and you take no sides well done young man
He was taking no side up until minute 30:40. From there on out he went political.
@@camilogyllback7193 because he is right
Russia will not attack Ukraine also the US will not help Ukraine.
Only, the US wants to sell more weapons that's why they are exaggerating the issue.
@@camilogyllback7193 Either give Ukraine a NATO membership or simply say membership won't be given.
end the dispute forever
@@gazz01 Russia has already attacked Ukraine in Crimea, Donbass and Luhansk.
@@camilogyllback7193
Sorry I don't know about this info
So he is definitely biased here
The best explanation I have seen. Regards from Mexico 🇲🇽 brother
Love from india 🇮🇳
This was a lot more informative than I thought it would be.
With many people trying to tell the status as per their own convenience, this was a very nice simple, clear and complete overview of the Ukraine and Russia conflict. Thank you. Great!
If I had a Biology teacher who could explain human anatomy the way you've explained the video,, I could be a doctor by now.
Lol
This video is trash, it says Ukraine is a young country without culture. Kyiv was founded ~1600 years ago, loooooong before morscow
@@erlendbb1289 Yes, but built by Soviet, which is Russia.. Kyiv is much older than Ukraine, and that is a fact
@@erlendbb1289 You mean Rus Kiev that covers all? They divided into different regions after that. Learn and comprehend the full history man. As if you're claiming Holy Roman Empire as the modern Germany.
@@tonkinthehanoian1843 It is exactly the opposite I tried to do, but it seems you intentionally misunderstand. For example Denmark and Norway is not the same country, its not same people, the only thing that we have in common is that we are scandinavians. Same goes for Norway and Sweeden, we have fought in 21 wars to protect our borders. Unfortunately todays Russia is raping Ukraine, hope Putin burn in hell together with Stalin and Hitler
I'm only halfway through this and I'm amazed at this entire presentation for being direct yet thorough, I feel like you're a pro lecturer.
This aged well.
This situationn moves me so much.....so I put together an energetic and hopeful video/song mix: Ukraine War footage and Lil Nas X - Star Walkin'. If you want have a look :)
Thanks for giving the world delightful understanding. Love from Africa 😍
I used your video for my home schooled son, on a Course that I created specially for him: Media & Public Affairs Strategic Communication-A Comparative Approach.
So that he learns early in life, how to stir clear of political rants & small uninformative talk designed to solicit sympathy....and be an intelligent media consumer.
Thanks a million Amit, this is rich substance!
russia is not Putin. we don’t want war. proofs here th-cam.com/video/25elCgzOEJw/w-d-xo.html
I used the follow up video too 👍👍
could yiu share the curriculum you created for your son? i am also plannong it
*Steer clear
Regarding the Russian language, yes, they speak Russian in the South and East, but this is the same situation as with English in India or South Africa, or any other post-colonial country, people identify themselves as Ukrainians, and consider themselves carriers of Ukrainian culture, the only reason why people still tied to Russian, this is a large media market in Russia - like the US media market
I've seen so many good Indian people on media platforms, big respect. Thank you so much for explanation. From Russia.
This is the most unbiased coverage of this topic.
Amazing video. Well-balanced perspective. This is why i believe India is one of the greatest countries in the world. A non-partisan superpower, open to all and with a full heart.
"You can't defeat culture."
You have a point. You can collapse a state in a week. But you can't collapse a culture in 100 years. In my country, the US, the government tried to stamp out Native American cultures for decades and only partially succeeded, even after taking everything from them.
One can with demographic change.. either quickly or subtly. IsIam defeated culturea and annihilated whole of North Africa mid Asia and north west India.
@@Valkyrie1941 Yeah, but just like with Christianity in Northern Europe, it was a pretty gradual transition. Even after official state conversion, the old culture sticks around for a long time until it's only a rural phenomenon and then disappears. Islam and Christianity both took a century or more to fully stamp out pagan religions in a given area. But Islam collapsed/replaced state governments extremely quickly.
Abrahamic religions aren't good, everyone of them spread through chaos, misery, bloodshed, pain and tears.
@@joydevsarkar4474 it's not just Abrahamic religions, it's humanity.
so in conclusion America is instigating the world war with Russia and Ukraine. None of nato european countries wants to fight the war because it will effect their economy because they import gas from Russia. America instigate the war in the middle EAST and now trying to instigate war with Russia ..... WASTING TAX PAYERS MONEY.
Concise, incisive and clear explanation of cause and effect. Inspires us to listen to all the facts and draw our own conclusions. You put all the big think tanks to shame. Glad I found about you.
Yet this video is full of errors and in some parts repeat Russian narratives
@@phlerpen In that case, why dont you point out the errors and share the facts. I still like the way he presents the big picture.
Bravo! The best well researched & detailed video I came across in 2022!
Prediction at 33:24 to 33:37 was accurate, it came to pass
Yes but he said if they did it without the war. They did it because they were invaded.
Search TH-cam . ' Ukraine Crisis - What You;re Not Being Told . '
The best explanation so far.
1. Full of details,
2. Facts,
3. History lessons,
4. Easy to understand.
Easily 10/10.
@@jacekpiterow900 yeah? so then try and explain your version like he did genius
@@gidionmartinsdaud4931 This guy has his own political agenda. Watch this instead you will learn the real truth. Let me know if this makes sense to you: th-cam.com/video/If61baWF4GE/w-d-xo.html
He didn't explain why there's never any combat captured on film.
@@johnellizz Because Russians do not want to fight Ukrainians. Putin feeds hate to nations to prevent them form joining forces. This is how soviets always did it. Keep in mind that Putin is a soviet General and is using old tactics.
@@jacekpiterow900 Actually, one of the enigmas of so-called 'war' is that combat has never been filmed in any war.
War appears to be devoid of fighting and killing. Cameras are everywhere but they never film a battle.
Im a Filipino and i pray that ukraine-russian conflict/crisis will end the soonest. thank you sir for your extra mile effort in making this detailed video. Let love and peace be...🙏
thanks for your valuable comment from india
I love Amit Senguptas channel, very very awesome, an intelligent man making content for average people like us on very complex topics, very factual.
Kudos for making such an informative, straight to the point video👏🙌🏻
I also agree.. you did an EXCELLENT job explaining the Ukraine/Russian conflict.. thank you so much for educating and enlightening us!
@DisasterEmergencyCommittee
Watching this reminds me of how politics and conflicts favours their own political interests and not the people…leaders focused more on how to regain and retain power in a certain region and economic benefit rather than humanitarian aspects to prevent losing countless lives.
You overrate value of ppls lifes - people always were and always will be a resource - not the most expensive one
Good morning
Not at all true ... US did it many times n failed everywhere .... Vietnam war lasted 6 years , bombs dropped 2 times more than WWII but what happened ....
@@vishalyeole9586 What happened?
Saving lives benefit nothing but that said life. The more the population grows the more stress on natural resources.
I never thought I would survive an entire video with Indian english but your effort of research and the quality made it worth it lol. Keep it up!
This is a very racist comment. Yes it’s an excellent video but ‘Indian’ English is how everyone in India speaks English.
Where are you from?
@@amartyadav How is it racist?! Would it be racist for you to not like british english then? I get that this is the normal english in India yes. I have a hard time with South African english too and they are white so it doesn't make sense for it to be racist. Holy moly... I'm from Sweden. I think Indian english sounds stupid, as if you have a problem speaking and I must be allowed to say that.
@@UWfalcin i dont think your comment was racist at all. I am an Indian myself. I am embarrassed of our Indian accent, but that's the way it is! We can't help it. It's naturally not possible for Indians to have accent you might be used to, lot of it depends on the native Indian languages and the alienated geography of India doesn't help either having little or no exposure to dominant ( and usually acceptable) English accent
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 i know, its just that i personally feel that way. It sounds funny
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 maybe!? But why are you so insecure and offended? That's the problem
A very concise account of Russo - Ukraine crisis! Thank you for the enlightenment.
Its funny how you learn nothing from bbc and cnn every weekend on this subject but understand the conflict in a 30 min video. Excellent.
Wow, thanks! Wish more actual journalists had a voice in this world. It's very refreshing to get information that isn't twisted to manufacture consent.
I totally agree with your words and I too am a big admirer of Amit Sengupta Sir but if you hadn't seen any vdos on WION especially the news covers by Palki Sharma Upadhyay then I'd strongly recommend to you to check it out. She is definitely the best news anchor I've ever seen.
He isn't a news reporter. He is an educator who is building young Indian minds.
I'm so honest that I'm afraid for myself.
Feed me with facts and I make news about it.can handle a scandal by any side. I think.
I really dont know wether you are talking on behalf of russian Foreign Affairs ministery … if not, they should contact you. You are just repeating the arguments of Mr. Lavrov and you do it very well. !
What an excellent educational video. Seems to be perfectly neutral. Well done.
Good job! However you have omitted the spicey details of how the Janukowich Regime change happened.
Also, the separatist feelings were not instigated by Putin but there were strong Euromaidan tensions, including use of the Ukrainian military inside Ukraine against pro Russian forces, with part of the military deserting and changing sides.
I do recommend Oliver Stones' documentaries "Ukraine on fire" and the followup "Revealing Ukraine", also on youtube
Oliver Stone speaks louder than words but the "Ukraine on fire" film is banned by the CIA.
"Revealing Ukraine" Open you mind, it works like a Parashut.
Even my uneducated experience of the situation FULLY 100% understood clearly what this gentleman was saying!! Thank you for helping me see things so much clearer!
This video is trash, it says Ukraine is a young country without culture. Kyiv was founded ~1600 years ago, loooooong before morscow
Congratulations Amit my friend.
Being myself a History Teacher,I must write that THIS = 1of THE best lectures over half an hour I've ever had the privilege to enjoy.
Some of the aspects involving the subject were clarifying even for ME.
Brilliant History lesson 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Except the last 4 minutes of USA roasting
@@darklen14 the roasting part perfectly sums up the real game of USA. Why should other countries involve themselves in American dirty game ?
First you need to understand that this is russian agression first, only then this is "conflict".
@Umang Singh Ironically, America is the most merciful empire in the history of man. Can you imagine what Hitler would have done had he had access to America's resources? All Asians must praise their gods for Americans being so without balls.
- Adûnâi
Excellent explanation of the Russia-Ukaraine standoff!
Helps immensely in understanding the present scenario.Thank you. 🙏
I think everyone should listen to this video and understand the true fact of the war 🤔
Search TH-cam . ' Why Is Ukraine the West's Fault . '
Thank you for this great explanation of what is really going on. I'm American and I think NATO and the U.S. needs to stay out of your concerns. God bless you all. ❤🇺🇸
Jen check out this video. There is alot missing from this overview. I do agree with you that individual countries need to not interfere in many conflicts but some times the way things play out, I get it. th-cam.com/video/If61baWF4GE/w-d-xo.html
I think its because they always ask help from US &Nato
th-cam.com/video/BCILu8cgesA/w-d-xo.html watch to know the truth in 2 mins.
What is the role of UN?
Why ignoring bcoz all member countries waiting for a solution.
The guy who made this video is Indian.
Thanks. A 3rd party concerning the matter can tell the story without emotion or manipulation. Good job!
EXCELLENT VIDEO. You explained the CRISIS UKRAINE ISSUE using economical words and making it easy to understand this complex political, cultural, ideological, and economical WEST ( NATO-US ), vs RUSSIA CRISES. First time, to hear an excellent video.
GREAT RESPECT TO SIR AMIT SENG...IS SUPERB and BRILLIANT HISTORY VLOGGER WITH DEEP SENSE O7F GLOBAL POLITICS....SIR , INDEED, YOU ARE THE BEST OF THE BESTS....
Without being prejudice, after having watched this explanation I just don't want any other explanation. Thank you Sir👌👏👏
Best explanation of that crisis I have seen in years! And I have read a lot and lived both in Russia and Ukraine.
Great job! Spread this to the world, people! Bravo! 👏👏👏👏👏
So, no mineral deposits or other natural resources involved in this war???
I'm praying for other people and both countries I pray God disengages let them break down the tanks helicopters airplanes I hope they break down and they do not work God please deliver all children the elderly and disabled out of those countries
@М Рио resources are involved, my opinion
@@user-qf1wr3nu8t @Growth Development Russia is ownself full of resources.
Excellent analysis on well researched timeline issues.saddest part of this tragedy is the general populace are the pawns who paid the price and received the hatred to bear forever!now all are laid bare,the stupidity of leaders unable to steer clear of disaster for their country is the main factor!So who to blame??? No long term strategy nor foresight!!!!!😭😭
You are offering most important information and speaking perfect English.
From ur past video regarding the east--west sea routes as well as 53% of Artic ocean coast is controlled by Russian land mass and controls surface area out 200 meters from the coast.
This more efficient route put Russia in a pivotal role that requires only accepting reality and maintaining those resources for the long term.
It seems clear to me that NATO/US feels no doubt that only they are capable to create the infrastructure and tap the wealth of these resources to gleen absolute world power and control
They have long determined how ridding Russia from their resources--which "should have been their own?"--solves all their problems they have stored for decades.
Even their ability to enslave China and India--no matter their technical advances. As long as they dictate distribution of goods, they just sit back and let the planet keep making energy to start the world's engine.
Wow. You turned on a bright light 💡 for me today. THANK YOU
Thank you for taking a complex issue and making it understandable and accessible.
Thank you for your intelligent, even-handed presentation of this situation. As an American, I mostly have had access only to the competing propagandist messages from media controlled by either by my own government or Russia. All states lie. Your perspective seems genuinely balanced and historically based.
Hardly even handed, and current events prove how naive the analysis is.
@Eugene Gibez Do you dispute the historical views presented, independent of any conclusions about the current situation or evaluation of a just way forward? If so, I would like to know what points you would correct.
This video is trash, it says Ukraine is a young country without culture. Kyiv was founded ~1600 years ago, loooooong before morscow
Thanks so much for this historical background and deep explanation . Very informative to understand Ukraine Russian war.
Thoroughly comprehensive, well done. There's also brilliant interviews by Col Richard Black posted by Schiller institute.
I just got boosted on my geopolitical outlook by watching this incredible clip explaining Ukraine and Russia. Thank you.
th-cam.com/video/BCILu8cgesA/w-d-xo.html watch to know the truth in 2 mins
Chapters (Powered by ChapterMe) -
00:00 - The ongoing tension between Russia and Ukraine
01:16 - Border Areas
02:18 - Cultures
03:52 - Political Parties
04:50 - Political Camps
06:56 - President Viktor Yanukovych
07:56 - His mistakes
08:24 - Russian naval base in the black sea at Sevastopol
10:50 - Amended Article 111 of Ukrainian constitution
12:09 - European Union association agreement - Euromaiden Movement
15:09 - President Petro Poroshenko
15:53 - Ukraine lost Crimea to Russia
17:30 - Ethnic division in eastern regions of Ukraine
18:37 - Donbas region
19:15 - Aircrafts shot down
20:09 - Cease Fire - Minsk and Minsk2 Agreements
20:46 - Why Minsk agreement failed?
22:53 - President Volodymyr Zelensky
23:02 - Steinmeier Formula - Peace Plan
24:20 - Ukraine current situation
25:53 - NATO and why has Ukraine not received NATO membership
28:45 - Who is going to bend?
29:50 - Russian natural gas market
31:46 - Germany is not participating actively against Russia
32:34 - United States Involvement and its sanctions on Russia
get a life
Great notes
And so Zelensky show continues... if only he hadn't been fool to believe US corrupt leaders who always cook up awar wherever they go. Wonder what they were doing in Ukraine for the past 8years. Obviously Daily Mail did expose Bidens laptop contents to be true they benefited from bio labs cooking up some more deadly viruses, just like it was leaked in usbranch in wuhan China. And to top it all, Russell Brand's they want war video is exposing usweapons industry prior to war discussing how to rattle Putin's cage and how they will benefit war inukraine. Any wonder they US leaders have been bullying many counties to buy weapons from them "to help Ukraine"
th-cam.com/users/shortsIhKk-qvDKq0?feature=share
Germany needs to stay away from Russia it's very simple!
You explained well about Russian interest but hugely skipped the western/US interest in Ukraine. It's an well known fact that USA backed the Euromaidan & the fall of Yanukovych government (AKA The Coup). Besides this, NATO's eastern expansions are naturally a threat to Russia -- who, despite having nukes, is still less powerful compared to NATO in conventional military.
Search TH-cam . ' Why Is Ukraine the West's Fault . '
You're the most understandable, so grateful for your talent 🙌🏽
Thank you Amit for your honest good work in laying out the past and present events in Ukraine and the reasoning behind the crisis. There is nothing more satisfying than the truth you have put forward. CHEERS.
The crisis is about "Murica" getting Nordstrom 2 gas pipeline stopped. Period!
"Russia invades Ukraine" Haa! Darn you America why did you force Russia to invade Ukraine?!?
Clearly this is Americas fault because they are too woke and evil. Clearly Russia is allowed to invade, subjugate, and kill Ukrainians whenever they want.
@@patrickganly5206 US is not stopping NS2. With NS2 Russia is trying to divide EU, get more control of Ukraine. This is political project
@@oceanloverforever8233 If you did some research before commentating you would understand that NS2 was the brainchild of Germany who made the origional proposition to Russia to build NS2. Most of the investors are German!
US crooked senator Ted Cruz has been pushing for it to be stopped for more than 2 years now so that he can have LNG shipped from Texas to Europe and he will get more votes from his constitutents for doing so and maybe run for POTUS even! barf!!
The existing pipes going through Ukraine are not enough to supply all of Western Europe and besides depending on them leaves all of Europe at the mercy of this most unstable republic. Russia have just struck a much bigger deal with China to supply them with same piped gas, so Germany and Europe are the big losers and not Russia if NS2 gets cancelled which ain't gonna happen because Germany won't allow it to be cancelled. Corrupt USA are going to have to suck this one up also!
This video is trash, it says Ukraine is a young country without culture. Kyiv was founded ~1600 years ago, loooooong before morscow
I see a lot of international viewers here amit sir
We all knw tht because medias everywhere have actually lost their ability and authenticity , not jst in india
Your video was very good and I enjoyed it thoroughly. I do have an opinion to share that, most likely, won't be liked across the board but, here goes....It seems, at least to me, that the US cannot do right by everyone at all times. What I mean is that if/when the US gets involved you have some who say they shouldn't, some who say it took too long and some who say they acted correctly. In more recent times, it seems no matter the coarse they decided to take a lot of people are up in arms about it. I feel for the peopes of Ukraine and pray they are victories. I also pray that would leaders will support Ukraine with everything they need to win.
This video has aged well. Over the last eight months, it's gone from prologue to epilogue. It's played out exactly as if you were recounting history before hand.
This is an excellent documentary on the Russian-Ukraine Crisis. Beautifully detailed and eloquently delivered. Thank You, Amit!
It's not crisis. ITS THE WAR!!
U have honestly described the situation , nobody should feel offended if u have narrated the fact
Beautifully explained! Thank you 👍 for keeping us updated on the on-going frictions in and between these countries!
Your expertise in this geopolitical issues are magnificent!
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼...."unbiased" "non-fabricated" "factual" ...we need more ppl like Amit to run world media! Kudos bro 👊🏼
Yeah, how this didn't get censored by YT is amazing.
In my opinion, he lost all credibility at the end when he chalked all of this up to a mere border dispute and accused the US of being up to “old dirty tactics” for having predicted exactly what would happen and look now? Look what is happening?
This video is trash, it says Ukraine is a young country without culture. Kyiv was founded ~1600 years ago, loooooong before morscow
@@erlendbb1289 but ukrain didn't exist when kyiv founded
@@phoenixman3194 No thats true, but the ukrainians did. Thats why we now call it Ukraine.
I am a Filipina, and I've been looking for precise explanation of Russian-Ukraine conflict. Thank you sir, this is well explained, I was able to understand it. Salute to you.
This video is trash, it says Ukraine is a young country without culture. Kyiv was founded ~1600 years ago, loooooong before morscow
@@SwagPad Putin will joint Stalin and Hitler in hell. I only have sympathy with the ukrainians which your country is raping, have raped for a long time. USSR tried to kill as many ukrainians as possible after WW1 by holodomor, later followed by assimilation attempts, despite that, the ukrainian have kept their most of their culture intact, and also their religion followed by independent Ukraine in 1991 after the Hellish nightmare of USSR finally collapsed by internal incompetence
th-cam.com/video/BCILu8cgesA/w-d-xo.html watch to know the truth in 2 mins
@@SwagPad 😂😂😂
@@SwagPad are you okay buddy
Appreciate your efforts and hard work behind creating this video...very well organised and deeply explained so that easy for children's to also understand the Geopolitics......great work.....
Great sir!
Thanks ☺️
Thank you! A concise , detailed, clear summary of the situation free from the overinflated headlines of mainstream media, THANK YOU! 🙏
Now I know we'll,thank u for that very clear explanation
Thank you, Mr. Sengupta. This was a VERY well done video, and I now understand the whole issue much better. I'd heard that Ukraine "used to be " part of Russia, but didn't know that the separation was that recent. Add in the territories with people who identify with "the other side" , and it becomes easier to understand the complexity of the situtation.
BTW, I teach at an international school here in Thailand, and I recently took a class through India's ancient history, including the Mauryan, Gupta, and Chola Dynasties, so your name caught my eye. Cheers!
Wow, did you lived on Mars? Ever heard of the collapse of the URSS?
Ever heard of the Polish Lithuanaian Commonwealth and how a secret agreement between Germany Austria and Russia agreed to split up their territory in the late XIX century?
Ucraina never stood a chance to be indipendent from Russia, like Finland did, but it never was Russia.
@@Leptospirosi no he said he live in Thailand, are you blind?
@@Leptospirosi He is from Asia, that's why he doesn't know about European history. You don't need to be rude. You don't know everything about Asia.
Identification with sides is not straight forward. I’m from Northeastern Ukraine and know many ethnic Russians who aren’t fine with Russian actions.
@@oceanloverforever8233 exceptions are always there
these video is just wow!! I have seen lots of video..but these one is best...thankyou❤️
thanks amit
This is the best explanation I have ever heard about this Russian-Ukrainian crisis so far! This is a straight fact and no biases in my understanding! Thank you for this wonderful job!
There is always bias, often the the omissions. But this is definitely much better than most.
He did a great job. The channel Break Through News also did an in depth explanation of the situation, which agrees with and further expounds on this young man's views.
Ukraine Doesn't want to lose Donbas because it is the industrial part of the country,and Donbas speaks Russian which makes it hard for Ukraine,is very complicated
Wasn't it though
@@yegorzakharov8514 Very True.
But that statement can't be understood enough *Always Bias*
No matter the angle, source or origin...
Amazing job, finally someone that is talking about this and not being biased
It sounded slightly biased to me. Or maybe that’s just me projecting.
He is clearly biased towards Russia.
@@24pavlo yes siding usa is gay😜
@@Sanjay-ub7eq not all americans agree with their politicans. unfortunately money is a dog leash for us politicians
@@24pavlo he is not biased towards russia. In fact i can clearly see from where he is coming from with the conclusion and all the things connected. And talks with macron have been, rather interesting.
Thank you so much for doing this, its quite expository and enlightening, God bless
This guy knows.
Have watched so many channels on this topic but this is by far the best explanation so far. Simple,precise and so easy to understand. Thanks👍
th-cam.com/video/BCILu8cgesA/w-d-xo.html watch to know the truth in 2 mins
Yet so full of errors and Russian narratives
@Sergio I see.
@Serhiy Stop spamming same comments west bot
@Serhiy a bot
Henry Kissinger once said, "To be an enemy of the US is dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal”
Well said.
I think that quote is apocryphal. Kissinger would never have said that.
Not United States 🇺🇸 actually United snakes 🇺🇸 😅
German here, even without Nord Stream 1 and 2, can anyone give me a decent reason why we should be against Russia in the first place?
Because you lost WW2 and US army has been present in your country since then. Even if you don't want, your military and foreign policy can't operate independently without the approval of US.
Thanks these are unbiased facts and opinions backed by detailed research, I wish to see similar unbiased facts on geopolitics of Iraq, Palestine conflicts etc would be interesting.
I can imagine the hard work behind this video. Well researched, unbiased.
It’s about NATO expending to the UKRAIN, it’s like put a gut to Russian head. About US sending weapons to the Ukrain and the ship Bomber from US and Destroyed ship from UK came to Black Sea. Look deeply m.th-cam.com/video/Nbj1AR_aAcE/w-d-xo.html
Unbiased. You may want to watch this video again and do more research
Till the end
@@naswright3041 Completely agreed. For a more indepth video without the agenda check out this one: th-cam.com/video/If61baWF4GE/w-d-xo.html. Fills in the gaps missing from this video and the end doesn't go off into left field.
Except Russia finally invaded Ukraine. So the US wasn’t just doing dirty politics. They were right !
Wow wow. Very enlightening. Now I have understood the whole issue on Russian - Ukraine war.
Thanks for sharing and congrats for taking time to research and understand the whole thing.
very informative. The US is too proud to respect the issues of other nations
Good to see what was happening BEFORE 2014...
That was hard work...like being at uni lecture.....because it's been the most objective and neutral analysis of the the Ukraine situation I've come across. Many thanks for your hard work .Comminsez! Thank you.
Don't suppose that many yanks and Brits have to attention span to watch it and learn though.
The media picth in the UK is like the gulf war......WHICH SIDE ARE YOU ON? With us or against us attitude.......but two is not a choice.
Same old media propaganda from MSM, BBC etc. BBC are not mainstream media in the UK anymore.
Watching MSM(BBC, CNN, FOX) is pointless at this point. Individual research through authentic sources is an ideal way to gauge the situation.
As a yank as you put it. I whole heartedly disagree, I learned many years ago to think for myself. Thanks to the internet and places like TH-cam you learn from the rest of the world thinkers. I wish there were more channels from other countries like this guy explaining from other points of view.
th-cam.com/video/BCILu8cgesA/w-d-xo.html watch to know the truth in 2 mins
russia is not Putin. we don’t want war. proofs here th-cam.com/video/25elCgzOEJw/w-d-xo.html
And so Zelensky show continues... if only he hadn't been fool to believe US corrupt leaders who always cook up awar wherever they go. Wonder what they were doing in Ukraine for the past 8years. Obviously Daily Mail did expose Bidens laptop contents to be true they benefited from bio labs cooking up some more deadly viruses, just like it was leaked in usbranch in wuhan China. And to top it all, Russell Brand's they want war video is exposing usweapons industry prior to war discussing how to rattle Putin's cage and how they will benefit war inukraine. Any wonder they US leaders have been bullying many counties to buy weapons from them "to help Ukraine"
Amazing how the mega media channels can't string together what Amit S. does so consistently. Ty
They could but they just choose not to. This is a goldmine for media outlets as situations like this net more views and clicks than anything. It is in their interests to drag it out as long as possible to keep people coming back for more snippets of information instead of making one complete package that will only be viewed once.
They could do but their financial masters won't allow them to express anything other than the officially approved version of the facts.
I would love to hear your perspective about the potencial for India coming from this crisis. The world is definitely changing geopolitically in order to achieve it Russia is delaying the end of the war to make changes permanent. I wonder how much of that is favouring the US as well otherwise they wouldn't be supplying more and more weapons like never before.